Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

What if this was YOU? Is this the government you wanted?

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

MUG RING BUSTED

Helpful raw-milk-drinking mom threatened with prosecution

BY Gumpert

20 DEC 2010 8:28 AM

For the last seven years, Rae Lynn Sandvig, a mother of four, has been helping a

local dairy farmer, Hartmann, distribute unpasteurized milk to 35 or 40

friends and neighbors in her suburban Minneapolis community of Bloomington.

Every two weeks, the farmer pulls up in her home's driveway, one stop among half

a dozen or so other homes in the metropolitan area that serve as distribution

points, and hands out jars of raw milk to customers who've placed orders.

Sometimes, Sandvig buys half a steer from the same farmer, and divvies it up

among four to six friends. (The USDA allows consumers to buy meat directly from

the farmer that has been sold live, " on the hoof " and then slaughtered in a

non-USDA inspected facility -- or on the farm -- for their personal consumption

under certain conditions.)

Sandvig gets nothing from this arrangement financially, she says. There is one

big benefit, though. " I've stood out there with other moms when it's

20-below-zero, and in 90-degree weather, and we've become a community. It's the

way life is supposed to work. "

It's not been working well over the last six months, though. Sandvig has found

herself a target of the Minnesota Department of Agriculture (MDA), culminating

in accusations over the past week that she is assisting in the illegal sale of

raw milk. She has been threatened with " criminal prosecution or administrative

penalties. "

By making Sandvig the first consumer to be caught up in the legal machinations,

Minnesota seems to have opened a new chapter in the five-year-old war on raw

milk. Up until now, government crackdowns around the country have focused

entirely on farmers who run raw-milk dairies, along with managers of buying

clubs and food clubs that help distribute milk, in states where its sale to

humans is illegal. Raw-milk can be sold legally in certain states as pet food,

or in so-called " herd shares. " (The Farm-to-Consumer Legal Defense Fund has a

good map of the breakdown by state).

While Minnesota is one of the states that allows its sale, the farmer whose milk

Sandvig was distributing has been linked to illnesses and has been prohibited by

the Minnesota Department of Agriculture from selling dairy products. Until

Minnesota went after Sandvig, the assumption by all involved, including the FDA,

seems to have been that consumers are off limits, representing a kind of red

line in the struggle that has seen the FDA and Centers for Disease Control push

hard to discourage raw-milk consumption.

The FDA, responding to a suit by the Farm-to-Consumer Legal Defense Fund earlier

this year on behalf of five consumers around the country, challenging the

federal prohibition on raw milk sales, trumpeted the fact that no consumers have

been prosecuted. " The government has neither brought nor threatened to bring a

single enforcement action against consumers who purchase unpasteurized milk, " it

said [PDF].

Last May, Minnesota public health officials believed they had linked Hartmann's

farm to five illnesses from raw milk, shortly after which the Minnesota

Department of Agriculture " embargoed dairy products on the Hartmann farm,

prohibiting movement or release of the products off the farm. " (Several more

were later announced as being connected to the farm.)

A few weeks after the initial outbreaks, Sandvig's problems began. Investigators

from the MDA, accompanied by local police, showed up at her home one morning,

presented her husband with a criminal search warrant, and spent two hours going

through the family's refrigerator and questioning her about whether she was

reselling milk, meat, and other food. She was " terrified, horrified,

traumatized " by the home search, breaking down in tears in front of the seven

investigators and police rummaging through her kitchen.

The event seemed even more threatening when she learned an MDA investigator had

visited the homes of three of her neighbors who had shared in the milk and beef

Hartmann delivered, seeking specifics about her food distribution practices. She

says the investigator threatened these consumers with subpoenas that would

require them to testify unless they allowed him into their homes to answer

questions and look into their refrigerators, and then sign an affidavit listing

foods they had acquired via Sandvig. The neighbors have since clammed up to her,

she says, but one told her the investigator was particularly interested in

packages of meat labeled " Not for Re-sale " on which the farmer had printed

Sandvig's name. Meat that is slaughtered or processed in a non-USDA-inspected

facility is labeled this way to prevent its retail sale.

Then, just a few days ago, Sandvig received a registered letter from the MDA

accusing her of " assisting in the sale of raw milk from your home in

Bloomington " and offering her an " opportunity to be heard " in an " administrative

meeting...before the department decides what if any enforcement action it will

take against you for operating a food business without a license, " most notably

" selling raw milk and selling food from unapproved sources. " Enforcement actions

could include criminal or administrative penalties, the letter stated.

The meeting was originally scheduled for last week but is now being re-scheduled

for January, Sandvig says. The Farm-to-Consumer Legal Defense Fund has agreed to

represent her in the meeting and any proceedings.

An official of the MDA declined to comment on the case, except to point out that

Minnesota law requires that targets of investigations be offered a chance to

meet with agency officials and take issue with planned charges.

Hartmann has a long history of challenging Minnesota food laws. When prosecutors

in his county charged him in 2002 with selling uninspected meat, he took the

case to the Minnesota Supreme Court, and won a partial victory, based on a

clause in the Minnesota constitution that allows farmers to " peddle " their food.

As a result of the June embargo on his farm's products, Hartmann filed suit

against the state, seeking a lifting of the embargo and the return of food the

state had seized. He argued that the linkage the state made between illnesses

and his farm was inconclusive, since tests on his farm's milk had shown no

pathogens. That led to a lengthy trial during the summer, attended by Sandvig

and other Hartmann customers. The judge is due to issue a decision in the case

before the end of this year.

The current raw milk situation has become complicated as well, because Minnesota

agriculture officials have extended their investigation and actions well beyond

seeking to limit Hartmann's sales of milk and meat. For example, state and local

officials raided a Minneapolis buying club, Traditional Foods Minnesota, last

June, and shut it down, even though it had no known connection to Hartmann. The

shutdown was attributed to local retail licensing problems, and the buying club

recently re-opened with additional permits. Officials also placed an embargo on

a Minnesota farmer, Alvin Schlangen, even though he, too, had no known

connection to Hartmann. He says he just received a letter similar to Sandvig's,

inviting him to a meeting with the MDA, preparatory to the possible filing of

charges.

The Hartmann case flared up again two weeks ago when two MDA officials

confronted Hartmann's brother, , and seized 400 gallons of milk in

front of a suburban Minneapolis home (not Sandvig's). About 40 Hartmann

supporters quickly gathered and loudly scolded the two MDA inspectors who carted

off milk samples and arranged for a tow truck to cart off the Hartmann truck;

the scene was caught on video, and posted on YouTube.

Sandvig isn't saying how she'll handle the upcoming meeting with the MDA. " I

have nothing to hide, " she says, adding she's already told them her side of the

story during the search of her home last June.

She has concluded that the campaign against Hartmann is part of " a

vendetta " by the state against the farmer, based on his previous challenges of

state authority. Including her in the Minnesota food-rights dragnet represents

" overreaching by the government, wanting licenses and registration for

everything. "

She adds, " I am on my own personal journey to keep learning about food. "

She'll also be learning much more about the legal system, as she may well become

a test case in an ominous new front in the struggle for consumers' right to

choose food straight from the farm.

Gumpert is the author of The Raw Milk Revolution: Behind America's

Emerging Battle Over Food Rights (Chelsea Green, 2009). He is also a journalist

who specializes in covering the intersection of health and business. His popular

blog has chronicled the increasingly unsettling battles over raw milk. He has

authored or coauthored seven books on various aspects of entrepreneurship and

business and previously been a reporter and editor with the Wall Street Journal,

Inc. magazine, and the Harvard Business Review.

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...