Bird Flu - Scare Scenario

[Guest guest]

Bird Flu - Scare Scenario

Of course, I know vaccines don't work so don't agree with the vaccine

statement, but the essence of this is good. Also those treated

homeopathically fared much better.

" In the case of bird flu, direct comparisons to the scourge of 1918 may

well be overblown. Many people died of pneumonia during that outbreak of

the Spanish flu because there were no antibiotics to treat it. There were

also no vaccines, no antivirals and little in the way of public health or

the sanitary conditions Americans take for granted today. We also have our

top scientists and epidemiologists tracking this avian flu, which was not

the case in 1918 prior to the essential mutation. "

Sheri

The Nation

This article can be found on the web at

http://www.thenation.com/doc/20051107/bird_flu_scare

Scare Scenario

by DR. MARC SIEGEL

[posted online on October 24, 2005]

When I see the posters for the soon-to-be released Chicken Little movie, I

have to wonder what the lead character would have to say about the current

bird flu craze. Would he say the sky is about to fall on him? Or would he

come to his senses and understand that even as an American chicken, he is

more likely to be killed by panic than by the flu?

The American public is profiting the least from the ongoing hysteria

surrounding avian influenza. The drug manufacturer Roche is suddenly in

great demand for its antiviral drug Tamiflu, which has only been tested

against bird flu in the test tube and has no current use, because the virus

has not mutated to a form that can easily be transmitted among humans. A

common misconception--that Tamiflu is some kind of a bird flu vaccine

rather than an antiviral that at best decreases symptoms of infection--has

led to a lot of impulse buying. As with the antibiotic Cipro, prescribed to

treat anthrax back in 2001, Tamiflu is becoming a treatment for the fear of

a virus rather than the virus itself.

Another main profiteer of the bird flu panic is our federal government.

Driven to avoid another disaster debacle like Hurricane Katrina, the Bush

Administration is galloping to the rescue in advance of anything happening.

The President's recent suggestion that he might use the military to control

an influenza pandemic reminds us how quickly civil liberties can be

sacrificed in an emergency. But more than that, it is a hysterical

suggestion. Pandemics infiltrate a community person by person. A show of

military force would likely cause a panic that would spread a virus more

quickly.

CONTINUED BELOW

Most bird flus don't mutate sufficiently to pass to humans. And those that

do are usually responsible for our yearly influenza outbreak. On the

average of three times per century, a mutated avian influenza is a bad

enough bug to cause a pandemic. The bird flu of current concern, A(H5N1),

is a big killer among birds but is still several mutations away from being

able to routinely infect us. The estimated sixty-five people who have died

of it over the past two years did so because of their close and repeated

contact with birds, not because of casual contact. Cooking a chicken kills

the influenza virus.

So why all the panic over a potential threat? In part the public hysteria

is due to the fact that basic information about this potential pandemic has

been misconstrued or ignored about this potential pandemic, much in the way

previous health threats in the news--anthrax, smallpox, West Nile virus,

mad cow disease--were all magnified beyond their ability to do great harm.

In each case there is a doomsday scenario that is packaged and sold to the

public by the media, which consequently makes some undeserving manufacturer

rich or collects votes for an undeserving leader.

In the case of bird flu, direct comparisons to the scourge of 1918 may well

be overblown. Many people died of pneumonia during that outbreak of the

Spanish flu because there were no antibiotics to treat it. There were also

no vaccines, no antivirals and little in the way of public health or the

sanitary conditions Americans take for granted today. We also have our top

scientists and epidemiologists tracking this avian flu, which was not the

case in 1918 prior to the essential mutation.

Fear leads to a diversion of resources; our fear of bird flu is being

translated into a proposal for massive stockpiles of perishable drugs and

vaccines. Congress could calmly and rationally designate funds to upgrade

our flu vaccine manufacturing capacity using the genetic technology we

already use routinely for other vaccines. Instead, our government allows

pharmaceutical companies to use an outdated chicken-egg medium that

requires three to six months to develop a vaccine against a particular

strain. This slow process is then a justification for panicked stockpiles.

Bird flu is better studied in the laboratory than in a news conference.

This virus deserves public attention only insomuch as it motivates our

government to improve emergency services while bringing methods of vaccine

manufacturing into the twenty-first century.

Get The Nation at home (and online!) for 75 cents a week!

If you like this article, consider making a donation to The Nation.

--------------------------------------------------------

Sheri Nakken, R.N., MA, Hahnemannian Homeopath

Vaccination Information & Choice Network, Nevada City CA & Wales UK

$$ Donations to help in the work - accepted by Paypal account

earthmysteriestours@... voicemail US 530-740-0561

(go to http://www.paypal.com) or by mail

Vaccines - http://www.nccn.net/~wwithin/vaccine.htm

Vaccine Dangers On-Line course - http://www.nccn.net/~wwithin/vaccineclass.htm

Reality of the Diseases & Treatment -

http://www.nccn.net/~wwithin/vaccineclass.htm

Homeopathy On-Line course - http://www.nccn.net/~wwithin/homeo.htm