Guest guest Posted September 21, 2007 Report Posted September 21, 2007 I just saw this topic heading. I think if everyone stopped vaxing intitially there would be a big fallout. There would probably be an increase in morbidity and mortality amongst infants due to measles. I am not worried about my 5 and 7yo getting measles but I would be considerably worried about a baby gettting it. Due to the vax program mothers have alot less immunity to protect their infants in the first year. I, for one, don't have natural immunity to measles - and perhaps those who do would not be getting their immunity 'boosted' periodically because the virus is not really circulating these days. I could be very wrong (I would hope so!); but I think this seems a likely scenario and it would take awhile for things to rebalance. When people say they believe there is no such thing as herd immunity I'm a little confused. Why else have measles outbreaks effectively stopped? I'm not convinced of the long-term safety but this seems to be one vaccine that is very effective. Carly. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 21, 2007 Report Posted September 21, 2007 Tash, I wouldn't be concerned about my children getting measles - though I would if they were infants. The mortality rate is around 1 in 1000 - but for infants the risks are somewhat greater. I'm talking in the general sense here - anecdotally there will always be those that handle it just fine. In immunnocompromised people the fatality rate about 30%, according to Wikipedia - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Measles#Complications I'm not interested in getting the MMR for myself or my kids. I'm just talking about what may happen in the unlikely event of everyone stopping vaccinating. Carly. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 21, 2007 Report Posted September 21, 2007 , If herd immunity is a myth - I am wondering why the periodic cycles of measles have dissapeared since widespread MMR vaccination? What is your theory? Believe me, in my 5.5 years of research I have run the gamut of " vaccination is safe and effective " to " vaccination is unsafe and ineffective " and now I have ended up somewhere in the middle. I find the more research I do the more moderate my views haev become. I always suspected the *truth* was somewhere in the middle. There are many shades of grey to this subject, IMO. I no longer vaccinate my kids (haven't since my youngest was born). Not because I don't think they are effective (and I don't think we can make blanket statements as each vaccine is different)but because there are no long-term studies to convince me of the safety. Carly. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 21, 2007 Report Posted September 21, 2007 , sorry, I should have clarified that I was talking specifically about " herd immunity " in terms of measles. I think HI is different depending on which vaccine/disease you are talking about. I really liked this thread on MDC.com, which explains it in more detail with differnt thoughts from both " sides " - http://www.mothering.com/discussions/showthread.php? t=733811 & highlight=herd+immunity (might have to cut and paste - URL too long!) Carly. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 21, 2007 Report Posted September 21, 2007 Re-sending - my earlier mail seems to have vanished into cyberspace - again!! Sue > >*> >*> I had measles as a child too, Tash. I had all the childhood >*> illnesses - including pertussis against which I was >*> vaccinated. <rolls eyes> My friends all had measles. We >*> all survived it, and like you, I never knew anyone who was >*> desperately ill or died from it. I have said many times >*> that I think in part that was because our mothers knew how >*> to *nurse* us when ill. My memory of measles was two weeks >*> in bed in a darkened room, plenty of sleep and plenty of >*> fluids, and being rather fed up that I wasn't playing with >*> my friends!! I think that measles itself is pretty inocuous >*> - but like flu, its complications can be serious. But I >*> also believe that complications can arise in part because of >*> poor care. Malnutrition also plays a part in measles >*> complications, as with many other illnesses. >*> >*> There will always be exceptions - it's possible to die from >*> a common cold if complications set in. Another reason to >*> approach it from the angle of keeping the body healthy and >*> strong, rather than worry about treating an illness if and >*> when it arrives. >*> >*> I have to be honest - I fail to understand the hysteria that >*> surrounds measles and all the other childhood illnesses. >*> I've never been able to understand why a vaccine was ever >*> developed against an illness that has been noted to offer >*> protection against atopic illness, diabetes and cancer in >*> later life. No contest, in my book. >*> >*> I don't believe it's that easy to obtain accurate statistics >*> for measles morbidity - or do you mean mortality? Have a >*> look at this: >*> http://www.hpa.org.uk/infections/topics_az/measles/nots_and_d eaths.htm - it's for the UK, but covers the period 1940-2006. and if you look at the accompanying graph (http://www.hpa.org.uk/infections/topics_az/measles/measles_deaths2007.htm) it is easy to see that measles deaths plummeted long before the vaccine was introduced. Case closed for me... Love, light and peace, Sue >*> >*> I had both german and red measles as a child within 4 months >*> of each other, >*> and under the age of a year. I know lots of people who had >*> measles as a >*> child and survived. I've never heard of anyone first-hand >*> dying from it. >*> >*> What's the morbidity rates for measles in un-vaccinated populations? >*> >*> Curious, >*> >*> Tash Quote
Guest guest Posted September 21, 2007 Report Posted September 21, 2007 Hi Lori, Yes I am talking about artificial immunity. From what I can gather that is what the whole theory is about. From Wikipedia - " Although no vaccine offers 100% protection, the spread of disease from person to person is much higher in those who remain un-vaccinated. [5] Virologists have found that when a certain percentage of a population is vaccinated, the spread of the disease is effectively stopped. This critical percentage, called the herd immunity threshold, depends on the disease and the vaccine.[4] It is the general aim of those involved in public health to establish herd immunity in most populations. " http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herd_immunity Carly. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 21, 2007 Report Posted September 21, 2007 Hi , No I agree with you that measles hasn't " dissapeared " . I should have qualified that. What I meant is that it is not circulating in any widespread way. The notifications in Australia (where I am) have been very low for years. If it were widely circulating infants would be contracting it left, right and centre - and they're not. Babies under 1 year are not vaxed for measles and many of them are not getting passive immunity from their mothers - so if measles were circulating many infants would likely contract it (and probably have complications). In countries that don't vax for measles it is still around. Yet those countries who do vax have very low levels of measles. Generation after generation had measles and yet this one doesn't. As far as I know, that has nothing to do with changes in hygiene and living conditions (with other diseases, yes). In one sense I would like my girls to get measles and have natural immunity - but its just not around! Believe me, I have kept my ear out! I just want to reiterate I'm not " provax " or " antivax " - I really hate those catagories!! It prevents any true analysis of information. Carly. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 21, 2007 Report Posted September 21, 2007 >> Anyway, I'm not so much anti-vax as I am anti-injury and our babies are being injured left and right. I think measles has died down because that's what diseases do, they come they go -- quite like the plague, you don't hear anyone dying of it today, that doesn't mean it couldn't happen, but that particular diease ran its course amongst humans. > , I'm not trying to prove anything - the evidence suggests it. The scientific community certainly seems to accept the hypothesis. You say measles has run it's course on its own. I think this is just not true. Why are there still epidemics in other countries? Why is it more widespread in Germany? Might it be because their vaccination rates are much lower? The fact is that measles ISN'T " coming and going " . The natural cycle has been interrupted somehow. It may come back at some stage - I'm not saying it won't - but to deny that vaccination has had any effect flies in the face of the evidence. Carly. PS. I really recommend the Mothering vaccine forum for lots of fact- based information. There are credentialled people on both sides and lots of interesting debate. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 21, 2007 Report Posted September 21, 2007 Carly, Please look at the graph previously sent re: deaths from measles. They say that plagarism is the best form of compliment - so, I'm going to plararize an author of an article (but I cannot remember who wrote it... LOL)... Anyway - the above is my disclaimer.... Mainstream doctors and media has made nearly almost all Americans' hypocondriacs! (end plagarisms...) In countries where there were " mass deaths " of these diseases - you were dealing with people (and at a time) where nutrition was nil; water was completely unsanitary; living conditions were extemely crowded - etc.... In America - we have clean water (somewhat) - we have households that are not over-crowded (most) - we don't let our children play in the sewer (most).... hence - the decline... Ladies and Gents.... quit buying into this crap! You want a healthy child? Give them nutrition. Give them exercise. Give them love. Give them sanitary living conditions (albeit, not " too " sanitary - many germs are " good " ). This is all my personal opinion - not meant as medical advice (another disclaimer)... Quote
Guest guest Posted September 21, 2007 Report Posted September 21, 2007 Randi, Thanks, I realise that " mass deaths " from measles are due to mitigating factors. I personally am not afraid of measles. Believe me, I have read all the " antivax " information. I read it for years. Then I realised that this couldn't be qualified as " research " because I was only looking at one side, essentially. Then I started to learn alot and realised some of the antivax stuff was pretty misleading. Some if it true, and some just not based on fact. So now I am much more moderate in my views, I guess. Therer is misinformation on both sides and I just wanted to get the facts. It's pretty much medically accepted that infants are more at risk from measles. That was my original point in the discussion. And while I may be wary of vaccines for many reasons I can see some of the benefits of herd immunity. For one thing, there are a huge number of immunocompromised people walking around these days. Without the protection of " the herd " there would be large numbers of fatalities amongst them. My mum just started chemo 2 weeks ago so she is now part of this club. There's little doubt that if everyone stopped vaxing these people would be especially vulnerable. Carly. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 21, 2007 Report Posted September 21, 2007 Joe, I would love to see the studies you are referring to - thanks! Carly. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 21, 2007 Report Posted September 21, 2007 > > So, basically, you think the vaccine works. I think it just gives our body a case of chronic measles that our immune system has to fight. Might be a case of semantics, might not. > To me it seems the vaccine works. I have heard this idea before of getting a " chronic case of measles " and it doesn't make sense? where is the evidence of this? Carly. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 21, 2007 Report Posted September 21, 2007 > Hi, In all the research I've done, I have discovered that when ever their is an outbreak of an illness, like measles, then you will find that the majority of those that get the measles have been vaccinated. This holds true across the spectrum of illnesses vaccinated for. > Joe > P.S. This is on a per capita basis. 100 vaccinated and 100 not vaccinated. You will always find more cases among the vaccinated. > Joe, let's say there was a population of 200, and 10 of these were unvaccinated, and the vaccine failure rate was 10% (so the protection rate was 90% - just using this as an example). Now if all those 10 unvaxed people got measles (likely) and the vaccine " failures " also got it there would be 19 of them. So there would be more vaxed people getting it than unvaxed. But this is misleading because there were many more who were vaxed. And 171 of these (90% of 190) DID NOT get measles. Do you see what I am getting at? In a highly vaxed population there will be more vaxed that get it because there are many more of them. It is the " attack rate " in both groups that is important. Carly. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 21, 2007 Report Posted September 21, 2007 Hi Meryl, Yes, the only thing that made sense to me was the Wakefield " measles in the gut " thing. And when I get a chance I would like to look further into it. I just don't necessarily *buy* that vaccine immunity is really a " chronic case of the disease " manifesting as immunity, you know? For some this may be true, but the vast majourity of vaccinated people? Believe me, I understand that injection of viruses and bacteria is a dubious practice. This is one of the main reasons I don't get my kids vaccinated. I still think vaccine safety is not proven. Carly. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 21, 2007 Report Posted September 21, 2007 , I am talking about 200 people who were exposed to the disease. Measles, for eg, is highly infectious. Everyone used to get it as a matter of course - not necessarily a 'bad' thing. I agree a strong immune system is important, but won't necessarily protect you from measles - just help you get over it without complications. OTOH, if we are talking about something like invasive Hib that is something else altogether and the healthiest people can be carriers and asymptomatic. Carly. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 21, 2007 Report Posted September 21, 2007 > > But, it does not mean that the vaxed ones who didn't get it are being protected by the vaccine. It does mean that they didn't come in contact with the bacteria. Or their immune systems were strong enough to fight it off even after having been vaxed. I just don't believe that injecting toxins in to a person confers immunity on that person. The presence of antigens after being vaxed only means that the immune system produced them as a result of the vaccination and not exposure to the real thing. *************************************** I was talking about a group of 200 *who have been exposed* to the disease. Measles is a viral disease, not bacterial. Why else would the vaxed ones have not been protected from the vaccine? We are talking about a highly infectious disease here. Please, I suggest people do some rudimentary reading on these diseases. I'm going to leave this discussion as it is because I don't see the point in arguing without that essential foundation. If people aren't willing to research outside of this group or " antivax " literature then how can they say they have " researched " ? I am certainly not saying this is true of everyone here, and certainly Meryl is one of the best informed people out there. But some of the assertions in this discussion have been a bit alarming. Like thinking Measles is a " bacterial " disease; and antibody titres are " antigens " . Carly. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 21, 2007 Report Posted September 21, 2007 > > Carly, with all due respect, I have been " reading " both sides of this argument for six years. Just because I can't toss out the citations at a moment's notice, does not make what I know any less true, or anyone else for that matter. > > You can go forward believing that they work -- I don't think they work, I think they harm. I don't think they " ever " worked, and if they did they did so by giving the person a case of what they were trying to avoid. > > Peace. , I don't necessarily believe they " work " or " don't work " . Its more complex than that. *That's what I am trying to get across*. Some work better than others. The pertussis vaccine is notoriously ineffective, for example. but not completely ineffective, either. I would say that *they* vastly overstate the effectiveness, yes. When they say " 99% effective " we all know its a croc. Probably 60 - 80% for most vaccines would be more accurate. Based on epidemiology, animal studies, serology, etc. I honestly have no desire to argue...and certainly less desire to stir up trouble. I'm just interested in fact-based arguments and sorting the fact from the fiction (on both sides, that is). I'm sure you are too. We are all trying to do the best we can for our families. Yes, well, vaccines are supposed to work by inducing a sub-clinical case of the disease and thus immunity, so I suppose you are right there. Its a shame there is no room for dissenting opinion here. I know posts that agree with my views have been censored. I don't vax. I have concerns about vaccine safety. That doesn't mean that I have to subscribe to a view that vaccines are completely ineffective and there is no such thing as herd immunity. I think that's just denying scientific reality. Carly. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 21, 2007 Report Posted September 21, 2007 --- In Vaccinations , " Fieldman " <> The underhandedness of the pharmaceutical companies and politicians etc have also influenced me. I am not trying to change your mind, or tell you that you are wrong. I just can't relate to your view thats all. I find it hard to understand why others, who have done the research, still think vaccines have merit. I am a country girl, who grew up with all the childhood diseases, and got dirty as a kid. That probably influenced my opinions a lot too. I haven't had the fear of disease instilled in me so much. > , I think you misunderstand me. I don't vaccinate my kids. I don't have a fear of most of these diseases. That doesn't mean vaccines have " no merit " . That doesn't mean that herd immunity does not exist for measles? Why have the periodic outbreaks of measles, the normal disease cycle, essentially stopped? Why is this different in countries that don't widely vaccinate against measles (eg. Germany) that have similar living conditions? I haven't seen a satisfactory answer to this question as yet. I don't trust drug companies or politicians either. If you go looking you can find lots of vaccine studies that are peer reviewed and/or independant of pharma. Carly. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 21, 2007 Report Posted September 21, 2007 It was my understanding that not all people who are exposed to a virus get sick from that virus (even measles and chickenpox). I also understand that people can carry the virus without actually becoming sick from it. Also, I believe it matters the level and duration of exposure. Tara Quote
Guest guest Posted September 21, 2007 Report Posted September 21, 2007 I would. Thanks! Tara Would anybody be interested to read it when it is finished? Quote
Guest guest Posted September 22, 2007 Report Posted September 22, 2007 Hi Sue, I totally agree with you on this issue. I think the reason for developing a vaccine for measles and other childhood diseases is money, as we all know. It is so sad that the younger generations have totally forgotten how to care for a sick child and will rely on pain killers and fever suppressers at the frist sign of a fever or pain and not give the child's body a chance to heal itself and develop a strong immune system. Ingrid > > I had measles as a child too, Tash. I had all the childhood illnesses - > including pertussis against which I was vaccinated. <rolls eyes> My > friends all had measles. We all survived it, and like you, I never knew > anyone who was desperately ill or died from it. I have said many times that > I think in part that was because our mothers knew how to *nurse* us when > ill. My memory of measles was two weeks in bed in a darkened room, plenty > of sleep and plenty of fluids, and being rather fed up that I wasn't playing > with my friends!! I think that measles itself is pretty inocuous - but like > flu, its complications can be serious. But I also believe that > complications can arise in part because of poor care. Malnutrition also > plays a part in measles complications, as with many other illnesses. > > There will always be exceptions - it's possible to die from a common cold if > complications set in. Another reason to approach it from the angle of > keeping the body healthy and strong, rather than worry about treating an > illness if and when it arrives. > > I have to be honest - I fail to understand the hysteria that surrounds > measles and all the other childhood illnesses. I've never been able to > understand why a vaccine was ever developed against an illness that has been > noted to offer protection against atopic illness, diabetes and cancer in > later life. No contest, in my book. > > I don't believe it's that easy to obtain accurate statistics for measles > morbidity - or do you mean mortality? Have a look at this: > http://www.hpa.org.uk/infections/topics_az/measles/nots_and_deaths.htm - > it's for the UK, but covers the period 1940-2006. and if you look at the > accompanying graph > (http://www.hpa.org.uk/infections/topics_az/measles/measles_deaths2007.htm) > it is easy to see that measles deaths plummeted long before the vaccine was > introduced. Case closed for me... > > Love, light and peace, > > Sue > > > >*> > >*> I had both german and red measles as a child within 4 months > >*> of each other, > >*> and under the age of a year. I know lots of people who had > >*> measles as a > >*> child and survived. I've never heard of anyone first-hand > >*> dying from it. > >*> > >*> What's the morbidity rates for measles in un-vaccinated populations? > >*> > >*> Curious, > >*> > >*> Tash > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 22, 2007 Report Posted September 22, 2007 Good point, Nita. IF there were no vaccinations, we would revert back to NATURAL immunity and the NATURAL progression of illness and disease. Vaccines don't lead to health. Never have, never will. Do they disrupt the immune system, for whatever reason, so people are unable to develop an acute case of the disease? Quite probably. But this does not equate health by any stretch of the term. When we mess with nature, we have consequences. And like Nita said below, when we stop fearing the diseases, we'll realize that the artificial " protection " vaccines may temporarily give come with a much worse price than proper treatment of a natural illness. Kay RE: CARRIE Re: If everyone stopped vaxing.....what.....?????? When you stop fearing these diseases, you'll stop thinking vaccines are a good thing. Fear sells. They want you to be afraid b/c then it's easier to control your mind and your thoughts. I don't fear these diseases. The m, m and r are not nasty, malevolent diseases. Nita Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2007 Report Posted September 24, 2007 > > All there is is a shift to another type of meningitis. > It isn't about the bacteria. And if you don't buy it that bacteria causes > illness, but is the result.................. > > Then the meningitis is the issue resulting from immune system problems > (previous vaccines, overload of antibiotics and other drugs, not breastfed > and on and on). > The bacteria that are present (tests show that is the bacteria present), > does not mean that it caused it. > I'll resend the Prevnar info about the new strains now appearing. > Sheri > Great to have you back, Sheri and all your good common sense info. NOt many people see the connection between these kind of health problems and the facts you mention above. Ingrid Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2007 Report Posted September 24, 2007 The " diseases " were simply renamed...encephalitis, menengitis, anything but the dreaded polio. It couldn't possibly be polio if there was a vaccine, right? Wrong. Connie > > > it's just too coincidental > > that the disease rates dropped so precipitously when the vaccine came > > out. I'd like to believe vaccines don't work because it would make > > wading through this issue so much easier, > > > Ok, I hope that I can get this out right, or that it hasn't been said already because I have had a busy weekend and haven't kept up with every post on the topic. What our chiropractors said was that it isn't necessarily doctors missing the diagnosis or researchers purposely " losing " numbers, BUT that the diagnostic criteria changes so that there are fewer people diagnosed with the disease. They said something about how the diagnosis for meningitis is similar to that of the one used for diagnosing polio. They said that the diagnosis for polio changed so that people would believe that the vaccine worked, but that we were now faced with a " new disease " that didn't fit the criteria. I do believe that it is similar to how vaccine reactions are diagnosed, I could be wrong, but I believe that if a reaction doesn't happen with a couple of days, it isn't considered vaccine damage, but something else. That only covers the immediate reactions and as we know, there are things that can happen from vaccines that are not noticed immediately. > > Sara > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 26, 2007 Report Posted September 26, 2007 If my understanding is correct, the diseases just are repressed in our bodies. They don't really go away. I would like to point out that children still get the measles and chicken pox. It is most likely that they aren't keeping the stats on the number of kids who do because it doesn't serve their purpose of scaremongering. My daughter had her MMR at 15 months then got a BAD case of the measles at age 6. One of our grandsons got the Chicken Pox vaccine as an infant and now at age 6 has the Chicken Pox! C. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.