Guest guest Posted December 28, 2010 Report Posted December 28, 2010 We've had similar results in the past, discarded the fuzzy stuff -- that way due to contact with air,different microbes, and happily eaten the good stuff below. It might be time to put the good stuff in smaller jars and refrigerate it. We've also used whey as a boost to the microbes. I think giving the kraut a good pounding is more important than we realize. My not so successful batches have happened when I didn't really get the juice out and the fibers submerged in it processes necessary to the anaerobic process. Maybe leaving the juice in the veg fiber leaves air pockets which then make it more aerobic with different microbes? Pound it! KL On Tue, Dec 28, 2010 at 5:42 PM, bubblingovernow <fhwhelan@...> wrote: > So I made kraut a few weeks ago, pretty much like I usually do, and it went > bad. It got a white and furry on the top and I tried eating some from below > the mold and it tastes fine. However, it's probably not worth the chance of > getting ill, so I'll pitch it. So sad. > > This is what I did: 2/3 gallon of white cabbage, 1/3 cup sea salt, some > Bubbies' kraut liquid as starter to accelerate it, some herbs, and water to > cover. I did not pound it down and I did not press it and while that's > worked fine in the past, this time it seemed that more cabbage floated than > usual. It's about 70 degrees in the house and I waited about 3 weeks. Not > much has changed, except that I hadn't used the Bubbies' starter before nor > had I waited that long before eating the kraut. > > I'd love for someone to dissect this failed effort and suggest what I > should do differently next time! Thank you! > > > > ------------------------------------ > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 28, 2010 Report Posted December 28, 2010 I use 3T salt layered with 5 lbs cabbage, pound until enough liquid is released to cover the cabbage when its pressed down. After pounding for a few minutes, if it's too dry, add additional brine to cover (1 1/2T salt per qt water). Strongly recommend unrefined salt and filtered water. If you've got a mandoline slicer, cabbage cut in 1mm threads makes really tasty kraut. If you are fermenting in an open container, I'd expect spotty results. For consistent, delicious ferments an anaerobic environment is required. Harsch crocks are great, as are the glass fermenting containers from www.pickl-it.com. I've experimented with ordinary mason jar lids, and using water filled plastic bags pressed on top of a ferment to make a cover, but neither seal well enough to make great kraut every time. My experience is that whey often adds off flavors and makes the kraut mushy. I'm pretty sure Bubbies kraut is pasteurized ( http://www.bestnaturalfoods.com/got_fermentation.html), so the juice is useless as a starter. Sometimes the top gets discolored or otherwise yucky. Almost always the underneath part is still OK. Greg On Tue, Dec 28, 2010 at 4:42 PM, bubblingovernow <fhwhelan@...> wrote: > > > So I made kraut a few weeks ago, pretty much like I usually do, and it went > bad. It got a white and furry on the top and I tried eating some from below > the mold and it tastes fine. However, it's probably not worth the chance of > getting ill, so I'll pitch it. So sad. > > This is what I did: 2/3 gallon of white cabbage, 1/3 cup sea salt, some > Bubbies' kraut liquid as starter to accelerate it, some herbs, and water to > cover. I did not pound it down and I did not press it and while that's > worked fine in the past, this time it seemed that more cabbage floated than > usual. It's about 70 degrees in the house and I waited about 3 weeks. Not > much has changed, except that I hadn't used the Bubbies' starter before nor > had I waited that long before eating the kraut. > > I'd love for someone to dissect this failed effort and suggest what I > should do differently next time! Thank you! > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 28, 2010 Report Posted December 28, 2010 i have not had this problem w/ Kraut. But i do pound on it for 10 min or so. I do the recipe from Nourishing Traditions and it seems to last forever. It isn't really very submerged. I have a mason type jar w/ the clamp and rubber seal (not sure what that is called). I leave it out for about 3 days and then i do transfer it to cold storage in our fridge. Once i did use our basement for cold storage which gets only to about 60 degrees. It seemed to be OK but i was nervous so i just do the fridge cold storage and export it if i have extra kraut that i feel i don't have room for. good luck! patrice > > From: gmiller99@... > Date: Tue, 28 Dec 2010 20:57:45 -0600 > Subject: Re: Kraut Turns Furry... Why? > > I use 3T salt layered with 5 lbs cabbage, pound until enough liquid is > released to cover the cabbage when its pressed down. After pounding for a > few minutes, if it's too dry, add additional brine to cover (1 1/2T salt per > qt water). Strongly recommend unrefined salt and filtered water. If you've > got a mandoline slicer, cabbage cut in 1mm threads makes really tasty kraut. > > If you are fermenting in an open container, I'd expect spotty results. For > consistent, delicious ferments an anaerobic environment is required. Harsch > crocks are great, as are the glass fermenting containers from > www.pickl-it.com. I've experimented with ordinary mason jar lids, and using > water filled plastic bags pressed on top of a ferment to make a cover, but > neither seal well enough to make great kraut every time. > > My experience is that whey often adds off flavors and makes the kraut mushy. > I'm pretty sure Bubbies kraut is pasteurized ( > http://www.bestnaturalfoods.com/got_fermentation.html), so the juice is > useless as a starter. Sometimes the top gets discolored or otherwise yucky. > Almost always the underneath part is still OK. > > Greg > > On Tue, Dec 28, 2010 at 4:42 PM, bubblingovernow <fhwhelan@...> wrote: > > > > > > > So I made kraut a few weeks ago, pretty much like I usually do, and it went > > bad. It got a white and furry on the top and I tried eating some from below > > the mold and it tastes fine. However, it's probably not worth the chance of > > getting ill, so I'll pitch it. So sad. > > > > This is what I did: 2/3 gallon of white cabbage, 1/3 cup sea salt, some > > Bubbies' kraut liquid as starter to accelerate it, some herbs, and water to > > cover. I did not pound it down and I did not press it and while that's > > worked fine in the past, this time it seemed that more cabbage floated than > > usual. It's about 70 degrees in the house and I waited about 3 weeks. Not > > much has changed, except that I hadn't used the Bubbies' starter before nor > > had I waited that long before eating the kraut. > > > > I'd love for someone to dissect this failed effort and suggest what I > > should do differently next time! Thank you! > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 Use Sandor Katz recipe, and you should have good success. I don't pound my cabbage anymore, it hurts my hands. It just takes longer to ferment. No air is really the key, and keeping it submerged and covered in brine. Use a plastic food grade bag of water on top if you don't have a good plate or jar or heavy item to sink it. Put a lid on. Keep ALL under brine. Keep away from light. You will not need any starters or anything if you are careful, clean and patient. Here's the website. http://www.wildfermentation.com/resources.php?page=pickles I like to use the brine recipe from the pickles and you can combine with the kraut recipe if you desire, or not. 3tbsp of salt per liter water approx, that's a bit salty for my taste but you can experiment. no need to measure cabbage, just keep pouring brine til it's covered. email me if you need more help. I love to ferment things Also, the suggestions about crocks and pickl-it jars are good, but costly. I use mason jars or buckets. once I used my old beer making bucket and airlock. > > So I made kraut a few weeks ago, pretty much like I usually do, and it went bad. It got a white and furry on the top and I tried eating some from below the mold and it tastes fine. However, it's probably not worth the chance of getting ill, so I'll pitch it. So sad. > > This is what I did: 2/3 gallon of white cabbage, 1/3 cup sea salt, some Bubbies' kraut liquid as starter to accelerate it, some herbs, and water to cover. I did not pound it down and I did not press it and while that's worked fine in the past, this time it seemed that more cabbage floated than usual. It's about 70 degrees in the house and I waited about 3 weeks. Not much has changed, except that I hadn't used the Bubbies' starter before nor had I waited that long before eating the kraut. > > I'd love for someone to dissect this failed effort and suggest what I should do differently next time! Thank you! > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 Sorry about the poor results! I still remember how disappointed I was by my slimy ginger carrots and moldy fruit chutney a couple years ago. I have since learned that using an appropriate container is critical. You can't allow any air in - kraut requires anaerobic conditions, something a mason jar is not (unless it's heat sealed, which totally defeats the purpose of lacto-fermentation.) I highly recommend Pickl-It jars, which are pretty much fail-proof. They are wire bail jars, which don't allow air in, with an airlock to allow gasses out. Exposure to oxygen allows growth of the bad organisms which can take over the good ones. This is when you get mold. Regardless of the type of container you use, airtight or not, you need to press your kraut down to get all of the air out. Leaving all of those little pockets between the cabbage threads is allowing more oxygen into the ferment - and oxygen is bad for lacto-fermentation. Be sure to pack it down next time. 70 degrees and 3 weeks sitting on the counter are fine; be sure to cover your ferment so it's not exposed to light if you haven't been. Starter is not necessary or even beneficial. You only need salt and filtered water, preferably fluoride-free. A good salt-to-cabbage ratio: 3 tablespoons of salt for every 5-pounds of sliced cabbage. Lactic-acid bacteria benefit from the minerals in unrefined, high-quality sea salt. Here's a helpful article http://www.pickl-it.com/blog/321/sauerkraut-thread-cut/ And here's a technique to help keep all of the kraut under the brine http://www.pickl-it.com/faq/312/keep-vegetables-under-brine/ What form of herbs did you use? Don't ever use ground herbs, as they muck up the brine. Only use whole herbs, and it might even be helpful to place them in cheesecloth or something similar, so you can take them out before placing the jar in cold storage. Hope this is helpful! Good luck with your next batch, Alyssa > > So I made kraut a few weeks ago, pretty much like I usually do, and it went bad. It got a white and furry on the top and I tried eating some from below the mold and it tastes fine. However, it's probably not worth the chance of getting ill, so I'll pitch it. So sad. > > This is what I did: 2/3 gallon of white cabbage, 1/3 cup sea salt, some Bubbies' kraut liquid as starter to accelerate it, some herbs, and water to cover. I did not pound it down and I did not press it and while that's worked fine in the past, this time it seemed that more cabbage floated than usual. It's about 70 degrees in the house and I waited about 3 weeks. Not much has changed, except that I hadn't used the Bubbies' starter before nor had I waited that long before eating the kraut. > > I'd love for someone to dissect this failed effort and suggest what I should do differently next time! Thank you! > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.