Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 For some reason your message has gone poof! Rich, I have a sigmoid/tortuous/mega/end stage esophagus as well. Its 10.5cm in diameter - this is even larger than most sigmoid/mega esophaguses. I was given the same options as you 1) do nothing 2) esophagectomy 3) myotomy. Since I am only 36, I opted for the myotomy. I went to Dr. Rice and Dr. Luketich for opinions and went with Dr. Luketich because of his extensive experience with minimally invasive surgeries and his bedside manner If and when I need to have the entire thing pulled, I will go to him as well. As for resection, I am curious to hear about your surgeon and his experience with such procedures. I would think that Dr. L would have suggested that if it had good results. I have not heard anything positive on this board about resections. Seems like they do a lot of them in Brazil where mega/esophagus is more common due to Chagas disease. Not sure if US doctors have enough experience with them. i would caution you to do more research before opting for a resection. I had great results with Dr. L with my myotomy. I had it on October 13th and I am swallowing very well now. For what its worth, if you never had a myotomy before, this may still be an option for you! Cara Quote
Guest guest Posted December 30, 2010 Report Posted December 30, 2010 Cara Thanks for taking the time to write. Basically, my doc has proposed the same solution as yours: myotomy. But, with the added twist (no pun intended) of re-sectioning in order to straighten out the esophagus a bit. The surgeon is Dr. Patti (thankfully right here in town). Though he has (only) done 20 esophageal re-sections in his career, he has done hundreds of (I believe) myotomies over the past 20 years. I am curious as to the decisions others who have been in this position and their experiences with re-sectioning. Of course, no one can speculate why or why not Dr. L didn't mention this possibility to you. As we all have learned, each patient's case is different (with different risks, too). And each Dr. has personal preferences and their " own " approach. I think many doctors seek that balance between offering the most benefit with the simplest treatment (fewest complications). Perhaps that factored into your doctor's decision. I am glad that you have had great results and hope that you continue to do so for a long time to come. I think I will be in good hands with Dr. Patti. Plus it's hard to beat the fact that he is so close. Right now I'm wrestling with whether or not to look any further (other docs) or not. It may well be that treatment by Dr. Patti is as good as I could find anywhere. And that would be great! --Rich (Chicago) > > For some reason your message has gone poof! Rich, I have a sigmoid/tortuous/mega/end stage esophagus as well. Its 10.5cm in diameter - this is even larger than most sigmoid/mega esophaguses. I was given the same options as you 1) do nothing 2) esophagectomy 3) myotomy. Since I am only 36, I opted for the myotomy. I went to Dr. Rice and Dr. Luketich for opinions and went with Dr. Luketich because of his extensive experience with minimally invasive surgeries and his bedside manner > > If and when I need to have the entire thing pulled, I will go to him as well. > > As for resection, I am curious to hear about your surgeon and his experience with such procedures. I would think that Dr. L would have suggested that if it had good results. I have not heard anything positive on this board about resections. Seems like they do a lot of them in Brazil where mega/esophagus is more common due to Chagas disease. Not sure if US doctors have enough experience with them. i would caution you to do more research before opting for a resection. > > I had great results with Dr. L with my myotomy. I had it on October 13th and I am swallowing very well now. For what its worth, if you never had a myotomy before, this may still be an option for you! > > Cara > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 30, 2010 Report Posted December 30, 2010 Rich, Wow, Dr. Patti is considered among the best of the best for achalasia so I am sure you are in good hands. I am definitely impressed that he said he could do a resection. I did not consult with him (except for an email or two) so I do not know if he would have recommended that for me as well. My sigmoid loop is one 90 degree turn at the bottom of the E. Its very dramatic and Dr. L was able to " straighten it " during my myotomy. However, it has regained some of its original shape. Anyway, the only issue I can forsee is that you will have a " stoma " (not sure if that is what its called) where they re attach the E to the resected portion of the E. This could a) leak or have scar tissue build up and need dilitation. These are all the same things that could happen with esophagectomy as well. Personally, if I was given the assurance of a good outcome with resection from a Doctor like Patti, I would choose that option. The key is that you are keeping your native esophagus and this to me is important. I wish you well and hope that everything goes smoothly. Thank you for sharing this story here because truthfully we have no heard much about this type of procedure. Nothing that postive at least. We would love to hear a positive story from you so please keep in touch and let us know how it all goes. Have you scheduled the surgery yet? Cara > > > > For some reason your message has gone poof! Rich, I have a sigmoid/tortuous/mega/end stage esophagus as well. Its 10.5cm in diameter - this is even larger than most sigmoid/mega esophaguses. I was given the same options as you 1) do nothing 2) esophagectomy 3) myotomy. Since I am only 36, I opted for the myotomy. I went to Dr. Rice and Dr. Luketich for opinions and went with Dr. Luketich because of his extensive experience with minimally invasive surgeries and his bedside manner > > > > If and when I need to have the entire thing pulled, I will go to him as well. > > > > As for resection, I am curious to hear about your surgeon and his experience with such procedures. I would think that Dr. L would have suggested that if it had good results. I have not heard anything positive on this board about resections. Seems like they do a lot of them in Brazil where mega/esophagus is more common due to Chagas disease. Not sure if US doctors have enough experience with them. i would caution you to do more research before opting for a resection. > > > > I had great results with Dr. L with my myotomy. I had it on October 13th and I am swallowing very well now. For what its worth, if you never had a myotomy before, this may still be an option for you! > > > > Cara > > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.