Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

RE: Son runs off

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Guest guest
Posted

Carolyn,

Please do not answer posts being so judgemental. When a person asks for advice, we can give them what has worked for us, and then they can decide what they might try to work for them. I could say the same to you, about the stick issue....but I wouldn't do that. As parents, we have the responsibility to keep our children safe....no matter how it is done as long as they are safe. I will not sit here and justify my actions, as I know that my children know they are loved and are very secure in my parenting.

Thank you for watching what you say from now on!!

Jodie

Son runs off

>

>

> My 3.5 year old with PDD-NOS/Asperger's runs off when we go places. I

> ask him to come back, he doesn't seem to care; I run after him, he

> goes farther (I think he thinks it's a game).

>

> Any suggestions on how to keep him from doing this?

>

> Thanks!

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

I had to tie my son Marty up to things when he was little because he was

so drugged up, etc. from the meds he took for seizures he couldn't

understand any commands or discipline. Funny about him too he used to

run towards the most dangerous thing he could find; fires, the river,

traffic, sigh, jumped out windows. He sounded just like that boy in the

Bible who rolled in fires, etc., where the father took him to Jesus to

heal, that was him.

I tied him up when went out on picnics, etc. for his protection and for

ours, but at times people did glare at us. " Why are you abusing that

child, " da, da, da!

Oh well.

Carolyn

Riley wrote:

>

>

> I used a harness on my son when he was small. There was some talk of

> banning them because it was seen as treating kids like animals, but it

> did work. I still see parents using them around here. Of course, it

> wouldn't look so good with a 10 yo. Otherwise, I just insisted he

> held my hand. He stopped running off by about 2 yo,which made life a

> lot easier. If you chase a kid, they always run because they like

> playing games, which is what it seem slike to them.

>

>

>

>

>

>>

>>

>> i don't have advice, i'm looking for advice for this too.� my son who

>> is almost 10 has done this as recently as this past year.� it has

>> lessened as he's gotten older, but he still does it if he gets too

>> frustrated.�

>> any tips on getting them to come back?� i'll be watching this thread.�

>> thanks for asking the question!

>> heather

>>

>> On Tue, Jun 14, 2011 at 8:03 AM, karjina <karjina@...

>> > wrote:

>>

>> �

>>

>> My 3.5 year old with PDD-NOS/Asperger's runs off when we go

>> places. I ask him to come back, he doesn't seem to care; I run

>> after him, he goes farther (I think he thinks it's a game).

>>

>> Any suggestions on how to keep him from doing this?

>>

>> Thanks!

>>

>>

>

Guest guest
Posted

Hi Carolyn,

I normally don't respond, just read, however, I responded today because I have this problem with my son who is 3.5. My husband and I tell my son bye when he runs off sometimes like we are going to leave him, but we would never do that. Its a tactic that is used on a lot of small children, even those whom are not on the spectrum. I find your response to be a little too serious, I don't believe for a second that saying bye to them like you are going to leave them when they run from you is as close to placing them in an institution.

Just my thoughts......

From: autism-aspergers [mailto:autism-aspergers ] On Behalf Of CarolynSent: Tuesday, June 14, 2011 11:58 AMTo: autism-aspergers Subject: Re: Son runs off

Oh man I hate that one, see people doing this in super markets, etc. "If you don't get over here I am leaving you." To me this seems like the worst abuse you can give a child and I have never ever used it. With me instead I have always assured them I would NEVER leave them, never, not for any reason would I leave them. My son Marty they wanted me to send him away to an institution and I refused, to me it is the worst thing you can do to a child, to threaten abandonment if they are not good. Because who of us are good all the time.Nobody!Just differences in how to raise children I guess, but this is one thing I have never ever done. Guess I didn't like it done to me. My mom to this day is very rejecting of me and it is a hurtful thing.Carolyn ;o(Jcoopalla wrote:> >> Just know, it does get better, because my 16 year old used to do the > same thing, and now he gets mad at me if I jaywalk!> > When he was very young, like yours, I used a modified harness. It was > a "fanny pack" where he kept some kind of toy, and on the back was a > ring which was attached to a bungee type cord. I started using this > when he ran into a parking lot and almost got hit by a car. Yes, I got > several nasty looks from people, but I basically said to them...would > you prefer he run off and get lost or perhaps kidnapped when he runs > off?? People turn quickly away and mind their own business.> > As for what worked for me when he was older and would stray away, I > would tell him (I'm sure he knew I would never follow through) that I > am now leaving, so he needed to come with me and stay with me. I would > then turn and walk toward the door or my car. I think down deep he > knew that I would never leave him, but just the idea of it was enough > for him to never stray very far. Now, that he is older I have complete > trust in him that he will be where he is supposed to be!> >>> >>> Son runs off>> > My 3.5 year old with PDD-NOS/Asperger's runs off when we go places. I > ask him to come back, he doesn't seem to care; I run after him, he > goes farther (I think he thinks it's a game).>> Any suggestions on how to keep him from doing this?>> Thanks!>>

===================================

Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail

Cleveland Clinic is ranked one of the top hospitals

in America by U.S.News World Report (2010). Visit us online at http://www.clevelandclinic.org for

a complete listing of our services, staff and

locations.

Confidentiality Note: This message is intended for use

only by the individual or entity to which it is addressed

and may contain information that is privileged,

confidential, and exempt from disclosure under applicable

law. If the reader of this message is not the intended

recipient or the employee or agent responsible for

delivering the message to the intended recipient, you are

hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or

copying of this communication is strictly prohibited. If

you have received this communication in error, please

contact the sender immediately and destroy the material in

its entirety, whether electronic or hard copy. Thank you.

Guest guest
Posted

That's a hard one, wondering if you're teaching him to run from you. I

believe in a LOT of hand holding. Just yesterday I picked up my grandson

who has been recently diagnosed with aspergers and I thought I was there

early but missed him. Luckily I caught a red flash out of the corner of

my eye of him heading towards the track. At his school there is a loop

and parents park along the loop and his mom is usually parked there so

he runs to her car. Well I had parked clear in back between the junior

high and elementary because my other grandson comes out that way and I

wanted him to see my van as he did not know I was coming for him.

Anyway I cut across the parking lot, two lanes of traffic and headed to

the end of the loop and yelled, " Lucas! " and he saw me and began to run

towards me, am so glad he didn't stumble on that black top and was

careful I was clear over so he did not have to cross traffic to get to

me. Once he did I took his hand and off we marched some distance to my

van, and I said " Boy you were in a hurry to get out of there, and I had

to walk clear over here with my sore knee. "

And he said, " Oh grandma I am sorry you have a sore knee, " more evidence

of his empathy! I didn't let go of his hand no matter he will be 7 next

month till I got him safely into the van.

Hand holding is a good thing.

Carolyn ;o)

lin, Jasmine wrote:

>

> Hi Karjina,

> My son does the same exact thing, he is 3.5 diagnosed last June. He

> thinks its a game of cat and mouse, he loves to be chased. We actually

> play with him like that in the house, I am wondering if we are making

> it worse! He smiles and laughs when he does it, not knowing how

> terrified we are, especially in a crowded area or in a parking lot. I

> am so scared that he will be hit by a car......I now just hold his

> hand when we are out without my husband. When my husband is with us,

> he will let him go but he is more stern with him and my son will

> normally come back when called by husband......

>

> ------------------------------------------------------------------------

> *From:* autism-aspergers

> [mailto:autism-aspergers ] *On Behalf Of *karjina

> *Sent:* Tuesday, June 14, 2011 8:04 AM

> *To:* autism-aspergers

> *Subject:* Son runs off

>

> My 3.5 year old with PDD-NOS/Asperger's runs off when we go places. I

> ask him to come back, he doesn't seem to care; I run after him, he

> goes farther (I think he thinks it's a game).

>

> Any suggestions on how to keep him from doing this?

>

> Thanks!

>

> ===================================

>

> Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail

>

>

>

> Cleveland Clinic is ranked one of the top hospitals

> in America by U.S.News World Report (2010).

> Visit us online at http://www.clevelandclinic.org for

> a complete listing of our services, staff and

> locations.

>

>

> Confidentiality Note: This message is intended for use

> only by the individual or entity to which it is addressed

> and may contain information that is privileged,

> confidential, and exempt from disclosure under applicable

> law. If the reader of this message is not the intended

> recipient or the employee or agent responsible for

> delivering the message to the intended recipient, you are

> hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or

> copying of this communication is strictly prohibited. If

> you have received this communication in error, please

> contact the sender immediately and destroy the material in

> its entirety, whether electronic or hard copy. Thank you.

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

If you think about it though the fear of abandonment is very serious,

people can have this feeling in them their whole lives and it can ruin

their lives.

I just don't see why that seed has to be planted in a child's heart at

all especially by his parent and have chosen not to do it with any of my

children, not ever.

Just think of the consequences as not all children are alike. Add to

this other types of rejection the child my get from others and it could

lead to a real sad kid. Some it may not affect as badly but I am not

willing to take that chance, putting the fear of me abandoning the child

I love in him if he does not " act right. "

Carolyn

lin, Jasmine wrote:

>

> Hi Carolyn,

> I normally don't respond, just read, however, I responded today

> because I have this problem with my son who is 3.5. My husband and I

> tell my son bye when he runs off sometimes like we are going to leave

> him, but we would never do that. Its a tactic that is used on a lot of

> small children, even those whom are not on the spectrum. I find your

> response to be a little too serious, I don't believe for a second that

> saying bye to them like you are going to leave them when they run from

> you is as close to placing them in an institution.

> Just my thoughts......

>

> ------------------------------------------------------------------------

> *From:* autism-aspergers

> [mailto:autism-aspergers ] *On Behalf Of *Carolyn

> *Sent:* Tuesday, June 14, 2011 11:58 AM

> *To:* autism-aspergers

> *Subject:* Re: Son runs off

>

> Oh man I hate that one, see people doing this in super markets, etc. " If

> you don't get over here I am leaving you. " To me this seems like the

> worst abuse you can give a child and I have never ever used it. With me

> instead I have always assured them I would NEVER leave them, never, not

> for any reason would I leave them. My son Marty they wanted me to send

> him away to an institution and I refused, to me it is the worst thing

> you can do to a child, to threaten abandonment if they are not good.

> Because who of us are good all the time.

>

> Nobody!

>

> Just differences in how to raise children I guess, but this is one

> thing I have never ever done. Guess I didn't like it done to me. My mom

> to this day is very rejecting of me and it is a hurtful thing.

>

> Carolyn ;o(

>

> Jcoopalla wrote:

> >

> >

> > Just know, it does get better, because my 16 year old used to do the

> > same thing, and now he gets mad at me if I jaywalk!

> >

> > When he was very young, like yours, I used a modified harness. It was

> > a " fanny pack " where he kept some kind of toy, and on the back was a

> > ring which was attached to a bungee type cord. I started using this

> > when he ran into a parking lot and almost got hit by a car. Yes, I got

> > several nasty looks from people, but I basically said to them...would

> > you prefer he run off and get lost or perhaps kidnapped when he runs

> > off?? People turn quickly away and mind their own business.

> >

> > As for what worked for me when he was older and would stray away, I

> > would tell him (I'm sure he knew I would never follow through) that I

> > am now leaving, so he needed to come with me and stay with me. I would

> > then turn and walk toward the door or my car. I think down deep he

> > knew that I would never leave him, but just the idea of it was enough

> > for him to never stray very far. Now, that he is older I have complete

> > trust in him that he will be where he is supposed to be!

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > Son runs off

> >

> >

> > My 3.5 year old with PDD-NOS/Asperger's runs off when we go places. I

> > ask him to come back, he doesn't seem to care; I run after him, he

> > goes farther (I think he thinks it's a game).

> >

> > Any suggestions on how to keep him from doing this?

> >

> > Thanks!

> >

> >

>

> ===================================

>

> Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail

>

>

>

> Cleveland Clinic is ranked one of the top hospitals

> in America by U.S.News World Report (2010).

> Visit us online at http://www.clevelandclinic.org for

> a complete listing of our services, staff and

> locations.

>

>

> Confidentiality Note: This message is intended for use

> only by the individual or entity to which it is addressed

> and may contain information that is privileged,

> confidential, and exempt from disclosure under applicable

> law. If the reader of this message is not the intended

> recipient or the employee or agent responsible for

> delivering the message to the intended recipient, you are

> hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or

> copying of this communication is strictly prohibited. If

> you have received this communication in error, please

> contact the sender immediately and destroy the material in

> its entirety, whether electronic or hard copy. Thank you.

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

I am sorry if I seem judgmental to you, just a little passionate about

this one I guess.

Anyway many here have been very judgmental about this stick issue and

other things.

Carolyn

Jcoopalla wrote:

>

>

> Carolyn,

> Please do not answer posts being so judgemental. When a person asks

> for advice, we can give them what has worked for us, and then they can

> decide what they might try to work for them. I could say the same to

> you, about the stick issue....but I wouldn't do that. As parents, we

> have the responsibility to keep our children safe....no matter how it

> is done as long as they are safe. I will not sit here and justify my

> actions, as I know that my children know they are loved and are very

> secure in my parenting.

>

> Thank you for watching what you say from now on!!

> Jodie

>

>

>

> Son runs off

> >

> >

> > My 3.5 year old with PDD-NOS/Asperger's runs off when we go places. I

> > ask him to come back, he doesn't seem to care; I run after him, he

> > goes farther (I think he thinks it's a game).

> >

> > Any suggestions on how to keep him from doing this?

> >

> > Thanks!

> >

> >

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

My son was an eloper from the time he could walk (run).   He even opened the front door and took off in the nieghborhood when he was 17 months old.  I didn't even know he could open the front door.  It was terrifying.  I found him playing about 2 blocks away in the backyard of a neighbor I didn't know.  When my daughter was 21 months old (who is 16 months younger then him), he encouraged her to come on a walk about with him - out the french doors of the back room.  I was having coffee in the kitchen when I didn't see them running around so I went looking to see what they were up to.  I saw them trotting downt he road together in nothing but diapers.  That was a sceene, me running after them in my bathrobe and slippers when they ran giggling down the road.  I tried to get Project Lifesaver set up in Orlando at the time, but couldn't generate enough interest from others to make it happen.

 

What worked for me.  I would take my son to the park and explain the rules to him (several times).  1. Do not leave ____ area.  2.  If you have to go to the bathroom, come and get me.   3.  If you want to go look at something, let me know first.   4.  If you do not follow the rules, we will go home.

 

There were times when we had been at the park for just a few minutes and he would run off.  I would get him, sit him down and ask him what the rule was.  I would go over the list of rules again.  Then, we would pack up and go home.  We lived in Orlando and we left Sea World, Universal Studios, waterparks...etc.   Eventually, he got it.

 

When he got old enough to read, I started writing the rules down and having him read them to me.  Then I would have him sign on the bottom that he understood and agreed to follow them.  If he broke a rule, I would call him out on it and ask him what the rule was.  Usually, he would repeat the rule and stop.  If he did not after one warning, we would go home.   Last summer, he flew home unaccompanied from Orlando to New York.  I had emailed the rules to him and had his grandma repeat them to him and had him sign off on them.  He was 9-years-old at the time and was diagnosed as " profoundly autistic " at 2 1/2.

 

You will HAVE to be very consistant for this to work.  Even if you want to stay, or your other kids want to stay.  Let the other kids know that you will do something else for them as a replacement.  My son is 10 now and I almost never have a problem with him straying away. 

 

 

 

My 3.5 year old with PDD-NOS/Asperger's runs off when we go places. I ask him to come back, he doesn't seem to care; I run after him, he goes farther (I think he thinks it's a game).Any suggestions on how to keep him from doing this?

Thanks!

Guest guest
Posted

Hello Debra, I love your rules. I always had rules for the kids also,

which I think most parents do. With me though I would work on one kid at

a time, if he didn't obey my rule he got the punishment on the spot, not

everybody went home. There was just too many things to keep up with I

guess. Like recently we were at the park and my daughter saw her son

Lucas throwing sand, she yelled at the window in a rather strong tone of

voice, " Lucaaas STOP throwing sand! " Her voice scared him so he stopped.

Another time some kids were climbing up the slide backwards and she

didn't want Lucas to do it, so she yelled again, " Stop climbing up the

slide! " and he stopped.

The kids have pretty much been trained to follow voice commands now, at

first there was reinforcement a few times with the stick.

Carolyn

Debra Donatto wrote:

>

> My son was an eloper from the time he could walk (run). He even

> opened the front door and took off in the nieghborhood when he was 17

> months old. I didn't even know he could open the front door. It was

> terrifying. I found him playing about 2 blocks away in the backyard

> of a neighbor I didn't know. When my daughter was 21 months old (who

> is 16 months younger then him), he encouraged her to come on a walk

> about with him - out the french doors of the back room. I was having

> coffee in the kitchen when I didn't see them running around so I went

> looking to see what they were up to. I saw them trotting downt he

> road together in nothing but diapers. That was a sceene, me running

> after them in my bathrobe and slippers when they ran giggling down the

> road. I tried to get Project Lifesaver set up in Orlando at the time,

> but couldn't generate enough interest from others to make it happen.

>

> What worked for me. I would take my son to the park and explain the

> rules to him (several times). 1. Do not leave ____ area. 2. If you

> have to go to the bathroom, come and get me. 3. If you want to go

> look at something, let me know first. 4. If you do not follow the

> rules, we will go home.

>

> There were times when we had been at the park for just a few minutes

> and he would run off. I would get him, sit him down and ask him what

> the rule was. I would go over the list of rules again. Then, we

> would pack up and go home. We lived in Orlando and we left Sea World,

> Universal Studios, waterparks...etc. Eventually, he got it.

>

> When he got old enough to read, I started writing the rules down and

> having him read them to me. Then I would have him sign on the bottom

> that he understood and agreed to follow them. If he broke a rule, I

> would call him out on it and ask him what the rule was. Usually, he

> would repeat the rule and stop. If he did not after one warning, we

> would go home. Last summer, he flew home unaccompanied from Orlando

> to New York. I had emailed the rules to him and had his grandma

> repeat them to him and had him sign off on them. He was 9-years-old

> at the time and was diagnosed as " profoundly autistic " at 2 1/2.

>

> You will HAVE to be very consistant for this to work. Even if you

> want to stay, or your other kids want to stay. Let the other kids

> know that you will do something else for them as a replacement. My

> son is 10 now and I almost never have a problem with him straying away.

>

>

>

>

> On Tue, Jun 14, 2011 at 8:03 AM, karjina <karjina@...

> > wrote:

>

>

>

> My 3.5 year old with PDD-NOS/Asperger's runs off when we go

> places. I ask him to come back, he doesn't seem to care; I run

> after him, he goes farther (I think he thinks it's a game).

>

> Any suggestions on how to keep him from doing this?

>

> Thanks!

>

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

Carolyn, not only is it abusive to treat a child that way, it teaches

them that if things get bad, they will be left behind and abandoned. I

once saw a parent that had done this a lot and the kid said to her, " Go

AHEAD and leave me! " But by then the kid was the parent, and the parent

was the kid - fully under the control of the child.

> Oh man I hate that one, see people doing this in super markets, etc. " If

> you don't get over here I am leaving you. " To me this seems like the

> worst abuse you can give a child and I have never ever used it. With me

> instead I have always assured them I would NEVER leave them, never, not

> for any reason would I leave them. My son Marty they wanted me to send

> him away to an institution and I refused, to me it is the worst thing

> you can do to a child, to threaten abandonment if they are not good.

> Because who of us are good all the time.

>

> Nobody!

>

> Just differences in how to raise children I guess, but this is one

> thing I have never ever done. Guess I didn't like it done to me. My mom

> to this day is very rejecting of me and it is a hurtful thing.

>

> Carolyn ;o(

>

> Jcoopalla wrote:

>>

>>

>> Just know, it does get better, because my 16 year old used to do the

>> same thing, and now he gets mad at me if I jaywalk!

>>

>> When he was very young, like yours, I used a modified harness. It was

>> a " fanny pack " where he kept some kind of toy, and on the back was a

>> ring which was attached to a bungee type cord. I started using this

>> when he ran into a parking lot and almost got hit by a car. Yes, I got

>> several nasty looks from people, but I basically said to them...would

>> you prefer he run off and get lost or perhaps kidnapped when he runs

>> off?? People turn quickly away and mind their own business.

>>

>> As for what worked for me when he was older and would stray away, I

>> would tell him (I'm sure he knew I would never follow through) that I

>> am now leaving, so he needed to come with me and stay with me. I would

>> then turn and walk toward the door or my car. I think down deep he

>> knew that I would never leave him, but just the idea of it was enough

>> for him to never stray very far. Now, that he is older I have complete

>> trust in him that he will be where he is supposed to be!

>>

>>

>>

>>

>>

>>

>> Son runs off

>>

>>

>> My 3.5 year old with PDD-NOS/Asperger's runs off when we go places. I

>> ask him to come back, he doesn't seem to care; I run after him, he

>> goes farther (I think he thinks it's a game).

>>

>> Any suggestions on how to keep him from doing this?

>>

>> Thanks!

>>

>>

>

> ------------------------------------

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

Upon thinking about this I realize you hit on my pet peeve and I ceased

the chance to vent my feelings about it. I really do hate it when I see

parents doing this.

First time I got to vent about it...

I do not support inflicting emotional abuse on our children all in the

name of discipline.

Carolyn

Carolyn wrote:

>

>

> I am sorry if I seem judgmental to you, just a little passionate about

> this one I guess.

>

> Anyway many here have been very judgmental about this stick issue and

> other things.

>

> Carolyn

>

> Jcoopalla wrote:

> >

> >

> > Carolyn,

> > Please do not answer posts being so judgemental. When a person asks

> > for advice, we can give them what has worked for us, and then they can

> > decide what they might try to work for them. I could say the same to

> > you, about the stick issue....but I wouldn't do that. As parents, we

> > have the responsibility to keep our children safe....no matter how it

> > is done as long as they are safe. I will not sit here and justify my

> > actions, as I know that my children know they are loved and are very

> > secure in my parenting.

> >

> > Thank you for watching what you say from now on!!

> > Jodie

> >

> >

> >

> > Son runs off

> > >

> > >

> > > My 3.5 year old with PDD-NOS/Asperger's runs off when we go places. I

> > > ask him to come back, he doesn't seem to care; I run after him, he

> > > goes farther (I think he thinks it's a game).

> > >

> > > Any suggestions on how to keep him from doing this?

> > >

> > > Thanks!

> > >

> > >

> >

> >

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

Jodie, I DID leave my child one day lol but he was being stubborn about getting in the car for school so i started pulling out and went down the block watching him the whole time. He got the picture and has never done it again. He was in Kindergarden or first and is now in fourth grade. These are kids that need black and white. There is no grey area with them and that is why sometimes they need the more "grown up" approach rather than the babying that most kids need. Braydon has been a flight risk from day 1. At 18 mos old he ran away 3 times while we were packing the moving van. We had 6 adults watching him and my 14 yo sis at the time and he still managed to get away. At age 4 he ran off completely and i had to call the cops. There have been

numerous other times i've turned around and he's been GONE. Its scarey but they do start to grow out of it. I still worry that he'll wander off...it is an over focussing thing that does it for him and he doesnt pay attention to what everyone else is doing around him. Just stay persistent. Put a leash on him if you need to. Make sure he's in the cart at the stores at all times. And know you're not alone...HUGS!!Daisy: wife to , Mom to Adayla, Braydon, Colton, and Faythe

>

>

> Just know, it does get better, because my 16 year old used to do the

> same thing, and now he gets mad at me if I jaywalk!

>

> When he was very young, like yours, I used a modified harness. It was

> a "fanny pack" where he kept some kind of toy, and on the back was a

> ring which was attached to a bungee type cord. I started using this

> when he ran into a parking lot and almost got hit by a car. Yes, I got

> several nasty looks from people, but I basically said to them...would

> you prefer he run off and get lost or perhaps kidnapped when he runs

> off?? People turn quickly away and mind their own business.

>

> As for what worked for me when he was older and would stray away, I

> would tell him (I'm sure he knew I would never follow through) that I

> am now leaving, so he needed to come with me and stay with me. I would

> then turn and walk toward the door or my car. I think down deep he

> knew that I would never leave him, but just the idea of it was enough

> for him to never stray very far. Now, that he is older I have complete

> trust in him that he will be where he is supposed to be!

>

>

>

>

>

>

> Son runs off

>

>

> My 3.5 year old with PDD-NOS/Asperger's runs off when we go places. I

> ask him to come back, he doesn't seem to care; I run after him, he

> goes farther (I think he thinks it's a game).

>

> Any suggestions on how to keep him from doing this?

>

> Thanks!

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

I agree 100%, consistency is the key to anything working.  There are

advantages and disadvantages to every form of discipline.  Each form

is a type of negative feedback used to force a type of behavior -

but it only works if it is solid and consistent 100% of the time. 

If the fire only burned on occasion, then why not test it at every

chance to see if the result is different THIS time.  It becomes a

game, and eventually the kid gets angry at the fire for burning him.

If you say no, and then reinforce with negative feedback, and you do

that every single time, then it will only take a few attempts to

break your will before the child stops the behavior and moves on to

new things.  If you allow the kid to break your will, then he wins,

you lose, and the bahavor will not only never stop but will

gradually get worse.  Why?  The kid loses respect for you and THAT

is the most dangerous thing you can ever happen.

My son was an eloper from the time he could walk (run).   He

even opened the front door and took off in the nieghborhood when

he was 17 months old.  I didn't even know he could open the

front door.  It was terrifying.  I found him playing about 2

blocks away in the backyard of a neighbor I didn't know.  When

my daughter was 21 months old (who is 16 months younger then

him), he encouraged her to come on a walk about with him - out

the french doors of the back room.  I was having coffee in the

kitchen when I didn't see them running around so I went looking

to see what they were up to.  I saw them trotting downt he road

together in nothing but diapers.  That was a sceene, me running

after them in my bathrobe and slippers when they ran giggling

down the road.  I tried to get Project Lifesaver set up in

Orlando at the time, but couldn't generate enough interest from

others to make it happen....

 

You will HAVE to be very consistant for this to work.  Even

if you want to stay, or your other kids want to stay.  Let the

other kids know that you will do something else for them as a

replacement.  My son is 10 now and I almost never have a problem

with him straying away. 

 _,_._,___

Guest guest
Posted

I agree with you on this one about being consistent. I think

that must be one of the things I got right in all of this, that

countered all the mistakes I've made. Nobody is perfect but I do believe

if you choose a path that you really need to stick to it and not waiver

trying new things all the time like you don't know what you are doing,

don't know who the parent is,, going this way and that...

I was real good with my own kids but not as good with my grandkids. For

one they have a mom and we don't always agree. I had them full time for

about 10 years when she worked from each one was born, so it got a

little confusing for all of us who the mom was. So now when they come

over after school almost every day, she yells at them and says, " Well my

mom wouldn't let me get away with that! " (she is talking about me) And

it is true I would not have, but her kids DO get away with it and

sometimes I am just soooo glad when they just go home after listening to

several hours of her yelling and them, and them NOT minding her.

She does have one tactic that works pretty well and I am proud of her

she's followed through on it, she grounds them. No friends, no video

games, can't go anywhere. When she has finally had enough, she finally

starts to warn them when they don't back down and obey her, usually it

is always the boys scuffling, maybe warns them a couple of times and

when she feels the have gone too far, Bam! they are grounded. And as far

as I know she follows through at home, I thank God I don't live with them.

When they were with me I gave a command, maybe two or three times and if

they refused to obey me they got the stick. She does have a stick at

home though that she has been known to use at times also, because sad to

say kids can be real brats, and it is our job to control them.

I remember though there was something else I used to use on my kids,

just came to me. We were a Christian family then and went to church and

I instilled into them that it was MY JOB to teach them to OBEY GOD, so

if they defied me, they defied Him. Kind of played the empathy card.

That seemed to work pretty well and I believed it with all my heart too,

still do too!

Carolyn ;o)

H wrote:

>

>

> I agree 100%, consistency is the key to anything working. There are

> advantages and disadvantages to every form of discipline. Each form

> is a type of negative feedback used to force a type of behavior - but

> it only works if it is solid and consistent 100% of the time. If the

> fire only burned on occasion, then why not test it at every chance to

> see if the result is different THIS time. It becomes a game, and

> eventually the kid gets angry at the fire for burning him.

>

> If you say no, and then reinforce with negative feedback, and you do

> that every single time, then it will only take a few attempts to break

> your will before the child stops the behavior and moves on to new

> things. If you allow the kid to break your will, then he wins, you

> lose, and the bahavor will not only never stop but will gradually get

> worse. Why? The kid loses respect for you and THAT is the most

> dangerous thing you can ever happen.

>

>

>

>

>> My son was an eloper from the time he could walk (run). He even

>> opened the front door and took off in the nieghborhood when he was 17

>> months old. I didn't even know he could open the front door. It was

>> terrifying. I found him playing about 2 blocks away in the backyard

>> of a neighbor I didn't know. When my daughter was 21 months old (who

>> is 16 months younger then him), he encouraged her to come on a walk

>> about with him - out the french doors of the back room. I was having

>> coffee in the kitchen when I didn't see them running around so I went

>> looking to see what they were up to. I saw them trotting downt he

>> road together in nothing but diapers. That was a sceene, me running

>> after them in my bathrobe and slippers when they ran giggling down

>> the road. I tried to get Project Lifesaver set up in Orlando at the

>> time, but couldn't generate enough interest from others to make it

>> happen....

>>

>>

>> You will HAVE to be very consistant for this to work. Even if you

>> want to stay, or your other kids want to stay. Let the other kids

>> know that you will do something else for them as a replacement. My

>> son is 10 now and I almost never have a problem with him straying away.

>> _,_._,___

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

oh but it's okay with you to inflict physical abuse on a child??? You, my dear woman are who is driving many people off of this site, even though it might be helpful. I am about one more time away from removing myself from this list and I feel that I have helped a lot of people on here. Advice, not judgements are what is expected from this site and the fact that it keeps happening, is not in the best interest of our loved ones that we are trying to help. Get with the program!!!!!!! uggghhhhhh

Son runs off

> > >

> > >

> > > My 3.5 year old with PDD-NOS/Asperger's runs off when we go places. I

> > > ask him to come back, he doesn't seem to care; I run after him, he

> > > goes farther (I think he thinks it's a game).

> > >

> > > Any suggestions on how to keep him from doing this?

> > >

> > > Thanks!

> > >

> > >

> >

> >

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

I don't see why I should be driving anybody anywhere, you are just a

bully. People are bullies who don't get their way looks like to me.

I have an opinion you have an opinion, why bully?

Carolyn

Jcoopalla wrote:

>

>

> oh but it's okay with you to inflict physical abuse on a child??? You,

> my dear woman are who is driving many people off of this site, even

> though it might be helpful. I am about one more time away from

> removing myself from this list and I feel that I have helped a lot of

> people on here. Advice, not judgements are what is expected from this

> site and the fact that it keeps happening, is not in the best interest

> of our loved ones that we are trying to help. Get with the

> program!!!!!!! uggghhhhhh

>

>

>

> Son runs off

> > > >

> > > >

> > > > My 3.5 year old with PDD-NOS/Asperger's runs off when we go

> places. I

> > > > ask him to come back, he doesn't seem to care; I run after him, he

> > > > goes farther (I think he thinks it's a game).

> > > >

> > > > Any suggestions on how to keep him from doing this?

> > > >

> > > > Thanks!

> > > >

> > > >

> > >

> > >

> >

> >

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

Daisy, so great that he got it...good for you! I know the feeling of the running away. There were a few times that I almost had to call the police, but there he was just perseverating on a flower behind a bush!!! No one say him go there. I think they see something and impulsively just run toward it and of course do not think of the consequences. It is not until we stress the consequences is there a change in behavior. Maturity and experiences do help our kids...mine has come such a long way. From having sensory meltdowns every day as a toddler, and running off at every opportunity to being a straight A student in high school and really contemplating living in a dorm at college. I will cry my eyes out the day that happens....and all his previous teachers who have stayed in touch with us will too! It is definitely a journey.

Son runs off

>

>

> My 3.5 year old with PDD-NOS/Asperger's runs off when we go places. I

> ask him to come back, he doesn't seem to care; I run after him, he

> goes farther (I think he thinks it's a game).

>

> Any suggestions on how to keep him from doing this?

>

> Thanks!

>

>

Guest guest
Posted

Can we please not get into the spanking discussion again. I think we

need to establish a 'naughty corner' here for those who stray into these

topics when we are meant to be having time out from them.

[moderator]

> I don't believe it! are you talking about spanking again!

>

> Just sat down to read my e-mails and yours was first. Made me laugh.

> Anyway I agree with you and your need to gain control in an instant.

> That is about all I ever had to use for was to gain control. Like

> yesterday my two grandsons were scuffing under a table where I had just

> dumped out a 1,000 piece puzzle and they were squirming and laughing and

> bumping the table legs and threw a pillow and spilled a bunch of my

> pieces. So I told them to " Go in the other room to scuffle, " but they

> ignored me and kept on under my table, so I said it again " Go in the

> other room, or better yet go outside. " No response, more scuffling.

>

> Then I said, " Do you want me to get my STICK! " and like magic they

> headed to the dining room. Don't even have to get it out anymore, just

> have to mention it's name. And that is the whole point people are

> missing, most kids it only take about one or two whacks at strategic

> times when you are working to teach them who their boss is, and then

> they " get it " forevermore, or at least that has been my experience in

> raising the four kids I have raised, and now these three of seven

> grandkids I am working on.

>

> Don't have to scream, don't have to yell, don't have to threaten, just

> mention its name.

>

> Perfect.

>

> Carolyn ;o)

>

>

> H wrote:

>> This is one of the few times where I would spank mine. Running off is a

>> deadly habit that I needed to stop immediately. I taught her that if

>> she ran off, or EVER ran away from me, she would get spanked on the spot.

>>

>> I was like most of you at first, until one afternoon she ran from me and

>> nearly got run down by a car. I needed to gain control, and needed to

>> do it fast.

>>

>> I quickly established that when I say STOP, she was to stop on the spot

>> and wait for me.

>>

>> She didn't like it, but after a short while, she would do things to make

>> me say stop and That would be the new game - one that we both enjoyed.

>>

>>> My 3.5 year old with PDD-NOS/Asperger's runs off when we go places.

>> I ask him to come back, he doesn't seem to care; I run after him, he

>> goes farther (I think he thinks it's a game).

>>> Any suggestions on how to keep him from doing this?

>>>

>>> Thanks!

>>>

>>>

>>>

>>> ------------------------------------

>>>

>>>

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...