Guest guest Posted January 17, 2010 Report Posted January 17, 2010 Exercise in normal people gives then energy. Doesn¹t work that way with CFS. Everything that I have read encourages us to move within our limits. It may be walking 5 minutes or swimming a 1/4 miles. Do only what you are comfortable with. Listen to your body to find your limit. A dr suggested 5 up/5 down. Exercise for 5 minutes. Lie down for 5 minutes. Repeat as able. Lois > I have cfs and I am trying to understand if excersising is for the better or > worse, I am wanting to get into shape but I have heard that working out is not > good is that true....doesn't excersise make you have more energy Quote
Guest guest Posted January 17, 2010 Report Posted January 17, 2010 thos of use with cfids have a specific exercise intolerance. My own personal recommendation is NOT to specific exericse-especialyy anything aerobic exercise. I made the mistake of doing that back in 1991 and have a severe relapse causing me to be bedridden again for another year. I have had CFIDS since 1977. Just trying to do daily activities is enough exercise for us. If you can do some slight walking but watch how you feel afterwards especially 24-48 hrs. afterwards. If you feel worse than stop or cut back. I wish that I had known this. some members of my suport group knew this but did't tell me. some support???? This is one of the difficult concepts for people to understand including doctors with this disease. Do research online-Dr.. Cheney and or Dr. Bell or any of the other CFIDS specialists and follow what they say not what your doctor says as he/she probably knows nothing about CFIDS. Diane ________________________________ I have cfs and I am trying to understand if excersising is for the better or worse, I am wanting to get into shape but I have heard that working out is not good is that true....doesn' t excersise make you have more energy Quote
Guest guest Posted January 17, 2010 Report Posted January 17, 2010 I *know* that when I am able to get regular, moderate exercise, I have MUCH more energy and less fatigue flare ups. May be different for others, tho. I am actually in school (at 38!) to become a personal trainer-- THAT is how much I enjoy working out Carey .. Eastern Standard Time, purplearies16@... writes: I have cfs and I am trying to understand if excersising is for the better or worse, I am wanting to get into shape but I have heard that working out is not good is that true....doesn'I have cfs and I am trying to under Quote
Guest guest Posted January 18, 2010 Report Posted January 18, 2010 I'm not sure what your situation is, but I can tell you that it took me awhile to work up the energy to even think about exercising.......like a good couple years. Once I got started, though, and found an activity that worked for me (cycling), it was almost like a miracle! Carey In a message dated 1/18/2010 9:08:39 P.M. Eastern Standard Time, wordtrix@... writes: Wish that were the case with me. Quote
Guest guest Posted January 18, 2010 Report Posted January 18, 2010 Wish that were the case with me. To: CFAlliance From: workingk9@... I *know* that when I am able to get regular, moderate exercise, I have MUCH more energy and less fatigue flare ups. May be different for others, tho. I am actually in school (at 38!) to become a personal trainer-- THAT is how much I enjoy working out Carey .. Eastern Standard Time, purplearies16@... writes: I have cfs and I am trying to understand if excersising is for the better or worse, I am wanting to get into shape but I have heard that working out is not good is that true....doesn'I have cfs and I am trying to under Quote
Guest guest Posted January 18, 2010 Report Posted January 18, 2010 I have fibro and fatigue and I can tell you my experience, with very little exercise and I felt the next day like a truck had hit me. My Doctor told me not to exercise until we get my pain more under contro. I do good to get dressed and get ready to go work out lololl ________________________________ Wish that were the case with me.. Quote
Guest guest Posted January 19, 2010 Report Posted January 19, 2010 I count my blessings that I don't have a pain issue to deal with, " only " the fatigue and flare ups. Carey Eastern Standard Time, debbieg1711@... writes: I have fibro and fatigue and I can tell you my experience, with very little exercise and I felt the next day like a truck had hit me. My Doctor told me not to exercise until we get my pain more under contro. I do good to get dressed and get ready to go work out lololl Quote
Guest guest Posted January 20, 2010 Report Posted January 20, 2010 My Dr says walk 5 mi a day in the forest and you'll walk outta fibro pain and c/f. I had a friend send me to her friend a special massuse who stood on me and twisted me. Talk about the hit by a truck effect. I went about 5 times OMG. I had to stop, that was NOT my answer. Mindy ________________________________ I count my blessings that I don't have a pain issue to deal with, " only " the fatigue and flare ups. Quote
Guest guest Posted January 23, 2010 Report Posted January 23, 2010 I have not read all the answers to this but I will willingly add my two cents worth of opinion. For those with ME/CFS, the exercise requirement IS A CROCK OF SH*$!! That said, I cannot speak for fibro patients, but it is common knowledge that, for whatever reason, exercise can be extremely detremental. This does not mean you should never exercise again, but realistically, would you go to the gym or run 20 minutes on the treadmill if you had H1N1? If you say " yes " , there is this thing called the Darwin theory you should look into.... I believe in exercise, I DO. But if you are in any stage of this disease beside the first (or fourth, whatever your label, anything less than " I can work, maintain a life and raise kids') exercise can send you back to the stone age... or at least back several days to weeks. Again, I personally prescribe to the theory of oxidative stress, 'cause I know for a fact that a 15 min trip to the grocery knocks me off for three days, at least. When I'm feeling really great, I do stretches or anything to help my muscles or core (but limited! One day I did a five minute pilates exercise and felt like I'd been kicked in the chest/stomach/groin area for at least a week - seriously almost went to the hospital - we don't need any help feeling worse, do we?) I actually had a doctor - a FEMALE physician - write me a prescription on her pad for " 5 minutes of exercise a day " - arrogant B#*$^@! The argument was, as a physician, she had been to all these conferences, and they stated exercise was imparative. My response? How the hell can you know that when they haven't even identified what causes this disease? (Poo-poo to the Whos!) Okay, I'll get off my soapbox now. Good luck to you and LISTEN to your body, not what everyone keeps telling you what your body must feel. They that don't walk in our moccasins don't know the stink. Good luck and feel well - ljg > > My Dr says walk 5 mi a day in the forest and you'll walk outta fibro pain and c/f. I had a friend send me to her friend a special massuse who stood on me and twisted me. Talk about the hit by a truck effect. I went about 5 times OMG. I had to stop, that was NOT my answer. Mindy Quote
Guest guest Posted January 23, 2010 Report Posted January 23, 2010 Everyone has to listen to ones one body. Each one of us are different some might be able to do more then others, The main thing is you have to figure out what your limit is. My doctor actually told me she thought that exercising was not good idea, while my psych thought it was. I listened to psych and made myself worse. I was also told by friend that I was overdoing it but I am so stubborn had to figure out on my own. Some days may not be able to do anything, have to learn that if that is the case do not push your body, only make things worse in long run. On days that you feel ok, if we have those days, are the dangerous days, took me long time to learn not to overdo things on my better days. The main thing is to listen to your body, not to others we are all different, some things might work for you but not others. It is trial and error, to find out what will work for you. I have been reading book called Flip The Switch, in which have found some real easy things to do to help turn on fat burning switches in our body that are simple to do exercises and take hardly any time and I have found easy on my body. Theresa. Quote
Guest guest Posted January 24, 2010 Report Posted January 24, 2010 Hopefully you fired this Dr. yeah, I would find that very insulting. I started seeing my PCP around 2000 and came down with Mono in May of 2003 and have never felt the same! Dr said it could take a couple of years for my immune system to " bounce " back or something to that effect. No real treatment(s) as we all know. Just try this then that...months and years go back and we continue to suffer. Who said life is fair?! Well it's not and luckily I can exercise and do more..., scheduled to work only 30hrs/wk thanks to FMLA and a supportive Dr.! but I also pay for it when I over do things! I have simplified my life over the years and do not demand as much from my body as in the past. Still learning though! Best of Luck to all and hang in there, Hopefully the XMRV will lead to bigger and better things for all of us, virus or not! Posted by: " kat13lady " kat13lady@... kat13lady Sat Jan 23, 2010 2:55 pm (PST) I have not read all the answers to this but I will willingly add my two cents worth of opinion. For those with ME/CFS, the exercise requirement IS A CROCK OF SH*$!! That said, I cannot speak for fibro patients, but it is common knowledge that, for whatever reason, exercise can be extremely detremental. This does not mean you should never exercise again, but realistically, would you go to the gym or run 20 minutes on the treadmill if you had H1N1? Quote
Guest guest Posted January 24, 2010 Report Posted January 24, 2010 I have fired several doctors over the past year. I am unable to exercise or I will be in bed for several days. I feel like a truck has hit me. ________________________________ Hopefully you fired this Dr. yeah, I would find that very insulting. I started seeing my PCP around 2000 and came down with Mono in May of 2003 and have never felt the same! Dr said it could take a couple of years for my immune system to " bounce " back or something to that effect.. No real treatment(s) as we all know. Just try this then that...months and years go back and we continue to suffer. Who said life is fair?! Quote
Guest guest Posted January 24, 2010 Report Posted January 24, 2010 5 miles a day??!! How about trying a mile a day and working up to 5 miles. That is absurd that a doctor would recommend that. If I had done that when I was first diagnosed, it would have sent me into a bad flareup. I highly recommend massage though and make sure you tell your massage therapist exactly where it hurts, the type of pain, what makes it worse and better, etc. Whitney in Portland 2010/1/20 Mindy Bledsoe > > > My Dr says walk 5 mi a day in the forest and you'll walk outta fibro pain > and c/f. I had a friend send me to her friend a special massuse who stood > on me and twisted me. Talk about the hit by a truck effect. I went about 5 > times OMG. I had to stop, that was NOT my answer. Mindy > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 25, 2010 Report Posted January 25, 2010 Even one mile a day is way toooo much-try a couple of city blocks a day at first. Remember not to walk too far as you have to get home too. Diane ________________________________ 5 miles a day??!! How about trying a mile a day and working up to 5 miles. That is absurd that a doctor would recommend that. If I had done that when I was first diagnosed, it would have sent me into a bad flareup. I highly recommend massage though and make sure you tell your massage therapist exactly where it hurts, the type of pain, what makes it worse and better, etc. Quote
Guest guest Posted January 28, 2010 Report Posted January 28, 2010 My new doctor recomends taking a bath in epson salts and then stretch as much as is comfoprtable,and that is all he wants me to do! Hugs Debbie ________________________________ 5 miles a day??!! How about trying a mile a day and working up to 5 miles. That is absurd that a doctor would recommend that. If I had done that when I was first diagnosed, it would have sent me into a bad flareup. I highly recommend massage though and make sure you tell your massage therapist exactly where it hurts, the type of pain, what makes it worse and better, etc. Quote
Guest guest Posted January 30, 2010 Report Posted January 30, 2010 I would just say go slow and if you hurt stop immediately. Who knows what you could work up to. Just don't overdo because it will really put you way back and it would take lots of time to recuperate. Debbie ________________________________ One of my closest friends in the world has been on a health kick since the summer. She and another friend are training for a half marathon. She was telling me today that she would like to help me get into the physical condition needed to do some of the jobs I am interested in after graduation. She asked about if I could go for a run or short hike or maybe a bike ride. She has also mentioned she was going to be jogging past my house on her way to visit the Humane Society in a bit of a hint that she wants me to come. I told her a few things today. Since I know she was genuinely curious and concerned I really wasn't upset by the offer. I might join her for a swim at the gym (if the cat will stop eating my swimsuits), but any other exercise I do needs to be limited in nature. I didn't want to go too into depth about it because we were at the career fair and supposed to be talking to organizations not each other. Quote
Guest guest Posted January 30, 2010 Report Posted January 30, 2010 I would just say go slow and if you hurt stop immediately. Who knows what you could work up to. Just don't overdo because it will really put you way back and it would take lots of time to recuperate. Debbie Quote
Guest guest Posted January 30, 2010 Report Posted January 30, 2010 My new Dr who I love wants me to take at least 1 hot bath with epson salts per day and then I need to stretch as much as I can with no pain. stop if it causes pain. Hugs Debbie liance , " " wrote: > > Because of post exertional fatigue you cannot just set an arbitrary goal - > you need to build up to see what you are able to do without relapse as if > you overdo it you could set yourself back for a very long time. It is very > individual and depends how bad your ME is. You also need to take into > account all the other things you do in the day that use energy as they count > towards the sum total. > > I am severely affected and so for me walking 15 paces and back is my norm > and I try to increase that as I feel able but if something unexpected causes > relapse (you cannot control life!) I have to start again to build up. > Von x > Please don't forget to search the net via > > http://www.everyclick.com/uk/meresearchuk/ > > and raise money for ME biomedical research just by clicking > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 1, 2010 Report Posted February 1, 2010 If you are already exhausted just by your daily activities then no way should you be going to the gym! You need to pace yourself and do little and often rather than travel to a gym and have a session! Do be very careful! > > I definately will work up to see what I can handle but as I say by the time I get dressed ( with the help of my hubby) I am exhausted. and then walking to my car which is about 20 yards away and I am done before we go anywhere. I am going to try to go to this gym my daughter found, a gym owned by a girl that has fibro so she has special programs just for fibro, and we shall see what I can do. lol > Love Debbie > ________________________________ > From: Veronicy hubby)<von@gotad will work up to see what I can handle but as I say juat the act of getting dressed (wit > way > Re: Excersise question > Because of post exertional fatigue you cannot just set an arbitrary goal - > you need to build up to see what you are able to do without relapse as if > you overdo it you could set yourself back for a very long time. It is very > individual and depends how bad your ME is. You also need to take into > account all the other things you do in the day that use energy as they count > towards the sum total. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 1, 2010 Report Posted February 1, 2010 Thats an interesting idea a lot of people with FM would not be able to get into a bath in the first place LOL! ----- Original Message ----- From: debbieg1711 My new Dr who I love wants me to take at least 1 hot bath with epson salts per day and then I need to stretch as much as I can with no pain. stop if it causes pain. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 2, 2010 Report Posted February 2, 2010 Very true I may take 15 steps 4 or5 times a day but when we go out just the act of getting dressed( with hubbys help) I am exhausted. Then to walk to my car which is a pretty good distance from my apartment. I'm done! we go to the store where I walk around for 10 minutes and we come home. After my huband undresses me and helps me get my jammies on I will lay down and take a 2 or 3 hour nap. Lots of hugs Debbie ________________________________ Because of post exertional fatigue you cannot just set an arbitrary goal - you need to build up to see what you are able to do without relapse as if you overdo it you could set yourself back for a very long time. It is very individual and depends how bad your ME is. You also need to take into account all the other things you do in the day that use energy as they count towards the sum total. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 4, 2010 Report Posted February 4, 2010 Pushing yourself with FM is just a bad idea sorry to tell you but try this method - say you do some exercise do 2 reps (no joke) maybe 2 on each arm and then something for each leg then when you are comfortably able to do that and I mean comfortably in the sense that the pain increases a little but goes down within a couple hours a day at the most and this could take 5-6 weeks for some people then go to 3 reps and do the same thing. I did rehab I was pushed beyond belief I have CFS as well as having the mix up with my meds but I was really pushed beyond belief and 5 days after it finished I ended up with bad tremors which turned out to be dytonia which i reckon happened when i had the med mix up but anyway I am in a wheelchair!!!! If they didn't push me so hard who knows perhaps I would still be able to walk. I understand you want to get stronger so do I I do hydro but I do it like i said 5 mins a week and then I did it for like 6-8 weeks in a row but didn't increase it because the reaction I got was so bad from 5 mins now i couldn't bare doing any less than 5 mins but remember I had to get dressed be in the car for half an hour get into the pool in the lifter and then come home have a shower its not really 5 mins!!! I hope this helps. I really dont think your situation is the same as mine but a relapse is a relapse and I would hate for you to get sicker and I hope this helps and makes sense. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 4, 2010 Report Posted February 4, 2010 Just other conditions as well as FM I am in a wheelchair due to other stuff but had trouble for ages before this. If you didn't have a partner to help I would be stuffed with the bath! ----- Original Message ----- From: Deb Gn And the reason they cant get into a bath, as I have it very severe and with the help of my husband I do just fine!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Debbie Quote
Guest guest Posted February 4, 2010 Report Posted February 4, 2010 I didn't say you weren't supposed to I was suggesting that with immense pain and fatigue it would be difficult to get into the bath in the first place. I am in a wheelchair and I have enough trouble transferring to a shower chair but before all this I still found it difficult to get into a bath. if you have a partner to help then I guess its OK mine has helped me more than once. ----- Original Message ----- From: Deb Gn Why are we not supposed to take a bath? Quote
Guest guest Posted February 5, 2010 Report Posted February 5, 2010 Very true I may take 15 steps 4 or5 times a day but when we go out just the act of getting dressed( with hubbys help) I am exhausted. Then to walk to my car which is a pretty good distance from my apartment. I'm done! we go to the store where I walk around for 10 minutes and we come home. After my huband undresses me and helps me get my jammies on I will lay down and take a 2 or 3 hour nap. Lots of hugs Debbie ________________________________ From: <von@... <mailto:von%40gotadsl.co.uk> > Because of post exertional fatigue you cannot just set an arbitrary goal - you need to build up to see what you are able to do without relapse as if you overdo it you could set yourself back for a very long time. It is very individual and depends how bad your ME is. You also need to take into account all the other things you do in the day that use energy as they count towards the sum total. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.