Guest guest Posted December 22, 2010 Report Posted December 22, 2010 So, the question is can significant foraminal narrowing have showed up in a year post trauma. That is a very good question. I have seen a study about osseous degenerative changes showing up 7 years later at a significantly higher rate than the normal population who wasn't in an accident, but I have not seen anything that says a year. Someone else may be up on that and it is not to say it can't happen in the big realm of healing. I would, however, think it is more likely that it was pre-existing narrowing, that gave the person a neck that just couldn't handle the forces in the accident as a "normal" neck would have. The accident is still causative even though the degeneration existed. That would be my justification as accident related IF the intermittent paresthesia was not there before the accident. To really find out, you may have them take a lie detector test, tie 'em down and do water boarding or a few of the other Abrahamson Techniques I learned at that last weekend seminar. In addition, if the paresthesia was there before the accident, and it is now worse....the accident is still causative of the worsening. Anyway, that is my way of thinking. What say you all?? I'm sure there are learned literature scholars that may be up on what is actually out there in regards to your question. Did you do motion films to assess stability at that level?? Don White, RN, DC Canyon Rd Chiropractic & Massage Beaverton, OR 97005 In a message dated 12/22/2010 4:54:46 P.M. Pacific Standard Time, jeff_foster_dc@... writes: Background: I have a patient with an intermittent left-hand paraesthesia (C7 dermatome). She has been getting regular treatments and has recovered/resolved most of her other complaints. Question: Could this accident (classic rearend collision/CADD syndrome)be responsible for a foraminal narrowing at the IVF and then the subsequent hand symptoms? The reason I ask is b/c a recent MRI confirmed these results and the symptoms match the findings. However, reporting to the insurance company has me a bit concerned b/c, to my way of thinking, any osseous changes at the vertebral level are going to be degenerative and likely the result of a lifetime of bad posture, and/or past truama, and NOT something that would appear within a year's time. Can anyone justify these findings as caused by a recent MVA case? Quote
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2010 Report Posted December 22, 2010 Dr. , Art Croft's work shows significant late-term effects, 6 months on from whiplash types of injuries. Do you have any evidence of disc damage at that level? You may want to look into Dr. Croft's work to support your findings. Ron Grice,DC On 12/22/2010 4:54 PM, jeff_foster_dc wrote: Background: I have a patient with an intermittent left-hand paraesthesia (C7 dermatome). She has been getting regular treatments and has recovered/resolved most of her other complaints. Question: Could this accident (classic rearend collision/CADD syndrome)be responsible for a foraminal narrowing at the IVF and then the subsequent hand symptoms? The reason I ask is b/c a recent MRI confirmed these results and the symptoms match the findings. However, reporting to the insurance company has me a bit concerned b/c, to my way of thinking, any osseous changes at the vertebral level are going to be degenerative and likely the result of a lifetime of bad posture, and/or past truama, and NOT something that would appear within a year's time. Can anyone justify these findings as caused by a recent MVA case? Quote
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2010 Report Posted December 22, 2010 It seems most likely that the degeneration is a pre-existing condition and should be viewed as a complicating factor. Try to focus on the symptoms before and after the accident. Pretty much what Dr. White said. BarrettFrom: "MekaAbou@..." <MekaAbou@...>jeff_foster_dc@...; Sent: Wed, December 22, 2010 7:57:31 PMSubject: Re: MVA....one year prior. Question: So, the question is can significant foraminal narrowing have showed up in a year post trauma. That is a very good question. I have seen a study about osseous degenerative changes showing up 7 years later at a significantly higher rate than the normal population who wasn't in an accident, but I have not seen anything that says a year. Someone else may be up on that and it is not to say it can't happen in the big realm of healing. I would, however, think it is more likely that it was pre-existing narrowing, that gave the person a neck that just couldn't handle the forces in the accident as a "normal" neck would have. The accident is still causative even though the degeneration existed. That would be my justification as accident related IF the intermittent paresthesia was not there before the accident. To really find out, you may have them take a lie detector test, tie 'em down and do water boarding or a few of the other Abrahamson Techniques I learned at that last weekend seminar. In addition, if the paresthesia was there before the accident, and it is now worse....the accident is still causative of the worsening. Anyway, that is my way of thinking. What say you all?? I'm sure there are learned literature scholars that may be up on what is actually out there in regards to your question. Did you do motion films to assess stability at that level?? Don White, RN, DC Canyon Rd Chiropractic & Massage Beaverton, OR 97005 In a message dated 12/22/2010 4:54:46 P.M. Pacific Standard Time, jeff_foster_dc@... writes: Background: I have a patient with an intermittent left-hand paraesthesia (C7 dermatome). She has been getting regular treatments and has recovered/resolved most of her other complaints. Question: Could this accident (classic rearend collision/CADD syndrome)be responsible for a foraminal narrowing at the IVF and then the subsequent hand symptoms? The reason I ask is b/c a recent MRI confirmed these results and the symptoms match the findings. However, reporting to the insurance company has me a bit concerned b/c, to my way of thinking, any osseous changes at the vertebral level are going to be degenerative and likely the result of a lifetime of bad posture, and/or past truama, and NOT something that would appear within a year's time. Can anyone justify these findings as caused by a recent MVA case? Quote
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2010 Report Posted December 22, 2010 THE CLASSIC HAIR THAT BROKE THE CAMEL'S BACK. Pre-existing DJD but asymptomatic. Describes MANY patients. Now add a traumatic destabilization of this area of vulnerability and VOILA! Just do your best to documents the before and after symptoms. If she didn't have the these symptoms before the collision, it would be reasonable to conclude that they are directly related to it. My 2 cents worth, Ann DC MVA....one year prior. Question: Background: I have a patient with an intermittent left-hand paraesthesia (C7 dermatome). She has been getting regular treatments and has recovered/resolved most of her other complaints. Question: Could this accident (classic rearend collision/CADD syndrome)be responsible for a foraminal narrowing at the IVF and then the subsequent hand symptoms? The reason I ask is b/c a recent MRI confirmed these results and the symptoms match the findings. However, reporting to the insurance company has me a bit concerned b/c, to my way of thinking, any osseous changes at the vertebral level are going to be degenerative and likely the result of a lifetime of bad posture, and/or past truama, and NOT something that would appear within a year's time. Can anyone justify these findings as caused by a recent MVA case? Quote
Guest guest Posted December 23, 2010 Report Posted December 23, 2010 What usually happens is that there is underlying DJD that is asymptomatic until trauma causes inflammation and swelling of the joint capsules and narrowing of the IVF from soft-tissue swelling, thereby resulting in radicular symptoms / paresthesias. The DJD, in all medical probability, will also accelerate, but it might be a few years before that is evident. Lyndon McGill, D.C. Salem, Oregon www.SalemSpineClinic.com www.EvolvingDaily.com > It seems most likely that the degeneration is a > pre-existing condition and should be viewed as a > complicating factor. Try to focus on the symptoms before > and after the accident. > > Pretty much what Dr. White said. > > Barrett > > > > > > ________________________________ > From: " MekaAbou@... " <MekaAbou@...> > jeff_foster_dc@...; > Sent: Wed, December 22, 2010 7:57:31 PM > Subject: Re: MVA....one year prior. > Question: > > > So, the question is can significant foraminal narrowing > have showed up in a year post trauma. That is a very > good question. I have seen a study about osseous > degenerative changes showing up 7 years later at a > significantly higher rate than the normal population who > wasn't in an accident, but I have not seen anything that > says a year. Someone else may be up on that and it is not > to say it can't happen in the big realm of healing. > > > I would, however, think it is more likely that it was > pre-existing narrowing, that gave the person a neck that > just couldn't handle the forces in the accident as a > " normal " neck would have. The accident is still causative > even though the degeneration existed. That would be my > justification as accident related IF the intermittent > paresthesia was not there before the accident. To really > find out, you may have them take a lie detector test, tie > 'em down and do water boarding or a few of the other > Abrahamson Techniques I learned at that last weekend > seminar. In addition, if the paresthesia was there before > the accident, and it is now worse....the accident is > still causative of the worsening. Anyway, that is my way > of thinking. > > > What say you all?? I'm sure there are learned literature > scholars that may be up on what is actually out there in > regards to your question. Did you do motion films to > assess stability at that level?? > > Don White, RN, DC > Canyon Rd Chiropractic & Massage > Beaverton, OR 97005 > > In a message dated 12/22/2010 4:54:46 P.M. Pacific > Standard Time, jeff_foster_dc@... writes: > > >Background: I have a patient with an intermittent > left-hand paraesthesia (C7 >dermatome). She has been > getting regular treatments and has >recovered/resolved > most of her other complaints. > > > > >Question: Could this accident (classic rearend > collision/CADD syndrome)be >responsible for a > foraminal narrowing at the IVF and then the subsequent > hand >symptoms? > > > > > >The reason I ask is b/c a recent MRI confirmed these > results and the symptoms >match the findings. However, > reporting to the insurance company has me a bit > >concerned b/c, to my way of thinking, any osseous changes > at the vertebral >level are going to be degenerative > and likely the result of a lifetime of bad >posture, > and/or past truama, and NOT something that would appear > within a >year's time. Can anyone justify these findings > as caused by a recent MVA >case? > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 23, 2010 Report Posted December 23, 2010 Concur. From a persuasion perspective, pre-existing condition which either makes the patient more susceptible to injury, more susceptible to a longer-term recovery, or which is aggravated by trauma, makes the case easier to prove. Those arguments come from the uniform civil jury instructions for previous infirm condition instruction and aggravation, which are pasted below. DAMAGES—PREVIOUS INFIRM CONDITION If you find that the plaintiff had a bodily condition that predisposed [him / her] to be more subject to injury than a person in normal health, nevertheless the defendant would be liable for any and all injuries and damage that may have been suffered by the plaintiff as the result of the negligence of the defendant, even though those injuries, due to the prior condition, may have been greater than those that would have been suffered by another person under the same circumstances. DAMAGES—AGGRAVATION OF PREEXISTINGINJURY OR DISABILITY In the present case the plaintiff has alleged that the injury which [he / she] sustained as the result of the negligence of the defendant aggravated a preexisting [injury / disability] of [his / hers]. In determining the amount of damages, if any, to be awarded the plaintiff in this case, you will allow [him / her] reasonable compensation for the consequences of any such aggravation that you find to have taken place as the result of defendant’s negligence. The recovery should not include damages for the earlier [injury / disability] but only those that are due to its enhancement or aggravation. They’re listed as damages instructions, but I consider them more as causation instructions, i.e. which consequences are caused by the trauma? If it’s a delayed presentation of symptoms with a delay of a year, that’s an uphill fight, even with these instructions, and I would suggest finding some good research on the issue to support you. T. Hill, PC520 SW Sixth Avenue, Suite 1250Portland, OR 97204(503) 227-4330chill@...http://www.portlandinjurylaw.com From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of kelly barrettSent: Wednesday, December 22, 2010 9:59 PMMekaAbou@...; jeff_foster_dc@...; Subject: Re: MVA....one year prior. Question: It seems most likely that the degeneration is a pre-existing condition and should be viewed as a complicating factor. Try to focus on the symptoms before and after the accident. Pretty much what Dr. White said. Barrett From: " MekaAbou@... " <MekaAbou@...>jeff_foster_dc@...; Sent: Wed, December 22, 2010 7:57:31 PMSubject: Re: MVA....one year prior. Question: So, the question is can significant foraminal narrowing have showed up in a year post trauma. That is a very good question. I have seen a study about osseous degenerative changes showing up 7 years later at a significantly higher rate than the normal population who wasn't in an accident, but I have not seen anything that says a year. Someone else may be up on that and it is not to say it can't happen in the big realm of healing. I would, however, think it is more likely that it was pre-existing narrowing, that gave the person a neck that just couldn't handle the forces in the accident as a " normal " neck would have. The accident is still causative even though the degeneration existed. That would be my justification as accident related IF the intermittent paresthesia was not there before the accident. To really find out, you may have them take a lie detector test, tie 'em down and do water boarding or a few of the other Abrahamson Techniques I learned at that last weekend seminar. In addition, if the paresthesia was there before the accident, and it is now worse....the accident is still causative of the worsening. Anyway, that is my way of thinking. What say you all?? I'm sure there are learned literature scholars that may be up on what is actually out there in regards to your question. Did you do motion films to assess stability at that level?? Don White, RN, DCCanyon Rd Chiropractic & MassageBeaverton, OR 97005 In a message dated 12/22/2010 4:54:46 P.M. Pacific Standard Time, jeff_foster_dc@... writes: Background: I have a patient with an intermittent left-hand paraesthesia (C7 dermatome). She has been getting regular treatments and has recovered/resolved most of her other complaints. Question: Could this accident (classic rearend collision/CADD syndrome)be responsible for a foraminal narrowing at the IVF and then the subsequent hand symptoms? The reason I ask is b/c a recent MRI confirmed these results and the symptoms match the findings. However, reporting to the insurance company has me a bit concerned b/c, to my way of thinking, any osseous changes at the vertebral level are going to be degenerative and likely the result of a lifetime of bad posture, and/or past truama, and NOT something that would appear within a year's time. Can anyone justify these findings as caused by a recent MVA case? Quote
Guest guest Posted December 23, 2010 Report Posted December 23, 2010 Seems to me that's where the 'greyness' come in, Ann. The discs at C6/7, L4/5 & 5/1, in my body, are radiographically gone but I have NO symptomatology. Knowing its vulnerability, I do guard against trauma to keep it so. As you say, it would be a complicating factor but not causal. Sunny Sunny Kierstyn, RN DC Fibromyalgia Care Center of Oregon 2677 Willakenzie Road, 7CEugene, Oregon, 97401541- 654-0850; Fx; 541- 654-0834www.drsunnykierstyn.com jeff_foster_dc@...; From: bluepearl2001@... Date: Thu, 23 Dec 2010 01:08:06 -0500Subject: Re: MVA....one year prior. Question: THE CLASSIC HAIR THAT BROKE THE CAMEL'S BACK. Pre-existing DJD but asymptomatic. Describes MANY patients. Now add a traumatic destabilization of this area of vulnerability and VOILA! Just do your best to documents the before and after symptoms. If she didn't have the these symptoms before the collision, it would be reasonable to conclude that they are directly related to it. My 2 cents worth, Ann DC MVA....one year prior. Question: Background: I have a patient with an intermittent left-hand paraesthesia (C7 dermatome). She has been getting regular treatments and has recovered/resolved most of her other complaints. Question: Could this accident (classic rearend collision/CADD syndrome)be responsible for a foraminal narrowing at the IVF and then the subsequent hand symptoms? The reason I ask is b/c a recent MRI confirmed these results and the symptoms match the findings. However, reporting to the insurance company has me a bit concerned b/c, to my way of thinking, any osseous changes at the vertebral level are going to be degenerative and likely the result of a lifetime of bad posture, and/or past truama, and NOT something that would appear within a year's time. Can anyone justify these findings as caused by a recent MVA case? Quote
Guest guest Posted December 23, 2010 Report Posted December 23, 2010 Hi Jeff, First was there any concomitant disc protrusion contributing to the nerve root impingement (foramina narrowing) in addition to the spondylosis? If so then since the patient was (I’m guessing) asymptomatic as per the left sided paresthesia one could say that it is more probable than not that this disc protrusion in an already compromised (degenerative) disc was secondary to the MVA. That this new disc protrusion added to the pre-existing osteophytic development (spondylosis) then caused a sufficient increase in the lateral recess stenosis to now make the individual symptomatic. One “medi-legal” suggestion: I would recommend that in these situations you always include in your initial comprehensive chart note a separate header entitled “Complicating Risk Factors;” And list things that we know from the world literature that will influence a MVA patients prognosis including lower the threshold for injury, slowing the rate of recovery, extending the length of curative treatment, reducing the probability of fully recovering, and that which increases the probably of permanent impairment (injury), and permanent partial disability (activities intolerance, ADL restrictions etc.). In this case some of those risk factors would be 1. Paraesthesia into the left upper extremity. 2. Gender a woman’s head to neck ratio makes them more easily injury than a man who tend to have thicker more muscular necks (that’s necks not heads!), 3. Pre-existing cervical spondylosis. 4. Rear-end collision. 5. It she had immediate symptoms following the crash. 6. Did she have pre-warning of the crash and time to brace herself if no that is a risk factor. 7. Was her head turned at impact….etc.,etc. You get the idea. Point being you need to be out front with these complicating risk factors from the get go and have a conversation with the claims rep as per how this individual was more likely to be injury and will more likely than not take longer to response to your care, care will likely go longer than the average MVA patient and she is more likely to have residuals….. Vern Saboe DC From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of jeff_foster_dcSent: Wednesday, December 22, 2010 4:55 PM Subject: MVA....one year prior. Question: Background: I have a patient with an intermittent left-hand paraesthesia (C7 dermatome). She has been getting regular treatments and has recovered/resolved most of her other complaints. Question: Could this accident (classic rearend collision/CADD syndrome)be responsible for a foraminal narrowing at the IVF and then the subsequent hand symptoms? The reason I ask is b/c a recent MRI confirmed these results and the symptoms match the findings. However, reporting to the insurance company has me a bit concerned b/c, to my way of thinking, any osseous changes at the vertebral level are going to be degenerative and likely the result of a lifetime of bad posture, and/or past truama, and NOT something that would appear within a year's time. Can anyone justify these findings as caused by a recent MVA case? No virus found in this incoming message.Checked by AVG - www.avg.comVersion: 8.5.449 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/3331 - Release Date: 12/22/10 07:34:00 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.