Guest guest Posted February 20, 2008 Report Posted February 20, 2008 , I personally don't care for the term "toxic mold". The poor term has gotten a really bad rap and is now equated with mass hysteria. US Chamber.."thus the notion that toxic mold is an insidious secret killer"...run! US Toxic Mold Safety and Protection Act...run! Toxic Mold takes over Dripping Springs Mansion...run! Ed McMann's dog dead from Toxic Mold...run! I think the term of "toxigenic mold" is better. tox·i·gen·ic /ˌtɒksɪˈdʒɛnɪk/ Pronunciation Key - Show Spelled Pronunciation[tok-si-jen-ik] Pronunciation Key - Show IPA Pronunciation –adjective (esp. of microorganisms) producing toxins. Just my two cents. Sharon Group, Lately for some reason, I have been asked to interpret the phrase 'toxic mold' . Some want to use it, others not. For many years now I have been one to avoid the use of the term toxic. Some are arguing that since the word toxic is often defined as meaning poisonous then just about any health effect can/should be categorized using the generic term toxic. Others argue that cytotoxic effects and/or mycotoxins must actually be present (or at least a known risk) to use the word toxic. I have tried to find references that state the negative. In other words, which particular mold is not toxic (e.g., under any circumstances). What I find is a lot of policy language. Most of you know I understand the big picture, and I have understanding of some specifics. But these questions are forcing me (us) to define better the application of the word toxic. E.g., as an IH, I understand for instance that many chemicals have toxic irritant effects (i.e., corrosive; as opposed to a purely physical irritant, like sand in your bathing suit). We know mold produces many VOC's, some of which have toxic irritant effects, hence the mold-produced V"OC's are toxic by definition. This is not to imply that the actual concentration is sufficient to cause actual irritation effects. Which then raises the issue, if the chemical is never of sufficient concentration (dose) but is a known toxin at higher levels, must the word toxic be applied? In the spirit of the precautionary principle, if one is to be honest and open with the public, the answer might be that mold that produces VOC's ought to be termed toxic. I know about the 2004 CDC caveat for the term, toxic mold, i.e., that it's the mycotoxins that are toxic not the mold. This, after several readings, is beginning to sound a little too much like bureaucratic spin. They have split hairs because of the syntax, not because it is easy to separate the toxin from the physical mold. If the toxin is on the mold, isn't the mold toxic? These are just some of the issues that are being raised in my discussions. I know that several of you have very well-defined opinions on both sides of the toxic issue. I welcome them, both here and in private (healthyhouseaol). I look forward to all your comments and references to support them. Delicious ideas to please the pickiest eaters. Watch the video on AOL Living. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 20, 2008 Report Posted February 20, 2008 : Trying to define/interpret the phase “toxic mold” is analogous to defining/interpreting the phrase “toxic plants.” Stay away from the idea that you are trying to define/interpret the phrase “toxic chemical” (which I believe the layperson understands) and you should do real well. Other similarities......toxic animals, toxic people, toxic societies......and the list goes on. Group, Lately for some reason, I have been asked to interpret the phrase 'toxic mold' . Some want to use it, others not. For many years now I have been one to avoid the use of the term toxic. Some are arguing that since the word toxic is often defined as meaning poisonous then just about any health effect can/should be categorized using the generic term toxic. Others argue that cytotoxic effects and/or mycotoxins must actually be present (or at least a known risk) to use the word toxic. I have tried to find references that state the negative. In other words, which particular mold is not toxic (e.g., under any circumstances). What I find is a lot of policy language. Most of you know I understand the big picture, and I have understanding of some specifics. But these questions are forcing me (us) to define better the application of the word toxic. E.g., as an IH, I understand for instance that many chemicals have toxic irritant effects (i.e., corrosive; as opposed to a purely physical irritant, like sand in your bathing suit). We know mold produces many VOC's, some of which have toxic irritant effects, hence the mold-produced V " OC's are toxic by definition. This is not to imply that the actual concentration is sufficient to cause actual irritation effects. Which then raises the issue, if the chemical is never of sufficient concentration (dose) but is a known toxin at higher levels, must the word toxic be applied? In the spirit of the precautionary principle, if one is to be honest and open with the public, the answer might be that mold that produces VOC's ought to be termed toxic. I know about the 2004 CDC caveat for the term, toxic mold, i.e., that it's the mycotoxins that are toxic not the mold. This, after several readings, is beginning to sound a little too much like bureaucratic spin. They have split hairs because of the syntax, not because it is easy to separate the toxin from the physical mold. If the toxin is on the mold, isn't the mold toxic? These are just some of the issues that are being raised in my discussions. I know that several of you have very well-defined opinions on both sides of the toxic issue. I welcome them, both here and in private (healthyhouse@...). I look forward to all your comments and references to support them. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 20, 2008 Report Posted February 20, 2008 : How about this: 1. A cow itself is not toxic but the E-Coli from its gut can be very toxic. 2. A spider itself is not toxic but the venom he can inject can be very toxic. 3. The Poison Ivy plant is usually not producing toxins but there are three months of the year when its leaves are covered with a toxin. 4. A cobra itself is not toxic but the venom it can inject is. --- Now mold itself IMO should not be termed toxic though several molds can under certain conditions produce mycotoxins which if consumed or inhaled in appropriate concentrations become quite toxic. So maybe we should be saying it is not the mycotoxin that is toxic but the concentration. Maybe the expression should be toxic concentration of mycotoxin. --- Even clean pure drinking water can be highly toxic if too much is consumed too quickly as evidenced recently with the deaths of the two thirsty athletes who each consumed over a gallon of cool water after a severe workout. They were dead within four hours. Their brains exploded within their skulls. --- I can not at the moment think of any mold which will be producing mycotoxins 100% of the time. --- For a list of edible molds I'd do a web search under <edible+mold> Isn't soy sauce from a mold? Aren't certain cheeses sold with a rind of edible mold covering the cheese? --- Consider the human body to function in good health must by nature have colonies of a number of species of mold and yeasts resident in the intestine along with over 30 species of friendly bacteria. GibalaMember, Mycological Association of Washington toxic terminologyGroup,Lately for some reason, I have been asked to interpret the phrase 'toxic mold' .Some want to use it, others not. For many years now I have been one to avoid the use of the term toxic.Some are arguing that since the word toxic is often defined as meaning poisonous then just about any health effect can/should be categorized using the generic term toxic. Others argue that cytotoxic effects and/or mycotoxins must actually be present (or at least a known risk) to use the word toxic.I have tried to find references that state the negative. In other words, which particular mold is not toxic (e.g., under any circumstances). What I find is a lot of policy language.Most of you know I understand the big picture, and I have understanding of some specifics. But these questions are forcing me (us) to define better the application of the word toxic E.g., as an IH, I understand for instance that many chemicals have toxic irritant effects (i.e., corrosive; as opposed to a purely physical irritant, like sand in your bathing suit). We know mold produces many VOC's, some of which have toxic irritant effects, hence the mold-produced V"OC's are toxic by definition. This is not to imply that the actual concentration is sufficient to cause actual irritation effects. Which then raises the issue, if the chemical is never of sufficient concentration (dose) but is a known toxin at higher levels, must the word toxic be applied? In the spirit of the precautionary principle, if one is to be honest and open with the public, the answer might be that mold that produces VOC's ought to be termed toxic.I know about the 2004 CDC caveat for the term, toxic mold, i.e., that it's the mycotoxins that are toxic not the mold. This, after several readings, is beginning to sound a little too much like bureaucratic spin. They have split hairs because of the syntax, not because it is easy to separate the toxin from the physical mold. If the toxin is on the mold, isn't the mold toxic? These are just some of the issues that are being raised in my discussions.I know that several of you have very well-defined opinions on both sides of the toxic issue. I welcome them, both here and in private (healthyhouse@aolcom).I look forward to all your comments and references to support them. Delicious ideas to please the pickiest eaters. Watch the video on AOL Living. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 21, 2008 Report Posted February 21, 2008 > > I have been asked to interpret the phrase 'toxic mold' . > Some want to use it, others not. ========================================== http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/mplusdictionary.html defines poison as 1 : a substance that through its chemical action usually kills, injures, or impairs an organism 2 : a substance that inhibits the activity of another substance or the course of a reaction or process <a catalyst poison> The term toxic refers to anything related to poisons although it can also be related, colloquially, to anything deemed harmful (e.g. `toxic' emotions). But you can certainly be justified in using the phrase `toxic' mold since you would have little reason to be writing about forms which are less injurious or benign in the environment. Poisons do much harm via direct and indirect channels. As do various forms of mold. Even its allergenic properties result in inflammation, an unhealthy state that leads to the promotion of other abnormal systemic events if it is sufficiently strong or prolonged. It depends upon how generic a discussion you are having. It is always great to be precise but if speaking in generalities about undesirable effects of specific molds leading to toxic states in people, I see no problems in the use of the term 'toxic', from the standpoint of linguistic accuracy. Simply be prepared to defend your assertion by having ready a listing of types of effects leading to direct and indirect hazards in some 'stock' response. No need to keep re-inventing the wheel on this. It is a distraction from the main points in most critiques. In others, it is a good reminder for us all to be as directed as possible in our statements and avoid rhetoric. Barb Rubin Quote
Guest guest Posted February 21, 2008 Report Posted February 21, 2008 - " Toxic mold " is not as much a technical term as a media term. I invite you to join in a rebranding. The new term to use is " toxic radon " in hopes of generating some of the same " buzz " Henry Slack, whose words represent his opinion and not his employer's Quote
Guest guest Posted February 21, 2008 Report Posted February 21, 2008 and group, WARNING: Chaotic mixed metaphor rant (hopefully not madness, but I'll let you decide that) is directly ahead! Re: Your response to Kenny G below: Their use of the " logic " that 'mold is not toxic, the toxins are toxic' is not unlike the argument that guns don't kill people, bullets do. How important is it, really, to distinguish between the specific substance that causes (I mean, " strongly associated with " ) the resulting damages, the delivery system or what activates the system? The mold that produces the toxins or the toxins themselves? Which, in the chain of causation, is THE a priori " cause " that must be stopped? " Causation " is another word as fraught with difficulty as " toxic mold. " Or, is it the environment which allows and supports the fungal growth (because someone is negligent or ignorant) which produces the toxins which are " associated with " the sequential damage to the ankle-bone, then the knee-bone and eventually the ham-bone for the want of a nail for the horseshoe leading to the destruction of a nation-at-war whose alert level is orange instead green except before an election when it is fire engine red ... no offense to firemen intended. Confused? Of course. But isn't this cross-contamination of Mobius strip metaphors how we all get lost while pretending we actually understand? Extreme reductionism codified as law for the purpose of determining when a legal claim may or may not prevail (where does that leave the health concern?) is the real problem because it forces a dissociation from reality. A dissociation which necessarily creates a surrogate because we long ago lost the original. Direct experience is dismissed as " psychogenic, " individuality is merely anecdotal, leaving physical measurements under the feudal priesthood of divine emperors to determine for us - after the fact - what " really " occurred. Cognitive dissonance must be denied especially at the expense of truth! Long live revisionist history! Where are the bread crumbs to mark our Hansel and Gretel return trail when we most need them? Oh, right, the legal-eagle defensors have snatched them up, destroying our pathway and theirs, and no amount of sophisticated statistical regeneration from the resulting scat can ever retrace the original path of associated influences back to the original flap of the butterfly wing. (or was it a moth? It does makes a difference, you know). Whew! Even I'm confused now and I swear I haven't been smoking anything " funny " tonight or any night. But we must plod on: So instead of unscrambling the spaghetti we create scapegoats. Industry blames suit-happy consumers and we blame the lawyers while politicians demand tort reform; all the while the ankle-bone falls off leaving the leg-bone dangling. But the mold, whether toxic or toxigenic (it makes no difference, you know) tenderizes the ham-bone, oblivious to the nattering nabobs of statisticalisms and detectional errors while people - remember them? - continue to be harmed. Proofreading this has made me dizzy so I must now lie down to commune with my mentor, Colbert (or Spiro Agnew) as he begins another night of reruns. (Can you tell the difference?) And you thought only Alice had a Wonderland. She is not alone and neither are we because we have all retreated as companions to be with her. Carl Grimes Healthy Habitats LLC ----- > > Ken, > Nice examples. > The snake and spider are usually called, even by experts in the profession, poisonous snakes or > poisonous spider. Poison ivy is always " poison ivy " , never " the ivy with 3 green leaves that > sometimes produces a toxigenic substance to which some humans are, in differing degrees, > sensitive " . > Yep, the cow with toxic e. coli is never a " poisonous cow " ; however, is e. coli referred to as toxic > bacteria? or toxin producing bacteria? > > Is the fungi from the cheese being made in the cheese factory toxic mold or benign mold? > Depends on the perspective. The consumer believes the mold is benign. > However, ask the worker in the factory ifhe needs respiratory protection becausehe can suffer > from " cheese workers lung " from thespores and fragments of the same mold. > > So, is CDC right or wrong (see also AIHA) when they say that the 'mold is not toxic, the toxins > are toxic'. (paraphrase, not direct quote). > > S Quote
Guest guest Posted February 22, 2008 Report Posted February 22, 2008 Carl, That was an excellent overview of the matter! I find the below phrase of yours to be right on the mark as to a key area I am well aware of, that has put us on the other side of the looking glass. "Extreme reductionism codified as law for the purpose of determining when a legal claim may or may not prevail (where does that leave the health concern?) is the real problem because it forces a dissociation from reality." As an example, I offer the upcoming UCLA/UC Irvine, Association of Occupational and Environmental Clinic (AOEC), Pediatric Environmental Health Specialty Unit (PEHSU) co-hosted seminar meant to educate physicians of mold induced illness while providing them CME credits for their new "education". The Government Funded clinics of AOEC/PEHSU are involved in "educating" these physicians, complete with a mock mold trial, used to teach these physicians how to determine what is a courtroom standard burden of proof before they treat. Two of the "environmental educators" for this Government Funded educational endeavor, were peer reviewers of the ACOEM mold statement. At least one, does IME's of mold patients on behalf of school districts and employers regarding symptoms indicative of toxicity, has been known to serve as an expert defense witness - while citing ACOEM for the "not plausible" stance, and also moonlights for an environmental risk management company, Exponent Inc. THESE are the medical educators we have put in charge and are Government Funding to advance the understanding of environmental illness in our children thru the Pediatric Environmental Health Specialty Units and Occupational Clinics? http://www.ph.ucla.edu/erc/mold-symposium-2-08.htm Dr. Harber and Dr. Fedoruk, are FACOEM members, who were among the 101 permitted to peer review. Session C—The Toxicology of Mold – Review of the Literature - M. ph Fedoruk, MDSession D—Mold-induced Occupational Lung Diseases – Philip Harber, MD, MPH WHY ARE WE GOVERNMENT FUNDING PHYSICIAN "EDUCATIONAL" MOLD SEMINARS PROVIDED BY EXPERT WITNESSES WHO WERE PEER REVIEWERS OF THE ACOEM MOLD STATEMENT -THAT DENIES THE PLAUSIBILITY OF POISONING BASED ON FALSE SCIENCE - AND THESE EDUCATORS/ACOEM PEER REVIEWERS HAVE USED THE ACOEM STATEMENT IN LITIGATION, TO DENY THE EXACT SAME ILLNESSES WE ARE GOVERNMENT FUNDING (SUPPOSEDLY) FOR THE PURPOSE OF BETTER UNDERSTANDING MOLD INDUCED ILLNESS IN OUR CHILDREN???????? Sharon and group, WARNING: Chaotic mixed metaphor rant (hopefully not madness, but I'll let you decide that) is directly ahead! Re: Your response to Kenny G below:Their use of the "logic" that 'mold is not toxic, the toxins are toxic' is not unlike the argument that guns don't kill people, bullets do.How important is it, really, to distinguish between the specific substance that causes (I mean, "strongly associated with") the resulting damages, the delivery system or what activates the system? The mold that produces the toxins or the toxins themselves? Which, in the chain of causation, is THE a priori "cause" that must be stopped?"Causation" is another word as fraught with difficulty as "toxic mold."Or, is it the environment which allows and supports the fungal growth (because someone is negligent or ignorant) which produces the toxins which are "associated with" the sequential damage to the ankle-bone, then the knee-bone and eventually the ham-bone for the want of a nail for the horseshoe leading to the destruction of a nation-at-war whose alert level is orange instead green except before an election when it is fire engine red ... no offense to firemen intended.Confused? Of course. But isn't this cross-contamination of Mobius strip metaphors how we all get lost while pretending we actually understand?Extreme reductionism codified as law for the purpose of determining when a legal claim may or may not prevail (where does that leave the health concern?) is the real problem because it forces a dissociation from reality. A dissociation which necessarily creates a surrogate because we long ago lost the original. Direct experience is dismissed as "psychogenic," individuality is merely anecdotal, leaving physical measurements under the feudal priesthood of divine emperors to determine for us - after the fact - what "really" occurred. Cognitive dissonance must be denied especially at the expense of truth! Long live revisionist history!Where are the bread crumbs to mark our Hansel and Gretel return trail when we most need them? Oh, right, the legal-eagle defensors have snatched them up, destroying our pathway and theirs, and no amount of sophisticated statistical regeneration from the resulting scat can ever retrace the original path of associated influences back to the original flap of the butterfly wing. (or was it a moth? It does makes a difference, you know).Whew! Even I'm confused now and I swear I haven't been smoking anything "funny" tonight or any night. But we must plod on:So instead of unscrambling the spaghetti we create scapegoats. Industry blames suit-happy consumers and we blame the lawyers while politicians demand tort reform; all the while the ankle-bone falls off leaving the leg-bone dangling. But the mold, whether toxic or toxigenic (it makes no difference, you know) tenderizes the ham-bone, oblivious to the nattering nabobs of statisticalisms and detectional errors while people - remember them? - continue to be harmed.Proofreading this has made me dizzy so I must now lie down to commune with my mentor, Colbert (or Spiro Agnew) as he begins another night of reruns. (Can you tell the difference?)And you thought only Alice had a Wonderland. She is not alone and neither are we because we have all retreated as companions to be with her.Carl GrimesHealthy Habitats LLC Delicious ideas to please the pickiest eaters. Watch the video on AOL Living. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 22, 2008 Report Posted February 22, 2008 Carl, EXCELLENT POST! Although I too became just a bit dizzy while reading it once...I can't imaging trying to proofread it! Your points are well made and IMHO, strangely but accurately describe the muddled path of trying to recreate the precise circumstances of any given exposure or set of exposures. I agree that the BEST we can usually hope to accurately accomplish in most if not all cases is to establish that the environment is likely (or not likely) to have presented elements that were/are problematic for the average individual (as a starting point). Given the above, I conduct thorough assessments, but only order analyses to the genus level. Speciation only adds more tangles to the spaghetti of information, and by necessity creates a need for even more, not less speculation as to the possible effects of the entities found. FOUND, not present, because we can never be certain, beyond a shadow of a doubt that we have found ALL microbial entities present (especially when we're trying to look backwards through the looking-glass, with Alice's help of course, to what a given environment MAY have presented previously. Therefore, again, IMHO, the only truly reasonably accurate evaluations we can make are whether or not a problematic environment, for the " average " individual (whatever the hell " average " really is) was likely to have existed, at the time/times of exposure. To attempt to do otherwise only adds more confusion to the puzzle. " Answers are the easy part, questions raise the doubt " . The more specific we attempt to be, the more questions we attempt to ask, the more questions seem to exponentially result. When litigation may be part of what we must anticipate and attempt to deal with, this often only serves to provide the opposing side with the unclear information to create further confusion and raise even more questions a/k/a, " reasonable doubt " . Now I'm getting dizzy, but I hope y'all get the point. In summary, in the IEQ world, usually less is more. If it shouldn't be there, it simply shoulnd't be there. Whew. Chuck Reaney, CIAQetc. Re: Re: toxic terminology > and group, > > WARNING: Chaotic mixed metaphor rant (hopefully not > madness, but I'll let you decide that) is directly ahead! > > Re: Your response to Kenny G below: > > Their use of the " logic " that 'mold is not toxic, the toxins are toxic' > is not unlike the argument that guns don't kill people, bullets do. > > How important is it, really, to distinguish between the specific > substance that causes (I mean, " strongly associated with " ) the > resulting damages, the delivery system or what activates the > system? The mold that produces the toxins or the toxins > themselves? Which, in the chain of causation, is THE a priori > " cause " that must be stopped? > > " Causation " is another word as fraught with difficulty as > " toxic mold. " > > Or, is it the environment which allows and supports the fungal > growth (because someone is negligent or ignorant) which > produces the toxins which are " associated with " the sequential > damage to the ankle-bone, then the knee-bone and eventually > the ham-bone for the want of a nail for the horseshoe leading to > the destruction of a nation-at-war whose alert level is orange > instead green except before an election when it is fire engine red > ... no offense to firemen intended. > > Confused? Of course. But isn't this cross-contamination > of Mobius strip metaphors how we all get lost while > pretending we actually understand? > > Extreme reductionism codified as law for the purpose of > determining when a legal claim may or may not prevail (where > does that leave the health concern?) is the real problem because > it forces a dissociation from reality. > > A dissociation which necessarily creates a surrogate because we > long ago lost the original. Direct experience is dismissed as > " psychogenic, " individuality is merely anecdotal, leaving physical > measurements under the feudal priesthood of divine emperors to > determine for us - after the fact - what " really " occurred. Cognitive > dissonance must be denied especially at the expense of truth! > Long live revisionist history! > > Where are the bread crumbs to mark our Hansel and Gretel > return trail when we most need them? Oh, right, the legal-eagle > defensors have snatched them up, destroying our pathway and > theirs, and no amount of sophisticated statistical regeneration > from the resulting scat can ever retrace the original path of > associated influences back to the original flap of the butterfly > wing. (or was it a moth? It does makes a difference, you know). > > Whew! Even I'm confused now and I swear I haven't > been smoking anything " funny " tonight or any night. But > we must plod on: > > So instead of unscrambling the spaghetti we create scapegoats. > Industry blames suit-happy consumers and we blame the lawyers > while politicians demand tort reform; all the while the ankle-bone > falls off leaving the leg-bone dangling. But the mold, whether > toxic or toxigenic (it makes no difference, you know) tenderizes > the ham-bone, oblivious to the nattering nabobs of statisticalisms > and detectional errors while people - remember them? - continue > to be harmed. > > Proofreading this has made me dizzy so I must now lie down to > commune with my mentor, Colbert (or Spiro Agnew) as > he begins another night of reruns. (Can you tell the difference?) > > And you thought only Alice had a Wonderland. She is not alone > and neither are we because we have all retreated as companions > to be with her. > > Carl Grimes > Healthy Habitats LLC > > ----- >> >> Ken, >> Nice examples. >> The snake and spider are usually called, even by experts in the >> profession, poisonous snakes or >> poisonous spider. Poison ivy is always " poison ivy " , never " the ivy with >> 3 green leaves that >> sometimes produces a toxigenic substance to which some humans are, in >> differing degrees, >> sensitive " . >> Yep, the cow with toxic e. coli is never a " poisonous cow " ; however, is >> e. coli referred to as toxic >> bacteria? or toxin producing bacteria? >> >> Is the fungi from the cheese being made in the cheese factory toxic mold >> or benign mold? >> Depends on the perspective. The consumer believes the mold is benign. >> However, ask the worker in the factory ifhe needs respiratory protection >> becausehe can suffer >> from " cheese workers lung " from thespores and fragments of the same mold. >> >> So, is CDC right or wrong (see also AIHA) when they say that the 'mold is >> not toxic, the toxins >> are toxic'. (paraphrase, not direct quote). >> >> S > > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 22, 2008 Report Posted February 22, 2008 Group, When making comments about mold’s “toxic terminology†that could “potentially†show some molds are toxic or toxigenic under certain conditions, we need to test the environment and materials for toxicity, otherwise we are making claims that have no basis of fact. I’m not aware of sampling methods and procedures for determining mold toxicity in an environment; and based on laboratory analysis, what are safe and unsafe levels for an occupied space. Anyone care to enlighten me? Moffett      From: iequality [mailto:iequality ] On Behalf Of snk1955@... Sent: Friday, February 22, 2008 11:01 AM To: iequality Subject: Re: Re: toxic terminology Carl, That was an excellent overview of the matter! I find the below phrase of yours to be right on the mark as to a key area I am well aware of, that has put us on the other side of the looking glass. " Extreme reductionism codified as law for the purpose of determining when a legal claim may or may not prevail (where does that leave the health concern?) is the real problem because it forces a dissociation from reality. " As an example, I offer the upcoming UCLA/UC Irvine, Association of Occupational and Environmental Clinic (AOEC), Pediatric Environmental Health Specialty Unit (PEHSU) co-hosted seminar meant to educate physicians of mold induced illness while providing them CME credits for their new " education " . The Government Funded clinics of AOEC/PEHSU are involved in " educating " these physicians, complete with a mock mold trial, used to teach these physicians how to determine what is a courtroom standard burden of proof before they treat. Two of the " environmental educators " for this Government Funded educational endeavor, were peer reviewers of the ACOEM mold statement. At least one, does IME's of mold patients on behalf of school districts and employers regarding symptoms indicative of toxicity, has been known to serve as an expert defense witness - while citing ACOEM for the " not plausible " stance, and also moonlights for an environmental risk management company, Exponent Inc. THESE are the medical educators we have put in charge and are Government Funding to advance the understanding of environmental illness in our children thru the Pediatric Environmental Health Specialty Units and Occupational Clinics? http://www.ph.ucla.edu/erc/mold-symposium-2-08.htm Dr. Harber and Dr. Fedoruk, are FACOEM members, who were among the 101 permitted to peer review. Session C—The Toxicology of Mold – Review of the Literature - M. ph Fedoruk, MD Session D—Mold-induced Occupational Lung Diseases – Philip Harber, MD, MPH WHY ARE WE GOVERNMENT FUNDING PHYSICIAN " EDUCATIONAL " MOLD SEMINARS PROVIDED BY EXPERT WITNESSES WHO WERE PEER REVIEWERS OF THE ACOEM MOLD STATEMENT -THAT DENIES THE PLAUSIBILITY OF POISONING BASED ON FALSE SCIENCE - AND THESE EDUCATORS/ACOEM PEER REVIEWERS HAVE USED THE ACOEM STATEMENT IN LITIGATION, TO DENY THE EXACT SAME ILLNESSES WE ARE GOVERNMENT FUNDING (SUPPOSEDLY) FOR THE PURPOSE OF BETTER UNDERSTANDING MOLD INDUCED ILLNESS IN OUR CHILDREN???????? Sharon In a message dated 2/22/2008 10:22:00 A.M. Pacific Standard Time, mgeyer@... writes: and group, WARNING: Chaotic mixed metaphor rant (hopefully not madness, but I'll let you decide that) is directly ahead! Re: Your response to Kenny G below: Their use of the " logic " that 'mold is not toxic, the toxins are toxic' is not unlike the argument that guns don't kill people, bullets do. How important is it, really, to distinguish between the specific substance that causes (I mean, " strongly associated with " ) the resulting damages, the delivery system or what activates the system? The mold that produces the toxins or the toxins themselves? Which, in the chain of causation, is THE a priori " cause " that must be stopped? " Causation " is another word as fraught with difficulty as " toxic mold. " Or, is it the environment which allows and supports the fungal growth (because someone is negligent or ignorant) which produces the toxins which are " associated with " the sequential damage to the ankle-bone, then the knee-bone and eventually the ham-bone for the want of a nail for the horseshoe leading to the destruction of a nation-at-war whose alert level is orange instead green except before an election when it is fire engine red ... no offense to firemen intended. Confused? Of course. But isn't this cross-contamination of Mobius strip metaphors how we all get lost while pretending we actually understand? Extreme reductionism codified as law for the purpose of determining when a legal claim may or may not prevail (where does that leave the health concern?) is the real problem because it forces a dissociation from reality. A dissociation which necessarily creates a surrogate because we long ago lost the original. Direct experience is dismissed as " psychogenic, " individuality is merely anecdotal, leaving physical measurements under the feudal priesthood of divine emperors to determine for us - after the fact - what " really " occurred. Cognitive dissonance must be denied especially at the expense of truth! Long live revisionist history! Where are the bread crumbs to mark our Hansel and Gretel return trail when we most need them? Oh, right, the legal-eagle defensors have snatched them up, destroying our pathway and theirs, and no amount of sophisticated statistical regeneration from the resulting scat can ever retrace the original path of associated influences back to the original flap of the butterfly wing. (or was it a moth? It does makes a difference, you know). Whew! Even I'm confused now and I swear I haven't been smoking anything " funny " tonight or any night. But we must plod on: So instead of unscrambling the spaghetti we create scapegoats. Industry blames suit-happy consumers and we blame the lawyers while politicians demand tort reform; all the while the ankle-bone falls off leaving the leg-bone dangling. But the mold, whether toxic or toxigenic (it makes no difference, you know) tenderizes the ham-bone, oblivious to the nattering nabobs of statisticalisms and detectional errors while people - remember them? - continue to be harmed. Proofreading this has made me dizzy so I must now lie down to commune with my mentor, Colbert (or Spiro Agnew) as he begins another night of reruns. (Can you tell the difference?) And you thought only Alice had a Wonderland. She is not alone and neither are we because we have all retreated as companions to be with her. Carl Grimes Healthy Habitats LLC Delicious ideas to please the pickiest eaters. Watch the video on AOL Living. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 24, 2008 Report Posted February 24, 2008 Sharon, I guess you haven’t been reading the American Bar Association’s “Toxic Mold Litigation†book by King, MD., JD. It is a fun read as a half inch thick paperback. The issue for this thread is an attempt to describe what is toxic mold and other terms that may apply to toxic mold, if any. The implications for describing mold is only one part of the story. Once you come up with an answer to what is toxic mold, how then do we quantify it scientifically? I enjoy Wei’s comments including those of , Steve and . They are informative and cause me to rethink “what is the toxic mold issue?†Let me share with you a case I’m involved with: As an environmental professional I’m often asked about the presence of certain mold and whether or not they are toxic? I too don’t like the term toxic mold for describing building mold problems without having supportive science. As you know people respond faster to buzz words rather than scientific evidence. In a recent case, the toxic mold syndrome raised its ugly head putting us as environmental professionals and remediation contractors in an awkward position. For instance, while the some of the laboratory data in a case suggests: there are bio-markers (marker fungi) present such as Stachybotrys on surfaces and in air (which the mold remediation contractor is being accused for allowing after remediation), I am not willing take the side of the coin and state: there are toxic or toxigenic mold condition present. I don’t believe testing and laboratory science is there yet for me to quantitatively document the presence or absence of “toxic mold; and now that is there, determine levels of toxicity that can or is affecting building occupantsâ€. The opposing counsel asked in this case: · “Mr. Moffett, the laboratory identified mold spores and growth that under certain conditions can be toxic?†I replied Yes. · “Did you have those samples or other samples analyzed to determine their toxicity and health effects on the building, its environment and the occupants? My answer was no. · “Based on the laboratory data there are molds present that are known to be toxin producers?†I said, yes. · “Ok then, aren’t you telling me we still have a mold toxin problem in the recently remediation area?†I replied, I believe we have a condition where further exploratory investigation may identify a hidden reservoir of mold growth or that further cleaning may be helpful to reduce existing spore counts. · “So, are you saying the remediation contractor failed to achieve clearance because they left behind toxic mold.†I said, I don’t believe I agreed with you, the mold that was present before, during and after remediation were toxigenic including the current spores analyzed by the laboratory. Sharon, to answer you, I too would like to have a better scientific explanation about the terminology describing - [environmental caused] mold toxins? Once we come up with an agreeable answer, the next step I believe is supporting the hypothesis, do mold toxins actually exist in the case you are investigating? Delicious ideas to please the pickiest eaters. Watch the video on AOL Living. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.