Guest guest Posted August 30, 2010 Report Posted August 30, 2010 I have trouble wading through scientific data- especially on a computer screen!!! Looking at some of that research though, the first thing that hits me is "joint angles". The trained subjects at various joint angles to build full range strength. The Bullworker does an awful job at allowing you to work through various angles. I believe the Bullworker is very limiting for getting the best results possible. Re: Bullworker Research. Jerrold Petrofsky has done a rather consierable amount of research in the area of isometrics:Here are two links to two of his published findings:http://www.jarcet.com/articles/Vol6Iss4/Petrofsky.pdfhttp://www.jarcet.com/articles/Vol7Iss1/Petrofsky.pdf--- In bullworkerclub , "edward" wrote:>> > > > > > >> > > > I have been trying to find interesting references to Bullworker on the net for the best part of a year now.I use the equipment and want to find out as much as I can about it,history,pros and cons, variant models and knock-offs,old advertising material,who has used it,opinions and prejudice etc and just about anything else you can think of.> > > > > > > > What a task I have set myself.Plenty of references,mostly commercial,a handful of pictures and old ads{interesting in themselves},a book about training with The Bullworker{which looks worth looking into} and endless adverts for Bully-Extreme.> > > > > > > > One of the most famous exercisers for decades and so little written about it cumulatively.ly I find this intensely frustrating.Has anyone one else found this?> > > >> > > Yes, it is frustrating. I've been interested in this myself over the years, and I haven't found much conclusive stuff either supporting or refuting Hettinger & Mueller's original studies -- resulting in the birth of the Bullworker.> > > > > > I'd love to see a study in which forms of exercise were compared. 1 group exercises conventionally with free weights, another with machines, another with the Bullworker - isometrically and another group uses the Bullworker a la -- isotonically.> > > > > > We are too often reduced to distilling anecdotal info -- including some really impressive success stories -- and attempt to measure the success of the Bullworker. > > > > > > Previous posts did show some isometric vs. Isotonic studies, but nothing that I'm aware of that focuses on the Bullworker. > > > > > > Please post if you come across any formal research!> > > Thanks> > >> >Thank you everyone who has responded to this topic.For a while I thought no one would.If anyone who has already responded has anything further to say it would be welcome.If anyone who has not and would like to add something-please do.Once again thank you.Ed> Quote
Guest guest Posted August 30, 2010 Report Posted August 30, 2010 > I have trouble wading through scientific data- especially on a computer > screen!!! > Looking at some of that research though, the first thing that hits me is > " joint angles " . The trained subjects at various joint angles to build > full range strength. The Bullworker does an awful job at allowing you to > work through various angles. I believe the Bullworker is very limiting > for getting the best results possible. I don't think so. The X5 has 4 straps thus enabling many different joint angles. ATB -- Sent from my computer as I don't have a Blackberry. Quote
Guest guest Posted August 30, 2010 Report Posted August 30, 2010 Thanks Marco.An interesting read although from time to time stating the absolutely obvious{nothing new in scientific papers of some sorts}.I cannot help be sceptical about some results real world applications such as the notion that isometrics are-superior to dynamic as a strength training modality.Perhaps a lot of weight lifters should be told that.Has for example an isometric only protocol produced any champion weight lifters in either Olympic or powerlifting?Before anyone says I am quite aware that old time strong men used heavy support work{that was isometric as weight held without movement having been raised} as an aid to developing tremendous strength.However they trained with movements also. Whammer your point also seems good about the bit that stands out for you.Joint angles.Bullworkers seem to provide most resistance when either at the fully contracted position{for each individual} or approaching it. I shall continue to use my Bullworkers as most of us.I have just never believed the hype about it. > > > > > > > > > > I have been trying to find interesting references to Bullworker on the net for the best part of a year now.I use the equipment and want to find out as much as I can about it,history,pros and cons, variant models and knock-offs,old advertising material,who has used it,opinions and prejudice etc and just about anything else you can think of. > > > > > > > > > > What a task I have set myself.Plenty of references,mostly commercial,a handful of pictures and old ads{interesting in themselves},a book about training with The Bullworker{which looks worth looking into} and endless adverts for Bully-Extreme. > > > > > > > > > > One of the most famous exercisers for decades and so little written about it cumulatively.ly I find this intensely frustrating.Has anyone one else found this? > > > > > > > > > Yes, it is frustrating. I've been interested in this myself over the years, and I haven't found much conclusive stuff either supporting or refuting Hettinger & Mueller's original studies -- resulting in the birth of the Bullworker. > > > > > > > > I'd love to see a study in which forms of exercise were compared. 1 group exercises conventionally with free weights, another with machines, another with the Bullworker - isometrically and another group uses the Bullworker a la -- isotonically. > > > > > > > > We are too often reduced to distilling anecdotal info -- including some really impressive success stories -- and attempt to measure the success of the Bullworker. > > > > > > > > Previous posts did show some isometric vs. Isotonic studies, but nothing that I'm aware of that focuses on the Bullworker. > > > > > > > > Please post if you come across any formal research! > > > > Thanks > > > > > > >Thank you everyone who has responded to this topic.For a while I thought no one would.If anyone who has already responded has anything further to say it would be welcome.If anyone who has not and would like to add something-please do.Once again thank you.Ed > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 30, 2010 Report Posted August 30, 2010 > > > I have trouble wading through scientific data- especially on a computer > > screen!!! > > Looking at some of that research though, the first thing that hits me is > > " joint angles " . The trained subjects at various joint angles to build > > full range strength. The Bullworker does an awful job at allowing you to > > work through various angles. I believe the Bullworker is very limiting > > for getting the best results possible. > > I don't think so. The X5 has 4 straps thus enabling many different joint > angles. > > ATB > > > -- > Sent from my computer as I don't have a Blackberry. > I have not thought through this carefully so my remarks are off the cuff here.If the X5{confessedly my least favourite Bullworker} allows joint angles the isometric contraction would be quite different at each position and quite weak at some.If you contrast this with the well known alternative arm self resisted isometric curl{done at different joint angles}I can resist with something like equal force in multi-postions. Quote
Guest guest Posted August 30, 2010 Report Posted August 30, 2010 Not really. The straps don't help all that much. Re: Re: Bullworker Research. > I have trouble wading through scientific data- especially on a computer> screen!!!> Looking at some of that research though, the first thing that hits me is> "joint angles". The trained subjects at various joint angles to build> full range strength. The Bullworker does an awful job at allowing you to> work through various angles. I believe the Bullworker is very limiting> for getting the best results possible.I don't think so. The X5 has 4 straps thus enabling many different joint angles.ATB-- Sent from my computer as I don't have a Blackberry. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.