Guest guest Posted March 27, 2010 Report Posted March 27, 2010 Jerry Telle wrote: H i , I essentially agree with everything you have expressed. Still I would like research to demonstrate your projections. It may be that you, and the likes of you, with the tremendous physical endowments you have would need 3-4 working sets (at what level of intensity?) while others would get 98% benefits from , after 2 warmup sets, 1 set training? Casler writes: Hi Jerry, If you perform " warm-up " and approach sets you have already moved to a multi-set model. For one to believe that a Single Set to Failure can produce equal or better results than a multiple set schema you need to buy into the OPTIMAL Stimulus argument, that you can provide the maximal and optimal stimulus to a muscle via a Single Set taken to Exhaustive Failure. To accept this you need then agree that no matter what your condition that you can somehow produce an overload within that set, or believe that the body will produce SuperCompensation indefinitely. In the arena of stimuli you have TENSIONS, and you have Fatigues. The Fatigues are Metabolic, Neural, Muscular, and Mental. In Strength Training the Primary Stimulus is Tension, with all the Fatigues providing the supporting roles to stimulus. All models of training combine these stimulus elements to an OVERLOAD within the framework of the current condition or last, most recent stimulus. That is, for an adaptive response to occur, the most recent stimulus " package " (not the government version) must in some way exceed what the organism has been previously exposed to. In the beginning trainees make a type of progress I call " leapfrog " or SUPER Compensation. This progress is usually rapid and driven by the fact that the Motor System can learn rather quickly how to produce and apply more force than the muscle have been accustomed to (overload), this then causes the muscles to adapt to the HIGHER TENSIONS and WORK via protein synthesis (growth). This process occurs for a short period driven by the cycle of neural and tissue adaptations (leapfrogging) to appear as " overcompensatory " adaptations. However the SuperCompensation observation reaches diminishing returns when applied via a Single Set program. Now you are faced with a dilemma of accepting that " further " stimulus via a second set will cause a greater stimulus, or that it will cause an " overtraining or over-reaching " result. Well of course we already know that it DOES NOT cause overtraining unless carried to the extreme under long term circumstances. We also know that increased workload (adequately applied) DOES cause overload conditions and further progress. The fallacy of the single set model as optimal also is based on the limited assumption that " full metabolic, mental and neural " exhaustion is the Optimal Stimulus, when it is not. The optimal stimulus for Strength training is Progressively Overloading the Tensions and the Work that a muscle(s) is exposed to. It is IMPOSSIBLE to create a continuously available overload indefinitely via a SINGLE SET. No one has ever done it, and no one is currently doing it. What IS possible is that you can reach a fairly high level (% result) via the Single Set model with the highest intensity (highest effort to each moment of the exercise). But just like there is no real perpetual motion machine, there is no single example of any elite strength athlete or World Champion employing anything close to this model. Jerry Telle wrote: Thanks for the Yates revelations. I always wondered about this. Casler writes: Strangely enough the Single Set proponents always trot out Dorian or Mike (who was an old friend of mine for many years) as examples of such training when neither actually succeeded in using that model for their ultimate genetic expression during their peaks. And while it might be claimed that they DID on occasion train a Single Set OF AN EXERCISE to FAILURE, they performed MULTIPLE Sets for each BodyPart which is MULTI-SET training, NOT Single. Regards, Casler TRI-VECTOR 3-D Force Systems Century City, CA Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.