Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Starvation/Thyroid Function/Vegetarians

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

I don't buy the fact that vegetarian eating is the quickest way to

hypothyroidism. I think you can eat plenty of PROTEIN being a

vegetarian, BUT you do have to pay attention to how much you're

eating. I've had a lot of friends who are vegetarians and they all

say it is hard for them to eat enough protein. BUT if you know how

much protein is in certain foods, such as beans, you have to make

sure you get enough.

Starvation: we're ALL starving! Even the " fat " people ( and I say

that kindly as I am one who is " morbidly obese " according to medical

standards ( at 188 pounds). We are all starving because the food we

eat is not FEEDING us...even if it is organic...if it is PICKED GREEN

and shipped is has lost most of the nutrient value by the time you

see it. I can't stress this enough. When the food we eat is not

feeding us, the hunger switch stays on. We usually eat until we're

full..not because we're being fed and the hunger switch says " ok

we've had plenty of nutrition, we can stop eating now. " People who

are overweight are that way because the body, that is not being fed

nutrients in the food, will hold on to EVERYTHING you eat, because it

IS BEING STARVED.

Just my 2 cents worth.

~Amy~

In Missouri

> >

>

Guest guest
Posted

Hi, I don't know who started this subject or brought up the concern with thyroid disease and or starvation and being a vegetarian. I have been a vegetarian since 1970, and the only time I went back to eating meat was for about 4 months while pregnant with my son in 1975, because I was so anemic and back then, that was the only option I was given. As soon as he was born, back off the meat and quick. I was also down to 100 pds when I got pregnant with him and gained 60 pds, which was loss quicklly. He weighed 9 pds and 10 oz, and when It was my six week checkup, I was back to 134 pds already. At five feet eight, I stayed this weight give or take 5 pds more or less for 20 years and probably was feeling " Pre-hypothyroid state." I began showing symptons in 1997, and it was allways brushed off as , " just getting older, close to Menopause, etc, etc." Finally in 2000 someone

was actually listening to my symptons and took some tests and I was diagnosed with Hypothyroidism, Hashimotos. It was one of the happiest days of my last few years, only because I knew I was not going crazy and there was a reason for what had been Slowly happening to me. So now it has been almost eight years of diagnois of thyroid problems, so the question of there being a connection between having a vegetarian diet and the quicker route to Thyroid disease, is certainly not true in my case. I was 46 when diagnosed, and from what I have read and heard, that is not early by any means. I totally agree with Amelia about being able to get all the protein you want on a Vegetarian diet, but if you dont know what you are doing, you do need to read labels, find a good cookbook or just learn about Complete Proteins and HOW MUCH PROTEIN is in what you eat. I use to read and look at

labels, but after being a vegetarian for so long, it is second nature by now, I never worry or measure things out as far as worrying about how much protein *I am getting. My husband eats meat and has been trying to get me to eat meat, fish or chicken for the 15 years we have been together and married. He was convinced that there was no way I was getting the Protein or noutrients I needed. It was only after blood tests for protein an other Metabolic Panels, and CBCs, that he saw I was healthy as can be, and in fact my diet was Better than his . His Lipids were Sky high! My Cholesteral , LDL, and other lipids were high far before I was diagnosed with Hashimotos, and part of it is genetic, my dad died of heart disease at 60.I am on meds to lower my lipids and take so many suppliments, it makes me sick.( not literally, but I hate taking them, but my husband thinks he is

taking care of my health, so who am I to argue?, it shows he cares. ) My husband has finally given up on trying to convert me to meat, or to eat chicken or fish, I won't do it for him or anyone except myself, if an when I ever change my mind, which I will not. Amelia is right about a lot of what she says about Starvation. You can be eating 3 meals a day, having snacks and think you are eating healthy, and going to the gym and getting plenty of fresh air and exercise. But if you are not eating Healthy Dense Nutrient rich foods, your body is still being starved. Have you ever just craved a certain food such as spinach, or a glass of fresh Orange Juice, or ( if you eat meat ) fresh fish from the ocean? Do you remember how you felt after eating or drinking what you were craving? ( and I do not mean craving a Big Mac or bowl of Ben and Jerry Ice Cream. The reason you felt better after indesting your food or drink, is because it is what your body was Crying out for. Remember our ancestors were not farmers, but Hunter Gathers long, long ago. So the foods we ate and what our bodies needed were what we hunted and what we picked or gathered as we migrated or moved .There were no candy, ice cream, no hamburgers, hotdogs, chips, soft drinks, cookies, sweet cereals, or processed foods. Everything was fresh and fresh picked. The way it was meant to be . There were no obese people ( unless it was a severe metabolic disease) people didn't have the advantage of storing fat, they couldn't afford to lose any weight, if was feast or famine. In times of famine, you died. There also was no need for pesticides, or artificial colors, flavors, etc. Look back a

hundred years or so, how many cases of heart disease did you hear of? How much Diabetes was there? These are Modern diseases, just as I believe Thyroid Disease in general is a Modern Disease. I don't think Hypothryoidism or Hyperthyroidism were prevalant a hundred years ago, I think thyroid disease would have been the " rarity,j' no;t something to be expected if you are a woman over 50. I think I have transgressed a little here, part of the " Brain fog" of thyroid problems, but I think you understand my train of thought, To shorten everything, I agree with Amelia that being a Vegetarian has nothing to do with increasing your chances of acquiring Thyroid disease any quicker than someone who eats meat. Also you can get the amount of protein you need quite easily being a vegetarian and it is easier than you think. I am not even going to comment more on the Starvation

issue, as I think it speaks for itself, and having been on a diet more than 40 years, and regardless of whether I weigh 100 pds, or my current 164 pds , dieting to me is part of a mental state of mind and way of life which has taken up way to much importance in my life. I now am trying to focus on getting in shape, and staying healthy, which in turn will take care of any excess pounds I want to lose, they will drop as I exercise and get in better shape. So Ameilia gave her 2 Cents worth, and now you have my " food for thought" as well. Patcat Amelia wrote: I don't buy the fact that vegetarian eating is the quickest way to hypothyroidism. I think you can eat plenty of PROTEIN being a vegetarian, BUT you do have to pay attention to how much you're eating. I've had a lot of friends who are vegetarians and they all say it is hard for them to eat enough protein. BUT if you know how much protein is in certain foods, such as beans, you have to make sure you get enough. Starvation: we're ALL starving! Even the "fat" people ( and I say that kindly as I am one who is "morbidly obese" according to medical standards ( at 188 pounds). We are all starving because the food we eat is not FEEDING us...even if it is organic...if it is PICKED GREEN and shipped is has lost most of the nutrient value by the time you see it. I can't stress this enough. When the food we eat is

not feeding us, the hunger switch stays on. We usually eat until we're full..not because we're being fed and the hunger switch says "ok we've had plenty of nutrition, we can stop eating now." People who are overweight are that way because the body, that is not being fed nutrients in the food, will hold on to EVERYTHING you eat, because it IS BEING STARVED.Just my 2 cents worth.~Amy~In Missouri> >>

Guest guest
Posted

It all depends on your metabolic type. Some people can do well as

vegetarians, particularly if they are ovo-lacto.

But according to statistics I have read about 50 % of the population

will not do well. I didn't. And I WAS starving for protein.

Vegetarianism, let alone strict veganism is simply not for everyone. It

isn't for me, and I DID get very ill from it.

You didn't. It doesn't mean your diet is healthier than mine. It just

means your diet works for you. My current diet works for me.

Congratulations to both of us for having found what works.

FWIW, I don't tell anyone else to eat meat or dairy, or anything. I

recommend people to find their metabolic type, and eat for it. I simply

warn people that vegetariansm isn't for everyone, which it is not.

However, I no longer think soy in the form of non-fermented soy, which

these days includes nearly all tofu, and includes hydrolyzed soy

proteins, is good for any human.

I do not apologize for needing to eat meat, or for using dairy. If I had

thrived as a vegetarian and later as a vegan, I'd still be one.

recovering vegetarian,

sol

Guest guest
Posted

Thank you for saying this, sol.

I have tried to be vegetarian several times and just

did not feel well at all. My body does seem to need

animal protein.

I have come to believe there is no one size fits all

way of eating. Over the years I have discovered what

works best for me- it often does not agree with the

popular thinking of the moment.

I feel my absolute best with lean meats, fresh fruits

and vegetables. That's it. The more I eat of

anything else- the more I want it and the worse I

feel.

--- sol wrote:

> It all depends on your metabolic type. Some people

> can do well as

> vegetarians, particularly if they are ovo-lacto.

> But according to statistics I have read about 50 %

> of the population

> will not do well. I didn't. And I WAS starving for

> protein.

>

> Vegetarianism, let alone strict veganism is simply

> not for everyone. It

> isn't for me, and I DID get very ill from it.

> You didn't. It doesn't mean your diet is healthier

> than mine. It just

> means your diet works for you. My current diet works

> for me.

> Congratulations to both of us for having found what

> works.

>

> FWIW, I don't tell anyone else to eat meat or dairy,

> or anything. I

> recommend people to find their metabolic type, and

> eat for it. I simply

> warn people that vegetariansm isn't for everyone,

> which it is not.

> However, I no longer think soy in the form of

> non-fermented soy, which

> these days includes nearly all tofu, and includes

> hydrolyzed soy

> proteins, is good for any human.

>

> I do not apologize for needing to eat meat, or for

> using dairy. If I had

> thrived as a vegetarian and later as a vegan, I'd

> still be one.

> recovering vegetarian,

> sol

>

>

>

>

>

________________________________________________________________________________\

____

Looking for last minute shopping deals?

Find them fast with Yahoo! Search.

http://tools.search.yahoo.com/newsearch/category.php?category=shopping

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...