Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 , Are we to interpret your post that you are inferring or concluding that growth within interstitial spaces is NOT making people sick? Does your opinion on this remain unchanged even where there is evidence of excessive moisture? Lastly, I don't believe that anyone should recommend remediation based upon limited information such as analytical results alone. So what is your point, that sampling of interstitial spaces isn't valid and that microbial growth found within can't possibly be making people sick or, that analytical results alone shouldn't be used to draw conclusions and recommend remediation? Chuck Reaney A. Reaney, CIEC, CIAQPProject Manager Alpha Environmental, Inc.IAQ/IEQ & Environmental ConsultingMedia, PA 19063 P: C: Interstitial Sampling, aka. The Wall Cavity Air Sample. I have reviewed far too many reports that site an interstitial/wall cavity sample as the reason that a building or home requires extensive if not complete remediation. The cases brought to me have increase recently at an alarming rate. Some of these samples have been collected on homes and buildings on crawl spaces that were built as much as 75 years ago.All of the reports that I have reviewed included very little background information and all had no elevated spore trap levels in the living/occupied space. A few identified elevated moisture but none identified the cause and origin of the moisture. All fell to the collection of air samples within several walls for a period of 5 minutes at a rate of 15 liters to provide the clients with a smoking gun and an answer to what in their home or office was making them sick.I believe the samples are collected in an attempt to justify the cost of the assessment by providing some form of a conclusion via laboratory results.If anyone out there is collecting wall cavity air sampling please help me understand how costly remediation can be based on these samples alone. More specifically why anyone would collect a wall sample from a 75 year old building on a crawl space with openings from the crawl space to the wall cavity. A lath and plaster wall cavity at that. Then recommend remediation and further investigation.But then again I prefer to sample as little as possible during the initial investigation.Just venting a bit.P.S. My clients are the property owners and/or the property management companies. The reports were all from tenant hired inspectors. Lapotaire Quote
Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 Chuck I am definitely not inferring or concluding that growth within interstitial spaces could NOT be making people sick. That can be a very serious problem that I’m sure most would identify without the need to pull air from a wall. I do however believe that the collection of an air sample in a wall cavity of a 75 year old building on a crawl space and concluding that the building is a sick building is crazy. Much, much, more information is required to even identify the presence of any actual microbial activity past or present. In all of the cases I am working there were no identified elevated moisture areas in the building and no elevated spore counts within the building. The inspector in an effort to identify the source of suspected hidden mold growth collected several air samples within the walls to help him locate the hidden mold. Then declared that the hidden mold was in most of the walls and the building should be evacuated. My issue will always be that if you don’t have a reason to open a wall, don’t. i.e. elevated moisture and/or visible staining or microbial growth, past or present. And don’t suck air from a 75 year old building on a crawl space and expect after 5 minutes at 15 liters not to find mold. If you do collect an air sample from a wall do it for a much shorter time and ensure that the wall cavity isn’t open to a crawl space. (Most 50 to 75 year old buildings here in Florida will have some degree of air infiltration from the crawl space into the wall cavities through the I x 6 flooring or the many drilled penetrations for HVAC, plumbing, and/or electrical) And when you do collect a sample from a wall and find what you believe is an elevation, don’t declare the building uninhabitable. (Remember, no identified moisture, and the building is 75 years old on a crawl space) I would prefer that these inspectors follow the last line in their report which reads “Further investigation to determine the source and level of mold growth is recommended”. If you have to end your report with that statement, just don’t write the report. P. Lapotaire, CIECBuilding Envelope & Indoor Environmental ConsultantFlorida State Licensed Mold Assessor MRS #4Microshield Environmental Services, LLCph fax www.Microshield-ES.com From: iequality [mailto:iequality ] On Behalf Of Chuck ReaneySent: Wednesday, December 29, 2010 1:33 PMTo: iequality Subject: Re: Interstitial Sampling, aka. The Wall Cavity Air Sample. , Are we to interpret your post that you are inferring or concluding that growth within interstitial spaces is NOT making people sick? Does your opinion on this remain unchanged even where there is evidence of excessive moisture? Lastly, I don't believe that anyone should recommend remediation based upon limited information such as analytical results alone. So what is your point, that sampling of interstitial spaces isn't valid and that microbial growth found within can't possibly be making people sick or, that analytical results alone shouldn't be used to draw conclusions and recommend remediation? Chuck Reaney A. Reaney, CIEC, CIAQPProject Manager Alpha Environmental, Inc.IAQ/IEQ & Environmental ConsultingMedia, PA 19063 P: C: Interstitial Sampling, aka. The Wall Cavity Air Sample. I have reviewed far too many reports that site an interstitial/wall cavity sample as the reason that a building or home requires extensive if not complete remediation. The cases brought to me have increase recently at an alarming rate. Some of these samples have been collected on homes and buildings on crawl spaces that were built as much as 75 years ago.All of the reports that I have reviewed included very little background information and all had no elevated spore trap levels in the living/occupied space. A few identified elevated moisture but none identified the cause and origin of the moisture. All fell to the collection of air samples within several walls for a period of 5 minutes at a rate of 15 liters to provide the clients with a smoking gun and an answer to what in their home or office was making them sick.I believe the samples are collected in an attempt to justify the cost of the assessment by providing some form of a conclusion via laboratory results.If anyone out there is collecting wall cavity air sampling please help me understand how costly remediation can be based on these samples alone. More specifically why anyone would collect a wall sample from a 75 year old building on a crawl space with openings from the crawl space to the wall cavity. A lath and plaster wall cavity at that. Then recommend remediation and further investigation.But then again I prefer to sample as little as possible during the initial investigation.Just venting a bit.P.S. My clients are the property owners and/or the property management companies. The reports were all from tenant hired inspectors. Lapotaire Quote
Guest guest Posted December 30, 2010 Report Posted December 30, 2010 , Thanks for your reply. I understand your perspective and neither agree nor disagree entirely. It sounds like we're both on the same page however that each building, occupant, concern and assessment is different and that no credible "one size fits all" generalizations can be made. As Wei pointed out in his reply, along with several other good points, that assessment/investigation is a process and that few if any meaningful conclusions can be drawn from analytical data alone, or from any other single piece of information, which is why the terms "testers" and "inspectors" rub me the wrong way. The same analytical data can be meaningful or not, and to different degrees in a variety of ways when considered as a single piece or group of information along with all of the other data, observations and information gained through the investigative process, not the least of which is the history of a structure and it's utilization over the course of that history. As investigators/assessors know, not everything is about mold, and sometimes some of the problems are about mold but quite often the mold is just one of several IEQ issues of concern that can be contributing factors. I've often described performing environmental assessments (IEQ as well as other types) as playing three-dimensional chess in zero gravity. I believe that statement takes us back to the point that generalizations are useless at best, and can also be potentially harmful in many ways. Therefore, it seems to me that the most accurate answer to most questions pertaining to IEQ is, "it depends". Cheers, Chuck Reaney A. Reaney, CIEC, CIAQPPresident/Project Manager Alpha Environmental, Inc.IAQ/IEQ & Environmental ConsultingMedia, PA 19063 P: C: Interstitial Sampling, aka. The Wall Cavity Air Sample. I have reviewed far too many reports that site an interstitial/wall cavity sample as the reason that a building or home requires extensive if not complete remediation. The cases brought to me have increase recently at an alarming rate. Some of these samples have been collected on homes and buildings on crawl spaces that were built as much as 75 years ago.All of the reports that I have reviewed included very little background information and all had no elevated spore trap levels in the living/occupied space. A few identified elevated moisture but none identified the cause and origin of the moisture. All fell to the collection of air samples within several walls for a period of 5 minutes at a rate of 15 liters to provide the clients with a smoking gun and an answer to what in their home or office was making them sick.I believe the samples are collected in an attempt to justify the cost of the assessment by providing some form of a conclusion via laboratory results.If anyone out there is collecting wall cavity air sampling please help me understand how costly remediation can be based on these samples alone. More specifically why anyone would collect a wall sample from a 75 year old building on a crawl space with openings from the crawl space to the wall cavity. A lath and plaster wall cavity at that. Then recommend remediation and further investigation.But then again I prefer to sample as little as possible during the initial investigation.Just venting a bit.P.S. My clients are the property owners and/or the property management companies. The reports were all from tenant hired inspectors. Lapotaire Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.