Guest guest Posted December 25, 2010 Report Posted December 25, 2010 From: contact@... Factual Inaccuracy, Dr Shepherd and the UK MEOpathy Association Dear all, On 22 December 2010 I posted an item on CoCure entitled *Response Re Pinching at the MEopathy Association - XMRV has no role in ME/CFS...* The text was also posted on various other websites. The CoCure post detail is as follows and the post is reproduced in full below as reference to it is important for what I have to say in this post. I gave permission for my post to be reposted. CoCure Item #024356, 22 December 2010, ACT: Response Re Pinching at the MEopathy Association - XMRV has no role in ME/CFS... http://www.co-cure.org/ On 24 December 2010, Dr Shepherd of the UK Myalgic EncephalOPATHY Association posted an item on CoCure entitled *MEA coverage of the latest research on XMRV.* The CoCure post detail is as follows and the post is also reproduced in full below as reference to it is important for what I have to say in this post. Note that Dr Shepherd clearly states that his post *MAY BE REPOSTED*. CoCure Item #024367, 24 December 2010, ACT: MEA coverage of the latest research on XMRV http://www.co-cure.org/ In his said 24 December post Dr Shepherd says: *Before anyone else sends me an abusive email over Christmas please could they note that the statement that has been sent round the internet by Short relating to the ME Association coverage of the latest XMRV research findings published in Retrovirology contains a number of factual inaccuracies.* I would firstly wish to make it clear that I do not condone anyone sending Dr Shepherd abusive emails and would emphatically advise all ME patients NOT to do this. Secondly, Dr Shepherd says that my said statement *contains a number of factual inaccuracies.* He goes on to say *The ME Association did not commission or request a commentary on these papers from Professor Tony Pinching. This commentary was provided for the Kent and Sussex ME Society. The link to the Kent and Sussex ME Society is* For the record, I did NOT say that Professor Pinching's article was commissioned exclusively for the Myalgic EncephalOPATHY Association. Neither did I say that the MEA requested Pinching's article, as Dr Shepherd seems to be claiming, I did. Moreover, I pasted the Pinching article, as it appeared on the MEA website, in full - and within my posting and at the end of the Pinching posting it clearly states: *Professor J Pinching*, *21 December 2010*, *Prof Pinching is a medical advisor to the Sussex & Kent ME/CFS Society*, *www.measussex.org.uk*. I therefore gave as much information about the source of the article as the MEA website did. My phrase *Pinching just happened to provide an 'XMRV Update...' article (see below) for the Myalgic EncephalOPATHY Association* is subject to semantic interpretation here. Pinching was the author of the article the MEA website published and Pinching has a direct and long-standing association with the Kent & Sussex ME/CFS Society [1 -see endnotes below]. Given Dr Shepherd is emphatically saying *The ME Association did not commission or request a commentary on these papers from Professor Tony Pinching then one has to conclude someone sent it to the MEA of their own accord. Presumably it therefore was the Sussex & Kent ME/CFS Society / Pinching that sent the article to the MEA? Perhaps Dr Shepherd and his Myalgic EncephalOPATHY Association can specify which? Dr Shepherd goes on to say *We believe in publishing a wide spectrum of information and opinion in our news section. We do not believe that we should censor material because we take the position that people with ME/CFS have a right to know what a variety of clinicians and researchers are saying about new research findings involving XMRV - even though they may not agree with the opinions being expressed.* Let me be quite clear, I emphatically do not believe the MEA should engage in censorship either, I never called for this and it is misleading if Dr Shepherd is claiming that I did. I also most certainly think that UK ME patients need to be aware both that Professor Pinching is presenting demonstrable misinformation relating to gamma retroviral research and should be aware of his questionable role in ME matters more generally [1 - see endnote below]. How the Pinching article got to the MEA is a minor point. My primary complaint against the Myalgic EncephalOPATHY Association website was, and is, that when crucial gamma retroviral research was, in my view, misrepresented in the Retrovirology journal and certainly misrepresented in much of the mainstream international press from 21 and 22 December respectively, The MEA website emphatically did NOT give: *a wide spectrum of information and opinion in our [its] news section.* On the contrary, it gave prime coverage on the matter on 20 & 21 December to two highly misleading and controversial articles, first from the Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute and second from Professor Pinching: *New UK study casts doubts on the link between XMRV and ME/CFS by tonybritton on December 20, 2010 Press release issued by the Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute, 20 December 2010 Chronic Fatigue Syndrome is not caused by XMRV New research shows XMRV virus is a lab contaminant A virus previously thought to be associated with chronic fatigue syndrome is not the cause of the disease, a detailed study has shown. The research shows that cell samples used in previous research were contaminated with the virus identified as XMRV and that XMRV is present in the mouse genome...* http://www.meassociation.org.uk/?p=3548 *XMRV update: comment from Professor Tony Pinching by tonybritton on December 21, 2010 Since the original study suggesting a possible link between CFS/ME and the XMRV retrovirus, there have been six published reports from reputable groups in three continents that have failed to find evidence of this virus. These studies have used appropriate techniques in well characterised CFS/ME patients. One study found evidence of two different retroviruses, the significance of which is unclear. Four very recent further studies (two of them including as author one of the original commentators on the first report) have provided strong evidence to suggest that laboratory and/or reagent contamination are the likely explanation for the original findings...* http://www.meassociation.org.uk/?p=3581 Please note: In spite of the fact that both Dr Judy Mikovits and Dr Kenny De Meirlier immediately posted rebuttals to the Retrovirology articles (they were so misleading that Dr Meirleir quite rightly called them *a crime against humanity*) and that these rebuttals were posted widely on ME lists to which Dr Shepherd subscribes, The MEA website did NOT carry their comments to balance those of the Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute and Pinching. In fact, in spite of my drawing Dr Shepherd's attention to such MEA website imbalance on 22 December on the UK LocalME weblist, to which he subscribes and to which he responded, the MEA website still did not correct the imbalance and then went on to post further one-sided disinformation the next day in the form of coverage by the BBC: *ME, or chronic fatigue syndrome, 'not caused by virus', say researchers – BBC News by tonybritton on December 22, 2010 From BBC News Online (story by Helen Briggs, health reporter). Updated version of story first published on 20 December,2010. A new study has cast further doubt on the idea that a virus called XMRV causes chronic fatigue syndrome. US scientists linked the condition, also known as ME, to a mouse-like virus in 2009 after finding it in blood samples. Now, UK experts say the discovery was a *false positive*, caused by cross contamination in the lab. The illness may still be caused by a virus, they say, but not the one at the centre of recent controversy. Our conclusion is quite simple: XMRV is not the cause of chronic fatigue syndrome,* said Professor Greg owers...* http://www.meassociation.org.uk/?p=3601 I hope that readers will take detailed note that it was not until AFTER I and others had publicly and strongly complained about the balance of the Myalgic EncephalOPATHY website coverage of the Retrovirology Journal's and others claims on *XMRV Contamination* that some of that balance eventually began to be redressed on the MEA website from December 23rd onwards. I simply do not believe such delay in giving balanced coverage on such a crucially important matter is good enough given all the money the MEA receives from ME patients in order to act as its advocate. Many other ME organisations that receive much less funding, or none at all for that matter, were able to give more balanced website coverage - including the Mikovits & De Meirleir rebuttals. Why not the MEA? Particularly given it has a de-facto role as a virtual media clearing-house in the UK given journalists lo to its website for as a main source of ME/CFS comment. That is why I said *Where is the editorial comment from Dr Shepherd and his MEOpathy Association giving a more balanced view of matters and pointing out the blatant inaccuracies in Pinching's article? Pinching's article and the MEOpathy website it is on is not only failing to do right by ME patients it is misleading both them and the public. With 'friends' like that who needs enemies?* The fact is, not only was Dr Shepherd and the MEA failing to post balancing and important comments by Drs Mikovits and De Meirleir and others on December 22nd on the MEA website, Dr Shepherd was actively drawing attention to the said highly misleading article by Professor Pinching. If the MEA do not *censor* on their website then they were certainly engaging in poor, imbalanced and misleading editorial practice in not posting the comments of Mikovits and De Meirlier. My complaint in my said posting of 22 December therefore was: *Dr Shepherd is posting on the internet (LocalME UK at Yahoo Groups 22 December 2010) notice of the fact that Professor Pinching just happened to provide an *XMRV Update...* article (see below) for the Myalgic EncephalOPATHY Association on the day that five decidedly dodgy *XMRV is all just lab contamination* papers/articles appeared courtesy of Retrovirology (followed the day after by further outstanding examples of grossly imbalanced British Journalism on the matter at the BBC, Guardian and elsewhere).* As said, I did NOT claim the Pinching article was provided exclusively for the MEA and my posting contained information on the Sussex & Kent ME/CFS Society source. I think that my primary concerns on its content and MEA website imbalanced coverage of it were fully justified. I also stated in my said 22 December post that *I think that UK Myalgic EncephaloMYELITIS patients would be much, MUCH better off giving their money to the charities 'Invest in ME' and 'ME Research UK' than to the decidedly failed and lukewarm so-called advocacy outfit that is the Myalgic EncephalOPATHY Association. I emphatically stand by such views. The one major oversight was that I should have added that, in my humble opinion, UK ME patients would be much better off in the long rung giving money to the Whittemore Institute for research than to the Myalgic EncephalOPATHY Association. I am happy to correct that oversight now. Please DO donate to the WPI at: http://www.wpinstitute.org/help/index.html Short. 25 December 2010. contact@... [Permission to repost] `````````` [ CoCure Item #024367, 24 December 2010, ACT: MEA coverage of the latest research on XMRV http://www.co-cure.org/ ] Date: Fri, 24 Dec 2010 13:33:38 -0000 From: Shepherd Subject: ACT: MEA coverage of the latest research on XMRV MAY BE REPOSTED Before anyone else sends me an abusive email over Christmas please could they note that the statement that has been sent round the internet by Short relating to the ME Association coverage of the latest XMRV research findings published in Retrovirology contains a number of factual inaccuracies. The ME Association did not commission or request a commentary on these papers from Professor Tony Pinching. This commentary was provided for the Kent and Sussex ME Society. The link to the Kent and Sussex ME Society is clearly included at the end of the commentary. The comments from Professor Pinching were placed in the MEA website news section as part of our coverage of the latest research papers that have been published in Retrovirology. We believe in publishing a wide spectrum of information and opinion in our news section. We do not believe that we should censor material because we take the position that people with ME/CFS have a right to know what a variety of clinicians and researchers are saying about new research findings involving XMRV - even though they may not agree with the opinions being expressed. In the case of the Retrovirology papers we published the Wellcome Trust press release along with the statement from the WPI. We have also provided links to, or republished, a number of other news items, blogs, videos (including the Nevada TV interview with Annette Whittemore and Dr Judy Mikovits (http://www.meassociation.org.uk/?p=3D3641) etc relating to this research. The MEA coverage is therefore balanced. I have also been in contact with the BBC about their on-line coverage of the Retrovirology papers and this has resulted in some additional balancing comment being placed at the end of in this website item: http://www.meassociation.org.uk/?p=3D3601 The latest XMRV summary from the MEA can be found here: http://www.meassociation.org.uk/?p=3D2240 This will shortly be updated to include the latest papers in Retrovirology. People are obviously free to choose where they send donations for research. The MEA has made it clear that the Ramsay Research Fund is keen to fund good quality applications which will help to resolve the uncertainty over XMRV and ME/CFS and we have been in discussion with various retrovirologists as to what form this might take. We are currently funding a study into muscle abnormalities in ME/CFS. Our major fundraising initiatives at present are to set up a UK biobank (which will hopefully start next year) and a post-mortem and tissue bank. Results from post-mortems that have already taken place were presented at an international research meeting in Australia in early December http://bit.ly/dEKUE6 More information on the Ramsay Research Fund can be found here: http://www.meassociation.org.uk/?page_id=3D1086 Dr Shepherd Hon Medical Adviser, MEA 24 December 2010 http://www.meassociation.org.uk `````````` [CoCure Item #024356, 22 December 2010, ACT: Response Re Pinching at the MEopathy Association - XMRV has no role in ME/CFS... http://www.co-cure.org/ ] Date: Wed, 22 Dec 2010 12:42:24 +0000 From: *contact@...* Subject: ACT: Response Re Pinching at the MEopathy Association - XMRV has no role in ME/CFS... Dear All, Dr Shepherd of the UK Myalgic EncephalOPATHY Association has taken exception to my below posting of 22 December 2010 entitled *Pinching at the MEopathy Association - XMRV has no role in ME/CFS...* He responds with the following explanation/excuse on the internet today for the MEA's recent website coverage of the XMRV/Retrovirology issue: *The MEA has a rolling news service on its website. We publish articles and news items which we feel will be of interest to the whole ME community and this involves publishing a wide spectrum of information and comment. We do not censor material that is likely to be of interest.* The only coverage however of the recent Retrovirology Journal/XMRV *contamination* matters on the MEA website that I could find at the time of me writing this however was decidedly one-sided, highly misleading and consisted of only two articles: the aforementioned one by Professor Pinching and the press-release by the Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute (posted below). I'm sorry but it is simply not good enough for the MEA website to be giving one-sided partial coverage of such matters. There were plenty of other views that would be *of interest to the whole ME community* such as the responses of Dr Mikovits and Dr De Meileir. Why did the MEA website not publish these? The ME Association and Dr Shepherd are supposed to be advocating for patients, not allowing their website to be used as a one-sided platform for those who are misrepresenting the science and potential dangers of XMRV and other retroviruses in ME. Dr Shepherd also states of me that *I know you don't like the MEA...* It is not however a case of me not personally liking the MEA because of some irrational vendetta, it is far more serious in that I think the MEA has simply not been doing an adequate advocacy job for patients who pay them to do so. On balance, I think the MEA has very badly let patients down over the years. Both the ME Association and Dr Shepherd unfortunately have a long-standing highly questionable record regarding their role in matters ME in my view and I say again, do please lo at the section on British ME charities in the document entitled 'Corporate Collusion' at: http://www.meactionuk.org.uk/Corporate_Collusion_2.htm Follow the paper trail on this generally in the documents section at: http://www.meactionuk.org.uk Enough really is enough as far as I am concerned. I again call on all UK ME patients to stop giving their money to the ME Association and instead use it far more productively by donating it to: The Whittemore Institute: http://www.wpinstitute.org/ Invest in ME: http://www.investinme.org/index.htm ME Research UK: http://www.meresearch.org.uk/ Short 22 December 2010 contact@... [Permission to repost]. `````````` From the MEA Website 22 December 2010: *New UK study casts doubts on the link between XMRV and ME/CFS on December 20th, 2010 New UK study casts doubts on the link between XMRV and ME/CFS by tonybritton on December 20, 2010 Press release issued by the Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute, 20 December 2010 http://www.meassociation.org.uk/?p=3D3548 Chronic Fatigue Syndrome is not caused by XMRV New research shows XMRV virus is a lab contaminant A virus previously thought to be associated with chronic fatigue syndrome is not the cause of the disease, a detailed study has shown. The research shows that cell samples used in previous research were contaminated with the virus identified as XMRV and that XMRV is present in the mouse genome. XMRV was first linked to chronic fatigue syndrome - also known as myalgic encephalomyelitis (ME) - in a study published in October 2009, where blood samples from chronic fatigue syndrome patients were found to have traces of the virus. XMRV had also been identified previously in samples from certain prostate cancer patients. The new study, published in Retrovirology, identifies the source of XMRV in chronic fatigue syndrome samples as being cells or mouse DNA rather than infection by XMRV. The research does not rule out a virus cause of chronic fatigue syndrome =96 it is simply not this virus. The research team developed improved methods to detect XMRV against the genetic noise of other sequences and make recommendations for future study of virus causes of human disease. *Our conclusion is quite simple: XMRV is not the cause of chronic fatigue syndrome*, says Professor Greg Towers, a Wellcome Trust Senior Research Fellow at University College London (UCL). *All our evidence shows that the sequences from the virus genome in cell culture have contaminated human chronic fatigue syndrome and prostate cancer samples. *It is vital to understand that we are not saying chronic fatigue syndrome does not have a virus cause we cannot answer that yet but we know it is not this virus causing it*. The team, from University College London, Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute and University of Oxford, showed clearly that the experimental design of previous studies would pick up sequences that resembled XMRV; however, in this improved study, they could prove that the signal was from contamination by a laboratory cell line or mouse DNA. The sequences from the contaminated cell line and chronic fatigue patient samples were extremely similar, contrary to the pattern of evolution expected during the infectious spread of a virus in a human population. They also showed that the existing methods would indicate that one in fifty human cell lines they examined were infected with XMRV-related viruses: they showed that contamination of human tumour cells with XMRV-related viruses is common and that a principal prostate cancer line used is contaminated. *When we compare viral genomes, we see signs of their history, of how far they have travelled in space or time*, says Dr Sephane Hue, Post Doctoral Researcher at UCL. *We would expect the samples from patients from around the world, collected at different times, to be more diverse than the samples from within a cell line in a lab, where they are grown under standard conditions. During infection and transmission in people, our immune system would push XMRV into new genetic variants. *Viral infection is a battle between the virus and the host and XMRV does not have the scars of a virus that transmits between people*. Together the results demonstrate that XMRV does not cause chronic fatigue syndrome or prostate cancer in these cases. The team's methods suggest ways to ensure that virus contamination does not confound the search for a cause of disease in future work. The authors propose that more rigorous methods are used to prevent contamination of cell and DNA samples. They also suggest that consistent and considered standards are needed for identifying viruses and other organisms as cause of a disease. *Increasingly, we are using DNA-based methods to accelerate our understanding of the role of pathogens in disease, explains Professor Kellam, Virus Genomics group leader from the Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute. *These will drive our understanding of infection, but we mus= t ensure that we close the circle from identification to association and then causation. The strongest lesson is that we must fully use robust guidelines and discriminatory methods to ascribe a cause to a disease.* `````````` Pinching at the MEopathy Association - XMRV has no role in ME/CFS... Dear All, Dr Shepherd is posting on the internet (LocalME UK at Yahoo Groups 22 December 2010) notice of the fact that Professor Pinching just happened to provide an *XMRV Update...* article (see below) for the Myalgic EncephalOPATHY Association on the day that five decidedly dodgy *XMRV is all just lab contamination* papers/articles appeared courtesy of Retrovirology (followed the day after by further outstanding examples of grossly imbalanced British Journalism on the matter at the BBC, Guardian and elsewhere). Professor Pinching concludes in his MEA article: *The current view of informed observers is that the research evidence does not support the idea that XMRV or other retroviruses have a role in the causation or manifestations of CFS/ME.* What utter rubbish! *informed observers*! If you want to know what genuinely informed observers really think then go to: http://bit.ly/h5jbJy http://on.fb.me/g6OT4p http://www.wpinstitute.org/index.html http://bit.ly/hlU44f Call me a cynic but such Pinching/MEOpathy coverage seems more than a tad imbalanced to me and out of place for an organisation that's supposed to be advocating for sound science and proper treatment for ME patients. Where is the editorial comment from Dr Shepherd and his MEOpathy Association giving a more balanced view of matters and pointing out the blatant inaccuracies in Pinching's article? Pinching's article and the MEOpathy website it is on, is not only failing to do right by ME patients it is misleading both them and the public. With 'friends' like that who needs enemies? Here's a personal opinion for free. I think that UK Myalgic EnephaloMYELITIS patients would be much, MUCH better off giving their money to the charities 'Invest in ME' and 'ME Research UK' than to the decidedly failed and lukewarm so-called advocacy outfit that is the Myalgic EncephalOPATHY Association. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.