Guest guest Posted March 24, 2010 Report Posted March 24, 2010 Hi - In reading your message, I couldn't quite tell what you're doing with the used pumps you purchase besides trying them out on yourself. If you are passing them along after cleaning, I'd worry that you put yourself at considerable risk since the manufacturer clearly states this is not safe. All you need is a claim that a used pump caused some condition (thrush, MRSA, low supply, . . .) and then negligence could be assumed. Or perhaps I'm misinterpreting and you're trying out two of each pump only on yourself? Ellen > > > > > > What is so interesting to me is we all really are not sharing consistent experiences with our client feedback regarding the pumps. And our professional experience with the pumps is apparently very varied as well! > > > > The feedback I get from my clients is overwhelmingly in support of the Symphony, and the PIS. On occasion I get feedback from a mother who has used both the Symphony and the Lactina that she prefers the Lactina, and I tell her this is not always an exact science and I want you to do what works best for you! > > > > But we are not going to carry the Lactina for much longer, all of our rental and in hospital pumps are being converted to Symphony. > > > > There are clear variations between the models listed in the specs. The cycle frequency of the Symphony is almost twice that of the Lactina at its maximum, the suction strength max for both is identical from what I can tell. > > > > It's difficult to know what will work best for every mother and probably impractical to expect places to carry both so she can figure it out. There will be variations in efficacy amongst users of different models, but in my experience I would say the feedback I get from mothers is overwhelmingly in favor of the Symphony and PIS. I wonder how we can all have this variety of feedback? > > > > And I'm still with Jaye on the whole thing and am peeved at Medela's lack of integrity! > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 26, 2010 Report Posted March 26, 2010 Hi and ! I don't re-sell the pump in styles to my clients. But I have bought some second-hand to try them out as this is much cheaper than buying them new. The motor itself does not need to be sterilized. Just the pump membrane section of the motor, which is fully capable of being sterilized in reality. I could take a picture of it for you if you like, or if you have access to a pump in style you can take a look. Just pop off the display part of the pump and you will see that it is very easy to get in there and clean it up. Remember, I have just bought a Hygiea Enjoye and Ameda elite for my rental pumps so those are going out to rent, but I also want to be able to give moms who ask about other pumps accurate first hand info regarding other personal pumps rather than just telling them " I don't know, but I've got 2 choices I can rent out to you " . I feel like this offers them more information, which is my job as a Consultant after all. Also I do admit that I have a personal bias. I find it very hard to believe that there are some of us who don't have a personal bias', but I congratulate those who claim to have none. My personal bias: I never liked breast pumps. In my own breastfeeding experience I preferred manually hand expressing. The pumps I tried, I hated. I'm now trying to open my mind some years later and I'm going to try all the pumps I can just so that I do have that first-hand experience to offer moms. I have seen some patients that I might even say are experiencing breastfeeding issues that were caused by using a pump (not improper use, just plain use). I am trying to reconsider all my beliefs about pumps right now while I try all the different ones out there and even offer them as a rental service to mother's who might benefit from pumping to increase their milk supply or for other reasons. I still don't quite buy the idea that pumping is completely normal and for most moms to try. I still think that it is something that should be used carefully and only when necessary. I still think it's important to inform moms that " go back to work " that their breastfeeding experience may be affected by that decision and that pumping is not a perfect substitute, yet I am opening to the fact that the world we live in is what it is and some women will choose to leave their new babies with someone else and still want to breastfeed partially. I am the first to admit that I have a bias, but I am trying to unbias myself. R. > > > > > > > > > What is so interesting to me is we all really are not sharing consistent experiences with our client feedback regarding the pumps. And our professional experience with the pumps is apparently very varied as well! > > > > > > The feedback I get from my clients is overwhelmingly in support of the Symphony, and the PIS. On occasion I get feedback from a mother who has used both the Symphony and the Lactina that she prefers the Lactina, and I tell her this is not always an exact science and I want you to do what works best for you! > > > > > > But we are not going to carry the Lactina for much longer, all of our rental and in hospital pumps are being converted to Symphony. > > > > > > There are clear variations between the models listed in the specs. The cycle frequency of the Symphony is almost twice that of the Lactina at its maximum, the suction strength max for both is identical from what I can tell. > > > > > > It's difficult to know what will work best for every mother and probably impractical to expect places to carry both so she can figure it out. There will be variations in efficacy amongst users of different models, but in my experience I would say the feedback I get from mothers is overwhelmingly in favor of the Symphony and PIS. I wonder how we can all have this variety of feedback? > > > > > > And I'm still with Jaye on the whole thing and am peeved at Medela's lack of integrity! > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 26, 2010 Report Posted March 26, 2010 I do have pumps I may recommend as demonstrated more/most effective but what I meant by denying 'personal bias' is I don't have any bias related to a specific pump based on my own personal experience because as a breastfeeding mother I never used a pump! Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.