Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: State testing matches E. coli bacteria from Gibbon farm with tho

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Guest guest
Posted

No grain ever can be done, even in MN and WI. I have not fed ANY grain, corn

silage, or other grain byproducts for over 10 years, and no corn for around 12

years. I hear the argument all the time that it can't be done, it's too cold in

winter, etc.. It's true we can't pasture dairy animals in the 'arctic' of WI and

MN, but we can still feed them forage only, which keeps us in the strictly

grass/forage category. I use kelp and sea salt as a mineral source, and I do

micro fertility on my land to grow nutrient dense forage. Farmers have to stay

away from garbage like urea that grows lots of " empty " grass with no nutrition

in it.

It does take good management to take away the grain crutch, and many are

afraid to venture into new territory, but I communicate with farmers around the

country that have cut out the grain.I talked to a guy in VA a couple years ago

that was down to 1 pound of grain a day, but he was just scared to take it

away.I do discourage going cold turkey off grain unless they have been working

towards it for a while.

It is the future, so I like to help farmers any way I can to help them figure

out ways to cut out the grain. Here is a link of pictures from my farm for

anyone that wants visual evidence. I keep my cows in good condition year around.

It has been a lot harder with the extreme drought the last several years, but

it's still working fine.

http://www.files.vaes.vt.edu/SPAREC/Cheyenne_Christianson-Handout.pdf

Cheyenne

>

> I think what Diane was saying was that in the winter months the animals can

> not be pastured. I think there is word confusion. Yes, animals can be

> grass fed through the winter, but in MN bitter cold, I doubt they can be

> pastured safely and they certainly do not have access to green grass, which

> I believe is part of the definition of being pastured.

>

>

>

> I think a lot of farmers believe you can not safely not supplement your

> animals with vitamins and minerals in the winter months, which must be mixed

> with grains. But I think the various large animal vets on the board would

> be better to comment than me.

>

>

>

> Carol

>

>

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

a, factory milk (loaded with pesticides, herbicides, antibiotics, synthetic

hormones and inflammatory omega-6s, as well as phytoestrogens from soy fed

animals) , and even pasteurized milk will 100% of the time be exhibiting a toxic

load on your system. How long your system can withstand that will depend on a

lot of different factors, but make no mistake, that milk is not " good " for you

or life giving, it is slowly and ever so surely reducing your longevity and

likely manifesting itself with some sort of symptom or set of symptoms. That is

my opinion, and I believe it to be fact, but good luck finding 'evidence' you'd

consider satisfactory to support my claim. This is because who funds studies?

People and groups with money and power, who desire that those studies produce a

certain outcome. There are not m(any) raw milk groups with that kind of money or

power, if there were they could produce their own biased studies which would

easily support their view, even if that bias is immoral.

Most studies are undertaken from the outset to prove something. And expensive

lab equipment and personnel have to be paid for by someone or some group.

Guest guest
Posted

a, factory milk (loaded with pesticides, herbicides, antibiotics, synthetic

hormones and inflammatory omega-6s, as well as phytoestrogens from soy fed

animals) , and even pasteurized milk will 100% of the time be exhibiting a toxic

load on your system. How long your system can withstand that will depend on a

lot of different factors, but make no mistake, that milk is not " good " for you

or life giving, it is slowly and ever so surely reducing your longevity and

likely manifesting itself with some sort of symptom or set of symptoms. That is

my opinion, and I believe it to be fact, but good luck finding 'evidence' you'd

consider satisfactory to support my claim. This is because who funds studies?

People and groups with money and power, who desire that those studies produce a

certain outcome. There are not m(any) raw milk groups with that kind of money or

power, if there were they could produce their own biased studies which would

easily support their view, even if that bias is immoral.

Most studies are undertaken from the outset to prove something. And expensive

lab equipment and personnel have to be paid for by someone or some group.

Guest guest
Posted

a, factory milk (loaded with pesticides, herbicides, antibiotics, synthetic

hormones and inflammatory omega-6s, as well as phytoestrogens from soy fed

animals) , and even pasteurized milk will 100% of the time be exhibiting a toxic

load on your system. How long your system can withstand that will depend on a

lot of different factors, but make no mistake, that milk is not " good " for you

or life giving, it is slowly and ever so surely reducing your longevity and

likely manifesting itself with some sort of symptom or set of symptoms. That is

my opinion, and I believe it to be fact, but good luck finding 'evidence' you'd

consider satisfactory to support my claim. This is because who funds studies?

People and groups with money and power, who desire that those studies produce a

certain outcome. There are not m(any) raw milk groups with that kind of money or

power, if there were they could produce their own biased studies which would

easily support their view, even if that bias is immoral.

Most studies are undertaken from the outset to prove something. And expensive

lab equipment and personnel have to be paid for by someone or some group.

Guest guest
Posted

I do understand that studies are always done by those with money and power,

hence my favorite statistic that '75% of statistics are made up,' and a rule

to always check the source. Don't even get me started on health care

statistics (statistics/health care junkie here). However calling all

pasteurized milk toxic is a little far fetched to me. It may not be

helping, but it doesn't mean it's toxic. And " toxic " is not the kind of

language that's going to make a lot of people rally to the raw milk cause.

It's too confrontational for mass America if you are actually trying to make

a change. I also will never believe anything that is 100% of the time. If

someone gives me a stat as 100%, I give a major side eye to the stat and the

giver of the statistic. The only thing I know of that is a 100% factor is

that we all die sometime, sooner or later, but certainly we do not all die

from drinking the Kemps. I'm not saying raw milk is bad. I'm not saying the

$1.80 at costco is awesome. I'm saying step back and make sure the

statistics we are throwing out are real or at least have some possibility of

being real, or you are going to end up alienating more people than you

attract.

a

> a, factory milk (loaded with pesticides, herbicides, antibiotics,

> synthetic hormones and inflammatory omega-6s, as well as phytoestrogens from

> soy fed animals) , and even pasteurized milk will 100% of the time be

> exhibiting a toxic load on your system. How long your system can withstand

> that will depend on a lot of different factors, but make no mistake, that

> milk is not " good " for you or life giving, it is slowly and ever so surely

> reducing your longevity and likely manifesting itself with some sort of

> symptom or set of symptoms. That is my opinion, and I believe it to be fact,

> but good luck finding 'evidence' you'd consider satisfactory to support my

> claim. This is because who funds studies? People and groups with money and

> power, who desire that those studies produce a certain outcome. There are

> not m(any) raw milk groups with that kind of money or power, if there were

> they could produce their own biased studies which would easily support their

> view, even if that bias is immoral.

>

> Most studies are undertaken from the outset to prove something. And

> expensive lab equipment and personnel have to be paid for by someone or some

> group.

>

>

>

> ------------------------------------

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

a,

The statistic is my own personal opinion and I believe it whole heartedly based

on what I know about pasturized milk, and I believe that it slowly causes

serious disease processes in the body. I never intended for it to seem like I

was stating a scientifically proven statistic. You disagree with it. Of course

you are welcome to have your own beliefs and make your own decisions. Again, my

sole point was not to argue the toxicity of pasturized milk, (that has been done

many times and you are choosing to ignore or disregard that) but to make a very

strong point that we should all be allowed to choose for ourselves, ESPECIALLY

since we all have differing opinions. I can not stress that enough. It frankly

frightened me that you made the statement about thank God we are not being

permitted to buy raw milk now, or something to that effect. I am hoping you are

not arguing we should not have freedom of choice, even though your statements

have seemed to say that to me. can you agree with that we each should be

permitted to make our own food choices and decisions? Or do you really believe

that those of us who disagree with you should be prohibited and have our

freedoms removed because of our beliefs and choices?

Carol

>

> I do understand that studies are always done by those with money and power,

> hence my favorite statistic that '75% of statistics are made up,' and a rule

> to always check the source. Don't even get me started on health care

> statistics (statistics/health care junkie here). However calling all

> pasteurized milk toxic is a little far fetched to me. It may not be

> helping, but it doesn't mean it's toxic. And " toxic " is not the kind of

> language that's going to make a lot of people rally to the raw milk cause.

> It's too confrontational for mass America if you are actually trying to make

> a change. I also will never believe anything that is 100% of the time. If

> someone gives me a stat as 100%, I give a major side eye to the stat and the

> giver of the statistic. The only thing I know of that is a 100% factor is

> that we all die sometime, sooner or later, but certainly we do not all die

> from drinking the Kemps. I'm not saying raw milk is bad. I'm not saying the

> $1.80 at costco is awesome. I'm saying step back and make sure the

> statistics we are throwing out are real or at least have some possibility of

> being real, or you are going to end up alienating more people than you

> attract.

>

> a

Guest guest
Posted

I never said ban raw milk, did I? I said don't make up statistics, it

discredits your cause, and it's misleading. Your opinions do not equal

statistics.

Glad I could frighten you. ;) You kinda frightened me by accusing Tipper of

working for the CSA. Same grass. different side.

I'm out though. The blinders of the only people talking in this group are

unreal.

> a,

>

> The statistic is my own personal opinion and I believe it whole heartedly

> based on what I know about pasturized milk, and I believe that it slowly

> causes serious disease processes in the body. I never intended for it to

> seem like I was stating a scientifically proven statistic. You disagree

> with it. Of course you are welcome to have your own beliefs and make your

> own decisions. Again, my sole point was not to argue the toxicity of

> pasturized milk, (that has been done many times and you are choosing to

> ignore or disregard that) but to make a very strong point that we should all

> be allowed to choose for ourselves, ESPECIALLY since we all have differing

> opinions. I can not stress that enough. It frankly frightened me that you

> made the statement about thank God we are not being permitted to buy raw

> milk now, or something to that effect. I am hoping you are not arguing we

> should not have freedom of choice, even though your statements have seemed

> to say that to me. can you agree with that we each should be permitted to

> make our own food choices and decisions? Or do you really believe that

> those of us who disagree with you should be prohibited and have our freedoms

> removed because of our beliefs and choices?

>

> Carol

>

>

> >

> > I do understand that studies are always done by those with money and

> power,

> > hence my favorite statistic that '75% of statistics are made up,' and a

> rule

> > to always check the source. Don't even get me started on health care

> > statistics (statistics/health care junkie here). However calling all

> > pasteurized milk toxic is a little far fetched to me. It may not be

> > helping, but it doesn't mean it's toxic. And " toxic " is not the kind of

> > language that's going to make a lot of people rally to the raw milk

> cause.

> > It's too confrontational for mass America if you are actually trying to

> make

> > a change. I also will never believe anything that is 100% of the time.

> If

> > someone gives me a stat as 100%, I give a major side eye to the stat and

> the

> > giver of the statistic. The only thing I know of that is a 100% factor

> is

> > that we all die sometime, sooner or later, but certainly we do not all

> die

> > from drinking the Kemps. I'm not saying raw milk is bad. I'm not saying

> the

> > $1.80 at costco is awesome. I'm saying step back and make sure the

> > statistics we are throwing out are real or at least have some possibility

> of

> > being real, or you are going to end up alienating more people than you

> > attract.

> >

> > a

>

>

>

>

> ------------------------------------

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

I never said ban raw milk, did I? I said don't make up statistics, it

discredits your cause, and it's misleading. Your opinions do not equal

statistics.

Glad I could frighten you. ;) You kinda frightened me by accusing Tipper of

working for the CSA. Same grass. different side.

I'm out though. The blinders of the only people talking in this group are

unreal.

> a,

>

> The statistic is my own personal opinion and I believe it whole heartedly

> based on what I know about pasturized milk, and I believe that it slowly

> causes serious disease processes in the body. I never intended for it to

> seem like I was stating a scientifically proven statistic. You disagree

> with it. Of course you are welcome to have your own beliefs and make your

> own decisions. Again, my sole point was not to argue the toxicity of

> pasturized milk, (that has been done many times and you are choosing to

> ignore or disregard that) but to make a very strong point that we should all

> be allowed to choose for ourselves, ESPECIALLY since we all have differing

> opinions. I can not stress that enough. It frankly frightened me that you

> made the statement about thank God we are not being permitted to buy raw

> milk now, or something to that effect. I am hoping you are not arguing we

> should not have freedom of choice, even though your statements have seemed

> to say that to me. can you agree with that we each should be permitted to

> make our own food choices and decisions? Or do you really believe that

> those of us who disagree with you should be prohibited and have our freedoms

> removed because of our beliefs and choices?

>

> Carol

>

>

> >

> > I do understand that studies are always done by those with money and

> power,

> > hence my favorite statistic that '75% of statistics are made up,' and a

> rule

> > to always check the source. Don't even get me started on health care

> > statistics (statistics/health care junkie here). However calling all

> > pasteurized milk toxic is a little far fetched to me. It may not be

> > helping, but it doesn't mean it's toxic. And " toxic " is not the kind of

> > language that's going to make a lot of people rally to the raw milk

> cause.

> > It's too confrontational for mass America if you are actually trying to

> make

> > a change. I also will never believe anything that is 100% of the time.

> If

> > someone gives me a stat as 100%, I give a major side eye to the stat and

> the

> > giver of the statistic. The only thing I know of that is a 100% factor

> is

> > that we all die sometime, sooner or later, but certainly we do not all

> die

> > from drinking the Kemps. I'm not saying raw milk is bad. I'm not saying

> the

> > $1.80 at costco is awesome. I'm saying step back and make sure the

> > statistics we are throwing out are real or at least have some possibility

> of

> > being real, or you are going to end up alienating more people than you

> > attract.

> >

> > a

>

>

>

>

> ------------------------------------

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

I never said ban raw milk, did I? I said don't make up statistics, it

discredits your cause, and it's misleading. Your opinions do not equal

statistics.

Glad I could frighten you. ;) You kinda frightened me by accusing Tipper of

working for the CSA. Same grass. different side.

I'm out though. The blinders of the only people talking in this group are

unreal.

> a,

>

> The statistic is my own personal opinion and I believe it whole heartedly

> based on what I know about pasturized milk, and I believe that it slowly

> causes serious disease processes in the body. I never intended for it to

> seem like I was stating a scientifically proven statistic. You disagree

> with it. Of course you are welcome to have your own beliefs and make your

> own decisions. Again, my sole point was not to argue the toxicity of

> pasturized milk, (that has been done many times and you are choosing to

> ignore or disregard that) but to make a very strong point that we should all

> be allowed to choose for ourselves, ESPECIALLY since we all have differing

> opinions. I can not stress that enough. It frankly frightened me that you

> made the statement about thank God we are not being permitted to buy raw

> milk now, or something to that effect. I am hoping you are not arguing we

> should not have freedom of choice, even though your statements have seemed

> to say that to me. can you agree with that we each should be permitted to

> make our own food choices and decisions? Or do you really believe that

> those of us who disagree with you should be prohibited and have our freedoms

> removed because of our beliefs and choices?

>

> Carol

>

>

> >

> > I do understand that studies are always done by those with money and

> power,

> > hence my favorite statistic that '75% of statistics are made up,' and a

> rule

> > to always check the source. Don't even get me started on health care

> > statistics (statistics/health care junkie here). However calling all

> > pasteurized milk toxic is a little far fetched to me. It may not be

> > helping, but it doesn't mean it's toxic. And " toxic " is not the kind of

> > language that's going to make a lot of people rally to the raw milk

> cause.

> > It's too confrontational for mass America if you are actually trying to

> make

> > a change. I also will never believe anything that is 100% of the time.

> If

> > someone gives me a stat as 100%, I give a major side eye to the stat and

> the

> > giver of the statistic. The only thing I know of that is a 100% factor

> is

> > that we all die sometime, sooner or later, but certainly we do not all

> die

> > from drinking the Kemps. I'm not saying raw milk is bad. I'm not saying

> the

> > $1.80 at costco is awesome. I'm saying step back and make sure the

> > statistics we are throwing out are real or at least have some possibility

> of

> > being real, or you are going to end up alienating more people than you

> > attract.

> >

> > a

>

>

>

>

> ------------------------------------

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

Cheyenne,

Do you keep at least some cows in milk year round? Or do you let them dry up

over winter? That would be one significant factor in keeping cows healthy and

robust.

Sara R

No grain ever can be done, even in MN and WI. I have not fed ANY grain, corn

silage, or other grain byproducts for over 10 years, and no corn for around 12

years. I hear the argument all the time that it can't be done, it's too cold in

winter, etc.. It's true we can't pasture dairy animals in the 'arctic' of WI and

MN, but we can still feed them forage only, which keeps us in the strictly

grass/forage category. I use kelp and sea salt as a mineral source, and I do

micro fertility on my land to grow nutrient dense forage. Farmers have to stay

away from garbage like urea that grows lots of " empty " grass with no nutrition

in it.

,_._,___

Guest guest
Posted

That's enough! Go for it. Leave. It's a free country. Tons of yahoogroups out

there. The badgering and insults that have crossed the board lately have been

very surprising. Sure people can be passionate about things that matter to them.

But that doesn't give anyone license to insult others nor make blanket

statements. Until now, I've consciously chosen to not respond to messages here

that I saw as inflammatory or badgering in tone. It's way more important to

stick together than to turn on each other. In my years on lists, I've seen

ruckuses kick up then die out. Hard feelings is a side effect which tend to

linger. That's a darn shame. This list is one of my favorites, because it's very

local and it's not excessively high volume nor dryly scientific like others.

But, hey, anyone who wants to leave for greener grass elsewhere, go for it. Just

go quietly, do not kick up a fuss and make a scene as you exit the room. Thank

you.

And moderator, please consider enforcing a zero tolerance policy for flaming.

Otherwise, it gets out of control and good people leave the list along with the

bad apples. And as a " Miss Manners " reminder, people should *not* post to the

list on behalf of others without first clearing it with the original poster.

Sara

I'm out though. The blinders of the only people talking in this group are

unreal.

_._,___

Guest guest
Posted

I milk year around. I have about half freshen in the spring, and the other

half summer and fall. I prefer to not have any babies from Nov. through March,

but that doesn't always happen. We use bulls for breeding, and this year we left

them in way too long, so will have some winter babies.

The main thing with a late freshening cow is having really good hay for

them.Pure alfalfa does not have the energy and has too much soluble protein

(same as too short of grass), so I like a grassy mix with clover and some

alfalfa. I also do some baleage.

I like my dry cows to be in really good condition, then they can milk off that

when they freshen, so they never get thin. They milk off the body reserves (fat)

level out, and gain back at the end, without ever getting thin.

I think there is a big difference between a cow getting fat on grass vs grain.

A grain fat cow can have a lot of different metabolic problems when she

freshens, I don't have to worry about that.

Cheyenne

>

> Cheyenne,

> Do you keep at least some cows in milk year round? Or do you let them dry up

over winter? That would be one significant factor in keeping cows healthy and

robust.

> Sara R

>

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...