Guest guest Posted July 16, 2008 Report Posted July 16, 2008 Not necessarily. Esophageal varices are a sign of severe liver damage/portal hypertension. On a personal note. I went for an endoscopy many months ago. The Dr. said I had small to moderate varices. After a bleed he went back down and found these varices huge and on the verge of popping. They were banded. A few weeks later a small varice became huge and tore. Now some people get banded and never have a problem with them again. I sneezed and tore one months ago. I have been very lucky. When I smell or taste blood I am on my way to the ER. The good thing is that these physicians are keeping a close watch on the varices as you say and as they should. If they find an enlargement they can take care of it before it explodes. A friend of mine had a few enlarged and he got them banded. That was years ago and he has had no problem since. Did they by chance give him a beta-blocker? I take Nadalol and it helps with absolutely no side effects. MOST IMPORTANT...listen to the Dr.s...an endoscopy is not invasive...not to me anyway. I certainly wish you the best of luck. From: Bob Aragon <robwalkingeagle@ yahoo.com> Subject: Re: surgery question To: livercirrhosissuppo rtyahoogroups (DOT) com Date: Wednesday, July 16, 2008, 7:14 AM I am a little confused ass well. Bleeding varicies especially reoccurring ones are a sign of decompensation, and decompensation is a positive indication that it's time for a liver transplant evaluation. What you should do is ask these same questions directly to the hepatologist there, and ask why your father is not being considered for a transplant if bleeding varicies can be and often are life threatening. As far as I know , banding is not a pre-emptive measure. At CU it sure isnt. It is an invasive procedure that is not without it's own risks, and it wouldn't be done just as a " routine thing " . I'm sorry Hannah, I am not very trustful of any doctors. If your dad has truly compensated cirrhosis and that means NO complications, or at least not any major ones, and bleeding varix are major, then why is he and the family being painted such a rosy picture? This is too often a recurring theme for me. Sorry again, I wish I could be of more help to you, and no doubt you will be worried about this, and I just wish he wasnt sick at all. Love Bobby surgery question Hi all, Hope you are all doing well. I had a quick question about my Dad and the procedures that he is having done every month. He has gone to the Lahey Clinic now twice to have the varices tied with the rubber bands (sorry if I am using the wrong terms again). He actually just went today and they said he will have to go back again in a month to have it done again. What does this mean? They told him he will not need a liver transplant so why does he need to keep having this procedure done? They said they have to make sure the blood will clot. He has not had any bleeding since the original incident that happened in February when he was diagnosed with cirrhosis of the liver. Can anyone help me out with this and maybe I would be able to understand it a little better. Will he have to have this done all the time? Thank you for your help, Hannah Quote
Guest guest Posted July 17, 2008 Report Posted July 17, 2008 Thank you this information is very helpful to me. I just want to make sure that my Dad is getting the right care and the correct information, ya know. Thanks again, God Bless, Hannah From: Bob Aragon <robwalkingeagle@ yahoo.com> Subject: Re: surgery question To: livercirrhosissuppo rtyahoogroups (DOT) com Date: Wednesday, July 16, 2008, 7:14 AM I am a little confused ass well. Bleeding varicies especially reoccurring ones are a sign of decompensation, and decompensation is a positive indication that it's time for a liver transplant evaluation. What you should do is ask these same questions directly to the hepatologist there, and ask why your father is not being considered for a transplant if bleeding varicies can be and often are life threatening. As far as I know , banding is not a pre-emptive measure. At CU it sure isnt. It is an invasive procedure that is not without it's own risks, and it wouldn't be done just as a " routine thing " . I'm sorry Hannah, I am not very trustful of any doctors. If your dad has truly compensated cirrhosis and that means NO complications, or at least not any major ones, and bleeding varix are major, then why is he and the family being painted such a rosy picture? This is too often a recurring theme for me. Sorry again, I wish I could be of more help to you, and no doubt you will be worried about this, and I just wish he wasnt sick at all. Love Bobby surgery question Hi all, Hope you are all doing well. I had a quick question about my Dad and the procedures that he is having done every month. He has gone to the Lahey Clinic now twice to have the varices tied with the rubber bands (sorry if I am using the wrong terms again). He actually just went today and they said he will have to go back again in a month to have it done again. What does this mean? They told him he will not need a liver transplant so why does he need to keep having this procedure done? They said they have to make sure the blood will clot. He has not had any bleeding since the original incident that happened in February when he was diagnosed with cirrhosis of the liver. Can anyone help me out with this and maybe I would be able to understand it a little better. Will he have to have this done all the time? Thank you for your help, Hannah Quote
Guest guest Posted July 17, 2008 Report Posted July 17, 2008 He actually told my Dad he does not need a transplant and would not be considered for one bc he said that he will live a lot longer without the transplant.....he said he has more risk of having the transplant done then dying without one.....he is I believe part of the Transplant team but he does not do the actual transplant......he has done all kinds of bloodwork on him as well. I guess I just thought this Doctor would know what he was talking about but now I am starting to question him.... Quote
Guest guest Posted July 17, 2008 Report Posted July 17, 2008 My Gastro. told me back when I was entertaining the thought of a transplant that wheather or not I get a transplant was solely up to the transplant team at Shands Hosp. in Gainsville. Just for what it's worth. Here is the catch 22. The Gastro. physician has to refer you to the transplant evaluation. If the Gastro. doesn't refer you thats a rung on the ladder missing, so to speak. This being said, I have very limited knowledge of transplantation logistics. I just offer an opinion. I decided early on that a transplant for me was out of the question. More than likely I would have not got one anyway. I have some other rather significant health issues like diabetes that could make a transplant less than average chances of a sucess. And now heptacellular carcinoma...a transplant would be foolish in my case and I doubt even a consideration. Have you been doing OK? Quote
Guest guest Posted July 17, 2008 Report Posted July 17, 2008 This is EXACTLY why my hepatologist has stopped my transplant evaluation. The words you used brought it all back to me clearly. He told me that the risks of having a transplant are far higher than taking our chances right now without one. He said to look at it as a last resort. It isnt a bad thing to have these questions, because MaC and I know of two beautiful ladies whom would have benefited with at least a chance for a transplant but were never given the opportunity. Doctors can be wrong too. They cannot foresee the future, and neither can we, but it shows that clearly what we hear and read about dec ompensation and when to evaluate for a transplant is not written in stone. Re: surgery question He actually told my Dad he does not need a transplant and would not be considered for one bc he said that he will live a lot longer without the transplant.. ...he said he has more risk of having the transplant done then dying without one.....he is I believe part of the Transplant team but he does not do the actual transplant.. ....he has done all kinds of bloodwork on him as well. I guess I just thought this Doctor would know what he was talking about but now I am starting to question him.... Quote
Guest guest Posted July 17, 2008 Report Posted July 17, 2008 Actually, Chief, they do transplants now specifically FOR HCC, but the tumors have to be a certain size and not metastatic. It used to be a complete contraindication, but now it is an indication specifically. Re: surgery question My Gastro. told me back when I was entertaining the thought of a transplant that wheather or not I get a transplant was solely up to the transplant team at Shands Hosp. in Gainsville. Just for what it's worth. Here is the catch 22. The Gastro. physician has to refer you to the transplant evaluation. If the Gastro. doesn't refer you thats a rung on the ladder missing, so to speak. This being said, I have very limited knowledge of transplantation logistics. I just offer an opinion. I decided early on that a transplant for me was out of the question. More than likely I would have not got one anyway. I have some other rather significant health issues like diabetes that could make a transplant less than average chances of a sucess. And now heptacellular carcinoma... a transplant would be foolish in my case and I doubt even a consideration. Have you been doing OK? Quote
Guest guest Posted July 17, 2008 Report Posted July 17, 2008 I would question whether he has even been evaluated by a transplant team and why not. It's the transplant team that decides if he goes on the transplant waiting list. Then he gets racked and stacked with everyone else. If his condition worsens the further up the list he goes. My wifes doctor kept putting her off and didn't even recommend the evaluation until a week before she died. Another doctor at the hospital told me during that time she should have been evaluated at a least a year prior. MaC Hannah Reid wrote: He actually told my Dad he does not need a transplant and would not be considered for one bc he said that he will live a lot longer without the transplant.....he said he has more risk of having the transplant done then dying without one.....he is I believe part of the Transplant team but he does not do the actual transplant......he has done all kinds of bloodwork on him as well. I guess I just thought this Doctor would know what he was talking about but now I am starting to question him.... Quote
Guest guest Posted July 17, 2008 Report Posted July 17, 2008 Is that right WalkingEagle? My tumors where <2.0 cm, the first two discovered and the other was <4 cm in which they found later. My labs came back not great but what one would expect with cirrhosis, you know, the 4.3 bilirubin, elevated amonia, and an protime (sp) at about an hour and a half ...:-) They called me at about 6;am and told me I had to go get an alpha-ferra-protein bloodtest. It was off the charts. I have to go back in the hosp. first of next week as the swelling is like every 2-3 days. I'll check in with ya'll guys from time to time and let you know how things are going. CLE Quote
Guest guest Posted July 17, 2008 Report Posted July 17, 2008 That is exactly what I thought bc his original doctor at the hospital when it all initially happened said that he can't live without a transplant (but he was the original jerk doctor that could not get us the appt at the Lahey in the first place)....I don't know how to tell my dad this?? Quote
Guest guest Posted July 17, 2008 Report Posted July 17, 2008 This is what I have been afraid of..... Quote
Guest guest Posted July 17, 2008 Report Posted July 17, 2008 I know it's a tough road Hannah. I have a saying, " the squeaky wheel gets the oil. " Now, I don't know how intrusive your Dad will let you be, but questions not asked don't get answered. I honestly hope that in your case the doctors are right and this worry is all for not. I believe now, that we should sometimes challenge our providers, (in a professional way of course) and be advocates for better health care. If your Dad agrees, challenge this doctor and ask that the transplant recommendation come after the " official " transplant evaluation. Even corner him and ask " Are you the final say whether he has a transplant or not? The be all end all? " Can I talk to someone about the hospitals transplant procedures? Who is the patient advocate for the hospital? But trust me, be careful how you ask the questions. If you come off wrong, doctors tend to get defensive and become guarded or feel they are being attacked. I find that if you explain how much love you have for your Dad, and that you are invested in his care and are worried (which is natural) and just want more information so your Dad can make proper decisions etc. They tend to be supportive. I would also review your hospitals Patient Bill of Rights. This is an important document that they are required to give the patient by law. Most overlook it. I would read it carefully. Anyway, I rambled on too long. Love & Peace, MaC MaC Hannah Reid wrote: This is what I have been afraid of..... I would question whether he has even been evaluated by a transplant team and why not. It's the transplant team that decides if he goes on the transplant waiting list. Then he gets racked and stacked with everyone else. If his condition worsens the further up the list he goes. My wifes doctor kept putting her off and didn't even recommend the evaluation until a week before she died. Another doctor at the hospital told me during that time she should have been evaluated at a least a year prior. MaC Quote
Guest guest Posted July 17, 2008 Report Posted July 17, 2008 Hannah, You may very well have to step on a few toes to get hip. Not long after my diagnosis of cirrhosis a had a Gastro. Dr. that would spend about a total of 5 minutes with me during an examination. He would mash my belly and ask if my medication was working. About it. But, I had questions. One day I noticed I was rattling off questions faster than an auctioneer just to get them all in. Sometimes I would be asking a question to the back of his elbows as he was walking out the door. I can still walk so I would follow him down the hall asking questions. One thing that helped me was making a list of questions to ask beforehand. Once after an endoscopy I was given a picture of a huge varice they found, handed to me when I was in the recovery room with the ol' standard post endoscopy instructions. I was furious. Was it banded? What it in the stomach? Was it in the esophageous? They didn't know, just a picture for me to look at and worry about for a month. It never bled so I guess it was banded or didn't need banding? How many times have I left the Dr.s office and got to the parking lot and realized I had a question I forgot to ask? Too many times I'll assure you. Now I just jot down a question as they pop up and take my list in with me. Hadn't had a problem since. Best of luck. CLE Quote
Guest guest Posted July 17, 2008 Report Posted July 17, 2008 Oh my gosh that is awful that you went through that...the nerve of his bedside manner.....I just need to fogure out a way to approach my dad with this bc all he keeps hearing is that he does not need a transplant and I think differently.....everything I read leads to him needing a transplant bc of the things that went wrong... Thank you for your help on this. You have really helped me out a lot! Quote
Guest guest Posted July 17, 2008 Report Posted July 17, 2008 Do you know if I am able to call the doctor myself ? Or do I have to have my parents permission? I live 2000 miles away from my dad and I can't go to the appt with him..... I would question whether he has even been evaluated by a transplant team and why not. It's the transplant team that decides if he goes on the transplant waiting list. Then he gets racked and stacked with everyone else. If his condition worsens the further up the list he goes. My wifes doctor kept putting her off and didn't even recommend the evaluation until a week before she died. Another doctor at the hospital told me during that time she should have been evaluated at a least a year prior. MaC Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.