Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 Posted by: " ambrosia@... " ambrosia@... eyddwen Fri Jan 15, 2010 11:45 am (PST) >>...Here's my thoughts on the matter: Let's start with the issue that Al just brought up re Safrole: " Cinnamon Leaf Oil is a reported carcinogen and mutagen due to it's Safrole content .....<< You have summarized much of the detail behind my post. Again, from an herbalist, but perfume novice, here's what I consider: --There is not a single constituent (in the naturally occurring plants we use) and there is a synergy or a matrix effect (in the pharmo-chemical sense) among constituents. --It matters when in the seasonal cycle you harvest (e.g. dandelion leaves are bitter in high summer but not in spring or late fall because of the seasonal variation in sesquiterpene lactones; it's roots have inulin [can help with blood sugar] stored up in the fall but not in the spring)--so, what part is harvested when matters a lot. --Then there are growing conditions which affect constituent levels and balance --There is the question of the solubility of a constituent depending on the extraction medium. --Then there is what you mix it with; some people use simples but many traditional herbalists make multi-herb formulas for each individual --And, last but perhaps not least, where it is used (on the skin in dabs, all over, consumed), in what quantity and for how long Makes it complicated when a single constituent (gathered who knows where, when or how) has been demonstrated to cause damage in a context far away from how it's used in people. And it makes us all keep a careful eye both on the research and the regs based on it. In my experience, so few people understand the science, that not much judgement is brought to bear on interpreting results. enough of this -- just got a set of samples from 1 of the guild members; I'm going back to sniffing lovely perfumes and waiting for my 1st order of essences to arrive! Essence and Alchemy was a great read; what should I read next? -- Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.