Guest guest Posted June 22, 2008 Report Posted June 22, 2008 I understand how time consuming it is for you to read all our posts, Marta. And I know how you worry about each of us. I hope you soon come back to us because we need you here. Remember, it was one person and not all of us who " went off. " Ntt t From: DS_Friends_Keshishian [mailto:DS_Friends_Keshishian ] On Behalf Of mjs93311 Sent: 22 June 2008 08:12 To: DS_Friends_Keshishian Subject: off line I am going offline. I feel the group is taking too much of my psychic energy right now. Talk to you all later. Quote
Guest guest Posted June 22, 2008 Report Posted June 22, 2008 I understand how time consuming it is for you to read all our posts, Marta. And I know how you worry about each of us. I hope you soon come back to us because we need you here. Remember, it was one person and not all of us who " went off. " Ntt t From: DS_Friends_Keshishian [mailto:DS_Friends_Keshishian ] On Behalf Of mjs93311 Sent: 22 June 2008 08:12 To: DS_Friends_Keshishian Subject: off line I am going offline. I feel the group is taking too much of my psychic energy right now. Talk to you all later. Quote
Guest guest Posted June 22, 2008 Report Posted June 22, 2008 In a message dated 6/22/2008 10:26:22 A.M. Central Daylight Time, sonofmosiah@... writes: And I know how you worry about each of us. I hope you soon come back to us because we need you here. Remember, it was one person and not all of us who " went off. " Ntt t _________________________________ Jim and all, I guess I opened this can of worms. I have been on the internet a long time and have seen a lot of people hawking their products online. I know peole can self educate themselves. Look at Jo, She is one of the most intelligent people I know about the Ds to not be a medical professional. BUT she has Dr. K's office behind her and checks before she tells anyone anything. I DO have a problem with a person prescribing without a licence which is basically what is happening here. Because vitamins and supplements are not controlled like prescription meds, they can be sold by anyone and anyone can tell you what ever they want as long as they add the disclaimer that these claims are not medically proven. There are people who will sell you anything you want in this day and age without any medical knowledge. I have seen a lot of it from fibromyalgia. There are a lot of snake oil salesmen out there if you know what I mean. Now as far as labs and supplements.... Nothing in my opinion trumps your doctors advice and the people who are actually treating you. I don't give a damn who vita lady has helped. I mean, I can tell people who are low in calcium to increase it. My doc told me that and usually they get better. But even as a RN, I refuse to dispense medical advice as far as supplements because of what marta said. Some supplements at larger levels are dangerous. Sometimes weird levels constantly are a sign of disease. I mean I had a problem with my stomach preop that was a protein losing gastroenteropathy. It was indicated by a very low level of b 12. I had been very low with no supplementation raising it. What if I was asking vita lady who has no knowledge of disease and some lab indications and just continued to supplement with greater doses of b12 and ignored the cause? Well, this problem can become cancerous with time. Jo, daddy died of the same problem and it is a oddity but sometimes it happens. So sometimes the labs are not just low vitamin levels are something bad and your doc should be the one monitoring the levels and you can buy whatever supplements you want, and you can listen o her advice, but My thoughts are run her advice by an actual medical professional such as your bariatric surgeon! Sometime one lab low, and maybe something can make a change like adding vitamin c to help absorb iron. Instead of just constantly increasing iron. Anyway, I am rambling..... I do not understand why advising people to listen to their docs about labs was such a crime? It is common sense. This lady is making a profit on this stuff, she is not a medical professional or nutritionist, She doesn't have any degrees to make he more knowledgeable than my doctor and therefore in my opinion she is nothing but a vitamin salesperson who is dispensing medical advice without a licence. This is my opinion and If you like her products, Buy them, but for the most part, I find them overpriced and sometimes more than is needed. I buy my own vitamins, go by the doctors advice. If I get advice from a non professional I ask my docs if it is a viable option. There are so many different opinions. For example there are different types of iron and calcium. Dr. K tells me he prefers ferrous fumerate at a office visit. So I look for that type. I have also heard that he doesn't tell people calcium citrate is so much better and would rather you get any calcium in than none of one specific kind. My last words on this subject is that if vita lady wants to get my respect she would get a degree to back up the advice she is dispensing. For the most part I feel she is harmless, but I am of the opinion that anyone selling something to you has an agenda and it is usually her pocketbook! **************Gas prices getting you down? Search AOL Autos for fuel-efficient used cars. (http://autos.aol.com/used?ncid=aolaut00050000000007) Quote
Guest guest Posted June 22, 2008 Report Posted June 22, 2008 AMEN!!!!!!! Getting wrong medical advice can be life threatening. Shame on her for doing this. For those who take her advice, what if you had a problem and went to her instead of your doc and then your problem was not resolved? If people dont want to listen to their doc, then dont complain about vit problems. They can happen even being 100% compliant. We have seen it and heard of it. You have done nothing wrong if you are compliant. If you keep you MEDICAL DEGREE doctor out of the loop, then you have to take responsibility for this because Miss Vitalady is not the one to give advice. Online medical advice. I shudder. I fully agree with what Mel said about Jo. She is very knowledgable but gives us info she has recieved from the office. That is true credible information. Vicki Sorry to be so harsh but this is our life and sometimes we all need to hear it without sugar coating it- including me. I have gotten butt kickings and I am more than grateful for it. Dr. Z and Dee didnt do this- you guys did. And I am forever grateful. This is what this group is for. Take the advice and dont be so butt hurt over it. If you cannot bear to hear it, dont ask...........Doc, I am so sorry and will understand if you delete my message., MDL1031@... wrote: In a message dated 6/22/2008 10:26:22 A.M. Central Daylight Time, sonofmosiah@... writes: And I know how you worry about each of us. I hope you soon come back to us because we need you here. Remember, it was one person and not all of us who " went off. " Ntt t _________________________________ Jim and all, I guess I opened this can of worms. I have been on the internet a long time and have seen a lot of people hawking their products online. I know peole can self educate themselves. Look at Jo, She is one of the most intelligent people I know about the Ds to not be a medical professional. BUT she has Dr. K's office behind her and checks before she tells anyone anything. I DO have a problem with a person prescribing without a licence which is basically what is happening here. Because vitamins and supplements are not controlled like prescription meds, they can be sold by anyone and anyone can tell you what ever they want as long as they add the disclaimer that these claims are not medically proven. There are people who will sell you anything you want in this day and age without any medical knowledge. I have seen a lot of it from fibromyalgia. There are a lot of snake oil salesmen out there if you know what I mean. Now as far as labs and supplements.... Nothing in my opinion trumps your doctors advice and the people who are actually treating you. I don't give a damn who vita lady has helped. I mean, I can tell people who are low in calcium to increase it. My doc told me that and usually they get better. But even as a RN, I refuse to dispense medical advice as far as supplements because of what marta said. Some supplements at larger levels are dangerous. Sometimes weird levels constantly are a sign of disease. I mean I had a problem with my stomach preop that was a protein losing gastroenteropathy. It was indicated by a very low level of b 12. I had been very low with no supplementation raising it. What if I was asking vita lady who has no knowledge of disease and some lab indications and just continued to supplement with greater doses of b12 and ignored the cause? Well, this problem can become cancerous with time. Jo, daddy died of the same problem and it is a oddity but sometimes it happens. So sometimes the labs are not just low vitamin levels are something bad and your doc should be the one monitoring the levels and you can buy whatever supplements you want, and you can listen o her advice, but My thoughts are run her advice by an actual medical professional such as your bariatric surgeon! Sometime one lab low, and maybe something can make a change like adding vitamin c to help absorb iron. Instead of just constantly increasing iron. Anyway, I am rambling..... I do not understand why advising people to listen to their docs about labs was such a crime? It is common sense. This lady is making a profit on this stuff, she is not a medical professional or nutritionist, She doesn't have any degrees to make he more knowledgeable than my doctor and therefore in my opinion she is nothing but a vitamin salesperson who is dispensing medical advice without a licence. This is my opinion and If you like her products, Buy them, but for the most part, I find them overpriced and sometimes more than is needed. I buy my own vitamins, go by the doctors advice. If I get advice from a non professional I ask my docs if it is a viable option. There are so many different opinions. For example there are different types of iron and calcium. Dr. K tells me he prefers ferrous fumerate at a office visit. So I look for that type. I have also heard that he doesn't tell people calcium citrate is so much better and would rather you get any calcium in than none of one specific kind. My last words on this subject is that if vita lady wants to get my respect she would get a degree to back up the advice she is dispensing. For the most part I feel she is harmless, but I am of the opinion that anyone selling something to you has an agenda and it is usually her pocketbook! **************Gas prices getting you down? Search AOL Autos for fuel-efficient used cars. (http://autos.aol.com/used?ncid=aolaut00050000000007) Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.