Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: Goitrogenics, oxalates, and raw veggies - please weigh in

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

I think you're supposed to vary your greens anyway--couldn't you just enjoy cruciferous veggies cooked and limit your raw spinach intake (more than the rest of us)? There are lots of other leafy and non-leafy greens that you can throw into the mix.

Have you asked you doctor about this? In the meantime, I'd play it safe and avoid the broccoli and cauliflower crudités on the buffet table. There are worse things than not having a broccoli-and-cabbage smoothie and cauliflower isn't green anyway (given that I detest it, I'm always happy to have the opportunity to take a swipe at it!). A lot of people find kale too bitter; maybe Swiss chard instead? And romaine's a great standby

Goitrogenics, oxalates, and raw veggies - please weigh in

Hi all,

I came across this blog post about raw veggies and it has me a little discouraged about my green smoothies. I have Hashimoto's thyroiditis (auto-immune) and it is pretty severe, along with other debilitating health conditions, so I obviously don't want to cause myself any more problems.

http://www.thehealthyhomeeconomist.com/2010/10/think-raw-veggies-are-best-think-again.html She cites this as one of her sources: http://www.westonaprice.org/abcs-of-nutrition/177

It says that cruciferous vegetables should be cooked or they will block production of the thyroid hormone. It also cautions eating raw spinach, parsley, etc. (which I love in my smoothies) because they contain oxalic acid, which blocks iron and calcium absorption and may contribute to the formation of kidney stones. I think that drinking lots of water, plus varying greens helps with the oxalates right? But then the cruciferous vegetables thing threw me for a loop.

I have been so hopeful for improvements in my health with eating more raw veggies with all the wonderful enzymes and vitamins and minerals. Please weigh in on this, if you have anything helpful to say, or know anything about this matter!

Posted

I also have Hashimoto's severe enough that I have gone into myexedema coma twice

from it, so I have researched this carefully. Yes, MANY veggies are NOT good

for thyroid conditions. Turns out I was actually making my thyroid condition

worse by consuming too many of the wrong kinds of fruits and veggies, and

unfortunately, I had to give up many of my favorites. That's the bad news. The

GOOD news is, there are plenty of other veggies that are fine for smoothies, and

will not disrupt the hormone balance-and you may need to make those adjustments.

That said, its important to remember that the information in the article (and

similar info available) is based on consuming those veggies and fruits in their

whole state. When liquidized, they are absorbed differently by the body, and

the nutrients are more bioavailable in liquid form-which means you are also

taking in additional calcium, iron, and the other things that are supposedly

" blocked " from absorption. In liquid form, you are likely to get what you need

and eliminate what you do not. I have pre existing kidney issues due to lupus,

so I have to be VERY careful with high oxalates. Having recovered from the

brink of checking out of this world simply through diet, I have learned to NOT

listen to everything that is defined as a do or don't for the masses-you need to

listen to YOUR body. If you feel good doing what you are doing, then keep on

doing it. If you are having persistent health issues, try keeping a food

journal to identify what is causing them, then make adjustments. There is no

cookie cutter approach, and I think it is unwise to start or stop doing

something just because you " heard " that it causes problems. Everyone has

different nutritional needs, and your own body and intuition is the best way to

make sure those needs are being met. For what it's worth, I was told many years

ago to " get my affairs in order " , and I was not expected to stick around much

longer. Due to relying on my OWN thoughts about food and nutrition, I am still

around aggravating society with my often unpopular thoughts on nutrition, and

flashing my leopard panties just because I still can!

>

> Hi all,

>

> I came across this blog post about raw veggies and it has me a little

> discouraged about my green smoothies. I have Hashimoto's thyroiditis

> (auto-immune) and it is pretty severe, along with other debilitating health

> conditions, so I obviously don't want to cause myself any more problems.

>

http://www.thehealthyhomeeconomist.com/2010/10/think-raw-veggies-are-best-think-\

again.html

> She cites this as one of her sources:

> http://www.westonaprice.org/abcs-of-nutrition/177

>

> It says that cruciferous vegetables should be cooked or they will block

> production of the thyroid hormone. It also cautions eating raw spinach,

> parsley, etc. (which I love in my smoothies) because they contain oxalic

> acid, which blocks iron and calcium absorption and may contribute to the

> formation of kidney stones. I think that drinking lots of water, plus

> varying greens helps with the oxalates right? But then the cruciferous

> vegetables thing threw me for a loop.

>

> I have been so hopeful for improvements in my health with eating more raw

> veggies with all the wonderful enzymes and vitamins and minerals. Please

> weigh in on this, if you have anything helpful to say, or know anything

> about this matter!

>

> Thanks,

>

>

Posted

For what it's worth, I was told many years ago to "get my affairs in order", and I was not expected to stick around much longer. Due to relying on my OWN thoughts about food and nutrition, I am still around aggravating society with my often unpopular thoughts on nutrition, and flashing my leopard panties just because I still can!And the world is a better place because you are still around to aggravate us ;-) Especially our little corner of the world :-)

Blessings,Lea Ann SavageSatellite Beach, FL(321) 773-7088 (home)(321-961-9219 (cell)))><'>www.VitamixLady.comwww..com<:)))><

Re: Goitrogenics, oxalates, and raw veggies - please weigh in

I also have Hashimoto's severe enough that I have gone into myexedema coma twice from it, so I have researched this carefully. Yes, MANY veggies are NOT good for thyroid conditions. Turns out I was actually making my thyroid condition worse by consuming too many of the wrong kinds of fruits and veggies, and unfortunately, I had to give up many of my favorites. That's the bad news. The GOOD news is, there are plenty of other veggies that are fine for smoothies, and will not disrupt the hormone balance-and you may need to make those adjustments. That said, its important to remember that the information in the article (and similar info available) is based on consuming those veggies and fruits in their whole state. When liquidized, they are absorbed differently by the body, and the nutrients are more bioavailable in liquid form-which means you are also taking in additional calcium, iron, and the other things that are supposedly "blocked" from absorption. In liquid form, you are likely to get what you need and eliminate what you do not. I have pre existing kidney issues due to lupus, so I have to be VERY careful with high oxalates. Having recovered from the brink of checking out of this world simply through diet, I have learned to NOT listen to everything that is defined as a do or don't for the masses-you need to listen to YOUR body. If you feel good doing what you are doing, then keep on doing it. If you are having persistent health issues, try keeping a food journal to identify what is causing them, then make adjustments. There is no cookie cutter approach, and I think it is unwise to start or stop doing something just because you "heard" that it causes problems. Everyone has different nutritional needs, and your own body and intuition is the best way to make sure those needs are being met. For what it's worth, I was told many years ago to "get my affairs in order", and I was not expected to stick around much longer. Due to relying on my OWN thoughts about food and nutrition, I am still around aggravating society with my often unpopular thoughts on nutrition, and flashing my leopard panties just because I still can!>> Hi all,> > I came across this blog post about raw veggies and it has me a little> discouraged about my green smoothies. I have Hashimoto's thyroiditis> (auto-immune) and it is pretty severe, along with other debilitating health> conditions, so I obviously don't want to cause myself any more problems.> http://www.thehealthyhomeeconomist.com/2010/10/think-raw-veggies-are-best-think-again.html> She cites this as one of her sources:> http://www.westonaprice.org/abcs-of-nutrition/177> > It says that cruciferous vegetables should be cooked or they will block> production of the thyroid hormone. It also cautions eating raw spinach,> parsley, etc. (which I love in my smoothies) because they contain oxalic> acid, which blocks iron and calcium absorption and may contribute to the> formation of kidney stones. I think that drinking lots of water, plus> varying greens helps with the oxalates right? But then the cruciferous> vegetables thing threw me for a loop.> > I have been so hopeful for improvements in my health with eating more raw> veggies with all the wonderful enzymes and vitamins and minerals. Please> weigh in on this, if you have anything helpful to say, or know anything> about this matter!> > Thanks,> >

Posted

Aw, how SWEET!!! You get an extra flash today, Lea Ann-you made my day! From: Lea Ann Savage <lsavage@...>Subject: Re: Re: Goitrogenics, oxalates, and raw veggies - please weigh in Date: Friday, November 5, 2010, 9:30 AM

For what it's worth, I was told many years ago to "get my affairs in order", and I was not expected to stick around much longer. Due to relying on my OWN thoughts about food and nutrition, I am still around aggravating society with my often unpopular thoughts on nutrition, and flashing my leopard panties just because I still can!And the world is a better place because you are still around to aggravate us ;-) Especially our little corner of the world :-)

Blessings,Lea Ann SavageSatellite Beach, FL(321) 773-7088 (home)(321-961-9219 (cell)))><'>www.VitamixLady.comwww..com<:)))><

Re: Goitrogenics, oxalates, and raw veggies - please weigh in

I also have Hashimoto's severe enough that I have gone into myexedema coma twice from it, so I have researched this carefully. Yes, MANY veggies are NOT good for thyroid conditions. Turns out I was actually making my thyroid condition worse by consuming too many of the wrong kinds of fruits and veggies, and unfortunately, I had to give up many of my favorites. That's the bad news. The GOOD news is, there are plenty of other veggies that are fine for smoothies, and will not disrupt the hormone balance-and you may need to make those adjustments. That said, its important to remember that the information in the article (and similar info available) is based on consuming those veggies and fruits in their whole state. When liquidized, they are absorbed differently by the body, and the nutrients are more bioavailable in liquid form-which means you are also taking in additional calcium, iron, and the other things that are supposedly "blocked" from absorption. In liquid form, you are likely to get what you need and eliminate what you do not. I have pre existing kidney issues due to lupus, so I have to be VERY careful with high oxalates. Having recovered from the brink of checking out of this world simply through diet, I have learned to NOT listen to everything that is defined as a do or don't for the masses-you need to listen to YOUR body. If you feel good doing what you are doing, then keep on doing it. If you are having persistent health issues, try keeping a food journal to identify what is causing them, then make adjustments. There is no cookie cutter approach, and I think it is unwise to start or stop doing something just because you "heard" that it causes problems. Everyone has different nutritional needs, and your own body and intuition is the best way to make sure those needs are being met. For what it's worth, I was told many years ago to "get my affairs in order", and I was not expected to stick around much longer. Due to relying on my OWN thoughts about food and nutrition, I am still around aggravating society with my often unpopular thoughts on nutrition, and flashing my leopard panties just because I still can!>> Hi all,> > I came across this blog post about raw veggies and it has me a little> discouraged about my green smoothies. I have Hashimoto's thyroiditis> (auto-immune) and it is pretty severe, along with other debilitating health> conditions, so I obviously don't want to cause myself any more problems.> http://www.thehealthyhomeeconomist.com/2010/10/think-raw-veggies-are-best-think-again.html> She cites this as one of her sources:> http://www.westonaprice.org/abcs-of-nutrition/177> > It says that cruciferous vegetables should be cooked or they will block> production of the thyroid hormone. It also cautions eating raw spinach,> parsley, etc. (which I love in my smoothies) because they contain oxalic> acid, which blocks iron and calcium absorption and may contribute to the> formation of kidney stones. I think that drinking lots of water, plus> varying greens helps with the oxalates right? But then the cruciferous> vegetables thing threw me for a loop.> > I have been so hopeful for improvements in my health with eating more raw> veggies with all the wonderful enzymes and vitamins and minerals. Please> weigh in on this, if you have anything helpful to say, or know anything> about this matter!> > Thanks,> >

Posted

Hi ,

I mostly lurk but felt I could give some info on this.

I also have Hashimoto's. I bought the VM with the idea of trying to improve my

health. I used greens every day in it. For the first week or so I felt good,

but suddenly I felt dreadful and initially did not know why. Absolutely no

energy, depressed, and the scariest thing was that my digestive system almost

slowed to a halt. Food would sit in my stomach, I wasn't having bowel

movements, I was terrified, thinking I had gastroparesis. Nothing I did that

should have helped did anything.

It finally dawned on me that most of what I was putting into the drinks,

including fruits, were goitrogens. So I completely stopped using them and

started feeling better within a couple days, but complete improvement took a

couple months of avoiding them.

I was too scared to use them again for over a year. But now maybe once or

twice a week I do put a minimal amount of greens into my drink and seem to

tolerate it, but I know other women can feel it immediately when they use any at

all (they also have thyroid problems) so it's very individual.

Not only cruciferous veggies, but most greens contain the goitrogens, as well as

several fruits. And tapioca (cassava) which is a major ingredient in

gluten-free products is high in goitrogens as well, and millet also contains

them.

Hope this helps.

>

> Hi all,

>

> I came across this blog post about raw veggies and it has me a little

> discouraged about my green smoothies. I have Hashimoto's thyroiditis

> (auto-immune) and it is pretty severe, along with other debilitating health

> conditions, so I obviously don't want to cause myself any more problems.

>

http://www.thehealthyhomeeconomist.com/2010/10/think-raw-veggies-are-best-think-\

again.html

> She cites this as one of her sources:

> http://www.westonaprice.org/abcs-of-nutrition/177

>

> It says that cruciferous vegetables should be cooked or they will block

> production of the thyroid hormone. It also cautions eating raw spinach,

> parsley, etc. (which I love in my smoothies) because they contain oxalic

> acid, which blocks iron and calcium absorption and may contribute to the

> formation of kidney stones. I think that drinking lots of water, plus

> varying greens helps with the oxalates right? But then the cruciferous

> vegetables thing threw me for a loop.

>

> I have been so hopeful for improvements in my health with eating more raw

> veggies with all the wonderful enzymes and vitamins and minerals. Please

> weigh in on this, if you have anything helpful to say, or know anything

> about this matter!

>

> Thanks,

>

>

Posted

I think that the Weston A. Price Foundation is really right on about a lot of

things, such as raw milk being an important component of a healthy diet and you

may want to read " Eat Fat, Lose Fat " by Dr. Enig and Sally Fallon.

Did you know that soy is also a goitrogen, unless consumed in a fermented form?

Also, Dr. Enig, a renowned expert on fats, recommends consuming 3 Tbsp. of raw

coconut oil a day to help support thyroid issues, among many other endocrine

issues.

thanks,

Joyce

>

> Hi all,

>

> I came across this blog post about raw veggies and it has me a little

> discouraged about my green smoothies. I have Hashimoto's thyroiditis

> (auto-immune) and it is pretty severe, along with other debilitating health

> conditions, so I obviously don't want to cause myself any more problems.

>

http://www.thehealthyhomeeconomist.com/2010/10/think-raw-veggies-are-best-think-\

again.html

> She cites this as one of her sources:

> http://www.westonaprice.org/abcs-of-nutrition/177

>

> It says that cruciferous vegetables should be cooked or they will block

> production of the thyroid hormone. It also cautions eating raw spinach,

> parsley, etc. (which I love in my smoothies) because they contain oxalic

> acid, which blocks iron and calcium absorption and may contribute to the

> formation of kidney stones. I think that drinking lots of water, plus

> varying greens helps with the oxalates right? But then the cruciferous

> vegetables thing threw me for a loop.

>

> I have been so hopeful for improvements in my health with eating more raw

> veggies with all the wonderful enzymes and vitamins and minerals. Please

> weigh in on this, if you have anything helpful to say, or know anything

> about this matter!

>

> Thanks,

>

>

Posted

,

Someone who introduced my wife to green smoothies, Snyder, has a blog.

I paraphrased your post into a comment on her blog.

http://kimberlysnyder.net/2010/11/02/seeyourimpact-org-and-organic-home-garden-k\

its/

I hope it is ok to do that. If anyone can answer your question, she can.

>

> Hi all,

>

> I came across this blog post about raw veggies and it has me a little

> discouraged about my green smoothies. I have Hashimoto's thyroiditis

> (auto-immune) and it is pretty severe, along with other debilitating health

> conditions, so I obviously don't want to cause myself any more problems.

>

http://www.thehealthyhomeeconomist.com/2010/10/think-raw-veggies-are-best-think-\

again.html

> She cites this as one of her sources:

> http://www.westonaprice.org/abcs-of-nutrition/177

>

> It says that cruciferous vegetables should be cooked or they will block

> production of the thyroid hormone. It also cautions eating raw spinach,

> parsley, etc. (which I love in my smoothies) because they contain oxalic

> acid, which blocks iron and calcium absorption and may contribute to the

> formation of kidney stones. I think that drinking lots of water, plus

> varying greens helps with the oxalates right? But then the cruciferous

> vegetables thing threw me for a loop.

>

> I have been so hopeful for improvements in my health with eating more raw

> veggies with all the wonderful enzymes and vitamins and minerals. Please

> weigh in on this, if you have anything helpful to say, or know anything

> about this matter!

>

> Thanks,

>

>

Posted

One of the interesting issues that this discussion brings up are the sometimes

enormous differences between the philosophies of the Weston A. Price Foundation

which espouses eating like our more recent ancestors, pre WWI Americans and

Europeans for the most part, and the " Green Smoothie " philosophy of

Boutenko who advocates eating like our Chimpanzee cousins, with whom, we share

97% of our DNA and eats a 99% raw diet. (Sorry for that long, run on sentence!)

Somewhere in the middle of all this are the " Paleo " eaters who eat like the

cavemen did with cooked meats and lots of different raw fruits and veggies that

they could forage with a few nuts and seeds thrown in here and there. (My 62

year-old former chiropractor follows this diet philosophy and looks amazing for

his age; very lean and fit.)

I am curious where other members of this group " weigh in " with their " food

philosophies " and how well they work for them!

thanks,

Joyce

>

Posted

I have had to completely change my views about food due to my allergies. I am of the mindset that so many people HAVE allergies from all the crap that is in food these days-the pesticide sprays, chemicals and garbage that are added are not natural, and our bodies don't know what to do with them. I almost want to laugh when someone says "I'm not allergic to any food", then they complain that they have frequent heartburn, headaches, stomach aches,excess weight, etc. They don't realize that those things ARE symptoms of food allergies, or sensitivities! I also believe that we eat too much of the same stuff every day, primarily wheat, soy and corn (lot of it is hidden in places you would never expect to find it) I believe that certain foods have a season for that very reason...we were not MEANT to eat things year round, but

just during the time they would grow in nature. Sure, new growing methods make it possible to eat fresh strawberries in January, but that doesn't mean we SHOULD. I try to eat as seasonally as possible, but with my diet being so limited by allergies, I have to make some adjustments and eat certain things out of season. If not for the allergies, I would eat a completely seasonal diet, giving my body a rest from things during the off times. I also believe we should eat small bits of food throughout the day, rather than stuffing our bellies with three meals a day and snacks. Your stomach is only the size of your fist, yet most people will stuff it with three or four times that amount, then wonder why they feel bad. I graze all day, rarely eating an actual "meal"....and my health is MUCH, MUCH, MUCH better for it! I had diabetes and irritable bowel syndrome for most of my life, along with some really serious

ailments, all of which resolved when I changed the way I eat. My blood sugar is perfect now, with no signs of diabetes, simply because I keep my sugar stable by grazing on proteins and balancing foods throughout the day. I also think we should eat foods in as close to their natural state as possible, usually raw. However, I like a nice hot bite of food and soup is my weakness, so I do cook some things. As much as I used to love meat, I now believe if I was MEANT to eat meat, I would be capable of hunting, catching, killing, and consuming an animal without the use of tools or cooking. It's clear to me that the human body is better designed for gardening, which tells me a plant based diet is a better option. Had anyone told me 10 years ago I would be a vegetarian, OR that I COULD change the way I ate, I would have laughed at them, but my own remarkable changes in my health are enough to convince me that I am

doing what is best for MY body, as others should do what they feel is best for THEIRS. I do not believe in following a "diet" designed for the masses-we are all far too different for that. From: hatchjoyce <Joyce_Handy@...>Subject: Re: Goitrogenics, oxalates, and raw veggies - please weigh in Date: Friday, November 5, 2010, 9:58 PM

One of the interesting issues that this discussion brings up are the sometimes enormous differences between the philosophies of the Weston A. Price Foundation which espouses eating like our more recent ancestors, pre WWI Americans and Europeans for the most part, and the "Green Smoothie" philosophy of Boutenko who advocates eating like our Chimpanzee cousins, with whom, we share 97% of our DNA and eats a 99% raw diet. (Sorry for that long, run on sentence!)

Somewhere in the middle of all this are the "Paleo" eaters who eat like the cavemen did with cooked meats and lots of different raw fruits and veggies that they could forage with a few nuts and seeds thrown in here and there. (My 62 year-old former chiropractor follows this diet philosophy and looks amazing for his age; very lean and fit.)

I am curious where other members of this group "weigh in" with their "food philosophies" and how well they work for them!

thanks,

Joyce

>

Posted

,

That made a lot of sense! Never thought of 'seasonal' food being what we should

eat in the seasons.

I have felt much better since I started Doug Kaufmans Phase 1 diet last Feb. I

was very strict with it for about 4 months, and the weight just melted off. Im a

little more lenient now.

I have cut out all sugar. Except for a little honey and the fruit I put in my

Vita Mix. I dont like to eat fruit, but I'll drink it!

I am a meat eater. For me, I can lose weight with no sugar and a lot of meat.

But since I got my Vita Mix I have drank more smoothies than eat a meal. Its

soooooooo good! I hope I dont gain weight from all the fruit sugar.

About the goitrogen foods. I looked up the list today and Strawberries are on

it. Apparently they dont bother me coz I have them everyday. I used to have a

spinach salad everyday. Im bad about eating one thing for months til I get sick

of it. Im sick of salad! Soon I'll be sick of strawberries ;o)

pam

--

Posted

> About the goitrogen foods. I looked up the list today and Strawberries are on

it. Apparently they dont bother me coz I have them everyday. I used to have a

spinach salad everyday. Im bad about eating one thing for months til I get sick

of it. Im sick of salad! Soon I'll be sick of strawberries ;o)

>

> pam

I guess thats exactly what I mean about foods on " lists " and " diets " . One thing

may bother some, not others. Strawberries effect my thyroid very badly, as does

spinach, yet I am fine with brasicas, which most people with thyroid issues

can't tolerate. I eat at LEAST one whole cauliflower every day, with no

problems, but three leaves of spinach would throw my kidneys into a tizzy. That

is why I think we have to listen to what our OWN body says, not some list, lol.

>

> --

>

Posted

wow we have a few " pam's " on here.  :)  brenda how can you tell your thyroid acts up with a bit of the offending food?  i have hashimoto's and would love to be able to discern this on my quest to wellness.  thanks.

pam (ny)On Sat, Nov 6, 2010 at 12:40 AM, <berrywell@...> wrote:

 

> About the goitrogen foods. I looked up the list today and Strawberries are on it. Apparently they dont bother me coz I have them everyday. I used to have a spinach salad everyday. Im bad about eating one thing for months til I get sick of it. Im sick of salad! Soon I'll be sick of strawberries ;o)

>

> pam

I guess thats exactly what I mean about foods on " lists " and " diets " . One thing may bother some, not others. Strawberries effect my thyroid very badly, as does spinach, yet I am fine with brasicas, which most people with thyroid issues can't tolerate. I eat at LEAST one whole cauliflower every day, with no problems, but three leaves of spinach would throw my kidneys into a tizzy. That is why I think we have to listen to what our OWN body says, not some list, lol.

>

> --

>

Posted

I SO AGREE with this - that is why I like the book, "Diet Wise". It helps you learn how to do an elimination diet to find YOUR hidden food allergies...

I think you were on to something with your post to me about the salictites (sp?) Not those is particular (although I will look into it) but the idea that a new food is causing me problems. I had been eating lots of coleslaw - perhaps it is the culprit. Am going to start a food diary and see if I can pin this down - I'm feeling better yesterday and today. One day at a time ;-)

Blessings,Lea Ann SavageSatellite Beach, FL(321) 773-7088 (home)(321-961-9219 (cell)))><'>www.VitamixLady.comwww..com<:)))><

Re: Goitrogenics, oxalates, and raw veggies - please weigh in

> About the goitrogen foods. I looked up the list today and Strawberries are on it. Apparently they dont bother me coz I have them everyday. I used to have a spinach salad everyday. Im bad about eating one thing for months til I get sick of it. Im sick of salad! Soon I'll be sick of strawberries ;o)> > pamI guess thats exactly what I mean about foods on "lists" and "diets". One thing may bother some, not others. Strawberries effect my thyroid very badly, as does spinach, yet I am fine with brasicas, which most people with thyroid issues can't tolerate. I eat at LEAST one whole cauliflower every day, with no problems, but three leaves of spinach would throw my kidneys into a tizzy. That is why I think we have to listen to what our OWN body says, not some list, lol.> > -->

Posted

I think we need to listen to our bodies but by the same taken, such lists can be useful to alert us to possible problem foods, even if they're not all the same for all people. It's comforting when experiencing a bad reaction to be able to scan a list and say "Aha! Maybe THAT caused my problem!" Note can be taken and either eliminating altogether or sampling again to see if the same reaction occurs can further help to pin down or eliminate offending items. And of course, different sources for similar items can also cause problems but one thing at a time. :)

Re: Re: Goitrogenics, oxalates, and raw veggies - please weigh in

I SO AGREE with this - that is why I like the book, "Diet Wise". It helps you learn how to do an elimination diet to find YOUR hidden food allergies...

I think you were on to something with your post to me about the salictites (sp?) Not those is particular (although I will look into it) but the idea that a new food is causing me problems. I had been eating lots of coleslaw - perhaps it is the culprit. Am going to start a food diary and see if I can pin this down - I'm feeling better yesterday and today. One day at a time ;-)

Blessings,

Lea Ann Savage

Satellite Beach, FL

(321) 773-7088 (home)

(321-961-9219 (cell)

www.VitamixLady.com

www..com

<:)))><

Re: Goitrogenics, oxalates, and raw veggies - please weigh in

> About the goitrogen foods. I looked up the list today and Strawberries are on it. Apparently they dont bother me coz I have them everyday. I used to have a spinach salad everyday. Im bad about eating one thing for months til I get sick of it. Im sick of salad! Soon I'll be sick of strawberries ;o)

>

> pam

I guess thats exactly what I mean about foods on "lists" and "diets". One thing may bother some, not others. Strawberries effect my thyroid very badly, as does spinach, yet I am fine with brasicas, which most people with thyroid issues can't tolerate. I eat at LEAST one whole cauliflower every day, with no problems, but three leaves of spinach would throw my kidneys into a tizzy. That is why I think we have to listen to what our OWN body says, not some list, lol.

Posted

Excellent point, . Many lists have given me knowledge about foods with potential issues, and afforded me the chance to check for myself whether they were causing me problems. I do know of people who will eliminate a food just because it is on a list though, and I only meant that we should check for ourselves. From: <kareningotham@...>Subject: Re: Re: Goitrogenics, oxalates, and raw veggies - please weigh in Date: Saturday, November 6, 2010, 9:30 AM

I think we need to listen to our bodies but by the same taken, such lists can be useful to alert us to possible problem foods, even if they're not all the same for all people. It's comforting when experiencing a bad reaction to be able to scan a list and say "Aha! Maybe THAT caused my problem!" Note can be taken and either eliminating altogether or sampling again to see if the same reaction occurs can further help to pin down or eliminate offending items. And of course, different sources for similar items can also cause problems but one thing at a time. :)

Re: Re: Goitrogenics, oxalates, and raw veggies - please weigh in

I SO AGREE with this - that is why I like the book, "Diet Wise". It helps you learn how to do an elimination diet to find YOUR hidden food allergies...

I think you were on to something with your post to me about the salictites (sp?) Not those is particular (although I will look into it) but the idea that a new food is causing me problems. I had been eating lots of coleslaw - perhaps it is the culprit. Am going to start a food diary and see if I can pin this down - I'm feeling better yesterday and today. One day at a time ;-)

Blessings,

Lea Ann Savage

Satellite Beach, FL

(321) 773-7088 (home)

(321-961-9219 (cell)

www.VitamixLady.com

www..com

<:)))><

Re: Goitrogenics, oxalates, and raw veggies - please weigh in

> About the goitrogen foods. I looked up the list today and Strawberries are on it. Apparently they dont bother me coz I have them everyday. I used to have a spinach salad everyday. Im bad about eating one thing for months til I get sick of it. Im sick of salad! Soon I'll be sick of strawberries ;o)

>

> pam

I guess thats exactly what I mean about foods on "lists" and "diets". One thing may bother some, not others. Strawberries effect my thyroid very badly, as does spinach, yet I am fine with brasicas, which most people with thyroid issues can't tolerate. I eat at LEAST one whole cauliflower every day, with no problems, but three leaves of spinach would throw my kidneys into a tizzy. That is why I think we have to listen to what our OWN body says, not some list, lol.

Posted

wow we have a few "pam's" on here. :) brenda how can you tell your thyroid acts up with a bit of the offending food? i have hashimoto's and would love to be able to discern this on my quest to wellness. thanks.

pam (ny)In my case, Pam, I have lupus, which tends to aggravate other conditions and make them hard to manage. Through careful use of a detailed food diary, I learned to tell which foods were aggravating which condition. For years, I was on many very caustic medications to control the lupus, and those very medication cause many of my body systems to basically quit functioning properly, such as my kidneys and thyroid. Over the years of managing my illness, I simply learned to tune in to what was going on in my body and to make adjustments accordingly. With my thyroid, I can tell it is out of whack by the condition of my skin and my energy levels. If I start noticing I am tired more than usual, or my skin starts feeling itchy or dry-then I know my thyroid is not happy about something I have consumes, or that I need to up my thyroid replacement (I adjust my own levels of thyroid

meds, having learned that the docs rely too much on a test once year, but my thyroid changes daily so I listen to IT, as opposed to some test-has taken many years of built up trust with my doc to get her to prescribe the RIGHT thyroid med, and with a script with enough so I can make adjustments as needed) Your body WILL alert you to issues going on, if you learn to LISTEN to it. We are taught to medicate every ailment and symptom, and those very symptoms are often alarm bells we should be listening to.,_._,___

Posted

Oh, I realized that and agree completely. People who are having no (apparent, anyway) problems whatsoever might go so far as to eliminate something just because it's on a list. You're quite right--listen to your body.

Re: Re: Goitrogenics, oxalates, and raw veggies - please weigh in

I SO AGREE with this - that is why I like the book, "Diet Wise". It helps you learn how to do an elimination diet to find YOUR hidden food allergies...

I think you were on to something with your post to me about the salictites (sp?) Not those is particular (although I will look into it) but the idea that a new food is causing me problems. I had been eating lots of coleslaw - perhaps it is the culprit. Am going to start a food diary and see if I can pin this down - I'm feeling better yesterday and today. One day at a time ;-)

Blessings,

Lea Ann Savage

Satellite Beach, FL

(321) 773-7088 (home)

(321-961-9219 (cell)

www.VitamixLady.com

www..com

<:)))><

Re: Goitrogenics, oxalates, and raw veggies - please weigh in

> About the goitrogen foods. I looked up the list today and Strawberries are on it. Apparently they dont bother me coz I have them everyday. I used to have a spinach salad everyday. Im bad about eating one thing for months til I get sick of it. Im sick of salad! Soon I'll be sick of strawberries ;o)

>

> pam

I guess thats exactly what I mean about foods on "lists" and "diets". One thing may bother some, not others. Strawberries effect my thyroid very badly, as does spinach, yet I am fine with brasicas, which most people with thyroid issues can't tolerate. I eat at LEAST one whole cauliflower every day, with no problems, but three leaves of spinach would throw my kidneys into a tizzy. That is why I think we have to listen to what our OWN body says, not some list, lol.

Posted

Hi ,I haven't asked my doctor - I will in a couple weeks when I go.  That will help.  I am wondering about any of the leafy greens being ok.  I was just so excited to get more greens and especially to get so many in an easy way like blending them up!  But other veggies will be helpful for my body.   I just need to re-think and compile a list of veggies I can eat.

We'll see!

On Fri, Nov 5, 2010 at 6:57 AM, <kareningotham@...> wrote:

I think you're supposed to vary your greens anyway--couldn't you just enjoy cruciferous veggies cooked and limit your raw spinach intake (more than the rest of us)? There are lots of other leafy and non-leafy greens that you can throw into the mix.

Have you asked you doctor about this? In the meantime, I'd play it safe and avoid the broccoli and cauliflower crudités on the buffet table. There are worse things than not having a broccoli-and-cabbage smoothie and cauliflower isn't green anyway (given that I detest it, I'm always happy to have the opportunity to take a swipe at it!). A lot of people find kale too bitter; maybe Swiss chard instead? And romaine's a great standby

Goitrogenics, oxalates, and raw veggies - please weigh in

 

Hi all,

I came across this blog post about raw veggies and it has me a little discouraged about my green smoothies.  I have Hashimoto's thyroiditis (auto-immune) and it is pretty severe, along with other debilitating health conditions, so I obviously don't want to cause myself any more problems.  

http://www.thehealthyhomeeconomist.com/2010/10/think-raw-veggies-are-best-think-again.html   She cites this as one of her sources: http://www.westonaprice.org/abcs-of-nutrition/177

It says that cruciferous vegetables should be cooked or they will block production of the thyroid hormone.  It also cautions eating raw spinach, parsley, etc. (which I love in my smoothies) because they contain oxalic acid, which blocks iron and calcium absorption and may contribute to the formation of kidney stones. I think that drinking lots of water, plus varying greens helps with the oxalates right?  But then the cruciferous vegetables thing threw me for a loop.

I have been so hopeful for improvements in my health with eating more raw veggies with all the wonderful enzymes and vitamins and minerals.  Please weigh in on this, if you have anything helpful to say, or know anything about this matter!

Posted

Oh wow , that is severe Hashi's.  Thank you for your input.  I really did feel worse doing green smoothies every day, and thought I was crazy.  So I am figuring out what works for me!  I had a tiny bit of energy last night, so I made pumpkin ice cream, and also a delicious roasted asparagus soup!  So do you not eat any leafy greens as a rule?  That is interesting about the liquid-form.  That is what I had thought before, but reading about goitrogenics gave me pause.  

You have some amazing determination and I am impressed.  I totally agree that we all needs to find what works for our particular bodies.  I am glad you around to " aggravate " society with all that you have learned!  And to flash your leopard undies!  :D

On Fri, Nov 5, 2010 at 7:23 AM, <berrywell@...> wrote:

I also have Hashimoto's severe enough that I have gone into myexedema coma twice from it, so I have researched this carefully.  Yes, MANY veggies are NOT good for thyroid conditions.  Turns out I was actually making my thyroid condition worse by consuming too many of the wrong kinds of fruits and veggies, and unfortunately, I had to give up many of my favorites.  That's the bad news.  The GOOD news is, there are plenty of other veggies that are fine for smoothies, and will not disrupt the hormone balance-and you may need to make those adjustments.  That said, its important to remember that the information in the article (and similar info available) is based on consuming those veggies and fruits in their whole state.  When liquidized, they are absorbed differently by the body, and the nutrients are more bioavailable in liquid form-which means you are also taking in additional calcium, iron, and the other things that are supposedly " blocked " from absorption.  In liquid form, you are likely to get what you need and eliminate what you do not.  I have pre existing kidney issues due to lupus, so I have to be VERY careful with high oxalates.  Having recovered from the brink of checking out of this world simply through diet, I have learned to NOT listen to everything that is defined as a do or don't for the masses-you need to listen to YOUR body.  If you feel good doing what you are doing, then keep on doing it.  If you are having persistent health issues, try keeping a food journal to identify what is causing them, then make adjustments.  There is no cookie cutter approach, and I think it is unwise to start or stop doing something just because you " heard " that it causes problems.  Everyone has different nutritional needs, and your own body and intuition is the best way to make sure those needs are being met.  For what it's worth, I was told many years ago to " get my affairs in order " , and I was not expected to stick around much longer.  Due to relying on my OWN thoughts about food and nutrition, I am still around aggravating society with my often unpopular thoughts on nutrition, and flashing my leopard panties just because I still can!

Posted

Hi ,Thanks for de-lurking to weigh in. :)  I was feeling generally worse, energy-wise, when I was expecting to feel better, so I am interested to hear your experience.  I have eliminated them for now and will see if I can add a bit in here and there after a break.  I already knew that I didn't feel as well with strawberries or peaches.  I did not known that about tapioca!

Do you still make smoothies when you are not doing the greens?  Any good ideas for what is good in them?  I try to only do about 1/3 fruit in mine to keep blood sugar stable.

On Fri, Nov 5, 2010 at 8:05 AM, Cin <b53cjf@...> wrote:

Hi ,

I mostly lurk but felt I could give some info on this.

I also have Hashimoto's.  I bought the VM with the idea of trying to improve my health.   I used greens every day in it.  For the first week or so I felt good, but suddenly I felt dreadful and initially did not know why.  Absolutely no energy, depressed, and the scariest thing was that my digestive system almost slowed to a halt.   Food would sit in my stomach, I wasn't having bowel movements, I was terrified, thinking I had gastroparesis.  Nothing I did that should have helped did anything.

It finally dawned on me that most of what I was putting into the drinks, including fruits, were goitrogens.   So I completely stopped using them and started feeling better within a couple days, but complete improvement took a couple months of avoiding them.

I was too scared to use them again for over a year.   But now maybe once or twice a week I do put a minimal amount of greens into my drink and seem to tolerate it, but I know other women can feel it immediately when they use any at all (they also have thyroid problems) so it's very individual.

Not only cruciferous veggies, but most greens contain the goitrogens, as well as several fruits.  And tapioca (cassava) which is a major ingredient in gluten-free products is high in goitrogens as well, and millet also contains them.

Hope this helps.

Posted

Hi Joyce,I totally agree with what you said in your other email - there are enormous differences between the philosophies of what is supposed to be healthy!  So I guess it is finding out what works for each of us and taking wisdom from each as we see fit for us.  I do use coconut oil all the time, and it is wonderful.  I did not know that about the 3 Tbsp though - I'll see if incorporating that in to my diet helps me. :)

Thanks,On Fri, Nov 5, 2010 at 10:48 AM, hatchjoyce <Joyce_Handy@...> wrote:

I think that the Weston A. Price Foundation is really right on about a lot of things, such as raw milk being an important component of a healthy diet and you may want to read " Eat Fat, Lose Fat " by Dr. Enig and Sally Fallon.

Did you know that soy is also a goitrogen, unless consumed in a fermented form?  Also, Dr. Enig, a renowned expert on fats, recommends consuming 3 Tbsp. of raw coconut oil a day to help support thyroid issues, among many other endocrine issues.

thanks,

Joyce

Posted

I think romaine's probably safe and the taste is pleasant, too (Lea Ann got some bitter stuff once but I've not had that happen). It and the chard should be safe for the time being. And maybe some wheatgrass juice? It's intense but you only need a little.

Goitrogenics, oxalates, and raw veggies - please weigh in

Hi all,

I came across this blog post about raw veggies and it has me a little discouraged about my green smoothies. I have Hashimoto's thyroiditis (auto-immune) and it is pretty severe, along with other debilitating health conditions, so I obviously don't want to cause myself any more problems.

http://www.thehealthyhomeeconomist.com/2010/10/think-raw-veggies-are-best-think-again.html She cites this as one of her sources: http://www.westonaprice.org/abcs-of-nutrition/177

It says that cruciferous vegetables should be cooked or they will block production of the thyroid hormone. It also cautions eating raw spinach, parsley, etc. (which I love in my smoothies) because they contain oxalic acid, which blocks iron and calcium absorption and may contribute to the formation of kidney stones. I think that drinking lots of water, plus varying greens helps with the oxalates right? But then the cruciferous vegetables thing threw me for a loop.

I have been so hopeful for improvements in my health with eating more raw veggies with all the wonderful enzymes and vitamins and minerals. Please weigh in on this, if you have anything helpful to say, or know anything about this matter!

Posted

Hi ,Thanks!  I couldn't find your comment on that post.  I would be interested to hear what she has to say.This group is so wonderful and helpful - thanks everyone!!!  Sorry for so many emails!

On Fri, Nov 5, 2010 at 11:33 AM, gary m harders jr <garyharde@...> wrote:

,

Someone who introduced my wife to green smoothies, Snyder, has a blog. I paraphrased your post into a comment on her blog.

http://kimberlysnyder.net/2010/11/02/seeyourimpact-org-and-organic-home-garden-kits/

I hope it is ok to do that. If anyone can answer your question, she can.

Posted

Hi ,Yes - romaine should be great huh?  And I love celery.  I'll try the chard, and the wheatgrass.  For some reason, when I think of wheatgrass I get mildly nauseous.  Funny - I don't know if I've even ever had it that I would be recalling a reaction to.  Still might be worth a try - I know it is a super food.  

Thanks again for all the help.On Sat, Nov 6, 2010 at 4:50 PM, <kareningotham@...> wrote:

I think romaine's probably safe and the taste is pleasant, too (Lea Ann got some bitter stuff once but I've not had that happen). It and the chard should be safe for the time being. And maybe some wheatgrass juice? It's intense but you only need a little.

Goitrogenics, oxalates, and raw veggies - please weigh in

 

Hi all,

I came across this blog post about raw veggies and it has me a little discouraged about my green smoothies.  I have Hashimoto's thyroiditis (auto-immune) and it is pretty severe, along with other debilitating health conditions, so I obviously don't want to cause myself any more problems.  

http://www.thehealthyhomeeconomist.com/2010/10/think-raw-veggies-are-best-think-again.html   She cites this as one of her sources: http://www.westonaprice.org/abcs-of-nutrition/177

It says that cruciferous vegetables should be cooked or they will block production of the thyroid hormone.  It also cautions eating raw spinach, parsley, etc. (which I love in my smoothies) because they contain oxalic acid, which blocks iron and calcium absorption and may contribute to the formation of kidney stones. I think that drinking lots of water, plus varying greens helps with the oxalates right?  But then the cruciferous vegetables thing threw me for a loop.

I have been so hopeful for improvements in my health with eating more raw veggies with all the wonderful enzymes and vitamins and minerals.  Please weigh in on this, if you have anything helpful to say, or know anything about this matter!

Posted

CELERY! Great idea! See? You're already getting creative!

The dark greens have more nutrition but celery's nice and refreshing and has lots of mineral. I read years ago to juice some celery along with apples and the juice is truly delicious (and a lot more interesting than plain apple juice). But I guess I have a prejudice--I like Cel-Ray soda, too.

Goitrogenics, oxalates, and raw veggies - please weigh in

Hi all,

I came across this blog post about raw veggies and it has me a little discouraged about my green smoothies. I have Hashimoto's thyroiditis (auto-immune) and it is pretty severe, along with other debilitating health conditions, so I obviously don't want to cause myself any more problems.

http://www.thehealthyhomeeconomist.com/2010/10/think-raw-veggies-are-best-think-again.html She cites this as one of her sources: http://www.westonaprice.org/abcs-of-nutrition/177

It says that cruciferous vegetables should be cooked or they will block production of the thyroid hormone. It also cautions eating raw spinach, parsley, etc. (which I love in my smoothies) because they contain oxalic acid, which blocks iron and calcium absorption and may contribute to the formation of kidney stones. I think that drinking lots of water, plus varying greens helps with the oxalates right? But then the cruciferous vegetables thing threw me for a loop.

I have been so hopeful for improvements in my health with eating more raw veggies with all the wonderful enzymes and vitamins and minerals. Please weigh in on this, if you have anything helpful to say, or know anything about this matter!

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...