Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of no-insurance. I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it as " I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that? " The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible. So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone else, it's business as they're used to. We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point to keep the hamster wheel from spinning. Best, Chad Costley Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 Chad, Stay away from United if you can and be on the lookout for Aetna not trying to “enroll” you in their $5 a month “capitated plan” without your knowledge. Look for small local insurance companies in your area, at least here in NYC, I have found that they pay way better than the big guys. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Chad Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 9:17 AM To: Subject: If you can't beat them... join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of no-insurance. I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it as " I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that? " The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible. So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone else, it's business as they're used to. We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point to keep the hamster wheel from spinning. Best, Chad Costley Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 Chad, Stay away from United if you can and be on the lookout for Aetna not trying to “enroll” you in their $5 a month “capitated plan” without your knowledge. Look for small local insurance companies in your area, at least here in NYC, I have found that they pay way better than the big guys. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Chad Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 9:17 AM To: Subject: If you can't beat them... join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of no-insurance. I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it as " I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that? " The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible. So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone else, it's business as they're used to. We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point to keep the hamster wheel from spinning. Best, Chad Costley Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 Chad, This is a very useful post. IMP is helpful but not sufficient if we can't sustain ourselves financially. After decades of third party payment, most patients are still not yet willing to pay for quality care. More will as their quality of care and service continues to worsen. The question is will we still be in business by the time enough of them figure that out. Did you try any sort of per visit or per call fee to reduce overutilization? Isn't it common for insurance contracts to prohibit fees or for insurers to simply drop you from their panel if you charge fees? Are you opted out of Medicare? Thanks, join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of no-insurance. I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it as "I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that?" The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible. So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone else, it's business as they're used to. We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point to keep the hamster wheel from spinning. Best, Chad Costley Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 Chad: Don't think that just because you start to take insurance that the amount of work will be any less. In fact people will just have the attitude " well, I have to pay a $20 co-pay and I pay good premiums, let me see how much I get out of my doctor " . You will also have to deal with all the other headaches we have: claims denials, referrals, pre-authorizations and patients complaining that we did not submit the appropriate code and why are THEY responsible for their deductible. I think you may need to raise your fees or have a lower monthly payment for certain bundled services and then charge for more time consuming services. For example, you can lower the fee to say $50 a month but only include one annual physical and " x " number of emails/phone calls a month. Another option would be to include the annual physican and one visit per month for the fee and charge for phone calls and emails at a lower rate.Your patients can then decide to hold their questions for their monthly visit or pay for a quick email. It you charge per 15min for the phone call, that will make their calls " efficient " - sort of like being on the phone with the lawyer! You can even go as far as including emails about refills as part of your monthly fees, unless you have another system for refill requests. If you charge higher, you may attract a client base that is more appreciative of your services. Based on the way things are going, physicians have one of two choices. Either join the herd of large hospital systems and multispecialty groups, earn a paycheck and call it a day OR drop all insurance and go to a fee for service/concierge/private md model. Here in NJ groups of four or fewer physicians are in jeopardy and many are beginning to sell their practices to large hospital based groups in order to survive. Many are beginning to retire. If the payment cuts go through-this will expedite the process. One of the large groups in North Jersey has already started courting these practices. The tentacles are spreading. -Sofia > > > > join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of > > no-insurance. > > > > I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is > > that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like > > retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many > > patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - > > they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't > > scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 > > emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the > > expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about > > health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee > > allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, > > comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it > > as " I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that? " > > The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible. > > > > So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really > > value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email > > access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture > > only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone > > else, it's business as they're used to. > > > > We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at > > the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point > > to keep the hamster wheel from spinning. > > > > Best, > > > > Chad Costley > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 This email and getting more cynical reinforces my feeling that what we are trying to do is really a niche product ( Mac to the PC). There really is only a small market for it..and that will take years to change. The net doctors product the Kathleen found is yet another sign.The only way I see forward is to worksmart (not hard) within the system, decrease expenses, market ourselves to the discerning and count on obsolescence of an MD providing primary care- in the next decade... and evolve.. the question is HOW? join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of no-insurance. I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it as " I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that? " The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible. So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone else, it's business as they're used to. We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point to keep the hamster wheel from spinning. Best, Chad Costley -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 MD’s providing Primary Care are not going to disappear. I think the big traditional medical practices are going the way of the mainframe and us “PC’s” are going to take over. We are the most cost-efficient way of providing care, period. In my neck of the woods, which should be considered the worst environment with high presence of big hospitals, low income, high for profit insurance presence and high government subsidized insurance presence, the big guys are closing up the practices; they can’t compete. Their model of low quality PCP’s just to take care of cold’s and refers everything and anything can’t survive in this cut cost environment. 10 people moving paper around an office and making calls is not health care, period. Our model is the new wave, barebone, high tech, high quality, efficient and available for patient’s needs is the future. We only have been really able to work this way the past 2 years with the presence of good EMR’s, high bandwidth internet, e-prescribing, lab bridges and access to good medical information. We are going to have to figure out how to survive the next 3 to 5 years, tops, for us to take over the field. There is no money out there to waste anymore and with more people, basically, paying out of pocket availability and quality are going to become paramount. The paternalistic, good Samaritan, view of trying to help needs to be changed to a service business approach that produces great care for the money. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sangeetha Murthy Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 1:05 PM To: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... This email and getting more cynical reinforces my feeling that what we are trying to do is really a niche product ( Mac to the PC). There really is only a small market for it..and that will take years to change. The net doctors product the Kathleen found is yet another sign. The only way I see forward is to worksmart (not hard) within the system, decrease expenses, market ourselves to the discerning and count on obsolescence of an MD providing primary care- in the next decade... and evolve.. the question is HOW? On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 6:17 AM, Chad wrote: join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of no-insurance. I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it as " I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that? " The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible. So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone else, it's business as they're used to. We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point to keep the hamster wheel from spinning. Best, Chad Costley -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 MD’s providing Primary Care are not going to disappear. I think the big traditional medical practices are going the way of the mainframe and us “PC’s” are going to take over. We are the most cost-efficient way of providing care, period. In my neck of the woods, which should be considered the worst environment with high presence of big hospitals, low income, high for profit insurance presence and high government subsidized insurance presence, the big guys are closing up the practices; they can’t compete. Their model of low quality PCP’s just to take care of cold’s and refers everything and anything can’t survive in this cut cost environment. 10 people moving paper around an office and making calls is not health care, period. Our model is the new wave, barebone, high tech, high quality, efficient and available for patient’s needs is the future. We only have been really able to work this way the past 2 years with the presence of good EMR’s, high bandwidth internet, e-prescribing, lab bridges and access to good medical information. We are going to have to figure out how to survive the next 3 to 5 years, tops, for us to take over the field. There is no money out there to waste anymore and with more people, basically, paying out of pocket availability and quality are going to become paramount. The paternalistic, good Samaritan, view of trying to help needs to be changed to a service business approach that produces great care for the money. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sangeetha Murthy Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 1:05 PM To: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... This email and getting more cynical reinforces my feeling that what we are trying to do is really a niche product ( Mac to the PC). There really is only a small market for it..and that will take years to change. The net doctors product the Kathleen found is yet another sign. The only way I see forward is to worksmart (not hard) within the system, decrease expenses, market ourselves to the discerning and count on obsolescence of an MD providing primary care- in the next decade... and evolve.. the question is HOW? On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 6:17 AM, Chad wrote: join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of no-insurance. I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it as " I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that? " The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible. So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone else, it's business as they're used to. We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point to keep the hamster wheel from spinning. Best, Chad Costley -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 Sofia, You said “One of the large groups in North Jersey has already started courting these practices. The tentacles are spreading.” Can you elaborate on this? Kathy Saradarian, MD Branchville, NJ www.qualityfamilypractice.com Solo 4/03, Practicing since 9/90 Practice Partner 5/03 Low staffing From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of drsof99 Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 12:47 PM To: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... Chad: Don't think that just because you start to take insurance that the amount of work will be any less. In fact people will just have the attitude " well, I have to pay a $20 co-pay and I pay good premiums, let me see how much I get out of my doctor " . You will also have to deal with all the other headaches we have: claims denials, referrals, pre-authorizations and patients complaining that we did not submit the appropriate code and why are THEY responsible for their deductible. I think you may need to raise your fees or have a lower monthly payment for certain bundled services and then charge for more time consuming services. For example, you can lower the fee to say $50 a month but only include one annual physical and " x " number of emails/phone calls a month. Another option would be to include the annual physican and one visit per month for the fee and charge for phone calls and emails at a lower rate.Your patients can then decide to hold their questions for their monthly visit or pay for a quick email. It you charge per 15min for the phone call, that will make their calls " efficient " - sort of like being on the phone with the lawyer! You can even go as far as including emails about refills as part of your monthly fees, unless you have another system for refill requests. If you charge higher, you may attract a client base that is more appreciative of your services. Based on the way things are going, physicians have one of two choices. Either join the herd of large hospital systems and multispecialty groups, earn a paycheck and call it a day OR drop all insurance and go to a fee for service/concierge/private md model. Here in NJ groups of four or fewer physicians are in jeopardy and many are beginning to sell their practices to large hospital based groups in order to survive. Many are beginning to retire. If the payment cuts go through-this will expedite the process. One of the large groups in North Jersey has already started courting these practices. The tentacles are spreading. -Sofia > > > > join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of > > no-insurance. > > > > I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is > > that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like > > retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many > > patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - > > they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't > > scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 > > emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the > > expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about > > health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee > > allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, > > comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it > > as " I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that? " > > The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible. > > > > So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really > > value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email > > access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture > > only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone > > else, it's business as they're used to. > > > > We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at > > the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point > > to keep the hamster wheel from spinning. > > > > Best, > > > > Chad Costley > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 Thats another way of looking at it.But I don't see the big guys going away too easily..Here,large groups negotiate and do get 120% of medicare from the commercial insurers while us solos get 80 %... I must say, the patients who come to me are the small to minuscule proportion that don't want antibiotics on call, narcotics on demand..and I am under tremendous pressure -multiple phone calls, emails, back door pharmacy requests,- to stretch the intervals between visits from them ( which is the only way HMO products make any sense -For the few HMO patients I have I am providing 120 % of comparable medicare service- I discount it as advertisement) Health care provision is getting more fragmented by the day..and we need to be prepared.But i sure hope you are right . MD’s providing Primary Care are not going to disappear. I think the big traditional medical practices are going the way of the mainframe and us “PC’s” are going to take over. We are the most cost-efficient way of providing care, period. In my neck of the woods, which should be considered the worst environment with high presence of big hospitals, low income, high for profit insurance presence and high government subsidized insurance presence, the big guys are closing up the practices; they can’t compete. Their model of low quality PCP’s just to take care of cold’s and refers everything and anything can’t survive in this cut cost environment. 10 people moving paper around an office and making calls is not health care, period. Our model is the new wave, barebone, high tech, high quality, efficient and available for patient’s needs is the future. We only have been really able to work this way the past 2 years with the presence of good EMR’s, high bandwidth internet, e-prescribing, lab bridges and access to good medical information. We are going to have to figure out how to survive the next 3 to 5 years, tops, for us to take over the field. There is no money out there to waste anymore and with more people, basically, paying out of pocket availability and quality are going to become paramount. The paternalistic, good Samaritan, view of trying to help needs to be changed to a service business approach that produces great care for the money. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sangeetha Murthy Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 1:05 PM To: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... This email and getting more cynical reinforces my feeling that what we are trying to do is really a niche product ( Mac to the PC). There really is only a small market for it..and that will take years to change. The net doctors product the Kathleen found is yet another sign. The only way I see forward is to worksmart (not hard) within the system, decrease expenses, market ourselves to the discerning and count on obsolescence of an MD providing primary care- in the next decade... and evolve.. the question is HOW? On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 6:17 AM, Chad wrote: join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of no-insurance. I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it as " I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that? " The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible. So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone else, it's business as they're used to. We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point to keep the hamster wheel from spinning. Best, Chad Costley -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 Cost efficiency by itself will not guarantee our survival. The big clinics will have the insurance and Medicare contracts in the future regardless of efficiency. We're too small and impotent to play that game. Our efficiency helps us by allowing us to offer much better service at a lower price than if we ran inefficient practices. Since the insurers and the government have promised far more care than they (or society) can afford, they'll be forced to continually cut costs and reduce service at the big clinics, growing a market niche for us. Thats another way of looking at it. But I don't see the big guys going away too easily.. Here,large groups negotiate and do get 120% of medicare from the commercial insurers while us solos get 80 %... I must say, the patients who come to me are the small to minuscule proportion that don't want antibiotics on call, narcotics on demand.. and I am under tremendous pressure -multiple phone calls, emails, back door pharmacy requests,- to stretch the intervals between visits from them ( which is the only way HMO products make any sense -For the few HMO patients I have I am providing 120 % of comparable medicare service- I discount it as advertisement) Health care provision is getting more fragmented by the day..and we need to be prepared. But i sure hope you are right . On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 10:21 AM, Batlle <jbatlleoptonline (DOT) net> wrote: MD’s providing Primary Care are not going to disappear. I think the big traditional medical practices are going the way of the mainframe and us “PC’s” are going to take over. We are the most cost-efficient way of providing care, period. In my neck of the woods, which should be considered the worst environment with high presence of big hospitals, low income, high for profit insurance presence and high government subsidized insurance presence, the big guys are closing up the practices; they can’t compete. Their model of low quality PCP’s just to take care of cold’s and refers everything and anything can’t survive in this cut cost environment. 10 people moving paper around an office and making calls is not health care, period. Our model is the new wave, barebone, high tech, high quality, efficient and available for patient’s needs is the future. We only have been really able to work this way the past 2 years with the presence of good EMR’s, high bandwidth internet, e-prescribing, lab bridges and access to good medical information. We are going to have to figure out how to survive the next 3 to 5 years, tops, for us to take over the field. There is no money out there to waste anymore and with more people, basically, paying out of pocket availability and quality are going to become paramount. The paternalistic, good Samaritan, view of trying to help needs to be changed to a service business approach that produces great care for the money. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sangeetha Murthy Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 1:05 PM To: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... This email and getting more cynical reinforces my feeling that what we are trying to do is really a niche product ( Mac to the PC). There really is only a small market for it..and that will take years to change. The net doctors product the Kathleen found is yet another sign. The only way I see forward is to worksmart (not hard) within the system, decrease expenses, market ourselves to the discerning and count on obsolescence of an MD providing primary care- in the next decade... and evolve.. the question is HOW? On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 6:17 AM, Chad <chadcostleymac> wrote: join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of no-insurance. I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it as "I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that?" The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible. So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone else, it's business as they're used to. We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point to keep the hamster wheel from spinning. Best, Chad Costley -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 In essence provide value for the same price..We return to the same issues. How do we convince our customers that we are better value? Cost efficiency by itself will not guarantee our survival. The big clinics will have the insurance and Medicare contracts in the future regardless of efficiency. We're too small and impotent to play that game. Our efficiency helps us by allowing us to offer much better service at a lower price than if we ran inefficient practices. Since the insurers and the government have promised far more care than they (or society) can afford, they'll be forced to continually cut costs and reduce service at the big clinics, growing a market niche for us. Thats another way of looking at it. But I don't see the big guys going away too easily.. Here,large groups negotiate and do get 120% of medicare from the commercial insurers while us solos get 80 %... I must say, the patients who come to me are the small to minuscule proportion that don't want antibiotics on call, narcotics on demand.. and I am under tremendous pressure -multiple phone calls, emails, back door pharmacy requests,- to stretch the intervals between visits from them ( which is the only way HMO products make any sense -For the few HMO patients I have I am providing 120 % of comparable medicare service- I discount it as advertisement) Health care provision is getting more fragmented by the day..and we need to be prepared. But i sure hope you are right . On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 10:21 AM, Batlle wrote: MD’s providing Primary Care are not going to disappear. I think the big traditional medical practices are going the way of the mainframe and us “PC’s” are going to take over. We are the most cost-efficient way of providing care, period. In my neck of the woods, which should be considered the worst environment with high presence of big hospitals, low income, high for profit insurance presence and high government subsidized insurance presence, the big guys are closing up the practices; they can’t compete. Their model of low quality PCP’s just to take care of cold’s and refers everything and anything can’t survive in this cut cost environment. 10 people moving paper around an office and making calls is not health care, period. Our model is the new wave, barebone, high tech, high quality, efficient and available for patient’s needs is the future. We only have been really able to work this way the past 2 years with the presence of good EMR’s, high bandwidth internet, e-prescribing, lab bridges and access to good medical information. We are going to have to figure out how to survive the next 3 to 5 years, tops, for us to take over the field. There is no money out there to waste anymore and with more people, basically, paying out of pocket availability and quality are going to become paramount. The paternalistic, good Samaritan, view of trying to help needs to be changed to a service business approach that produces great care for the money. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sangeetha Murthy Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 1:05 PM To: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... This email and getting more cynical reinforces my feeling that what we are trying to do is really a niche product ( Mac to the PC). There really is only a small market for it..and that will take years to change. The net doctors product the Kathleen found is yet another sign. The only way I see forward is to worksmart (not hard) within the system, decrease expenses, market ourselves to the discerning and count on obsolescence of an MD providing primary care- in the next decade... and evolve.. the question is HOW? On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 6:17 AM, Chad wrote: join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of no-insurance. I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it as " I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that? " The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible. So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone else, it's business as they're used to. We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point to keep the hamster wheel from spinning. Best, Chad Costley -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 , There is hope. 2 of the biggest government sponsored insurers just took their Primary Care contracts away form 2 of the big local hospitals and sent all their patients the way of my IPA (95% PCP and totally controlled by PCP types). The insurers are giving us preferential contracts because we provide cheaper and better services than the Hospital based practices. This group of PCP’s is on a spectrum me on one side and more traditional type of practices on the other but as a group we are way cheaper than anything the Hospital clinics can provide because of less overhead and more access. Unless we believe that the market is going to continue throwing money away in keeping high overhead systems going, they are going the way of big cars from Detroit, it may take a while but eventually they are going to disappear. In my neck of the woods already 2 big Medicare Advantage plans are pulling out of the Medicare business, no big profits; the others are trying any way they can to get cheaper care; the hospital practices can’t provide this. The problem is that the insurers see isolated doc’s as little guys, the only way to get their attention is to form groups, that is where we fail ourselves. José from The Barrio Hating this rain more by the minute. From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Pierce Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 3:18 PM To: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... Cost efficiency by itself will not guarantee our survival. The big clinics will have the insurance and Medicare contracts in the future regardless of efficiency. We're too small and impotent to play that game. Our efficiency helps us by allowing us to offer much better service at a lower price than if we ran inefficient practices. Since the insurers and the government have promised far more care than they (or society) can afford, they'll be forced to continually cut costs and reduce service at the big clinics, growing a market niche for us. Thats another way of looking at it. But I don't see the big guys going away too easily.. Here,large groups negotiate and do get 120% of medicare from the commercial insurers while us solos get 80 %... I must say, the patients who come to me are the small to minuscule proportion that don't want antibiotics on call, narcotics on demand.. and I am under tremendous pressure -multiple phone calls, emails, back door pharmacy requests,- to stretch the intervals between visits from them ( which is the only way HMO products make any sense -For the few HMO patients I have I am providing 120 % of comparable medicare service- I discount it as advertisement) Health care provision is getting more fragmented by the day..and we need to be prepared. But i sure hope you are right . MD’s providing Primary Care are not going to disappear. I think the big traditional medical practices are going the way of the mainframe and us “PC’s” are going to take over. We are the most cost-efficient way of providing care, period. In my neck of the woods, which should be considered the worst environment with high presence of big hospitals, low income, high for profit insurance presence and high government subsidized insurance presence, the big guys are closing up the practices; they can’t compete. Their model of low quality PCP’s just to take care of cold’s and refers everything and anything can’t survive in this cut cost environment. 10 people moving paper around an office and making calls is not health care, period. Our model is the new wave, barebone, high tech, high quality, efficient and available for patient’s needs is the future. We only have been really able to work this way the past 2 years with the presence of good EMR’s, high bandwidth internet, e-prescribing, lab bridges and access to good medical information. We are going to have to figure out how to survive the next 3 to 5 years, tops, for us to take over the field. There is no money out there to waste anymore and with more people, basically, paying out of pocket availability and quality are going to become paramount. The paternalistic, good Samaritan, view of trying to help needs to be changed to a service business approach that produces great care for the money. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sangeetha Murthy Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 1:05 PM To: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... This email and getting more cynical reinforces my feeling that what we are trying to do is really a niche product ( Mac to the PC). There really is only a small market for it..and that will take years to change. The net doctors product the Kathleen found is yet another sign. The only way I see forward is to worksmart (not hard) within the system, decrease expenses, market ourselves to the discerning and count on obsolescence of an MD providing primary care- in the next decade... and evolve.. the question is HOW? On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 6:17 AM, Chad wrote: join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of no-insurance. I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it as " I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that? " The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible. So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone else, it's business as they're used to. We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point to keep the hamster wheel from spinning. Best, Chad Costley -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 That is a tough cookie to chew. I don’t think people appreciate health until it is lacking and then it is still tough. The advantages of quality care, at least in the present environment, are not tangible. First, most patient’s still think that more is better (more diagnostics test, more medications, more labs); second, great diabetes care means you avoided complications and that it is difficult to appreciate in foresight. If you are feeling well is very difficult, at least for a big chunk of our citizens, to rationalize what could have happen with bad care and third, the time to make a difference is huge for most problems. The only place where we make a direct point is on access: if patient can get their problem taken care of now and not wait or have to go to urgent care but for most of those problems the perception is that anyone can do it. Remember we are in a country were healthy people don’t want to contribute to the pie and expect to get “everything done” when they are sick. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sangeetha Murthy Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 3:55 PM To: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... In essence provide value for the same price.. We return to the same issues. How do we convince our customers that we are better value? On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 12:18 PM, Pierce wrote: Cost efficiency by itself will not guarantee our survival. The big clinics will have the insurance and Medicare contracts in the future regardless of efficiency. We're too small and impotent to play that game. Our efficiency helps us by allowing us to offer much better service at a lower price than if we ran inefficient practices. Since the insurers and the government have promised far more care than they (or society) can afford, they'll be forced to continually cut costs and reduce service at the big clinics, growing a market niche for us. Thats another way of looking at it. But I don't see the big guys going away too easily.. Here,large groups negotiate and do get 120% of medicare from the commercial insurers while us solos get 80 %... I must say, the patients who come to me are the small to minuscule proportion that don't want antibiotics on call, narcotics on demand.. and I am under tremendous pressure -multiple phone calls, emails, back door pharmacy requests,- to stretch the intervals between visits from them ( which is the only way HMO products make any sense -For the few HMO patients I have I am providing 120 % of comparable medicare service- I discount it as advertisement) Health care provision is getting more fragmented by the day..and we need to be prepared. But i sure hope you are right . On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 10:21 AM, Batlle wrote: MD’s providing Primary Care are not going to disappear. I think the big traditional medical practices are going the way of the mainframe and us “PC’s” are going to take over. We are the most cost-efficient way of providing care, period. In my neck of the woods, which should be considered the worst environment with high presence of big hospitals, low income, high for profit insurance presence and high government subsidized insurance presence, the big guys are closing up the practices; they can’t compete. Their model of low quality PCP’s just to take care of cold’s and refers everything and anything can’t survive in this cut cost environment. 10 people moving paper around an office and making calls is not health care, period. Our model is the new wave, barebone, high tech, high quality, efficient and available for patient’s needs is the future. We only have been really able to work this way the past 2 years with the presence of good EMR’s, high bandwidth internet, e-prescribing, lab bridges and access to good medical information. We are going to have to figure out how to survive the next 3 to 5 years, tops, for us to take over the field. There is no money out there to waste anymore and with more people, basically, paying out of pocket availability and quality are going to become paramount. The paternalistic, good Samaritan, view of trying to help needs to be changed to a service business approach that produces great care for the money. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sangeetha Murthy Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 1:05 PM To: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... This email and getting more cynical reinforces my feeling that what we are trying to do is really a niche product ( Mac to the PC). There really is only a small market for it..and that will take years to change. The net doctors product the Kathleen found is yet another sign. The only way I see forward is to worksmart (not hard) within the system, decrease expenses, market ourselves to the discerning and count on obsolescence of an MD providing primary care- in the next decade... and evolve.. the question is HOW? On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 6:17 AM, Chad wrote: join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of no-insurance. I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it as " I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that? " The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible. So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone else, it's business as they're used to. We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point to keep the hamster wheel from spinning. Best, Chad Costley -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 Perhaps you need to collect and publish statistics on your performance.Are you a 5 star practice or a 3 star practice? That is a tough cookie to chew. I don’t think people appreciate health until it is lacking and then it is still tough. The advantages of quality care, at least in the present environment, are not tangible. First, most patient’s still think that more is better (more diagnostics test, more medications, more labs); second, great diabetes care means you avoided complications and that it is difficult to appreciate in foresight. If you are feeling well is very difficult, at least for a big chunk of our citizens, to rationalize what could have happen with bad care and third, the time to make a difference is huge for most problems. The only place where we make a direct point is on access: if patient can get their problem taken care of now and not wait or have to go to urgent care but for most of those problems the perception is that anyone can do it. Remember we are in a country were healthy people don’t want to contribute to the pie and expect to get “everything done” when they are sick. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sangeetha Murthy Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 3:55 PM To: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... In essence provide value for the same price.. We return to the same issues. How do we convince our customers that we are better value? On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 12:18 PM, Pierce wrote: Cost efficiency by itself will not guarantee our survival. The big clinics will have the insurance and Medicare contracts in the future regardless of efficiency. We're too small and impotent to play that game. Our efficiency helps us by allowing us to offer much better service at a lower price than if we ran inefficient practices. Since the insurers and the government have promised far more care than they (or society) can afford, they'll be forced to continually cut costs and reduce service at the big clinics, growing a market niche for us. Thats another way of looking at it. But I don't see the big guys going away too easily.. Here,large groups negotiate and do get 120% of medicare from the commercial insurers while us solos get 80 %... I must say, the patients who come to me are the small to minuscule proportion that don't want antibiotics on call, narcotics on demand.. and I am under tremendous pressure -multiple phone calls, emails, back door pharmacy requests,- to stretch the intervals between visits from them ( which is the only way HMO products make any sense -For the few HMO patients I have I am providing 120 % of comparable medicare service- I discount it as advertisement) Health care provision is getting more fragmented by the day..and we need to be prepared. But i sure hope you are right . On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 10:21 AM, Batlle wrote: MD’s providing Primary Care are not going to disappear. I think the big traditional medical practices are going the way of the mainframe and us “PC’s” are going to take over. We are the most cost-efficient way of providing care, period. In my neck of the woods, which should be considered the worst environment with high presence of big hospitals, low income, high for profit insurance presence and high government subsidized insurance presence, the big guys are closing up the practices; they can’t compete. Their model of low quality PCP’s just to take care of cold’s and refers everything and anything can’t survive in this cut cost environment. 10 people moving paper around an office and making calls is not health care, period. Our model is the new wave, barebone, high tech, high quality, efficient and available for patient’s needs is the future. We only have been really able to work this way the past 2 years with the presence of good EMR’s, high bandwidth internet, e-prescribing, lab bridges and access to good medical information. We are going to have to figure out how to survive the next 3 to 5 years, tops, for us to take over the field. There is no money out there to waste anymore and with more people, basically, paying out of pocket availability and quality are going to become paramount. The paternalistic, good Samaritan, view of trying to help needs to be changed to a service business approach that produces great care for the money. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sangeetha Murthy Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 1:05 PM To: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... This email and getting more cynical reinforces my feeling that what we are trying to do is really a niche product ( Mac to the PC). There really is only a small market for it..and that will take years to change. The net doctors product the Kathleen found is yet another sign. The only way I see forward is to worksmart (not hard) within the system, decrease expenses, market ourselves to the discerning and count on obsolescence of an MD providing primary care- in the next decade... and evolve.. the question is HOW? On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 6:17 AM, Chad wrote: join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of no-insurance. I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it as " I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that? " The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible. So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone else, it's business as they're used to. We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point to keep the hamster wheel from spinning. Best, Chad Costley -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D -- Graham Chiuhttp://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 I absolutely agree. We got away from UHC and we couldn't be happier about that choice. They paid her like dirt, were a real pain in the butt to deal with, we could never talk to a live human being in a pinch and our provider reps kept changing every time we would start to get somewhere with the last one.... Could discuss renegotiating terms, prices and conditions or having them approve her for her Subozone therapy no less discuss the appropriate compensation for that as well... In short they STINK, run away as fast as you can... We are losing out Aetan contract thru 's IPO this spring and we have been real hesitant to sign their private contract. It looked so complicated and overly complicated for what it should be... They want dibs on our first born I think. But now that you talk about this $5 per month cap plan, the heck with those bozos. At $5 a month, that's but $60 per year!!! Are they insane or what??? That's like paying for one lousy Medicare rate, eastcoast priced est patient level 3 visit for an entire years worth of care..... I never realized that took an oath of poverty on graduation day... Geeezzzzzz..... To: Sent: Tue, February 23, 2010 10:15:21 AMSubject: RE: If you can't beat them... Chad, Stay away from United if you can and be on the lookout for Aetna not trying to “enroll†you in their $5 a month “capitated plan†without your knowledge. Look for small local insurance companies in your area, at least here in NYC, I have found that they pay way better than the big guys. José from The Barrio From: Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) com [mailto:Practiceimp rovement1@ yahoogroups. com] On Behalf Of ChadSent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 9:17 AMTo: Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) comSubject: [Practiceimprovemen t1] If you can't beat them... join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of no-insurance.I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it as "I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that?" The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible.So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone else, it's business as they're used to.We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point to keep the hamster wheel from spinning.Best,Chad Costley Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 but what statistics truly resonates with patients? I know Hows your health is one, but is that something patients can understand and appreciate? I remember a study statistics not withstanding, a hospital with beautiful gardens is preferred over a better one with better statistics with no garden. So , we are really selling ourselves to the discerning customer arent we? Perhaps you need to collect and publish statistics on your performance. Are you a 5 star practice or a 3 star practice? That is a tough cookie to chew. I don’t think people appreciate health until it is lacking and then it is still tough. The advantages of quality care, at least in the present environment, are not tangible. First, most patient’s still think that more is better (more diagnostics test, more medications, more labs); second, great diabetes care means you avoided complications and that it is difficult to appreciate in foresight. If you are feeling well is very difficult, at least for a big chunk of our citizens, to rationalize what could have happen with bad care and third, the time to make a difference is huge for most problems. The only place where we make a direct point is on access: if patient can get their problem taken care of now and not wait or have to go to urgent care but for most of those problems the perception is that anyone can do it. Remember we are in a country were healthy people don’t want to contribute to the pie and expect to get “everything done” when they are sick. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sangeetha Murthy Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 3:55 PM To: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... In essence provide value for the same price..We return to the same issues. How do we convince our customers that we are better value? Cost efficiency by itself will not guarantee our survival. The big clinics will have the insurance and Medicare contracts in the future regardless of efficiency. We're too small and impotent to play that game. Our efficiency helps us by allowing us to offer much better service at a lower price than if we ran inefficient practices. Since the insurers and the government have promised far more care than they (or society) can afford, they'll be forced to continually cut costs and reduce service at the big clinics, growing a market niche for us. Thats another way of looking at it.But I don't see the big guys going away too easily..Here,large groups negotiate and do get 120% of medicare from the commercial insurers while us solos get 80 %... I must say, the patients who come to me are the small to minuscule proportion that don't want antibiotics on call, narcotics on demand..and I am under tremendous pressure -multiple phone calls, emails, back door pharmacy requests,- to stretch the intervals between visits from them ( which is the only way HMO products make any sense -For the few HMO patients I have I am providing 120 % of comparable medicare service- I discount it as advertisement) Health care provision is getting more fragmented by the day..and we need to be prepared.But i sure hope you are right . MD’s providing Primary Care are not going to disappear. I think the big traditional medical practices are going the way of the mainframe and us “PC’s” are going to take over. We are the most cost-efficient way of providing care, period. In my neck of the woods, which should be considered the worst environment with high presence of big hospitals, low income, high for profit insurance presence and high government subsidized insurance presence, the big guys are closing up the practices; they can’t compete. Their model of low quality PCP’s just to take care of cold’s and refers everything and anything can’t survive in this cut cost environment. 10 people moving paper around an office and making calls is not health care, period. Our model is the new wave, barebone, high tech, high quality, efficient and available for patient’s needs is the future. We only have been really able to work this way the past 2 years with the presence of good EMR’s, high bandwidth internet, e-prescribing, lab bridges and access to good medical information. We are going to have to figure out how to survive the next 3 to 5 years, tops, for us to take over the field. There is no money out there to waste anymore and with more people, basically, paying out of pocket availability and quality are going to become paramount. The paternalistic, good Samaritan, view of trying to help needs to be changed to a service business approach that produces great care for the money. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sangeetha Murthy Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 1:05 PMTo: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... This email and getting more cynical reinforces my feeling that what we are trying to do is really a niche product ( Mac to the PC). There really is only a small market for it..and that will take years to change. The net doctors product the Kathleen found is yet another sign.The only way I see forward is to worksmart (not hard) within the system, decrease expenses, market ourselves to the discerning and count on obsolescence of an MD providing primary care- in the next decade... and evolve.. the question is HOW? join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of no-insurance.I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it as " I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that? " The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible. So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone else, it's business as they're used to. We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point to keep the hamster wheel from spinning.Best,Chad Costley -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D -- Graham Chiuhttp://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/ Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR. -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D Quote
Guest guest Posted February 23, 2010 Report Posted February 23, 2010 Patients have no idea on how to gauge quality. That we know.That's how quacks make a living.How do you measure your quality vs other practitioners? but what statistics truly resonates with patients? I know Hows your health is one, but is that something patients can understand and appreciate? I remember a study statistics not withstanding, a hospital with beautiful gardens is preferred over a better one with better statistics with no garden. So , we are really selling ourselves to the discerning customer arent we? Perhaps you need to collect and publish statistics on your performance. Are you a 5 star practice or a 3 star practice? That is a tough cookie to chew. I don’t think people appreciate health until it is lacking and then it is still tough. The advantages of quality care, at least in the present environment, are not tangible. First, most patient’s still think that more is better (more diagnostics test, more medications, more labs); second, great diabetes care means you avoided complications and that it is difficult to appreciate in foresight. If you are feeling well is very difficult, at least for a big chunk of our citizens, to rationalize what could have happen with bad care and third, the time to make a difference is huge for most problems. The only place where we make a direct point is on access: if patient can get their problem taken care of now and not wait or have to go to urgent care but for most of those problems the perception is that anyone can do it. Remember we are in a country were healthy people don’t want to contribute to the pie and expect to get “everything done” when they are sick. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sangeetha Murthy Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 3:55 PM To: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... In essence provide value for the same price..We return to the same issues. How do we convince our customers that we are better value? Cost efficiency by itself will not guarantee our survival. The big clinics will have the insurance and Medicare contracts in the future regardless of efficiency. We're too small and impotent to play that game. Our efficiency helps us by allowing us to offer much better service at a lower price than if we ran inefficient practices. Since the insurers and the government have promised far more care than they (or society) can afford, they'll be forced to continually cut costs and reduce service at the big clinics, growing a market niche for us. Thats another way of looking at it.But I don't see the big guys going away too easily..Here,large groups negotiate and do get 120% of medicare from the commercial insurers while us solos get 80 %... I must say, the patients who come to me are the small to minuscule proportion that don't want antibiotics on call, narcotics on demand..and I am under tremendous pressure -multiple phone calls, emails, back door pharmacy requests,- to stretch the intervals between visits from them ( which is the only way HMO products make any sense -For the few HMO patients I have I am providing 120 % of comparable medicare service- I discount it as advertisement) Health care provision is getting more fragmented by the day..and we need to be prepared.But i sure hope you are right . MD’s providing Primary Care are not going to disappear. I think the big traditional medical practices are going the way of the mainframe and us “PC’s” are going to take over. We are the most cost-efficient way of providing care, period. In my neck of the woods, which should be considered the worst environment with high presence of big hospitals, low income, high for profit insurance presence and high government subsidized insurance presence, the big guys are closing up the practices; they can’t compete. Their model of low quality PCP’s just to take care of cold’s and refers everything and anything can’t survive in this cut cost environment. 10 people moving paper around an office and making calls is not health care, period. Our model is the new wave, barebone, high tech, high quality, efficient and available for patient’s needs is the future. We only have been really able to work this way the past 2 years with the presence of good EMR’s, high bandwidth internet, e-prescribing, lab bridges and access to good medical information. We are going to have to figure out how to survive the next 3 to 5 years, tops, for us to take over the field. There is no money out there to waste anymore and with more people, basically, paying out of pocket availability and quality are going to become paramount. The paternalistic, good Samaritan, view of trying to help needs to be changed to a service business approach that produces great care for the money. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sangeetha Murthy Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 1:05 PMTo: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... This email and getting more cynical reinforces my feeling that what we are trying to do is really a niche product ( Mac to the PC). There really is only a small market for it..and that will take years to change. The net doctors product the Kathleen found is yet another sign.The only way I see forward is to worksmart (not hard) within the system, decrease expenses, market ourselves to the discerning and count on obsolescence of an MD providing primary care- in the next decade... and evolve.. the question is HOW? join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of no-insurance.I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it as " I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that? " The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible. So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone else, it's business as they're used to. We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point to keep the hamster wheel from spinning.Best,Chad Costley -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D -- Graham Chiuhttp://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/ Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR. -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D -- Graham Chiuhttp://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 24, 2010 Report Posted February 24, 2010 I'm not sure what measures and gauges hit the spot with patients. Most people respond to kindness but that can't be quantified. Most people respond negatively to pain-in-the neck hassles, ie if a service takes a lot of time running around, making phone calls, parking, waiting. There is way too much comfort with the ease of swiping an insurance card. No fuss, no muss. If the co-pays are smallish, the cost of the service is hidden. The amount taken out of salary for monthly insurance premiums We respond to wallet issues but it's complicated. If a large bill comes long after the service, maybe the appreciation of that service decreases.If something is very expensive, people may appreciate a commodity more. Great example is cosmetics. People will pay more if they think they are getting a better mascara or face cream. We pay for magic and hope. There is a large body of literature on that. I don't think that applies to services. Although many people will pay a lot more to fly first class. I think that's only partly to do with comfort. I think it has a lot to do with the perception of being treated better. Big Insurance, Big Pharma and Big Hospitals have spent fortunes on public relations, fortunes on focus groups to get the right euphemistic name on a product or slogan. And it's been working. Healthcare has been bought by pretty names that suggest hope and magic and the perception of better treatment. By contrast, we, the workers in healthcare that actually make that magic and better treatment happen, have spent squat time and money educating people on the value of good primary care. Not that I think throwing money at public relations campaigns would do much even if we did have the money. In the game of purchased public relations, we will lose. Most of us don't have that kind of money. If we pooled resources we might be able to add a tinny sounding voice to the din. How do we 'justify' our worth in healthcare? or perception of our worth?Kathleen Patients have no idea on how to gauge quality. That we know.That's how quacks make a living.How do you measure your quality vs other practitioners?On Wed, Feb 24, 2010 at 11:52 AM, Sangeetha Murthy <sangeethamurthygmail> wrote:but what statistics truly resonates with patients? I know Hows your health is one, but is that something patients can understand and appreciate? I remember a study statistics not withstanding, a hospital with beautiful gardens is preferred over a better one with better statistics with no garden. So , we are really selling ourselves to the discerning customer arent we?On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 2:12 PM, Graham Chiu <compkarorigmail> wrote: Perhaps you need to collect and publish statistics on your performance.Are you a 5 star practice or a 3 star practice?On Wed, Feb 24, 2010 at 11:05 AM, Batlle <jbatlleoptonline (DOT) net> wrote:That is a tough cookie to chew. I don’t think people appreciate health until it is lacking and then it is still tough. The advantages of quality care, at least in the present environment, are not tangible. First, most patient’s still think that more is better (more diagnostics test, more medications, more labs); second, great diabetes care means you avoided complications and that it is difficult to appreciate in foresight. If you are feeling well is very difficult, at least for a big chunk of our citizens, to rationalize what could have happen with bad care and third, the time to make a difference is huge for most problems. The only place where we make a direct point is on access: if patient can get their problem taken care of now and not wait or have to go to urgent care but for most of those problems the perception is that anyone can do it. Remember we are in a country were healthy people don’t want to contribute to the pie and expect to get “everything done” when they are sick. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sangeetha MurthySent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 3:55 PMTo: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... In essence provide value for the same price..We return to the same issues. How do we convince our customers that we are better value?On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 12:18 PM, Pierce <bpiercemidcoastmedicine> wrote: Cost efficiency by itself will not guarantee our survival. The big clinics will have the insurance and Medicare contracts in the future regardless of efficiency. We're too small and impotent to play that game.Our efficiency helps us by allowing us to offer much better service at a lower price than if we ran inefficient practices. Since the insurers and the government have promised far more care than they (or society) can afford, they'll be forced to continually cut costs and reduce service at the big clinics, growing a market niche for us. Thats another way of looking at it.But I don't see the big guys going away too easily..Here,large groups negotiate and do get 120% of medicare from the commercial insurers while us solos get 80 %...I must say, the patients who come to me are the small to minuscule proportion that don't want antibiotics on call, narcotics on demand..and I am under tremendous pressure -multiple phone calls, emails, back door pharmacy requests,- to stretch the intervals between visits from them ( which is the only way HMO products make any sense -For the few HMO patients I have I am providing 120 % of comparable medicare service- I discount it as advertisement)Health care provision is getting more fragmented by the day..and we need to be prepared.But i sure hope you are right .On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 10:21 AM, Batlle <jbatlleoptonline (DOT) net> wrote: MD’s providing Primary Care are not going to disappear. I think the big traditional medical practices are going the way of the mainframe and us “PC’s” are going to take over. We are the most cost-efficient way of providing care, period. In my neck of the woods, which should be considered the worst environment with high presence of big hospitals, low income, high for profit insurance presence and high government subsidized insurance presence, the big guys are closing up the practices; they can’t compete. Their model of low quality PCP’s just to take care of cold’s and refers everything and anything can’t survive in this cut cost environment. 10 people moving paper around an office and making calls is not health care, period. Our model is the new wave, barebone, high tech, high quality, efficient and available for patient’s needs is the future. We only have been really able to work this way the past 2 years with the presence of good EMR’s, high bandwidth internet, e-prescribing, lab bridges and access to good medical information. We are going to have to figure out how to survive the next 3 to 5 years, tops, for us to take over the field. There is no money out there to waste anymore and with more people, basically, paying out of pocket availability and quality are going to become paramount. The paternalistic, good Samaritan, view of trying to help needs to be changed to a service business approach that produces great care for the money. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sangeetha MurthySent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 1:05 PMTo: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... This email and getting more cynical reinforces my feeling that what we are trying to do is really a niche product ( Mac to the PC). There really is only a small market for it..and that will take years to change.The net doctors product the Kathleen found is yet another sign.The only way I see forward is to worksmart (not hard) within the system, decrease expenses, market ourselves to the discerning and count on obsolescence of an MD providing primary care- in the next decade... and evolve..the question is HOW?On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 6:17 AM, Chad <chadcostleymac> wrote: join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of no-insurance.I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it as "I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that?" The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible.So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone else, it's business as they're used to.We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point to keep the hamster wheel from spinning.Best,Chad Costley-- Sangeetha Murthy M.D-- Sangeetha Murthy M.D-- Sangeetha Murthy M.D-- Graham Chiuhttp://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR.-- Sangeetha Murthy M.D-- Graham Chiuhttp://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 24, 2010 Report Posted February 24, 2010 By comparing yourself to others who provide the same or similar service.http://www.ihi.org/IHI/Topics/OfficePractices/Access/ImprovementStories/Overhauling%20the%20Office%20Practices%20at%20CareSouth%20Carolina I'm not sure what measures and gauges hit the spot with patients. Most people respond to kindness but that can't be quantified. Most people respond negatively to pain-in-the neck hassles, ie if a service takes a lot of time running around, making phone calls, parking, waiting. There is way too much comfort with the ease of swiping an insurance card. No fuss, no muss. If the co-pays are smallish, the cost of the service is hidden. The amount taken out of salary for monthly insurance premiums We respond to wallet issues but it's complicated. If a large bill comes long after the service, maybe the appreciation of that service decreases.If something is very expensive, people may appreciate a commodity more. Great example is cosmetics. People will pay more if they think they are getting a better mascara or face cream. We pay for magic and hope. There is a large body of literature on that. I don't think that applies to services. Although many people will pay a lot more to fly first class. I think that's only partly to do with comfort. I think it has a lot to do with the perception of being treated better. Big Insurance, Big Pharma and Big Hospitals have spent fortunes on public relations, fortunes on focus groups to get the right euphemistic name on a product or slogan. And it's been working. Healthcare has been bought by pretty names that suggest hope and magic and the perception of better treatment. By contrast, we, the workers in healthcare that actually make that magic and better treatment happen, have spent squat time and money educating people on the value of good primary care. Not that I think throwing money at public relations campaigns would do much even if we did have the money. In the game of purchased public relations, we will lose. Most of us don't have that kind of money. If we pooled resources we might be able to add a tinny sounding voice to the din. How do we 'justify' our worth in healthcare? or perception of our worth?Kathleen Patients have no idea on how to gauge quality. That we know.That's how quacks make a living. How do you measure your quality vs other practitioners?On Wed, Feb 24, 2010 at 11:52 AM, Sangeetha Murthy wrote: but what statistics truly resonates with patients? I know Hows your health is one, but is that something patients can understand and appreciate? I remember a study statistics not withstanding, a hospital with beautiful gardens is preferred over a better one with better statistics with no garden. So , we are really selling ourselves to the discerning customer arent we? On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 2:12 PM, Graham Chiu wrote: Perhaps you need to collect and publish statistics on your performance. Are you a 5 star practice or a 3 star practice? On Wed, Feb 24, 2010 at 11:05 AM, Batlle wrote: That is a tough cookie to chew. I don’t think people appreciate health until it is lacking and then it is still tough. The advantages of quality care, at least in the present environment, are not tangible. First, most patient’s still think that more is better (more diagnostics test, more medications, more labs); second, great diabetes care means you avoided complications and that it is difficult to appreciate in foresight. If you are feeling well is very difficult, at least for a big chunk of our citizens, to rationalize what could have happen with bad care and third, the time to make a difference is huge for most problems. The only place where we make a direct point is on access: if patient can get their problem taken care of now and not wait or have to go to urgent care but for most of those problems the perception is that anyone can do it. Remember we are in a country were healthy people don’t want to contribute to the pie and expect to get “everything done” when they are sick. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sangeetha Murthy Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 3:55 PM To: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... In essence provide value for the same price..We return to the same issues. How do we convince our customers that we are better value? Cost efficiency by itself will not guarantee our survival. The big clinics will have the insurance and Medicare contracts in the future regardless of efficiency. We're too small and impotent to play that game. Our efficiency helps us by allowing us to offer much better service at a lower price than if we ran inefficient practices. Since the insurers and the government have promised far more care than they (or society) can afford, they'll be forced to continually cut costs and reduce service at the big clinics, growing a market niche for us. Thats another way of looking at it. But I don't see the big guys going away too easily..Here,large groups negotiate and do get 120% of medicare from the commercial insurers while us solos get 80 %... I must say, the patients who come to me are the small to minuscule proportion that don't want antibiotics on call, narcotics on demand..and I am under tremendous pressure -multiple phone calls, emails, back door pharmacy requests,- to stretch the intervals between visits from them ( which is the only way HMO products make any sense -For the few HMO patients I have I am providing 120 % of comparable medicare service- I discount it as advertisement) Health care provision is getting more fragmented by the day..and we need to be prepared.But i sure hope you are right . MD’s providing Primary Care are not going to disappear. I think the big traditional medical practices are going the way of the mainframe and us “PC’s” are going to take over. We are the most cost-efficient way of providing care, period. In my neck of the woods, which should be considered the worst environment with high presence of big hospitals, low income, high for profit insurance presence and high government subsidized insurance presence, the big guys are closing up the practices; they can’t compete. Their model of low quality PCP’s just to take care of cold’s and refers everything and anything can’t survive in this cut cost environment. 10 people moving paper around an office and making calls is not health care, period. Our model is the new wave, barebone, high tech, high quality, efficient and available for patient’s needs is the future. We only have been really able to work this way the past 2 years with the presence of good EMR’s, high bandwidth internet, e-prescribing, lab bridges and access to good medical information. We are going to have to figure out how to survive the next 3 to 5 years, tops, for us to take over the field. There is no money out there to waste anymore and with more people, basically, paying out of pocket availability and quality are going to become paramount. The paternalistic, good Samaritan, view of trying to help needs to be changed to a service business approach that produces great care for the money. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sangeetha Murthy Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 1:05 PMTo: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... This email and getting more cynical reinforces my feeling that what we are trying to do is really a niche product ( Mac to the PC). There really is only a small market for it..and that will take years to change. The net doctors product the Kathleen found is yet another sign.The only way I see forward is to worksmart (not hard) within the system, decrease expenses, market ourselves to the discerning and count on obsolescence of an MD providing primary care- in the next decade... and evolve.. the question is HOW? join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of no-insurance. I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it as " I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that? " The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible. So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone else, it's business as they're used to. We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point to keep the hamster wheel from spinning. Best,Chad Costley -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D -- Graham Chiuhttp://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/ Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR. -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D -- Graham Chiu http://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR. -- Graham Chiuhttp://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 24, 2010 Report Posted February 24, 2010 Chad, Sorry to hear your plan didn't work out. I think expectations of health care vary vastly by region (and by patient of course). I know my patients use more services when they first join and then it tapers off (I like to think it is because they are finally gaining some confidence and knowledge, as well as trust that they can get me when they need me, but who knows). I do agree for sure that we all need to keep working at changing this whole system and band together to prove the value of excellent primary care; these piecemeal solutions are just that. Keep us posted on how the transition goes. If you want to post, it would be interesting to hear how many patients joined over what period of time. Data such as number of visits per patient member month would be interesting also (although I know those numbers may be hard to come up with.....). Best in the transition, Sharon Sharon McCoy MDRenaissance Family Medicine10 McClintock Court; Irvine, CA 92617PH: (949)387-5504 Fax: (949)281-2197 Toll free phone/fax: www.SharonMD.com Quote
Guest guest Posted February 24, 2010 Report Posted February 24, 2010 ' Do you think small billing companies could help us compile our efforts? Carolyn Brumm Mc Cormick MD, FAAFP , There is hope. 2 of the biggest government sponsored insurers just took their Primary Care contracts away form 2 of the big local hospitals and sent all their patients the way of my IPA (95% PCP and totally controlled by PCP types). The insurers are giving us preferential contracts because we provide cheaper and better services than the Hospital based practices. This group of PCP’s is on a spectrum me on one side and more traditional type of practices on the other but as a group we are way cheaper than anything the Hospital clinics can provide because of less overhead and more access. Unless we believe that the market is going to continue throwing money away in keeping high overhead systems going, they are going the way of big cars from Detroit, it may take a while but eventually they are going to disappear. In my neck of the woods already 2 big Medicare Advantage plans are pulling out of the Medicare business, no big profits; the others are trying any way they can to get cheaper care; the hospital practices can’t provide this. The problem is that the insurers see isolated doc’s as little guys, the only way to get their attention is to form groups, that is where we fail ourselves. José from The Barrio Hating this rain more by the minute. From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Pierce Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 3:18 PM To: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... Cost efficiency by itself will not guarantee our survival. The big clinics will have the insurance and Medicare contracts in the future regardless of efficiency. We're too small and impotent to play that game. Our efficiency helps us by allowing us to offer much better service at a lower price than if we ran inefficient practices. Since the insurers and the government have promised far more care than they (or society) can afford, they'll be forced to continually cut costs and reduce service at the big clinics, growing a market niche for us. Thats another way of looking at it.But I don't see the big guys going away too easily..Here,large groups negotiate and do get 120% of medicare from the commercial insurers while us solos get 80 %... I must say, the patients who come to me are the small to minuscule proportion that don't want antibiotics on call, narcotics on demand..and I am under tremendous pressure -multiple phone calls, emails, back door pharmacy requests,- to stretch the intervals between visits from them ( which is the only way HMO products make any sense -For the few HMO patients I have I am providing 120 % of comparable medicare service- I discount it as advertisement) Health care provision is getting more fragmented by the day..and we need to be prepared.But i sure hope you are right . MD’s providing Primary Care are not going to disappear. I think the big traditional medical practices are going the way of the mainframe and us “PC’s” are going to take over. We are the most cost-efficient way of providing care, period. In my neck of the woods, which should be considered the worst environment with high presence of big hospitals, low income, high for profit insurance presence and high government subsidized insurance presence, the big guys are closing up the practices; they can’t compete. Their model of low quality PCP’s just to take care of cold’s and refers everything and anything can’t survive in this cut cost environment. 10 people moving paper around an office and making calls is not health care, period. Our model is the new wave, barebone, high tech, high quality, efficient and available for patient’s needs is the future. We only have been really able to work this way the past 2 years with the presence of good EMR’s, high bandwidth internet, e-prescribing, lab bridges and access to good medical information. We are going to have to figure out how to survive the next 3 to 5 years, tops, for us to take over the field. There is no money out there to waste anymore and with more people, basically, paying out of pocket availability and quality are going to become paramount. The paternalistic, good Samaritan, view of trying to help needs to be changed to a service business approach that produces great care for the money. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sangeetha Murthy Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 1:05 PMTo: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... This email and getting more cynical reinforces my feeling that what we are trying to do is really a niche product ( Mac to the PC). There really is only a small market for it..and that will take years to change. The net doctors product the Kathleen found is yet another sign.The only way I see forward is to worksmart (not hard) within the system, decrease expenses, market ourselves to the discerning and count on obsolescence of an MD providing primary care- in the next decade... and evolve.. the question is HOW? join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of no-insurance.I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it as " I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that? " The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible. So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone else, it's business as they're used to. We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point to keep the hamster wheel from spinning.Best,Chad Costley -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D Quote
Guest guest Posted February 24, 2010 Report Posted February 24, 2010 Aack! Don't let the billing companies be the glue that hold us together -that's how we get sold down the river by business types.What patients want and need is what we have to offer:AccessRelationship over timeComprehensive servicesCare coordinationThose are the attributes of primary care. When delivered in an exemplary fashion the outcomes are terrific and the patients are delighted. Ask Pamela Wible what she found out when she ran community meetings "What do you want?"Answer: "access, relationship, respect, dignity, time..."As Wasson from his 100K+ Patient studies:"Access, no wasted time, good communication, help me feel better, help me understand, help me gain confidence."The themes are basic and we have the goods. When we band together let it be based on agreeing to deliver exemplary primary care. Let it be based on who we are as professionals and what we can do when given the funding to do it right.There are small spots of brilliance on the map of the US. I came from a wonderful meeting of docs in NYC (including Soma, Sofia, Moitri, , - hi guys!). We're ready to create a local group working together on quality and taking that quality message to small self-funded employers desperate to get their employees into practices like ours.We're going to meet again, expand the group, work with others, and we plan to change the game here and in other parts of the country as we gain critical mass in local markets. I'll let you all know how this is going as we proceed.Gordon ' Do you think small billing companies could help us compile our efforts? Carolyn Brumm Mc Cormick MD, FAAFP On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 4:42 PM, Batlle <jbatlleoptonline (DOT) net> wrote: , There is hope. 2 of the biggest government sponsored insurers just took their Primary Care contracts away form 2 of the big local hospitals and sent all their patients the way of my IPA (95% PCP and totally controlled by PCP types). The insurers are giving us preferential contracts because we provide cheaper and better services than the Hospital based practices. This group of PCP’s is on a spectrum me on one side and more traditional type of practices on the other but as a group we are way cheaper than anything the Hospital clinics can provide because of less overhead and more access. Unless we believe that the market is going to continue throwing money away in keeping high overhead systems going, they are going the way of big cars from Detroit, it may take a while but eventually they are going to disappear. In my neck of the woods already 2 big Medicare Advantage plans are pulling out of the Medicare business, no big profits; the others are trying any way they can to get cheaper care; the hospital practices can’t provide this. The problem is that the insurers see isolated doc’s as little guys, the only way to get their attention is to form groups, that is where we fail ourselves. José from The BarrioHating this rain more by the minute. From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Pierce Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 3:18 PM To: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... Cost efficiency by itself will not guarantee our survival. The big clinics will have the insurance and Medicare contracts in the future regardless of efficiency. We're too small and impotent to play that game. Our efficiency helps us by allowing us to offer much better service at a lower price than if we ran inefficient practices. Since the insurers and the government have promised far more care than they (or society) can afford, they'll be forced to continually cut costs and reduce service at the big clinics, growing a market niche for us. Thats another way of looking at it.But I don't see the big guys going away too easily..Here,large groups negotiate and do get 120% of medicare from the commercial insurers while us solos get 80 %... I must say, the patients who come to me are the small to minuscule proportion that don't want antibiotics on call, narcotics on demand..and I am under tremendous pressure -multiple phone calls, emails, back door pharmacy requests,- to stretch the intervals between visits from them ( which is the only way HMO products make any sense -For the few HMO patients I have I am providing 120 % of comparable medicare service- I discount it as advertisement) Health care provision is getting more fragmented by the day..and we need to be prepared.But i sure hope you are right . On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 10:21 AM, Batlle <jbatlleoptonline (DOT) net> wrote: MD’s providing Primary Care are not going to disappear. I think the big traditional medical practices are going the way of the mainframe and us “PC’s” are going to take over. We are the most cost-efficient way of providing care, period. In my neck of the woods, which should be considered the worst environment with high presence of big hospitals, low income, high for profit insurance presence and high government subsidized insurance presence, the big guys are closing up the practices; they can’t compete. Their model of low quality PCP’s just to take care of cold’s and refers everything and anything can’t survive in this cut cost environment. 10 people moving paper around an office and making calls is not health care, period. Our model is the new wave, barebone, high tech, high quality, efficient and available for patient’s needs is the future. We only have been really able to work this way the past 2 years with the presence of good EMR’s, high bandwidth internet, e-prescribing, lab bridges and access to good medical information. We are going to have to figure out how to survive the next 3 to 5 years, tops, for us to take over the field. There is no money out there to waste anymore and with more people, basically, paying out of pocket availability and quality are going to become paramount. The paternalistic, good Samaritan, view of trying to help needs to be changed to a service business approach that produces great care for the money. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sangeetha Murthy Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 1:05 PMTo: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... This email and getting more cynical reinforces my feeling that what we are trying to do is really a niche product ( Mac to the PC). There really is only a small market for it..and that will take years to change. The net doctors product the Kathleen found is yet another sign.The only way I see forward is to worksmart (not hard) within the system, decrease expenses, market ourselves to the discerning and count on obsolescence of an MD providing primary care- in the next decade... and evolve.. the question is HOW? On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 6:17 AM, Chad <chadcostleymac> wrote: join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of no-insurance.I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it as "I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that?" The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible. So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone else, it's business as they're used to. We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point to keep the hamster wheel from spinning.Best,Chad Costley -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D-- Sangeetha Murthy M.D Quote
Guest guest Posted February 24, 2010 Report Posted February 24, 2010 Sharon and others, It's not really that the plan didn't work out - the model can absolutely work. The tricky part is the decision whether to see non-member patients at all. My patients are a dichotomy. On the one hand, I'm in an area with a large number of relatively young, healthy and transient patients. They want to come see me when they sprain their ankle or have a cough. The notion of even $60 per month when they might need a doctor twice per year wouldn't and probably shouldn't appeal to them. So - I started charging $120 for initial visits and $80 for follow-up visits if patients weren't members. Problem with that is if the patient has insurance, they're uncomfortable at the $80 level vs. their standard $20 co-pay. Because I practice comprehensive care, I'd often end up spending 30 minutes or more with them talking about alcohol, risky sex, etc. - all the real health risks facing young people that rarely get addressed as they use urgent cares for their runny noses. So...they pay $80 rather than $20 and I collect $80 for a 99214 for which the insurers would pay significantly more than that. Who loses financially? My patient and me. Who wins - the big insurance company that collects premiums but doesn't pay for the care I provide. If the patient is paying the monthly fee, none of this matters as I'm fairly compensated either way, but once I decided to see non-members - the writing was on the wall for accepting insurance. On the other hand, there's the overusers - probably only 10% of the members but enough of them to drive you nuts. I agree someone's post about visit fees for members ($20 in my case did limit the physical visits). Putting a wall up on phone calls and electronic communications is harder. My practice sits on a busy street in a walking neighborhood - I literally have patients who open the front door to say hello or drop an article they read in the New Yorker on my desk. Charming in a strange way...but you can't run a practice that turns into a public meeting house for your members. Just to clarify - I'm not turning off my membership approach. Patients can still choose to be members of the practice if they want benefits that aren't paid for by their insurance (e.g. after hour visits, house calls, virtual visits...). Also, 30% of my Member patients don't have insurance at all so nothing will change for those folks. Other answers to posts: - yes, I'm opted out of Medicare and have no intention of rejoining. Medicare patients have to sign a private contract and receive care on a cash-per-visit or membership basis. I'll get some grief on this, but my position is clear. " If you're not happy with Medicare's ability to attract quality doctors to it's program, talk to your Congressman about fixing the ponzi-scheme that is the program. " Of course I wouldn't say this - but it's fun to type. - interesting concerns on United. Billed my first United patient today. $70 for a 99213 adjudicated in real-time on-line with confirmation of payment via the best direct billing website I've seen of the four insurance companies with whom I'm contracted. Will keep my radar up for other given the comments. - As far as metrics, my goal was to add 10 new Member patients per month. During the months that I aggressively worked to meet that goal, we made it most of the time (peak was 15 in October.) I backed off the past two months as I realized I didn't like the model as much as I anticipated. I didn't track all the emails, phone calls, random drop-ins for a non-medical chat, etc. but they were excessive in too many cases. Access is critical - but good fences also make good neighbors. Sorry for the long post but it justified given the interest. I'm excited going forward. I've crunched the numbers given my expenses and expect to not kill myself and make a decent living. Perhaps I'm just in a good area because the reimbursement rates in my easy to get contracts just aren't as bad as what many of you are unfortunately describing. Cheers, Chad > > Chad, > > Sorry to hear your plan didn't work out. I think expectations of health > care vary vastly by region (and by patient of course). I know my patients > use more services when they first join and then it tapers off (I like to > think it is because they are finally gaining some confidence and knowledge, > as well as trust that they can get me when they need me, but who knows). > > I do agree for sure that we all need to keep working at changing this whole > system and band together to prove the value of excellent primary care; these > piecemeal solutions are just that. Keep us posted on how the transition > goes. > > If you want to post, it would be interesting to hear how many patients > joined over what period of time. Data such as number of visits per patient > member month would be interesting also (although I know those numbers may be > hard to come up with.....). > > Best in the transition, > Sharon > > Sharon McCoy MD > Renaissance Family Medicine > 10 McClintock Court; Irvine, CA 92617 > PH: (949)387-5504 Fax: (949)281-2197 Toll free phone/fax: > www.SharonMD.com > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 24, 2010 Report Posted February 24, 2010 Gordon,I was hoping you would jump in here with the IMP haiku of attributes.(well not quite haiku)KathleenAack! Don't let the billing companies be the glue that hold us together -that's how we get sold down the river by business types.What patients want and need is what we have to offer:AccessRelationship over timeComprehensive servicesCare coordinationThose are the attributes of primary care. When delivered in an exemplary fashion the outcomes are terrific and the patients are delighted. Ask Pamela Wible what she found out when she ran community meetings "What do you want?"Answer: "access, relationship, respect, dignity, time..."As Wasson from his 100K+ Patient studies:"Access, no wasted time, good communication, help me feel better, help me understand, help me gain confidence."The themes are basic and we have the goods. When we band together let it be based on agreeing to deliver exemplary primary care. Let it be based on who we are as professionals and what we can do when given the funding to do it right.There are small spots of brilliance on the map of the US. I came from a wonderful meeting of docs in NYC (including Soma, Sofia, Moitri, , - hi guys!). We're ready to create a local group working together on quality and taking that quality message to small self-funded employers desperate to get their employees into practices like ours.We're going to meet again, expand the group, work with others, and we plan to change the game here and in other parts of the country as we gain critical mass in local markets. I'll let you all know how this is going as we proceed.Gordon ' Do you think small billing companies could help us compile our efforts?Carolyn Brumm Mc Cormick MD, FAAFP On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 4:42 PM, Batlle <jbatlleoptonline (DOT) net> wrote: , There is hope. 2 of the biggest government sponsored insurers just took their Primary Care contracts away form 2 of the big local hospitals and sent all their patients the way of my IPA (95% PCP and totally controlled by PCP types). The insurers are giving us preferential contracts because we provide cheaper and better services than the Hospital based practices. This group of PCP’s is on a spectrum me on one side and more traditional type of practices on the other but as a group we are way cheaper than anything the Hospital clinics can provide because of less overhead and more access. Unless we believe that the market is going to continue throwing money away in keeping high overhead systems going, they are going the way of big cars from Detroit, it may take a while but eventually they are going to disappear. In my neck of the woods already 2 big Medicare Advantage plans are pulling out of the Medicare business, no big profits; the others are trying any way they can to get cheaper care; the hospital practices can’t provide this. The problem is that the insurers see isolated doc’s as little guys, the only way to get their attention is to form groups, that is where we fail ourselves. José from The BarrioHating this rain more by the minute. From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of PierceSent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 3:18 PMTo: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... Cost efficiency by itself will not guarantee our survival. The big clinics will have the insurance and Medicare contracts in the future regardless of efficiency. We're too small and impotent to play that game.Our efficiency helps us by allowing us to offer much better service at a lower price than if we ran inefficient practices. Since the insurers and the government have promised far more care than they (or society) can afford, they'll be forced to continually cut costs and reduce service at the big clinics, growing a market niche for us. Thats another way of looking at it.But I don't see the big guys going away too easily..Here,large groups negotiate and do get 120% of medicare from the commercial insurers while us solos get 80 %...I must say, the patients who come to me are the small to minuscule proportion that don't want antibiotics on call, narcotics on demand..and I am under tremendous pressure -multiple phone calls, emails, back door pharmacy requests,- to stretch the intervals between visits from them ( which is the only way HMO products make any sense -For the few HMO patients I have I am providing 120 % of comparable medicare service- I discount it as advertisement)Health care provision is getting more fragmented by the day..and we need to be prepared.But i sure hope you are right .On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 10:21 AM, Batlle <jbatlleoptonline (DOT) net> wrote: MD’s providing Primary Care are not going to disappear. I think the big traditional medical practices are going the way of the mainframe and us “PC’s” are going to take over. We are the most cost-efficient way of providing care, period. In my neck of the woods, which should be considered the worst environment with high presence of big hospitals, low income, high for profit insurance presence and high government subsidized insurance presence, the big guys are closing up the practices; they can’t compete. Their model of low quality PCP’s just to take care of cold’s and refers everything and anything can’t survive in this cut cost environment. 10 people moving paper around an office and making calls is not health care, period. Our model is the new wave, barebone, high tech, high quality, efficient and available for patient’s needs is the future. We only have been really able to work this way the past 2 years with the presence of good EMR’s, high bandwidth internet, e-prescribing, lab bridges and access to good medical information. We are going to have to figure out how to survive the next 3 to 5 years, tops, for us to take over the field. There is no money out there to waste anymore and with more people, basically, paying out of pocket availability and quality are going to become paramount. The paternalistic, good Samaritan, view of trying to help needs to be changed to a service business approach that produces great care for the money. José from The Barrio From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sangeetha MurthySent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 1:05 PMTo: Subject: Re: If you can't beat them... This email and getting more cynical reinforces my feeling that what we are trying to do is really a niche product ( Mac to the PC). There really is only a small market for it..and that will take years to change.The net doctors product the Kathleen found is yet another sign.The only way I see forward is to worksmart (not hard) within the system, decrease expenses, market ourselves to the discerning and count on obsolescence of an MD providing primary care- in the next decade... and evolve..the question is HOW?On Tue, Feb 23, 2010 at 6:17 AM, Chad <chadcostleymac> wrote: join them - cliche time at my practice. Update from the world of no-insurance.I've made the decision to start accepting insurance. Biggest reason is that I was surprised to discover that I didn't really like retainer-based medicine. The recurring revenue is great, but too many patients saw $60 a month as a real stretch. Once they'd stretched - they wanted to use the heck out of their investment. The model isn't scalable at that price point if patients think they should utilize 3-4 emails, a couple of phone calls, and a visit per month to justify the expense. We've trained our society to think transactionally about health care. Many of my patients understood that the membership fee allowed the practice to slow down, be accessible, unrushed, comprehensive, etc., but too many people don't get that. They saw it as "I've paid $60 - how much of my doctor time can I get for that?" The retraining process is exhausting if not impossible.So...I'm going to offer a high level membership for those who really value direct phone access, phone consultations, virtual visits, email access, etc. The price is going up for this offering and I picture only 10% of the practice being in this group long-term. For everyone else, it's business as they're used to.We've contracted with 4 insurers (BCBS, United, Cigna, and Aetna) at the list may stay that short. So it's about cost control at this point to keep the hamster wheel from spinning.Best,Chad Costley-- Sangeetha Murthy M.D-- Sangeetha Murthy M.D Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.