Guest guest Posted June 3, 2010 Report Posted June 3, 2010 Any response from the Hartmann's? Kathy Quote
Guest guest Posted June 3, 2010 Report Posted June 3, 2010 Haven't seen one yet but WCCO's latest sound bite is making it sound like 5 *more* people got sick. Now they say a fourth person was " found " to be sickened, and a 5th person, a young child, was not hospitalized. ~Joe > > Any response from the Hartmann's? > > Kathy > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 3, 2010 Report Posted June 3, 2010 Thank god they stopped milk production then, so that people who wanted to protest by drinking milk didn't sicken themselves and their children to make a point. It's a bad situation all around. a > Haven't seen one yet but WCCO's latest sound bite is making it sound like 5 > *more* people got sick. Now they say a fourth person was " found " to be > sickened, and a 5th person, a young child, was not hospitalized. > ~Joe > > > > > > > > Any response from the Hartmann's? > > > > Kathy > > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 3, 2010 Report Posted June 3, 2010 > Haven't seen one yet but WCCO's latest sound bite is making it sound like 5 *more* people got sick. Now they say a fourth person was " found " to be sickened, and a 5th person, a young child, was not hospitalized. Joe, Does it really matter what wording the media are using? It's evident now that the milk made people sick, and that animals and products from the farm contain E. coli. - Tipper Quote
Guest guest Posted June 3, 2010 Report Posted June 3, 2010 I found this article today after I read the press release from the Health Department. I had always believed that there couldn't be e coli 0157 h7 in grass fed animals, but I am not sure now that the data supports this. http://www.slate.com/id/2242290 Sara > > > Haven't seen one yet but WCCO's latest sound bite is making it sound like 5 *more* people got sick. Now they say a fourth person was " found " to be sickened, and a 5th person, a young child, was not hospitalized. > > Joe, > > Does it really matter what wording the media are using? It's evident now that the milk made people sick, and that animals and products from the farm contain E. coli. > > - Tipper > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 3, 2010 Report Posted June 3, 2010 keep in mind grass fed beef does not mean 100% grass fed so that huge company most like did not 100% grass feed.............The dairy I get my milk from 100% grass feeds their cows. I have been told they are only one in the state that does that........ > > > I found this article today after I read the press release from the Health > Department. I had always believed that there couldn't be e coli 0157 h7 in > grass fed animals, but I am not sure now that the data supports this. > > http://www.slate.com/id/2242290 > > Sara > > > > > > > > Haven't seen one yet but WCCO's latest sound bite is making it sound > like 5 *more* people got sick. Now they say a fourth person was " found " to > be sickened, and a 5th person, a young child, was not hospitalized. > > > > Joe, > > > > Does it really matter what wording the media are using? It's evident now > that the milk made people sick, and that animals and products from the farm > contain E. coli. > > > > - Tipper > > > > > -- Kathy-jo c. ebay store: http://stores.ebay.com/Uptown-rags http://finance.groups.yahoo.com/group/MNBlueSkyGuideExchange/ Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2010 Report Posted June 4, 2010 > > Does it really matter what wording the media are using? It's evident now that the milk made people sick, and that animals and products from the farm contain E. coli. > > - Tipper Are you seriously trying to stir the pot again, like last week? Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2010 Report Posted June 4, 2010 As it stands right now, this case raises some pretty serious issues from a trad foods/food safety point of view. What options remain for those who prefer unpasteurized, non-irradiated products, if traditional, grass fed farming practices don't offer protection against e.coli O157? Or would you argue that it is something specific to the Hartmann's? This is the first case I'm aware of where grassfed cows were harboring e.coli O157. Anyone know if the full report is available yet from MDA/MDH? Greg > > > I found this article today after I read the press release from the Health > Department. I had always believed that there couldn't be e coli 0157 h7 in > grass fed animals, but I am not sure now that the data supports this. > > http://www.slate.com/id/2242290 > > Sara > > > > > > > > Haven't seen one yet but WCCO's latest sound bite is making it sound > like 5 *more* people got sick. Now they say a fourth person was " found " to > be sickened, and a 5th person, a young child, was not hospitalized. > > > > Joe, > > > > Does it really matter what wording the media are using? It's evident now > that the milk made people sick, and that animals and products from the farm > contain E. coli. > > > > - Tipper > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2010 Report Posted June 4, 2010 Tipper, Wording DOES matter...why do you think we have the terms " spin doctor " or propaganda? I'll have to admit, things do look bad for the Hartmanns, but I'm still waiting to hear their side of the story before I make a determination. Kathy Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2010 Report Posted June 4, 2010 Greg, I like that you are talking about the actual issue here, and that is that we don't actually know if this source of raw " alive " milk is safe. As much as we like the good, alive part of it, is it worth the risk of the very deadly, dangerous part of drinking it? Hopefully Hartmann will do some investigation into the root cause of what caused the E.Coli, and let their customer knows what it was, if it can be fixed, or if it's unknown. Maybe it was a one time incident, or maybe it could happen again because they can't figure it out. If it's unknown, would you risk giving your children that milk again, especially with one still in the hospital this time around? I'm not currently a raw milk drinker, but I did consider it before this incident. I wont consider it now being pregnant and having a young child. My alternative, and what I would suggest to raw milk families in the mean time: If I wanted to get all the good cultures would be to give my family pasteurized, organic milk (grass fed if you can even select that), and then also give a probiotic supplement to get healthy live cultures into our bodies. The report probably wont be available for a while, but hopefully they are keeping the Hartmann's in the loop. As risky as their business seems right now, I doubt it would ever be their intention to make anyone sick, and I'm sure they will do everything they need to make sure their product is safe before thinking about selling it again. Side note question: Is Hartmann the only raw milk dealer in the metro area? a > As it stands right now, this case raises some pretty serious issues from a > trad foods/food safety point of view. > > What options remain for those who prefer unpasteurized, non-irradiated > products, if traditional, grass fed farming practices don't offer > protection > against e.coli O157? > > Or would you argue that it is something specific to the Hartmann's? This > is > the first case I'm aware of where grassfed cows were harboring e.coli O157. > > Anyone know if the full report is available yet from MDA/MDH? > > Greg > > > > > > > > > I found this article today after I read the press release from the Health > > Department. I had always believed that there couldn't be e coli 0157 h7 > in > > grass fed animals, but I am not sure now that the data supports this. > > > > http://www.slate.com/id/2242290 > > > > Sara > > > > > > > > > > > > > Haven't seen one yet but WCCO's latest sound bite is making it sound > > like 5 *more* people got sick. Now they say a fourth person was " found " > to > > be sickened, and a 5th person, a young child, was not hospitalized. > > > > > > Joe, > > > > > > Does it really matter what wording the media are using? It's evident > now > > that the milk made people sick, and that animals and products from the > farm > > contain E. coli. > > > > > > - Tipper > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2010 Report Posted June 4, 2010 > Are you seriously trying to stir the pot again, like last week? No, I'm trying to get you to talk about the case honestly, and without trying to divert attention from the real issue. Greg hit the nail on the head with his comment that this raises questions about food safety from a traditional foods point of view. The focus should be on moving forward, instead of trying to prove, somehow, that this has been entirely manufactured by the government and the media. - Tipper Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2010 Report Posted June 4, 2010 OK, here's something to consider: The people in charge of testing and making the subjective interpretation of the test results are on record as being opposed to raw milk being available. US Dept of Health & Human Services objective FS HP2020-9: Increase the number of States that have prohibited sale or distribution of unpasteurized dairy products. (as defined by FDA, unpasteurized liquid milk and cheeses aged < 60 days). This is part of the 'Healthy People 2020' program http://tinyurl.com/286pxfx MDH affirms Healthy People 2020 as one of their goals: http://www.health.state.mn.us/about/mission.html Do you think MDH can conduct an unbiased investigation under these circumstances? Greg > > > > Are you seriously trying to stir the pot again, like last week? > > No, I'm trying to get you to talk about the case honestly, and without > trying to divert attention from the real issue. Greg hit the nail on the > head with his comment that this raises questions about food safety from a > traditional foods point of view. The focus should be on moving forward, > instead of trying to prove, somehow, that this has been entirely > manufactured by the government and the media. > > - Tipper > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2010 Report Posted June 4, 2010 > keep in mind grass fed beef does not mean 100% grass fed so that huge > company most like did not 100% grass feed.............The dairy I get my > milk from 100% grass feeds their cows. I have been told they are only one in > the state that does that........ I talked with Diane a couple of weeks ago and she said that a farm can have 100% grass fed but not 100% pasture fed cattle in Minnesota, due to the weather. Their cattle receive some corn silage. I would hope that the Hartmann's demand an independent testing of their products as is their constitutional right. Anne Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2010 Report Posted June 4, 2010 If I ever had to buy " store " milk my choice would be grassfed, non-homogenized milk, i.e. Cedar Summit. (Processed milk is both homogenized and pasteurized.) It's the lesser of two evils. Sara My alternative, and what I would suggest to raw milk families in the mean time: If I wanted to get all the good cultures would be to give my family pasteurized, organic milk (grass fed if you can even select that), and then also give a probiotic supplement to get healthy live cultures into our bodies. ___ Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2010 Report Posted June 4, 2010 > Do you think MDH can conduct an unbiased investigation under these > circumstances? > > Greg Even though the goals of the Minnesota Department of Health are at odds with those of raw milk dairy farmers, I find it extremely hard to believe that this whole situation was somehow manufactured or the product of a biased investigation. People became sick. Those who became seriously ill ended up in the hospital and were identified as being afflicted by e coli 0157. I'm guessing that any time a hospital finds such a bug in a critically ill patient, they must report the findings to the Minnesota Department of Health. Upon questioning the families, the Department of Health discovered a possible common thread: raw milk from the Hartmann farm. The Minnesota Department of Health encouraged consumers to discard products from the farm while it conducted an investigation. Products from the farm and animals on the farm were tested and found to contain the same strain of e coli that made people ill. I'm sure people could argue all day about the Minnesota Department of Health's intentions in the big picture of raw dairy. But this specific case certainly doesn't lead me to scream " bias. " I wouldn't doubt, however, that this case will be used to leverage support for the Minnesota Department of Health's larger goals. I'm not a raw milk consumer, though, so I'm more inclined to focus on the facts of this specific case and not worry about what might happen to the raw milk trade in the future. I read in the Star Tribune that the toddler who had been hospitalized was released on Wednesday. I pray that he or she is doing well and will make a full recovery! -Angie Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2010 Report Posted June 4, 2010 We're very happy with our Cedar Summit milk. For healthy bacteria, we eat yogurt with live cultures and take probiotics. -Angie > > If I ever had to buy " store " milk my choice would be grassfed, non-homogenized milk, i.e. Cedar Summit. (Processed milk is both homogenized and pasteurized.) It's the lesser of two evils. > Sara > > My alternative, and what I would suggest to raw milk families in the mean > time: If I wanted to get all the good cultures would be to give my family > pasteurized, organic milk (grass fed if you can even select that), and then > also give a probiotic supplement to get healthy live cultures into our > bodies. > > ___ > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2010 Report Posted June 4, 2010 Hi Sara! That's what I also always recommend for people who want pasteurized milk. Unfortunately, it is not always convenient or even available in some markets. Kathy Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2010 Report Posted June 4, 2010 Yea the glass factor is not convenient for everyone, my glass-breaking family included. But, oh hey, I see Cedar Summit in almost every grocery store! If not, the customer can always ask the manager to stock it. I've seen it at Byerly's, Kowalski's, Cub, Rainbow, VNF, Whole Foods, perhaps at Traders Joe's. It's a primarily regional brand so I wouldn't expect to see much of it out of the metro area. Gosh, I will miss my raw milk when I'm on my 15 day road trip later this month! (Sure I could bring some along but with all the driving I will be doing, it'd turn into butter! lol!) Sara PS Today my son turns 13. He is 5'9 " (could have gained another inch when I wasn't looking) and I'm gonna attribute it to family genes and REAL milk! He's had it for over half his life. ________________________________ That's what I also always recommend for people who want pasteurized milk. Unfortunately, it is not always convenient or even available in some markets. Kathy _ ,_._,___ Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2010 Report Posted June 4, 2010 My response to " keep in mind grass fed beef does not mean 100% grass fed so that huge company most like did not 100% grass feed.............The dairy I get my milk from 100% grass feeds their cows. I have been told they are only one in the state that does that........ I talked with Diane a couple of weeks ago and she said that a farm can have 100% grass fed but not 100% pasture fed cattle in Minnesota, due to the weather. Their cattle receive some corn silage. I would hope that the Hartmann's demand an independent testing of their products as is their constitutional right. Anne " Our cows are subjected to the same weather but receive no corn or corn silage. They are on pasture until winter and then receive a mix of grass bales. They are truly 100% grass-fed. It can be done. Some say that the winter weather is to hard on them and they will loose weight and suffer. We have not found that to be true as long as they have access to as much as they want to eat of quality bales, sea salt, and kelp as minerals. This is again the case of knowing your farmer, knowing his pratices, and inspecting their farm.  They should maintain an open-door policy at all times on all things to be trusted in my opinion.  ________________________________ To: trad-foods-MN Sent: Fri, June 4, 2010 8:16:16 AM Subject: Re: State testing matches E. coli bacteria from Gibbon farm with those from ill consumers   Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2010 Report Posted June 4, 2010 My response to " keep in mind grass fed beef does not mean 100% grass fed so that huge company most like did not 100% grass feed.............The dairy I get my milk from 100% grass feeds their cows. I have been told they are only one in the state that does that........ I talked with Diane a couple of weeks ago and she said that a farm can have 100% grass fed but not 100% pasture fed cattle in Minnesota, due to the weather. Their cattle receive some corn silage. I would hope that the Hartmann's demand an independent testing of their products as is their constitutional right. Anne " Our cows are subjected to the same weather but receive no corn or corn silage. They are on pasture until winter and then receive a mix of grass bales. They are truly 100% grass-fed. It can be done. Some say that the winter weather is to hard on them and they will loose weight and suffer. We have not found that to be true as long as they have access to as much as they want to eat of quality bales, sea salt, and kelp as minerals. This is again the case of knowing your farmer, knowing his pratices, and inspecting their farm.  They should maintain an open-door policy at all times on all things to be trusted in my opinion.  ________________________________ To: trad-foods-MN Sent: Fri, June 4, 2010 8:16:16 AM Subject: Re: State testing matches E. coli bacteria from Gibbon farm with those from ill consumers   Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2010 Report Posted June 4, 2010 My response to " keep in mind grass fed beef does not mean 100% grass fed so that huge company most like did not 100% grass feed.............The dairy I get my milk from 100% grass feeds their cows. I have been told they are only one in the state that does that........ I talked with Diane a couple of weeks ago and she said that a farm can have 100% grass fed but not 100% pasture fed cattle in Minnesota, due to the weather. Their cattle receive some corn silage. I would hope that the Hartmann's demand an independent testing of their products as is their constitutional right. Anne " Our cows are subjected to the same weather but receive no corn or corn silage. They are on pasture until winter and then receive a mix of grass bales. They are truly 100% grass-fed. It can be done. Some say that the winter weather is to hard on them and they will loose weight and suffer. We have not found that to be true as long as they have access to as much as they want to eat of quality bales, sea salt, and kelp as minerals. This is again the case of knowing your farmer, knowing his pratices, and inspecting their farm.  They should maintain an open-door policy at all times on all things to be trusted in my opinion.  ________________________________ To: trad-foods-MN Sent: Fri, June 4, 2010 8:16:16 AM Subject: Re: State testing matches E. coli bacteria from Gibbon farm with those from ill consumers   Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2010 Report Posted June 4, 2010 Who did the studies, and who funded them? Why was that not disclosed in the article? The second comment following the article goes into more detail on that account. Other things I would question are...were these truly grass fed animals, or were they confinement animals that got a little grass? I was recently part of a discussion on another list about the impossibility of having grass fed because the CLA levels will drop in winter. The researcher did some tests many years back on a high producing, confinement herd that got some grass for 4 months. Seriously???? That data is totally useless, yet was published, and is used as an example why grass fed won't work.I'm sure CLA does drop, but will an animal that has grass and forage always, with no grain, corn silage, or other garbage give the same results? And, if it does drop, does that mean we shouldn't/can't do grass fed? No studies have been done with strictly grass fed animals. I offered samples of my 10+ years of grass/forage only milk for her to test. There is some thought that GMO's are also part of the e-coli mutation. I've also read that GMO's are changing the DNA of those (animals included) that eat them. So, could an animal that had grain at some point in it's life now carry some mutated strains of things like e-coli. Another thought is grazing height. The cow produces natural buffers when she ruminates (chews her cud). She needs fiber to do this. If someone was feeding too short of grass the animal may become acidic. Most research is done with an agenda and the parameters are set, so results may be greatly skewed.That is why many of us have little faith in what the university comes up with (or regulatory officials). There is a LOT at stake (for those making $ off status quo) as we eliminate chemical, corn, confinement agriculture. Cheyenne > > I found this article today after I read the press release from the Health Department. I had always believed that there couldn't be e coli 0157 h7 in grass fed animals, but I am not sure now that the data supports this. > > http://www.slate.com/id/2242290 > > Sara > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2010 Report Posted June 4, 2010 Who did the studies, and who funded them? Why was that not disclosed in the article? The second comment following the article goes into more detail on that account. Other things I would question are...were these truly grass fed animals, or were they confinement animals that got a little grass? I was recently part of a discussion on another list about the impossibility of having grass fed because the CLA levels will drop in winter. The researcher did some tests many years back on a high producing, confinement herd that got some grass for 4 months. Seriously???? That data is totally useless, yet was published, and is used as an example why grass fed won't work.I'm sure CLA does drop, but will an animal that has grass and forage always, with no grain, corn silage, or other garbage give the same results? And, if it does drop, does that mean we shouldn't/can't do grass fed? No studies have been done with strictly grass fed animals. I offered samples of my 10+ years of grass/forage only milk for her to test. There is some thought that GMO's are also part of the e-coli mutation. I've also read that GMO's are changing the DNA of those (animals included) that eat them. So, could an animal that had grain at some point in it's life now carry some mutated strains of things like e-coli. Another thought is grazing height. The cow produces natural buffers when she ruminates (chews her cud). She needs fiber to do this. If someone was feeding too short of grass the animal may become acidic. Most research is done with an agenda and the parameters are set, so results may be greatly skewed.That is why many of us have little faith in what the university comes up with (or regulatory officials). There is a LOT at stake (for those making $ off status quo) as we eliminate chemical, corn, confinement agriculture. Cheyenne > > I found this article today after I read the press release from the Health Department. I had always believed that there couldn't be e coli 0157 h7 in grass fed animals, but I am not sure now that the data supports this. > > http://www.slate.com/id/2242290 > > Sara > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2010 Report Posted June 4, 2010 Who did the studies, and who funded them? Why was that not disclosed in the article? The second comment following the article goes into more detail on that account. Other things I would question are...were these truly grass fed animals, or were they confinement animals that got a little grass? I was recently part of a discussion on another list about the impossibility of having grass fed because the CLA levels will drop in winter. The researcher did some tests many years back on a high producing, confinement herd that got some grass for 4 months. Seriously???? That data is totally useless, yet was published, and is used as an example why grass fed won't work.I'm sure CLA does drop, but will an animal that has grass and forage always, with no grain, corn silage, or other garbage give the same results? And, if it does drop, does that mean we shouldn't/can't do grass fed? No studies have been done with strictly grass fed animals. I offered samples of my 10+ years of grass/forage only milk for her to test. There is some thought that GMO's are also part of the e-coli mutation. I've also read that GMO's are changing the DNA of those (animals included) that eat them. So, could an animal that had grain at some point in it's life now carry some mutated strains of things like e-coli. Another thought is grazing height. The cow produces natural buffers when she ruminates (chews her cud). She needs fiber to do this. If someone was feeding too short of grass the animal may become acidic. Most research is done with an agenda and the parameters are set, so results may be greatly skewed.That is why many of us have little faith in what the university comes up with (or regulatory officials). There is a LOT at stake (for those making $ off status quo) as we eliminate chemical, corn, confinement agriculture. Cheyenne > > I found this article today after I read the press release from the Health Department. I had always believed that there couldn't be e coli 0157 h7 in grass fed animals, but I am not sure now that the data supports this. > > http://www.slate.com/id/2242290 > > Sara > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2010 Report Posted June 4, 2010 > My alternative, and what I would suggest to raw milk families in the mean > time: If I wanted to get all the good cultures would be to give my family > pasteurized, organic milk (grass fed if you can even select that), and then > also give a probiotic supplement to get healthy live cultures into our > bodies. > There are risks in everything, and probiotic supplements are no exception. Here is some info to keep in mind: " According to this new report, laboratory testing of 12 refrigerated and 8 non-refrigerated, randomly selected probiotic supplements obtained from different health food stores revealed that only one product contained the same bacteria as those listed on the label. Many of the refrigerated products had some beneficial bacteria, but contained fewer species of organisms than the label claimed. More than 30% of all supplements were contaminated with other microorganisms and 50% of the non-refrigerated products were completely dead. Dead probiotics have no impact on improving intestinal function or restoring the balance of normal intestinal flora. " <http://bastyrcenter.org/content/view/664/> In other words, 50% of the time consumers were wasting their money and 30% of the time consumers were being put at risk by contamination. My family will continue to consume raw milk and raw milk products because we trust our farmer and prefer the benefits and risks of live food vs the benefits and risks of huge corporations and their dead food. Yes, things happen - some granola bars that I ate during my first pregnancy in 2007 were included in the big peanut recall, and that could have ended in tragedy for me and my fetus. Thankfully it didn't. There is not one single avenue we can choose that is guaranteed to be safe. Therefore, I choose the one I feel is most likely to benefit my family, and it happens to be the path that includes raw milk from a trusted source. Everybody should be free to make that decision for their own family without interference from anybody. Alyssa Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.