Guest guest Posted December 26, 2010 Report Posted December 26, 2010 > > Does anyone have one of those indoor automatic gardening things? I believe they are called aerogardens.I am not serious about getting one, but wondered if anyone had any experience with them?here is a link to their website: > www.aerogarden.com I'm gonna pipe up on this one. I was checking those out a few years ago, too. I'd love to do some hydroponic tomatoes (fed with liquid kelp), but could not find an affordable way to get started. The Aerogarden looks great (conceptually) but has more negatives attached to it than otherwise. One thing that really stood out was reading that you're " locked in " to using *their* seeds which are not organic. I don't recall why one couldn't use other seed but at the time that alone was sufficient to turn me off. Aside from that it seemed like a crap shoot. Some people swear by it...others hate the results. Unless something's changed in the last couple or three years, I'd be cautious about buying one. Don Quote
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 Don,Thanks for confirming what I also thought--I don't like the idea of using their seed pods and that they aren't organic. For that price, I want to use what I want to use. The reason I ever looked at them was because my husband absolutely loves tomatoes and at this time of year, they taste like cardboard-hence the thought of my own hydroponic tomatoes was very appealing.I have heard good things and bad things about the aerogardens, but the clincher to me was the problem with the seeds. I had thought it would be so cool to grow tomatoes and basil on it, but it is just better to have the tomatoes in season. Basil I can grow anytime in the house. n Quote
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 i have an aerogarden & you can buy the pods w/o seeds & grow what ever you want to grow by adding your OWN seeds. I am about to start some cherry tomatoes & some lettuce... I will let you know how that goes! I bought it & used their seeds, grew the herb garden. It did pretty good actually. This will be my 2nd attempt at growing in the aerogarden. Patti ________________________________ To: sproutpeople Sent: Mon, December 27, 2010 8:42:54 AM Subject: Re: Re: aerogardens Don,Thanks for confirming what I also thought--I don't like the idea of using their seed pods and that they aren't organic. For that price, I want to use what I want to use. The reason I ever looked at them was because my husband absolutely loves tomatoes and at this time of year, they taste like cardboard-hence the thought of my own hydroponic tomatoes was very appealing.I have heard good things and bad things about the aerogardens, but the clincher to me was the problem with the seeds. I had thought it would be so cool to grow tomatoes and basil on it, but it is just better to have the tomatoes in season. Basil I can grow anytime in the house. n Quote
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 Patti,Please keep us posted how it goes! I had no idea one could use different seeds. Please let us know how those tomatoes grow!Good luck with it and how fun! n  i have an aerogarden & you can buy the pods w/o seeds & grow what ever you want to grow by adding your OWN seeds. I am about to start some cherry tomatoes & some lettuce... I will let you know how that goes! I bought it & used their seeds, grew the herb garden. It did pretty good actually. This will be my 2nd attempt at growing in the aerogarden. Patti ________________________________ To: sproutpeople Sent: Mon, December 27, 2010 8:42:54 AM Subject: Re: Re: aerogardens Don,Thanks for confirming what I also thought--I don't like the idea of using their seed pods and that they aren't organic. For that price, I want to use what I want to use. The reason I ever looked at them was because my husband absolutely loves tomatoes and at this time of year, they taste like cardboard-hence the thought of my own hydroponic tomatoes was very appealing.I have heard good things and bad things about the aerogardens, but the clincher to me was the problem with the seeds. I had thought it would be so cool to grow tomatoes and basil on it, but it is just better to have the tomatoes in season. Basil I can grow anytime in the house. n Quote
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 Don and all, I looked at these too. I remember two of the complaints were that the thing is very bright, and people complained that some crops outgrew others, so effectively not all the plants grow. Some seeds don't germinate well in hydroponic conditions. I've grown enough herbs outdoors that people's results made sense to me--basil grows quicker than chives. I hoped there was a work around for using their seed pellets (or however they come). I came to essentially the same conclusion--crap shoot. Although some people are amazingly incompetent when it comes to growing plants, so I figured that since I can garden on some level, I'd figure the thing out. I thought it was big and expensive, and I got into sprouting instead. There are other hydroponic systems I never checked out that might give more real estate for the same money--the aerogarden is not big enough for many tomatoes. But it seems expensive and time consuming, so it's really on the back burner for me. There must be a yahoo group for hydroponic gardeners. Nicola > > > > Does anyone have one of those indoor automatic gardening things? I believe they are called aerogardens.I am not serious about getting one, but wondered if anyone had any experience with them?here is a link to their website: > > www.aerogarden.com > > I'm gonna pipe up on this one. I was checking those out a few years ago, too. I'd love to do some hydroponic tomatoes (fed with liquid kelp), but could not find an affordable way to get started. The Aerogarden looks great (conceptually) but has more negatives attached to it than otherwise. One thing that really stood out was reading that you're " locked in " to using *their* seeds which are not organic. I don't recall why one couldn't use other seed but at the time that alone was sufficient to turn me off. Aside from that it seemed like a crap shoot. Some people swear by it...others hate the results. Unless something's changed in the last couple or three years, I'd be cautious about buying one. > > Don > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 > > i have an aerogarden & you can buy the pods w/o seeds & grow what ever > you want > to grow by adding your OWN seeds. I am about to start some cherry > tomatoes & > some lettuce... I will let you know how that goes! I bought it & used > their > seeds, grew the herb garden. It did pretty good actually. This will be > my 2nd > attempt at growing in the aerogarden. > > Patti > Hi Patti Thanks for this review. I have looked at them many times as it seemed that the price was a bit high for what it actually is. Its nice to know it does work. Lorri in NH Quote
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 I got lucky & found mine for under $40.. it as 9 holes? i think? Anyway at that price I grabbed it up! I had been wanting one for a long time when I found this one. I got it at a store called Tuesday Morning, they sell brand name goods at discounted prices (in Texas). Patti ________________________________ To: sproutpeople Sent: Mon, December 27, 2010 9:13:10 AM Subject: Re: Re: aerogardens > > i have an aerogarden & you can buy the pods w/o seeds & grow what ever > you want > to grow by adding your OWN seeds. I am about to start some cherry > tomatoes & > some lettuce... I will let you know how that goes! I bought it & used > their > seeds, grew the herb garden. It did pretty good actually. This will be > my 2nd > attempt at growing in the aerogarden. > > Patti > Hi Patti Thanks for this review. I have looked at them many times as it seemed that the price was a bit high for what it actually is. Its nice to know it does work. Lorri in NH Quote
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 Patti, Do let us know how it goes. What variety of cherry tomatoes are you growing? I would think it must be one of the small determinate plants as the aerogarden is not big enough to grow a full-sized tomato vine. For me it seems like a lot of expense for a box or two of cherry tomatoes. The organic ones from whole foods can still have flavor in the winter. So let us know if you think your crop is worth it! Happy gardening, Nicola > > i have an aerogarden & you can buy the pods w/o seeds & grow what ever you want > to grow by adding your OWN seeds. I am about to start some cherry tomatoes & > some lettuce... I will let you know how that goes! I bought it & used their > seeds, grew the herb garden. It did pretty good actually. This will be my 2nd > attempt at growing in the aerogarden. > > > > > Patti > > > > > ________________________________ > > To: sproutpeople > Sent: Mon, December 27, 2010 8:42:54 AM > Subject: Re: Re: aerogardens > > > > Don,Thanks for confirming what I also thought--I don't like the idea of using > their seed pods and that they aren't organic. For that price, I want to use what > I want to use. The reason I ever looked at them was because my husband > absolutely loves tomatoes and at this time of year, they taste like > cardboard-hence the thought of my own hydroponic tomatoes was very appealing.I > have heard good things and bad things about the aerogardens, but the clincher to > me was the problem with the seeds. I had thought it would be so cool to grow > tomatoes and basil on it, but it is just better to have the tomatoes in season. > Basil I can grow anytime in the house. n > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 You must not have looked at the aerogardens web site recently, but they now do have their grow anything kits where you use your own seed. http://bit.ly/gnSm2L For do-it-yourselfers check out the Window Farms web site, they have plans for systems made out of 2 or 3 liter soda bottles, tubing and aquarium pumps. I personally stay away from hydroponic systems, I don't think its as healthy as growing in dirt and humus. However, I have heard good things about integrated Aquaculture/Hydroponic systems. Lee > > > > > Does anyone have one of those indoor automatic gardening things? I believe they are called aerogardens.I am not serious about getting one, but wondered if anyone had any experience with them?here is a link to their website: > > www.aerogarden.com > > I'm gonna pipe up on this one. I was checking those out a few years ago, too. I'd love to do some hydroponic tomatoes (fed with liquid kelp), but could not find an affordable way to get started. The Aerogarden looks great (conceptually) but has more negatives attached to it than otherwise. One thing that really stood out was reading that you're " locked in " to using *their* seeds which are not organic. I don't recall why one couldn't use other seed but at the time that alone was sufficient to turn me off. Aside from that it seemed like a crap shoot. Some people swear by it...others hate the results. Unless something's changed in the last couple or three years, I'd be cautious about buying one. > > Don Quote
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 Lee,It is fun at least reading about this stuff.Thanks for the info. Since I am snowed in, I will take a look at what you mentioned. I find that I really like indoor gardening as it does not require all of the bending outdoor gardening does. Plus, the outside animals can't get into things. They usually eat everything in our yard--even " deer proof " (no such thing) plants recommended by Rutgers Extension here in NJ. They are the gardener's go-to resource for us in NJ. n Quote
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 > > I got lucky & found mine for under $40.. it as 9 holes? i think? > Anyway at > that price I grabbed it up! I had been wanting one for a long time > when I found > this one. I got it at a store called Tuesday Morning, they sell brand > name > goods at discounted prices (in Texas). > > Patti > > ________________________________ > Wow what a great deal Patti, At that price I would have given it a try too. We do have Tuesday Mornings here too. But as I hate to shop anywhere but online its hard for me to find such great deals. Lorri in NH Quote
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 I have used an aerogarden for a few years now. I got it from their outlet store online, and it was $25 plus shipping. I have grown basil, chives, thyme,mint, and sage. The first time I used the thyme, I had some problems with the seed pod. Customer service was amazing. They re-sent the thyme, without a hestitation. They are very nice. I did order some tomato pods to try that are made for the three-pod, smaller aerogarden. You can get them for the larger gardens also. I have not tried them yet, as I moved to another town, and trying to get organized. Also, they do have the supplies to use your own seeds! You use their pod and plastic domes, and they show you how to add your own seeds to that. The tomato pods I ordered were heirloom. I am in a tall apartment building, with no outdoor gardening available to me here. I plan to grow the tomato starts, and plant them in my son's garden here in town. Wait till the garden you want is on sale, and get it from the outlet store they have. It is fun playing with it, and the basil I started on there is thriving a year later in a pot on my kitchen window sill. It has been a fun experience. Phyllis Quote
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 Patti,At $40 I would have picked one up too! What a deal. I tend to do most if not all of my shopping online now. Except for fresh food that we don't grow ourselves and the occasional trip to a clothing store--but even then, I head for a thrift shop. I think there are some good deals online now for aerogardens. n Quote
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 I have had one for about 2 1/2 years now. (I actually have two more stored in the garage that I got online from some nutrition site at a fab price!) I used the original seed kit -- mixed herbs. Due to my poor pruning and poor attention, the basil and parsley eventually died off, but the mint, chives, and thyme continue. (Mind you, they say a kit is for 4 months.) Their seeds aren't very flavorful strains but as noted, you can now use your own. PROS: -Plug-and-play. Does not require glue, drill, saw, PVC piping, etc. -Great for lousy gardeners -- this thing does produce even if abused. -Fits in a kitchen. Mine lives on top of microwave. -Always have cheerful light and green things even in dead of winter. -You can cluster potted plants or sprouts around it to green up. -Probably best for herbs and lettuces. CONS: -Will need attention while you vacation -- I have to add water about every 3 days. -Not for very leggy plants or heavy fruiters. Think small. -Needs hydroponic supplements, that the company will be happy to sell you. I just add liquid kelp. -More spendy than homebrewed hydroponic setups, or potted herbs. -Cats enjoy the lovely garden you've obviously made for them. Needs to be out of feline range. -Any grow lights are power hungry. Would I buy again? Yes, already have, I've got two on backup. But only at discount. And I am a lousy gardener, so it's nice to have success. I'm fixing to clean this one out and try their lettuce kit (also in storage). Will have to see how it goes. Molly > > Does anyone have one of those indoor automatic gardening things? I believe they are called aerogardens.I am not serious about getting Quote
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 Thanks so much Molly for the critique with the pros and cons. If I see one for a good deal I will probably try it out. I laughed when I read the bit about the cats. I have two that usually stay out of my stuff, but this Summer, for some strange reason, one of them was fascinated by my cactus collection--I had to buy two large barrel cactus to use as deterrents to keep him away from the lithops (living rocks) and a succulent that was flowering! I think he might like the aerogarden! The other cat got to a small orchid I had and snipped off the flowers within an hour of my bringing it home! Cats are no longer allowed near the plant stand!!! Can imagine how they'd like an aerogarden.marionfinally dug and plowed out of the snow Quote
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 I hope the info does help n. It really is a workable gadget and I enjoy having it. And just wanted to say... oooooh, lithops. I am so intrigued by these little plants but again, lousy gardener. I will have to try a couple in the house in the spring. Molly > > Thanks so much Molly for the critique with the pros and cons. If I see one for a good deal I will probably try it out. Quote
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 > > I have had one for about 2 1/2 years now. (I actually have two more > stored in the garage that I got online from some nutrition site at a > fab price!) I used the original seed kit -- mixed herbs. Due to my > poor pruning and poor attention, the basil and parsley eventually died > off, but the mint, chives, and thyme continue. (Mind you, they say a > kit is for 4 months.) Their seeds aren't very flavorful strains but as > noted, you can now use your own. > > PROS: > -Plug-and-play. Does not require glue, drill, saw, PVC piping, etc. > -Great for lousy gardeners -- this thing does produce even if abused. > -Fits in a kitchen. Mine lives on top of microwave. > -Always have cheerful light and green things even in dead of winter. > -You can cluster potted plants or sprouts around it to green up. > -Probably best for herbs and lettuces. > > CONS: > -Will need attention while you vacation -- I have to add water about > every 3 days. > -Not for very leggy plants or heavy fruiters. Think small. > -Needs hydroponic supplements, that the company will be happy to sell > you. I just add liquid kelp. > -More spendy than homebrewed hydroponic setups, or potted herbs. > -Cats enjoy the lovely garden you've obviously made for them. Needs to > be out of feline range. > -Any grow lights are power hungry. > > Would I buy again? Yes, already have, I've got two on backup. But only > at discount. And I am a lousy gardener, so it's nice to have success. > > I'm fixing to clean this one out and try their lettuce kit (also in > storage). Will have to see how it goes. > > Molly > Wow Molly great review. You have given me lots to think about and deals to look for. Thank you! Lorri in NH Quote
Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 Phyllis,Thank you for sharing your aerogarden experiences. I hope your tomatoes grow well! Please let us know how it goes.I did not even know there was an aerogarden outlet store. But it makes sense. One can buy a reconditioned Vitamix or dehydrator fully warrantied, Makes these investments more do-able I think.Well after reading your note and hearing about 's bio-dome lettuce experiment, I am giving some thought to more indoor gardening. Perhaps something my husband could take charge of--he is amazing with outdoor gardening and I have not only sprouts, microgreens, and grasses growing, but also an orchid, gesneriad, and cactus collection to manage. And I don't have a greenhouse. Every windowsill not claimed by the cats or dogs is shelved with houseplants--plus one lighted plant stand.So maybe if it was an aerogarden or something like it that could grow tomatoes--and could be kept out of the reach of the kittys! ncurrently sitting with an orange tabby while writing Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.