Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: FW: Switzerland - WIFI out of schools [3 Attachments]

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

Thank you so very much for posting this.. I campaigned to keep our primary school WIFI free 5 years ago.. really good that there is more information out there now to protect children. I would urge each of us to contact their LEA and forward this information and ask for their comments and how they are going to prove that EVERY CHILD MATTERS!!  I have targetted Suffolk county Councillors and head of SCC this evening!!

 

Tracey

 

[Attachment(s) from June Goh included below]

  

A Tale of Two Countries

Wired vs. Wireless Internet in Schools

Magda Havas, B.Sc., Ph.D.

Environmental & Resource Studies, Trent University,

borough, ON, Canada, mhavas@...

October 15, 2010

Switzerland gives free Fiber Optics to Schools WiFi is OUT

 

The World Wide Web was invented and developed in Switzerland and made its debut in

1994. Swiss students discovered the value of this technology long ago, as they were early

adaptors. Today, in Switzerland this technology brings unique learning experiences into the

classroom such as video on demand (VOD) via FREE fiber optic technology.

As responsible educators we certainly want the best for our students. We want to help them

become well informed, successful, contributing members in society. The Internet is

definitely a technology we want students to master, so providing them with fast, secure,

health effect-free access in the classroom is the future of education.

There are several ways of providing Internet access. Two common ones are LAN (Local

Area Networks that are connected by wires) and WLAN (wireless Local Area Networks)

also referred to as WiFi.

 

In Canada, wireless networks are preferred presumably because they are more convenient

to use (no need for wires) and are less expensive to install. However, WLAN transmitters

generate constant, pulse, digital, microwave radiation, which has been shown to have

adverse biological effects at levels well below Health Canadas Safety Code 6.

Switzerland has one of the most stringent standards for microwave radiation and actively

promotes low emission devices. For this reason, the Federal Department of Public Health in

Switzerland prefers LAN (wired connections) to wireless. Indeed Switzerland has a much

different view on the safety of wireless technology than Canada. The questions is . . . Why?

 

Switzerland has stricter guidelines than Canada for Microwave Radiation

Switzerland is home to the World Health Organization and the Red Cross. They are also

home to CERN where scientists have won Noble prizes for their research in high-energy

physics. Obviously health care and high quality science and technology are valued in this

country. As a result they maintain high standards to protect public health.

For example, the Swiss limits for exposure to microwave radiationthe radiation emitted

by WLANare much more protective than those in Canada. While Health Canada allows

the general population to be exposed to a power density of 1000 microW/cm2 (intensity of

the radiation), in Switzerland the guideline is 10 microW/cm2 (or 1% of Canadas exposure

limit).

 

The Canadian guidelines established by Health Canada and described in Safety Code 6 are

based on a thermal effect and were established originally to protect soldiers working with

radar. The guidelines in Switzerland are based on minimizing biological effects that occur

whether or not there is a heating effect on the body. These biological effects occur well

below the thermal guidelines.

 

Switzerland also identifies Places of Sensitive Use (German acronym is OMEN). These

places include: living rooms; classrooms and kindergartens; hospitals and nursing homes;

permanent jobs (where people spend more than 2.5 days per week); and playgrounds.

For these OMEN sites, the Swiss government is recommending that greater precaution be

taken for long-term exposure to weak radiation. In these places, radiation from wireless

microwave base stations (such as cordless phones or WLAN/WiFi) within the home, work

or school environment may exceed radiation from nearby cell phone base stations and

hence these devices must generate emissions as low as possible. Schools fit into this

OMEN classification.

 

The Swiss government and the World Health Organization share the latest microwave

research studies, and some of these studies are showing adverse effects. The Swiss

Government and Swisscomthe government telecommunications providerhave decided

to use the Precautionary Approach given our incomplete knowledge about the potential

health effects to children associated with long-term, low level exposure to microwave

radiation generated by a growing number of WiFi devices.

 

Long-term, low-level exposure to 2.4 GHz promotes cancers in rats

In North America the WiFi base station (and cordless phone base station) transmitters

constantly pulse a microwave beacon signal, 10 times per second using 2.4 or 5.8 GHz

frequencies. This rapid pulsed frequency is much more biologically harmful to the human

body than continuous waves such as used in microwave ovens.

To date there have been no long-term, low-levels studies of 2.4 GHz radiation except on

rats. In laboratory studies, rats exposed for long periods to low-level 2.4 GHz microwave

radiation had an impaired immune system and developed more cancers than sham-exposed

rats (Chou et al. 1992). Is this what will happen to students in the classroom exposed for

long periods (6 hours daily) to low-levels of microwave radiation? The answer is we dont

know for certain. Do we want to take that chance?

 

Swiss Government takes action

Swisscom was so concerned about the effects from long-term exposure to pulsed WiFi

radiation from their Internet service provider that they filed a patent with the World Patent

Office that demonstrates a method to eliminate the radiation that constantly broadcasts

from WiFi base stations when not in use. These methods have now been implemented

into Swisscom's home portable phone system that they offer their customers. Their low

radiation portable DECT phones (Digital Enhanced Cordless Telephone) may be the safest

wireless portable phones in the world. Unfortunately, their WiFi solution could not be

implemented because Swisscom has no control over the computer companiessuch as

Apple and Ciscothat produce the WiFi devices.

 

To introduce you to their concerns about WiFi, a copy of the patent is included in this

document. Note that the patent provides information about studies that found genetic

damage from constant low-level microwave radiation and they document the methods that

Swisscom used to remove that radiation.

 

As a consequence of the Precautionary Approach, the Swiss government's

telecommunication provider, Swisscom, now offers FREE fiber optic connections to

schools, with the provision that the computers are hard wired via Ethernet (LAN) to

connect the computers to the Internet.

Read about it on Swisscom's Web site:

http://www.swisscom.com/GHQ/content/SAI/Internetanschluss/Anforderungen/?lang=en

 

Pros and Cons Wireless vs. Wired

IT departments often complain that wiring a classroom is cost prohibitive and difficult to

accomplish. They are not correct in that statement. Even portable computers need to be

plugged in from time to time to recharge the battery; therefore an Ethernet port can be

installed with the electrical outlet to provide connectivity.

There are three benefits to wired systems:

1. Wired connections are more secure than wireless because they are more difficult

to hack into.

2. Wired systems are faster than wireless if high-speed gigabit Ethernet connections

are used.

3. Wired systems dont expose students to microwave radiation.

Swisscom has considerable experience with faster systems using fiber optics, as does

Lakehead University in Thunder Bay, Ontario. The data rate of the Internet connection

becomes critical with multiple, simultaneous users sharing large files such as videos. WiFi

base stations are NOT designed to provide simultaneous high-speed connections to

hundreds of computers and hand-held WiFi devices. The wireless agenda that Canadian

schools are now adopting will result in a future that becomes so congested that the initial

broadband bandwidth delivered to the school will eventually devolve, slowing to a crawl as

with dial-up connections.

mhavas@... A Tale of Two Countries: Wired vs. Wireless Internet in Schools page 4/6

To provide the highest bandwidth possible via WiFi, some Canadian schools currently

installing WiFi are using industrial-strength base stations that are radiating all the time even

when no wireless devices are accessing the Internet. These base stations are more powerful

and have a greater range than WiFi systems in homes.

Additionally, even higher levels of radiation are transmitted when these base stations are

streaming datasuch as videoto the computer or hand-held WiFi device. Students,

faculty, staff and volunteers in the classroom are going to be exposed to this constant

unnatural " level of radiation, and those closest to the base station transmitters are going to

be exposed to higher levels.

Furthermore, this radiation can be blocked or reflected by metal objects and absorbed or

reflected by human bodies. This causes hot and cold spots in the classroom. It is

virtually impossible to accurately calculate exposure levels with multiple users in a

classroom. The best way to determine exposure is to measure it during peak use.

Students will also be exposed to an even greater level of constant radiation generated by

their WiFi-enabled devicesuch as an iPad, smart phone, or laptop computer when they

are downloading and uploading information. The closer students (and others) are to these

devices, the higher their exposure. Indeed, the microwave transmitter may be hand-held

(iPad or smart phone) or placed on their lap (portable computer) with this radiation being

directly absorbed into the body. It is this direct contact that worries the Swiss government,

and I will quote from their health department website:

" caution should be exercised primarily when using devices held close to the body,

such as laptops, PDAs and Internet telephones. "

You might read that WiFi radiation has been measured and found to be 50 times lower than

cell phones. These studies did not measure the radiation from the hand-held WiFi devices

nor did they measure them near the portable computers. Switzerland commissioned a

detailed report on WiFi, which measured the hand-held devices and found that a PDA had a

peak spatial SAR (specific absorption rate) value above the 2 W/kg limit (very similar to

cell phone SAR limits).

 

How much is too much?

What level of pulsed microwave radiation is safe? This is the crux of the controversy. The

truth is we dont know.

With this uncertainty in mind why is Canada rushing ahead to install WiFi in schools,

even in school that currently have wired Ethernet connections?

Students in some schools with WiFi have already started to complain about headaches,

difficulty concentrating, weakness and heart problems. Two students in the Barrie area are

taking heart medication. One student in a Toronto school collapsed when she was standing

near a WiFi transmitter. These complaints need to be taken seriously.

mhavas@... A Tale of Two Countries: Wired vs. Wireless Internet in Schools page 5/6

Obviously, parents are concerned and have asked that levels of radiation in the classroom

be lowered and that the WiFi units be turned off when not in use or deactivated in rooms

where computers are not used (kindergarten, for example). So far their concerns have been

ignored. Why?

 

Schools take health issues seriously. Asbestos was removed from schools across Canada at

great expense years after it was recognized to be a carcinogen. It is quite likely that WiFi

will experience the same fate unless precautions are taken.

Schools protect students against second-hand smoke and those with peanut allergies by

making schools smoke-free and nut-free. Schools should also be radiation-free to

protect staff who may be pregnant and those students and teachers who may have

electrohypersensitivity (i.e., adverse reaction to electromagnetic energy)?

According to the Swiss government, 5% of the Swiss population is extremely sensitive to

wireless technology, and that number is growing exponentially with the addition of new

wireless products.

 

In Canada, with approximately 5.2 millions students in elementary and secondary schools

as many as 260,000 students (5%) across Canada may be adversely affected by this

radiationwithout even knowing it. Do we want to gamble with the health of so many

students?

 

Health Canada maintains that thermal guidelines are sufficient to protect the public. What

if they are wrong? Is this a chance we are willing to take with the health of millions of

students and their teachers?

 

Explore Switzerland's Federal Department of Public Health web page that is devoted to

WLAN (WiFi), and view their concerns and safe practices regarding WiFi. They were

among the first countries to use the Internet and, judging by their conservative approach to

 

WiFi, they may have learned from this experience. Here is the link:

http://www.bag.admin.ch/themen/strahlung/00053/00673/03570/index.html?lang=en

 

I ask you to reconsider the rapid deployment of WiFi and this is based on 15 years of my

own research in this field and after having read thousands of documents showing this

radiation may be harmful at low levels, substantially below the limits established by Health

Canada in Safety Code 6.

 

Please note that I am not alone in these concerns. Scientists and Medical Doctors have

signed Resolutions and Appeals asking International Agencies (ICNIRP) to reduce

guidelines due to both biological and health effects. These include: The Salzburg

Resolution (2000), Catania Resolution (2002), Freiburger Appeal (2002), Irish Doctors

Environmental Associate Appeal (2005), Helsinki Appeal (2005), Benevento Resolution

(2006), BioInitiative Report (2007), Venice Appeal (2008) and the Porto Alegre

Resolutions (2009).

 

Health officials in various countries have issued warnings for children to limit their use of

mobile phones (cell and cordless): United Kingdom (2000), Germany (2007), France

(2008), Russia (2008), India (2008), Toronto Public Health (2008), Pittsburgh Cancer

Institute (2008), Belgium (2008), Israel (2008), Japan (2008), Finland (2009), Seoul Korea

(2009), and the most recent being the U.S. Federal Communication Commission (2009).

Warnings vary but generally they recommend that children under the age of 12 not use

mobile phones and those under the age of 16 limit their use of these phones. If health

officials in these countries are limiting childrens exposure to microwave radiation from

mobile phones, how can schools in Canada expose students, ages 5 to 18, to microwave

radiation for hours each day?

 

What can you do?

While setting guidelines for radio frequency radiation is a federal issue, it does not exempt

provincial, municipal, and regional health authorities from protecting the people under their

jurisdiction. Nor does it exempt schools from protecting their staff and students. We look

to Health Canada for guidance but we need to question the guidelines when the evidence so

strongly indicates this form of radiation is harmful. In the long-term, the health cost of

WiFi may far outweigh its convenience.

We often state that the life of a child is priceless and that our health is priceless. Lets act

as though we genuinely believe this to be true.

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...