Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: Re: 600 degrees / survival ???

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Guest guest
Posted

Larry,

Thanks for that info. I have some reservations about the use of heat due to how the building contents might be affected (differential expansion of materials resulting in cracking, delaminating, etc.). However, one of the things you left out of your list of the benefits is that "structural pasteurization" would be one heck of a good bake-out procedure for volatiles, including MVOCs. I think many people who become sensitized in water-damaged buildings become sensitized to MVOCs.

I was wondering if you have any information on the effectiveness of heat treatment on the removal of adsorbed and absorbed volatile compounds from indoor surfaces. Instead of the LEED flushout protocol to reduce TVOCs, heat might do the job much better.

Steve Temes

Ole , Semco...

I am not a mycologist, but I do have some references regarding the thermal resistance of fungi. In a separate thread discussing a chemical release in ducting and resultant adsorbant contamination, Carl Grimes commented he wasn't sure what type of professional to refer, one of whom, he said jokingly (I think), was an arsonist. In the case of a 600F resolution for Stachybotrys chartarum, the professional would indeed be an arsonist. And, the treatment would undoubtedly be effective.

There are research results that indicate the thermal death point of Stachybotrys chartarum to be between 50 and 60C (140F). These research results (Domsch 1993 and Bollen 1969) were referencing soil pasteurization studies. In the Bollen work he describes Stachy as being "moderately heat tolerant". In the same study Bollen found that Aspergillus fumigatus was more heat tolerant and was found to survive temperatures of 65C (149F), but not 70C (158F). Most fungal species that are surviving comfortably in a human environment will be susceptible to these ranges of temperatures. New fungal growth will be less resistant than dormant spores. Large amounts of biomass will probably have more survivors of these temperatures than smaller amounts of biomass.

There are other issues regarding high temperatures and the properties of fungi. At what temperatures are toxins affected? Allergens? It may be that the 600F temperature reference is to some of the toxins associated with fungi. Pasteurization types of temperatures will most likely be ineffective with many toxins that have chemical properties. Toxins that are proteins may be affected. For example, Stachylysin is a mycotoxin produced by Stachybotrys chartarum. It is a hemolysin and is a protein. In a study evaluating the heat sensitivity of stachylysin (Vesper et al 2001) it was determined a temperature of 60C (140F) inactivated the stachylysin. This temperature is consistent with the thermal death point.

In another study (Fogle et al 2008) the heat stability of chaetoglobosins A and C were studied. Chaetomium globosum is oftentimes found in water damaged structures and it produces the mycotoxins chaetoglobosin A and C. The study determined that the Ch-A toxins were significantly reduced when exposed to a temperature of 75C (167F) for 24 hours. The Ch-C toxins were reduced but not significantly.

Allergens may be affected similarly to toxins. In a single experiment involving the effect of temperature on the allergen from Aspergillus fumigatus in dust samples it was found that no allergens were detected after several hours of heating at 100C. This experiment was not repeated and should not be relied upon.

In another study researching the effect of high temperatures on household allergens (Cain 1998), it was concluded that dry heating methods may provide an alternative treatment for the removal of mite allergens. The study determined that increased temperatures and durations significantly reduced levels of dust mite allergans, but that cat and dog allergens were less affected.

In the ANSI/IICRC S520, 2008 version, the concept of "structural pasteurization" is introduced and defined. The definition in the S520 is as follows:

"Structural Pasteurization - An engineered process in which high temperatures are introduced to a structure or portion of a structure for the purpose of reducing bio-organisms to acceptable levels without damage to the structure."

Additionally, the S520 defines "heat" as an alternative methodology. The S520 uses the following definition:

"Methods involving controlled application of heat to a structure have been reported to be an effective form of biological control, which might or might not kill some fungal spores and vegetative structures. This process is a developing technology and should be evaluated and understood before use. It is important to note that killing mold and fungal spores has not been shown to eliminate the contaminants or their allergenic or toxigenic properties."

The research seems to indicate that structural pasteurization should significantly reduce the viability of bio-organisms in structures, but more needs to be understood about other concerns associated with water damaged structures such as toxins and allergens. The concept of structural pasteurization is fairly easily understood, but the application is complex. Efficacy is dependent on reaching and maintaining a uniform target temperature for a specific duration throughout the structure or containment. Structures are complicated, consisting of wood, stone, fabric, synthetic materials, etc, etc, etc. The use of high temperatures can be a very effective component of a remediation process, particularly as a part of a water restoration process as pasteurization temperatures are even more effective with many bacteria associated with water loss as well as viruses, parasites, insects, etc. Use of high temperature as a remediation tool should be specified and/or engineered by an environmental professional.

Larry Chase

ThermaPureHeat®

Disclosure: I have been involved with the development of the ThermaPure process of structural pasteurization for the past seven years. I am an employee of E-Therm, the licensing company of ThermaPure.

>>

>>SteveX4 - I can't agree more with you regarding mold professionals (non professionals) using the types of mold as scare topics. That should not be done. However, there are so many scams in this industry, the above is only one.

>>

>>Regarding the types of mold, I firmly believe if a house is consumed or heavily contaminated with stachy, for example, (as finding it in air samples since it is more of a wet mold or Cladosporium as well), the house should be tore down. There have been many studies regarding some types of mold that can survive just about anything you throw at it. For example, in temperatures in excess of 600 degrees, stachy survives.

>>

>>I realize it is the goal to remove all mold ridden surfaces and materials from a house, however, some types of mold tend to spread easier and return at the first possible moment the environment allows it. Heavy humidity would be one.

>>

>>I do not believe ALL mold can be successfully removed from a contaminated home period. I believe great strides can be acheived, but not all mold and that can be very dangerous to mold sensitive people.

>>

>>C

Guest guest
Posted

I'd guess the 600 degree bacteria being referenced are the sulphur-oxidizing bacteria found near deep sea hydrothermal vents. Temps there can reach 750F at 7000 ft depth. A very different organism because it is in a very different environment.

Carl Grimes

Healthy Habitats LLC

-----

Larry,

Thanks for that info. I have some reservations about the use of heat due to how the building contents might be affected (differential expansion of materials resulting in cracking, delaminating, etc.). However, one of the things you left out of your list of the benefits is that " structural pasteurization " would be one heck of a good bake-out procedure for volatiles, including MVOCs. I think many people who become sensitized in water-damaged buildings become sensitized to MVOCs.

I was wondering if you have any information on the effectiveness of heat treatment on the removal of adsorbed and absorbed volatile compounds from indoor surfaces. Instead of the LEED flushout protocol to reduce TVOCs, heat might do the job much better.

Steve Temes

Ole , Semco...

I am not a mycologist, but I do have some references regarding the thermal resistance of fungi. In a separate thread discussing a chemical release in ducting and resultant adsorbant contamination, Carl Grimes commented he wasn't sure what type of professional to refer, one of whom, he said jokingly (I think), was an arsonist. In the case of a 600F resolution for Stachybotrys chartarum, the professional would indeed be an arsonist. And, the treatment would undoubtedly be effective.

There are research results that indicate the thermal death point of Stachybotrys chartarum to be between 50 and 60C (140F). These research results (Domsch 1993 and Bollen 1969) were referencing soil pasteurization studies. In the Bollen work he describes Stachy as being " moderately heat tolerant " . In the same study Bollen found that Aspergillus fumigatus was more heat tolerant and was found to survive temperatures of 65C (149F), but not 70C (158F). Most fungal species that are surviving comfortably in a human environment will be susceptible to these ranges of temperatures. New fungal growth will be less resistant than dormant spores. Large amounts of biomass will probably have more survivors of these temperatures than smaller amounts of biomass.

There are other issues regarding high temperatures and the properties of fungi. At what temperatures are toxins affected? Allergens? It may be that the 600F temperature reference is to some of the toxins associated with fungi. Pasteurization types of temperatures will most likely be ineffective with many toxins that have chemical properties. Toxins that are proteins may be affected. For example, Stachylysin is a mycotoxin produced by Stachybotrys chartarum. It is a hemolysin and is a protein. In a study evaluating the heat sensitivity of stachylysin (Vesper et al 2001) it was determined a temperature of 60C (140F) inactivated the stachylysin. This temperature is consistent with the thermal death point.

In another study (Fogle et al 2008) the heat stability of chaetoglobosins A and C were studied. Chaetomium globosum is oftentimes found in water damaged structures and it produces the mycotoxins chaetoglobosin A and C. The study determined that the Ch-A toxins were significantly reduced when exposed to a temperature of 75C (167F) for 24 hours. The Ch-C toxins were reduced but not significantly.

Allergens may be affected similarly to toxins. In a single experiment involving the effect of temperature on the allergen from Aspergillus fumigatus in dust samples it was found that no allergens were detected after several hours of heating at 100C. This experiment was not repeated and should not be relied upon.

In another study researching the effect of high temperatures on household allergens (Cain 1998), it was concluded that dry heating methods may provide an alternative treatment for the removal of mite allergens. The study determined that increased temperatures and durations significantly reduced levels of dust mite allergans, but that cat and dog allergens were less affected.

In the ANSI/IICRC S520, 2008 version, the concept of " structural pasteurization " is introduced and defined. The definition in the S520 is as follows:

" Structural Pasteurization - An engineered process in which high temperatures are introduced to a structure or portion of a structure for the purpose of reducing bio-organisms to acceptable levels without damage to the structure. "

Additionally, the S520 defines " heat " as an alternative methodology. The S520 uses the following definition:

" Methods involving controlled application of heat to a structure have been reported to be an effective form of biological control, which might or might not kill some fungal spores and vegetative structures. This process is a developing technology and should be evaluated and understood before use. It is important to note that killing mold and fungal spores has not been shown to eliminate the contaminants or their allergenic or toxigenic properties. "

The research seems to indicate that structural pasteurization should significantly reduce the viability of bio-

organisms in structures, but more needs to be understood about other concerns associated with water damaged structures such as toxins and allergens. The concept of structural pasteurization is fairly easily understood, but the application is complex. Efficacy is dependent on reaching and maintaining a uniform target temperature for a specific duration throughout the structure or containment. Structures are complicated, consisting of wood, stone, fabric, synthetic materials, etc, etc, etc. The use of high temperatures can be a very effective component of a remediation process, particularly as a part of a water restoration process as pasteurization temperatures are even more effective with many bacteria associated with water loss as well as viruses, parasites, insects, etc. Use of high temperature as a remediation tool should be specified and/or engineered by an environmental professional.

Larry Chase

ThermaPureHeat®

Disclosure: I have been involved with the development of the ThermaPure process of structural pasteurization for the past seven years. I am an employee of E-Therm, the licensing company of ThermaPure.

>>

>>SteveX4 - I can't agree more with you regarding mold professionals (non professionals) using the types of mold as scare topics. That should not be done. However, there are so many scams in this industry, the above is only one.

>>

>>Regarding the types of mold, I firmly believe if a house is consumed or heavily contaminated with stachy, for example, (as finding it in air samples since it is more of a wet mold or Cladosporium as well), the house should be tore down. There have been many studies regarding some types of mold that can survive just about anything you throw at it. For example, in temperatures in excess of 600 degrees, stachy survives.

>>

>>I realize it is the goal to remove all mold ridden surfaces and materials from a house, however, some types of mold tend to spread easier and return at the first possible moment the environment allows it. Heavy humidity would be one.

>>

>>I do not believe ALL mold can be successfully removed from a contaminated home period. I believe great strides can be acheived, but not all mold and that can be very dangerous to mold sensitive people.

>>

>>C

The following section of this message contains a file attachment

prepared for transmission using the Internet MIME message format.

If you are using Pegasus Mail, or any other MIME-compliant system,

you should be able to save it or view it from within your mailer.

If you cannot, please ask your system administrator for assistance.

---- File information -----------

File: DEFAULT.BMP

Date: 16 Jun 2009, 0:10

Size: 358 bytes.

Type: Unknown

Guest guest
Posted

Steve,Many years ago, at the start of the 1990s IAQ problems, we did some experimentation with "baking out" office buildings. We would heat them up to 90 °F and monitor the increase in VOC emissions. If I remember correctly, there were a few papers published about this. In general, it was effective for about 2 weeks. Then the effects were minimal in accelerating degassing. This was attributed to long term degassing that occurs from monomers "deep" inside building materials and furnishing. These "buried" VOCs only diffused out based on the internal gradient in the product and did not appear to be significantly affected by slightly elevated temperatures. RH also has some early effects. "Baking out" appeared to removed the VOCs very near the surface, but the "deeper" chemicals would just take a lot of time. As for "structural pasteurization" it will have some effect, but will not significantly affect long term VOC decay curves. Bob

I'd guess the 600 degree bacteria being referenced are the sulphur-oxidizing bacteria found near deep sea hydrothermal vents. Temps there can reach 750F at 7000 ft depth. A very different organism because it is in a very different environment.

Carl Grimes

Healthy Habitats LLC

-----

Larry,

Thanks for that info. I have some reservations about the use of heat due to how the building contents might be affected (differential expansion of materials resulting in cracking, delaminating, etc.). However, one of the things you left out of your list of the benefits is that "structural pasteurization" would be one heck of a good bake-out procedure for volatiles, including MVOCs. I think many people who become sensitized in water-damaged buildings become sensitized to MVOCs.

I was wondering if you have any information on the effectiveness of heat treatment on the removal of adsorbed and absorbed volatile compounds from indoor surfaces. Instead of the LEED flushout protocol to reduce TVOCs, heat might do the job much better.

Steve Temes

In a message dated 3/16/2010 3:40:08 PM Eastern Daylight Time, lchasethermapure writes:

Ole , Semco...

I am not a mycologist, but I do have some references regarding the thermal resistance of fungi. In a separate thread discussing a chemical release in ducting and resultant adsorbant contamination, Carl Grimes commented he wasn't sure what type of professional to refer, one of whom, he said jokingly (I think), was an arsonist. In the case of a 600F resolution for Stachybotrys chartarum, the professional would indeed be an arsonist. And, the treatment would undoubtedly be effective.

There are research results that indicate the thermal death point of Stachybotrys chartarum to be between 50 and 60C (140F). These research results (Domsch 1993 and Bollen 1969) were referencing soil pasteurization studies. In the Bollen work he describes Stachy as being "moderately heat tolerant". In the same study Bollen found that Aspergillus fumigatus was more heat tolerant and was found to survive temperatures of 65C (149F), but not 70C (158F). Most fungal species that are surviving comfortably in a human environment will be susceptible to these ranges of temperatures. New fungal growth will be less resistant than dormant spores. Large amounts of biomass will probably have more survivors of these temperatures than smaller amounts of biomass.

There are other issues regarding high temperatures and the properties of fungi. At what temperatures are toxins affected? Allergens? It may be that the 600F temperature reference is to some of the toxins associated with fungi. Pasteurization types of temperatures will most likely be ineffective with many toxins that have chemical properties. Toxins that are proteins may be affected. For example, Stachylysin is a mycotoxin produced by Stachybotrys chartarum. It is a hemolysin and is a protein. In a study evaluating the heat sensitivity of stachylysin (Vesper et al 2001) it was determined a temperature of 60C (140F) inactivated the stachylysin. This temperature is consistent with the thermal death point.

In another study (Fogle et al 2008) the heat stability of chaetoglobosins A and C were studied. Chaetomium globosum is oftentimes found in water damaged structures and it produces the mycotoxins chaetoglobosin A and C. The study determined that the Ch-A toxins were significantly reduced when exposed to a temperature of 75C (167F) for 24 hours. The Ch-C toxins were reduced but not significantly.

Allergens may be affected similarly to toxins. In a single experiment involving the effect of temperature on the allergen from Aspergillus fumigatus in dust samples it was found that no allergens were detected after several hours of heating at 100C. This experiment was not repeated and should not be relied upon.

In another study researching the effect of high temperatures on household allergens (Cain 1998), it was concluded that dry heating methods may provide an alternative treatment for the removal of mite allergens. The study determined that increased temperatures and durations significantly reduced levels of dust mite allergans, but that cat and dog allergens were less affected.

In the ANSI/IICRC S520, 2008 version, the concept of "structural pasteurization" is introduced and defined. The definition in the S520 is as follows:

"Structural Pasteurization - An engineered process in which high temperatures are introduced to a structure or portion of a structure for the purpose of reducing bio-organisms to acceptable levels without damage to the structure."

Additionally, the S520 defines "heat" as an alternative methodology. The S520 uses the following definition:

"Methods involving controlled application of heat to a structure have been reported to be an effective form of biological control, which might or might not kill some fungal spores and vegetative structures. This process is a developing technology and should be evaluated and understood before use. It is important to note that killing mold and fungal spores has not been shown to eliminate the contaminants or their allergenic or toxigenic properties."

The research seems to indicate that structural pasteurization should significantly reduce the viability of bio-

organisms in structures, but more needs to be understood about other concerns associated with water damaged structures such as toxins and allergens. The concept of structural pasteurization is fairly easily understood, but the application is complex. Efficacy is dependent on reaching and maintaining a uniform target temperature for a specific duration throughout the structure or containment. Structures are complicated, consisting of wood, stone, fabric, synthetic materials, etc, etc, etc. The use of high temperatures can be a very effective component of a remediation process, particularly as a part of a water restoration process as pasteurization temperatures are even more effective with many bacteria associated with water loss as well as viruses, parasites, insects, etc. Use of high temperature as a remediation tool should be specified and/or engineered by an environmental professional.

Larry Chase

ThermaPureHeat®

Disclosure: I have been involved with the development of the ThermaPure process of structural pasteurization for the past seven years. I am an employee of E-Therm, the licensing company of ThermaPure.

>>

>>SteveX4 - I can't agree more with you regarding mold professionals (non professionals) using the types of mold as scare topics. That should not be done. However, there are so many scams in this industry, the above is only one.

>>

>>Regarding the types of mold, I firmly believe if a house is consumed or heavily contaminated with stachy, for example, (as finding it in air samples since it is more of a wet mold or Cladosporium as well), the house should be tore down. There have been many studies regarding some types of mold that can survive just about anything you throw at it. For example, in temperatures in excess of 600 degrees, stachy survives.

>>

>>I realize it is the goal to remove all mold ridden surfaces and materials from a house, however, some types of mold tend to spread easier and return at the first possible moment the environment allows it. Heavy humidity would be one.

>>

>>I do not believe ALL mold can be successfully removed from a contaminated home period. I believe great strides can be acheived, but not all mold and that can be very dangerous to mold sensitive people.

>>

>>C

Guest guest
Posted

Larry, Thanks for posting the really great information and references on structural pasteurization and baking out. Is there any data on the microbial testing right after the process is complete and how long the building takes to return to normal fungal ecology. The Canadian study on new housing showed normal/equalization levels were reached in about 18 months. I would be particularly interested in whether Clado was the initial indoor genera as opposed to Pen/Asp or others. In the case of structural pasteurization, the inhabitant, rather than the building materials should be the vectors for recolonization. Another interesting data would be the recolonization of bacteria. The occupant SA should be the first species to show up. How long before other gram + and some gram - start to recolonize?I doubt that 2 years on, that the normal microflora would be different than other buildings, but this is an interesting question to ponder.For example, would structural pasteurization be good for homes where people are severely immuno compromised?Bob

Steve,

Bob is correct regarding the work that was done in the 1990s with building "bakeouts". There is considerable literature from that period (Girman, 1987, 1989, 1990), (Offerman 1993), (Bayer 1990, 1991) and I believe Hal Levin did some research as well. These studies generally produced inconsistent results and concluded that building bakeouts were not adviseable.

The typical methodology of the bakeout was to increase the temperature of the structure using the building HVAC system. The assumption was that most buildings of that era were overdesigned and you could generate significantly higher temperatures by just turning up the heat. This would increase vapor pressure and accelerate off-gassing.

There were several problems with the 1990s building bakeout approach, first, these buildings did not have the ability to generate significant air exchanges. As a result, the chemicals off-gassed were adsorbed to other materials, typically porous materials such as carpet, furniture, etc. Second, the HVAC system could not increase the temperature enough, nor could it create significant amounts of air flow, both of these elements are required to produce better results.

Today, using a "structural pasteurization" approach, the temperature would be increased to higher levels - 45-50C (113-122F), convection would be increased by adding fans (similar to a drying project), and air exchanges increased by supplementing the exhaust. The duration would be determined by the types of materials and the severity of the problem. It could be 2 to 4 days. This approach would significantly increase the vapor pressure of the structural materials and add convection and exhaust to remove the off-gassed material from the structure. There are a number of anectdotal successes using this approach.

There is some support for these temperatures in the literature. One study (VanDerWal 1997) indicated that both the initial emission rate and the source decay rate increased with temperature. The highest temperature they evaluated was 50C. This study also determined that lower temperatures (30C) for short durations (one-two days) were not effective with the exception of paints.

Another study (Kim 2005) was developed to understand the source of some IAQ issues in Korean homes with under heating systems. The under heating systems produced a temperature of 50C under the floor and 37C at the floor in order to create comfort conditions in the home. Kim measured for the presence of formaldehyde and found that emissions from flooring materials near the 50C temp area fell off rapidly and were nearly non-existent after several days. The long term impact from formaldehyde in the home was from the furniture in the structure, not the MDF or other formaldehyde bearing materials in the flooring system or even materials on the floor such as carpet. These materials had already off-gassed.

Regarding MVOCs, structural pasteurization would reduce or eliminate them through off-gassing of the VOCs and by stopping the source of the microbial growth by drying or killing the bacteria or fungi.

The other comment you made was about damages. This is a legitimate concern. Depending upon the objectives of the structural pasteurization project, ambient space temperatures may have to reach 70-75C (158-167F). Processed air that is supplied to the space from a direct fired heater might reach 100C. For most structural materials; wood, plaster, gypsum board, etc., this is not a problem. For manufactured products, synthetics, plastics, etc., it can be a problem. It is important that anyone applying these technologies to structures understand what materials are damaged at which temperatures and how to protect them. Some items have to be removed and others can be protected. A couple of years ago Ralph Moon wrote a three part series for Cleaning and Restoration magazine and damages was one of the topics he covered. It was a good evaluation of the use of high temperatures in structures.

I have specific references to the susceptibility of various construction materials to high temperatures if anyone is interested.

Larry Chase

ThermaPureHeat

> > >>

> > >>SteveX4 - I can't agree more with you regarding mold professionals (non professionals) using the types of mold as scare topics. That should not be done. However, there are so many scams in this industry, the above is only one.

> > >>

> > >>Regarding the types of mold, I firmly believe if a house is consumed or heavily contaminated with stachy, for example, (as finding it in air samples since it is more of a wet mold or Cladosporium as well), the house should be tore down. There have been many studies regarding some types of mold that can survive just about anything you throw at it. For example, in temperatures in excess of 600 degrees, stachy survives.

> > >>

> > >>I realize it is the goal to remove all mold ridden surfaces and materials from a house, however, some types of mold tend to spread easier and return at the first possible moment the environment allows it. Heavy humidity would be one.

> > >>

> > >>I do not believe ALL mold can be successfully removed from a contaminated home period. I believe great strides can be acheived, but not all mold and that can be very dangerous to mold sensitive people.

> > >>

> > >>C

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

>

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...