Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 I wanted to clarify some things about my former message. In spite of how my list of RAW MILK PRODUCTION safety protocol sounded to some, I was by no means abandoning the Hartmann's. I was one of the early adopters to their dairy. That was not my point at all. Nor is the protocol, as writes, designed as a 'SUCK-UP-TO-THE-STATE " series of tests and improvements. Far, far from it! At least 90% of these tests are not required by the government at all. These are COMMON SENSE tests for selling milk today. It's 2010, not 1910! Following a strict and pro-active protocol is now the ONLY way to successfully market raw milk in this country. You can't turn back the clock. No one is implying that this protocol " eliminates all danger " , that's ridiculous. However, we intend to mitigate risk to levels that make this aspect of dairy farming worthwhile. No cutting edge enterprise is for the faint of heart, that's a given. I work with people across the US who are selling raw milk. Successfully. Many in states with laws considered to be worse than ours. (You are calling Minnesota a " corrupt " state by comparison? Come on!). To my knowledge none of these successful producers spend much time ranting about conspiracy theories, belaboring collusions between Big Gov- Big Ag or using other big bad wolves as a cop-out for doing nothing. They don't have time. I don't either, in fact, I think it's counter-productive, merely depressing some people and throwing the rest into fear-based inaction. To me, getting down to work itself, and working smart, THAT is the Big Picture. Will Winter Quote
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 Hi Carol: You bet. I was on my Blackberry so abbreviated a bit. I agree. Those who don't vaccinate (we don't) or who use raw milk (we don't YET but really don't use much milk anyway--it's more cheese for us, which I've taken the baby step to buy local and raw from the co-op) have done a lot of research. I meant to say that my scientist friends (I mentioned I'm an intellectual property lawyer so I have a bunch of them) tend to really like government and state-funded/educational research not this " alternative quackery " that I propose. Fortunately I was raised on organic, whole foods so I had a good head start! Thanks for the welcome! e On Mon, Dec 27, 2010 at 8:37 AM, Carol Frisk <carolfrisk@...> wrote: > > > Hi e, > > Welcome to the group. Regarding your comment that the better educated are > less likely to rely on their gut and go with research is an interesting > comment. I read an article regarding vaccines and then another one > regarding raw dairy products. Both concluded that people who move away from > vaccines and separately those who move to raw dairy are more likely to have > a larger income and to be better educated. I extensively researched > vaccines and the more I researched the more I did not trust vaccines. I > think people assume the FDA is to be trusted regarding their conclusions to > the research, even though people do not do the research themselves, and > they > are viewing themselves as trusting research and facts. But it seems to me > that people who delve in and evaluate the research themselves frequently > come back with a very different conclusion. So what I am saying is that I > do not think people who eat whole foods are really going with their gut at > all, but rather have done extensive research and have decided what the FDA > says is not in their best interest. > > > Carol > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 Will, Thanks for your posts and protocols. I don't think they are a suck up and some things need to change if for no other reason than to have something in place for when the state comes knocking! I think it is also good to have some things in place and a set of standards to aim for to keep things running smoothly. Are there any other things that you (or anyone else) like to see--building design, age of animals, type of pastures/rotations, length of lactations, use or not use of certain breeds, etc., that you would be willing to share? On one of my goat lists currently there is a huge debate/discussion about when to dry off does so just getting all info thoughts and ideas together to help make the final decisions. And final decisions always tend to evolve anyway! Quote
Guest guest Posted December 28, 2010 Report Posted December 28, 2010 I love the time article that started saying something to the effect that they (us) are not kooks and the government is really out to get them. Lol. While I see your point about getting distracted with theories and hating government to the point of depression and inaction, I also think it is wise to keep in mind the national agenda put forth by health and human services to essentially end raw dairy. It helps keep the perspective that the Hartmann issue is much bigger than there farm, and is not really about food poisoning or even their farm at all. So many people do not get this. But it is the bigger more whole picture. I think it is super that the dairies in the country are working together. I think that is wise given this is a national push implemented at the state level, and it indicates that they get the fact that there is a government national agenda on the matter. (Thanks also for reporting the meeting. I had no idea that was happening.) Carol Quote
Guest guest Posted December 28, 2010 Report Posted December 28, 2010 Hi Carol, What I mean: Like Judge Napolitano in his book, The Constitution in Exile, p. 183, I'm calling conditional grants of federal funding to State agencies " bribery " . The latest supreme Court case to mark the legality of such bribery, as far as I know, is South Dakota v. Dole (1987), http://supreme.justia.com/us/483/203/case.html <http://supreme.justia.com/us/483/203/case.html> . You can get a better idea about how pervasive such bribery is by going to this article: http://supreme.justia.com/constitution/article-1/18-spending-for-general\ -welfare.html <http://supreme.justia.com/constitution/article-1/18-spending-for-genera\ l-welfare.html> . Search for " Conditional Grants-in-Aid " . P.S.: I'm sorry if this message shows up twice in this thread. I'm still learning how to use -groups. > > , > > > > What do you mean that the courts have ruled bribery is legal? Can you refer > me to an article regarding this? > > Thanks, > > Carol > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 I apologize for my ignorance but i know some states get away with selling milk for the consumption of animals. Is this something that farmers can use to still sell milk in Minnesota? Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.