Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Unions in Michigan

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

Illinois isn't the only state challenging union membership drives among home

health care or child care professionals. Thought those of you involved in the

IPADD 'education campaign' regarding SEIU's drive to unionize Home Based &

Community Support workers might find this interesting.

Mich. child care workers sue to break from union

By ED WHITE, Associated Press Writer Ed White, Associated Press Writer - Sun Sep

12, 1:43 pm ET

DETROIT - Peggy Mashke tends to 12 children for 12 hours a day at her home, so

she was surprised to get a letter welcoming her to the United Auto Workers

union.

" I thought it was a joke, " said Mashke, 50, of northern Michigan's Ogemaw

County. " I work out of my home. I'm not an auto worker. How can I become a

member of the UAW? I didn't get it. "

Willing or not, Mashke and 40,000 other at-home providers are members of a labor

partnership that represents people across Michigan who watch children from

low-income families. Two unions receive 1.15 percent of the state subsidies

granted to those providers, or more than $1 million a year.

Mashke has given up about $100 this year, and while she says it's not a huge

amount of money, she's among a small group of home-based providers suing in

federal court to break free from organized labor.

" It's the principle. It's my constitutional rights, " she said.

The plaintiffs claim they were driven into the union and forced to support it

financially even though they work at home, are hired by families and are not

state employees. In some cases, they are even related to the children in their

care.

In 2006, the UAW and the American Federation of State, County and Municipal

Employees, or AFSCME, were formally approved as partners in a union called Child

Care Providers Together Michigan. Only 15 percent of the providers cast ballots,

but 92 percent were in favor.

The lawsuit, filed by the National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation,

claims that Gov. Granholm, a Democrat, and her administration cleared

the way for the union in exchange for valuable political support from the UAW

and AFSCME.

Michigan is one of at least 16 states where unions are mandatory representatives

of personal-care workers, according to National Right to Work.

The state and the unions have defended the arrangement as the legal result of a

process that was blessed by the Michigan Employment Relations Commission. They

say there is no role for a federal judge to second-guess what has occurred.

Union attorney West acknowledged it's a " novel approach " to bring

home-based workers under the labor umbrella.

" This is really a pretty important issue, " West said at a July 13 court hearing.

" We have a problem that's been festering for a long time in a lot of states

where you have a large group of generally poorly paid, often

not-very-well-trained employees.

" To try and resolve this issue and improve the situation, unions in a number of

states have put a lot of effort into trying to organize these people,

successfully in many instances, " he said.

On its website, The UAW says the partnership " gives a much-needed voice and

power " to child care providers who have problems dealing with the state's

bureaucracy.

" They might not get their check from the state. You wouldn't believe how much

that happens, " a UAW vice president, Estrada, told The Associated Press.

" Or they don't know they can get an increase in their subsidy if they get more

training. ... You wouldn't believe how much an extra 10 dollars a day can help. "

And there are providers who say the union has been helpful. Hall, 61,

who looks after three children at her home in suburban Detroit, said she was

having trouble getting paid by the state but the UAW " cut a lot of corners and

got right to the source. I was very elated. "

" The UAW is very resourceful, " Hall said. " If there's anything you're not aware

of, they bring the information to us. "

Jonker, a federal judge in Grand Rapids, Mich., has ruled that the

seven-month-old lawsuit can proceed, at least in the early stages. The Mackinac

Center for Public Policy, a Midland-based think tank that promotes free market

capitalism, is suing in state court to stop the union on other grounds.

Mackinac Center lawyer called it an " underhanded scheme. "

" It's an interesting issue, " said Chaison, professor of industrial

relations at University in Worcester, Mass.

" The idea is for unions like the UAW and AFSCME to have a fertile and expanding

area to organize to offset the membership losses because of plant closings - in

the case of the UAW - or state and city downsizing in the case of AFSCME, " he

said.

Posted

One of the best lines I've heard was quoted by a former member of ton's

mental health board.  He knew  some of the history of closing institutions in

Michigan and said --- " The state's budget for human services should not be used

to provide full employment for AFSCME members. "  

Of course, in IL, we'd substitute SEIU.

Bonnie Dohogne

From: Jerue Family <jeruefamily@...>

Subject: Unions in Michigan

IPADDUnite

Date: Monday, September 13, 2010, 3:34 PM

 

Illinois isn't the only state challenging union membership drives among

home health care or child care professionals. Thought those of you involved in

the IPADD 'education campaign' regarding SEIU's drive to unionize Home Based &

Community Support workers might find this interesting.

Mich. child care workers sue to break from union

By ED WHITE, Associated Press Writer Ed White, Associated Press Writer - Sun Sep

12, 1:43 pm ET

DETROIT - Peggy Mashke tends to 12 children for 12 hours a day at her home, so

she was surprised to get a letter welcoming her to the United Auto Workers

union.

" I thought it was a joke, " said Mashke, 50, of northern Michigan's Ogemaw

County. " I work out of my home. I'm not an auto worker. How can I become a

member of the UAW? I didn't get it. "

Willing or not, Mashke and 40,000 other at-home providers are members of a labor

partnership that represents people across Michigan who watch children from

low-income families. Two unions receive 1.15 percent of the state subsidies

granted to those providers, or more than $1 million a year.

Mashke has given up about $100 this year, and while she says it's not a huge

amount of money, she's among a small group of home-based providers suing in

federal court to break free from organized labor.

" It's the principle. It's my constitutional rights, " she said.

The plaintiffs claim they were driven into the union and forced to support it

financially even though they work at home, are hired by families and are not

state employees. In some cases, they are even related to the children in their

care.

In 2006, the UAW and the American Federation of State, County and Municipal

Employees, or AFSCME, were formally approved as partners in a union called Child

Care Providers Together Michigan. Only 15 percent of the providers cast ballots,

but 92 percent were in favor.

The lawsuit, filed by the National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation,

claims that Gov. Granholm, a Democrat, and her administration cleared

the way for the union in exchange for valuable political support from the UAW

and AFSCME.

Michigan is one of at least 16 states where unions are mandatory representatives

of personal-care workers, according to National Right to Work.

The state and the unions have defended the arrangement as the legal result of a

process that was blessed by the Michigan Employment Relations Commission. They

say there is no role for a federal judge to second-guess what has occurred.

Union attorney West acknowledged it's a " novel approach " to bring

home-based workers under the labor umbrella.

" This is really a pretty important issue, " West said at a July 13 court hearing.

" We have a problem that's been festering for a long time in a lot of states

where you have a large group of generally poorly paid, often

not-very-well-trained employees.

" To try and resolve this issue and improve the situation, unions in a number of

states have put a lot of effort into trying to organize these people,

successfully in many instances, " he said.

On its website, The UAW says the partnership " gives a much-needed voice and

power " to child care providers who have problems dealing with the state's

bureaucracy.

" They might not get their check from the state. You wouldn't believe how much

that happens, " a UAW vice president, Estrada, told The Associated Press.

" Or they don't know they can get an increase in their subsidy if they get more

training. ... You wouldn't believe how much an extra 10 dollars a day can help. "

And there are providers who say the union has been helpful. Hall, 61,

who looks after three children at her home in suburban Detroit, said she was

having trouble getting paid by the state but the UAW " cut a lot of corners and

got right to the source. I was very elated. "

" The UAW is very resourceful, " Hall said. " If there's anything you're not aware

of, they bring the information to us. "

Jonker, a federal judge in Grand Rapids, Mich., has ruled that the

seven-month-old lawsuit can proceed, at least in the early stages. The Mackinac

Center for Public Policy, a Midland-based think tank that promotes free market

capitalism, is suing in state court to stop the union on other grounds.

Mackinac Center lawyer called it an " underhanded scheme. "

" It's an interesting issue, " said Chaison, professor of industrial

relations at University in Worcester, Mass.

" The idea is for unions like the UAW and AFSCME to have a fertile and expanding

area to organize to offset the membership losses because of plant closings - in

the case of the UAW - or state and city downsizing in the case of AFSCME, " he

said.

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...