Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

RE: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

I feel for both you and your niece, alas my own family experience is also disappointing. It adds to how important it is that we keep campaigning and speaking up for universal services. Meanwhile, have you also told your niece about netmums. This might at the least help on terms of peer support.Best wishesOn 7 Jan 2010, at 22:25, Village <ljlaw66@...> wrote:

I am a Health Visitor and CPT who 'left' the profession 6 years ago now to persue a a multi agency role in Child Protection. I deliberated hard about leaving health visiting, I was and am passionate about the difference the service can make universally - not only to vulnerable groups. First time mothers (even one's without predefined vulnerabilities...social deprivation etc) aren't born with the confidence to successfully breastfeed, wean well, place baby back to sleep, cope with sleepless nights, adjustment to motherhood etc etc etc.... Health Visiting should be there to be there, advise, support, screen for pnd and essentially HEALTH VISIT.

Recently my niece - a 26 yr old married professional has had her first baby, a sudden birth at 35 weeks whilst she was shopping in London - she lives in a rural county up North. She gave up breast feeding at 2 days because of conflicting advise from midwives (grrrr...) Her HV visited her at home at 7 days??? wondered why she didn't have a red book and left asking my niece to come to clinic in 2 weeks. I saw my niece and beautiful great (!) niece at 16 days. My niece was (not unusually) struggling and knackered, but she didn't know who her HV was, how to contact her, when clinic was, why she had to go to clinic, not to mention struggling with a now windy bottle fed baby with little family support ( I live 2 hours away)

Being concerned I took it upon myself to phone the HV base and highlight that my niece needed some support. I asked if primary visits had changed from 11 days to 7, to which I was asked who I was and why I was phoning. I came clean, said I was calling about my niece but I was also a HV and wanted to just tip the wink that there was a Mum here with a small baby, struggling with wind and who needed some support and HEALTH VISITING. They told me not to worry, things had changed in the last 5 years but they would deal with it. They then phoned my niece, asked if she was unhappy with the service as I had phoned to say she was (?) to which my niece tearfully said she wasn't. The HV said "oh good" and again told her she should come to clinic.

I am furious and embarrassed about the service. I desperately want to phone the local HV manager but daren't as I dont want any more fall out for my niece who is still struggling with a windy bottle fed baby. She hasn't been to clinic and phones me if she wants any advise or support.

Sorry to rant but it is the grass roots of the profession that underpins our status

Village

Use Hotmail to send and receive mail from your different email accounts. Find out how.

Posted

Hi ,

I too feel for you both. I campaign as hard as I can to

shout up about ladies just like your niece.

Sadly I feel much more emphasis is often put on those deemed

to be at a disadvantage in some way, yet like your niece, who on paper ‘has

it all’ are left out in the cold!

All new mothers are vulnerable and should be considered as

such until proven otherwise!

I too was a professional (teacher); nice house; husband;

supportive family and planned meticulously for my baby. In spite of all that my

maternal mental health suffered badly.

I often get Mums approaching me for help and support and I

continue to be so frustrated by services being cut and families left to suffer.

I appreciate how frustrated you are at both a personal and professional

level.

Netmums is a great support for many Mums. So often I get

ladies telling me that one of the biggest aspects which helps them is to know they

are not alone – hearing them say ‘so it’s not just me that

feels stupid, etc.’ is a huge step forward and a great relief.

I had read all the books about birth, motherhood, etc. and

thought I knew it all – how wrong I was!

I am sure you will give her as much support as you can but I

also encourage her to get peer support too in the absence of a health visiting

service which should be there for her.

Meanwhile we will keep on with our campaigning ….

Elaine A Hanzak

www.hanzak.com Tel: +44 (0) 1928 751 235 Mob: +44 (0)

07762 148 183

See my blog at http://elainehanzak.blogspot.com/

https://www.greatvine.com/elaine_hanzak

Inspirational

speaker and author of ‘Eyes without Sparkle – a journey through

postnatal illness’.

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Eyes-without-Sparkle-Journey-Postnatal/dp/185775655X/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8 & s=books & qid=1262600605 & sr=8-1

‘Elaine can be seen

as a partner as she possesses a wealth of information gained not only through

her personal experience, but also through her activities at national and

international arenas – we have to appreciate it’.

Ilona Vindule, a mental health commissioner.

'Thank you so much for your excellent talk to the

Home-Start St Helens volunteers. Your talk was truly inspirational and has

given a valuable insight to the issues around postnatal depression'.

, Scheme Manager.

Posted

,

I am a HV of 17 years standing who is ,these days, ashamed to

call herself a HV. Especially when the impact of service cuts ( or should I say,

targeted quality services), is demonstrably so damaging and sad.

From:

[mailto: ] On Behalf

Of Village

Sent: 07 January 2010 22:25

Subject: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!

I am a Health Visitor and CPT who 'left' the

profession 6 years ago now to persue a a multi agency role in Child Protection.

I deliberated hard about leaving health visiting, I was and am passionate about

the difference the service can make universally - not only to vulnerable

groups. First time mothers (even one's without predefined vulnerabilities...social

deprivation etc) aren't born with the confidence to successfully breastfeed,

wean well, place baby back to sleep, cope with sleepless nights, adjustment

to motherhood etc etc etc.... Health Visiting should

be there to be there, advise, support, screen for pnd and essentially

HEALTH VISIT.

Recently my niece - a 26 yr old married professional has had her first baby, a

sudden birth at 35 weeks whilst she was shopping in London - she lives in

a rural county up North. She gave up breast feeding at 2 days

because of conflicting advise from midwives (grrrr...) Her HV visited her at

home at 7 days??? wondered why she didn't have a red book and left asking my niece

to come to clinic in 2 weeks. I saw my niece and beautiful great

(!) niece at 16 days. My niece was (not unusually) struggling and knackered,

but she didn't know who her HV was, how to contact her, when clinic was,

why she had to go to clinic, not to mention struggling with a now windy bottle

fed baby with little family support ( I live 2 hours away)

Being concerned I took it upon myself to phone the HV base and highlight that

my niece needed some support. I asked if primary visits had changed

from 11 days to 7, to which I was asked who I was and why I was phoning. I came

clean, said I was calling about my niece but I was also a HV and wanted to just

tip the wink that there was a Mum here with a small baby, struggling with wind

and who needed some support and HEALTH VISITING. They told me not to worry,

things had changed in the last 5 years but they would deal with it. They then

phoned my niece, asked if she was unhappy with the service as I had phoned to

say she was (?) to which my niece tearfully said she wasn't. The HV

said " oh good " and again told her she should come to clinic.

I am furious and embarrassed about the service. I desperately want to phone the

local HV manager but daren't as I dont want any more fall out for my niece who

is still struggling with a windy bottle fed baby. She hasn't been to clinic and

phones me if she wants any advise or support.

Sorry to rant but it is the grass roots of the profession that underpins our

status

Village

Use Hotmail to send and receive mail from your different

email accounts. Find out how.

Posted

Dear Like so many others, I recognise your description and could describe similar very unhappy experiences, with my grandchildren and daughter-in-law. I was interested in your capitalisation and use of 'health visiting' as verb, to describe form of practice. My doctorate was completed more than 20 years ago, which was when I first recognised that usage: nurses do nursing, teachers do teaching and health visitors do health visiting. It is particular form of practice, which requires specific skills, such as proactivity, relationship building, respect, caring and the ability to assess individuals' needs in non-judgemental way, then to provide appropriate, knowledgeable and skilled support to prevent the development of a raft of potential problems. That is health visiting, what Robyn described is health visiting, but the 'service' your niece is being invited to use is not health visiting.I wish we could clarify the issues to the extent that they became criteria for assessing the quality and safety of practice, although unfortunately, we are at the point now where so many people have been forced into this new, judemental and dismissive form of activity, that it feels like a losing battle at times. It is one of the reasons we need, badly, to get health visiting back into statute, so we can start to have some control our standards again. So, another reminder to sign the CPHVA's petition, if you haven't already.Very best wishes to you and your family.On 7 Jan 2010, at 22:25, Village wrote:I am a Health Visitor and CPT who 'left' the profession 6 years ago now to persue a a multi agency role in Child Protection. I deliberated hard about leaving health visiting, I was and am passionate about the difference the service can make universally - not only to vulnerable groups. First time mothers (even one's without predefined vulnerabilities...social deprivation etc) aren't born with the confidence to successfully breastfeed, wean well, place baby back to sleep, cope with sleepless nights, adjustment to motherhood etc etc etc.... Health Visiting should be there to be there, advise, support, screen for pnd and essentially HEALTH VISIT. Recently my niece - a 26 yr old married professional has had her first baby, a sudden birth at 35 weeks whilst she was shopping in London - she lives in a rural county up North. She gave up breast feeding at 2 days because of conflicting advise from midwives (grrrr...) Her HV visited her at home at 7 days??? wondered why she didn't have a red book and left asking my niece to come to clinic in 2 weeks. I saw my niece and beautiful great (!) niece at 16 days. My niece was (not unusually) struggling and knackered, but she didn't know who her HV was, how to contact her, when clinic was, why she had to go to clinic, not to mention struggling with a now windy bottle fed baby with little family support ( I live 2 hours away) Being concerned I took it upon myself to phone the HV base and highlight that my niece needed some support. I asked if primary visits had changed from 11 days to 7, to which I was asked who I was and why I was phoning. I came clean, said I was calling about my niece but I was also a HV and wanted to just tip the wink that there was a Mum here with a small baby, struggling with wind and who needed some support and HEALTH VISITING. They told me not to worry, things had changed in the last 5 years but they would deal with it. They then phoned my niece, asked if she was unhappy with the service as I had phoned to say she was (?) to which my niece tearfully said she wasn't. The HV said "oh good" and again told her she should come to clinic. I am furious and embarrassed about the service. I desperately want to phone the local HV manager but daren't as I dont want any more fall out for my niece who is still struggling with a windy bottle fed baby. She hasn't been to clinic and phones me if she wants any advise or support. Sorry to rant but it is the grass roots of the profession that underpins our status Village Use Hotmail to send and receive mail from your different email accounts. Find out how. Cowleysarahcowley183@...http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

Posted

Hi

Returning HV to statue is a brilliant campaign and one I fully support. However

there must be more that we can do to raise our profile alongside this, such as writing to

commissioners, senior management, chief execs, etc with our concerns and raising grievances when they are ignored.

The lack

of finance which impacts not only on the amount of HV's employed but the

training offered is one that this government should be ashamed about. Our trust has had thousands cut from its HV and school nurse budget.

It is sad that with transforming community services comes the threat of

privatisation, unfortunately the message out there is that if we complain too

loudly we will be TUPE'd out to a private organisation. However if we don’t campaign

and raise our profile we wont have much of a service left to fight for!

From: Cowley <sarahcowley183@...> Sent: Friday, 8 January, 2010 20:45:08Subject: Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!

Dear Like so many others, I recognise your description and could describe similar very unhappy experiences, with my grandchildren and daughter-in- law. I was interested in your capitalisation and use of 'health visiting' as verb, to describe form of practice. My doctorate was completed more than 20 years ago, which was when I first recognised that usage: nurses do nursing, teachers do teaching and health visitors do health visiting. It is particular form of practice, which requires specific skills, such as proactivity, relationship building, respect, caring and the ability to assess individuals' needs in non-judgemental way, then to provide appropriate, knowledgeable and skilled support to prevent the development of a raft of potential problems. That is health visiting, what Robyn described is health visiting, but the 'service' your niece is being invited to use is not

health visiting.I wish we could clarify the issues to the extent that they became criteria for assessing the quality and safety of practice, although unfortunately, we are at the point now where so many people have been forced into this new, judemental and dismissive form of activity, that it feels like a losing battle at times. It is one of the reasons we need, badly, to get health visiting back into statute, so we can start to have some control our standards again. So, another reminder to sign the CPHVA's petition, if you haven't already.Very best wishes to you and your family.On 7 Jan 2010, at 22:25, Village wrote:I am a Health Visitor and CPT who 'left' the profession 6 years ago now to persue a a multi agency role in Child Protection. I deliberated hard about leaving health visiting, I was and am passionate about the difference the service can make universally - not only to vulnerable groups. First time mothers (even one's without predefined vulnerabilities. ..social deprivation etc) aren't born with the confidence to successfully breastfeed, wean well, place baby back to sleep, cope with sleepless nights, adjustment to motherhood etc etc etc.... Health Visiting should be there to be there, advise, support,

screen for pnd and essentially HEALTH VISIT. Recently my niece - a 26 yr old married professional has had her first baby, a sudden birth at 35 weeks whilst she was shopping in London - she lives in a rural county up North. She gave up breast feeding at 2 days because of conflicting advise from midwives (grrrr...) Her HV visited her at home at 7 days??? wondered why she didn't have a red book and left asking my niece to come to clinic in 2 weeks. I saw my niece and beautiful great (!) niece at 16 days. My niece was (not unusually) struggling and knackered, but she didn't know who her HV was, how to contact her, when clinic was, why she had to go to clinic, not to mention struggling with a now windy bottle fed baby with little family support ( I live 2 hours away) Being concerned I took it upon myself to phone the HV base and highlight

that my niece needed some support. I asked if primary visits had changed from 11 days to 7, to which I was asked who I was and why I was phoning. I came clean, said I was calling about my niece but I was also a HV and wanted to just tip the wink that there was a Mum here with a small baby, struggling with wind and who needed some support and HEALTH VISITING. They told me not to worry, things had changed in the last 5 years but they would deal with it. They then phoned my niece, asked if she was unhappy with the service as I had phoned to say she was (?) to which my niece tearfully said she wasn't. The HV said "oh good" and again told her she should come to clinic. I am furious and embarrassed about the service. I desperately want to phone the local HV manager but daren't as I dont want any more fall out for my niece who is still struggling with a windy bottle fed baby. She hasn't been to clinic and phones me if she wants

any advise or support. Sorry to rant but it is the grass roots of the profession that underpins our status Village Use Hotmail to send and receive mail from your different email accounts. Find out how. Cowleysarahcowley183@ btinternet. comhttp://myprofile. cos.com/S124021C On

Posted

Dear

How sad this is! Sounds like a real let down. We've always had

hopeless practitioners, as has every other trade. Any decent MW or

HV would by angry and disappointed about the way this mother's needs

were neglected and by the response of the health visitor concerned.

If this happens to educated and articulate women, what's it like for

the less advantaged?

I think the key thing is that this is poor practice - an uncaring

response to a deficient service. It's just useless to clients and it

suggests either a poorly trained practitioner who's been taught to

deliver a low standard of service without any reference to the

knowledge base which should inform her practice, or alternatively, a

failing member of a profession who should be investigated and

informed that this sort of behaviour doesn't meet adequate standards.

I would guess that there isn't such a thing as a 'health visitor

manager' in that area for you to speak to. If there were, s/he's not

on top of her job if s/he's allowing this to occur. It's more likely

that it's some ill informed person from another background (lay

management or unrelated professional) who's simply not up to their

responsibilities and hasn't bothered to look at the standard of

services, professional education or practice on their patch. Clinic

based services can never meet the full range of needs of mothers and

small children, even if they're lucky enough to have access to

transport.

You might guess at this point that I don't like laissez faire

managers who don't bother with the standards of care the public is

receiving. It's just that I've seen so many managers allowing things

to slide into inadequacy such as you describe. 's right. How

on earth a universal primary care service can be 'targeted', I can't

imagine. Just a euphemism for rationing, IMO.

Good luck to your neice and her baby. Hope things settle down soon.

H

< >

From: " Noy " <julia@...>

Date sent: Fri, 8 Jan 2010 19:49:33 -0000

Subject: RE: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!

Send reply to:

,

I am a HV of 17 years standing who is ,these days, ashamed to call

herself a HV. Especially when the impact of service cuts ( or should

I say, targeted quality services), is demonstrably so damaging and

sad.

From: [mailto:SENATE-

HVSN ] On Behalf Of Village

Sent: 07 January 2010 22:25

Subject: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!

I am a Health Visitor and CPT who 'left' the profession 6 years ago

now to persue a a multi agency role in Child Protection. I

deliberated hard about leaving health visiting, I was and am

passionate about the difference the service can make universally -

not only to vulnerable groups. First time mothers (even one's without

predefined vulnerabilities...social deprivation etc) aren't born with

the confidence to successfully breastfeed, wean well, place baby back

to sleep, cope with sleepless nights, adjustment tomotherhoodetc

etc etc....HealthVisitingshould be there to be there,advise,

support, screen for pnd andessentially HEALTH VISIT.

Recently my niece - a 26 yr old married professional has had her

first baby, a sudden birth at 35 weeks whilst she was shopping in

London - shelives in a rural county up North.She gave up breast

feeding at 2 days because of conflicting advise from midwives

(grrrr...) Her HV visited her at home at 7 days??? wondered why she

didn't have a red book and left asking my niece to come to clinic in

2 weeks. Isaw my niece andbeautifulgreat (!) niece at 16 days. My

niece was (not unusually) struggling and knackered, but shedidn't

know who her HV was, how to contact her, when clinic was, why she had

to go to clinic, not to mention struggling with a now windy bottle

fed baby withlittle family support ( I live 2 hours away)

Being concerned I took it upon myself to phone the HV base and

highlight that my nieceneeded some support. Iasked if primary

visits had changed from 11 days to 7, to which I was asked who I was

and why I was phoning. I came clean, said I was calling about my

niece but I was also a HV and wanted to just tip the wink that there

was a Mum here with a small baby, struggling with wind and who needed

some support and HEALTH VISITING. They told me not to worry, things

had changed in the last 5 years but they would deal with it. They

then phoned my niece, asked if she was unhappy with the service as I

had phoned to say she was (?)to which my niece tearfully saidshe

wasn't. The HV said " oh good " and again told her she should come to

clinic.

I am furious and embarrassed about the service. I desperately want to

phone the local HV manager but daren't as I dont want any more fall

out for my niece who is still struggling with a windy bottle fed

baby. She hasn't been to clinic and phones me if she wants any advise

or support.

Sorry to rant but it is the grass roots of the profession that

underpins our status

Village

Use Hotmail to send and receive mail from your different email

accounts. Find out how.

Posted

Hi I am sure you are right, but the question is, what can we do? One of the five key areas that we looked at in the UKPHA regenerate health visiting project, was how and where health visitors should be employed in future, with all the changes going on. The key thing is to have provider unit that can actually advocate for the service, get proper commissions and set clear criteria for the quality and safety of the service.. We made list of 'key attributes' required by a provider unit, and realised that they are not present in many current NHS providers. So, how can we change that? Sorry; I tripped and broke my wrist last week, so slow left-hand typing here: I attach the full report in case anyone missed it last time around. Ideas for taking forward any of the recommendations welcomebest wishes On 8 Jan 2010, at 23:42, SARAH FORSYTH wrote:Hi Returning HV to statue is a brilliant campaign and one I fully support. However there must be more that we can do to raise our profile alongside this, such as writing to commissioners, senior management, chief execs, etc with our concerns and raising grievances when they are ignored. The lack of finance which impacts not only on the amount of HV's employed but the training offered is one that this government should be ashamed about. Our trust has had thousands cut from its HV and school nurse budget.It is sad that with transforming community services comes the threat of privatisation, unfortunately the message out there is that if we complain too loudly we will be TUPE'd out to a private organisation. However if we don’t campaign and raise our profile we wont have much of a service left to fight for!From: Cowley <sarahcowley183btinternet> Sent: Friday, 8 January, 2010 20:45:08Subject: Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not! Dear Like so many others, I recognise your description and could describe similar very unhappy experiences, with my grandchildren and daughter-in- law. I was interested in your capitalisation and use of 'health visiting' as verb, to describe form of practice. My doctorate was completed more than 20 years ago, which was when I first recognised that usage: nurses do nursing, teachers do teaching and health visitors do health visiting. It is particular form of practice, which requires specific skills, such as proactivity, relationship building, respect, caring and the ability to assess individuals' needs in non-judgemental way, then to provide appropriate, knowledgeable and skilled support to prevent the development of a raft of potential problems. That is health visiting, what Robyn described is health visiting, but the 'service' your niece is being invited to use is not health visiting.I wish we could clarify the issues to the extent that they became criteria for assessing the quality and safety of practice, although unfortunately, we are at the point now where so many people have been forced into this new, judemental and dismissive form of activity, that it feels like a losing battle at times. It is one of the reasons we need, badly, to get health visiting back into statute, so we can start to have some control our standards again. So, another reminder to sign the CPHVA's petition, if you haven't already.Very best wishes to you and your family.On 7 Jan 2010, at 22:25, Village wrote:I am a Health Visitor and CPT who 'left' the profession 6 years ago now to persue a a multi agency role in Child Protection. I deliberated hard about leaving health visiting, I was and am passionate about the difference the service can make universally - not only to vulnerable groups. First time mothers (even one's without predefined vulnerabilities. ..social deprivation etc) aren't born with the confidence to successfully breastfeed, wean well, place baby back to sleep, cope with sleepless nights, adjustment to motherhood etc etc etc.... Health Visiting should be there to be there, advise, support, screen for pnd and essentially HEALTH VISIT. Recently my niece - a 26 yr old married professional has had her first baby, a sudden birth at 35 weeks whilst she was shopping in London - she lives in a rural county up North. She gave up breast feeding at 2 days because of conflicting advise from midwives (grrrr...) Her HV visited her at home at 7 days??? wondered why she didn't have a red book and left asking my niece to come to clinic in 2 weeks. I saw my niece and beautiful great (!) niece at 16 days. My niece was (not unusually) struggling and knackered, but she didn't know who her HV was, how to contact her, when clinic was, why she had to go to clinic, not to mention struggling with a now windy bottle fed baby with little family support ( I live 2 hours away) Being concerned I took it upon myself to phone the HV base and highlight that my niece needed some support. I asked if primary visits had changed from 11 days to 7, to which I was asked who I was and why I was phoning. I came clean, said I was calling about my niece but I was also a HV and wanted to just tip the wink that there was a Mum here with a small baby, struggling with wind and who needed some support and HEALTH VISITING. They told me not to worry, things had changed in the last 5 years but they would deal with it. They then phoned my niece, asked if she was unhappy with the service as I had phoned to say she was (?) to which my niece tearfully said she wasn't. The HV said "oh good" and again told her she should come to clinic. I am furious and embarrassed about the service. I desperately want to phone the local HV manager but daren't as I dont want any more fall out for my niece who is still struggling with a windy bottle fed baby. She hasn't been to clinic and phones me if she wants any advise or support. Sorry to rant but it is the grass roots of the profession that underpins our status Village Use Hotmail to send and receive mail from your different email accounts. Find out how. Cowleysarahcowley183@ btinternet. comhttp://myprofile. cos.com/S124021C On Cowleysarahcowley183@...http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

1 of 1 File(s)

health visiting matters final report.pdf

Posted

Thanks Maggie and all who have sent good wishes. One thought about a way to improve health visiting services: could we emulate the maternity services committees that exist up and down the country? They are very powerful organisations, and might help to make cler what is, or is not, acceptable in services. Might Netmums have a role here?On 11 Jan 2010, at 00:17, Maggie Fisher wrote:So sorry to hear about your wrist , wishing you a speedy recovery back to 2 handedness Best wishesMaggie Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!>>> Dear >> Like so many others, I recognise your description and could describe > similar very unhappy experiences, with my grandchildren and daughter- > in- law.>> I was interested in your capitalisation and use of 'health visiting' > as verb, to describe form of practice. My doctorate was completed > more than 20 years ago, which was when I first recognised that > usage: nurses do nursing, teachers do teaching and health visitors > do health visiting. It is particular form of practice, which > requires specific skills, such as proactivity, relationship > building, respect, caring and the ability to assess individuals' > needs in non-judgemental way, then to provide appropriate, > knowledgeable and skilled support to prevent the development of a > raft of potential problems. That is health visiting, what Robyn > described is health visiting, but the 'service' your niece is being > invited to use is not health visiting.>> I wish we could clarify the issues to the extent that they became > criteria for assessing the quality and safety of practice, although > unfortunately, we are at the point now where so many people have > been forced into this new, judemental and dismissive form of > activity, that it feels like a losing battle at times. It is one > of the reasons we need, badly, to get health visiting back into > statute, so we can start to have some control our standards again. > So, another reminder to sign the CPHVA's petition, if you haven't > already.>> Very best wishes to you and your family.>> >>> On 7 Jan 2010, at 22:25, Village wrote:>>> I am a Health Visitor and CPT who 'left' the profession 6 years ago >> now to persue a a multi agency role in Child Protection. I >> deliberated hard about leaving health visiting, I was and am >> passionate about the difference the service can make universally - >> not only to vulnerable groups. First time mothers (even one's >> without predefined vulnerabilities. ..social deprivation etc) >> aren't born with the confidence to successfully breastfeed, wean >> well, place baby back to sleep, cope with sleepless nights, >> adjustment to motherhood etc etc etc.... Health Visiting should be >> there to be there, advise, support, screen for pnd and essentially >> HEALTH VISIT.>>>> Recently my niece - a 26 yr old married professional has had her >> first baby, a sudden birth at 35 weeks whilst she was shopping in >> London - she lives in a rural county up North. She gave up breast >> feeding at 2 days because of conflicting advise from midwives >> (grrrr...) Her HV visited her at home at 7 days??? wondered why she >> didn't have a red book and left asking my niece to come to clinic >> in 2 weeks. I saw my niece and beautiful great (!) niece at 16 >> days. My niece was (not unusually) struggling and knackered, but >> she didn't know who her HV was, how to contact her, when clinic >> was, why she had to go to clinic, not to mention struggling with a >> now windy bottle fed baby with little family support ( I live 2 >> hours away)>>>> Being concerned I took it upon myself to phone the HV base and >> highlight that my niece needed some support. I asked if primary >> visits had changed from 11 days to 7, to which I was asked who I >> was and why I was phoning. I came clean, said I was calling about >> my niece but I was also a HV and wanted to just tip the wink that >> there was a Mum here with a small baby, struggling with wind and >> who needed some support and HEALTH VISITING. They told me not to >> worry, things had changed in the last 5 years but they would deal >> with it. They then phoned my niece, asked if she was unhappy with >> the service as I had phoned to say she was (?) to which my niece >> tearfully said she wasn't. The HV said "oh good" and again told her >> she should come to clinic.>>>> I am furious and embarrassed about the service. I desperately want >> to phone the local HV manager but daren't as I dont want any more >> fall out for my niece who is still struggling with a windy bottle >> fed baby. She hasn't been to clinic and phones me if she wants any >> advise or support.>>>> Sorry to rant but it is the grass roots of the profession that >> underpins our status>>>> Village>>>>>>>>>>>> Use Hotmail to send and receive mail from your different email >> accounts. Find out how.>>>> Cowley> sarahcowley183@ btinternet. com> http://myprofile. cos.com/S124021C On>>>>>> Cowleysarahcowley183btinternethttp://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn Cowleysarahcowley183@...http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

Posted

Hello and SENATE

anything to standardise practice is welcome. It seems the idiosyncracy of

individual management is

the problem. Do maternity services committees address this? Who funds them?

Definitely supporting health visiting return to statute.

>>> Cowley <sarahcowley183@...> 11/01/10 11:41 AM >>>

Thanks Maggie and all who have sent good wishes.

One thought about a way to improve health visiting services: could we

emulate the maternity services committees that exist up and down the

country? They are very powerful organisations, and might help to make

cler what is, or is not, acceptable in services. Might Netmums have a

role here?

On 11 Jan 2010, at 00:17, Maggie Fisher wrote:

>

> So sorry to hear about your wrist , wishing you a speedy

> recovery back to 2 handedness

> Best wishes

> Maggie

> Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!

> >

> >

> > Dear

> >

> > Like so many others, I recognise your description and could describe

> > similar very unhappy experiences, with my grandchildren and

> daughter-

> > in- law.

> >

> > I was interested in your capitalisation and use of 'health visiting'

> > as verb, to describe form of practice. My doctorate was completed

> > more than 20 years ago, which was when I first recognised that

> > usage: nurses do nursing, teachers do teaching and health visitors

> > do health visiting. It is particular form of practice, which

> > requires specific skills, such as proactivity, relationship

> > building, respect, caring and the ability to assess individuals'

> > needs in non-judgemental way, then to provide appropriate,

> > knowledgeable and skilled support to prevent the development of a

> > raft of potential problems. That is health visiting, what Robyn

> > described is health visiting, but the 'service' your niece is being

> > invited to use is not health visiting.

> >

> > I wish we could clarify the issues to the extent that they became

> > criteria for assessing the quality and safety of practice, although

> > unfortunately, we are at the point now where so many people have

> > been forced into this new, judemental and dismissive form of

> > activity, that it feels like a losing battle at times. It is one

> > of the reasons we need, badly, to get health visiting back into

> > statute, so we can start to have some control our standards again.

> > So, another reminder to sign the CPHVA's petition, if you haven't

> > already.

> >

> > Very best wishes to you and your family.

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > On 7 Jan 2010, at 22:25, Village wrote:

> >

> >> I am a Health Visitor and CPT who 'left' the profession 6 years ago

> >> now to persue a a multi agency role in Child Protection. I

> >> deliberated hard about leaving health visiting, I was and am

> >> passionate about the difference the service can make universally -

> >> not only to vulnerable groups. First time mothers (even one's

> >> without predefined vulnerabilities. ..social deprivation etc)

> >> aren't born with the confidence to successfully breast

feed, wean

> >> well, place baby back to sleep, cope wi> >> adjustment to motherhood etc

etc etc.... Health Visiting should be

> >> there to be there, advise, support, screen for pnd and essentially

> >> HEALTH VISIT.

> >>

> >> Recently my niece - a 26 yr old married professional has had her

> >> first baby, a sudden birth at 35 weeks whilst she was shopping in

> >> London - she lives in a rural county up North. She gave up breast

> >> feeding at 2 days because of conflicting advise from midwives

> >> (grrrr...) Her HV visited her at home at 7 days??? wondered why she

> >> didn't have a red book and left asking my niece to come to clinic

> >> in 2 weeks. I saw my niece and beautiful great (!) niece at 16

> >> days. My niece was (not unusually) struggling and knackered, but

> >> she didn't know who her HV was, how to contact her, when clinic

> >> was, why she had to go to clinic, not to mention struggling with a

> >> now windy bottle fed baby with little family support ( I live 2

> >> hours away)

> >>

> >> Being concerned I took it upon myself to phone the HV base and

> >> highlight that my niece needed some support. I asked if primary

> >> visits had changed from 11 days to 7, to which I was asked who I

> >> was and why I was phoning. I came clean, said I was calling about

> >> my niece but I was also a HV and wanted to just tip the wink that

> >> there was a Mum here with a small baby, struggling with wind and

> >> who needed some support and HEALTH VISITING. They told me not to

> >> worry, things had changed in the last 5 years but they would deal

> >> with it. They then phoned my niece, asked if she was unhappy with

> >> the service as I had phoned to say she was (?) to which my niece

> >> tearfully said she wasn't. The HV said " oh good " and again told her

> >> she should come to clinic.

> >>

> >> I am furious and embarrassed about the service. I desperately want

> >> to phone the local HV manager but daren't as I dont want any more

> >> fall out for my niece who is still struggling with a windy bottle

> >> fed baby. She hasn't been to clinic and phones me if she wants any

> >> advise or support.

> >>

> >> Sorry to rant but it is the grass roots of the profession that

> >> underpins our status

> >>

> >> Village

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >>

> >> Use Hotmail to send and receive mail from your different email

> >> accounts. Find out how.

> >>

> >

> > Cowley

> > sarahcowley183@ btinternet. com

> > http://myprofile. cos.com/S124021C On

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

>

> Cowley

> sarahcowley183@...

> http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

>

>

>

>

>

Cowley

sarahcowley183@...

http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

Posted

Dear All

just for information, this organisation came up on another information/web group and apparently reported they have been having talks with the UK opposition leader.

Its really just to be aware of what is out there and who is lobbying what, especially given the changes in service provisions, commissioning and developments in general.

http://nursesforreform.com/

regards

From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of ColesSent: 12 January 2010 10:52 Subject: Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!

Hello and SENATEanything to standardise practice is welcome. It seems the idiosyncracy of individual management isthe problem. Do maternity services committees address this? Who funds them?Definitely supporting health visiting return to statute.>>> Cowley <sarahcowley183btinternet> 11/01/10 11:41 AM >>>Thanks Maggie and all who have sent good wishes.One thought about a way to improve health visiting services: could we emulate the maternity services committees that exist up and down the country? They are very powerful organisations, and might help to make cler what is, or is not, acceptable in services. Might Netmums have a role here?On 11 Jan 2010, at 00:17, Maggie Fisher wrote:>> So sorry to hear about your wrist , wishing you a speedy > recovery back to 2 handedness> Best wishes> Maggie> Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!> >> >> > Dear > >> > Like so many others, I recognise your description and could describe> > similar very unhappy experiences, with my grandchildren and > daughter-> > in- law.> >> > I was interested in your capitalisation and use of 'health visiting'> > as verb, to describe form of practice. My doctorate was completed> > more than 20 years ago, which was when I first recognised that> > usage: nurses do nursing, teachers do teaching and health visitors> > do health visiting. It is particular form of practice, which> > requires specific skills, such as proactivity, relationship> > building, respect, caring and the ability to assess individuals'> > needs in non-judgemental way, then to provide appropriate,> > knowledgeable and skilled support to prevent the development of a> > raft of potential problems. That is health visiting, what Robyn> > described is health visiting, but the 'service' your niece is being> > invited to use is not health visiting.> >> > I wish we could clarify the issues to the extent that they became> > criteria for assessing the quality and safety of practice, although> > unfortunately, we are at the point now where so many people have> > been forced into this new, judemental and dismissive form of> > activity, that it feels like a losing battle at times. It is one> > of the reasons we need, badly, to get health visiting back into> > statute, so we can start to have some control our standards again.> > So, another reminder to sign the CPHVA's petition, if you haven't> > already.> >> > Very best wishes to you and your family.> >> > > >> >> > On 7 Jan 2010, at 22:25, Village wrote:> >> >> I am a Health Visitor and CPT who 'left' the profession 6 years ago> >> now to persue a a multi agency role in Child Protection. I> >> deliberated hard about leaving health visiting, I was and am> >> passionate about the difference the service can make universally -> >> not only to vulnerable groups. First time mothers (even one's> >> without predefined vulnerabilities. ..social deprivation etc)> >> aren't born with the confidence to successfully breastfeed, wean> >> well, place baby back to sleep, cope wi> >> adjustment to motherhood etc etc etc.... Health Visiting should be> >> there to be there, advise, support, screen for pnd and essentially> >> HEALTH VISIT.> >>> >> Recently my niece - a 26 yr old married professional has had her> >> first baby, a sudden birth at 35 weeks whilst she was shopping in> >> London - she lives in a rural county up North. She gave up breast> >> feeding at 2 days because of conflicting advise from midwives> >> (grrrr...) Her HV visited her at home at 7 days??? wondered why she> >> didn't have a red book and left asking my niece to come to clinic> >> in 2 weeks. I saw my niece and beautiful great (!) niece at 16> >> days. My niece was (not unusually) struggling and knackered, but> >> she didn't know who her HV was, how to contact her, when clinic> >> was, why she had to go to clinic, not to mention struggling with a> >> now windy bottle fed baby with little family support ( I live 2> >> hours away)> >>> >> Being concerned I took it upon myself to phone the HV base and> >> highlight that my niece needed some support. I asked if primary> >> visits had changed from 11 days to 7, to which I was asked who I> >> was and why I was phoning. I came clean, said I was calling about> >> my niece but I was also a HV and wanted to just tip the wink that> >> there was a Mum here with a small baby, struggling with wind and> >> who needed some support and HEALTH VISITING. They told me not to> >> worry, things had changed in the last 5 years but they would deal> >> with it. They then phoned my niece, asked if she was unhappy with> >> the service as I had phoned to say she was (?) to which my niece> >> tearfully said she wasn't. The HV said "oh good" and again told her> >> she should come to clinic.> >>> >> I am furious and embarrassed about the service. I desperately want> >> to phone the local HV manager but daren't as I dont want any more> >> fall out for my niece who is still struggling with a windy bottle> >> fed baby. She hasn't been to clinic and phones me if she wants any> >> advise or support.> >>> >> Sorry to rant but it is the grass roots of the profession that> >> underpins our status> >>> >> Village> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >> Use Hotmail to send and receive mail from your different email> >> accounts. Find out how.> >>> >> > Cowley> > sarahcowley183@ btinternet. com> > http://myprofile. cos.com/S124021C On> >> >> >> >> >> >>> Cowley> sarahcowley183btinternet> http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn>>>>> Cowleysarahcowley183btinternethttp://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

University Campus Suffolk is one the UK’s newest higher education institutions. The main campus is located in Ipswich with centres in Bury St Edmunds, Great Yarmouth, Lowestoft and Otley. For further details on courses, open days or general information visit www.ucs.ac.uk

This email is confidential and may be privileged. If you are not the intended recipient please accept our apologies. Please do not disclose, copy, or distribute information in this email nor take any action in reliance on its contents: to do so is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful. Please inform us that this message has gone astray before deleting it. Thank you for your co-operation.

University Campus Suffolk (UCS) is the trading name of University Campus Suffolk Ltd, a company registered in England & Wales, registered number 5078498, registered office Waterfront Building, Neptune Quay, Ipswich, IP4 1QJ.

Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail.

Posted

Scary stuff! Thanks for highlighting this, . It shows the head of steam that can be built up by a sustained campaign, and in this instance (far right, anti-NHS and so-called 'socialised medicine') it is clear why they are speaking to opposition parties, not governments. I guess there is a warning there, to avoid being seen as the 'radical fringe,' although this group has clearly managed to get into some pretty mainstream places.best wishes On 12 Jan 2010, at 10:58, Fogarty wrote:Dear Alljust for information, this organisation came up on another information/web group and apparently reported they have been having talks with the UK opposition leader.Its really just to be aware of what is out there and who is lobbying what, especially given the changes in service provisions, commissioning and developments in general.http://nursesforreform.com/ regardsFrom: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of ColesSent: 12 January 2010 10:52 Subject: Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not! Hello and SENATEanything to standardise practice is welcome. It seems the idiosyncracy of individual management isthe problem. Do maternity services committees address this? Who funds them?Definitely supporting health visiting return to statute.>>> Cowley <sarahcowley183btinternet> 11/01/10 11:41 AM >>>Thanks Maggie and all who have sent good wishes.One thought about a way to improve health visiting services: could we emulate the maternity services committees that exist up and down the country? They are very powerful organisations, and might help to make cler what is, or is not, acceptable in services. Might Netmums have a role here?On 11 Jan 2010, at 00:17, Maggie Fisher wrote:>> So sorry to hear about your wrist , wishing you a speedy > recovery back to 2 handedness> Best wishes> Maggie> Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!> >> >> > Dear > >> > Like so many others, I recognise your description and could describe> > similar very unhappy experiences, with my grandchildren and > daughter-> > in- law.> >> > I was interested in your capitalisation and use of 'health visiting'> > as verb, to describe form of practice. My doctorate was completed> > more than 20 years ago, which was when I first recognised that> > usage: nurses do nursing, teachers do teaching and health visitors> > do health visiting. It is particular form of practice, which> > requires specific skills, such as proactivity, relationship> > building, respect, caring and the ability to assess individuals'> > needs in non-judgemental way, then to provide appropriate,> > knowledgeable and skilled support to prevent the development of a> > raft of potential problems. That is health visiting, what Robyn> > described is health visiting, but the 'service' your niece is being> > invited to use is not health visiting.> >> > I wish we could clarify the issues to the extent that they became> > criteria for assessing the quality and safety of practice, although> > unfortunately, we are at the point now where so many people have> > been forced into this new, judemental and dismissive form of> > activity, that it feels like a losing battle at times. It is one> > of the reasons we need, badly, to get health visiting back into> > statute, so we can start to have some control our standards again.> > So, another reminder to sign the CPHVA's petition, if you haven't> > already.> >> > Very best wishes to you and your family.> >> > > >> >> > On 7 Jan 2010, at 22:25, Village wrote:> >> >> I am a Health Visitor and CPT who 'left' the profession 6 years ago> >> now to persue a a multi agency role in Child Protection. I> >> deliberated hard about leaving health visiting, I was and am> >> passionate about the difference the service can make universally -> >> not only to vulnerable groups. First time mothers (even one's> >> without predefined vulnerabilities. ..social deprivation etc)> >> aren't born with the confidence to successfully breastfeed, wean> >> well, place baby back to sleep, cope wi> >> adjustment to motherhood etc etc etc.... Health Visiting should be> >> there to be there, advise, support, screen for pnd and essentially> >> HEALTH VISIT.> >>> >> Recently my niece - a 26 yr old married professional has had her> >> first baby, a sudden birth at 35 weeks whilst she was shopping in> >> London - she lives in a rural county up North. She gave up breast> >> feeding at 2 days because of conflicting advise from midwives> >> (grrrr...) Her HV visited her at home at 7 days??? wondered why she> >> didn't have a red book and left asking my niece to come to clinic> >> in 2 weeks. I saw my niece and beautiful great (!) niece at 16> >> days. My niece was (not unusually) struggling and knackered, but> >> she didn't know who her HV was, how to contact her, when clinic> >> was, why she had to go to clinic, not to mention struggling with a> >> now windy bottle fed baby with little family support ( I live 2> >> hours away)> >>> >> Being concerned I took it upon myself to phone the HV base and> >> highlight that my niece needed some support. I asked if primary> >> visits had changed from 11 days to 7, to which I was asked who I> >> was and why I was phoning. I came clean, said I was calling about> >> my niece but I was also a HV and wanted to just tip the wink that> >> there was a Mum here with a small baby, struggling with wind and> >> who needed some support and HEALTH VISITING. They told me not to> >> worry, things had changed in the last 5 years but they would deal> >> with it. They then phoned my niece, asked if she was unhappy with> >> the service as I had phoned to say she was (?) to which my niece> >> tearfully said she wasn't. The HV said "oh good" and again told her> >> she should come to clinic.> >>> >> I am furious and embarrassed about the service. I desperately want> >> to phone the local HV manager but daren't as I dont want any more> >> fall out for my niece who is still struggling with a windy bottle> >> fed baby. She hasn't been to clinic and phones me if she wants any> >> advise or support.> >>> >> Sorry to rant but it is the grass roots of the profession that> >> underpins our status> >>> >> Village> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >> Use Hotmail to send and receive mail from your different email> >> accounts. Find out how.> >>> >> > Cowley> > sarahcowley183@ btinternet. com> > http://myprofile. cos.com/S124021C On> >> >> >> >> >> >>> Cowley> sarahcowley183btinternet> http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn>>>>> Cowleysarahcowley183btinternethttp://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COnUniversity Campus Suffolk is one the UK’s newest higher education institutions. The main campus is located in Ipswich with centres in Bury St Edmunds, Great Yarmouth, Lowestoft and Otley. For further details on courses, open days or general information visit www.ucs.ac.ukThis email is confidential and may be privileged. If you are not the intended recipient please accept our apologies. Please do not disclose, copy, or distribute information in this email nor take any action in reliance on its contents: to do so is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful. Please inform us that this message has gone astray before deleting it. Thank you for your co-operation.University Campus Suffolk (UCS) is the trading name of University Campus Suffolk Ltd, a company registered in England & Wales, registered number 5078498, registered office Waterfront Building, Neptune Quay, Ipswich, IP4 1QJ.Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail. Cowleysarahcowley183@...http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

Posted

Diane, was responding to Fogarty, who drew our attention to the link below. best wishesOn 12 Jan 2010, at 10:58, Fogarty wrote:Dear Alljust for information, this organisation came up on another information/web group and apparently reported they have been having talks with the UK opposition leader.Its really just to be aware of what is out there and who is lobbying what, especially given the changes in service provisions, commissioning and developments in general.http://nursesforreform.com/ regards Cowleysarahcowley183@...http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

Posted

Dear ,

Thank you ever so much. And I have been meaning to write with sympathy for your broken wrist. What a nuisance. And do hope it repairs quickly!

I do have some insights about the two publications cited by the Nurses for Reform group. Will come back to Senate a little later.

All v best, Diane

Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!

Diane, was responding to Fogarty, who drew our attention to the link below. best wishes

On 12 Jan 2010, at 10:58, Fogarty wrote:

Dear All

just for information, this organisation came up on another information/web group and apparently reported they have been having talks with the UK opposition leader.

Its really just to be aware of what is out there and who is lobbying what, especially given the changes in service provisions, commissioning and developments in general.

http://nursesforreform.com/

regards

Cowley

sarahcowley183btinternet

http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

Posted

Dear ,

I'm a bit out of "synch" by responding to the information from the United States. But.......

has sent me her scholarly work on the USA (2005) and it is excellent. I am talking to Healther separately -- in order not to produce long essays on Senate.

But, there are just two insights I meant to send to Senate quickly about the Nurses For Reform group.

First, the reference to the Washington Times and then to the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research give us a quick understanding of the political context and belief system of the Nurses for Reform group.

These two sources are spokes-persons for the neo-conservative position that put W Bush in office. They argue the rights of the individual over the social context and they refer to any health system that has what Americans refer to as a "welfare" component -- in terms of "left wing" and "proto-communist". They are seriously biased.

The point here is that both take the position that individual competition is argued to be the best way to organise health care. These are the investors in the health insurance companies and they are explicit about the fear that their investments would drop in value if the insurance companies were "controlled" by government.

That is a position that roughly half the American population holds. But that half is also the wealthiest.

I am also concerned that suggestions that "European" equals "welfare state" and "American" equals "free enterprise. In fact, every single country has a different health care system. And it is how the individual histories are modified and developed that is of interest. We can learn from others. But not if we pretend that there are simple systems.

The current legislation for health reform in the United States runs to about 2,500 pages and progress is complex and gradual anad is not simple to describe. But it is the determination to break the status quo that matters, I think.

Sorry, I did "run on a bit".

Thanks, , for the opportunity to talk about this....................

My advice is to investigate the sources of arguments............I would suggest that the Washington Post (not the Washington Times) is the paper to follow here and ignore the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research (it is a "front" for the Republican Party at its most radically right wing).

In other words, we need to know the intellectual base and the "objectivity of analysis" in our references.

All v good wishes,

Diane

Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!

Diane, was responding to Fogarty, who drew our attention to the link below. best wishes

On 12 Jan 2010, at 10:58, Fogarty wrote:

Dear All

just for information, this organisation came up on another information/web group and apparently reported they have been having talks with the UK opposition leader.

Its really just to be aware of what is out there and who is lobbying what, especially given the changes in service provisions, commissioning and developments in general.

http://nursesforreform.com/

regards

Cowley

sarahcowley183btinternet

http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

Posted

Hi DianeThanks for giving us the benefit of your knowledge and wisdom here. It always seems important to understand where other people are coming from, even if (perhaps especially if) we don't agree. One of my regrets is the loss of social policy studies from the health visiting programme, as it is so fundamental to understanding public health. Of course, you are right that each health system is fundamentally different, but the big insurance companies are incredibly influential, and their ethos is widely accepted in our purchaser-provider split; hence the constant demands for 'packages of care' and resultant specific 'outcomes'. best wishesOn 16 Jan 2010, at 11:57, Diane DeBell wrote:Dear , I'm a bit out of "synch" by responding to the information from the United States. But....... has sent me her scholarly work on the USA (2005) and it is excellent. I am talking to Healther separately -- in order not to produce long essays on Senate. But, there are just two insights I meant to send to Senate quickly about the Nurses For Reform group. First, the reference to the Washington Times and then to the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research give us a quick understanding of the political context and belief system of the Nurses for Reform group. These two sources are spokes-persons for the neo-conservative position that put W Bush in office. They argue the rights of the individual over the social context and they refer to any health system that has what Americans refer to as a "welfare" component -- in terms of "left wing" and "proto-communist". They are seriously biased. The point here is that both take the position that individual competition is argued to be the best way to organise health care. These are the investors in the health insurance companies and they are explicit about the fear that their investments would drop in value if the insurance companies were "controlled" by government. That is a position that roughly half the American population holds. But that half is also the wealthiest. I am also concerned that suggestions that "European" equals "welfare state" and "American" equals "free enterprise. In fact, every single country has a different health care system. And it is how the individual histories are modified and developed that is of interest. We can learn from others. But not if we pretend that there are simple systems. The current legislation for health reform in the United States runs to about 2,500 pages and progress is complex and gradual anad is not simple to describe. But it is the determination to break the status quo that matters, I think. Sorry, I did "run on a bit". Thanks, , for the opportunity to talk about this.................... My advice is to investigate the sources of arguments............I would suggest that the Washington Post (not the Washington Times) is the paper to follow here and ignore the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research (it is a "front" for the Republican Party at its most radically right wing). In other words, we need to know the intellectual base and the "objectivity of analysis" in our references. All v good wishes, Diane Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not! Diane, was responding to Fogarty, who drew our attention to the link below. best wishesOn 12 Jan 2010, at 10:58, Fogarty wrote:Dear Alljust for information, this organisation came up on another information/web group and apparently reported they have been having talks with the UK opposition leader.Its really just to be aware of what is out there and who is lobbying what, especially given the changes in service provisions, commissioning and developments in general.http://nursesforreform.com/ regards Cowleysarahcowley183btinternethttp://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn Cowleysarahcowley183@...http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

Posted

Hi DianeThanks for giving us the benefit of your knowledge and wisdom here. It always seems important to understand where other people are coming from, even if (perhaps especially if) we don't agree. One of my regrets is the loss of social policy studies from the health visiting programme, as it is so fundamental to understanding public health. Of course, you are right that each health system is fundamentally different, but the big insurance companies are incredibly influential, and their ethos is widely accepted in our purchaser-provider split; hence the constant demands for 'packages of care' and resultant specific 'outcomes'. best wishesOn 16 Jan 2010, at 11:57, Diane DeBell wrote:Dear , I'm a bit out of "synch" by responding to the information from the United States. But....... has sent me her scholarly work on the USA (2005) and it is excellent. I am talking to Healther separately -- in order not to produce long essays on Senate. But, there are just two insights I meant to send to Senate quickly about the Nurses For Reform group. First, the reference to the Washington Times and then to the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research give us a quick understanding of the political context and belief system of the Nurses for Reform group. These two sources are spokes-persons for the neo-conservative position that put W Bush in office. They argue the rights of the individual over the social context and they refer to any health system that has what Americans refer to as a "welfare" component -- in terms of "left wing" and "proto-communist". They are seriously biased. The point here is that both take the position that individual competition is argued to be the best way to organise health care. These are the investors in the health insurance companies and they are explicit about the fear that their investments would drop in value if the insurance companies were "controlled" by government. That is a position that roughly half the American population holds. But that half is also the wealthiest. I am also concerned that suggestions that "European" equals "welfare state" and "American" equals "free enterprise. In fact, every single country has a different health care system. And it is how the individual histories are modified and developed that is of interest. We can learn from others. But not if we pretend that there are simple systems. The current legislation for health reform in the United States runs to about 2,500 pages and progress is complex and gradual anad is not simple to describe. But it is the determination to break the status quo that matters, I think. Sorry, I did "run on a bit". Thanks, , for the opportunity to talk about this.................... My advice is to investigate the sources of arguments............I would suggest that the Washington Post (not the Washington Times) is the paper to follow here and ignore the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research (it is a "front" for the Republican Party at its most radically right wing). In other words, we need to know the intellectual base and the "objectivity of analysis" in our references. All v good wishes, Diane Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not! Diane, was responding to Fogarty, who drew our attention to the link below. best wishesOn 12 Jan 2010, at 10:58, Fogarty wrote:Dear Alljust for information, this organisation came up on another information/web group and apparently reported they have been having talks with the UK opposition leader.Its really just to be aware of what is out there and who is lobbying what, especially given the changes in service provisions, commissioning and developments in general.http://nursesforreform.com/ regards Cowleysarahcowley183btinternethttp://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn Cowleysarahcowley183@...http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

Posted

Dear ,

So kind of you to provide a short answer. I could feel myself slipping into diatribe about the American system of health care. PPI is also an import from the American system as well as elements of the purchaser-provider split. The insurance companies are the most powerful lobbyists against health reform in the USA.

What I wished to suggest, however, is that the sources cited by the original Nurses for Reform article do take the position of media lobbyists against reform.

And apologies. I suspect that this is becoming a bit boring.

You won't be surprised to hear that I agree with you about the value of social policy studies as a component of health visitor education. I would agree, of course.

All v best, Diane

PS. Do hope your wrist is healing well.............takes forever, I know.

Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!

Diane, was responding to Fogarty, who drew our attention to the link below. best wishes

On 12 Jan 2010, at 10:58, Fogarty wrote:

Dear All

just for information , this organisation came up on another information/web group and apparently reported they have been having talks with the UK opposition leader.

Its really just to be aware of what is out there and who is lobbying what, especially given the changes in service provisions, commissioning and developments in general.

http://nursesforreform.com/

regards

Cowley

sarahcowley183btinternet

http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

Cow ley

sarahcowley183btinternet

http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

Posted

Dear All

I am inquiring if anyone on the list has any further update information on Child Public Health Competency Framework/Career Pathway. I googled it and got the second draft report by the 'UKHPA Discussion paper on the role of Child Public Health Practitioners for the School Aged Population' pub. September 2009

If anyone has any further information I would be interested to hear

Diane it was interesting to read your recent feedback and its not boring, I think its really important to be aware of wider issues at all levels and engage in debate and discussion as the impacts are not just for health/wellbeing of communities and individuals but the profession as a whole.

Many thanks

good wishes for 2010

regards

FogartyLecturerUniversity Campus SuffolkWaterfront BuildingNeptune QuayIpswichSuffolk

From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Diane DeBellSent: 18 January 2010 07:24 Subject: Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!

Dear ,

So kind of you to provide a short answer. I could feel myself slipping into diatribe about the American system of health care. PPI is also an import from the American system as well as elements of the purchaser-provider split. The insurance companies are the most powerful lobbyists against health reform in the USA.

What I wished to suggest, however, is that the sources cited by the original Nurses for Reform article do take the position of media lobbyists against reform.

And apologies. I suspect that this is becoming a bit boring.

You won't be surprised to hear that I agree with you about the value of social policy studies as a component of health visitor education. I would agree, of course.

All v best, Diane

PS. Do hope your wrist is healing well.............takes forever, I know.

Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!

Diane, was responding to Fogarty, who drew our attention to the link below. best wishes

On 12 Jan 2010, at 10:58, Fogarty wrote:

Dear All

just for information , this organisation came up on another information/web group and apparently reported they have been having talks with the UK opposition leader.

Its really just to be aware of what is out there and who is lobbying what, especially given the changes in service provisions, commissioning and developments in general.

http://nursesforreform.com/

regards

Cowley

sarahcowley183btinternet

http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

Cow ley

sarahcowley183btinternet

http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

University Campus Suffolk is one the UK’s newest higher education institutions. The main campus is located in Ipswich with centres in Bury St Edmunds, Great Yarmouth, Lowestoft and Otley. For further details on courses, open days or general information visit www.ucs.ac.uk

This email is confidential and may be privileged. If you are not the intended recipient please accept our apologies. Please do not disclose, copy, or distribute information in this email nor take any action in reliance on its contents: to do so is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful. Please inform us that this message has gone astray before deleting it. Thank you for your co-operation.

University Campus Suffolk (UCS) is the trading name of University Campus Suffolk Ltd, a company registered in England & Wales, registered number 5078498, registered office Waterfront Building, Neptune Quay, Ipswich, IP4 1QJ.

Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail.

Posted

Dear Diane

I agree about the usefulness of social policy studies in health visitor

education. I trained at North East London Polytechnic (long ago!) and social

policy was examined in our finals alongside other aspects of social science, and

epidemiology and statistics. Our lecturers were from the social science

Department and, for what was then a certificate, it gave added depth to our

insight into the workings of local government and national policies affecting

health, housing, education, the family and employment. When health visitors

advocate for clients, they are being political and encompassing the Principles

of Health Visiting. THey need the education to do this effectively.

Dr Coles PhD BA RHV RGN

Honorary Senior Research Fellow

Department of Child Health

School of Medicine

Cardiff University

Heath Park

Cardiff CF14 4XN

>>> " Diane DeBell " <ddebell@...> 18/01/10 7:26 AM >>>

Dear ,

So kind of you to provide a short answer. I could feel myself slipping into

diatribe about the American system of health care. PPI is also an import from

the American system as well as elements of the purchaser-provider split. The

insurance companies are the most powerful lobbyists against health reform in the

USA.

What I wished to suggest, however, is that the sources cited by the original

Nurses for Reform article do take the position of media lobbyists against

reform.

And apologies. I suspect that this is becoming a bit boring.

You won't be surprised to hear that I agree with you about the value of social

policy studies as a component of health visitor education. I would agree, of

course.

All v best, Diane

PS. Do hope your wrist is healing well.............takes forever, I know.

Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!

Diane, was responding to Fogarty, who drew our attention to

the link below. best wishes

On 12 Jan 2010, at 10:58, Fogarty wrote:

Dear All

just for information , this organisation came up on another

information/web group and apparently reported they have been having talks with

the UK opposition leader.

Its really just to be aware of what is out there and who is lobbying

what, especially given the changes in service provisions, commissioning and

developments in general.

http://nursesforreform.com/

regards

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Cowley

sarahcowley183@...

http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

Cow ley

sarahcowley183@...

http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

Posted



Dear ,

Very kind of you. I do find that comparative analyses of healthcare delivery systems (USA and other countries) provides invaluable insights for professionals seeking to understand their own practice, etc.

V good wishes,

Diane

Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!

Diane, was responding to Fogarty, who drew our attention to the link below. best wishes

On 12 Jan 2010, at 10:58, Fogarty wrote:

Dear All

just for information , this organisation came up on another information/web group and apparently reported they have been having talks with the UK opposition leader.

Its really just to be aware of what is out there and who is lobbying what, especially given the changes in service provisions, commissioning and developments in general.

http://nursesforreform.com/

regards

Cowley

sarahcowley183btinternet

http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

Cow ley

sarahcowley183btinternet

http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

University Campus Suffolk is one the UK’s newest higher education institutions. The main campus is located in Ipswich with centres in Bury St Edmunds, Great Yarmouth, Lowestoft and Otley. For further details on courses, open days or general information visit www.ucs.ac.ukThis email is confidential and may be privileged. If you are not the intended recipient please accept our apologies. Please do not disclose, copy, or distribute information in this email nor take any action in reliance on its contents: to do so is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful. Please inform us that this message has gone astray before deleting it. Thank you for your co-operation.University Campus Suffolk (UCS) is the trading name of University Campus Suffolk Ltd, a company registered in England & Wales, registered number 5078498, registered office Waterfront Building, Neptune Quay, Ipswich, IP4 1QJ.Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail.

Posted

Dear ,

Thank you for your very valuable response (see also Fogarty). If I can do anything to progress these views and arguments, do let me know.

V best wishes,

Diane

Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!Diane, was responding to Fogarty, who drew our attention to the link below. best wishesOn 12 Jan 2010, at 10:58, Fogarty wrote:Dear Alljust for information , this organisation came up on another information/web group and apparently reported they have been having talks with the UK opposition leader.Its really just to be aware of what is out there and who is lobbying what, especially given the changes in service provisions, commissioning and developments in general.http://nursesforreform.com/regards---------------------------------------------------------- Cowleysarahcowley183btinternethttp://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn Cow leysarahcowley183btinternethttp://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

Posted

Dear ,

Thank you for your very valuable response (see also Fogarty). If I can do anything to progress these views and arguments, do let me know.

V best wishes,

Diane

Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!Diane, was responding to Fogarty, who drew our attention to the link below. best wishesOn 12 Jan 2010, at 10:58, Fogarty wrote:Dear Alljust for information , this organisation came up on another information/web group and apparently reported they have been having talks with the UK opposition leader.Its really just to be aware of what is out there and who is lobbying what, especially given the changes in service provisions, commissioning and developments in general.http://nursesforreform.com/regards---------------------------------------------------------- Cowleysarahcowley183btinternethttp://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn Cow leysarahcowley183btinternethttp://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

Posted

Hi All

What an interesting debate this has been - I was away in the sun so missed it all live but have enjoyed reading it on my return and found Diane's explanation of the American system fascinating - read a couple of Barack Obama's books on holiday so it was very topical for me and the books are a good read.

The syllabus you learnt health visiting against was known as the 1965 syllabus and stood for almost 30 years having 5 parts including sociology, social policy and psychology. It was an excellent syllabus to work to and teach to and perhaps needs to be revisited and renewed as certainly I get the impression that today's modular syllabus does not meet the needs of practice today and is not producing the Hv and Sn with the skills we need for today's world. And that is another big discussion as to what is needed.

I like Maggie's idea of a really working now to set up a professional organisation for health visiting (and school nursing). Have been quite upset to see the behaviour of UNITE with other workers and am seriously considering whether to renew my membership and I have been member of the HVA since 1972! I think the way they are presently responding to the Conservatives views on HV is not good and lacks the professional perspective. I know they are a Union and support Labour but some of what is being said and written by the Tories needs to be considered more carefully and used politically to get what is needed - here is me encompassing the Principles of Health Visiting.

Margaret

Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!Diane, was responding to Fogarty, who drew our attention to the link below. best wishesOn 12 Jan 2010, at 10:58, Fogarty wrote:Dear Alljust for information , this organisation came up on another information/web group and apparently reported they have been having talks with the UK opposition leader.Its really just to be aware of what is out there and who is lobbying what, especially given the changes in service provisions, commissioning and developments in general.http://nursesforreform.com/regards---------------------------------------------------------- Cowleysarahcowley183btinternethttp://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn Cow leysarahcowley183btinternethttp://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn

Posted

Hello everyoneI couldn't agree with you more Margaret.. Havn't got much time to keep up with the debate as I am so busy marking assignments, but I constantly hark back to the old syllabus which was fit for purpose then and may still have some mileage now. Certainly the students are constantly telling us that what we teach is not happening in the real world.From: Margaret Buttigieg <margaret@...> Sent: Thu, 21 January, 2010 9:58:09Subject: Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!

Hi All

What an interesting debate this has been - I was away in the sun so missed it all live but have enjoyed reading it on my return and found Diane's explanation of the American system fascinating - read a couple of Barack Obama's books on holiday so it was very topical for me and the books are a good read.

The syllabus you learnt health visiting against was known as the 1965 syllabus and stood for almost 30 years having 5 parts including sociology, social policy and psychology. It was an excellent syllabus to work to and teach to and perhaps needs to be revisited and renewed as certainly I get the impression that today's modular syllabus does not meet the needs of practice today and is not producing the Hv and Sn with the skills we need for today's world. And that is another big discussion as to what is needed.

I like Maggie's idea of a really working now to set up a professional organisation for health visiting (and school nursing). Have been quite upset to see the behaviour of UNITE with other workers and am seriously considering whether to renew my membership and I have been member of the HVA since 1972! I think the way they are presently responding to the Conservatives views on HV is not good and lacks the professional perspective. I know they are a Union and support Labour but some of what is being said and written by the Tories needs to be considered more carefully and used politically to get what is needed - here is me encompassing the Principles of Health Visiting.

Margaret

Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!Diane, was responding to Fogarty, who drew our attention to the link below. best wishesOn 12 Jan 2010, at 10:58, Fogarty wrote:Dear Alljust for information , this organisation came up on another information/ web group and apparently reported they have been having talks with the UK opposition leader.Its really just to be aware of what is out there and who is lobbying what, especially given the changes in service provisions, commissioning and developments in general.http://nursesforref orm.com/regards------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- - Cowleysarahcowley183@ btinternet. comhttp://myprofile. cos.com/S124021C On Cow leysarahcowley183@ btinternet. comhttp://myprofile. cos.com/S124021C On

Posted

Yes I share your experience of what students says - do yours also add - that

they feel they need to practice more of the ideas being taught and it's the

rules set by line managers because of 'what has or hasn't been commissioned'

that constrains them.

Sometimes I think we need to write a HV-SN course for commissioners!

Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!

Hi All

What an interesting debate this has been - I was away in the sun so missed

it all live but have enjoyed reading it on my return and found Diane's

explanation of the American system fascinating - read a couple of Barack

Obama's books on holiday so it was very topical for me and the books are a

good read.

The syllabus you learnt health visiting against was known as the 1965

syllabus and stood for almost 30 years having 5 parts including sociology,

social policy and psychology. It was an excellent syllabus to work to and

teach to and perhaps needs to be revisited and renewed as certainly I get

the impression that today's modular syllabus does not meet the needs of

practice today and is not producing the Hv and Sn with the skills we need

for today's world. And that is another big discussion as to what is needed.

I like Maggie's idea of a really working now to set up a professional

organisation for health visiting (and school nursing). Have been quite

upset to see the behaviour of UNITE with other workers and am seriously

considering whether to renew my membership and I have been member of the HVA

since 1972! I think the way they are presently responding to the

Conservatives views on HV is not good and lacks the professional

perspective. I know they are a Union and support Labour but some of what is

being said and written by the Tories needs to be considered more carefully

and used politically to get what is needed - here is me encompassing the

Principles of Health Visiting.

Margaret

Re: Health Visiting Today? I hope not!

Diane, was responding to Fogarty, who drew our

attention to the link below. best wishes

On 12 Jan 2010, at 10:58, Fogarty wrote:

Dear All

just for information , this organisation came up on another

information/ web group and apparently reported they have been having talks

with the UK opposition leader.

Its really just to be aware of what is out there and who is lobbying

what, especially given the changes in service provisions, commissioning and

developments in general.

http://nursesforref orm.com/ <http://nursesforreform.com/>

regards

------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- -

Cowley

sarahcowley183@ btinternet. com

<mailto:sarahcowley183%40btinternet.com>

http://myprofile. cos.com/S124021C On

<http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn>

Cow ley

sarahcowley183@ btinternet. com

<mailto:sarahcowley183%40btinternet.com>

http://myprofile. cos.com/S124021C On

<http://myprofile.cos.com/S124021COn>

No virus found in this incoming message.

Checked by AVG - www.avg.com

Version: 8.5.432 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2635 - Release Date: 01/20/10

19:18:00

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...