Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Urinary Porphyrins

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone lately he

mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might not be just an

indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also could be a marker for

oxidative stress.

OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if it could be

more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not as much mercury as I

thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury then?

Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean.

Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by chance heard

of this or is this just absolute dribble?

Thanks,

Posted

Hi ,you are right, quite a few things will affect porphyrin results such as clinical or subclinical epilepsy and other factors resulting in oxidative stress. KenSubject: Urinary PorphyrinsTo: Autism-Biomedical-Europe Date: Thursday, 11 November, 2010, 20:16

When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone lately he mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might not be just an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also could be a marker for oxidative stress.

OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if it could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not as much mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury then?

Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean.

Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by chance heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?

Thanks,

Posted

Hi ,you are right, quite a few things will affect porphyrin results such as clinical or subclinical epilepsy and other factors resulting in oxidative stress. KenSubject: Urinary PorphyrinsTo: Autism-Biomedical-Europe Date: Thursday, 11 November, 2010, 20:16

When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone lately he mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might not be just an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also could be a marker for oxidative stress.

OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if it could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not as much mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury then?

Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean.

Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by chance heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?

Thanks,

Posted

Hi ,you are right, quite a few things will affect porphyrin results such as clinical or subclinical epilepsy and other factors resulting in oxidative stress. KenSubject: Urinary PorphyrinsTo: Autism-Biomedical-Europe Date: Thursday, 11 November, 2010, 20:16

When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone lately he mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might not be just an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also could be a marker for oxidative stress.

OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if it could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not as much mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury then?

Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean.

Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by chance heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?

Thanks,

Posted

Ken,Any chance you might know where to read about what things affect the porphyrin results? Thank you, Subject: Urinary PorphyrinsTo: Autism-Biomedical-Europe Date: Thursday, 11 November, 2010, 20:16

When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone lately he mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might not be just an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also could be a marker for oxidative stress.

OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if it could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not as much mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury then?

Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean.

Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by chance heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?

Thanks,

Posted

DS had near identical results in Nov 09, before chelation and Aug 10 after we stalled. Would you be satisfied with this or as confirmation or would you do a hair test? Thank you Subject: Re: Urinary PorphyrinsTo: Autism-Biomedical-Europe Date: Friday, November 12, 2010, 8:10 AM

Some toxic folks have negative porphyrins tests until AFTER they start chelation because the metals can be tightly bound, one of our listers here had that, so its not the holy grail some people think it is

Mandi x

When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone lately he mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might not be just an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also could be a marker for oxidative stress. OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if it could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not as much mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury then?Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean. Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by chance heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?Thanks,

Posted

DS had near identical results in Nov 09, before chelation and Aug 10 after we stalled. Would you be satisfied with this or as confirmation or would you do a hair test? Thank you Subject: Re: Urinary PorphyrinsTo: Autism-Biomedical-Europe Date: Friday, November 12, 2010, 8:10 AM

Some toxic folks have negative porphyrins tests until AFTER they start chelation because the metals can be tightly bound, one of our listers here had that, so its not the holy grail some people think it is

Mandi x

When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone lately he mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might not be just an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also could be a marker for oxidative stress. OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if it could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not as much mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury then?Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean. Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by chance heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?Thanks,

Posted

Mandi,I guess I like being able to take a look at where we are every now and again. I like knowing if I'm on the right track. DS's oxiditive stress was nearly the same after 9 mths and I realised that what I was doing wasn't working so I've had to change tact and up the Enhansa, add in more beta carotenes, add in a little melatonin, get back to ALA and reflect on his diet. I realise that it's not so easy when it comes to mercury but I guess I'm doing this on my own, I need to ask all the questions I can and I really do like to check up on myself so I really appreciate the input and advice,Thanks,

Subject: Re: Urinary PorphyrinsTo: Autism-Biomedical-Europe Date: Friday, November 12, 2010, 8:10 AM

Some toxic folks have negative porphyrins tests until AFTER they start chelation because the metals can be tightly bound, one of our listers here had that, so its not the holy grail some people think it is

Mandi x

When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone lately he mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might not be just an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also could be a marker for oxidative stress. OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if it could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not as much mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury then?Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean. Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by chance heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?Thanks,

Posted

Mandi,I guess I like being able to take a look at where we are every now and again. I like knowing if I'm on the right track. DS's oxiditive stress was nearly the same after 9 mths and I realised that what I was doing wasn't working so I've had to change tact and up the Enhansa, add in more beta carotenes, add in a little melatonin, get back to ALA and reflect on his diet. I realise that it's not so easy when it comes to mercury but I guess I'm doing this on my own, I need to ask all the questions I can and I really do like to check up on myself so I really appreciate the input and advice,Thanks,

Subject: Re: Urinary PorphyrinsTo: Autism-Biomedical-Europe Date: Friday, November 12, 2010, 8:10 AM

Some toxic folks have negative porphyrins tests until AFTER they start chelation because the metals can be tightly bound, one of our listers here had that, so its not the holy grail some people think it is

Mandi x

When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone lately he mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might not be just an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also could be a marker for oxidative stress. OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if it could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not as much mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury then?Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean. Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by chance heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?Thanks,

Posted

Mandi,I guess I like being able to take a look at where we are every now and again. I like knowing if I'm on the right track. DS's oxiditive stress was nearly the same after 9 mths and I realised that what I was doing wasn't working so I've had to change tact and up the Enhansa, add in more beta carotenes, add in a little melatonin, get back to ALA and reflect on his diet. I realise that it's not so easy when it comes to mercury but I guess I'm doing this on my own, I need to ask all the questions I can and I really do like to check up on myself so I really appreciate the input and advice,Thanks,

Subject: Re: Urinary PorphyrinsTo: Autism-Biomedical-Europe Date: Friday, November 12, 2010, 8:10 AM

Some toxic folks have negative porphyrins tests until AFTER they start chelation because the metals can be tightly bound, one of our listers here had that, so its not the holy grail some people think it is

Mandi x

When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone lately he mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might not be just an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also could be a marker for oxidative stress. OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if it could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not as much mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury then?Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean. Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by chance heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?Thanks,

Posted

A toxic child is going to oixidative stress until the metals are out, its not like something you can make a big impact on until the cause is dealt with. A, C, E, Selenium, NADH, chelation is basic stuff

Sam gets Megahydrate twice daily, I can't tell you it does what it says on the tin for sure but it made me feel better.

The other biggie that was trialled with tests pre and post dosing showing very effective on adult (annagram actually she has Chrohns) I forget begins with P pro summat or other, i'll ask gram today and post again, i keep meaning to get some for Sam

Why beta cariotenes? Many of our kids can't convert these

Mandi x

Mandi, I guess I like being able to take a look at where we are every now and again. I like knowing if I'm on the right track. DS's oxiditive stress was nearly the same after 9 mths and I realised that what I was doing wasn't working so I've had to change tact and up the Enhansa, add in more beta carotenes, add in a little melatonin, get back to ALA and reflect on his diet.

I realise that it's not so easy when it comes to mercury but I guess I'm doing this on my own, I need to ask all the questions I can and I really do like to check up on myself so I really appreciate the input and advice,

Thanks,

Subject: Re: Urinary PorphyrinsTo: Autism-Biomedical-Europe Date: Friday, November 12, 2010, 8:10 AM

Some toxic folks have negative porphyrins tests until AFTER they start chelation because the metals can be tightly bound, one of our listers here had that, so its not the holy grail some people think it is

Mandi x

When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone lately he mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might not be just an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also could be a marker for oxidative stress. OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if it could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not as much mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury then?Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean. Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by chance heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?Thanks,

Posted

A toxic child is going to oixidative stress until the metals are out, its not like something you can make a big impact on until the cause is dealt with. A, C, E, Selenium, NADH, chelation is basic stuff

Sam gets Megahydrate twice daily, I can't tell you it does what it says on the tin for sure but it made me feel better.

The other biggie that was trialled with tests pre and post dosing showing very effective on adult (annagram actually she has Chrohns) I forget begins with P pro summat or other, i'll ask gram today and post again, i keep meaning to get some for Sam

Why beta cariotenes? Many of our kids can't convert these

Mandi x

Mandi, I guess I like being able to take a look at where we are every now and again. I like knowing if I'm on the right track. DS's oxiditive stress was nearly the same after 9 mths and I realised that what I was doing wasn't working so I've had to change tact and up the Enhansa, add in more beta carotenes, add in a little melatonin, get back to ALA and reflect on his diet.

I realise that it's not so easy when it comes to mercury but I guess I'm doing this on my own, I need to ask all the questions I can and I really do like to check up on myself so I really appreciate the input and advice,

Thanks,

Subject: Re: Urinary PorphyrinsTo: Autism-Biomedical-Europe Date: Friday, November 12, 2010, 8:10 AM

Some toxic folks have negative porphyrins tests until AFTER they start chelation because the metals can be tightly bound, one of our listers here had that, so its not the holy grail some people think it is

Mandi x

When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone lately he mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might not be just an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also could be a marker for oxidative stress. OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if it could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not as much mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury then?Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean. Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by chance heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?Thanks,

Posted

A toxic child is going to oixidative stress until the metals are out, its not like something you can make a big impact on until the cause is dealt with. A, C, E, Selenium, NADH, chelation is basic stuff

Sam gets Megahydrate twice daily, I can't tell you it does what it says on the tin for sure but it made me feel better.

The other biggie that was trialled with tests pre and post dosing showing very effective on adult (annagram actually she has Chrohns) I forget begins with P pro summat or other, i'll ask gram today and post again, i keep meaning to get some for Sam

Why beta cariotenes? Many of our kids can't convert these

Mandi x

Mandi, I guess I like being able to take a look at where we are every now and again. I like knowing if I'm on the right track. DS's oxiditive stress was nearly the same after 9 mths and I realised that what I was doing wasn't working so I've had to change tact and up the Enhansa, add in more beta carotenes, add in a little melatonin, get back to ALA and reflect on his diet.

I realise that it's not so easy when it comes to mercury but I guess I'm doing this on my own, I need to ask all the questions I can and I really do like to check up on myself so I really appreciate the input and advice,

Thanks,

Subject: Re: Urinary PorphyrinsTo: Autism-Biomedical-Europe Date: Friday, November 12, 2010, 8:10 AM

Some toxic folks have negative porphyrins tests until AFTER they start chelation because the metals can be tightly bound, one of our listers here had that, so its not the holy grail some people think it is

Mandi x

When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone lately he mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might not be just an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also could be a marker for oxidative stress. OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if it could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not as much mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury then?Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean. Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by chance heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?Thanks,

Posted

Hi Mandi,Well we are on our way again, back on round and yes I'm giving him A,C, E and selenium. I don't know what NADH is but the read up on Mega Hydrate sounds really good.I didn't know about the beta carotenes so thanks and I'd be very interested in the other biggie if you do happen to find out the name of it.Thanks for the help,

Subject: Re: Urinary PorphyrinsTo: Autism-Biomedical-Europe Date: Friday, November 12, 2010, 8:10 AM

Some toxic folks have negative porphyrins tests until AFTER they start chelation because the metals can be tightly bound, one of our listers here had that, so its not the holy grail some people think it is

Mandi x

When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone lately he mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might not be just an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also could be a marker for oxidative stress. OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if it could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not as much mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury then?Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean. Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by chance heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?Thanks,

Posted

Hi Mandi,Well we are on our way again, back on round and yes I'm giving him A,C, E and selenium. I don't know what NADH is but the read up on Mega Hydrate sounds really good.I didn't know about the beta carotenes so thanks and I'd be very interested in the other biggie if you do happen to find out the name of it.Thanks for the help,

Subject: Re: Urinary PorphyrinsTo: Autism-Biomedical-Europe Date: Friday, November 12, 2010, 8:10 AM

Some toxic folks have negative porphyrins tests until AFTER they start chelation because the metals can be tightly bound, one of our listers here had that, so its not the holy grail some people think it is

Mandi x

When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone lately he mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might not be just an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also could be a marker for oxidative stress. OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if it could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not as much mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury then?Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean. Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by chance heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?Thanks,

Posted

Hi Mandi,Well we are on our way again, back on round and yes I'm giving him A,C, E and selenium. I don't know what NADH is but the read up on Mega Hydrate sounds really good.I didn't know about the beta carotenes so thanks and I'd be very interested in the other biggie if you do happen to find out the name of it.Thanks for the help,

Subject: Re: Urinary PorphyrinsTo: Autism-Biomedical-Europe Date: Friday, November 12, 2010, 8:10 AM

Some toxic folks have negative porphyrins tests until AFTER they start chelation because the metals can be tightly bound, one of our listers here had that, so its not the holy grail some people think it is

Mandi x

When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone lately he mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might not be just an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also could be a marker for oxidative stress. OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if it could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not as much mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury then?Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean. Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by chance heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?Thanks,

Posted

I'm posting my reply again below. I've had a couple posts not go through this last week so sorry if this comes through twice.Hi Mandi,Well we are on our way again, back on round and yes I'm giving him A,C, E and selenium. I don't know what NADH is but the read up on Mega Hydrate sounds really good.I didn't know about the beta carotenes so thanks and I'd be very interested in the other biggie if you do happen to find out the name of it.Thanks for the help,

Subject: Re: Urinary PorphyrinsTo: Autism-Biomedical-Europe Date: Friday, November 12, 2010, 8:10 AM

Some toxic folks have negative porphyrins tests until AFTER they start chelation because the metals can be tightly bound, one of our listers here had that, so its not the holy grail some people think it is

Mandi x

When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone lately he mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might not be just an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also could be a marker for oxidative stress. OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if it could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not as much mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury then?Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean. Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by chance heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?Thanks,

Posted

I'm posting my reply again below. I've had a couple posts not go through this last week so sorry if this comes through twice.Hi Mandi,Well we are on our way again, back on round and yes I'm giving him A,C, E and selenium. I don't know what NADH is but the read up on Mega Hydrate sounds really good.I didn't know about the beta carotenes so thanks and I'd be very interested in the other biggie if you do happen to find out the name of it.Thanks for the help,

Subject: Re: Urinary PorphyrinsTo: Autism-Biomedical-Europe Date: Friday, November 12, 2010, 8:10 AM

Some toxic folks have negative porphyrins tests until AFTER they start chelation because the metals can be tightly bound, one of our listers here had that, so its not the holy grail some people think it is

Mandi x

When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone lately he mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might not be just an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also could be a marker for oxidative stress. OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if it could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not as much mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury then?Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean. Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by chance heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?Thanks,

Posted

I'm posting my reply again below. I've had a couple posts not go through this last week so sorry if this comes through twice.Hi Mandi,Well we are on our way again, back on round and yes I'm giving him A,C, E and selenium. I don't know what NADH is but the read up on Mega Hydrate sounds really good.I didn't know about the beta carotenes so thanks and I'd be very interested in the other biggie if you do happen to find out the name of it.Thanks for the help,

Subject: Re: Urinary PorphyrinsTo: Autism-Biomedical-Europe Date: Friday, November 12, 2010, 8:10 AM

Some toxic folks have negative porphyrins tests until AFTER they start chelation because the metals can be tightly bound, one of our listers here had that, so its not the holy grail some people think it is

Mandi x

When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone lately he mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might not be just an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also could be a marker for oxidative stress. OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if it could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not as much mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury then?Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean. Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by chance heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?Thanks,

Posted

No, you can get all the metals you want out and the child will still

have oxidative stress and will still have autism. Don't confuse effect

with the cause.

Natasa

>

>

> From: Mum231ASD@... Mum231ASD@...

> Subject: Re: Urinary Porphyrins

> To: Autism-Biomedical-Europe

> Date: Friday, November 12, 2010, 8:10 AM

>

>

>

> Some toxic folks have negative porphyrins tests until AFTER they

start

> chelation because the metals can be tightly bound, one of our listers

here

> had that, so its not the holy grail some people think it is

>

> Mandi x

>

>

> In a message dated 11/11/2010 20:17:47 GMT Standard Time,

> lisastubner@... writes:

>

>

> When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone

lately he

> mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might not be

just

> an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also could be a

> marker for oxidative stress.

> OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if

it

> could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not

as much

> mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury

then?

> Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean.

> Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by

chance

> heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?

> Thanks,

>

>

Posted

porphyrins can be messed up due to mitochondrial dysfunction, which most

of our kids have anyway. imo the test is a waste of money.

Natasa

>

> From: lisastubner@...

> Subject: Urinary Porphyrins

> To: Autism-Biomedical-Europe

> Date: Thursday, 11 November, 2010, 20:16

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>  

>

>

>

>

>

>

> When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone

lately he mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might

not be just an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also

could be a marker for oxidative stress.

>

> OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if it

could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not as

much mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury

then?

>

> Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean.

>

> Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by

chance heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?

>

> Thanks,

>

>

>

Posted

porphyrins can be messed up due to mitochondrial dysfunction, which most

of our kids have anyway. imo the test is a waste of money.

Natasa

>

> From: lisastubner@...

> Subject: Urinary Porphyrins

> To: Autism-Biomedical-Europe

> Date: Thursday, 11 November, 2010, 20:16

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>  

>

>

>

>

>

>

> When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone

lately he mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might

not be just an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also

could be a marker for oxidative stress.

>

> OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if it

could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not as

much mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury

then?

>

> Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean.

>

> Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by

chance heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?

>

> Thanks,

>

>

>

Posted

porphyrins can be messed up due to mitochondrial dysfunction, which most

of our kids have anyway. imo the test is a waste of money.

Natasa

>

> From: lisastubner@...

> Subject: Urinary Porphyrins

> To: Autism-Biomedical-Europe

> Date: Thursday, 11 November, 2010, 20:16

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>  

>

>

>

>

>

>

> When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone

lately he mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might

not be just an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also

could be a marker for oxidative stress.

>

> OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if it

could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not as

much mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury

then?

>

> Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean.

>

> Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by

chance heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?

>

> Thanks,

>

>

>

Posted

Anita,Your not rambling, you express yourself very well and I am new at this so it's good to hear from those that have more experience.My son is mercury toxic and I know it's one of his problems. We saw improvements in speech when we first started chelation and he decided to go to wee wee all by himself when previously he wouldn't even go near a toilet. So the improvements were there and they have remained but we stopped with yeast and bacteria problems. We've now restarted and I guess that's why I've been

so interested in his urinary porphyrins (I feel that chelation helped and I feel we need to continue). But I do understand everyone's point in that there is no way I can truly measure his level of toxicity. Thanks for sharing your thoughts, --- On

Thu, 11/18/10, mysuperteach wrote:Subject: Re: Urinary PorphyrinsTo: Autism-Biomedical-Europe Date: Thursday, November 18, 2010, 4:10 AM

I agree with what Natasa has said in regard to you can get all the metals out and the child will still have autism; however, I don't believe that would be a good reason to leave metals in, especially as I know a lot of kids who have done just that--gotten the metals out and lost their autism. Mercury isn't the only cause of autism, obviously, but for some kids, including my own, it is one of the assaults to his body that left him with autism.

I do understand completely the urge to look at test results if the biomedical approaches you're using aren't giving you clear-cut results. That has very much been the case here. My son's responses are often very subtle or confusing or both.

We've chelated AC a long time. Our porphyrins results have been helpful, with a significant reduction between the first test (at about 70 rounds) and the second (at about 110). The second result still shows him to have signficant toxicity, but not off the charts. Knowing what I know now, I won't use another porphyrins test for a long time.

Mercury, lead, arsenic, antimony, etc, can all create damage that looks remarkably similar in my opinion. I do happen to believe that mercury is the most dangerous based on everything I've read. Part of the problem is that many of our kids, probably most of our kids, are exposed to a lot of metals, a lot of organophosphates, and a lot of immune assaults. All of these things can damage them in myriad ways with the outcome being pretty similar, so it is difficult to know what specific damage your child might have received.

People who are fortuntate enough to have good results from their biomedical efforts tend to believe that they did figure out exactly what went wrong and they've addressed those things. I don't buy that all the time. I think for the most part many of our kids have taken multiple, multiple hits. Metals are often part of that and chelation has help hundreds, but clearly chelation alone is insufficient for a lot of kids too.

Sorry to be rambling so much, but I thought maybe some of my thoughts on this issue of testing and progress and metals and causes might help a bit.

Anita

,

> >

> >

> > From: Mum231ASD@ Mum231ASD@

> > Subject: Re: Urinary Porphyrins

> > To: Autism-Biomedical-Europe

> > Date: Friday, November 12, 2010, 8:10 AM

> >

> >

> >

> > Some toxic folks have negative porphyrins tests until AFTER they

> start

> > chelation because the metals can be tightly bound, one of our listers

> here

> > had that, so its not the holy grail some people think it is

> >

> > Mandi x

> >

> >

> > In a message dated 11/11/2010 20:17:47 GMT Standard Time,

> > lisastubner@ writes:

> >

> >

> > When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone

> lately he

> > mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might not be

> just

> > an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also could be a

> > marker for oxidative stress.

> > OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if

> it

> > could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not

> as much

> > mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury

> then?

> > Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean.

> > Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by

> chance

> > heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?

> > Thanks,

> >

> >

>

Posted

Anita,Your not rambling, you express yourself very well and I am new at this so it's good to hear from those that have more experience.My son is mercury toxic and I know it's one of his problems. We saw improvements in speech when we first started chelation and he decided to go to wee wee all by himself when previously he wouldn't even go near a toilet. So the improvements were there and they have remained but we stopped with yeast and bacteria problems. We've now restarted and I guess that's why I've been

so interested in his urinary porphyrins (I feel that chelation helped and I feel we need to continue). But I do understand everyone's point in that there is no way I can truly measure his level of toxicity. Thanks for sharing your thoughts, --- On

Thu, 11/18/10, mysuperteach wrote:Subject: Re: Urinary PorphyrinsTo: Autism-Biomedical-Europe Date: Thursday, November 18, 2010, 4:10 AM

I agree with what Natasa has said in regard to you can get all the metals out and the child will still have autism; however, I don't believe that would be a good reason to leave metals in, especially as I know a lot of kids who have done just that--gotten the metals out and lost their autism. Mercury isn't the only cause of autism, obviously, but for some kids, including my own, it is one of the assaults to his body that left him with autism.

I do understand completely the urge to look at test results if the biomedical approaches you're using aren't giving you clear-cut results. That has very much been the case here. My son's responses are often very subtle or confusing or both.

We've chelated AC a long time. Our porphyrins results have been helpful, with a significant reduction between the first test (at about 70 rounds) and the second (at about 110). The second result still shows him to have signficant toxicity, but not off the charts. Knowing what I know now, I won't use another porphyrins test for a long time.

Mercury, lead, arsenic, antimony, etc, can all create damage that looks remarkably similar in my opinion. I do happen to believe that mercury is the most dangerous based on everything I've read. Part of the problem is that many of our kids, probably most of our kids, are exposed to a lot of metals, a lot of organophosphates, and a lot of immune assaults. All of these things can damage them in myriad ways with the outcome being pretty similar, so it is difficult to know what specific damage your child might have received.

People who are fortuntate enough to have good results from their biomedical efforts tend to believe that they did figure out exactly what went wrong and they've addressed those things. I don't buy that all the time. I think for the most part many of our kids have taken multiple, multiple hits. Metals are often part of that and chelation has help hundreds, but clearly chelation alone is insufficient for a lot of kids too.

Sorry to be rambling so much, but I thought maybe some of my thoughts on this issue of testing and progress and metals and causes might help a bit.

Anita

,

> >

> >

> > From: Mum231ASD@ Mum231ASD@

> > Subject: Re: Urinary Porphyrins

> > To: Autism-Biomedical-Europe

> > Date: Friday, November 12, 2010, 8:10 AM

> >

> >

> >

> > Some toxic folks have negative porphyrins tests until AFTER they

> start

> > chelation because the metals can be tightly bound, one of our listers

> here

> > had that, so its not the holy grail some people think it is

> >

> > Mandi x

> >

> >

> > In a message dated 11/11/2010 20:17:47 GMT Standard Time,

> > lisastubner@ writes:

> >

> >

> > When discussing my sons levels of Precoproporphyrin with someone

> lately he

> > mentioned that he'd heard recently that elevated levels might not be

> just

> > an indicator of mercury as previously thought but it also could be a

> > marker for oxidative stress.

> > OK I know that mercury causes oxidative stress but I'm wondering if

> it

> > could be more of a marker then for oxidative stress and possibly not

> as much

> > mercury as I thought. Possibly not a reliable marker for mercury

> then?

> > Gosh I hope I'm making sense here and that you know what I mean.

> > Anyway, I would really like to read more about it so has any one by

> chance

> > heard of this or is this just absolute dribble?

> > Thanks,

> >

> >

>

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...