Guest guest Posted December 21, 2010 Report Posted December 21, 2010 http://bit.ly/g6OT4p XMRV Global Action's Response to the CBC News Coverage of Retrovirology on XMRV By XMRV Global Action Tuesday, 21 December 2010 Here is our full response to the CBC's journalistic embarrassment: " Chronic fatigue virus study tainted " . You can view and comment on the December 20th CBC News article here: (Here is our full response to the CBC's journalistic embarrassment: " Chronic fatigue virus study tainted " . You can view and comment on the December 20th CBC News article here: http://bit.ly/huueDn Feel free to copy/paste (with credit to XMRV Global Action and a link to this page please), for your blogs or letters to the media. CBC's COVERAGE OF XMRV STORY TAINTED The CBC has sunk to a new low in journalism, with the publication of tripe on an issue that could be central not only to our economic recovery, but also our national security. The mere idea that a new retrovirus may have infected 10x more patients than HIV, that may have tainted our blood supply – AGAIN - , and that may be associated with multiple cancers and neuro-immune disease (including the most aggressive prostate cancers, and 25% of breast cancers, including infectious breast cancer) merits no less than fastidious, rigorous, balanced coverage. What the CBC has offered instead, is empty spin on a sloth's timetable. Shame! A few facts are in order. SENSATIONALISTIC TITLE DOES NOT EQUAL FACT Firstly, the sensationalistic title, " Chronic Fatigue Virus Study Tainted " is not supported by the Retrovirology findings. As et al commented in Retrovirology: http://bit.ly/ieHHFe " Collectively, these results cast serious doubts on the PCR evidence used to support claims of MLV-related viruses in prostate cancer and CFS patients. " SCIENCE RESEARCH ON XMRV/CFS USED 4 METHODS It is abundantly evident that the CBC hasn't taken the time to do their due journalistic diligence. The Lombardi et al. Science article – unlike the " zero/zero " rebuttal studies, used FOUR methods of detection including: 1. PCR to detect viral genome in tissue or peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs); 2. Viral culture (growing the virus); and counting it (real-time PCR) to demonstrate viraemia (actual viral nucleic acid) in plasma; 3. Immunofluorescence to demonstrate viral antigen; and 4. Serology to demonstrate a host response to infection (detecting antibodies to XMRV, indicating a previous immune response) Additional précis of the flaws in the Retrovirology conclusions can be found here: http://bit.ly/gqO7wc CONTAMINANTS DON'T TRANSMIT INFECTIOUS VIRUS, NOR BUD ON ELECTRON MICROGRAPHS I would encourage the CBC to take a look at the following picture (Slide 4 from Dr D. 's presentation to the US Department of Health and Human Services http://bit.ly/g9dbov of a budding retrovirus, taken by the Lombardi team, after they transferred infectious XMRV to a prostate cell line. Since when does a lab contaminant generate infectious virus that can be transmitted from infected blood, grown, and photographed? MISSING: BALANCED INTERVIEWS WITH LEADING SCIENTISTS ON XMRV The CBC missed the opportunity to conduct real interviews which capture a balance of credible opinion on the emerging XMRV science. For example, they could have spoken with: DR IAN LIPKIN – US VIRUS HUNTER Dr Lipkin was the guru the US Government brough on board when they needed someone to investigate the SARS epidemic. From a recent email from Ian Lipkin: http://bit.ly/g0znZA " These papers emphasize the pitfalls of molecular assays and raise concerns. NONETHELESS, IT IS PREMATURE TO RULE OUT XMRV OR RELATED VIRUSES AS FACTORS IN PROSTATE CANCER OR CFS. Links have also been made based on serology and the presence of viral proteins as well as of viral sequences. Thus, we still need appropriately powered, rigorous blinded studies of well characterized patients and controls. One such study is underway under the auspices of the National Institutes Health. " Dr Lipkin will be presenting at a New York Academy of Sciences symposium entitled, " Pathogens in the Blood Supply " with Science co-author Dr Judy Mikovits on March 29, 2011 [http://bit.ly/dVSEnu]. Not the behavior you'd expect from someone who thinks XMRV is a contaminant. DR HARVEY ALTER: CO-DISCOVERER OF HEPATITIS-C His transcribed comment, made to the recent meeting of the U.S. HHS XMRV Blood Research Working Group [http://on.fb.me/f2vPy7]: " When a group finds a new agent, (they) become biased it's real. When it's not found by another group, they become even more biased it's unreal. Our goal should be to find the truth. The truth will out over the next year. I concur we have no evidence for causality, especially when we're at the limit of detection (LoD) and assay performance is so critical. But I still want to counter (the contamination argument) by saying that THE CURRENT EVIDENCE FOR DISEASE ASSOCIATION IS VERY STRONG THAT XMRV OR MLV IS STRONGLY ASSOCIATED WITH CFS. IN THOSE LABS WHO DO FIND THE AGENT (XMRV/MLV), IT'S VERY REPRODUCIBLE. YEAR AFTER YEAR, SAME PATIENTS. CONFIRMED BY SEQUENCING, REPRODUCIBLE OVER TIME. Dr. Hanson has demonstrated how critical the assays are. When tweaked assays, findings (are) identical to Lo (Lo/Alter) lab. (There is) diversity of XMRV/MLV being confirmed in WPI lab, so not only agent being confirmed there. In 100s of negative controls in same lab, extremely negative (for contamination), has done what Coffin recommended was also neg. Always negative for contamination. It isn't logical to suggest otherwise. Stoye used single-case anecdotal info to try to make a case (for contamination). Simply because it has happened in the past isn't valid to negate reproducible data from 4 different laboratories. I'm not a CFS Dr, but have learned a lot in last 6 months. Absolutely convinced when you define this (ME/CFS) by proper criteria, it's a very serious, medical disease. Characteristics of a viral disease. If it's not XMRV, we must continue the research to find out what is. " WHAT THE CBC SHOULD BE COVERING: OUR BLOOD SUPPLY MAY BE TAINTED WITH A NEW CANCER AND NEURO-IMMUNE DISEASE-CAUSING RETROVIRUS Where is the CBC's coverage on measures being taken around the world to protect the blood supply from XMRV and related Murine Leukemia Virus-related Viruses? Where is the coverage of the recent vote by the U.S. Health and Human Services Blood XMRV Scientific Working Group, which recommended in a 9 to 5 vote that the FDA add a screening question to identify and ban CFS patients from donating blood? Where is the CBC's coverage that Dr Coffin – one of the authors of the Retrovirology papers – voted FOR this ban? Where is the coverage that Luc Montagnier (co-discoverer of HIV) has joined the European Society for Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (aka the neuro-immune disease ME/CFS), whose Think Tank recently called for a Europe-wide ban of donations by CFS patients [http://www.esme-eu.com/ ] because of risk from the XMRV/MLV retroviruses? XMRV HAS BEEN FOUND IN THE MOST AGGRESSIVE PROSTATE CANCERS AND IN 25% OF BREAST CANCERS One of the most fascinating accounts of this research can be seen in a patent application by noted XMRV researcher Dr Ila Singh, who has been researching XMRV in prostate cancer, in cadavers, and in CFS. XMRV was found in a staggering 25% of breast cancers. A summary of the patent, with links, can be viewed here: [http://on.fb.me/gQXAKD]. COULD XMRV BE THE ROOT OF INFECTIOUS BREAST CANCER? Could Ila Singh's research provide the answer to a notorious Australian breast cancer cluster in a confined workspace that was featured on the Passionate eye: " Catching Cancer " this summer (http://bit.ly/hFWjfB )? If ME/CFS could be potentially casually transmitted in infectious clusters (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rBiwNmv1Wns ), such as the constrained staffroom of a school in Truckee, might it be possible for XMRV/MVV-related breast cancer, possibly a different strain, to be transmitted similarly? " Sixteen women working in this building developed breast cancer. Most were young. None had a family history of the disease. And many of them sat around THIS desk. The possibility of this being chance is literally one in a million…. The entire site was evacuated in December 2006. The cause remains a mystery. One controversial theory is that the cancer is caused by a virus… perhaps even a MOUSE virus. " You can read a discussion about it here: [http://on.fb.me/eIASry] SMALL CHANGES IN XMRV VIRUS AND HOST CHARACTERISTICS COULD CAUSE MANY DISEASES A fascinating research paper [http://bit.ly/i6KU0H] recently outlined how X/P MLV's could cause a variety of diseases – exactly what we are finding associated with XMRV/MLV's. " The xenotropic/polytropic subgroup of mouse leukemia viruses (MLVs) all rely on the XPR1 receptor for entry, but these viruses vary in tropism, distribution among wild and laboratory mice, pathogenicity, strategies used for transmission, and sensitivity to host restriction factors…. The co-evolution of these viruses with their receptor and other host factors that affect their replication has produced a heterogeneous group of viruses capable of inducing various diseases. " LEADING UNIVERSITIES ARE TAKING XMRV and ME/CFS VERY SERIOUSLY Stanford University is just one example of a center which is expanding their Infectious Diseases department to study viral/bacterial and retroviral factors causing ME/CFS, Chronic Lyme, MS, and other infection-associated diseases. Dr Montoya, a renowned Stanford researcher would make an excellent interviewee – if the CBC would expand their journalistic approach of copy/paste to include actual interviews. Similarly, the Li Kai Shing Institute of Virology in Edmonton is spearheading research into XMRV and ME/CFS which includes cytokine arrays, XMRV/MLV evaluation. Where is the coverage on this seminal research? A MODEL FOR THE CBC TO FOLLOW: THE WALL STREET JOURNAL'S COVERAGE OF XMRV Anyone wanting serious, balanced coverage of the unfolding XMRV story is encouraged to turn to the Wall Street Journal, particularly Amy Dockser-Marcus' blog on the issue. Excerpts from her latest article on the Retrovirology rebuttals http://on.wsj.com/hfmbPT " (The Retrovirology papers) are unlikely to resolve the debate over whether XMRV is linked to diseases like chronic fatigue syndrome or prostate cancer, especially since the authors of the papers disagree on the interpretation of their data…. M. Coffin, a retrovirologist and a co-author of two of today's Retrovirology papers, told Health Blog that while his groups' studies demonstrated that mouse DNA is everywhere in labs, none of today's published papers " definitively show that any prior study is wrong. " A. , a research assistant professor at University of Washington in Seattle who wrote a commentary in Retrovirology summarizing the studies, told Health Blog that the possibility of contamination means that future studies must be done very carefully before conclusions about disease association are made. But he said he is unwilling to state that the reported link between XMRV and CFS or prostate cancer is no longer viable…. The papers focus on various problems associated with a specific kind of test used to detect XMRV but does not examine every method used to detect XMRV. pointed out that some of the previous papers on prostate cancer found XMRV integrated into the patients' DNA and " I can't come up with a mechanism where there would be contamination there. " So how does the CBC come up with this garbage on XMRV? It's pure journalistic sloppiness on a health issue that is already financially crippling our nation – much less the hundreds of thousands of patients with ME/CFS and immune dysfunction – and potentially infected with this retrovirus. We MUST understand the pathogenesis of ME/CFS, autism, aggressive prostate cancer, and infectious breast cancer, and whether XMRV/MLV's present a real risk. And that requires science-based, judicious, careful reporting of all meritorious arguments - not spin. The WSJ " gets " that, and puts the CBC to shame by asking the tough questions, and differentiating spin from robust scientific conclusions. Bottom line, it's time for the CBC to clean up its act, and start taking this potentially explosive health issue seriously. Many of us sat up and took notice on the day the Science paper was published. It's time the CBC woke up from its extended XMRV-nap. A WAKE-UP CALL: EXPLOSIVE IMPLICATIONS OF XMRV FOR IVF, AUTISM, ME/CFS To close on an explosive note, I'd encourage any citizen, scientist or politician wanting to learn more about XMRV, to read the hair-raising testimony– given to the Health and Human Services CFS Advisory Committee – by a medical scientist with specialization in immunology and retrovirology, who made a presentation to the FDA in early 2010 on the seriousness of XMRV [http://bit.ly/icLZsu]. His discussion of the potential transmission of XMRV by biologicals, the disease states potentially associated with an epidemic, and the implications for vaccinations and national health should be enough to make any CBC executive – much less Canadian - lose sleep: " I have already raised the issue of urine derived human chorionic gonadotropin (uHCG) used for infertility treatments and for cycles of " in vitro fertilization " as being potential candidate sources of XMRV for the CFS/ME and/or autism epidemics, with the US FDA (February 11, 2010). They are taking this challenge seriously, and I have obtained early survey evidence supporting the notion that IVF treatments (generally which employs more injections of uHCG) may carry an increased risk of severe autism. " CBC and other reporters: Wake UP! Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.