Guest guest Posted May 23, 2006 Report Posted May 23, 2006 Edited to correct top post.... --- <mfrey_97@...> wrote: > Now, I know this is considered a sensitizer, so I > have been avoiding > use of this material. But, I see a lot of people do > use this item. > My question is - has anyone actually had or known > anyone with a > reaction to benzoin? I am certainly tempted to > experiment with it > (even if only for my own use), particularly when I > see posts with > tempting combinations using benzoin! > > Thanks!! > , I've been using a lot of benzoin (with caution) and I have extremely sensitive skin-- I can't use most soaps because of synthetic fragrances and I even get a rash from most natural deodorants. But benzoin has not been a problem. It's possible that I will develop an allergy over time but so far so good. Quote
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2006 Report Posted May 23, 2006 >> Now, I know this is considered a sensitizer, so I have been avoiding use of this material. But, I see a lot of people do use this item. My question is - has anyone actually had or known anyone with a reaction to benzoin? I am certainly tempted to experiment with it (even if only for my own use), particularly when I see posts with tempting combinations using benzoin! Thanks!! << Hi , Benzoin, when used in small amounts, is fine for use. I love the delicate vanilla scent it imparts. It can be difficult to work with at first, particularly in non-perfume applications. Did you know: Gum benzoin is used to produce sodium benzoate, which is a preservative found in many foods we ingest daily. In my eleven plus years of handling and selling this product, neither I, nor any of my staff, have ever become " sensitized " by gum benzoin. Trina at Snowdrift Farm Quote
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2006 Report Posted May 23, 2006 > My question is - has anyone actually had or known anyone with a > reaction to benzoin? > Hi , That would be me! As a newbie, not even aware of sensitivities, I just started blending and testing 50% dilutions on the backs of my hands. After about 3 days, I started getting tiny, tiny blisters that itched like a furry. Even though I stopped using the benzion, the rash kept moving up my arms and getting worse. I tried every type of lotion, bath, etc... including several perscription creams. The dermotolist evenually put me on 2 courses of steriods which finally worked. Since then, I've done a 5% patch test on my skin, and I'm alright. Don't take any significant risk, . It's not nice. Janet Quote
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2006 Report Posted May 23, 2006 > > Hi , > That would be me! As a newbie, not even aware of sensitivities, I just > started blending and testing 50% dilutions on the backs of my hands. > After about 3 days, I started getting tiny, tiny blisters that itched > like a furry. Even though I stopped using the benzion, the rash kept > moving up my arms and getting worse. I tried every type of lotion, > bath, etc... including several perscription creams. The dermotolist > evenually put me on 2 courses of steriods which finally worked. Since > then, I've done a 5% patch test on my skin, and I'm alright. > Don't take any significant risk, . It's not nice. > Janet Hi Janet, Could you say what type of benzoin you used? Also whether it was pourable or solid when you got it and what you blended it with for your 50% dilution. Thank you! Will Eden Botanicals Quote
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2006 Report Posted May 23, 2006 > > > > > Hi , > > That would be me! As a newbie, not even aware of sensitivities, I just > > started blending and testing 50% dilutions on the backs of my hands. > > After about 3 days, I started getting tiny, tiny blisters that itched > > like a furry. Even though I stopped using the benzion, the rash kept > > moving up my arms and getting worse. I tried every type of lotion, > > bath, etc... including several perscription creams. The dermotolist > > evenually put me on 2 courses of steriods which finally worked. Since > > then, I've done a 5% patch test on my skin, and I'm alright. > > Don't take any significant risk, . It's not nice. > > Janet > > Hi Janet, > > Could you say what type of benzoin you used? Also whether it was > pourable or solid when you got it and what you blended it with for > your 50% dilution. > > Thank you! > > Will > Eden Botanicals Me Too: It is my understanding that the crude of Benzoin such as Styrax and Siam Benzoin, have a greater potential for allergic reaction than the distilled versions. The distilled oils of Benzoin are said to be less effective as a fixative. Yet I find that they still carry a nice essence. This can also be said for Balsam of Peru Oil . I think that 50% of any single essential oil or resin applied directly to the skin may be excessive, and cause a reaction in some people . With these resins, and even the oils, a little goes a long way and can be diluted down to less than 1% and still be effective in a blend or as a fixative, wihtout causing adverse reactions. But....... people do react differently. Yet another reason for full disclosure in labeling. Peace, Zz................ Quote
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2006 Report Posted May 23, 2006 As a newbie, not even aware of sensitivities, I just > > started blending and testing 50% dilutions on the backs of my > >hands. > Could you say what type of benzoin you used? Also whether it was > pourable or solid when you got it and what you blended it with for > your 50% dilution. > Will Hi Will, I may not know what I'm doing, but I usually always have good records! It was Styrax benzoin from Indonesia that I bought from Liberty in Aug 2004. It had a molassas-like consistancy. Very nice. I was trying to create a variety of ambers... so I was using typical EOs for that kind of blend... vanilla, peru balsam, labdanum. Gosh, I hate to admit this, but it was so early in my involvement that I didn't even understand dilutions. There was probably 20% jojoba and the rest EOs. I could have done a real number to myself, but I was having such a wonderful time. Thanks to you guys I haven't burned my skin to a crisp... yet! Janet Quote
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2006 Report Posted May 23, 2006 No problems with Benzoin. I use in small percentages for fixing alcohol and in base notes. Dorothy Dorothy McCall, Cert. Aroma. Kingsbury Fragrances The Royal York 3955 Bigelow Blvd. Ste. 907 Pittsburgh, PA. 15213 (412) 687-2720 www.kingsburyfragrances.com " Vibrating aromatic threads speak of the Divine through tapestries of scent " Dorothy McCall Cert. Aroma. Quote
Guest guest Posted January 8, 2007 Report Posted January 8, 2007 > > I have read that Benzoin should not be used on the skin as people > develop senstivities to it. So, that pretty much means you shouldn't > use it in perfume? > > Sora > Hi Sora I have used Benzoin in aromatherapy blends, but in a low dilution (1 -1.5%). However, these blends would not be used over prolonged, regular timeframe, but more for a one off/short period of use. However, you could always do a sample, with benzoin in low percentage, and then skin test it,- but this is probably only applicable on people who you know well and you are making the formula for. People with already sensitive skin may be irritated by it, but then irritation and sensitivity can be very individual and idiosyncratic. And I have found cinnamon and clove to be more problematic! Am sure the more experienced NP-ers out there will advise you ;-) Quote
Guest guest Posted January 8, 2007 Report Posted January 8, 2007 > I have read that Benzoin should not be used on the skin as people > develop senstivities to it. So, that pretty much means you shouldn't > use it in perfume? > > Sora > This question comes up with great frequency, so I would be very interested to know here you heard it. Basically, no, not so. Benzoin may cause sensitivity very rarely, but ther is no evidence that it does, and there are no industry guidelines that forbid its use. Sometimes there is confusion between benzoin (Styrax benzoin) and Styrax, or Liquidambar (Liquidambar styraciflua), which is a skin sensitizer, nad should not be used at more than 0.6%. Also, should not be confused with information about " compound tincture of benzoin " which contains both benzoin and styrax. Tisserand Quote
Guest guest Posted January 8, 2007 Report Posted January 8, 2007 From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Tisserand Sent: Monday, January 08, 2007 1:59 PM Subject: Re: Benzoin > I have read that Benzoin should not be used on the skin as people > develop senstivities to it. So, that pretty much means you shouldn't > use it in perfume? This question comes up with great frequency, so I would be very interested to know here you heard it. Basically, no, not so. Benzoin may cause sensitivity very rarely, but ther is no evidence that it does, and there are no industry guidelines that forbid its use. Sometimes there is confusion between benzoin (Styrax benzoin) and Styrax, or Liquidambar (Liquidambar styraciflua), which is a skin sensitizer, nad should not be used at more than 0.6%. Also, should not be confused with information about " compound tincture of benzoin " which contains both benzoin and styrax. Tisserand I believe, , that this taboo originated in the U.S. in Sylla Shepphard-Hanger's Aromatherapy Practitioner Manual, originally published in 1995. In it, Benzoin is listed as " tested at low dose non-toxic & non irritating, possible strong SENSITIZER (benzoic & cinnamic acid-strong sensitizers), cross sensitization to Peru balsam; has no place in skin uses, fragrance use is fine. " I can see how confusion has arisen; of course, perfumes are applied to the skin, so what fragrance use would she be referencing, other than perhaps environmental mists or sprays? Here's Watt's paper on Benzoin http://www.aromamedical.com/articles/benzoin.html I'd appreciate your response to Sylla/'s conclusions, . Thank you. Be well, Marcia Elston, Samara Botane, http://www.wingedseed.com/katrina.htm " First of all, cultivate a contented spirit; a garden is a good place to begin. " Quote
Guest guest Posted January 8, 2007 Report Posted January 8, 2007 --- Tisserand <tisserand@...> wrote: > > Basically, no, not so. Benzoin may cause sensitivity > very rarely, but ther is no evidence that > it does, and there are no industry guidelines that > forbid its use. > > Sometimes there is confusion between benzoin (Styrax > benzoin) and Styrax, or > Liquidambar (Liquidambar styraciflua), which is a > skin sensitizer, nad should not be used > at more than 0.6%. > > Also, should not be confused with information about > " compound tincture of benzoin " > which contains both benzoin and styrax. > > Tisserand ************************************************* Of some interest, my next door neighbor is an OR nurse and told me that they use benzoin (I think the compound tincture) to prep the skin before surgery. I think she said it's used as an antiseptic. I found this out because I was working on a perfume for her and she couldn't stand the first version because it contained benzoin. Reminded her of work, I guess. -Patty __________________________________________________ Quote
Guest guest Posted January 8, 2007 Report Posted January 8, 2007 > > I have read that Benzoin should not be used on the skin as people > > develop senstivities to it. So, that pretty much means you shouldn't > > use it in perfume? > This question comes up with great frequency, so I would be very interested > to know here > you heard it. > > Basically, no, not so. Benzoin may cause sensitivity very rarely, but ther > is no evidence that > it does, and there are no industry guidelines that forbid its use. > > Sometimes there is confusion between benzoin (Styrax benzoin) and Styrax, or > > Liquidambar (Liquidambar styraciflua), which is a skin sensitizer, nad > should not be used > at more than 0.6%. > > Also, should not be confused with information about " compound tincture of > benzoin " > which contains both benzoin and styrax. > > Tisserand > > > I believe, , that this taboo originated in the U.S. in Sylla > Shepphard-Hanger's Aromatherapy Practitioner Manual, originally published in > 1995. In it, Benzoin is listed as " tested at low dose non-toxic & non > irritating, possible strong SENSITIZER (benzoic & cinnamic acid-strong > sensitizers), cross sensitization to Peru balsam; has no place in skin uses, > fragrance use is fine. " > > I can see how confusion has arisen; of course, perfumes are applied to the > skin, so what fragrance use would she be referencing, other than perhaps > environmental mists or sprays? > > Here's Watt's paper on Benzoin > http://www.aromamedical.com/articles/benzoin.html > > I'd appreciate your response to Sylla/'s conclusions, . Thank > you. > > Be well, > Marcia Elston The bottom line is that there are very few relevant bit of research that relate to benzoin, so no-one really knows the risk. We do know that in the 10 years to 2002, there were no reports of allergy to compound tincture of benzoin. As for its constituents, both benzoic acid and cinnamic acid have produced some allergic reactions, and benzyl benzoate and benzyl alcohol are listed in the EU as allergens, though they are certainly not high-risk. Considering the wide use of benzoin in fragrances over many years it's surprising that there isn't more information. It's also surprising, if it's a strong sensitizer, that there seem to be so few reports of adverse reactions. I would perhaps be a little careful with benzoin, but I don't think it needs the skull and crossbones treatment. Tisserand Quote
Guest guest Posted January 8, 2007 Report Posted January 8, 2007 > > Considering the wide use of benzoin in fragrances over many years it's surprising that > there isn't more information. It's also surprising, if it's a strong sensitizer, that there seem > to be so few reports of adverse reactions. > > I would perhaps be a little careful with benzoin, but I don't think it needs the skull and > crossbones treatment. > > Tisserand I can't help but relate this to what was said concerning a ambiant incence sold in France, called " papier d'armenie " (armenian paper), that has a strong benzoin component. It was found that the level of Benzene in its smoke was high and judged dangerous. The producer's answer is that this is not a threat if the incence is properly used (= a few at a time, in a ventilated area, as all incences probably should, anyway). Finding benzene in benzoin fumes does not sound surprising per se, obviously, and burning a lot of it and then finding high level of dangerous components, hence condemning the product, leaves me in perplexity. Any product, natural or not, may be harmful in improperly used, right? fab Quote
Guest guest Posted January 9, 2007 Report Posted January 9, 2007 West <tribalpatty@...> wrote: > Of some interest, my next door neighbor is an OR nurse > and told me that they use benzoin (I think the > compound tincture) to prep the skin before surgery. I > think she said it's used as an antiseptic. I haven't seen it used as a surgical skin prep or antiseptic - povidone iodine or chlorhexidine are standard - but compound tincture of benzoin (tinct.benz.co., in prescriptionspeak) is used as a skin application before some dressings, to enhance adhesion. Sometimes also, though this is pretty much out of style, as a base for medications such as podophyllin (a wart medicine, so you want it to stick to the area it's applied to). Lara ps I'm new here. Hi, all. Quote
Guest guest Posted November 7, 2008 Report Posted November 7, 2008 > > I'm acquiring materials that are soluble in fixed oils, or at least > not antagonistic to them. I ordered some bezoin liquid resin (in the > resin section not absolutes) from Liberty Natural. At first the rep > told me yes it's soluble in fixed oils, then she said her manager > told her that it's thicker than fixed oils so I might have to use a > little alcohol. Can someone explain to me what they're talking about? > Hi Adam, It sounds to me like she meant that you would need to mix the benzoin up with a little alcohol to make it less goopy, and then mix it all into your fixed oil. Benzoin can get pretty thick. I've not worked with scent in fixed oils, though, so I don't know how the benzoin and alcohol would mix with yours. Cheers, Andrine Quote
Guest guest Posted November 7, 2008 Report Posted November 7, 2008 > > I'm acquiring materials that are soluble in fixed oils, or at least > not antagonistic to them. I ordered some bezoin liquid resin (in the > resin section not absolutes) from Liberty Natural. At first the rep > told me yes it's soluble in fixed oils, then she said her manager > told her that it's thicker than fixed oils so I might have to use a > little alcohol. Can someone explain to me what they're talking about? > Alcohol isn't necessary. Benzoin is soluble in oil. Yes it is very thick and sticky and hard to work with. I use it all the time as it is a great fixative. Here is my method. I use a mug warmer to warm my tenacious oils until pourable. Once pourable dilute with a little of your fixed oil to thin it out a little more. Mix well to throughly incorporate, then add that to the remaining fixed oil. Keep in mind it does cloud your oils because it is a resin. The residue will eventually settle to the bottom of your container. Molly Quote
Guest guest Posted November 7, 2008 Report Posted November 7, 2008 Molly, once you get that melted, what scents do you use for that to be a fixtive that works well with? I am always in the market for a better fixative and I have balsam of Peru which I think does the same thing....but I love amber and overjoyed with frank and murray ....but I need fixatives for making floral scents and some of the base notes like oakmoss, sapmoss etc. Â evie Quote
Guest guest Posted November 7, 2008 Report Posted November 7, 2008 Hi Adam, I had the problem with Benzoin always ending up at the bottom of my oil based perfumes. Heating only makes it more pourable. So my solution was to pre-infuse the base oil for about a month after warming the solution first. Then I use the infused oil minus the bits at the bottom in the quantity and strength I need. I always keep the infused oil in stock at same strength so that I know how much to add to my perfumes - after much testing. I do the same with other oils that are difficult to dilute in oil based perfumes. Sophia Quote
Guest guest Posted November 8, 2008 Report Posted November 8, 2008 > > Molly, > once you get that melted, what scents do you use for that to be a fixtive that works well with? > I am always in the market for a better fixative and I have balsam of Peru which I think does the same thing....but I love amber and overjoyed with frank and murray ....but I need fixatives for making floral scents and some of the base notes like oakmoss, sapmoss etc. > > evie > incense is a fixative too and pretty much rounds almost everything. Personally I use benzoin with almost everything more so spices and florals. Oakmoss is a fixative but one I tend to stray away from as it is very strong. Other great fixatives are vetiver, cedarwood, balsam peru, myrrh, opopanax, sandalwood, patchouli and I'm sure their are many more that I forgot. Another base oil that I like to keep around is vetiver for anything with patchouli. Quote
Guest guest Posted November 8, 2008 Report Posted November 8, 2008 Thanks. I do use patch as a fixative, always have amber and I do have and Murray in resin form.....that I can 'fix'....I've not had the pleasure of smelling vetiver...I do have cedar I cannot afford sandalwood.....that just breaks my heart LOL...a nice sandalwood....its the little black dress of blending. Â e Quote
Guest guest Posted November 8, 2008 Report Posted November 8, 2008 > I cannot afford sandalwood.....that just breaks my heart Liberty Natural's Australian sandalwood EO is only $48/ounce. I'm no sandalwood expert, but to me this smells mighty fine. I don't buy into the idea that Indian and other sandalwood is oh-so special, markedly more pleasing than Australian. I like the Australian at least as much as the others I've smelled. Quote
Guest guest Posted November 8, 2008 Report Posted November 8, 2008 um, even at 48 still to high.....I'm the shopper who buys teaspoons of things like jasmine absolute etc LOL.......I would have had that but I needed tires first.....sort makes the ride a lot smoother LOL! Â if any body has a teaspoon or half an ounce holler at me. evie Quote
Guest guest Posted November 8, 2008 Report Posted November 8, 2008 > > Thanks. I do use patch as a fixative, always have amber and I do have and Murray in resin form.....that I can 'fix'....I've not had the pleasure of smelling vetiver...I do have cedar I cannot afford sandalwood.....that just breaks my heart LOL...a nice sandalwood....its the little black dress of blending. > > e > I like EOU's sandalwood blend I believe it is 27.00 for 1oz. It is a blend of 5 different sandalwoods. If your looking for inexpensive I think that would be a good start. Quote
Guest guest Posted November 8, 2008 Report Posted November 8, 2008 > Liberty Natural's Australian sandalwood EO is only $48/ounce. I'm no > sandalwood expert, but to me this smells mighty fine. I don't buy > into the idea that Indian and other sandalwood is oh-so special, > markedly more pleasing than Australian. I like the Australian at > least as much as the others I've smelled. > I have a Vanuatu Sandalwood from Eden Botanicals that is so complex. It has that warm lemony woody scent of the sandalwood along with a smoky charred note that I love. It's like eating wild caught salmon that has been smoked on a hickory plank. Maggie Quote
Guest guest Posted November 8, 2008 Report Posted November 8, 2008 > um, even at 48 still to high ..12 oz is 6 bucks. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.