Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 Pick your poison... The goal, in general, is not to find the best sugar, but to slowly reduce the intake of these " jet fuel " concentrated carbohydrates in the overall diet. That being said, there is a difference. If you go to the WAPF website you will now see that Sally and crew have nixed agave sugar (there was a nice article about it in Wise Traditions last year). There is also some global concern about the horrific destruction of the palm forest worldwide, but I believe that is about oil extraction. Lately I've been working on a team involved with bioremediation of abandoned sugar cane plantations (converting them to grazing grass) and I find that cane production is one of the most toxic industries in the world! Scorched earth pesticides, then K-line plastic drip irrigation lines, then super NPK fertilizers, constant spraying with pesticides and herbicides, then burning the field, bulldozing everything up (including all the melted K-lines) and then extracting the sugar along with all that melted plastic! It's one of the sickest industries ever devised. Even organic sugar cane has most of these problems. Toxic then the land is left a barren moonscape that won't even grow a weed. US cane production has now moved to South America. One of the biggest problems with beet-derived sugar is that production is shifting to all GMO beets! You can't win! Seems like maple syrup production burns an enormous amount of fossil fuel to concentrate it, and the poor bees are working themselves to death while we steal their honey and offer them high-fructose corn syrup to live on. Our 160# per capita annual consumption of sugar is draining the planet (and killing us!). Will Winter Quote
Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 I totally agree. But I just want a really good cup of coffee in the morning. We go through a 5 lb bag every six months, so we are not using it a lot. I don't bake too much, so we don't use a ton of sweetners. But the reality is that we have to have some sweet foods sometimes. So what can we do? Are there are NO earth friendly sweetners? I don't expect any sweetner to be good for my body, but is there anything that is neutral-ish? I was thinking I was doing better by buying this stuff. The package says it's " sustainable " . I know you can't trust everything you read on packages, but I do trust my co-op... mostly. I was suspicious about the " organic " soba noodles from CHINA!!! Hello. I don't believe that for a second. I didn't realize that's where they were from. I took them back during my next shop. Any suggestions are welcome! Thank you all! I love this group. > > Pick your poison... The goal, in general, is not to find the best sugar, but to slowly reduce the intake of these " jet fuel " concentrated carbohydrates in the overall diet. That being said, there is a difference. If you go to the WAPF website you will now see that Sally and crew have nixed agave sugar (there was a nice article about it in Wise Traditions last year). There is also some global concern about the horrific destruction of the palm forest worldwide, but I believe that is about oil extraction. > > Lately I've been working on a team involved with bioremediation of abandoned sugar cane plantations (converting them to grazing grass) and I find that cane production is one of the most toxic industries in the world! Scorched earth pesticides, then K-line plastic drip irrigation lines, then super NPK fertilizers, constant spraying with pesticides and herbicides, then burning the field, bulldozing everything up (including all the melted K-lines) and then extracting the sugar along with all that melted plastic! It's one of the sickest industries ever devised. Even organic sugar cane has most of these problems. Toxic then the land is left a barren moonscape that won't even grow a weed. US cane production has now moved to South America. > > One of the biggest problems with beet-derived sugar is that production is shifting to all GMO beets! You can't win! Seems like maple syrup production burns an enormous amount of fossil fuel to concentrate it, and the poor bees are working themselves to death while we steal their honey and offer them high-fructose corn syrup to live on. Our 160# per capita annual consumption of sugar is draining the planet (and killing us!). > > Will Winter > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 Hi , Coconut palm sugar has a similar GI index (low) as agave (I know you're not worried about that, but just for comparison). It does have tons more nutrients (especially minerals) than regular cane sugar, so I would definitely go with the cococonut palm sugar over regular cane sugar as a " healthier " sweetner for the times we do use them. Hope that helps answer your question. --Kelli > > Hello all! > I've been reading Nourishing Traditions!!!! Love it. And reading up on sugar, etc. I went to my co-op today and picked up some organic coconut palm sugar. Does anyone know about that? Nourishing traditions recommends agave, stevia, honey and maple syrup as substitutes for sugar, but nutritionally, does anyone know about coconut palm sugar? Is it as harmful as regular cane sugar? I was using turbinado previously, and I guess that is just as bad. huh. Any info would be helpful. I'm not a diabetic, so I don't pay too much attention to GI #'s. Thanks! > > - > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 I don't actually have the answer but I do read a lot of blogs. Maybe one of these articles would help? http://www.thenourishinggourmet.com/2008/11/in-my-kitchen-coconut-sugar.html http://www.thenourishinggourmet.com/2008/12/guide-to-natural-sweeteners_08.html http://www.passionatehomemaking.com/2008/09/my-favorite-natural-sweeteners.html Oh, and I don't like it for baking but when I'm thirsty I make a big pitcher of tea then use 100% apple juice concentrate to sweeten it. It works well for us considering I am one of those sugar addicts. I've also heard of people using dates to sweeten things too though I'm not sure how that works. -Crystal > > > > Pick your poison... The goal, in general, is not to find the best sugar, but to slowly reduce the intake of these " jet fuel " concentrated carbohydrates in the overall diet. That being said, there is a difference. If you go to the WAPF website you will now see that Sally and crew have nixed agave sugar (there was a nice article about it in Wise Traditions last year). There is also some global concern about the horrific destruction of the palm forest worldwide, but I believe that is about oil extraction. > > > > Lately I've been working on a team involved with bioremediation of abandoned sugar cane plantations (converting them to grazing grass) and I find that cane production is one of the most toxic industries in the world! Scorched earth pesticides, then K-line plastic drip irrigation lines, then super NPK fertilizers, constant spraying with pesticides and herbicides, then burning the field, bulldozing everything up (including all the melted K-lines) and then extracting the sugar along with all that melted plastic! It's one of the sickest industries ever devised. Even organic sugar cane has most of these problems. Toxic then the land is left a barren moonscape that won't even grow a weed. US cane production has now moved to South America. > > > > One of the biggest problems with beet-derived sugar is that production is shifting to all GMO beets! You can't win! Seems like maple syrup production burns an enormous amount of fossil fuel to concentrate it, and the poor bees are working themselves to death while we steal their honey and offer them high-fructose corn syrup to live on. Our 160# per capita annual consumption of sugar is draining the planet (and killing us!). > > > > Will Winter > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 Really? NT recommends Agave as an alternative? That's a little weird considering what a modern food it is. When looking for sugar look for the least refining in process, if you can get one that has never been heated or chemically treated then you're doing good. And of course, with sugar, less is more, most of us eat way too much of it, even when we think we're not consuming so much. Quote
Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 I think so... I could be wrong. I was just reading up on it a few days ago, and started looking into alternatives. The amounts of sugar she mentions in that book are startling... I think she said like 100 some pounds a year per person. And I think I have the 2000 or 2001 edition. So it may be more.... I think that's what she said. I have to re-read the chapter. > > Really? NT recommends Agave as an alternative? That's a little weird considering what a modern food it is. > > When looking for sugar look for the least refining in process, if you can get one that has never been heated or chemically treated then you're doing good. And of course, with sugar, less is more, most of us eat way too much of it, even when we think we're not consuming so much. > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 hahaha. I'm not the best reader. It must have been Stevia and........ ummm. I have to re-read. > > NOOOO, NT does NOT recommend agave! > > > Re: coconut palm sugar? Good or bad? > > > Really? NT recommends Agave as an alternative? That's a little weird considering what a modern food it is. > > When looking for sugar look for the least refining in process, if you can get one that has never been heated or chemically treated then you're doing good. And of course, with sugar, less is more, most of us eat way too much of it, even when we think we're not consuming so much. > > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.