Guest guest Posted April 18, 2010 Report Posted April 18, 2010 Bill, your advice is excellent and well said. I hope she can find the strength and courage to follow it. Re: Normal vs Functioning > mynelltx wrote: > > Bill, Since you are AS, a wise and educated man, what is your advice > > to to meet Jayne half way and 'see' her point of view too? > > Advising is *waaay* beyond my competence. It appears to me he > requires professional care, maybe even institutional care. > > Such advice as I feel competent to give is directed to Jayne: > If she has genuine " caring " feelings for , she should do what she > can to get him the *professional* services he needs. > Then, *for her own mental and physical health*, she should put > serious distance between and herself. This relationship, and > her, is a big mistake. > > > After all, Jayne is the only one working (60 hours per week) while taking > > an interest in and asking for help so he can have independence. > > From the story so far, it seems he may never have " independence " . If > the relationship continues, *neither will she*. Unfortunately, I'm not sure Jayne can/will follow this advice. Bill, you see that she needs to put some distance in the relationship, and so do I, but I don't think she does. [Jayne, feel free to voice your opinions.] It sounds like Jayne is not being guided by rationality in her feelings for .... I don't know if it's love, but she definitely feels he is worth some degree of sacrifice for. They decision for Jayne is, how much is she willing to harm herself in caring for ? From the way Jayne describes , he does need some level of professional care -- maybe not a live-in institution, but more than a girlfriend can give, even if she's an R.N. needs someone who is trained to help the autistic learn to care for themselves ... Jayne could get that training, and devote herself 100% to , or she could investigate other ways he can get that help, and how to pay for it. [Government assistance or whatever.] In any case, Jayne is going to exhaust herself and end up hospitalized again if she takes full responsibility for . She is also at risk for being emotionally drained, and never getting the love, care and affection *she* needs. This is why Jayne needs to develop some distance from , so she can find ways to get her needs met without expecting to do so. [This is reminding me of my life when my kids were infants. Maternal burnout is very real, and when one has a high-need baby like my eldest was, or one who needed surgery at 7 weeks, like my younger, burnout is almost inevitable. The difference is, babies are only this high need for a year or three, whereas an adult can be this needy for decades.] --Liz ------------ The Aspie Parent blog: http://aspergersparent.wordpress.com/ SF, science, and Gifted Ed butons, mugs, and other items at http://www.zazzle.com/CartesianBear* Higher Quality Adult & kid shirts at http://www.printfection.com/cartesianbear ------------------------------------ " We each have our own way of living in the world, together we are like a symphony. Some are the melody, some are the rhythm, some are the harmony It all blends together, we are like a symphony, and each part is crucial. We all contribute to the song of life. " ...Sondra We might not always agree; but TOGETHER we will make a difference. ASPIRES is a closed, confidential, moderated list. Responsibility for posts to ASPIRES lies entirely with the original author. Do NOT post mail off-list without the author's permission. When in doubt, please refer to our list rules at: http://www.aspires-relationships.com/info_rules.htm ASPIRES ~ Climbing the mountain TOGETHER http://www.aspires-relationships.com Quote
Guest guest Posted April 18, 2010 Report Posted April 18, 2010 The problem may be in the interpretation of 'half way'. With someone as far away from normal (i.e. typically acceptable behavior) as obviously is he may well be meeting her halfway. It might be this is all there is. Also clearly mess does not bother him. That's not a function of AS that's a function of personality and environment. My mother is like this, not to the extent of grubs but to the extent of stink, mold building up in obvious places, removing a carpet and chucking it out the window to dispose of it, finding a dead mouse dried in a bin of old clothes after it stunk for weeks, etc. None of her children have chosen to be that way when we grew up. I can imagine my mom making what she would view a HUGE effort to compromise and yet her level of cleanliness would never be anywhere close to my sister's level of expectation. Both of them could be compromising huge amounts and yet never come anywhere near each other. The canyon between levels of acceptability is just too big. clearly has a completely different level of expectation of how to live. And clearly it doesn't bug him. Whatever people might say I still firmly believe that people (and people) FIX what bothers them. It doesn't bother him. He is therefore compromising when he cleans when told to, showers when told to. That IS a compromise for him. Dare I also say, people will usually live up to whatever has been expected of them. I grew up with the understanding that when I turned 18 I was expected to move out of the home, get a job and take care of myself. I expected that my parents would NOT be there to support me. Therefore when the time came there was no possibility of returning home, or asking for money, or not getting a job, or whatever. I simply HAD to do whatever HAD to be done. Was it hard? It was excruciating. It took constant vigilance in thought and observation of others. My boss at one job later told me she was shocked that I ended up working out, that she had only hired me because she was hiring everyone and anyone and she did not expect me to last. She was surprised to find out that once I found the routine I was faster and more efficient than the majority of her workers. This was even a job where I had to deal with people/customers. I think part of the problem NT people have is they do not realize just how far away we AS are coming from or how deep the canyon is between us nor how much effort it takes just for us to go to the grocery store and deal with the checker saying, " How are you? " Let alone unexpectedly running into someone you are supposed to know, or trying to talk to someone who you don't want to offend but you can't hear a thing they are saying because of background noise. Jennie AS Normal vs Functioning > >SNIP< > > Bill writes: >> >> It's " normal " for him. Normal for AS, normal for Jennie, normal for >> *me*. >> >> *He* may come to learn about yours; even adapt to it in many ways. >> *You* may reach a similar accommodation to his. But if so, *even then*, >> the difference remains ...always. And remains, always, a ready source >> of misunderstanding, conflict and disappointment among the *best* >> adapted of couples. >> >> You really cannot interpret his responses to you and your efforts in an >> NT light: NT and AS viewpoints are *fundamentally* different. >> Often only subtly so; even maybe unnoticed at first. Yet that >> difference can have a cumulative effect than is *anything but* subtle! >> ...... > Bill, > Since you are AS, a wise and educated man, what is your advice to to > meet Jayne half way and 'see' her point of view too? After all, Jayne is > the only one working (60 hours per week) while taking an interest in > and asking for help so he can have independence. The emotional and > physical strain put her in the hospital. What are some of things can > do to help take care of Jayne? > >> - Bill, dx AS; ...been there, done that; all four sides of the divide. >> >> -- >> WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA >> http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm > > I agree Bill, there are different 'normals' for each individual. > was not living as an independent when Jayne met him. > He was living with an elderly aunt who was at the > end of her rope with 'his' ways in her home. > She was ready for him to leave. > sounds like he would be homeless if it wasn't > for the kindness, willingness and patience > of others to help him integrate in ways that afford him > a roof over head and a healthy living > environment with food in his belly. There is a difference > between being messy and being open to disease. Jayne and 's aunt are > in no way 's enemy. certainly doesn't seem to mind living with > others and letting them pay the expenses. I have to say that any one in my > home that had actual garbage in the room with crawling grubs would find > them selves curbside. My house looks lived in, but I wouldn't tolerate > garbage or grubs. > They have both bent over backwards to accommodate . > I just wanted to make sure that their love and kindness are not > overlooked or diminished in any way. > ~ K D > Everyone's side has value. Everyone's side should be considered. > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > " We each have our own way of living in the world, together we > are like a symphony. > Some are the melody, some are the rhythm, some are the harmony > It all blends together, we are like a symphony, and each part is crucial. > We all contribute to the song of life. " > ...Sondra > > We might not always agree; but TOGETHER we will make a difference. > > ASPIRES is a closed, confidential, moderated list. > Responsibility for posts to ASPIRES lies entirely with the original > author. > Do NOT post mail off-list without the author's permission. > When in doubt, please refer to our list rules at: > http://www.aspires-relationships.com/info_rules.htm > ASPIRES ~ Climbing the mountain TOGETHER > http://www.aspires-relationships.com > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 mynelltx wrote: [ snip ] >> *He* may come to learn about yours; even adapt to it in many ways. >> *You* may reach a similar accommodation to his. But if so, *even >> then*, the difference remains ...always. And remains, always, a >> ready source of misunderstanding, conflict and disappointment among >> the *best* adapted of couples. >> >> You really cannot interpret his responses to you and your efforts >> in an NT light: NT and AS viewpoints are *fundamentally* >> different. Often only subtly so; even maybe unnoticed at first. >> Yet that difference can have a cumulative effect than is *anything >> but* subtle! ...... > Bill, Since you are AS, a wise and educated man, what is your advice > to to meet Jayne half way and 'see' her point of view too? Advising is *waaay* beyond my competence. It appears to me he requires professional care, maybe even institutional care. Such advice as I feel competent to give is directed to Jayne: If she has genuine " caring " feelings for , she should do what she can to get him the *professional* services he needs. Then, *for her own mental and physical health*, she should put serious distance between and herself. This relationship, and her, is a big mistake. > After > all, Jayne is the only one working (60 hours per week) while taking > an interest in and asking for help so he can have independence. From the story so far, it seems he may never have " independence " . If the relationship continues, *neither will she*. > The emotional and physical strain put her in the hospital. What are > some of things can do to help take care of Jayne? You can't be serious. A person unable to " take care " of themselves cannot " take care " of another. Rhetorically: Is he " taking care " of his aunt? > >> - Bill, dx AS; ...been there, done that; all four sides of the >> divide. >> >> -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA >> http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm > > I agree Bill, there are different 'normals' for each individual. > was not living as an independent when Jayne met him. He was living > with an elderly aunt who was at the end of her rope with 'his' ways > in her home. She was ready for him to leave. sounds like he > would be homeless if it wasn't for the kindness, willingness and > patience of others to help him integrate in ways that afford him a > roof over head and a healthy living environment with food in his > belly. In California at any rate it's euphemistically called " Adult Protective Services " . It seems to me that *both* and his aunt (as described) are *prime* candidates for that kind of governmental / institutional care. The situation (as described so far) is far beyond what one individual working alone can handle. Nor should they try. Yes, I've been there, done that too. It's quite impossible. > There is a difference between being messy and being open to > disease. Jayne and 's aunt are in no way 's enemy. > certainly doesn't seem to mind living with others and letting them > pay the expenses. I have to say that any one in my home that had > actual garbage in the room with crawling grubs would find them selves > curbside. Yes; rightly so. You've made my case. > My house looks lived in, but I wouldn't tolerate garbage or > grubs. They have both bent over backwards to accommodate . I just > wanted to make sure that their love and kindness are not overlooked > or diminished in any way. KD, I'm neither overlooking it, nor wanting to diminish it. In *this* case, apparently quite singular, ...I do not understand it. > ~ K D > Everyone's side has value.Everyone's side should be considered. ....A commentary with which I cannot agree completely; rather: There exist some sides which have only VANISHINGLY SMALL value. There exist some sides which SHOULD NOT be considered. - Bill, dx AS -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 > mynelltx wrote: > > Bill, Since you are AS, a wise and educated man, what is your advice > > to to meet Jayne half way and 'see' her point of view too? > > Advising is *waaay* beyond my competence. It appears to me he > requires professional care, maybe even institutional care. > > Such advice as I feel competent to give is directed to Jayne: > If she has genuine " caring " feelings for , she should do what she > can to get him the *professional* services he needs. > Then, *for her own mental and physical health*, she should put > serious distance between and herself. This relationship, and > her, is a big mistake. > > > After all, Jayne is the only one working (60 hours per week) while taking > > an interest in and asking for help so he can have independence. > > From the story so far, it seems he may never have " independence " . If > the relationship continues, *neither will she*. Unfortunately, I'm not sure Jayne can/will follow this advice. Bill, you see that she needs to put some distance in the relationship, and so do I, but I don't think she does. [Jayne, feel free to voice your opinions.] It sounds like Jayne is not being guided by rationality in her feelings for .... I don't know if it's love, but she definitely feels he is worth some degree of sacrifice for. They decision for Jayne is, how much is she willing to harm herself in caring for ? From the way Jayne describes , he does need some level of professional care -- maybe not a live-in institution, but more than a girlfriend can give, even if she's an R.N. needs someone who is trained to help the autistic learn to care for themselves ... Jayne could get that training, and devote herself 100% to , or she could investigate other ways he can get that help, and how to pay for it. [Government assistance or whatever.] In any case, Jayne is going to exhaust herself and end up hospitalized again if she takes full responsibility for . She is also at risk for being emotionally drained, and never getting the love, care and affection *she* needs. This is why Jayne needs to develop some distance from , so she can find ways to get her needs met without expecting to do so. [This is reminding me of my life when my kids were infants. Maternal burnout is very real, and when one has a high-need baby like my eldest was, or one who needed surgery at 7 weeks, like my younger, burnout is almost inevitable. The difference is, babies are only this high need for a year or three, whereas an adult can be this needy for decades.] --Liz ------------ The Aspie Parent blog: http://aspergersparent.wordpress.com/ SF, science, and Gifted Ed butons, mugs, and other items at http://www.zazzle.com/CartesianBear* Higher Quality Adult & kid shirts at http://www.printfection.com/cartesianbear Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 WD Loughman wrote: << ...A commentary with which I cannot agree completely; rather: There exist some sides which have only VANISHINGLY SMALL value. There exist some sides which SHOULD NOT be considered. >> Bill, you don't know how refreshing it is to see someone be bold enough to actually say this in public. Are you also like me in believing that informed opinions have far more value to society than those of the kneejerk variety? Best, ~CJ Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 I agree with Bill, And would only add, sometimes the gap is too big to be bridged, then other means of assistance are needed. J Re: Normal vs Functioning > mynelltx wrote: > [ snip ] >>> *He* may come to learn about yours; even adapt to it in many ways. >>> *You* may reach a similar accommodation to his. But if so, *even >>> then*, the difference remains ...always. And remains, always, a >>> ready source of misunderstanding, conflict and disappointment among >>> the *best* adapted of couples. >>> >>> You really cannot interpret his responses to you and your efforts >>> in an NT light: NT and AS viewpoints are *fundamentally* >>> different. Often only subtly so; even maybe unnoticed at first. >>> Yet that difference can have a cumulative effect than is *anything >>> but* subtle! ...... > >> Bill, Since you are AS, a wise and educated man, what is your advice >> to to meet Jayne half way and 'see' her point of view too? > > Advising is *waaay* beyond my competence. It appears to me he > requires professional care, maybe even institutional care. > > Such advice as I feel competent to give is directed to Jayne: > If she has genuine " caring " feelings for , she should do what she > can to get him the *professional* services he needs. > Then, *for her own mental and physical health*, she should put > serious distance between and herself. This relationship, and > her, is a big mistake. > >> After >> all, Jayne is the only one working (60 hours per week) while taking >> an interest in and asking for help so he can have independence. > > From the story so far, it seems he may never have " independence " . If > the relationship continues, *neither will she*. > >> The emotional and physical strain put her in the hospital. What are >> some of things can do to help take care of Jayne? > > You can't be serious. A person unable to " take care " of themselves > cannot " take care " of another. Rhetorically: Is he " taking care " of > his aunt? > >> >>> - Bill, dx AS; ...been there, done that; all four sides of the >>> divide. >>> >>> -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA >>> http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm >> >> I agree Bill, there are different 'normals' for each individual. >> was not living as an independent when Jayne met him. He was living >> with an elderly aunt who was at the end of her rope with 'his' ways >> in her home. She was ready for him to leave. sounds like he >> would be homeless if it wasn't for the kindness, willingness and >> patience of others to help him integrate in ways that afford him a >> roof over head and a healthy living environment with food in his >> belly. > > In California at any rate it's euphemistically called " Adult Protective > Services " . > It seems to me that *both* and his aunt (as described) are > *prime* candidates for that kind of governmental / institutional care. > The situation (as described so far) is far beyond what one individual > working alone can handle. Nor should they try. > > Yes, I've been there, done that too. It's quite impossible. > >> There is a difference between being messy and being open to >> disease. Jayne and 's aunt are in no way 's enemy. >> certainly doesn't seem to mind living with others and letting them >> pay the expenses. I have to say that any one in my home that had >> actual garbage in the room with crawling grubs would find them selves >> curbside. > > Yes; rightly so. You've made my case. > >> My house looks lived in, but I wouldn't tolerate garbage or >> grubs. They have both bent over backwards to accommodate . I just >> wanted to make sure that their love and kindness are not overlooked >> or diminished in any way. > > KD, I'm neither overlooking it, nor wanting to diminish it. > > In *this* case, apparently quite singular, ...I do not understand it. > >> ~ K D >> Everyone's side has value.Everyone's side should be considered. > > ...A commentary with which I cannot agree completely; rather: > There exist some sides which have only VANISHINGLY SMALL value. > There exist some sides which SHOULD NOT be considered. > > - Bill, dx AS > > -- > WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA > http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm > > > ------------------------------------ > > " We each have our own way of living in the world, together we > are like a symphony. > Some are the melody, some are the rhythm, some are the harmony > It all blends together, we are like a symphony, and each part is crucial. > We all contribute to the song of life. " > ...Sondra > > We might not always agree; but TOGETHER we will make a difference. > > ASPIRES is a closed, confidential, moderated list. > Responsibility for posts to ASPIRES lies entirely with the original > author. > Do NOT post mail off-list without the author's permission. > When in doubt, please refer to our list rules at: > http://www.aspires-relationships.com/info_rules.htm > ASPIRES ~ Climbing the mountain TOGETHER > http://www.aspires-relationships.com > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Having read more of the details of 's difficulties in function, I am with Bill and Liz on this one. I think that the caring nature that caused Jayne to want to go into helping others as an RN has been put on overdrive with and that her maternal and/or "fixer" instinct is so driven in his case that she doesn't fully see that it is damaging to herself and unfair to both of them for her to be putting herself (and him) in the position she is putting herself in. I say unfair to both of them, but I want to stress that I don't think she would ever intentionally be unfair to but that she needs to understand that he needs more help than she is qualified to offer and the love or affection she may feel for him is not enough, no matter her good intentions, unless she is financially able to quit her job and has someone else who can take care of her needs besides (he can't) and even with all of that, she does not have the training to manage his needs anyway. Unconditional love is a beautiful thing, but it in my experience it is only possible to maintain when the one offering it can 100 percent satisfy their own needs and it is not "conditioned" upon getting anything in return (hence, unconditional). This is not a healthy relationship or even a healthy friendship, because Jayne does have needs, and they cannot be met here. is not sufficiently able to be self sufficient and she is never going to be able to get him that way no matter what improvements she may find happening. The best thing she can do for him if she truly cares for him is to get him help from someone other than herself so that he is NOT relying on her and learns to do things for himself. Already being in the hospital herself for mental health issues once, essentially having had a breakdown over the situation, should be clue enough here and the definition they say of insanity is trying to do the same thing the same way and get different results. I am glad that Jayne is reaching out to others now but I would say that rather than trying to do the same thing in _different_ ways, in this case the thing she is trying to do, is what is fundamentally inappropriate and a "new approach" is not going to be enough. It is possible to love and admire traits in another human being but it doesn't mean they are compatible with us for a day to day relationship. It is possible that Jayne needs to evaluate whether this relationship is really good for her or whether she has just convinced herself that he needs her and because she is used to being a somewhat selfless helper and deriving satisfaction from being needed and because the help and improvement she does bring to his life are giving her positive reinforcement, she is not seeing that it is not ultimately the best for her or for to continue in this way. Re: Normal vs Functioning > mynelltx wrote:> > Bill, Since you are AS, a wise and educated man, what is your advice> > to to meet Jayne half way and 'see' her point of view too?> > Advising is *waaay* beyond my competence. It appears to me he > requires professional care, maybe even institutional care.> > Such advice as I feel competent to give is directed to Jayne:> If she has genuine "caring" feelings for , she should do what she > can to get him the *professional* services he needs.> Then, *for her own mental and physical health*, she should put > serious distance between and herself. This relationship, and > her, is a big mistake.> > > After all, Jayne is the only one working (60 hours per week) while taking> > an interest in and asking for help so he can have independence.> > From the story so far, it seems he may never have "independence". If > the relationship continues, *neither will she*.Unfortunately, I'm not sure Jayne can/will follow this advice. Bill, you see that she needs to put some distance in the relationship, and so do I, but I don't think she does. [Jayne, feel free to voice your opinions.]It sounds like Jayne is not being guided by rationality in her feelings for ... I don't know if it's love, but she definitely feels he is worth some degree of sacrifice for. They decision for Jayne is, how much is she willing to harm herself in caring for ?From the way Jayne describes , he does need some level of professional care -- maybe not a live-in institution, but more than a girlfriend can give, even if she's an R.N. needs someone who is trained to help the autistic learn to care for themselves ... Jayne could get that training, and devote herself 100% to , or she could investigate other ways he can get that help, and how to pay for it. [Government assistance or whatever.]In any case, Jayne is going to exhaust herself and end up hospitalized again if she takes full responsibility for . She is also at risk for being emotionally drained, and never getting the love, care and affection *she* needs. This is why Jayne needs to develop some distance from , so she can find ways to get her needs met without expecting to do so.[This is reminding me of my life when my kids were infants. Maternal burnout is very real, and when one has a high-need baby like my eldest was, or one who needed surgery at 7 weeks, like my younger, burnout is almost inevitable. The difference is, babies are only this high need for a year or three, whereas an adult can be this needy for decades.]--Liz------------The Aspie Parent blog: http://aspergersparent.wordpress.com/SF, science, and Gifted Ed butons, mugs, and other items at http://www.zazzle.com/CartesianBear*Higher Quality Adult & kid shirts at http://www.printfection.com/cartesianbear Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Liz Cademy wrote: << In any case, Jayne is going to exhaust herself and end up hospitalized again if she takes full responsibility for . She is also at risk for being emotionally drained, and never getting the love, care and affection *she* needs. This is why Jayne needs to develop some distance from , so she can find ways to get her needs met without expecting to do so. >> This was the rationale that my late husband used to justify his infidelity. Strangely enough, as the betrayed spouse I don't completely disagree with the position. Ah... the blessings (and the curse) of being a world-class Devil's Advocate. Best, ~CJ Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Would be curious to know what would happen if someone who was AS was involved with someone who was in AS, instead of NT meeting a AS. Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 wrote: << Would be curious to know what would happen if someone who was AS was involved with someone who was in AS, instead of NT meeting a AS. >> I think much of the same would apply to *any* relationship in which there is a wide gulf between the parties in the ability to function and care for oneself within the world as it is, not as one might wish it to be. Spectrum vs. non-spectrum may be irrelevant. Even though I am AS myself, I honestly cannot imagine being fulfilled in a relationship (or even a platonic friendship) with an AS person who is not able to make it in the world without constant direction from me. I place high value on observational insight, savvy, and worldliness (is that a word?) in my friends and partners, which makes dependent and/or naive folks a poor choice for me. A relationship with someone at a very different level of functionality than myself (whether AS or NT) would not feel like a partnership to me. Instead, it would be reminiscent of parent and child, a dynamic that I do not find attractive at all. Some people don't mind that sort of power imbalance, yet I am not one of them. Best, ~CJ Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 > Liz Cademy wrote: > > << In any case, Jayne is going to exhaust herself and end up > hospitalized again if she takes full responsibility for . She is > also at risk for being emotionally drained, and never getting the love, > care and affection *she* needs. This is why Jayne needs to develop some > distance from , so she can find ways to get her needs met without > expecting to do so. >> > > This was the rationale that my late husband used to justify his infidelity. > > Strangely enough, as the betrayed spouse I don't completely disagree > with the position. There's a BIG difference between getting one's need for friendship and emotional support met and infidelity ... lots of women have female friends they do this with. A lot of my female internet acquaintances talk about their book clubs, or going to chick flicks, or card parties ... I wonder what that's like .... <Aspie grin> And I think you don't disagree because you know that I wasn't advocating Jayne find herself a boyfriend on the side. > Ah... the blessings (and the curse) of being a world-class Devil's > Advocate. You and me both, sister! --Liz who can see two sides to every argument, and sometimes a third as well! ------------ The Aspie Parent blog: http://aspergersparent.wordpress.com/ SF, science, and Gifted Ed butons, mugs, and other items at http://www.zazzle.com/CartesianBear* Higher Quality Adult & kid shirts at http://www.printfection.com/cartesianbear Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 > > > ~ K D > > Everyone's side has value.Everyone's side should be considered. > > ...A commentary with which I cannot agree completely; rather: > There exist some sides which have only VANISHINGLY SMALL value. > There exist some sides which SHOULD NOT be considered. > > - Bill, dx AS > > -- > WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA > http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm > Bill, Thanks for your opinions and answering my post. I do think we all have equal value however and I can not agree that one individual has " vanishingly small value " . Who makes this determination? Who is greater and who is lesser? When I refer to 'sides' I am referring to people and their point of view and their feelings. You know what they say about underestimating. ~ K D Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 >SNIP< I think that the caring nature that caused Jayne to want to go into helping others as an RN has been put on overdrive with and that her maternal and/or " fixer " instinct is so driven in his case that she doesn't fully see that it is damaging to herself and unfair to both of them for her to be putting herself (and him) in the position she is putting herself in. I say unfair to both of them, but I want to stress that I don't think she would ever intentionally be unfair to but that she needs to understand that he needs more help than she is qualified to offer and the love or affection she may feel for him is not enough, no matter her good intentions, ...... > > From the way Jayne describes , he does need some level of professional care -- maybe not a live-in institution, but more than a girlfriend can give, even if she's an R.N. needs someone who is trained to help the autistic learn to care for themselves ... Jayne could get that training, and devote herself 100% to , or she could investigate other ways he can get that help, and how to pay for it. [Government assistance or whatever.] > > In any case, Jayne is going to exhaust herself and end up hospitalized again if she takes full responsibility for . She is also at risk for being emotionally drained, and never getting the love, care and affection *she* needs. This is why Jayne needs to develop some distance from , so she can find ways to get her needs met without expecting to do so. ........... An excellent point I hope Jayne considers. ~ K D > ---- I completely agree, , I think the situation is too much for an individual to handle. It is easy to get caught up when you care about someone or a situation. Exactly the point I was making in my post about " The Giving Tree'. We all have to come to our own realization with the choices life presents us. I wish the best for Jayne, and his Aunt and others who find themselves in similar situations. ~ K D Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 mynelltx wrote: >>> ~ K D >>> Everyone's side has value.Everyone's side should be considered. >> >> ...A commentary with which I cannot agree completely; rather: >> There exist some sides which have only VANISHINGLY SMALL value. >> There exist some sides which SHOULD NOT be considered. >> >> - Bill, dx AS >> >> -- >> WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA >> http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm >> > Bill, > Thanks for your opinions and answering > my post. > I do think we all have equal value however and I can not agree > that one individual has " vanishingly small value " . Who makes You have misread what I wrote. Take it carefully - word by word. > this determination? Who is greater and who is lesser? > When I refer to 'sides' I am referring to people and their point > of view and their feelings. Yes, that is what I understood you to mean. I stand by my response. > You know what they say about > underestimating. No. What is it? - Bill, dx AS; ...curious -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 > > This is an important point, but rather complicated. > I agree that not all opinions have equal value.  I hate it when journalists say they have to give " equal weight " to all sides, even when one side has tons of evidence to back it up, and one is just empty rhetoric. > On the other hand, when you're dealing with interpersonal relationships (especially a one-on-one situation), I think it is important to consider both points of view.  Please note that I say CONSIDER, not accept.  If a person honestly believes their point of view, what is gained by dismissing it without considering it?  Surely you're better off to consider both sides, and respond thoughtfully after that consideration.  Once you understand where both people are coming from, you have a chance of finding common ground.  Or pointing out incorrect information or conclusions.  Or you may discover that you can't reach common ground, but at least you've both been heard.  In any case, you've gone through the process of trying to communicate with each other. > Of course, if you don't think the other person is being honest, if they have a long, repeated history of outright lies and gross manipulation, then maybe you shouldn't listen to them.  But if one of the partners is so dishonest that even considering their point of view is a waste of time, then why pretend to have a discussion?  It's not any kind of genuine discourse, and shouldn't be the basis for principles about how to approach genuine discussion with others. >... Well put, Becca. We are on the same page here. ~ K D Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010  Hi Becca, I mostly agree with your words. I could expand on them probably and give you several other "what ifs" where you would probably agree that no consideration is necessary as it would be a waste of time. I just wanted to point out that having seen Bill's thought processes and writing style over the last umpteen years I don't think you said anything different than what Bill said. He just said it in fewer words : ). Best, Re: Re: Normal vs Functioning This is an important point, but rather complicated. I agree that not all opinions have equal value. I hate it when journalists say they have to give "equal weight" to all sides, even when one side has tons of evidence to back it up, and one is just empty rhetoric. On the other hand, when you're dealing with interpersonal relationships (especially a one-on-one situation), I think it is important to consider both points of view. Please note that I say CONSIDER, not accept. If a person honestly believes their point of view, what is gained by dismissing it without considering it? Surely you're better off to consider both sides, and respond thoughtfully after that consideration. Once you understand where both people are coming from, you have a chance of finding common ground. Or pointing out incorrect information or conclusions. Or you may discover that you can't reach common ground, but at least you've both been heard. In any case, you've gone through the process of trying to communicate with each other. Of course, if you don't think the other person is being honest, if they have a long, repeated history of outright lies and gross manipulation, then maybe you shouldn't listen to them. But if one of the partners is so dishonest that even considering their point of view is a waste of time, then why pretend to have a discussion? It's not any kind of genuine discourse, and shouldn't be the basis for principles about how to approach genuine discussion with others. >>> ~ K D>>> Everyone's side has value.Everyone' s side should be considered.>>>> ...A commentary with which I cannot agree completely; rather:>> There exist some sides which have only VANISHINGLY SMALL value.>> There exist some sides which SHOULD NOT be considered.>>>> - Bill, dx AS>>>> -->> WD "Bill" Loughman - Berkeley, California USA>> http://home. earthlink. net/~wdloughman/ wdl.htm>>> Bill,> Thanks for your opinions and answering> my post.> I do think we all have equal value however and I can not agree> that one individual has "vanishingly small value". Who makesYou have misread what I wrote. Take it carefully - word by word.> this determination? Who is greater and who is lesser?> When I refer to 'sides' I am referring to people and their point> of view and their feelings.Yes, that is what I understood you to mean. I stand by my response.> You know what they say about> underestimating.No. What is it?- Bill, dx AS; ...curious-- WD "Bill" Loughman - Berkeley, California USAhttp://home. earthlink. net/~wdloughman/ wdl.htm Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 > > Yes. It really astonishes me when others can't see all that. Was Steve > right? " Dumbth " really does prevail? > > - Bill, dx AS > > -- > WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA > http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm > Bill, While I love Steve and that is a good joke that is generally relate-able (humans do tend to think those who disagree are 'dumber' than us) I find your statement interesting and contradictory especially coming from an educator. On 4/17/10 you posted: Jayne, this is the *heart and soul* of what I hoped you'd hear in my earlier post. Your man *thinks* differently from you. His *viewpoint* about the world and everything in it, what it means and how to interpret it, is very different from yours. It's " normal " for him. Normal for AS, normal for Jennie, normal for *me*. On 4/18/10 you posted: In *this* case, apparently quite singular, ...I do not understand it. In the first post it would appear you do understand and his point of view that hygiene along with other so called social norms may not be as important an issue to him as it is to the outside world. Then you go on to state it is normal for those with AS, yourself and Jennie. In the next post you state you (dx/AS) do not understand it. This seems like a contradiction. I guess I am astonished that it seems to be so easy for some to dismiss others, dehumanize them and then devalue them. Many who post here expect the outside world to understand their personal struggles and shortcomings and show them patience and empathy. Do you think that is happening here? As I have stated before, that is what we all want and we all have shortcomings. When we become less self focused this becomes more evident. It would seem that some people are saying they don't suffer fools well. Have you ever considered the Fool's suffering from actions on your behalf? There are infinite degrees of athletic abilities as well as cognitive abilities. If we as individuals want to be accepted warts and all then we must accept others warts and all. I personally can not go along with humiliating or devaluing a person with less intelligence. How does that make the higher IQ better? Shouldn't the smarter person be the example setter? Is it 'dumb' to not understand that there are different levels of intelligence? " We each have our own way of living in the world, together we are like a symphony. Some are the melody, some are the rhythm, some are the harmony It all blends together, we are like a symphony, and each part is crucial. We all contribute to the song of life. " ....Sondra We might not always agree; but TOGETHER we will make a difference ~ K D Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Hi KD, Having, in the past, taken issue on the list with the manner in which Bill has said something, I have found after we have gone back and forth a bit that he and I are truthfully on the same page more often than not. He will be the first to admit that he sometimes has a manner of expressing himself that could sound like he's being a "know it all" and dismissive of other's viewpoints. On further exploration and getting to "know" him better on this list I have seen that he is nothing of the kind, and probably has more sympathy and empathy for human beings and human conditions than many persons in this world combined. But I have probably been guilty on more than one occasion of _sounding_ like a know it all, or _sounding_ incompassionate, and hopefully persons who don't know me can balance out anything helpful I say with any other statements. I think sometimes we draw verbal lines like Bill did ("there are some sides with no value") because a) well, if we are willing to admit it, they are true statements -- it does not mean all sides have no value, but you too could find "some" sides with no value I believe such as the statements Jennie offered from her family members, or things that others here have suggested; and because we care _too much_ and are struggling not to do so and go to the opposite extreme, if that makes sense, and we have found situations in life where we had to convince ourselves that some sides DO have no value after years of being hostage to an opposite view, for example, a viewpoint we SHOULD have discounted but did not--we are kind of talking to ourselves when we say such things as much as to anyone else, and c) I feel his statement in my own getting older bones as a reaction to a somewhat modern day & world condition where everything in the world is given "value", toilets can be painted as modern art, and many people (especially in the world of academia that Bill has lived) see only the Emporer's New Clothes and feel compelled to oooh and ahhhh about it. How's all that for an NT/AS (who knows) overanalysis that Bill hasn't asked for and may or may not be right, to explain my different perception of his words and yours; in short, I think you are reacting mainly to the tone, rather than the content, as I have done in the past. The only reason I butt in and offer this as a possible bridge to understanding is not because my help is needed (you and Bill are expressing yourselves quite well without me!) or JUST that I am a buttinski (which I can be) but because I am fundamentally selfish and have seen cases where long time posters feel they suddenly have no value if their words get misconstrued and they go offline and it is a shame when that happens : ). Best, Re: Normal vs Functioning > > Yes. It really astonishes me when others can't see all that. Was Steve > right? "Dumbth" really does prevail?> > - Bill, dx AS> > -- > WD "Bill" Loughman - Berkeley, California USA> http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm>Bill,While I love Steve and that is a good joke that is generally relate-able(humans do tend to think those who disagree are 'dumber' than us)I find your statement interesting and contradictoryespecially coming from an educator.On 4/17/10 you posted:Jayne, this is the *heart and soul* of what I hoped you'd hear in my earlier post.Your man *thinks* differently from you. His *viewpoint* about the world and everything in it, what it means and how to interpret it, is very different from yours.It's "normal" for him. Normal for AS, normal for Jennie, normal for *me*.On 4/18/10 you posted:In *this* case, apparently quite singular, ...I do not understand it.In the first post it would appear you do understand and his point of view that hygiene along with other so called social norms may not be as important an issue to him as it is to the outside world. Then you go on to state it is normal for those with AS, yourself and Jennie.In the next post you state you (dx/AS) do not understand it.This seems like a contradiction.I guess I am astonished that it seems to be so easy for someto dismiss others, dehumanize them and then devalue them.Many who post here expect the outside world to understandtheir personal struggles and shortcomings and show them patience and empathy. Do you think that is happening here?As I have stated before, that is what we all want and we all have shortcomings. When we become less self focused this becomes more evident.It would seem that some people are saying they don't suffer fools well. Have you ever considered the Fool's suffering from actions on your behalf?There are infinite degrees of athletic abilities as well as cognitive abilities. If we as individuals want to be accepted warts and all then we must accept others warts and all.I personally can not go along with humiliating or devaluing a person with less intelligence. How does that make the higher IQ better?Shouldn't the smarter person be the example setter? Is it 'dumb' to not understand that there are different levels of intelligence?"We each have our own way of living in the world, together we are like a symphony.Some are the melody, some are the rhythm, some are the harmony It all blends together, we are like a symphony, and each part is crucial.We all contribute to the song of life."...Sondra We might not always agree; but TOGETHER we will make a difference~ K D Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 I can't say whether this is an NT/AS difference until I find out if you are NT or not! I am AS, also ADHD; so it might be AS or it might be ADHD on my part, or a combination of both! ~ "Nobody realizes that some people expend tremendous energy merely to be normal."--Albert Camus Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerryDate: Mon, 19 Apr 2010 07:16:26 -0400To: <aspires-relationships >Subject: Re: Re: Normal vs Functioning Hi ,I noticed but didn't feel the need to comment. Is this an NT/AS difference <g>? However the Freudian slip potential which I missed, is funny <g>. Thanks. Re: Re: Normal vs Functioning >>...A commentary with which I cannot agree completely; rather:>> There exist some sides which have only VANISHINGLY SMALL value.>> There exist some sides which SHOULD NOT be considered.>>>> - Bill, dx ASBill can I paste this quote from you into my facebook page? I'd love to see if it generates conversation... I could post it with a link to your web page.Either way I really like what you said here. Early on in martial issues with my husband a pastor once said something along the lines of all opinions and/or feelings being equal. It was just silly. There was no concept of some things are just flat out incorrect and/or morally wrong. There are people in the world who will in all seriousness expect other people to accept their every opinion and behavior regardless of how nasty. Surely that cannot be of equal value as someone else's feeling that they do NOT wish to be treated that way!Anyway... J Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 > Jennie > Did you mean " martial issues " or did you mean marital issues? Was that a typo? Or was it a Freudian slip? > > Did anyone else catch thIs, or am I the only who noticed? Perhaps you were all too focused on the Jayne/ issues and/or implications? I bet lots of us Aspies saw that one! I sure did, and assumed it was a typo, though a humorous one. As far as the /Jayne issue, I personally never understood why people assume the caretaker role in a relationship. My SIL did this for her late husband (both NT as far as I know, though she grew up in a spectrum family), even opening the flip top on his Coke cans for him. Then again, I'm not sure why he permitted it, either. The whole concept baffles me. --Liz ------------ The Aspie Parent blog: http://aspergersparent.wordpress.com/ SF, science, and Gifted Ed butons, mugs, and other items at http://www.zazzle.com/CartesianBear* Higher Quality Adult & kid shirts at http://www.printfection.com/cartesianbear Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 I just assumed it was a typo. Lowry www.brendaandwaynefamilypetservices.com Owner/Head Trainer Dyno Dogs Performing Dog Team Founder/Owner Kinder Way Canine Studies Become a Certified Dog Trainer, Behaviour and Aggression Consultant NEW!!! Become a Certified Dog /Pet Sitter NEW!!! Become a Professional Dog Groomer Professional Dog /Pet Sitter Professional Dog Groomer ABTA Certified Trainer Behavior Consultant Aggression Consultant C.A.P.P.D.T member Ontario East Regional Rep C.A.P.P.D.T. I.P.D.T.A member CKC member CKC CGN Certified Evaluator ABC Mentor Trainer To: aspires-relationships Sent: Mon, April 19, 2010 7:06:37 AMSubject: Re: Re: Normal vs Functioning Jennie Did you mean "martial issues" or did you mean marital issues? Was that a typo? Or was it a Freudian slip?Did anyone else catch thIs, or am I the only who noticed? Perhaps you were all too focused on the Jayne/ issues and/or implications? ~"Nobody realizes that some people expend tremendous energy merely to be normal."--Albert Camus Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry From: Jennie Unknown <mossbtweenmetoes@ tds.net> Date: Sun, 18 Apr 2010 21:25:14 -0700 To: <aspires-relationshi psyahoogroups (DOT) com> Subject: Re: [aspires-relationsh ips] Re: Normal vs Functioning >>...A commentary with which I cannot agree completely; rather:>> There exist some sides which have only VANISHINGLY SMALL value.>> There exist some sides which SHOULD NOT be considered.>>>> - Bill, dx ASBill can I paste this quote from you into my facebook page? I'd love to see if it generates conversation. .. I could post it with a link to your web page.Either way I really like what you said here. Early on in martial issues with my husband a pastor once said something along the lines of all opinions and/or feelings being equal. It was just silly. There was no concept of some things are just flat out incorrect and/or morally wrong. There are people in the world who will in all seriousness expect other people to accept their every opinion and behavior regardless of how nasty. Surely that cannot be of equal value as someone else's feeling that they do NOT wish to be treated that way!Anyway... J Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 Hi , truthfully I have no clue "what I am." I was just joking around with you, about it being an AS/NT thing <g>. The first few years of being part of this list, I was 100 percent certain that I was NT and my husband, AS. After many years of studying the issue, and seeing how there are so many different flavors of AS and how Asperger's traits often appear so differently in men and women I have come to a secret theory that I mention on here once in a while that many more persons are AS than they realize and that there might even be something in an AS person that "recognizes" another AS person on some deep fundamental level that causes an attraction and that there are many of us who are AS on this list who believe themselves NT and only that some-time-in-the-future genetic test for AS will be able to reveal. When I was a kid, I stimmed in ways that I had all but forgotten about, such as rocking my head against the headboard (maybe that just knocked sense into or out of me) and always felt different from others. But I have never been faceblind, I think I have always had pretty strong sympathy and empathy, I enjoy writing and painting as well as science, I have a brain that systematizes as well as sees big pictures, and I have always enjoyed both sex and cleanliness <g>, so go figure! I have only lacked for friends when I couldn't find people I thought were real and genuine, and while I perseverate on many things I always know I'm doing it and it helps me to get really deep understandings of things not to mention that annoying gift for figuring out not only how many angels can dance on the head of a pin but whether it's the rumba, tango, moonwalk or something else <g>. So, your guess is as good as mine. If such a genetic test were ever to come about some day, I will be happy to take it, but only if my friends will too, because I really want to know whether I'm wrong or right about them too <g>. Best, Re: Re: Normal vs Functioning >>...A commentary with which I cannot agree completely; rather:>> There exist some sides which have only VANISHINGLY SMALL value.>> There exist some sides which SHOULD NOT be considered.>>>> - Bill, dx ASBill can I paste this quote from you into my facebook page? I'd love to see if it generates conversation... I could post it with a link to your web page.Either way I really like what you said here. Early on in martial issues with my husband a pastor once said something along the lines of all opinions and/or feelings being equal. It was just silly. There was no concept of some things are just flat out incorrect and/or morally wrong. There are people in the world who will in all seriousness expect other people to accept their every opinion and behavior regardless of how nasty. Surely that cannot be of equal value as someone else's feeling that they do NOT wish to be treated that way!Anyway... J Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 LOL I assure you it was a completely innocent slip, though considering the state of my marriage issues at the time maybe it was my inner self talking. LOL Jennie AS Re: Re: Normal vs Functioning >>...A commentary with which I cannot agree completely; rather:>> There exist some sides which have only VANISHINGLY SMALL value.>> There exist some sides which SHOULD NOT be considered.>>>> - Bill, dx ASBill can I paste this quote from you into my facebook page? I'd love to see if it generates conversation... I could post it with a link to your web page.Either way I really like what you said here. Early on in martial issues with my husband a pastor once said something along the lines of all opinions and/or feelings being equal. It was just silly. There was no concept of some things are just flat out incorrect and/or morally wrong. There are people in the world who will in all seriousness expect other people to accept their every opinion and behavior regardless of how nasty. Surely that cannot be of equal value as someone else's feeling that they do NOT wish to be treated that way!Anyway... J Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 D. Pawliczek wrote: > Hi Becca, > I mostly agree with your words. I could expand on them probably and give > you several other " what ifs " where you would probably agree that no > consideration is necessary as it would be a waste of time. I just wanted > to point out that having seen Bill's thought processes and writing style > over the last umpteen years I don't think you said anything different > than what Bill said. He just said it in fewer words : ). > Best, > Bless you, . ...*Bless* you! > * Re: Re: Normal vs Functioning > > This is an important point, but rather complicated. [ snip ] - Bill dx AS -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm Quote
Guest guest Posted April 19, 2010 Report Posted April 19, 2010 mynelltx wrote: > >> >> Yes. It really astonishes me when others can't see all that. Was >> Steve right? " Dumbth " really does prevail? >> >> - Bill, dx AS >> >> -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA >> http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm >> > Bill, While I love Steve and that is a good joke that is > generally relate-able (humans do tend to think those who disagree are > 'dumber' than us) I find your statement interesting and > contradictory especially coming from an educator. 's neologism has *nothing* to do with people disagreeing. For others' benefit: The 1998 book's full title is Dumbth: The Lost Art of Thinking With 101 Ways to Reason Better & Improve Your Mind The publisher's review included: " ...this is Steve 's humorous and provocative examination of the increasing American tendency toward muddle-headedness and ineptitude, which uniquely defines as " dumbth. " KD, the rest of your response to me is so full of misunderstanding my words, and misconstruals of meaning, I hardly know where to begin. This is getting Kafka-esque. So I won't begin. I accept that you disagree with me. I accept your absolute right to disagree without interference from me. [ snip KD's expositions and questions ] > Is it 'dumb' to not understand that there are different levels of > intelligence? - Bill, dx AS; ...retiring from this fray -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.