Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 I am strongly leaning toward option (3) which can be done laparoscopically with good results. hey Rich - where do you get the 'good results'? from your doctor? as you said - end stage tortuous, sigmoid E is a very rare condition. My 2 cents (and I've had A since 1982 and had an -ectomy about 3 years ago) is, why go for a partial -ectomy? that's what you are talking about- unless they are speaking about an esophagoplasty which I think our collective experience would tell you to NOT do. in NY was offered a plasty and has chosen to put off any further procedures for now, Isabella knows of I think 2 in Germany who had them and one had to have the ectomy anyway and Tim in England opted for the plasty first and then had the ectomy within just a few months. I know that an ectomy sounds so incredibly radical and crazy but they are fairly common, can be done in a minimally invasive way to limit your hospital stay and believe me - you can get your life back!! If I had not had any complications - I would have been discharged 5 days post-op - hell, I was in for 6 days back in '89 after my myotomy! As far as hospitals - the top 3 we tend to recommend (where are you anyway?) are Dr. Patti in Chicago, Dr. Rice at TCC (cleveland) and Dr. Luketich (my surgeon) at the University of Pittsburgh. They are all very experienced top notched surgeons who have been used by many of us on this site. Someone will be able to tell you the good/bad/ugly on all 3 of them. For what it's worth - I had my surgery done by Dr. L in Pittsburgh and he does 150 -ectomies a year and my 'new normal' is better than my 'old achalasia normal' was for decades!! I don't regret for one moment having this surgery. I hope that helps and if there is any other insight I can help with, please do not hesitate to ask. Keep us posted. ~ in NC achalasia free for 3 years!! > > My esophagus was pronounced " sigmoid-shaped " and " tortuous " several years ago. For the past few years, I have been managing my achalasia via balloon dilatation. This provided me with mildly improved swallowing. > > Four months ago, my swallowing ability declined a notch and I once again sought treatment. My doc refused to dilate and offered that additional dilatations would offer no improvement. > > I met with another doc (surgeon) who presented me with three options: (1) do nothing, (2) esophagectomy, or (3) esophageal re-section (basically shortening the esophagus and straightening its path so as to remove the 'S-curve'). I believe Heller myotomy is part of the picture, too, with the 2nd & 3rd options. > > I would like to know: > > 1. If any of you have been in the same situation - and how you handled your decision. Was re-sectioning offered as an option? > > 2. Specific recommendations or cautions regarding (US) surgeons/hospitals bearing in mind that treating a 'sigmoid/tortuous' esophagus is extremely rare. > > By my estimate, there are approx. 30 new cases per year in the ENTIRE USA. (So I would be surprised if ANY surgeon does a significant volume of esophageal re-sections.) > > I am strongly leaning toward option (3) which can be done laparoscopically with good results. > > Thanks in advance for your response! > > --Rich > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 30, 2010 Report Posted December 30, 2010 , Thanks for writing. Yes, option (3) seems to make a lot of sense to me, too. Doing an 'ectomy' remains an option if all else fails. Re-sectioning, which I take to be a way of shortening the esophagus by removing excess material, makes intuitive sense to me. I just haven't read much about it here. I am not sure how this differs from esophagoplasty. Has anyone in the group had a 're-section'? Of course, a Heller myotomy will be performed at the same time. The 'good results' I mentioned were the surgeon's stats: improvement 90% of cases (myotomy)/80% of cases (myotomy + resection). As far as your question goes, ( " why go for a partial -ectomy? " ), I think the reasoning is that the myotomy/re-section is less complex and can be done with fewer complications. The hospital stay is overnight (similar to a myotomy). , I am glad to hear that your 'new normal' is improved over your 'old normal'. I would be very happy to achieve a similar outcome! --Rich P.S. I live in Chicago and seen both Drs. Kahrilas & Patti > > > > My esophagus was pronounced " sigmoid-shaped " and " tortuous " several years ago. For the past few years, I have been managing my achalasia via balloon dilatation. This provided me with mildly improved swallowing. > > > > Four months ago, my swallowing ability declined a notch and I once again sought treatment. My doc refused to dilate and offered that additional dilatations would offer no improvement. > > > > I met with another doc (surgeon) who presented me with three options: (1) do nothing, (2) esophagectomy, or (3) esophageal re-section (basically shortening the esophagus and straightening its path so as to remove the 'S-curve'). I believe Heller myotomy is part of the picture, too, with the 2nd & 3rd options. > > > > I would like to know: > > > > 1. If any of you have been in the same situation - and how you handled your decision. Was re-sectioning offered as an option? > > > > 2. Specific recommendations or cautions regarding (US) surgeons/hospitals bearing in mind that treating a 'sigmoid/tortuous' esophagus is extremely rare. > > > > By my estimate, there are approx. 30 new cases per year in the ENTIRE USA. (So I would be surprised if ANY surgeon does a significant volume of esophageal re-sections.) > > > > I am strongly leaning toward option (3) which can be done laparoscopically with good results. > > > > Thanks in advance for your response! > > > > --Rich > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 31, 2010 Report Posted December 31, 2010 Don't make decisions based on GI options which probably didn't work for you in the past--maybe so. But GI's have been about as helpful to my end-stage achalasia as a phathologist. For the first part, a baloon dilatation will significantly add to the risk of perforation. In my case, my " renowned " GI specifically advised me against any further manipulation or baloon dilatation. I've heard of the heller myotomy and esophagectomy, but not the straightening part. a heller myotomy made my symptoms worse. With my experience with surgery and the way I'm treated, I'm wary of any surgeon. I'm going through a similar episode where pain management is treated like some horrendous reason to abuse and apply personal prejudices--like you're some abominable human garbage. It's not worth it, and I have very strong standards about how I'm treated. So,unless doctors broaden their pain managment coursework (they usually take less trhan 4 units), I wouldn't plan on any radical surgery > > My esophagus was pronounced " sigmoid-shaped " and " tortuous " several years ago. For the past few years, I have been managing my achalasia via balloon dilatation. This provided me with mildly improved swallowing. > > Four months ago, my swallowing ability declined a notch and I once again sought treatment. My doc refused to dilate and offered that additional dilatations would offer no improvement. > > I met with another doc (surgeon) who presented me with three options: (1) do nothing, (2) esophagectomy, or (3) esophageal re-section (basically shortening the esophagus and straightening its path so as to remove the 'S-curve'). I believe Heller myotomy is part of the picture, too, with the 2nd & 3rd options. > > I would like to know: > > 1. If any of you have been in the same situation - and how you handled your decision. Was re-sectioning offered as an option? > > 2. Specific recommendations or cautions regarding (US) surgeons/hospitals bearing in mind that treating a 'sigmoid/tortuous' esophagus is extremely rare. > > By my estimate, there are approx. 30 new cases per year in the ENTIRE USA. (So I would be surprised if ANY surgeon does a significant volume of esophageal re-sections.) > > I am strongly leaning toward option (3) which can be done laparoscopically with good results. > > Thanks in advance for your response! > > --Rich > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.