Guest guest Posted March 8, 2007 Report Posted March 8, 2007 I have a couple of kettlebells and I've competed as both an olympic lifter and a powerlifter. I like the kettlebells. They are fun and different. But there is no inherent advantage in the kettlebell over a dumbbell or a swingbell that imparts skill or conditioning transfer. Kettlebells are trendy and yes, I've read most of the claims including testimonies from some good lifters. IMO to say that a kettlebell is _the best_ assistance is totally wrong. If you were to say that a kettlebell can be an effective assistance tool for some people at some time in their training than I would agree. But there is no best for every person for all time. Even given that... For olympic weightlifters the Bulgarians have proven that you don't need a lot of different assistance exercises to be successful as an olympic weightlifter. Certainly they don't use kettlebells. Abadzhiev eliminated virtually all assistance exercises where there wasn't a strong correlation between results in the classic lifts and the assistance and was left with power versions of the classic lifts and squats. In the training of most olympic weightlifters kettlebells simply do not give enough resistance or specificity to be a really usefull assistance tool. They are simply too light and the heavy ones are too awkward. Roman, the great Russian coach, and Verkhoshanskey (who wasn't a weightlifting coach per se, but certainly influenced the training of Russian weightlifters) listed jumps with the kettlebell as assistance if speed/strength is poor. But in terms of importance in their assistance exercise they would be of minimal value and there were other tools which could be used to the same purpose. Put another way - if the kettlebells weren't available in a Russian gym Roman or Verkhoshanskey wouldn't have missed a beat. and some other powerlifters have used kettlebells for some assistance, but once again. The best assitance? To my knowledge Ed Coan has never used a kettlebell and look at his performance. Sure, they can be used as assistance and have some purpose, but there are not 'the best' or even essential. If you don't have a kettlebell a dumbbell can be used for virtually every exercise and the only sport where you would notice a functional difference is kettlebell lifting! Specificity rules! I'm willing to bet that our late mentor, Dr. Siff, would have included a section in his 'Facts and Fallacies' book addressing the kettlebell and the really outrageous claims being made for their effectiveness. Once again - there is nothing wrong with a kettlebell and I have no problems with people who are marketing the kettlebells so effectively. For the typical person the best fitness tool is the one they use. I have included kettlebells in some training programs I have developed for wrestlers if they were available. I have nothing against kettlebells. But as a kinesiologist saying the kettlebell is the important thing is as much a fallacy as saying 'train the muscles'. For sports performance you don't train muscles - you train movement. Movement is trained through various strength, speed and endurance exercises. There is virtually no sporting movement that you can train for those characteristics that I can't train just as effectively using some other device. There is no magic in the device. There is no magic bullet and kettlebells certainly are not the magic bullet. Bill wrote: > I had made a suggestion in an earlier post in discussions with > Schaefer that the best assist work a power lifter or Olympic Lifter > could do was working with Kettlebells. I have not heard back from > and was just curious what the rest of the group thought. Does > anyone in the group have any experience working with Kettlebells? > > Bill > West Chester, PA > > -- Hobman Saskatoon, CANADA Quote
Guest guest Posted March 8, 2007 Report Posted March 8, 2007 > > I had made a suggestion in an earlier post in discussions with Schaefer that the best assist work a power lifter or Olympic Lifter could do was working with Kettlebells. I have not heard back from and was just curious what the rest of the group thought. Does anyone in the group have any experience working with Kettlebells? > > Bill > West Chester, PA > **** I can see the use of them for GPP purposes and certian accessory lifts but to label them as the best assistance work a PL or OL could do is a bit much. They are simply a tool to be used, not the be all and end all as they are held up to be in some circles. Could you expand on why you feel they would be the best assistance tool? Mick Morrey Staffordshire UK Quote
Guest guest Posted March 8, 2007 Report Posted March 8, 2007 very well put. I concur. I think a great deal of people get too caught up in a " system " . If you analyze the successful strength coaches you see a variety of " systems " but within those systems a similar methodology. There is no magic bullet and there really is not one perfect way to train everyone. I do think some systems work better for a majority of athletes over other systems that may have a more specific nature to a given athlete and his/her respective sport. I think people also have a tendency to forget that powerlifting is the sport of powerlifting. Train hard and smart! Damien Chiappini SPFS Pittsburgh,PA.. Re: Kettlebells I have a couple of kettlebells and I've competed as both an olympic lifter and a powerlifter. I like the kettlebells. They are fun and different. But there is no inherent advantage in the kettlebell over a dumbbell or a swingbell that imparts skill or conditioning transfer. Kettlebells are trendy and yes, I've read most of the claims including testimonies from some good lifters. IMO to say that a kettlebell is _the best_ assistance is totally wrong. If you were to say that a kettlebell can be an effective assistance tool for some people at some time in their training than I would agree. But there is no best for every person for all time. Even given that... For olympic weightlifters the Bulgarians have proven that you don't need a lot of different assistance exercises to be successful as an olympic weightlifter. Certainly they don't use kettlebells. Abadzhiev eliminated virtually all assistance exercises where there wasn't a strong correlation between results in the classic lifts and the assistance and was left with power versions of the classic lifts and squats. In the training of most olympic weightlifters kettlebells simply do not give enough resistance or specificity to be a really usefull assistance tool. They are simply too light and the heavy ones are too awkward. Roman, the great Russian coach, and Verkhoshanskey (who wasn't a weightlifting coach per se, but certainly influenced the training of Russian weightlifters) listed jumps with the kettlebell as assistance if speed/strength is poor. But in terms of importance in their assistance exercise they would be of minimal value and there were other tools which could be used to the same purpose. Put another way - if the kettlebells weren't available in a Russian gym Roman or Verkhoshanskey wouldn't have missed a beat. and some other powerlifters have used kettlebells for some assistance, but once again. The best assitance? To my knowledge Ed Coan has never used a kettlebell and look at his performance. Sure, they can be used as assistance and have some purpose, but there are not 'the best' or even essential. If you don't have a kettlebell a dumbbell can be used for virtually every exercise and the only sport where you would notice a functional difference is kettlebell lifting! Specificity rules! I'm willing to bet that our late mentor, Dr. Siff, would have included a section in his 'Facts and Fallacies' book addressing the kettlebell and the really outrageous claims being made for their effectiveness. Once again - there is nothing wrong with a kettlebell and I have no problems with people who are marketing the kettlebells so effectively. For the typical person the best fitness tool is the one they use. I have included kettlebells in some training programs I have developed for wrestlers if they were available. I have nothing against kettlebells. But as a kinesiologist saying the kettlebell is the important thing is as much a fallacy as saying 'train the muscles'. For sports performance you don't train muscles - you train movement. Movement is trained through various strength, speed and endurance exercises. There is virtually no sporting movement that you can train for those characteristics that I can't train just as effectively using some other device. There is no magic in the device. There is no magic bullet and kettlebells certainly are not the magic bullet. Hobman Saskatoon, CANADA ================= Quote
Guest guest Posted March 8, 2007 Report Posted March 8, 2007 Bill, I would not say they are the best assistance exercise for powerlifting, however they are another tool. You have to realize that powerlifting and Olympic lifting are sports unto themselves and would need to be trained with specificity. Variations of the lifts and performing partials that build on the lifts are what is necessary for success in powerlifting. The use of a kettlebell has some application in hip extension training and of course can be used or has a greater role in trainng for GPP. I think the answer that Mr. Hobman provided was spot on. Don't get too caught up in the thinking that one method is the only way. The more tools you have the more variety you can apply in training an athlete for sports. I would like to hear why you feel thay are the best assistance tools that a powerlifter could use. Train hard and smart! Damien Chiappini SPFS Pittsburgh, PA. Kettlebells I had made a suggestion in an earlier post in discussions with Schaefer that the best assist work a power lifter or Olympic Lifter could do was working with Kettlebells. I have not heard back from and was just curious what the rest of the group thought. Does anyone in the group have any experience working with Kettlebells? Bill West Chester, PA Quote
Guest guest Posted March 8, 2007 Report Posted March 8, 2007 Thank you, , for reiterating the points I made originally and adding the OL perspective. As a general rule, persons who read the original posting and well, respond on topic will find I tend to respond back to them here quite promptly. The best assistance work for the powerlifts ARE THE POWERLIFTS. <grin>. The barbell squat, bench press, and deadlift, all are supplemental exercises to attain success in the lift and the other ones. A PL could survive in a gym with a bench, rack, and barbell/plates and chalk. Even dumbbells would not be " NECESSARY " . Why then would a kettlebell be " the best assistance " ? they, like many other objects we can play with, add spice but are not the meat and potatoes on which you build your size and strength overall. A lot of things can be fun, sure - and won't hurt your competition lifting. That being said, I do enjoy some " strongman " type moves, also the occasional OL dumbbell and barbell moves too, variation is fun for one thing. A far higher priority is more 25 kg plates where I lift most of the time....and more squat racks. Some more heavy duty PL bars... I don't see us buying more than 2 or 3 kettles or believing they're the end all and be all for our strength training here lol. Probably just a couple and selective moves to support a couple of sports...I don't see our PL giving up bp, sq, and dl and their variations to swing kettles as their primary assist work! I think some may find the handles more agreeable to their hands and that serves some purpose, yes, but there are handled plates, and handled weight balls too, again, it's a matter of personal preference. If you like a kettlebell and can afford to buy them, go ahead, it's what makes you happy lol. I'm not the Anti-(kettle) Belle..... I am the Anti whoopie cushion, wobbly board, and well, generally rehabbing healthy backs for no reason person though...an examination of the archives will readily prove that. <shrug> But to state as Mr. did to me originally that such a kettlebell waving for 30 minutes would be a superior cardio/strength workout for a competing POWERLIFTER to my suggestion of 5 sets of 10 moderately heavy DEADLIFT (60-80% of 1 rep max) performed with strict 3-5 minute rest interval between sets, followed by heavy farmer's walk for 3 full sets of whatever length you can manage before grip and wind fail you, THAT is what the original discussion was about. I suppose could try both workouts and report back if he's not involved in anything too serious at the moment <grin>. Mr. finds his 30 min of his 24 kg kettlebell waving to be superior for his needs as a rugby, ultimate fighter and highlands games person, but I would NEVER choose such a workout waving his 24 kg kettle for 30 min as my " best assistance ever " as a competing powerlifter, for many of the reasons both and I laid out previously. Success as a competing powerlifter without a kettlebell in my immediate vicinity for a decade pretty much tells me I don't have to use a kettlebell.... <grin>. Maybe they make good luck charms, wear 1 on a chain around my neck? <JUST KIDDING OK?> Mr. , thank you in future for your more careful reading of the previous postings, and I wish you well in your pursuits. I will stick to my " cardio " and strength workouts. They tend to build my strength, endurance, and my capacity for work, which then yields more strength...and should I wish to swing something, I'm sure I can find a nicely sized dumbbell around the gym....<grin>. I think generally I'd prefer to have dumbbells because they're very versatile and frankly people break stuff constantly where i lift... if you prefer kettlebells, I see no reason you couldn't use them. I just don't think that as the original argument stated, they are the " best assistance " above MANY other things for a competing powerlifter. Somehow I can hear someone suggesting the next fad will be the " dead cat " workout - where you swing roadkill for an hour and it yields 50% increases in your strength, yet it's environmentally friendly....<grin> and if you are lacking in roadkill in your location, how to construct sandbags correctly simulating the real thing...coupled with the notion that the wind resistance of an uneven object, and well, grip requirements of something kinda flattened make this superior to any existing gym equipment... Oh and bad news, kettlebell fans, the starlets in Hollywood are using them now (apparently to supplement their plastic surgery and implants..) according to the " women's fitness mags " now......which means you're not going to be well, hard core any more? JUST KIDDING <GRIN> Course you guys can argue they've made the " pink plastic kettle " version over there....plastic coated, very LIGHT kettles....now THOSE might make nice luck charms for the strength athlete....just like the cute lil plastic db's make good paperweights? Hey if someone sells that roadkill workout, remember, you heard it here first...and I want royalties! With frugality of investment in mind, chalk on hands, and my sense of humor at the many " implements " now touted as well, the latest and greatest.... The Phantom aka Schaefer, CMT, CSCS, competing powerlifter Denver, Colorado, USA Re: Kettlebells I have a couple of kettlebells and I've competed as both an olympic lifter and a powerlifter. I like the kettlebells. They are fun and different. But there is no inherent advantage in the kettlebell over a dumbbell or a swingbell that imparts skill or conditioning transfer. Kettlebells are trendy and yes, I've read most of the claims including testimonies from some good lifters. IMO to say that a kettlebell is _the best_ assistance is totally wrong. If you were to say that a kettlebell can be an effective assistance tool for some people at some time in their training than I would agree. But there is no best for every person for all time. Even given that... For olympic weightlifters the Bulgarians have proven that you don't need a lot of different assistance exercises to be successful as an olympic weightlifter. Certainly they don't use kettlebells. Abadzhiev eliminated virtually all assistance exercises where there wasn't a strong correlation between results in the classic lifts and the assistance and was left with power versions of the classic lifts and squats. In the training of most olympic weightlifters kettlebells simply do not give enough resistance or specificity to be a really usefull assistance tool. They are simply too light and the heavy ones are too awkward. Roman, the great Russian coach, and Verkhoshanskey (who wasn't a weightlifting coach per se, but certainly influenced the training of Russian weightlifters) listed jumps with the kettlebell as assistance if speed/strength is poor. But in terms of importance in their assistance exercise they would be of minimal value and there were other tools which could be used to the same purpose. Put another way - if the kettlebells weren't available in a Russian gym Roman or Verkhoshanskey wouldn't have missed a beat. and some other powerlifters have used kettlebells for some assistance, but once again. The best assitance? To my knowledge Ed Coan has never used a kettlebell and look at his performance. Sure, they can be used as assistance and have some purpose, but there are not 'the best' or even essential. If you don't have a kettlebell a dumbbell can be used for virtually every exercise and the only sport where you would notice a functional difference is kettlebell lifting! Specificity rules! I'm willing to bet that our late mentor, Dr. Siff, would have included a section in his 'Facts and Fallacies' book addressing the kettlebell and the really outrageous claims being made for their effectiveness. Once again - there is nothing wrong with a kettlebell and I have no problems with people who are marketing the kettlebells so effectively. For the typical person the best fitness tool is the one they use. I have included kettlebells in some training programs I have developed for wrestlers if they were available. I have nothing against kettlebells. But as a kinesiologist saying the kettlebell is the important thing is as much a fallacy as saying 'train the muscles'. For sports performance you don't train muscles - you train movement. Movement is trained through various strength, speed and endurance exercises. There is virtually no sporting movement that you can train for those characteristics that I can't train just as effectively using some other device. There is no magic in the device. There is no magic bullet and kettlebells certainly are not the magic bullet. Hobman Saskatoon, CANADA Quote
Guest guest Posted March 9, 2007 Report Posted March 9, 2007 <<I like the kettlebells. They are fun and different. But there is no inherent advantage in the kettlebell over a dumbbell or a swingbell that imparts skill or conditioning transfer. Kettlebells are trendy and yes, I've read most of the claims including testimonies from some good lifters.>> ***** I don't agree that ALL exercises that can be done with a kettlebell can be done with a dumbell, especially those exercises that require swings between the legs...due to the fact that dumbells are wider, I really cant see doing those with dbs (without seriously beating up all THREE legs On the other hand, there are a bunch of exercises in which you could replace the KB with the DB. The KB is trendy....and despite the claims of some of its proponents you can get serious injuries. Even though I took instruction in the KB, I seriously messed up my right elbow doing KB cleans. Seay Palo Alto, CA Quote
Guest guest Posted March 9, 2007 Report Posted March 9, 2007 I remember when Newsweek devoted some pages to Kettlebells, making outrageous claims like 'they' burn more fat and 'they' build more muscle. A trainer at my gym smiled and looked over at our pile of KB's and said " 'they' just sit there. " A tool doesn't do anything without the user, and no lump of iron in any shape has proven 'better' than any other yet. Chip Conrad Bodytribe Fitness Sacramento, CA www.physicalsubculture.com > > I had made a suggestion in an earlier post in discussions with Schaefer that the best assist work a power lifter or Olympic Lifter could do was working with Kettlebells. I have not heard back from and was just curious what the rest of the group thought. Does anyone in the group have any experience working with Kettlebells? > > Bill > West Chester, PA > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 9, 2007 Report Posted March 9, 2007 I'd have to disagree. You take a wider stance and swing the dumbbell. I've done it with 60# dbs. If you don't have the necessary motor skill to get a db through there you probably should be working on something other than kb swings. Seay wrote: > <<I like the kettlebells. They are fun and different. > But there is no > inherent advantage in the kettlebell over a dumbbell > or a swingbell that > imparts skill or conditioning transfer. Kettlebells > are trendy and yes, > I've read most of the claims including testimonies > from some good lifters.>> > > ***** > I don't agree that ALL exercises that can be done with > a kettlebell can be done with a dumbell, especially > those exercises that require swings between the > legs...due to the fact that dumbells are wider, I > really cant see doing those with dbs (without > seriously beating up all THREE legs : > > > -- Hobman Saskatoon, CANADA Quote
Guest guest Posted March 10, 2007 Report Posted March 10, 2007 , You beat me to it. I had the same thought. I have used a 100lb. Dumbbell with out a problem.. MOST any kettlebell exercise can be done with dumbbells. Train hard and smart! Damien CHiappini SPFS Pittsburgh, PA. Re: Kettlebells I'd have to disagree. You take a wider stance and swing the dumbbell. I've done it with 60# dbs. If you don't have the necessary motor skill to get a db through there you probably should be working on something other than kb swings. Seay wrote: > <<I like the kettlebells. They are fun and different. > But there is no > inherent advantage in the kettlebell over a dumbbell > or a swingbell that > imparts skill or conditioning transfer. Kettlebells > are trendy and yes, > I've read most of the claims including testimonies > from some good lifters.>> > > ***** > I don't agree that ALL exercises that can be done with > a kettlebell can be done with a dumbell, especially > those exercises that require swings between the > legs...due to the fact that dumbells are wider, I > really cant see doing those with dbs (without > seriously beating up all THREE legs : > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 10, 2007 Report Posted March 10, 2007 I cracked up at the beginning of this thread when wrote about the futility of " waving around Kettlebells " . I knew that would prompt some replies. I had been reading elsewhere about the controversy of Pavel's supposedly fabricated credentials and the exodus at Dragon Door. Such a simple device but you throw some money into the mix and suddenly it's Machiavelli's " The Prince " . Phrase never again to be spoken: " kettlebells are not a magic bullet " . As for swinging (waving?) a 60-pound dumbell repeatedly between my legs, I 'm not that coordinated on swing# 37, and I value all three legs. Roy Zornow New York City <snip>...due to the fact that dumbells are wider, I > really cant see doing those with dbs (without > seriously beating up all THREE legs </snip> Quote
Guest guest Posted March 11, 2007 Report Posted March 11, 2007 I have read (but not tried yet) an article by Chad Waterbery who wrapped a stout rope around a dumbbell and used that for swinging, but also for single arm snatches. The idea was that it made the dumbell behave a little more a kettlebell in that you have the weight at the end of a lever, it also helps with grip. Regards Nick Tatalias Johannesburg South Africa > > , > > You beat me to it. I had the same thought. I have used a 100lb. Dumbbell > with out a problem.. MOST any kettlebell exercise can be done with > dumbbells. > > Train hard and smart! > Damien CHiappini > SPFS > Pittsburgh, PA. > > Re: Kettlebells > > I'd have to disagree. You take a wider stance and swing the dumbbell. > I've done it with 60# dbs. If you don't have the necessary motor skill > to get a db through there you probably should be working on something > other than kb swings. > > Seay wrote: > > > <<I like the kettlebells. They are fun and different. > > But there is no > > inherent advantage in the kettlebell over a dumbbell > > or a swingbell that > > imparts skill or conditioning transfer. Kettlebells > > are trendy and yes, > > I've read most of the claims including testimonies > > from some good lifters.>> > > > > ***** > > I don't agree that ALL exercises that can be done with > > a kettlebell can be done with a dumbell, especially > > those exercises that require swings between the > > legs...due to the fact that dumbells are wider, I > > really cant see doing those with dbs (without > > seriously beating up all THREE legs : > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 11, 2007 Report Posted March 11, 2007 I have read (but not tried yet) an article by Chad Waterbery who wrapped a stout rope around a dumbbell and used that for swinging, but also for single arm snatches. The idea was that it made the dumbell behave a little more a kettlebell in that you have the weight at the end of a lever, it also helps with grip. Regards Nick Tatalias Johannesburg South Africa > > , > > You beat me to it. I had the same thought. I have used a 100lb. Dumbbell > with out a problem.. MOST any kettlebell exercise can be done with > dumbbells. > > Train hard and smart! > Damien CHiappini > SPFS > Pittsburgh, PA. > > Re: Kettlebells > > I'd have to disagree. You take a wider stance and swing the dumbbell. > I've done it with 60# dbs. If you don't have the necessary motor skill > to get a db through there you probably should be working on something > other than kb swings. > > Seay wrote: > > > <<I like the kettlebells. They are fun and different. > > But there is no > > inherent advantage in the kettlebell over a dumbbell > > or a swingbell that > > imparts skill or conditioning transfer. Kettlebells > > are trendy and yes, > > I've read most of the claims including testimonies > > from some good lifters.>> > > > > ***** > > I don't agree that ALL exercises that can be done with > > a kettlebell can be done with a dumbell, especially > > those exercises that require swings between the > > legs...due to the fact that dumbells are wider, I > > really cant see doing those with dbs (without > > seriously beating up all THREE legs : > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 12, 2007 Report Posted March 12, 2007 In a message dated 3/8/2007 3:14:41 P.M. Central Standard Time, highlander89982003@... writes: <<<<I had made a suggestion in an earlier post in discussions with Schaefer that the best assist work a power lifter or Olympic Lifter could do was working with Kettlebells. I have not heard back from and was just curious what the rest of the group thought. Does anyone in the group have any experience working with Kettlebells?>>>> **** Yes, I have some experience with kettlebells. I think they are tremendously fun, and if used correctly can positively impact performance in a wide variety of activities. I am not a certified kettlebell instructor right now, so will limit my comments to that. *grin* Besides, I prefer Clubbells. They scare the h*** out of the powerlifters and bodybuilders at my gym. Most of them can't even handle the 15 lb Clubbells. kson, CST, CMT Minneapolis, MN USA _www.ClubbellTrainer.com_ (http://www.clubbelltrainer.com/) " Better Living Through Movement. " " Be good to yourself. If you don't take care of your body, where will you live? " - Kobi Yamada Quote
Guest guest Posted March 13, 2007 Report Posted March 13, 2007 I here you about the Clubbells. I love them. I sold all my kettlebells to get them. I had a guy in the gym who can bench 400pds and he had problems with 25pd club, we had to drop down to the 15pd club. I love all the looks ). Lutan ***Please sign all letters to Supertraining with your full name, city and country.*** >From: ClubbellTrainer@... >Reply-To: Supertraining >To: Supertraining >Subject: Re: Kettlebells >Date: Tue, 13 Mar 2007 03:26:49 EDT > >In a message dated 3/8/2007 3:14:41 P.M. Central Standard Time, >highlander89982003@... writes: > ><<<<I had made a suggestion in an earlier post in discussions with >Schaefer that the best assist work a power lifter or Olympic Lifter could >do was >working with Kettlebells. I have not heard back from and was just >curious >what the rest of the group thought. Does anyone in the group have any >experience working with Kettlebells?>>>> > > >**** >Yes, I have some experience with kettlebells. I think they are >tremendously >fun, and if used correctly can positively impact performance in a wide >variety of activities. I am not a certified kettlebell instructor right >now, so >will limit my comments to that. > >*grin* Besides, I prefer Clubbells. They scare the h*** out of the >powerlifters and bodybuilders at my gym. Most of them can't even handle the >15 lb >Clubbells. > > kson, CST, CMT >Minneapolis, MN USA >_www.ClubbellTrainer.com_ (http://www.clubbelltrainer.com/) > > " Better Living Through Movement. " > > " Be good to yourself. If you don't take care of your body, where will you >live? " >- Kobi Yamada Quote
Guest guest Posted March 13, 2007 Report Posted March 13, 2007 The barbell squat, bench press, and dead lift are the WORK for a power-lifter. What I mean by assist work is something that does not comprise the actual lifts that you are competing in. You talk about reading the post carefully but never did I suggest that you should give up you primary lifts to use kettlebells or that keeping a kettlebell moving for thirty minutes would benefit you as a power-lifter. The original post what about combining strength training and cardio together. I said that I like to challenge myself with different things and that keeping a kettlebell moving for 30 minutes is one of the hardest things I have ever done. I have worked with athletes from high school to the professional level. Every athlete that I have incorporated two handed swings and snatches into their program have seen a quick jump of anywhere from 30lbs to 80lbs in their dead-lift and squat. I am not a kettlebell fanatic but have found that the speed, power and control needed to perform the exercises translates very well into a wide variety of sports. The most recent fad? They have been around for almost 300 years. As far as doing the same exercises with dumbbells. Yes, you can do some of them with dumbbells. Is it the same? No. I studied architecture before getting my degree in Exercise Physiology. If you place a weight at the end of a lever (your arm) and balance that weight evenly (dumbbell) the strength and stability require from that lever is not the same if the weight is extended farther from the end point of the lever and dynamicly moving (kettlebell). I will pay $1000.00 to anyone who can overhead press 32kg kettlebells starting with a neutral grip as many times as the can press 70lbs dumbells. I would also challenge anyone to press them once " bottoms up " . I have used chains, bands, sleds, plyo box jumps and everything else under the sun and love them all. I was just surprised by the quick and measurable results I, and the athletes I have trained, have received with kettlebells. I still think from experience that they are the best " Assist " work that a powerlifter could do. I am interested in hearing what other assist work the group would recomend for power-lifters and olympic lifters besides partials and front squats for olympic lifters. Bill West Chester =========================== Schaefer wrote: Thank you, , for reiterating the points I made originally and adding the OL perspective. As a general rule, persons who read the original posting and well, respond on topic will find I tend to respond back to them here quite promptly. The best assistance work for the powerlifts ARE THE POWERLIFTS. <grin>. The barbell squat, bench press, and deadlift, all are supplemental exercises to attain success in the lift and the other ones. A PL could survive in a gym with a bench, rack, and barbell/plates and chalk. Even dumbbells would not be " NECESSARY " . Why then would a kettlebell be " the best assistance " ? they, like many other objects we can play with, add spice but are not the meat and potatoes on which you build your size and strength overall. A lot of things can be fun, sure - and won't hurt your competition lifting. That being said, I do enjoy some " strongman " type moves, also the occasional OL dumbbell and barbell moves too, variation is fun for one thing. A far higher priority is more 25 kg plates where I lift most of the time....and more squat racks. Some more heavy duty PL bars... I don't see us buying more than 2 or 3 kettles or believing they're the end all and be all for our strength training here lol. Probably just a couple and selective moves to support a couple of sports...I don't see our PL giving up bp, sq, and dl and their variations to swing kettles as their primary assist work! I think some may find the handles more agreeable to their hands and that serves some purpose, yes, but there are handled plates, and handled weight balls too, again, it's a matter of personal preference. If you like a kettlebell and can afford to buy them, go ahead, it's what makes you happy lol. I'm not the Anti-(kettle) Belle..... I am the Anti whoopie cushion, wobbly board, and well, generally rehabbing healthy backs for no reason person though...an examination of the archives will readily prove that. <shrug> But to state as Mr. did to me originally that such a kettlebell waving for 30 minutes would be a superior cardio/strength workout for a competing POWERLIFTER to my suggestion of 5 sets of 10 moderately heavy DEADLIFT (60-80% of 1 rep max) performed with strict 3-5 minute rest interval between sets, followed by heavy farmer's walk for 3 full sets of whatever length you can manage before grip and wind fail you, THAT is what the original discussion was about. I suppose could try both workouts and report back if he's not involved in anything too serious at the moment <grin>. Mr. finds his 30 min of his 24 kg kettlebell waving to be superior for his needs as a rugby, ultimate fighter and highlands games person, but I would NEVER choose such a workout waving his 24 kg kettle for 30 min as my " best assistance ever " as a competing powerlifter, for many of the reasons both and I laid out previously. Success as a competing powerlifter without a kettlebell in my immediate vicinity for a decade pretty much tells me I don't have to use a kettlebell.... <grin>. Maybe they make good luck charms, wear 1 on a chain around my neck? <JUST KIDDING OK?> Mr. , thank you in future for your more careful reading of the previous postings, and I wish you well in your pursuits. I will stick to my " cardio " and strength workouts. They tend to build my strength, endurance, and my capacity for work, which then yields more strength...and should I wish to swing something, I'm sure I can find a nicely sized dumbbell around the gym....<grin>. I think generally I'd prefer to have dumbbells because they're very versatile and frankly people break stuff constantly where i lift... if you prefer kettlebells, I see no reason you couldn't use them. I just don't think that as the original argument stated, they are the " best assistance " above MANY other things for a competing powerlifter. Somehow I can hear someone suggesting the next fad will be the " dead cat " workout - where you swing roadkill for an hour and it yields 50% increases in your strength, yet it's environmentally friendly....<grin> and if you are lacking in roadkill in your location, how to construct sandbags correctly simulating the real thing...coupled with the notion that the wind resistance of an uneven object, and well, grip requirements of something kinda flattened make this superior to any existing gym equipment... Oh and bad news, kettlebell fans, the starlets in Hollywood are using them now (apparently to supplement their plastic surgery and implants..) according to the " women's fitness mags " now......which means you're not going to be well, hard core any more? JUST KIDDING <GRIN> Course you guys can argue they've made the " pink plastic kettle " version over there....plastic coated, very LIGHT kettles....now THOSE might make nice luck charms for the strength athlete....just like the cute lil plastic db's make good paperweights? Hey if someone sells that roadkill workout, remember, you heard it here first...and I want royalties! With frugality of investment in mind, chalk on hands, and my sense of humor at the many " implements " now touted as well, the latest and greatest.... The Phantom aka Schaefer, CMT, CSCS, competing powerlifter Denver, Colorado, USA Re: Kettlebells I have a couple of kettlebells and I've competed as both an olympic lifter and a powerlifter. I like the kettlebells. They are fun and different. But there is no inherent advantage in the kettlebell over a dumbbell or a swingbell that imparts skill or conditioning transfer. Kettlebells are trendy and yes, I've read most of the claims including testimonies from some good lifters. IMO to say that a kettlebell is _the best_ assistance is totally wrong. If you were to say that a kettlebell can be an effective assistance tool for some people at some time in their training than I would agree. But there is no best for every person for all time. Even given that... For olympic weightlifters the Bulgarians have proven that you don't need a lot of different assistance exercises to be successful as an olympic weightlifter. Certainly they don't use kettlebells. Abadzhiev eliminated virtually all assistance exercises where there wasn't a strong correlation between results in the classic lifts and the assistance and was left with power versions of the classic lifts and squats. In the training of most olympic weightlifters kettlebells simply do not give enough resistance or specificity to be a really usefull assistance tool. They are simply too light and the heavy ones are too awkward. Roman, the great Russian coach, and Verkhoshanskey (who wasn't a weightlifting coach per se, but certainly influenced the training of Russian weightlifters) listed jumps with the kettlebell as assistance if speed/strength is poor. But in terms of importance in their assistance exercise they would be of minimal value and there were other tools which could be used to the same purpose. Put another way - if the kettlebells weren't available in a Russian gym Roman or Verkhoshanskey wouldn't have missed a beat. and some other powerlifters have used kettlebells for some assistance, but once again. The best assitance? To my knowledge Ed Coan has never used a kettlebell and look at his performance. Sure, they can be used as assistance and have some purpose, but there are not 'the best' or even essential. If you don't have a kettlebell a dumbbell can be used for virtually every exercise and the only sport where you would notice a functional difference is kettlebell lifting! Specificity rules! I'm willing to bet that our late mentor, Dr. Siff, would have included a section in his 'Facts and Fallacies' book addressing the kettlebell and the really outrageous claims being made for their effectiveness. Once again - there is nothing wrong with a kettlebell and I have no problems with people who are marketing the kettlebells so effectively. For the typical person the best fitness tool is the one they use. I have included kettlebells in some training programs I have developed for wrestlers if they were available. I have nothing against kettlebells. But as a kinesiologist saying the kettlebell is the important thing is as much a fallacy as saying 'train the muscles'. For sports performance you don't train muscles - you train movement. Movement is trained through various strength, speed and endurance exercises. There is virtually no sporting movement that you can train for those characteristics that I can't train just as effectively using some other device. There is no magic in the device. There is no magic bullet and kettlebells certainly are not the magic bullet. Hobman Saskatoon, CANADA Quote
Guest guest Posted March 14, 2007 Report Posted March 14, 2007 Personal experience only, but I prefer overhead pressing a KB to a DB, and, hence, might be able to take you up on your bet simply through practice and preference. Part of the reason is my other preference of cleaning a KB versus a DB, hence getting the weight into position is easier. So I do it more. There's a great pic floating around the internet of Mike Mahler bottoms up pressing a KB over 100 pounds. (I bottom-upped my first 32K recently, one hand only). So many toys, so little time. Chip Conrad Bodytribe Fitness Sacramento, CA www.physicalsubculture.com > > The barbell squat, bench press, and dead lift are the WORK for a power-lifter. What I mean by assist work is something that does not comprise the actual lifts that you are competing in. You talk about reading the post carefully but never did I suggest that you should give up you primary lifts to use kettlebells or that keeping a kettlebell moving for thirty minutes would benefit you as a power- lifter. The original post what about combining strength training and cardio together. I said that I like to challenge myself with different things and that keeping a kettlebell moving for 30 minutes is one of the hardest things I have ever done. > > I have worked with athletes from high school to the professional level. Every athlete that I have incorporated two handed swings and snatches into their program have seen a quick jump of anywhere from 30lbs to 80lbs in their dead-lift and squat. I am not a kettlebell fanatic but have found that the speed, power and control needed to perform the exercises translates very well into a wide variety of sports. > > The most recent fad? They have been around for almost 300 years. As far as doing the same exercises with dumbbells. Yes, you can do some of them with dumbbells. Is it the same? No. I studied architecture before getting my degree in Exercise Physiology. If you place a weight at the end of a lever (your arm) and balance that weight evenly (dumbbell) the strength and stability require from that lever is not the same if the weight is extended farther from the end point of the lever and dynamicly moving (kettlebell). I will pay $1000.00 to anyone who can overhead press 32kg kettlebells starting with a neutral grip as many times as the can press 70lbs dumbells. I would also challenge anyone to press them once " bottoms up " . > > I have used chains, bands, sleds, plyo box jumps and everything else under the sun and love them all. I was just surprised by the quick and measurable results I, and the athletes I have trained, have received with kettlebells. I still think from experience that they are the best " Assist " work that a powerlifter could do. I am interested in hearing what other assist work the group would recomend for power-lifters and olympic lifters besides partials and front squats for olympic lifters. > > Bill > West Chester > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 14, 2007 Report Posted March 14, 2007 For an olympic lifter I'd recommend front squats, power versions, hi-pulls and pulls from the hang as assistance. Bill wrote: > The barbell squat, bench press, and dead lift are the WORK for a > power-lifter. What I mean by assist work is something that does not > comprise the actual lifts that you are competing in. You talk about > reading the post carefully but never did I suggest that you should > give up you primary lifts to use kettlebells or that keeping a > kettlebell moving for thirty minutes would benefit you as a > power-lifter. The original post what about combining strength training > and cardio together. I said that I like to challenge myself with > different things and that keeping a kettlebell moving for 30 minutes > is one of the hardest things I have ever done. > > I have worked with athletes from high school to the professional > level. Every athlete that I have incorporated two handed swings and > snatches into their program have seen a quick jump of anywhere from > 30lbs to 80lbs in their dead-lift and squat. I am not a kettlebell > fanatic but have found that the speed, power and control needed to > perform the exercises translates very well into a wide variety of sports. > > The most recent fad? They have been around for almost 300 years. As > far as doing the same exercises with dumbbells. Yes, you can do some > of them with dumbbells. Is it the same? No. I studied architecture > before getting my degree in Exercise Physiology. If you place a weight > at the end of a lever (your arm) and balance that weight evenly > (dumbbell) the strength and stability require from that lever is not > the same if the weight is extended farther from the end point of the > lever and dynamicly moving (kettlebell). I will pay $1000.00 to anyone > who can overhead press 32kg kettlebells starting with a neutral grip > as many times as the can press 70lbs dumbells. I would also challenge > anyone to press them once " bottoms up " . > > I have used chains, bands, sleds, plyo box jumps and everything else > under the sun and love them all. I was just surprised by the quick and > measurable results I, and the athletes I have trained, have received > with kettlebells. I still think from experience that they are the best > " Assist " work that a powerlifter could do. I am interested in hearing > what other assist work the group would recomend for power-lifters and > olympic lifters besides partials and front squats for olympic lifters. > > Bill > West Chester -- Hobman Saskatoon, CANADA Quote
Guest guest Posted March 14, 2007 Report Posted March 14, 2007 Bill, Kettle Bells have their place in one's training tool box of exercises. However, catagorizing them or anything else as " the best " assistance exercise for powerlifters is absurd. The best axuiliary exercise is the one that addresses the athlete's weakness. 's statement that " The best assistance exercises for the power lifts ARE THE POWERLIFTS... " is an oxymoron. The powwerlifts, especially for , are the primary exercises. An assistance exercise is a specialized exercise used to aid the primary exercise in the development of strength. Hobman nailed it with his reply " ...- if the kettlebells weren't available in a Russian gym Roman or Verkhoshanskey wouldn't have missed a beat. The best assitance? To my knowledge Ed Coan has never used a kettlebell and look at his performance. " Kenny Croxdale Orange, CA Re: Kettlebells The barbell squat, bench press, and dead lift are the WORK for a power-lifter. What I mean by assist work is something that does not comprise the actual lifts that you are competing in. You talk about reading the post carefully but never did I suggest that you should give up you primary lifts to use kettlebells or that keeping a kettlebell moving for thirty minutes would benefit you as a power-lifter. The original post what about combining strength training and cardio together. I said that I like to challenge myself with different things and that keeping a kettlebell moving for 30 minutes is one of the hardest things I have ever done. I have worked with athletes from high school to the professional level. Every athlete that I have incorporated two handed swings and snatches into their program have seen a quick jump of anywhere from 30lbs to 80lbs in their dead-lift and squat. I am not a kettlebell fanatic but have found that the speed, power and control needed to perform the exercises translates very well into a wide variety of sports. The most recent fad? They have been around for almost 300 years. As far as doing the same exercises with dumbbells. Yes, you can do some of them with dumbbells. Is it the same? No. I studied architecture before getting my degree in Exercise Physiology. If you place a weight at the end of a lever (your arm) and balance that weight evenly (dumbbell) the strength and stability require from that lever is not the same if the weight is extended farther from the end point of the lever and dynamicly moving (kettlebell). I will pay $1000.00 to anyone who can overhead press 32kg kettlebells starting with a neutral grip as many times as the can press 70lbs dumbells. I would also challenge anyone to press them once " bottoms up " . I have used chains, bands, sleds, plyo box jumps and everything else under the sun and love them all. I was just surprised by the quick and measurable results I, and the athletes I have trained, have received with kettlebells. I still think from experience that they are the best " Assist " work that a powerlifter could do. I am interested in hearing what other assist work the group would recomend for power-lifters and olympic lifters besides partials and front squats for olympic lifters. Bill West Chester Quote
Guest guest Posted March 14, 2007 Report Posted March 14, 2007 Ok Kenny - Let's take a look at this one more time. <sigh> And then I am most assuredly not posting to this thread again. I have a bench press specialist. He does NOT compete the full meet. Thus he does NOT do the squat and the deadlift. That is, UNTIL he was asked to, and his bench press then IMPROVED. Why is that? Because the assistance work I do for my bench includes my squat and deadlift, as well as other things. The powerlifts are not JUST what you compete, but assistance work to AID THE OTHER LIFTS. Thus they serve TWO purposes for the powerlifter! put on his list of assistance work for OL the power versions of the OL lifts. This means that his CLEANs and his SNATCHES, while being WHAT HE COMPETES, are ALSO PART OF ASSISTANCE WORK. Therefore this is NOT an oxymoron but a FACT. Why else would Westside do a zillion variations of the bench press, the squat, and some deadlift ones? Because the BEST assistance work is the other powerlifts....they complement each other! When I plan to compete a single lift (deadlift only) competition, and am NOT going to do squat or bench press in a meet, I INTENTIONALLY take my squat and my bench press to approximately 75% of their maxes in cycle WITH MY DEADLIFT PEAK OUT. Why is this? Because my squat and my bench press ARE part of the Assist WORK for my DEADLIFT. Yes, they are EVENTS I compete - but they are also Assistance work performed for the OTHER events. The deadlift has been described by some as " 1/3 of a back squat " with regard to the extension of hips and knees and straightening up. Why then would the back squat NOT be assistance work FOR THIS VERY MOVEMENT? In converse, the deadlift resembles a squat LOCKOUT. Why then would the deadlift NOT be assistance work FOR THIS MOVEMENT? The bench press builds core power, some leg drive (particularly the arching one I do) and yes, upper body strength in support of both the deadlift and the squat as well.... and the deadlift certainly enhances the bench press, especially if your grip is in fairly close and you may be actually relying on BACK power to lock your bench out! Working on deadlift would assist the bench in that fashion, and I could not sufficiently HOLD a bench arch until my DL was strong enough!! working the squat helps you hold your legs tight and push through your heels to lockout too! I am in agreement with the posters who has suggested that Mr 's idea that kettlebells are the best assistance work for EVERYTHING, and in particular PL events, is not correct. I still think if he enjoys them, and anybody else likes them, feel free to use them. But it's a matter of losing sight of the end result in my opinion to take a narrow view that they are the end all and be all, seeing as they haven't been around since say, people started picking up rocks to move them around and train... By your own definition of assistance exercise, I maintain that the powerlifts are the first choice for me in assistance work FOR THE POWERLIFTS. Assistance work is not ONLY for aiding the primary exercise in the development of strength, BUT also to help strengthen weak points you may have. The squat, bench press and deadlift do a FINE job for each other in helping work the weaker spots you may have in the other lifts! The Phantom aka Schaefer, CMT, CSCS, competing powerlifter Denver, Colorado, USA Re: Kettlebells The barbell squat, bench press, and dead lift are the WORK for a power-lifter. What I mean by assist work is something that does not comprise the actual lifts that you are competing in. You talk about reading the post carefully but never did I suggest that you should give up you primary lifts to use kettlebells or that keeping a kettlebell moving for thirty minutes would benefit you as a power-lifter. The original post what about combining strength training and cardio together. I said that I like to challenge myself with different things and that keeping a kettlebell moving for 30 minutes is one of the hardest things I have ever done. I have worked with athletes from high school to the professional level. Every athlete that I have incorporated two handed swings and snatches into their program have seen a quick jump of anywhere from 30lbs to 80lbs in their dead-lift and squat. I am not a kettlebell fanatic but have found that the speed, power and control needed to perform the exercises translates very well into a wide variety of sports. The most recent fad? They have been around for almost 300 years. As far as doing the same exercises with dumbbells. Yes, you can do some of them with dumbbells. Is it the same? No. I studied architecture before getting my degree in Exercise Physiology. If you place a weight at the end of a lever (your arm) and balance that weight evenly (dumbbell) the strength and stability require from that lever is not the same if the weight is extended farther from the end point of the lever and dynamicly moving (kettlebell). I will pay $1000.00 to anyone who can overhead press 32kg kettlebells starting with a neutral grip as many times as the can press 70lbs dumbells. I would also challenge anyone to press them once " bottoms up " . I have used chains, bands, sleds, plyo box jumps and everything else under the sun and love them all. I was just surprised by the quick and measurable results I, and the athletes I have trained, have received with kettlebells. I still think from experience that they are the best " Assist " work that a powerlifter could do. I am interested in hearing what other assist work the group would recomend for power-lifters and olympic lifters besides partials and front squats for olympic lifters. Bill West Chester ======================= Quote
Guest guest Posted March 14, 2007 Report Posted March 14, 2007 A nice extract from the Mel: " " One has to distinguish between technique of competitive movements and technique of noncompetitive or supplementary movements. In the competitive case, the effective acquisition of competitive skills relies on precise repetition and specificity of movement patterns. Here it is vital that the movements become as automatic and efficient as possible through frequent repetition of the same patterns. For each individual, there is an optimum spatio-temporal pattern of muscular contraction, joint motion, momentum transfer and elastic energy utilization for maximizing performance. Slight, occasional variations of grip, foot spacing, joint angle and so on are used to enhance technical expertise and safety, particularly in the case of the novice. In noncompetitive cases, variations are used to provide progressive neuromuscular overload to condition the musculoskeletal system as extensively as possible. This can improve the nonspecific aspects of strength, speed, flexibility and physjcal structure and thereby optimize the balance between mobility and stability. As far as I am aware, there is no research that shows categorically that variations even as frequent as from one set or repetition to the next are detrimental to overall conditioning within the context of noncompetitive exercise, provided basic safety roles are observed. In fad, brain research indicates that regular imposition of novel, challenging tasks can enhance the richness of neural interconnections. Variations in movement patterns, therefore, arrear to contribute to physical and mental development. Generally, variation may be used to stimulate one through a physical or psychological barrier. " " ================== ===================== Carruthers Wakefield, UK > > > The barbell squat, bench press, and dead lift are the WORK for a > > power-lifter. What I mean by assist work is something that does not > > comprise the actual lifts that you are competing in. You talk about > > reading the post carefully but never did I suggest that you should > > give up you primary lifts to use kettlebells or that keeping a > > kettlebell moving for thirty minutes would benefit you as a > > power-lifter. The original post what about combining strength training > > and cardio together. I said that I like to challenge myself with > > different things and that keeping a kettlebell moving for 30 minutes > > is one of the hardest things I have ever done. > > > > I have worked with athletes from high school to the professional > > level. Every athlete that I have incorporated two handed swings and > > snatches into their program have seen a quick jump of anywhere from > > 30lbs to 80lbs in their dead-lift and squat. I am not a kettlebell > > fanatic but have found that the speed, power and control needed to > > perform the exercises translates very well into a wide variety of sports. > > > > The most recent fad? They have been around for almost 300 years. As > > far as doing the same exercises with dumbbells. Yes, you can do some > > of them with dumbbells. Is it the same? No. I studied architecture > > before getting my degree in Exercise Physiology. If you place a weight > > at the end of a lever (your arm) and balance that weight evenly > > (dumbbell) the strength and stability require from that lever is not > > the same if the weight is extended farther from the end point of the > > lever and dynamicly moving (kettlebell). I will pay $1000.00 to anyone > > who can overhead press 32kg kettlebells starting with a neutral grip > > as many times as the can press 70lbs dumbells. I would also challenge > > anyone to press them once " bottoms up " . > > > > I have used chains, bands, sleds, plyo box jumps and everything else > > under the sun and love them all. I was just surprised by the quick and > > measurable results I, and the athletes I have trained, have received > > with kettlebells. I still think from experience that they are the best > > " Assist " work that a powerlifter could do. I am interested in hearing > > what other assist work the group would recomend for power-lifters and > > olympic lifters besides partials and front squats for olympic lifters. > > > > Bill > > West Chester > > > -- > Hobman > Saskatoon, CANADA > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 14, 2007 Report Posted March 14, 2007 , Perfoming variations the squat, bench press and deadlift are the not same as performing the lift itself. Certainly, the best movements are those which mimic the lift closely. That is why Westside utilizes a variety types of squatting such as front squats, belt squats, safety squats. The same applies to for the bench press and deadlift. With that said, these auxiliary exercises are NOT the powerlifts in and of themselves. Thus the term auxiliary exercises. Calling the bench press an auxiliary exercise for the squat and deadlift, talk about stretching things! Quarter squats do more for the deadlift than a squat. Kenny Croxdale, CSCS, competitive powerlifter, etc... Orange, CA ======================== Re: Kettlebells Ok Kenny - Let's take a look at this one more time. <sigh> And then I am most assuredly not posting to this thread again. I have a bench press specialist. He does NOT compete the full meet. Thus he does NOT do the squat and the deadlift. That is, UNTIL he was asked to, and his bench press then IMPROVED. Why is that? Because the assistance work I do for my bench includes my squat and deadlift, as well as other things. The powerlifts are not JUST what you compete, but assistance work to AID THE OTHER LIFTS. Thus they serve TWO purposes for the powerlifter! put on his list of assistance work for OL the power versions of the OL lifts. This means that his CLEANs and his SNATCHES, while being WHAT HE COMPETES, are ALSO PART OF ASSISTANCE WORK. Therefore this is NOT an oxymoron but a FACT. Why else would Westside do a zillion variations of the bench press, the squat, and some deadlift ones? Because the BEST assistance work is the other powerlifts....they complement each other! When I plan to compete a single lift (deadlift only) competition, and am NOT going to do squat or bench press in a meet, I INTENTIONALLY take my squat and my bench press to approximately 75% of their maxes in cycle WITH MY DEADLIFT PEAK OUT. Why is this? Because my squat and my bench press ARE part of the Assist WORK for my DEADLIFT. Yes, they are EVENTS I compete - but they are also Assistance work performed for the OTHER events. The deadlift has been described by some as " 1/3 of a back squat " with regard to the extension of hips and knees and straightening up. Why then would the back squat NOT be assistance work FOR THIS VERY MOVEMENT? In converse, the deadlift resembles a squat LOCKOUT. Why then would the deadlift NOT be assistance work FOR THIS MOVEMENT? The bench press builds core power, some leg drive (particularly the arching one I do) and yes, upper body strength in support of both the deadlift and the squat as well.... and the deadlift certainly enhances the bench press, especially if your grip is in fairly close and you may be actually relying on BACK power to lock your bench out! Working on deadlift would assist the bench in that fashion, and I could not sufficiently HOLD a bench arch until my DL was strong enough!! working the squat helps you hold your legs tight and push through your heels to lockout too! I am in agreement with the posters who has suggested that Mr 's idea that kettlebells are the best assistance work for EVERYTHING, and in particular PL events, is not correct. I still think if he enjoys them, and anybody else likes them, feel free to use them. But it's a matter of losing sight of the end result in my opinion to take a narrow view that they are the end all and be all, seeing as they haven't been around since say, people started picking up rocks to move them around and train... By your own definition of assistance exercise, I maintain that the powerlifts are the first choice for me in assistance work FOR THE POWERLIFTS. Assistance work is not ONLY for aiding the primary exercise in the development of strength, BUT also to help strengthen weak points you may have. The squat, bench press and deadlift do a FINE job for each other in helping work the weaker spots you may have in the other lifts! The Phantom aka Schaefer, CMT, CSCS, competing powerlifter Denver, Colorado, USA =================== Quote
Guest guest Posted March 14, 2007 Report Posted March 14, 2007 , you are the only person I know who can actually YELL in print! Pretty cool. Keep up the good work. Lee Robillard Mississauga Ontario, Canada ====================== Schaefer wrote: Ok Kenny - Let's take a look at this one more time. <sigh> And then I am most assuredly not posting to this thread again. I have a bench press specialist. He does NOT compete the full meet. Thus he does NOT do the squat and the deadlift. That is, UNTIL he was asked to, and his bench press then IMPROVED. Why is that? Because the assistance work I do for my bench includes my squat and deadlift, as well as other things. The powerlifts are not JUST what you compete, but assistance work to AID THE OTHER LIFTS. Thus they serve TWO purposes for the powerlifter! put on his list of assistance work for OL the power versions of the OL lifts. This means that his CLEANs and his SNATCHES, while being WHAT HE COMPETES, are ALSO PART OF ASSISTANCE WORK. Therefore this is NOT an oxymoron but a FACT. Why else would Westside do a zillion variations of the bench press, the squat, and some deadlift ones? Because the BEST assistance work is the other powerlifts....they complement each other! When I plan to compete a single lift (deadlift only) competition, and am NOT going to do squat or bench press in a meet, I INTENTIONALLY take my squat and my bench press to approximately 75% of their maxes in cycle WITH MY DEADLIFT PEAK OUT. Why is this? Because my squat and my bench press ARE part of the Assist WORK for my DEADLIFT. Yes, they are EVENTS I compete - but they are also Assistance work performed for the OTHER events. The deadlift has been described by some as " 1/3 of a back squat " with regard to the extension of hips and knees and straightening up. Why then would the back squat NOT be assistance work FOR THIS VERY MOVEMENT? In converse, the deadlift resembles a squat LOCKOUT. Why then would the deadlift NOT be assistance work FOR THIS MOVEMENT? The bench press builds core power, some leg drive (particularly the arching one I do) and yes, upper body strength in support of both the deadlift and the squat as well.... and the deadlift certainly enhances the bench press, especially if your grip is in fairly close and you may be actually relying on BACK power to lock your bench out! Working on deadlift would assist the bench in that fashion, and I could not sufficiently HOLD a bench arch until my DL was strong enough!! working the squat helps you hold your legs tight and push through your heels to lockout too! I am in agreement with the posters who has suggested that Mr 's idea that kettlebells are the best assistance work for EVERYTHING, and in particular PL events, is not correct. I still think if he enjoys them, and anybody else likes them, feel free to use them. But it's a matter of losing sight of the end result in my opinion to take a narrow view that they are the end all and be all, seeing as they haven't been around since say, people started picking up rocks to move them around and train... By your own definition of assistance exercise, I maintain that the powerlifts are the first choice for me in assistance work FOR THE POWERLIFTS. Assistance work is not ONLY for aiding the primary exercise in the development of strength, BUT also to help strengthen weak points you may have. The squat, bench press and deadlift do a FINE job for each other in helping work the weaker spots you may have in the other lifts! The Phantom aka Schaefer, CMT, CSCS, competing powerlifter Denver, Colorado, USA Quote
Guest guest Posted March 14, 2007 Report Posted March 14, 2007 Kettlebells are harder to lift than dumbbells because of their shape. That means if you are competing in kettlebell lifting, you need to practice with kettlebells. That does not mean there is anything special about kettlebells. Just because a lift is harder does not necessarily mean it is better. It is also harder to overhead press two dumbbells while kneeling on a Swiss ball than it is to overhead press a barbell with your feet firmly planted on a stable lifting surface. That doesn't mean that the Swiss ball lift is anything other than the latest fad with a higher risk of injury. Other than the anecdotal stories from the proponents of these awkward lifting environments, is there any scientific proof that this type of lifting is superior to traditional lifting when the goal is to increase the amount of weight that can be lifted off of a stable platform or bench? Jon Haddan Irvine Quote
Guest guest Posted March 14, 2007 Report Posted March 14, 2007 Kettlebells are harder to lift than dumbbells because of their shape. That means if you are competing in kettlebell lifting, you need to practice with kettlebells. That does not mean there is anything special about kettlebells. Just because a lift is harder does not necessarily mean it is better. It is also harder to overhead press two dumbbells while kneeling on a Swiss ball than it is to overhead press a barbell with your feet firmly planted on a stable lifting surface. That doesn't mean that the Swiss ball lift is anything other than the latest fad with a higher risk of injury. Other than the anecdotal stories from the proponents of these awkward lifting environments, is there any scientific proof that this type of lifting is superior to traditional lifting when the goal is to increase the amount of weight that can be lifted off of a stable platform or bench? Jon Haddan Irvine Quote
Guest guest Posted March 15, 2007 Report Posted March 15, 2007 > > Kettlebells are harder to lift than dumbbells because > of their shape. That means if you are competing in > kettlebell lifting, you need to practice with > kettlebells. That does not mean there is anything > special about kettlebells. > > Just because a lift is harder does not necessarily > mean it is better. It is also harder to overhead > press two dumbbells while kneeling on a Swiss ball > than it is to overhead press a barbell with your feet > firmly planted on a stable lifting surface. That > doesn't mean that the Swiss ball lift is anything > other than the latest fad with a higher risk of > injury. > > Other than the anecdotal stories from the proponents > of these awkward lifting environments, is there any > scientific proof that this type of lifting is superior > to traditional lifting when the goal is to increase > the amount of weight that can be lifted off of a > stable platform or bench? NO! Kettlebells are just a tool to be utilised, the same as any other (Dumbells, sandbags etc). Anyone who says differently is either selling something or already been sold. They add variety and a new twist but nothing more. Morrey Staffordshire UK Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.