Guest guest Posted June 29, 2010 Report Posted June 29, 2010 > Having never smelt real musk, I don't know what to really compare > the botanicals to and what aspects of them are the musky parts. I > recall a few horrible synthetic perfumes that are supposed to be > musks, and a few fragrance oils as well. Mostly those just hurt my > nose. :-) I have applied my nose to some of the botanicals such as > ambrette seed co2, angelica root co2, spikenard, oakmoss, labdanum, > costus, etc. I even have some hyrax stone tincture I have smelled. > I just can't find the common theme between them all that make them > musky. I've even tortured my poor partner and had him smelling away > at them, but more times than not he says they smell like root beer. > Sense of smell isn't a strong point in his family. :-) > > > Also, any good suggestions for Ambergris or Civet botanicals? > > I have seen the amber chord of benzoin, labdanum, and vanilla > before, even mixed it. I think Adam was 100% right in his post > saying that it isn't even comparable to the Ambergris tincture. Hi all, I have not seen or read any of the thread on the mystery of musk (or any other threads for a month or so). But I did see this post above... I have smelled real musk grains, once. (And am intimately familiar with ambergris.) I would not recommend anyone to purchase, use or otherwise trade in that product, and hope that the trade in real musk simply stops. And yet I met with a collector who had real musk grains, and so of course I smelled them. The aroma was unlike any other animal product that I had smelled, and I could see why it is so coveted. I think the only thing that could rival the musk in the animal aromas would be some very, very special ambergris. Of course they would be quite different but they both could be just as beautiful and exulting in their own respective ways. I also sense that the ambrette seed and the like are very different than musk, and yet, I feel that a musk droppleganger could be made using natural aromatic oils. I don't think synthetics could create anything close to musk or ambergris (even if they can make certain chemicals that appear in the natural products). The aromas of each are just far to, well - natural! I like that the above list of possible botanicals for musk include oakmoss, labdanum and spikenard. Some elements of these are needed to be blended with the ambrette and/or the more commonly thought of musk type botanicals oils. The true musk was surprisingly sweet, and also well rounded and full bodied as compared to ambrette, angelica, costus and the like. There are some old formulas for ambergris that include labdanum (of course), clary sage or fractions, cedar fractions and even (surprisingly to me) lavender. I would definitely add the fossilized amber oil to a musk or ambergris droppleganger, and also I would think about trying to get a nice cultivated agarwood (not wild) to work with too. They both would add the depth and are far more powerful in fixative value. The two single essences that are most closely related to ambergris are labdanum and fossilized amber oil. Also I think oakmoss and a good angelica absolute rather than co2 or essential oil of angelica, I would think would be key to a formula for musk. The angelica absolutes that I have sampled are far closer to real musk than either the co2 or eo. They have that sweetness and roundedness that I usually do not find in the eo or co2 extracts, and there are different species of angelica to try, if you can find them (try white lotus, christopher sometimes has them, I believe). The amber accord of benzoin, labdanum, vanilla (there are many variations) are more trying to recreate an aromatic amber resin or simply making an amber accord, I believe, rather than actually trying to imitate ambergris itself. Although these essences certainly could be used in an ambergris droppleganger (especially labdanum), they would not of themselves (alone or together) work for imitating ambergris - too sweet, needs more earthy aromas (fossilized amber, agarwood, etc.), a bit of seaweed, maybe some tobacco, and perhaps tonka instead of vanilla/benzoin, and an old style open fire cistus to round out and deepen the labdanum absolute which will help toned down its sweetness. Cheers and happy blending! Will Eden Botanicals will@... Quote
Guest guest Posted June 29, 2010 Report Posted June 29, 2010 Hi Will, no matter what you add to a Ambrette Seed Oil, it will not become more musk or more beautiful. All one does it to create a fragrance, with some musk note in it. I have purified Musk coming from the Musk Deer around 30 years ago. A small amount of about 1 Kg. I used to work for the fourth largest fragrance company in the world, so they could effort it. I know exactly how it smells and there is absolutely nothing in Nature that can substitute it. Once you smelled it, you will never forget. Substitute for Ambergris. There is none natural. There is nothing that comes even close to Ambergris Natural. Believe me. My old company had a big chunk of Ambergris. Absolutely wonderful scent. And I never ever forget how things smell. Civet. I had the opportunity to see, smell and feel the real Civet secret. I remember I scraped it out of a metal box, with all the impurities with it, hair, stones, dirt, wood. I purified it in the lab. Absolutely stinky stuff. But in high solution wonderful. There is no natural substitute for it. Also, real Musk from the Musk Deer, purified smells very different to Ambrette Seed Oil. Why I can say that? I saw it, smelled it and felt it. I made Ambrette Seed Oil my self through Steam Distillation. Therefore I can say there is no way to make Ambrette See Oil more musky smelling by adding all kind of suggested naturals. So, don't be frustrated when you don't get it. That's just the way it is. You just can try to create a nice scent with a beautiful musk note in it. Udo Quote
Guest guest Posted June 30, 2010 Report Posted June 30, 2010 Udo.... so real. So poetic. Thank you. Quote
Guest guest Posted June 30, 2010 Report Posted June 30, 2010 > > > > > > Hi Will, > no matter what you add to a Ambrette Seed Oil, it will not become more musk or more beautiful. All one does it to create a fragrance, with some musk note in it. > I have purified Musk coming from the Musk Deer around 30 years ago. A small amount of about 1 Kg. I used to work for the fourth largest fragrance company in the world, so they could effort it. I know exactly how it smells and there is absolutely nothing in Nature that can substitute it. Once you smelled it, you will never forget. > Substitute for Ambergris. There is none natural. There is nothing that comes even close to Ambergris Natural. Believe me. My old company had a big chunk of Ambergris. Absolutely wonderful scent. And I never ever forget how things smell. > Civet. I had the opportunity to see, smell and feel the real Civet secret. I remember I scraped it out of a metal box, with all the impurities with it, hair, stones, dirt, wood. I purified it in the lab. Absolutely stinky stuff. But in high solution wonderful. There is no natural substitute for it. > Also, real Musk from the Musk Deer, purified smells very different to Ambrette Seed Oil. > Why I can say that? I saw it, smelled it and felt it. I made Ambrette Seed Oil my self through Steam Distillation. > Therefore I can say there is no way to make Ambrette See Oil more musky smelling by adding all kind of suggested naturals. > So, don't be frustrated when you don't get it. That's just the way it is. You just can try to create a nice scent with a beautiful musk note in it. > > Udo > Thanks Udo and Will. It is so good to hear from people on the " supply " side, real life experience is the best. A Kg of Musk grains, the mind goes soft and useless at the thought of so much scent. Ross http://olfactoryrescueservice.wordpress.com/ Quote
Guest guest Posted June 30, 2010 Report Posted June 30, 2010 _______________________________ Thanks Udo and Will. It is so good to hear from people on the " supply " side, real life experience is the best. A Kg of Musk grains, the mind goes soft and useless at the thought of so much scent. Ross http://olfactoryrescueservice.wordpress.com/ Ross, aren't we all suppliers? Can not say that my mind got soft and useless when I did the Tincture. I count myself as very lucky that I was able to smell the real Musk. I don't think that one can find Musk from the Musk deer anymore, because it is almost erased from this earth. I have studied your nice web side and found some incenses that contain musk. Do you think this musk is natural or is it synthetic? Udo Quote
Guest guest Posted June 30, 2010 Report Posted June 30, 2010 > no matter what you add to a Ambrette Seed Oil, it will not become > more musk or more beautiful. > Substitute for Ambergris. There is none natural. There is nothing > that comes even close to Ambergris Natural. > So, don't be frustrated when you don't get it. That's just the way > it is. You just can try to create a nice scent with a beautiful musk > note in it. > > Udo Hi Udo and all, I may have missed a whole bunch because I have not followed or read the thread on the mystery of musk - and it is usually a bad idea to respond to an email without reading the thread, but time isn't allow that in the moment. I do hope to go back one day and find out what I have missed... But in the meantime... Yes, agreed that you can't find or make a true substitute for musk or ambergris or make ambrette seed more beautiful than it is - and yet we are artists and creators and experimenters in the field of fragrance and natural perfumes. We each have our own reasons for it, but still we experiment and create scent art and sometimes attempt to recreate a flower than does not easily give up its essence. So we create dropplegangers of honeysuckle, gardenia, violet, lily and the like, with natural essences. These can be quite beautiful in and of themselves and surprisingly they can also be recognizable as the original flower that we were tying to imitate (if we have done our job well!) - not the same as the original flower, but certainly like it and a very good substitute for it. Why not with ambergris and musk - or at least why not attempt the improbable? Ambrette seed is already used as a musk substitute, yet it does not smell like natural musk. Maybe we can't make the ambrette seed more beautiful, but can we make its aroma appear more like natural musk grains? Labdanum is the main amber note in perfumery - why? Because it does have an association with ambergris (chemically), and it has a unique aroma that in some way reminds us of ambergris, but it too could be enhanced to become more like actual ambergris (even if not recognizable as ambergris) - and we can have fun and learn something in trying to recreate such a complex aroma as ambergris. Labdanum has the sweet amber note (found in good ambergris), but is missing so many of the other notes (marine, tobacco, faecal, etc.) and other aromatic components that composes actual ambergris. Maybe we can't make labdanum more beautiful as compared to natural labdanum, but we can change it, enhance it, blend it and at least attempt to create amber base accords that mimic ambergris - or at least attempts to mimic ambergris. I also agree to not be frustrated when we can't recreate musk or ambergris (the flower dropplegangers are easier!). And yet I think we should keep trying and should celebrate our efforts when we create beauty, And to simply keep learning (and trying) when our attempts fail... Here is what just came into my email box from a very gifted creator, blender, experimenter and lover of (and in) the field of natural aromatic plants and their oils and extracts. He is writing about the ounce of fossilized amber resin he had just received (some of you will recognize who wrote this by the writing alone). Interestingly enough, he speaks directly to this topic: " Dear Will- Kind greetings! The amber oil arrived today. It is very nice and I will need to spend more time studying it as it has a whole world of intriguing aromas within it which you have already aptly described. It is going to be an invaluable oil for creative perfumery work as it will suit all botanical musk accords, amber bases, incense creations, exotic oriental perfumes etc to perfection. Along with all the other subtle complexities of its olfactory profile it has a very fine precious woods note that is very rare in any oil. " Cheers and happy blending! Will Eden Botanicals Quote
Guest guest Posted July 1, 2010 Report Posted July 1, 2010 Hi agree with almost everything you expressed. As people who have a passion for good scents we are on the same page in an artistic way, I believe. that is why we are here on this webside.  here are the points I disagree with you: Maybe we can't make the ambrette seed more beautiful, but can we make its aroma appear more like natural musk grains?  We only can use Ambrette Seed to create a fragrance. Ambrette Seed by itself does not smell good as a fragrance. It would also be too expensive, unless we through in some Profitin, sorry I meant Neobee M5 COS. There is no natural substitute for Musk for the almost extinct Musk Deer.  Because it does have an association with ambergris (chemically), and it has a unique aroma that in some way reminds us of ambergris, but it too could be enhanced to become more like actual ambergris (even if not recognizable as ambergris Labdanum is not chemically similiar to Ambergris at all. Also not sense wise. There are synthetics that come much closer to Ambergris then any Naturals. I have smelled real Ambergris many years ago. And I don't believe that a small company has it. I believe whatever is out there is reserved for multi billion dollar companies. Real Ambergris is so expensive that it would not be cost effetive in Perfumes. Many people talk about Ambergris and have never smelled it before.  Thanks and have a great day,  Udo Ludwig, Quote
Guest guest Posted July 1, 2010 Report Posted July 1, 2010 I smelled ambergris compliments of the owner of Profumo.it. He sells a animalic tinctures. See this link: http://www.profumo.it/perfume/prodotti.asp?cat=5 & lang=en To me, ambergris smelled like bad breath or rotten teeth. It really did. Quote
Guest guest Posted July 1, 2010 Report Posted July 1, 2010 I think Ambergris is available from http://www.profumo.it/, or at least it used to be. Quote
Guest guest Posted July 1, 2010 Report Posted July 1, 2010 On Thu, Jul 1, 2010 at 12:40 PM, Eden Botanicals wrote: > > > Here is what just came into my email box from a very gifted creator, > blender, experimenter and lover of (and in) the field of natural > aromatic plants and their oils and extracts. He is writing about the > ounce of fossilized amber resin he had just received (some of you will > recognize who wrote this by the writing alone). > And now he's blogged it! http://blog.whitelotusaromatics.com/ There's something very gladdening to think of you two amazing suppliers over there on the other side of the world (to me) swapping emails, ideas, fragrances, and your own botanicals in such a friendly way. Best wishes Johanna Quote
Guest guest Posted July 1, 2010 Report Posted July 1, 2010 > > To me, ambergris smelled like bad breath or rotten teeth. It really did. > Thats funny! To me,although at first is smells slightly sweet and flowery, in the end it ends up smelling like a barn and animal funk. In and of itself, I dont find it all that great, so I always scratch my head when NPers go on and on about what an indescribable, complex, beautiiful scent it is. I'm always thinking; " HUH? " Quote
Guest guest Posted July 1, 2010 Report Posted July 1, 2010 ________________________________ To: NaturalPerfumery Sent: Thu, July 1, 2010 4:36:40 PM Subject: Re: Musks, Botanical Musks, and Exultant Abilities > > To me, ambergris smelled like bad breath or rotten teeth. It really did. > Thats funny! To me,although at first is smells slightly sweet and flowery, in the end it ends up smelling like a barn and animal funk. In and of itself, I dont find it all that great, so I always scratch my head when NPers go on and on about what an indescribable, complex, beautiiful scent it is. I'm always thinking; " HUH? " ********************************************************************************\ ********** Hi That's interesting. I have that exact same impression of the ambergris I started tincturing years ago. The ambergris resin itself doesn't seem to have much of a smell. When I first started it in alcohol, it just smelled disgusting, much like how described it. Then it evolved over time and started smelling like old people's sweaters. Then, after years, it developed this amazing sweet, syrupy, almost floral scent right out of the bottle, but on drydown...yup, here come the funk. Patty Ganache for Lips http://www.ganacheforlips.com Quote
Guest guest Posted July 1, 2010 Report Posted July 1, 2010 I smelled ambergris compliments of the owner of Profumo.it. He sells a animalic tinctures. See this link: http://www.profumo.it/perfume/prodotti.asp?cat=5 <http://www.profumo.it/perfume/prodotti.asp?cat=5 & lang=en> & lang=en To me, ambergris smelled like bad breath or rotten teeth. It really did. I find it interesting that perfume has been based, for many years, on fecal matter, urine, vomit and other secretions! I wonder if there's some human secretion that we could use as a substitute. And, no, not like in the book Perfume! Sonsa Quote
Guest guest Posted July 2, 2010 Report Posted July 2, 2010 Udo Ludwig wrote: > > > I have smelled real Ambergris many years ago. And I don't believe that > a small company has it. I believe whatever is out there is reserved > for multi billion dollar companies. Real Ambergris is so expensive > that it would not be cost effetive in Perfumes. > Many people talk about Ambergris and have never smelled it before. > > Thanks and have a great day, > > Udo Ludwig, > > ,_. Hi Udo, I have some Ambergris....the real thing. As do a number of us here. it is still available, as it is still found on beaches. Personally, I dont like it much. It is interesting in perfumes in tiny amounts at the base...but there are other ingredients I far prefer. I too find the " shit " odour part of it simply off putting..... I have two different batches, one dark and one lighter....the lighter one is much more bearable. I have it ageing in alcohol and in a small muslin bag exposed to the air...I;m still hopeing it will improve with age, grin! Ambrosia > _,___ Quote
Guest guest Posted July 2, 2010 Report Posted July 2, 2010 Awesome. May I ask how much the Kilo price is tody ? Udo Quote
Guest guest Posted July 2, 2010 Report Posted July 2, 2010 >Awesome. May I ask how much the Kilo price is tody ? >Udo __._,_._ I'm not sure of per kilo prices, but you can buy beach ambergris from suppliers in New Zealand. This is one website - I'm not sure of their reputability: http://www.ambergris.co.nz/ They give prices in smaller amounts I think. Be interested to hear if anyone has had experience with this particular group? Johanna Wellington, New Zealand Quote
Guest guest Posted July 2, 2010 Report Posted July 2, 2010 > > Hi agree with almost everything you expressed. As people who have a passion for good scents we are on the same page in an artistic way, I believe. that is why we are here on this webside. >  > here are the points I disagree with you: > Maybe we can't make the ambrette > seed more beautiful, but can we make its aroma appear more like > natural musk grains? >  > We only can use Ambrette Seed to create a fragrance. Ambrette Seed by itself does not smell good as a fragrance. It would also be too expensive, unless we through in some Profitin, sorry I meant Neobee M5 COS. > There is no natural substitute for Musk for the almost extinct Musk Deer. > >  Because it does have an association with ambergris (chemically), > and it has a unique aroma that in some way reminds us of ambergris, > but it too could be enhanced to become more like actual ambergris > (even if not recognizable as ambergris > Labdanum is not chemically similiar to Ambergris at all. Also not sense wise. There are synthetics that come much closer to Ambergris then any Naturals. I have smelled real Ambergris many years ago. And I don't believe that a small company has it. I believe whatever is out there is reserved for multi billion dollar companies. Real Ambergris is so expensive that it would not be cost effetive in Perfumes. > Many people talk about Ambergris and have never smelled it before. >  > Thanks and have a great day, >  > Udo Ludwig, > @udo, i am really quit supprised with this post, and am in complete disagrement with this info. ambrette seed oil, abs or any extracts couldn't be further away from ambergris chemically, in fact there is nothing similar. and on the other hand chemically labdanum IS similar, as a matter of fact most synthesised ambergris materials start from labdanes, such as the large variety of syntheses for ambrox etc. don't know where you gained this info, but it is inaccurate. regards luigi Quote
Guest guest Posted July 2, 2010 Report Posted July 2, 2010 > > > > > > I'm not sure of per kilo prices, but you can buy beach ambergris from > suppliers in New Zealand. > > This is one website - I'm not sure of their reputability: > http://www.ambergris.co.nz/ > > They give prices in smaller amounts I think. > Be interested to hear if anyone has had experience with this particular > group? > > these are who I got mine from...the first batch was dark and sticky and smelt appalling....so I complained and they sent me another lighter batch. It certainly seems to be the genuine thing. I still don't like it much though, grin! I get the impression it's almost like a kind of underground organisation....both packages came from different addresses in unmarked envelopes...quite exciting really! Ambrosia -- http://www.perfumebynature.com.au Quote
Guest guest Posted July 2, 2010 Report Posted July 2, 2010 hello Ambrosia, i have happen to know these people / company and i would reccomend them to anyone, i beleieve they are extremely honest. that being said, i know them personally and am also involved in a very small way, so i thought i would be honest about that. but non the less, great people. if you order again, as i understand, you could ask for a grade of ambergris, or even you might ask for a specific odor profile, or as a newbie to ambergris, you could just ask for a color, e.g. white, white/grey etc.. the chemist anya speaks about, [douglas] would be the direct person to ask about this, as i would have to say he would be the current #1 ambergris authority now in the US. cheers, luigi Quote
Guest guest Posted July 2, 2010 Report Posted July 2, 2010 > > i have happen to know these people / company and i would > reccomend them to anyone, i beleieve they are extremely > honest. > <snip> > if you order again, as i understand, you could ask for a grade of > ambergris, or even you might ask for a specific odor profile, or as a newbie > to ambergris, you could just ask for a color, e.g. white, white/grey etc.. > > Hi Ambrosia and Luigi Really interesting replies! (Ambrosia, lol, I would love all that underground organisation feeling stuff too!) I sent them an enquiry about 5 weeks ago, curious to experience real ambergris. (And the prices seem very reasonable for small amounts.) I asked for postage costs within New Zealand, and I also asked them: 'Also, could you tell me what colour it would be? I'm assuming you would be selling pale, well cured examples, but just wanted to double check.' I didn't get a reply. So I figured either my message got lost in the system, or they don't bother too much with very small buyers (although if that's the case they shouldn't advertise very small amounts), or they weren't completely reputable. At least I now know the last option isn't the case!! Best wishes Johanna Quote
Guest guest Posted July 2, 2010 Report Posted July 2, 2010 > > > I wonder if there's some human secretion that we could use as a substitute. > And, no, not like in the book Perfume! > > I have no idea (and probably never will know) what real musk smells like, but thinking about the synthetic musks I have smelt, and also about the single example of Ambrette Seed I know - to me the closest human odour to those smells is oily unwashed hair! Best wishes Johanna Quote
Guest guest Posted July 2, 2010 Report Posted July 2, 2010 _______________________________ @udo, i am really quit supprised with this post, and am in complete disagrement with this info. ambrette seed oil, abs or any extracts couldn't be further away from ambergris chemically, in fact there is nothing similar. and on the other hand chemically labdanum IS similar, as a matter of fact most synthesised ambergris materials start from labdanes, such as the large variety of syntheses for ambrox etc. don't know where you gained this info, but it is inaccurate. regards luigi Luigi, it looks like that you and me are in complete disagreement. And that we both don't know where each of us got our information from. I also did not get the information were you think I am wrong and you did not tell me where your are right. I assume you have a Chemistry background and so do I. I am foremost a Perfumer by trade and education who works with the Nose, odor memory and inspiration. I don't know if you have a Perfumer background or just chemistry. This is a Natural Perfumer Group and they don't like synthetics. Since you bring up Ambrox and stated I am inaccurate, I feel I have to explain a bit more in detail, with all my respect to your knowledge. ambrette seed oil, abs or any extracts couldn't be further away from ambergris chemically, in fact there is nothing similar. Idid not say that. I said: There is no substitute for Musk from the almost extinct Musk deer. That means Ambrette Seed Oil ( steam distilled not a Tincture) is very different then musk from the deer. That is olfactory wise and not chemically. I don't consider them chemically similar, just because they have a few trace amounts of the same molucules together. Olfactory, Ambergris is absolutely not comparable to Ambrette Seed Oil. Your statement: and on the other hand chemically labdanum IS similar, as a matter of fact most synthesised ambergris materials start from labdanes, such as the large variety of syntheses for ambrox etc. I know that Labdanum is or better was, a starting material to synthesize Ambrox. Just because in the 50's they isolated Tetranorlabdane oxide out of Labdanum to synthesize Ambrox, does not mean for me, Labdanum smells simmiliar to Ambergris. That would be like comparing a little car with a Mercedes. Ambergris is so complex and unique that it is hard for my nose to compare Ambergris with Labdanum. Just think about the fecal note. A key note in Ambergris is Ambrox. But there are hundreds of other trace amounts missing that make the full body. Ambrox comes very close. I have stated in my post that there are synthetics that comes much closer then Labdanum and that is what I meant. Just did not want to mention it because of the guidelines set here. There are many ways to make an " artificial " Ambergris. Starting material can be from natural source like from Clary Sage Oil. Isolating Sclareol, Sclareolide. Ambeine. There are more derivates like Ambrox, CetaloxSclaroxan etc. And there are even more Starting materials. It is more complicated, but I want to keep it simple. Everything is " similiar " in perfume ingredients. They all have C = Carbon, O= Oxygen and H= Hydrogenium in there molecular structures. Some have even S=Sulfur or N= Nitrogenium in it. The characteristic scent of an individual EO or Absolute depends of how mother nature put them together ( aroma chemicals ) and most importantly in which amounts and which aroma chemicals. That is for me one of the wonders in this world. I don't mean to be controversial or hurt anybodies feeling, I just had to answer that was posted to the group. Best regards, Udo Ludwig Quote
Guest guest Posted July 5, 2010 Report Posted July 5, 2010 Hello all, Thanks for the very informative and thoughtful responses on my questions about musks! So as there isn't a true botanical replacement for musk deer, does anyone have a source for or happen to be selling the goats hair/musk tincture that has been discussed in the group? It sounds pretty intruiging. Also, I would still love to hear from Anya or any other members who have experimented with musk root as a tincture and where it falls in the spectrum of musks. I was able to source some root but am not sure if it would be worthwhile. Thanks so much, this group is full of amazing people and so much knowledge! Sincerely, Quote
Guest guest Posted July 5, 2010 Report Posted July 5, 2010 > Hello all, > > Thanks for the very informative and thoughtful responses on my questions about musks! > > So as there isn't a true botanical replacement for musk deer, does anyone have a source for or happen to be selling the goats hair/musk tincture that has been discussed in the group? It sounds pretty intruiging. > > Also, I would still love to hear from Anya or any other members who have experimented with musk root as a tincture and where it falls in the spectrum of musks. I was able to source some root but am not sure if it would be worthwhile. > > Thanks so much, this group is full of amazing people and so much knowledge! > > Sincerely, > > > > Hi : About the goats: you need to contact somebody that has male goats when the are rutting in the Fall. That's the best advice I can offer at this time. Costus root EO smells just like goat hair, and a lot of labdanums have the note, since goats roam around the bushes and some of their stink sticks to the plant and makes it through the extraction processes. Musk root does not tincture. I had some EO of it years ago. Don't know why it doesn't give up the scent to tincture, but that's what I read. I have never been able to source any of the true root. It seems homeopaths buy it up. I have to get to a homepathic supply house and beg, I guess. Anya McCoy http://AnyasGarden.com http://PerfumeClasses.com http://NaturalPerfumers.com Quote
Guest guest Posted July 5, 2010 Report Posted July 5, 2010 Hi Anya, Thank you so much for response! I just recieved a pound of Musk Root (Ferula moschata). From the information I have been able to scrounge together on it, it seems authentic. I probed the supplier for information on sourcing, growing conditions, and such and got satisfactory answers. I haven't actually worked with it before though, so I can't claim an expert opinion here. I was wondering if you would be willing to take a sniff at it if I sent some your direction? From the limited information I have seen on tincturing, it seems to give more of its musk scent when the resin in the root and water are combined, so I am thinking that after tincturing in 190 proof alcohol to pull the resin and eo, diluting the tincture with some water may yield out that scent. The water would certainly present some challenges later when working with it in perfumes, but an interesting idea none the less. Let me know if you would be willing to check it out or have any interest in it. Thanks again for the help and information! Now to try to find some goats :-) Sincerely, Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.