Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 Not at all. I stand firm in my assessment of them as such. They and other organizations worked hard to push this bill and put forth the illusion that these so-called exemptions will help us any. To the contrary they have huge loopholes and will be ineffective at best. They should have stood strong with us in opposition to the bill. They got the exemptions in, good for them. But they should have still opposed the final text and their not doing so greatly helped final passage. The so called hysteria was and is quite accurate if you understand something of how the federal regulatory agencies work and what their true goals are. The main problems were unintentional misinformation due to the confusing and changing nature of what text and bill was actually current at any given time combined with the tendancy to copy information without checking accuracy. Unfair characterizations of the opposition such as yours did not help. They are not born out of understanding our true and valid concerns. Government power is easily and readily abused to a much greater stake then the supporters of this bill would admit. The main problem at the end of the day is this bill gives the FDA the tools it needs to shut down small family farmers and the FDA has expressed exactly that goal (in general and specifically with respect to raw milk). This is an agency which thinks we have no right to good health or to control what food we eat. They treat us as slaves, not free men. Why should be give them one iota more power than they already have? It is suicide. Pete The political reality is that the too much of the constituency that opposed this bill outright was weak and ineffective and did itself quite a lot of damage to its own credibility and political clout by allowing ridiculous myths about the bill and general hysteria to permeate its response instead of a) educating itself so it could have attacked the bill with facts and building grassroots alliances among friends in the organic/sustainable ag/local food producer and consumer groups to strengthen its power. The opposers were off in a corner making weird noises while the ones who realized that the bill was going to pass (given the political environment of widespread fear among the populace about food poisoning outbreaks) rolled up their sleeves to do the heavy lifting required to save the small farm, small processor and local food system from a bill that surely would have steamrolled that whole sector without that effort having been made. I think you don't realize how much worse it would be today with out NSAC's efforts. To call them turncoats is absurd. Chrys Chrys Ostrander, Director of Farming Programs People for Environmental Action and Community Health "Local Food for All" Manager, p.e.a.c.h. Community Farm at Pine Meadow 10425 S. Andrus Rd. Cheney, Wa 99004 farms@... www.peachlocal.com "We regard passage of this bill as a great accomplishment, as it will help promote food safety with scale-appropriate standards." No, it will destroy small farmers. NSAC are turncoats. They supported this awful legislation with the amendments. But the amendments offer no real protection. It should have been opposed, even with the amendments. Pete Congress has sent the Food Safety Bill to the President’s Desk. It includes six amendments that were supported by, and worked hard for by, the National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition. It was predictable that this bill was going to pass and that's why it was so important that protections for small farmers and local food systems were included, despite the very strong efforts of big agribusiness to block these amendments. Check below for the specifics. Kick NSAC some $$ if you can. http://sustainableagriculture.net/blog/house-passes-food-safety-act/ Congress Sends Food Safety Bill to President’s Desk December 21st, 2010 On December 21, 2010, the House of Representatives voted 215-144 to pass the Senate version of the Food Safety Modernization Act, with the Tester-Hagan amendment protecting small farms intact. This final vote by the House ends weeks of procedural wrangling, and sends the bill to the President’s desk for enactment. As we reported in a previous blog post, the food safety bill hit a roadblock after passing the Senate in late November because a provision requiring the collection of user fees violated the Constitutional mandate that all revenue-generating measures must originate in the House. House leaders then attached the bill as an amendment to two separate spending bills, neither of which were able to gain sufficient support. Then, on Sunday, December 19, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) circumvented the original technical mistake by attaching the bill to a House-originated measure (HR 2751) authorizing a cash-for-clunkers program – a “shell bill” with bipartisan support. The Senate approved this shell bill by voice vote. The final bill passed today by the House mirrors the bill passed three weeks ago by the Senate. It includes six NSAC-supported amendments championed by: * Senators Jon Tester (D-MT) and Kay Hagan (D-NC) to give very small farms and food processing facilities as well as direct-market farms who sell locally the option of complying with state regulation or with modified, scale-appropriate federal regulation. * Senator (I-VT) providing FDA authority to either exempt farms engaged in low or no risk processing or co-mingling activities from new regulatory requirements or to modify particular regulatory requirements for such farming operations. * Senator Bennet (D-CO) to reduce unnecessary paperwork and excess regulation required under the preventative control plan and the produce standards sections of the bill, including instructions to FDA to minimize the number of different standards that apply to separate foods, to make requirements scale appropriate, and to prohibit FDA from requiring farms and other food facilities to hire outside consultants to write food safety plans. * Senator Debbie Stabenow (D-MI) to provide for a USDA-delivered competitive grants program for food safety training for farmers, small processors and wholesalers, with a priority on small and mid-scale farms. * Senator Barbara Boxer (D-CA) to strip the bill of wildlife-threatening enforcement against “animal encroachment” of farms and require FDA to apply sound science to any requirements that might impact wildlife and wildlife habitat. * Senator Sherrod Brown (D-OH) to exempt farmers from extensive and expensive traceability and recordkeeping requirements if they sell food directly to consumers or to grocery stores, to allow labeling that preserves the identity of the farm through to the consumer to satisfy traceability requirements, and to in most cases limit farm recordkeeping to the first point of sale when the product leaves the farm. NSAC has been a primary player in negotiations over the content of the Food Safety Modernization Act for more than a year. We regard passage of this bill as a great accomplishment, as it will help promote food safety with scale-appropriate standards. -- Chrys Ostrander, Director of Farming Programs People for Environmental Action and Community Health "Local Food for All" Manager, p.e.a.c.h. Community Farm at Pine Meadow 10425 S. Andrus Rd. Cheney, Wa 99004 farms@... www.peachlocal.com Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.