Guest guest Posted March 9, 2010 Report Posted March 9, 2010 Hi. This is my first post.I only realized that my husband is AS recently -- after 27 years of marriage. (I have had a suspicion for a while, but he has been telling me more how he processes " stuff " that is stressful, like our arguments, and suddenly I " got it " .) Anyway, reading this site and my first couple of books (Asperger's from the Inside Out, Asperger Syndrome and Social Relationships), I have read enough to make a few important changes, especially when we are having trouble: 1. I give him time to be quiet for a while, either in the same room or in a different room. He always returns if I give him time and space. We then talk, not true dialogue, but we each listen to each other, which helps a lot. 2. I let him say out loud his " history " of the fight, start to finish, because that is how he works things though. I used to get so frustrated because he wouldn't just " take it from where we are now " like I want to. He just can't and now I know that. 3. I read in one chapter by an AS person that they deal in " just the facts " , not ambiguities and innuendos. I am really trying hard to be more direct, not hint-hint or using vocal tone to get certain responses (like I am so used to doing with girlfriends and family members). If I stay with facts, he can deal with them. I would love advice from others as well. For me, the more I keep our differences in mind, the more we can prevent trouble. So far, so good. I think that the majority of our arguments over the years have been due to my hurt feelings and expectations and never anything really important. There is so much about his AS I have come to love and appreciate -- his creativity, his allowing me space, his loyalty and lack of criticism of my failings, and much more. I try to tell him that more often. He makes up for his sense of social isolation with knowing he pleases me with his interesting and creative work (building, writing and more.) I wish you well.Kathy My husband has said several times before that he thought he might have mild Aspergers, a self-diagnosis based on his understanding of his younger brother's more severe Aspergers. I didn't understand how mild Aspergers made any difference to our relationship until last night, when he finally explained some things to me about how he thinks and perceives things, and social behaviors he has learned but doesn't understand, which opened my eyes to the impact this has had on our communication. How did I miss this after 8 years of marriage and 14 years total of being together?? I'm still at a loss to understand how to communicate with him about this or anything else, really. He seems to misunderstand me constantly and I think I have been assuming too often that he thinks like I do when he doesn't. Can anyone give me pointers on how to communicate with an AS spouse? In particular I need help learning how to express anger in a way that doesn't make him feel threatened and cause him to flip out. Thanks for your help! It's encouraging to know that there are other people out there who know what I'm going through. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 9, 2010 Report Posted March 9, 2010 Hello ecofrugal, What a stimulating and important question you ask here. I might be able to give you a few suggestions. For a start, this issue of you missing his real meaning and understanding after 8 years of marriage. There are two or three reasons for this. First, an Aspergian can go through life absolutely missing the commonly understood meanings of words. Because he may never have experienced factors like Intimacy, Bonding, Sexual Chemistry and even Love in the way that others know them, he may sincerely believe that his own experience of them is identical with that of other people. Intimacy may well be interpreted by him as meaning being polite to the other party; or being tolerant of their views and habits. Maybe it may mean to him nothing more than having a series of agreements and problem solving processes that are necessary when in partnership closely with another. Bonding might mean to him simply that he Likes the person and believes that he wants to share daily life with them. Sexual Chemistry might mean nothing more than attraction to anyone of the opposite sex, with the understanding that the sexual side of it is appropriate and permissible specifically when a willing partner makes herself available. Sexual arousal then simply means that he applies his sexual interest purely to that one person (being thus available), where strictly speaking any other willing and attractive person could be interchangeable with them. Love,-- well, you really need to ask any individual Aspie just what he means by the term. You may get quite a range of replies. But I’m always reminded here of the case in Barbara ’s book “Loving Mr Spock” when she asks her AS boyfriend Danny just what he is meaning when he speaks of loving. He actually has to think it over for a while, and then states that it means to him the fact that ‘he feels safe’. Notice that his comment does not state or imply anything about the other person. It is purely involving his own inner state of being. As I would elaborate on it, he is saying that this person he ‘loves’ has the unique advantage of representing no detriment to his life, and gives him no negative feelings such as danger or intrusion. This often I believe represents the very specific reason why he marries in the first place. Another reason for your missing the real meaning and understanding of him is to do with his relative inability to express clearly and honestly just what he really feels. We aspies actually live a very rich inner life of feeling and perception, but we don’t comprehend just how to convey any of it to another person, regardless of our relationship to them. The common self-centredness that so many of us have is something we don’t dare to express to others. Relationship is something that is probably not so deep for us as it is for the NTs of the world. In our childhood, we probably went through nightmare confrontations when we endeavoured to be frank and honest about our real feelings. No-one understood, and we determined not to tell others about our inner states ever again. Then there is the fact that so many AS folks don’t have any idea about letting their outer expressions or body language coincide with the inner states of emotion or feeling. We can smile or frown at the wrong time, or joke inappropriately. And of course all too often we don’t pick up the subtle hints and ‘sub-text’ that represent so much in ordinary NT interaction. For this reason too, we may not have the facility in our communication for conveying what we really mean. If you really want to know just what an Aspie is thinking or how he is interpreting things, you need to ask him. But make sure you ask him in an unthreatening fashion, WHEN HE IS RELAXED AND CAN BE SPONTANEOUS. If he feels threatened, then he may fudge about the issue to try and find the safest way to say it; or he may be oblivious of the importance of the question and tell you bluntly of things that you may not want to hear. Whatever you do, make sure you listen to exactly what he says in the unguarded moment. The first things he says are crucial. Be as open as possible to whatever he has to say. Don’t take notice of what he says after an argument or an confrontation or interrogation. Don’t try to read his body language either. It is quite possible that it will be at loggerheads with his words. In many cases too, I’d recommend that you don’t go by what he actually DOES. Listen to exactly what he says in the beginning, and don’t try to read things into it. Now as to anger. Well, it can simply confuse many Aspies. He may well have no idea of how to deal with it. he may not know how to apply or express it himself. It is my idea too that if you are explaining anything important or intimate where serious or emotional issues are at stake, try to keep your comments short and simple. Too many words, too many sentences may just confuse him and send him into panic. Try not to include emotion AND reason in the same sentence or communication. Separate them so that he is getting at one particular moment the emotion you are going through, and at another later (or earlier) moment the particular message or information or request that you want to get over to him. It is quite likely too, I would postulate that when he is undergoing an interrogation or a confrontation that he will totally lose track of the relationship you have with him. He will possibly find himself entering one of his ‘compartments’ when your message becomes the only thing on his mind. You yourself then may fade into the background, and be temporarily lost to him. If he has to deal with both the things you are saying, and your feelings at the same time, he may lapse into chaos. The last thing I’d say is, keep in mind the fact that in regard to some crucial matters of relationships, he may be just completely blind. He may well be going through shock and horror to discover that the relationship he believes in is nothing like what he anticipates. It may be hard for him to realize that his partner is not controllable or as easily manipulated as is his computer. Other human beings including his partner may well represent the worst nightmares for him. Cheers, Ron. 74 yr old Australian., diagnosed AS in his late 60s. (married three times!!!) Subject: How to Fight Fair with an AS Spouse? My husband has said several times before that he thought he might have mild Aspergers, a self-diagnosis based on his understanding of his younger brother's more severe Aspergers. I didn't understand how mild Aspergers made any difference to our relationship until last night, when he finally explained some things to me about how he thinks and perceives things, and social behaviors he has learned but doesn't understand, which opened my eyes to the impact this has had on our communication. How did I miss this after 8 years of marriage and 14 years total of being together?? I'm still at a loss to understand how to communicate with him about this or anything else, really. He seems to misunderstand me constantly and I think I have been assuming too often that he thinks like I do when he doesn't. Can anyone give me pointers on how to communicate with an AS spouse? In particular I need help learning how to express anger in a way that doesn't make him feel threatened and cause him to flip out. Thanks for your help! It's encouraging to know that there are other people out there who know what I'm going through. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 9, 2010 Report Posted March 9, 2010 > Can anyone give me pointers on how to communicate with an AS spouse? In particular I need help learning how to express anger in a way that doesn't make him feel threatened and cause him to flip out. Thanks for your help! It's encouraging to know that there are other people out there who know what I'm going through. I'm still learning, and I've been married almost 20 years! But then, we still don't know if my husband is officially Aspie (or just has Aspie traits). I do have several adult friends with AS, and here's what I've learned from them: - subtlety and polite euphemism don't work. If J calls me on the phone, I can't get across the idea that I want to stop talking by saying " I have a busy day today " or " I need to go get my son from school. " I have to say " J, I have to hang up now. " J does not take this as bluntness or an insult. Most Aspies are not hung up on proper voice tone, hidden meanings, or message subtext. If you say X, they hear X, not X(y). Similarly, we don't usually say things with hidden messages. - While lots of us like puns and word play (at least in my family!), don't use it when you have an important message to get across. For serious talk, use a serious manner. Story: many years ago, my ex-husband (NT) was unhappy at how I (AS) cleaned the house. One day, he drew a smiley face in the dust on a table in a little used room ... a few weeks later he was surprised I didn't understand that he wanted me to clean the table. [i did clean that room before company came over, why bother other times?] Had he said " Liz, can you dust that table every week? " , I would have understood. As others have said, don't expect us to have standard reactions to life. There are times I don't even understand myself ... I have long internal conversations on whether I am capable of loving as NT folk know love, and if not, do I have an acceptable substitute feeling? And ASpies don't even share a common set of alternate feelings -- I'm sure my DH and I don't mean the same thing when we say love. I'm going to stop now ... a combination of a sinus headache and antihistamine-induced fuzzy brain are making me incoherent. It's barely spring, but the pollen is flowing! --Liz Quote
Guest guest Posted March 9, 2010 Report Posted March 9, 2010 hello and welcome! It may be a trueism that Aspergers are almost word 'deaf', in that they concentrate on things that they understand and are interested in, and everything else is filtered. Much as they dont read faces or expressions, tones of voice dont register, either. The most frustrating thing about communication for me, as an NT living with Ian, AS, for 11 years, is that he doesnt adapt to flowing conversations or heed to my requirement to unload thoughts or feelings at will. He backs off. I have done most of the adapting in that I dont tell him about anything except that which is of interest him. I will have to tell him if the house is on fire, but even then I would have trouble getting it through, as he would have to have flames licking at his butt to realise. He often says What??? as though he hasnt clicked to anything I have said in the past moments. He used to say 'are you STILL talking' but I've explained that he will have a poker past his head if he keeps using that one. He doesnt do listening very well, as he is always eager to have HIS say. So, the burden of communicating effectively, is on you, but it doesnt mean you have to change your core self, just that you have to devise a method of approach for the AS in your midst; perhaps you can have your meaningful conversations with others, your friends, neighbours, family. Please seek them out, its natural you will want to let off a few angst ridden thoughts. Try not to fall into the trap of complaining to them about the AS person, others can be disloyal to you and your partner if that happens. Find yourself an agony aunt so that you have an outlet for any resentment! When I first met Ian I couldnt work out what was wrong, he came across as gregarious and funny, and very attentive. But that was because we werent having face to face contact, he was editing a book and I was indexing it, we had a common goal and therefore he loved talking to me about a subject he was keen on, and were talking via email (where he communicated very well) and by phone (where he didnt always sound too happy). Once we decided to go out with each other, on meeting him I was both appalled by his seemingly aggressive, impatient stance, and taken aback by his clear obsession with me. Light, ordinary chit chat didnt work. If I deviated from his line of opinion or changed a subject mid conversation - as you can with most NT's - he would put the phone down on me, or if in the same room, just stop talking and leave the room. We had some pretty tense times until, after several years, we got the diagnosis of Aspergers, It all fitted. No one was more relieved than Ian himself. He felt he had spent the whole of his life 'watching the world through perspex' and so wanted to be at ease socially, but couldnt work out why his own communication didnt work the magic he assumed it would! He used to use pre determined scripts when talking to people, in the hope that would open the door to conversation and friendship. It didnt work because the other people didnt have a copy of his script! Ian spent a lot of his early life pretending to behave in certain ways, that he had copied from films and others. They didnt often work, because once the script was used up, he didnt know what came next. He still does it when meeting strangers, and he doesnt trust his own abilities to communicate, so asks me to keep him on track. The hardest thing for me in terms of living with an Aspie, is the inscrutable way he can blithely not see when I am angry, sad, or desperate. I have just phoned him because at the moment we have hardly any funds, I'm having hospital treatment, and the house is falling down. I dont know why, after all these years, I expected him to be able to reply in any other way to my wail of 'I'm so miserable today', with anything other than 'Are you? Why? What do you expect me to do about it'!!! Ian communicates well when talking about his pet subjects; and if writing rather than speaking, and if he knows beforehand what he wishes to say, on the phone. Unexpected turns and twists of the kind of conversations we have with strangers on the bus, or with family members, or (horror of horrors) small children, not only terrify Ian but are beyond his powers. When I get angry it shakes Ian up, for someone with typical AS meltdowns, its ironic that he cant take anger from others. His meltdowns are the gasket blowing after days or weeks of frustration or pent up obsession. Mine are due to the hell of being the responsible adult, or resentment at carrying a shedload of bad luck and hard cheese. I know that he cant deal with anger, just as he cant deal with my misery. I take my anger away (I have a remote place near here where I go and shout!). Its fair, and its not right, but its how it is. However, thats not to let Ian off. If he has consistently acted selfishly and overwhelmed me with his own needs, I will tell him. I carefully choose the moment though.I do it without getting angry (having already gone into the woods and yelled!) and what I say is, 'I would like you to do this', or 'it would please me if you did that'. A lot of the things I used to expect of Ian, I know he physically cant face. He cant fill in forms. He cant make split second decisions. But he now asks me if I am OK. And he asks me if I agree or disagree with an action of his, which he never used to do. Negotiation. He is able to be honest, sincere and blunt. I was being mucked about by a boss, and he told me that I had to do something about it! So he motivates me to be more ambitious, and bang my own drum more.. Many of us here in Aspires find ourselves as surrogate mums, 'nurturers', the ones who fix things. If you are used to the idea of either an equal partnership, or a partnership where the other one will be the hero and save kittens from fires, this can be a cruncher. I have been through the phase of a) who the hell does he think he is ah, poor soul has Aspergers c) OK, so you have Aspergers, now get on with it d) lts worth us working on each of our strengths as people, to make a good relationship here. We had several feet of snow overnight and were cut off for several days; added to which we had no power or phones for a few days. Ian and I managed very well, as without all the outside stimuli, he was calm and felt safe. He didnt like the lack of computer games or laptop, and the minute the power went on he headed for the computer, me for the cooker and hot shower! Understanding his limitations is a good thing, although it does bring some kind of horrible resolution that this is probably as good as it can be. Ian cant stand smells, noise, chatter around him, lights and busy places. I dont struggle to take him to restaurants and I now go with all my pals instead. Ian needs to decompress every day, and that means long hours in the room of his choice. I am a widow all but in name. I've found though, that he is much calmer, collected and able to respond to me and my needs, when he has had his decompression time. We negotiate this. I aint his landlady or his geisha. For so many hours doing what he wants to do, I negotiate time for us together, although he usually wins there too, its something he can cope with so its certainly not going to a dance hall together. His meltdowns, fears, and confusion are lessened when we communicate in short bursts, negotiate what to do each day, and I dont bother him with the perils of human life. I spent a lot of time reading up on Aspergers (which he didnt, oddly) and feeding him snippets. He is delighted to know that he is 'normal' for him, as he had terrible times as a child and young adult trying to fit in. He has issues about that. I also tell him firmly what I need, and when. If he cant cut the mustard in terms of supporting me, I say to him, that wont be Ok for me, but I'll do such and such instead. So he knows, and isnt unaware of my plans. Its a hard call, you cant get from an AS what you'd get from an NT, but there are benefits. Ian is quirky, a genius, witty, we've got that couple shorthand that comes with the years, and now he realises he doesnt have to pretend, he accepts his AS. As do I. Take your anger to the woods, be clear and calm when you explain how you feel, dont expect that he will have a reference to your feelings, and read and discuss AS so you both know exactly how to manage it. I cant recommend the quiet decompression times enough. Avoid busy situations and sudden change. Write him notes. He will communicate better than if you suddenly blether at him, If you love him, its worth the adaptation. And use your family and friends to the hilt. Best of luck Judy B, finally seeing the snow retreat; spring yet to be sprung here in my part of Scotland Subject: How to Fight Fair with an AS Spouse?To: aspires-relationships Date: Tuesday, 9 March, 2010, 0:18 My husband has said several times before that he thought he might have mild Aspergers, a self-diagnosis based on his understanding of his younger brother's more severe Aspergers. I didn't understand how mild Aspergers made any difference to our relationship until last night, when he finally explained some things to me about how he thinks and perceives things, and social behaviors he has learned but doesn't understand, which opened my eyes to the impact this has had on our communication. How did I miss this after 8 years of marriage and 14 years total of being together?? I'm still at a loss to understand how to communicate with him about this or anything else, really. He seems to misunderstand me constantly and I think I have been assuming too often that he thinks like I do when he doesn't. Can anyone give me pointers on how to communicate with an AS spouse? In particular I need help learning how to express anger in a way that doesn't make him feel threatened and cause him to flip out. Thanks for your help! It's encouraging to know that there are other people out there who know what I'm going through. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 9, 2010 Report Posted March 9, 2010 Thank you, everyone! There are some examples in your replies that ring true and I will keep rereading your suggestions until I can remember them. We recently discovered, for instance, that we communicate well via email after a fight. I'm just trying to avoid the fights altogether at this point, because he's sending me clear signals that we can't keep doing that. I always thought I could handle 90% of the communication, but it seems I'm really required to do 99% of it, huh? I told him this morning that while reading up on Aspergers I kept reading that I was doomed to always be lonely, and I couldn't handle the idea of always being lonely, so I wanted him to think about a way we could communicate... and we could talk about it later. He seemed to appreciate that I was giving him a head start to think about the issue and problem solve it, and he initiated a hug and seemed to understand and be upset that I was upset because he was distant. I think we can work something out. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 9, 2010 Report Posted March 9, 2010 > while reading up on Aspergers I kept reading that I was doomed to always be lonely, ... I don't believe this, not for a minute. You may have to change your definition of " not lonely " , but a person with AS can learn to be a good companion, someone you can tell your troubles to. Of course, the Aspie has to *want* to learn, and see the benefit is so doing, but we can learn. Similarly, we can learn to take joy in making others around us happy. I may not enjoy playing golf, but if my partner does, I may play golf anyway, just to make him happy and see the joy in his face. The problem lies in the fact that most Aspies have no clue how this works. They don't realize people like it when someone just listens to them (I have to expressly tell my husband when I need to vent and don't want advice!), or that there's a benefit to making others happy. We have to earn this consciously, and never have an instinctive grasp of this, but we can always work on improving. I like to think of birthday/holiday gifts in this regard. While an NT couple will look for clues on what to get each other that the other will like, if an Aspie buys a gift at all, it will be something she likes. [ " Hubby, I bought you this aftershave ... I love the smell. " ] But, if you give an Aspie a list of possible gifts, and tell her that you would love something on the list for your birthday, could she choose something and wrap it, you will get something good. And if you respond in a good way, next year your Aspie will ask you for a list. <assuming s/he doesn't lose the list, grin> --Liz Quote
Guest guest Posted March 9, 2010 Report Posted March 9, 2010 for 'alone' read 'independent' or 'self managing'. You wont be alone with your Aspie, especially when he gets into the swing of a long talk on HIS favourite subject. But you will be a lone player, when it comes to socialising as a couple, and that you can sort out by finding good mates to socialise with. with warm wishes judy b Subject: Re: How to Fight Fair with an AS Spouse?To: aspires-relationships Date: Tuesday, 9 March, 2010, 19:33 Thank you, everyone! There are some examples in your replies that ring true and I will keep rereading your suggestions until I can remember them. We recently discovered, for instance, that we communicate well via email after a fight. I'm just trying to avoid the fights altogether at this point, because he's sending me clear signals that we can't keep doing that. I always thought I could handle 90% of the communication, but it seems I'm really required to do 99% of it, huh? I told him this morning that while reading up on Aspergers I kept reading that I was doomed to always be lonely, and I couldn't handle the idea of always being lonely, so I wanted him to think about a way we could communicate. .. and we could talk about it later. He seemed to appreciate that I was giving him a head start to think about the issue and problem solve it, and he initiated a hug and seemed to understand and be upset that I was upset because he was distant. I think we can work something out. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 15, 2010 Report Posted March 15, 2010 Ron,I think you have in one note articulatedwhat is inside the AS bubble we tend to live in. Well thought throughcomments that describe exactly the perception that I have and continueto have in dealing with relationships.Note that the interchangeability ofpartners smacks of a utilitarian approach to sexual congress. Thisis why I think that NT partners feel they are being used. The manipulationof people is a classic AS trait I think although I am sure some NT peoplecan do the same thing. I know my partner has felt manipulated andused even though behaviours were based on good intentions. Kind RegardsGreg DX AS at 53To:<aspires-relationships >Date:09/03/2010 04:06 PMSubject:RE: How to FightFair with an AS Spouse?Sent by:aspires-relationships Hello ecofrugal,What a stimulating and important questionyou ask here. I might be able to give you a few suggestions. For a start, this issue of you missing hisreal meaning and understanding after 8 years of marriage. Thereare two or three reasons for this. First, an Aspergian can go throughlife absolutely missing the commonly understood meanings of words. Because he may never have experienced factors like Intimacy, Bonding, SexualChemistry and even Love in the way that others know them, he may sincerelybelieve that his own experience of them is identical with that of otherpeople. Intimacy may well be interpreted by him as meaningbeing polite to the other party; or being tolerant of their views and habits.Maybe it may mean to him nothing more thanhaving a series of agreements and problem solving processes that are necessarywhen in partnership closely with another. Bonding might mean tohim simply that he Likes the person and believes that he wants to sharedaily life with them. Sexual Chemistry might mean nothing more thanattraction to anyone of the opposite sex, with the understanding that thesexual side of it is appropriate and permissible specifically when a willingpartner makes herself available. Sexual arousal then simply means that heapplies his sexual interest purely to that one person (being thus available),where strictly speaking any other willing and attractive person could beinterchangeable with them. Love,-- well, you really needto ask any individual Aspie just what he means by the term. Youmay get quite a range of replies. But I’m always reminded hereof the case in Barbara ’s book “Loving Mr Spock†when she asksher AS boyfriend Danny just what he is meaning when he speaks of loving. He actually has to think it over for a while, and then statesthat it means to him the fact that ‘he feels safe’. Notice thathis comment does not state or imply anything about the other person. Itis purely involving his own inner state of being. As I wouldelaborate on it, he is saying that this person he ‘loves’ has the uniqueadvantage of representing no detriment to his life, and gives him no negativefeelings such as danger or intrusion. This often I believe represents the very specific reason why he marries in the first place. Another reason for your missing the realmeaning and understanding of him is to do with his relative inability toexpress clearly and honestly just what he really feels. Weaspies actually live a very rich inner life of feeling and perception,but we don’t comprehend just how to convey any of it to another person,regardless of our relationship to them. The common self-centrednessthat so many of us have is something we don’t dare to express to others. Relationship is something that is probably not so deep for us asit is for the NTs of the world. In our childhood, we probably wentthrough nightmare confrontations when we endeavoured to be frank and honestabout our real feelings. No-one understood, and we determined notto tell others about our inner states ever again. Then thereis the fact that so many AS folks don’t have any idea about letting theirouter expressions or body language coincide with the inner states of emotionor feeling. We can smile or frown at the wrong time, or jokeinappropriately. And of course all too often we don’t pickup the subtle hints and ‘sub-text’ that represent so much in ordinaryNT interaction. For this reason too, we may not have the facilityin our communication for conveying what we really mean. If you really want to know just what an Aspieis thinking or how he is interpreting things, you need to ask him. But make sure you ask him in an unthreatening fashion, WHEN HE IS RELAXEDAND CAN BE SPONTANEOUS. If he feels threatened, then he may fudgeabout the issue to try and find the safest way to say it; or he may beoblivious of the importance of the question and tell you bluntly of thingsthat you may not want to hear. Whatever you do, make sureyou listen to exactly what he says in the unguarded moment. Thefirst things he says are crucial. Be as open as possible to whateverhe has to say. Don’t take notice of what he says after an argumentor an confrontation or interrogation. Don’t try to read his bodylanguage either. It is quite possible that it will be at loggerheadswith his words. In many cases too, I’d recommend that youdon’t go by what he actually DOES. Listen to exactly whathe says in the beginning, and don’t try to read things into it. Now as to anger. Well, it can simplyconfuse many Aspies. He may well have no idea of how to dealwith it. he may not know how to apply or express it himself. It is my idea too that if you are explaining anything important or intimatewhere serious or emotional issues are at stake, try to keep your commentsshort and simple. Too many words, too many sentences may just confusehim and send him into panic. Try not to include emotion ANDreason in the same sentence or communication. Separate them so thathe is getting at one particular moment the emotion you are going through,and at another later (or earlier) moment the particular message or informationor request that you want to get over to him. It is quite likely too, I would postulatethat when he is undergoing an interrogation or a confrontation that hewill totally lose track of the relationship you have with him. Hewill possibly find himself entering one of his ‘compartments’ when yourmessage becomes the only thing on his mind. You yourself then mayfade into the background, and be temporarily lost to him. If hehas to deal with both the things you are saying, and your feelings at thesame time, he may lapse into chaos. The last thing I’d say is, keepin mind the fact that in regard to some crucial matters of relationships,he may be just completely blind. He may well be going through shockand horror to discover that the relationship he believes in is nothinglike what he anticipates. It may be hard for him to realizethat his partner is not controllable or as easily manipulated as is hiscomputer. Other human beings including his partner may wellrepresent the worst nightmares for him. Cheers, Ron. 74 yr old Australian.,diagnosed AS in his late 60s. (married three times!!!) Subject: How to Fight Fairwith an AS Spouse? My husband has said several times before that hethought he might have mild Aspergers, a self-diagnosis based on his understandingof his younger brother's more severe Aspergers. I didn't understand howmild Aspergers made any difference to our relationship until last night,when he finally explained some things to me about how he thinks and perceivesthings, and social behaviors he has learned but doesn't understand, whichopened my eyes to the impact this has had on our communication. How didI miss this after 8 years of marriage and 14 years total of being together??I'm still at a loss to understand how to communicate with him about thisor anything else, really. He seems to misunderstand me constantly and Ithink I have been assuming too often that he thinks like I do when he doesn't.Can anyone give me pointers on how to communicate with an AS spouse? Inparticular I need help learning how to express anger in a way that doesn'tmake him feel threatened and cause him to flip out. Thanks for your help!It's encouraging to know that there are other people out there who knowwhat I'm going through. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 15, 2010 Report Posted March 15, 2010 Greg Greer wrote: > > Ron, > > I think you have in one note articulated what is inside the AS bubble we > tend to live in. Well thought through comments that describe exactly the > perception that I have and continue to have in dealing with relationships. > > Note that the interchangeability of partners smacks of a utilitarian > approach to sexual congress. This is why I think that NT partners feel > they are being used. The manipulation of people is a classic AS trait I Greg, I gotta disagree! Not " a classic AS trait " at all. If anything, it's the other way 'round! Gullibility, and 'easy to manipulate' are what I understand as AS-ish - relative to NTs in a given situation. That's the case even with adults who've been convinced by others that AS is a " disability " . ...The medicalization of a *behavior* which in an " NT " is passed over with nothing more that a snide comment. A gullible AS adult is led to believe her/his " disability " is *the cause* of relationship problems. It isn't. All relationships depend on *two* parties keeping their cool in any problem situations. One, say AS, may inadvertently say or do the " wrong thing " to, say, an NT. It's the *NT's* misunderstanding (knee-jerk reaction?) which leads to their feeling of " being used. " Even though - in your own words - the AS's " behaviours were based on good intentions " . That's not manipulation by an AS; it's the other way 'round. > think although I am sure some NT people can do the same thing. I know my > partner has felt manipulated and used even though behaviours were based > on good intentions. > > Kind Regards > > Greg DX AS at 53 > > > > To: <aspires-relationships > > Date: 09/03/2010 04:06 PM > Subject: RE: How to Fight Fair with an AS Spouse? > Sent by: aspires-relationships > > Hello ecofrugal, > > What a stimulating and important question you ask here. I might be able > to give you a few suggestions. > > For a start, this issue of you missing his real meaning and > understanding after 8 years of marriage. There are two or three reasons > for this. First, an Aspergian can go through life absolutely missing the > commonly understood meanings of words. Because he may never have > experienced factors like Intimacy, Bonding, Sexual Chemistry and even > Love in the way that others know them, he may sincerely believe that his > own experience of them is identical with that of other people. Intimacy > may well be interpreted by him as meaning being polite to the other > party; or being tolerant of their views and habits. [ snip ] Bill, dx AS -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm Quote
Guest guest Posted March 15, 2010 Report Posted March 15, 2010 >> >> Note that the interchangeability of partners smacks of a utilitarian >> approach to sexual congress. This is why I think that NT partners feel >> they are being used. The manipulation of people is a classic AS trait I I disagree also ... the AS people I know, myself included, rarely have the skills necessary to manipulate others. We may try, but it's like a totally color-blind person painting a rainbow ... we know where the colors go, but it just doesn't look right. As far as a utilitarian approach to sex ... well, if AS folk had that, my DS (probably Aspie) and I (definitely Aspie) would not be in couples counseling for, in part, sexual communication issues. It may be just me, but Ron, this sentence sounds somewhat hurtful and mean. --Liz Quote
Guest guest Posted March 15, 2010 Report Posted March 15, 2010 WD Loughman wrote: << Gullibility, and 'easy to manipulate' are what I understand as AS-ish - relative to NTs in a given situation. >> I agree here. Unfortunately, in the most severe cases (and I'm familiar with plenty of them), the social problems can further snowball and make the situation even worse for the naive AS person. Once the AS individual realizes that the joke is on them (yet again), the resulting embarrassment and shame can morph into anger and bitterness toward the perceived oppressor. Sometimes leading to all sorts of " acting out " that can further alienate the AS individual from others (both AS and NT alike). << All relationships depend on *two* parties keeping their cool in any problem situations. One, say AS, may inadvertently say or do the " wrong thing " to, say, an NT. It's the *NT's* misunderstanding (knee-jerk reaction?) which leads to their feeling of " being used. " Even though - in your own words - the AS's " behaviours were based on good intentions " . >> I think you've described the phenomenon well, Bill. I'm a member of several " Cassandra " groups for women, and have noticed that the way in which some NTs choose to interpret their AS partner's behavior contributes greatly to the problem. As the women all come together to validate and support each other's perspectives as 'victims' of emotional abuse, such viewpoints only become more 'real' to each of them. Now having said that, I can totally understand where the NT person is at, especially when both parties have only recently become aware of AS and the way in which it can impact communication within the relationship. In their mutual ignorance, painful and disappointing interactions (that could have many explanations) are instead taken so very personally and regarded as intentionally inflicted. Over the years, the feelings of emotional abandonment, intense disappointment, and opportunity cost build upon each other and become a toxic stew of resentment and anger. After awhile, perspective changes and the emotional abuse becomes very real to these self-appointed 'victims'. I've got lots of personal experience living with this relationship dynamic myself, I'm afraid. There really does come a point where the 'victim' becomes so mired in their own pain that the obstacles to clarity and understanding simply become insurmountable. Had both parties been aware of AS earlier in the relationship, they might have had a chance to meet in the middle before the anger and resentment became too great, thereby snuffing out the spark of the very magic that brought that couple together in the first place. Best, ~CJ Quote
Guest guest Posted March 15, 2010 Report Posted March 15, 2010 I agree with Bill (below). I myself have been manipulated more times than I can count, mostly previous to learning about AS and less and less as I have learned more. But even as I learn more I have no interest or desire to manipulate... From the time I was a small child I could see no point what so ever in manipulating of any sort, rather I was always on a quest for what was REAL. I found myself completely lacking any interest in being in relationships with people who were fake or manipulative yet found myself over and over with those type of people. I could never understand how I got there until I learned about my AS and started realizing that others do not think the way I do. One thing I learned about me personally is that my basic assumption about others is: " Of course they are telling me the truth, why would anyone want to lie or bother to lie. " With each and every person I thought this until proven wrong, which happened more times than not. It never crossed my mind to manipulate others to get them to be what I wanted because that would have been at cross purposes with what I wanted in the first place which was total genuine honest interaction. Jennie AS gullible doesn't understand manipulation but has learned to recognize it. Re: How to Fight Fair with an AS Spouse? > Greg, I gotta disagree! Not " a classic AS trait " at all. If anything, > it's the other way 'round! Gullibility, and 'easy to manipulate' are > what I understand as AS-ish - relative to NTs in a given situation. > > That's the case even with adults who've been convinced by others that AS > is a " disability " . ...The medicalization of a *behavior* which in an > " NT " is passed over with nothing more that a snide comment. > A gullible AS adult is led to believe her/his " disability " is *the > cause* of relationship problems. > > It isn't. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 16, 2010 Report Posted March 16, 2010 Bill,I expressed myself poorly. I didnot mean to pathologise the issue of manipulation. The manipulation I was trying to referto is the way AS sometimes do not reciprocate emotionally or respond inthe required way which can be interpreted as manipulation. It isa perception that is made more solid when there seems to be a discrepancybetween the behaviour and what is said or the body language not matchingthe words.AS can feel they are being manipulatedby a very emotional partner when they cannot make sense of their own feelingsand this leads to some perception that we are being told how to think andfeel.More about perceptions than real factbased observable phenomena. The perceptions are what is so different.Greg DX AS at 53From:WD Loughman To:aspires-relationships Date:16/03/2010 06:44 AMSubject:Re: How to FightFair with an AS Spouse?Sent by:aspires-relationships Greg Greer wrote:>> Ron,>> I think you have in one note articulated what is inside the AS bubblewe> tend to live in. Well thought through comments that describe exactlythe> perception that I have and continue to have in dealing with relationships.>> Note that the interchangeability of partners smacks of a utilitarian> approach to sexual congress. This is why I think that NT partnersfeel> they are being used. The manipulation of people is a classic AS traitIGreg, I gotta disagree! Not " a classic AS trait " at all. If anything,it's the other way 'round! Gullibility, and 'easy to manipulate' are what I understand as AS-ish - relative to NTs in a given situation.That's the case even with adults who've been convinced by others that ASis a " disability " . ...The medicalization of a *behavior* whichin an " NT " is passed over with nothing more that a snide comment.A gullible AS adult is led to believe her/his " disability " is*the cause* of relationship problems.It isn't.All relationships depend on *two* parties keeping their cool in any problem situations. One, say AS, may inadvertently say or do the " wrongthing " to, say, an NT.It's the *NT's* misunderstanding (knee-jerk reaction?) which leads to their feeling of " being used. " Even though - in your own words- the AS's " behaviours were based on good intentions " .That's not manipulation by an AS; it's the other way 'round.> think although I am sure some NT people can do the same thing. I knowmy> partner has felt manipulated and used even though behaviours werebased> on good intentions.>> Kind Regards>> Greg DX AS at 53>>> > To: <aspires-relationships >> Date: 09/03/2010 04:06 PM> Subject: RE: How to Fight Fair with an ASSpouse?> Sent by: aspires-relationships >> Hello ecofrugal,>> What a stimulating and important question you ask here. I might beable> to give you a few suggestions.>> For a start, this issue of you missing his real meaning and> understanding after 8 years of marriage. There are two or three reasons> for this. First, an Aspergian can go through life absolutely missingthe> commonly understood meanings of words. Because he may never have> experienced factors like Intimacy, Bonding, Sexual Chemistry and even> Love in the way that others know them, he may sincerely believe thathis> own experience of them is identical with that of other people. Intimacy> may well be interpreted by him as meaning being polite to the other> party; or being tolerant of their views and habits.[ snip ]Bill, dx AS-- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USAhttp://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm Quote
Guest guest Posted March 16, 2010 Report Posted March 16, 2010 Greg Greer wrote: > > Bill, > > I expressed myself poorly. I did not mean to pathologise the issue of > manipulation. Your expression was very clear. I understood what you were writing; ....just disagreed with the phrase you used, and its meaning. > > The manipulation I was trying to refer to is the way AS sometimes do not > reciprocate emotionally or respond in the required way which can be > interpreted as manipulation. But that interpretation - usually by NTs - is *mistaken*, and betrays a basic lack of charity in that person's perception of others ( " knee-jerk " was my term). > It is a perception that is made more solid > when there seems to be a discrepancy between the behaviour and what is > said or the body language not matching the words. That's the key to " lack of charity " : *Given* the discrepancy, not spending a moment to understand why it happened. Not asking the relevant question(s). Not attempting to maintain harmony, but wading right in and firing that first shot. I.e.: " Shoot first and ask questions later. " That's how wars start. > > AS can feel they are being manipulated by a very emotional partner when > they cannot make sense of their own feelings and this leads to some > perception that we are being told how to think and feel. Which is what I was too-archly trying to tell you. *You're* not manipulative - *your partner* is. And that's not your fault. > > More about perceptions than real fact based observable phenomena. The > perceptions are what is so different. Yes. But knowing that, *both* partners have to give it a " Good Ol' College Try. " Nicht wahr?? > Greg Greer wrote: > > Ron, > > > > I think you have in one note articulated what is inside the AS bubble we > > tend to live in. Well thought through comments that describe exactly the > > perception that I have and continue to have in dealing with > > relationships. > > > > Note that the interchangeability of partners smacks of a utilitarian > > approach to sexual congress. This is why I think that NT partners feel > > they are being used. The manipulation of people is a classic AS trait I [ snip ] To that I (WDL) responded: -------------------------- > Greg, I gotta disagree! Not " a classic AS trait " at all. If anything, > it's the other way 'round! Gullibility, and 'easy to manipulate' are > what I understand as AS-ish - relative to NTs in a given situation. > > That's the case even with adults who've been convinced by others that AS > is a " disability " . ...The medicalization of a *behavior* which in an > " NT " is passed over with nothing more that a snide comment. > A gullible AS adult is led to believe her/his " disability " is *the > cause* of relationship problems. > > It isn't. > > All relationships depend on *two* parties keeping their cool in any > problem situations. One, say AS, may inadvertently say or do the " wrong > thing " to, say, an NT. > It's the *NT's* misunderstanding (knee-jerk reaction?) which leads to > their feeling of " being used. " Even though - in your own words - the > AS's " behaviours were based on good intentions " . > > That's not manipulation by an AS; it's the other way 'round. [ snip ] Bill, dx AS -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm Quote
Guest guest Posted March 16, 2010 Report Posted March 16, 2010 Not a classic AS trait? My husband must be unique, then. He spent years studying, through books and online, not only to understand how he should react in social situations, but also how to manipulate others. Specifically, how to manipulate women to get what he wants. He can also manipulate other people. He said it's really easy when you're not emotionally invested in something to get others to respond the way you want. He can pretend to say and feel and do all the right things to make women fall in love with him, and he can manipulate them into being very " clingy " by playing certain mind-games with them. I also have to agree with the comment about the utilitarian approach to sex. I won't go into details on that. > > > > Ron, > > > > I think you have in one note articulated what is inside the AS bubble we > > tend to live in. Well thought through comments that describe exactly the > > perception that I have and continue to have in dealing with relationships. > > > > Note that the interchangeability of partners smacks of a utilitarian > > approach to sexual congress. This is why I think that NT partners feel > > they are being used. The manipulation of people is a classic AS trait I > > Greg, I gotta disagree! Not " a classic AS trait " at all. If anything, > it's the other way 'round! Gullibility, and 'easy to manipulate' are > what I understand as AS-ish - relative to NTs in a given situation. > > That's the case even with adults who've been convinced by others that AS > is a " disability " . ...The medicalization of a *behavior* which in an > " NT " is passed over with nothing more that a snide comment. > A gullible AS adult is led to believe her/his " disability " is *the > cause* of relationship problems. > > It isn't. > > All relationships depend on *two* parties keeping their cool in any > problem situations. One, say AS, may inadvertently say or do the " wrong > thing " to, say, an NT. > It's the *NT's* misunderstanding (knee-jerk reaction?) which leads to > their feeling of " being used. " Even though - in your own words - the > AS's " behaviours were based on good intentions " . > > That's not manipulation by an AS; it's the other way 'round. > > > think although I am sure some NT people can do the same thing. I know my > > partner has felt manipulated and used even though behaviours were based > > on good intentions. > > > > Kind Regards > > > > Greg DX AS at 53 > > > > > > > > To: <aspires-relationships > > > Date: 09/03/2010 04:06 PM > > Subject: RE: How to Fight Fair with an AS Spouse? > > Sent by: aspires-relationships > > > > Hello ecofrugal, > > > > What a stimulating and important question you ask here. I might be able > > to give you a few suggestions. > > > > For a start, this issue of you missing his real meaning and > > understanding after 8 years of marriage. There are two or three reasons > > for this. First, an Aspergian can go through life absolutely missing the > > commonly understood meanings of words. Because he may never have > > experienced factors like Intimacy, Bonding, Sexual Chemistry and even > > Love in the way that others know them, he may sincerely believe that his > > own experience of them is identical with that of other people. Intimacy > > may well be interpreted by him as meaning being polite to the other > > party; or being tolerant of their views and habits. > [ snip ] > > Bill, dx AS > > -- > WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA > http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 16, 2010 Report Posted March 16, 2010 Newland wrote: > > Hi Bill: I think I am missing something here when your said: > / Which is what I was too-archly trying to tell you. *You're* not > manipulative - *your partner* is. And that's not your fault. / > / / > It sounded like he was telling you how he feels and instead of > validating his feelings you are telling him he is wrong IMO Greg was declaring a belief, not expressing a feeling. But *if he were* expressing a feeling, why would I want to " validate " it? Anyway, IMHO *some* feelings are wildly " off the mark " and deserve repudiation - not validation. [That's *not* a commentary on Greg's (cited) words or feelings.] > as his partner > it to blame? I didn't say that. I did say: " *You're* not manipulative - *your partner* is. And that's not your fault. " I declared my opinion that Greg wasn't being manipulative. I declared my opinion that his partner was being manipulative. Then I declared my opinion: Greg's partner being manipulative was not Greg's fault. I said *nothing* about blaming Greg's partner for anything. > How would either of us know that? We don't live with them? I don't *know* anything about Greg (or anyone else) and his situation except what he's written on this List. My responses to him, or to anyone else, are based on my interpretations of what I read, and the reasonable inferences I make from that and all the other things he's written. > Just curious and I apologize if I got another meaning from your words > or took them out of context. No apology needed. Curiosity's a good thing. - Bill, dx AS -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm Quote
Guest guest Posted March 17, 2010 Report Posted March 17, 2010 WD Loughman wrote: << IMO Greg was declaring a belief, not expressing a feeling. But *if he were* expressing a feeling, why would I want to " validate " it? Anyway, IMHO *some* feelings are wildly " off the mark " and deserve repudiation - not validation. >> This sort of thing gives me trouble too, Bill. I think much like you about this sort of thing, or at least about the way I perceive your thought process as described here. It's very hard for me to validate someone's feelings if they seem " off the mark " as you say. Instead, I would prefer to help them understand why such feelings may be working against them. I want to help so as to lessen their pain and confusion. That's how I would want to be treated by others. Yet I have discovered that I seem to be in the minority. What I have needed to learn is that most people do not want this sort of 'help' when they are sharing their feelings. They just want to be *heard* and have their feelings accepted as okay (validated) even if said feelings are full of cognitive distortions and make no sense whatsoever. Feelings don't always respond well to logic. They are a product of the emotions, which is by no means logical. So it has been very hard for me to come to a place where I can accept this enough to actual reflect this acceptance in my behavior toward others. It's almost as if I fight this acceptance within myself, because on some level I feel that emotions create more problems for people than they solve. I try very hard to make peace with the fact that the world doesn't turn according to logic, and that emotions play a huge role in driving thinking and behavior. It's hard for me though. I may have gone off on a tangent with my ramblings. Yet your exchange with reminded me of a communication disconnect in my own life, and I just wanted to explore that a bit here. Best, ~CJ Quote
Guest guest Posted March 17, 2010 Report Posted March 17, 2010 Greg Greer wrote: > > Bill, > > I was approaching commenting on Ron's note from the angle of AS needing > to control their environment. Yes; I understand AS that control. Almost everyone has the same need; it's not unique to AS, doesn't define AS. But yes, it's a *very strong* need. 'Member? I'm AS and have the same strong need; have had for pushing-eight decades. > That is where my partner gets the > perception that I am manipulative as I need time out to decompress and > be social. Being social is not a natural thing for me and I have learned > to pretend so that I can get through without turning people off. I have > become very good at it but it is not seen as genuine by my partner and > daughters. They see me trying to act this way socially and then at home > I have to become myself which seems fake to them Ah-HA! *Now* you've hit the nail on its head! Pretty good with people everywhere *else*, but not at home. Yup - very common in AS/NT marriages. Happened in mine too - a never-ending source of friction for us both. Engendered despair (and anger) in me, anger (and despair) in her. That work/home disparity problem can be overcome. But you can't do it alone. Those around you must do their share. Just like they'd have to with *anyone* they cared about. - Bill, dx AS -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm Quote
Guest guest Posted March 17, 2010 Report Posted March 17, 2010 Greg Greer wrote: > > Bill, and Ron, > > You may have some observations about this. > > Another observation about manipulation of people for good or ill. > > In my job I need to engage people to get things done and I have > developed the knack of being interested in their expertise and appearing > to be technically non proficient so I can get their support to solve > problems. For mile deep technical expertise I am deficient. However I > can join the dots really well between a group of technical folk to drive > solutions and untangle problems. Close to what others in my work-places have said about me. > > That in a way is being manipulative and I am being honest when I > represent myself as technically inferior to really technically skilled > people. However it is for a good purpose and they end up accepting my > skills in leading the group and articulating what to do based on their > recommendations. Pretty much the way I've done things. > > So it is a win win and there is no hidden agenda. Which *again* is a pretty good match for my results. That, in leading what's defined in USA Public Health law as " high-complexity " labs - the highest rating, requiring the most stringent oversight of tasks performed. Bio-warfare labs are rated no higher. My labs also were cited often as among the best in the country; with the highest staff satisfaction, lowest staff turn-over, highest efficiency, etc etc etc. The point is *not* to brag. It's to say I *know* what you're talking about, from decades of personal experience! > > In my relationship I try the same approach but my partner gets very > emotional and I do not understand how to deal with that as I cannot > really comprehend why she feels that way. Heh. Again, also from personal experience, *I know* what you're talking about. > I want to collaborate but > their needs to be a shared sense of purpose which can be at odds in an > intimate relationship. Yes. Of course it shouldn't be " at odds " . Trouble here, inter alia, is what means " sense of purpose " , really, and *especially* what means " shared " . One person's " shared " may be the other's submission. That's death to any " compromise " . In my two marriages, that *always* was the biggest single problem. Not money; not sex. *Always*: " Bill, your idea of sharing is permitting me to do things your way. " This never was true, but I never could get across what *was* true. That's one of the three *defining* AS criteria: Impaired reciprocal social communication. The official definition says " impaired " - in our case (my wives and me), it was " failure " . > I believe that her focus is on getting the > relationship to where she needs it to be. Can you not see? That requires *your* submission! There's no " compromise " in that. > My focus is fitting the > relationship into my areas of interest which sometimes consume me and > trying to accommodate her wishes. A situation which is quite fraught > with contradictions. On the other hand, your focus isn't all that different from hers: " ...fitting the relationship into *my* areas of interest " most certainly must require her submission. I don't hear compromise in that. Greg, something's got to give. And it *can not* be your choice alone as to what that will be. > She cannot accept that people are not the centre of > my life and from her perspective why should she. Her needs are not being > met. Neither are yours. How well do you think she understands that? Or does she understand it at all? > > So compromise is something I am learning about. Greg, that's a *life-long* task; because compromise always involves at least two people. Unless everyone you deal with is the same ol' person, there *always* will be new people and new " situations " . How and why you enter into a compromise always will be changing, always be a bit (or a lot) different from the last time. That BTW is the reason why your success at work doesn't " square " with your experience at home. The workplace has rules, usually pretty clear, and everyone abides by them - " or else! " There's always a *3rd-party* Final Arbiter that nobody can ignore or escape - The Boss. Or his/her boss, or... Marriage isn't like that. That's what makes a good living for all the shrinks and counselors out there. Play-acting at being the final arbiters which they never are, nor ever can be. Greg's words, above, were in response to: ------------------------------ > > To: aspires-relationships > Date: 17/03/2010 09:15 AM > Subject: Re: How to Fight Fair with an AS Spouse? > Sent by: aspires-relationships > > Greg Greer wrote: > > Bill, > > I expressed myself poorly. I did not mean to pathologise the issue of > > manipulation. > > Your expression was very clear. I understood what you were writing; > ...just disagreed with the phrase you used, and its meaning. [ snip ] - Bill, dx AS; ...decades married; finally happy -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm Quote
Guest guest Posted March 17, 2010 Report Posted March 17, 2010 CJ wrote: > WD Loughman wrote: [ snip ] > It's very hard for me to validate someone's feelings if they seem " off > the mark " as you say. Instead, I would prefer to help them understand > why such feelings may be working against them. I want to help so as to > lessen their pain and confusion. Which is all and only what I've tried to do on this list. Not always so successfully as I'd have liked. > > That's how I would want to be treated by others. > > Yet I have discovered that I seem to be in the minority. What I have > needed to learn is that most people do not want this sort of 'help' when > they are sharing their feelings. They just want to be *heard* and have > their feelings accepted as okay (validated) even if said feelings are > full of cognitive distortions and make no sense whatsoever. You're absolutely right. It's the meat'n'potatoes of this list. Some though, like Gregg, at least after awhile begin to need more. They want *answers* - maybe even some genuine help. - not validation. > > Feelings don't always respond well to logic. They are a product of the > emotions, which is by no means logical. So it has been very hard for me > to come to a place where I can accept this enough to actual reflect this > acceptance in my behavior toward others. It's almost as if I fight this > acceptance within myself, because on some level I feel that emotions > create more problems for people than they solve. " The sensation is familiar " , ...said he, drily. You have my sympathy. > > I try very hard to make peace with the fact that the world doesn't turn > according to logic, and that emotions play a huge role in driving > thinking and behavior. It's hard for me though. Heh. Like far too many others, you appear to have been " taken in " by my way (in some situations) of lapsing into somewhat prissy prose. Others have said: " Bill, you're always so logical. " Often in a tone, with body language, which shouts: " too @ & %!$# _goddam_ logical " . Guilty as charged. But I'm not Being Logical. Logic, logical thinking, to me implies Boolean algebra and funny symbols my word processor doesn't make. I believe what I do is better described as Reason, reasoning. The opposite of what Steve 's book ' Dumbth! ' was all about. I see no incompatibility between Reason and Feeling. In my view both not only are possible together, it's *necessary* they be so for a full and happy life! (With another nod to Steve , and apologies to, um, St. Augustine?) > > I may have gone off on a tangent with my ramblings. Yet your exchange > with reminded me of a communication disconnect in my own life, and > I just wanted to explore that a bit here. Explore away. I'd like to hear more. - Bill, dx AS -- WD " Bill " Loughman - Berkeley, California USA http://home.earthlink.net/~wdloughman/wdl.htm Quote
Guest guest Posted March 17, 2010 Report Posted March 17, 2010 > Greg Greer wrote: > > That is where my partner gets the > > perception that I am manipulative as I need time out to decompress and > > be social. Being social is not a natural thing for me and I have learned > > to pretend so that I can get through without turning people off. I have > > become very good at it but it is not seen as genuine by my partner and > > daughters. They see me trying to act this way socially and then at home > > I have to become myself which seems fake to them > > Ah-HA! *Now* you've hit the nail on its head! Pretty good with people > everywhere *else*, but not at home. Yup - very common in AS/NT marriages. > Happened in mine too - a never-ending source of friction for us both. > Engendered despair (and anger) in me, anger (and despair) in her. > > That work/home disparity problem can be overcome. > But you can't do it alone. Those around you must do their share. > Just like they'd have to with *anyone* they cared about. Marriage does not function like a workplace. At work, we are only with others for about 40-50 hours a week, during which we are not working together much of the time. And we don't try to get too intimate with our workmates -- at least, I hope not! But in marriage, we expect to spend the rest of our lives very close to another person -- or they expect that of us. It's the rare relationship where one partner can say " I need a vacation from the marriage, see you in 2 weeks. " The false fronts and pretending we do at work don't function well in a marriage. As Greg sees, when someone lives with another who is pretending most of the time, it doesn't work out well. Marriage works best when both partners communicate openly about their needs, wants, and preferences. If the couple can do this, and both are understanding of each other, the marriage can work well -- NT-NT, AS-NT, or AS-AS. The problem comes when one member of the couple (or both): - does not know themselves well enough to communicate to the other, - doesn't know how to communicate without hurting their partner, - refuses to accept their partner as-is. Before writing off marriage, I would look at these factors, and see if any of them can be repaired. Sometimes they can't, but often they can be fixed, with some work. This is what I'm doing ... I know I have communication problems, and I think my DH doesn't understand himself well -- and I know he doesn't accept me the way I am. --Liz ------------ SF, science, and Gifted Ed butons, mugs, and other items at http://www.zazzle.com/CartesianBear* Higher Quality Adult & kid shirts at http://www.printfection.com/cartesianbear Quote
Guest guest Posted March 17, 2010 Report Posted March 17, 2010 Bill, Couldn't there be mutual submission to each others NEEDS and mutual 'deal with it yourself' for WANTS...? Theoretically of course.... Jennie Re: How to Fight Fair with an AS Spouse? >> I believe that her focus is on getting the >> relationship to where she needs it to be. > > Can you not see? That requires *your* submission! There's no > " compromise " in that. > >> My focus is fitting the >> relationship into my areas of interest which sometimes consume me and >> trying to accommodate her wishes. A situation which is quite fraught >> with contradictions. > > On the other hand, your focus isn't all that different from hers: > " ...fitting the relationship into *my* areas of interest " most > certainly must require her submission. > > I don't hear compromise in that. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 17, 2010 Report Posted March 17, 2010 Aha! This is exactly what my husband has been trying to tell me, but in language I understand. And of course, it's easier to hear from a stranger than the person you love Thank you. Now if my husband could just try to understand the other side of it. > > > It's very hard for me to validate someone's feelings if they seem " off > the mark " as you say. Instead, I would prefer to help them understand > why such feelings may be working against them. I want to help so as to > lessen their pain and confusion. > > That's how I would want to be treated by others. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 17, 2010 Report Posted March 17, 2010 If that were the case then would we be having this discussion? Doesn't mutual submission suggest one has the capacity think of others feelings and emotional needs as well as being willing to meet them? My experience with my now ex-(AS) wife says differently. In order to submit one must be aware of the needs and desires of another person. ScooterSent from my BlackBerry Smartphone provided by AlltelDate: Wed, 17 Mar 2010 10:04:17 -0700To: <aspires-relationships >Subject: Re: How to Fight Fair with an AS Spouse? Bill,Couldn't there be mutual submission to each others NEEDS and mutual 'deal with it yourself' for WANTS...? Theoretically of course....Jennie Re: How to Fight Fair with an AS Spouse?>> I believe that her focus is on getting the>> relationship to where she needs it to be.>> Can you not see? That requires *your* submission! There's no> " compromise " in that.>>> My focus is fitting the>> relationship into my areas of interest which sometimes consume me and>> trying to accommodate her wishes. A situation which is quite fraught>> with contradictions.>> On the other hand, your focus isn't all that different from hers:> " ...fitting the relationship into *my* areas of interest " most> certainly must require her submission.>> I don't hear compromise in that. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 17, 2010 Report Posted March 17, 2010 He doesn't do it all the time. I should have mentioned that he's not playing these games with other women while he's married to me. It's something from his past that he was honest about. He claims he never intentionally tried to manipulate me when we were dating, but looking back I think he did. Before I knew about AS, I thought he might be a sociopath, because that was the only thing I'd ever heard of that would explain why he could mimic emotions perfectly, but not seem to actually feel them. But he doesn't go around using and hurting people like a sociopath. He mostly just wants to be left alone. I think the whole phase of using women came about because of some rejections in high school. Making girls like him became a project. He also went through a phase of trying to figure out why he's different. He took tons of personality tests. I believe that some did show he had some narcissistic tendencies, but he also rated high on some other things that didn't completely fit. I think they're all just parts of his AS, and of course he never took a test for that, because he doesn't believe in it. > > Um.... frankly that sounds like narcissism. Not to say he's not AS but he > could be both. Jennie married into a narcissistic family who manipulate for > self without remorse. > > Re: How to Fight Fair with an AS Spouse? > > > > Not a classic AS trait? My husband must be unique, then. He spent years > > studying, through books and online, not only to understand how he should > > react in social situations, but also how to manipulate others. > > Specifically, how to manipulate women to get what he wants. He can also > > manipulate other people. He said it's really easy when you're not > > emotionally invested in something to get others to respond the way you > > want. He can pretend to say and feel and do all the right things to make > > women fall in love with him, and he can manipulate them into being very > > " clingy " by playing certain mind-games with them. > > > > I also have to agree with the comment about the utilitarian approach to > > sex. I won't go into details on that. > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.