Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: Advice on anti-depressants please

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

Hi

Sorry to hear you are depressed.

Do you feel that the HC and t3 are helping you? At first, the HC made me feel

worse inmyself - i may be unusual in that respect, i don't know.

Have you considered any other options for depression, like st johns wort? (eg,

Kira brand from boots -google it?)

do you feel anxious with your depression or do you feel like you have low

energy? from reading what you said it sounds more like the latter.

have you considered the book the mood cure - that has lots of into on it about

natural help for depression - you can do a questionnaire that gives you some

indication what might help you http://www.moodcure.com/

do you feel bad enough that you need prescription antidepressants? i think if

you are really low and really struggling you should take medical advice

were you depressed before losing your job?do you think you are depressed because

of something else or 'just' as a reaction to being treated badly at work? if

it's a 'reactive depression', have you considered whether some good therapy

might help you - for instance 'human givens counselling' can be effective, so

can brief solution focussed thereapy, as can CBT, you dn't need to delve into

the past with these therapies as they focus on the here and now. maybe these

therapies could help you bounce back and move on, remind you of your resrouces,

strenghts and skills, and re-empower you, as losing your job in such a bad way

is going to affect you a lot isn't it obviously

please consider googling human givens therapy, or CBT if you think these might

help. There are couple of HG therapists in kent :

http://www.hgi.org.uk/register/complete-list.htm

chris

>

> I saw my GP almost four weeks ago and she said I was suffering from

depression. Hardly surprising since I had recently lost my job in very

unpleasant circumstances and through no fault of my own. She wouldn't prescribe

an anti-depressant at the time, as apparently you have be depressed for six

weeks before they will prescribe.

Posted

On Thu, 02 Dec 2010 11:20:55 -0000, you wrote:

>

>I would be grateful for some advice as to which anti-depressant would be best,

given that I am taking T3 and HC and I don't want to interfere with the progress

I've made so far. Can anybody help please?

Are you on enough T3 to clear hypo symptoms and normalise

temperatures??

Getting T3 levels right can be an extremely good way of clearing

depression

Nick

Posted

I too am planning on starting on anti depressants again ( I used to take them) -

Sertraline is the one I've taken before, and doesn't have any obvious side

effects to me. But in the long run, does it make getting better more difficult?

Does it, for example interfere with absorbtion of T3 or T4, or any of the

vitamins and minerals?

I'm just finding life too difficult ......

Sue

>

> >

> >I would be grateful for some advice as to which anti-depressant would be

best, given that I am taking T3 and HC and I don't want to interfere with the

progress I've made so far. Can anybody help please?

>

> Are you on enough T3 to clear hypo symptoms and normalise

> temperatures??

>

>

> Getting T3 levels right can be an extremely good way of clearing

> depression

>

> Nick

>

Posted

thanks for your extensive reply. This very much a reactive depression,

due to being unfairly dismissed. I have a lawyer currently looking into whether

I have grounds to go to an employment tribunal. I started HC back in April and

T3 in June and both are helping. I've been taking SJW, but it's not enough.

Nick, I don't feel the depression is due to a lack of T3, as I'm currently

taking 2 Cynomel and 3 Goldshield T3 a day - the Goldshield seem to be about

half the strength of the Cynomel, so this dosage is possibly not as high as it

may look.

Sue, I'm sorry to hear you are depressed too and I understand what you mean

about life being too difficult. I wish you well.

Has anyone any advice on which anti-depressants are ok and which are not?

Posted

On Fri, 03 Dec 2010 11:19:01 -0000, you wrote:

>

>Nick, I don't feel the depression is due to a lack of T3, as I'm currently

taking 2 Cynomel and 3 Goldshield T3 a day - the Goldshield seem to be about

half the strength of the Cynomel, so this dosage is possibly not as high as it

may look.

OK, and thanks for the calibration on the Gold Sheild!

Nick

Posted

What have you tried AD wise before, what worked? For me, the old tricyclic ones

were better than the new ones like SSRIs. The tricyclics have differnt

profiles, some are more sedating, some aren't. some can cause weight gain.

Gamanil/lofepramine for me was more activating, amitryptiline+dothiepin were

much more sedating (and caused weight gain). not sure if amitrypt and dothiepin

(now dosulepin) are used by GPs much - i think you can still get amitrypt but

dosulepin is supposed to be started by a psychiatrist or was last time i looked.

mirtazapine - newsh drug (compared to the tricyclics!) - was ok ish for me,

sedating though, caused a lot of weight gain becausse of cravings. very good for

sleep, can be activating at higher doses though, gave me nightmares at higher

doses.

citalopram/escitalopram (SSRI like prozac) - no good for me, made me worse and

gave me a headache.

Prozac - caused me to feel stressed all the time and agitated, prob aggressive

too, also gave me abdominal obesity. it double cortisol evels and made me feel

bad when i came off it.

cymbalta/duloxetine - made me feel bad, didn't stay on it for long. someone on

the forum didn't get on too well with it recently.

so for me, i found the old antidepressants better than the new ones.

what are you symptoms? are you agitated and need sedating, or do you need some

get up and go? or both?

Re : employmen tribunal

it sounds like you might be able to fight back, which is good, especially when

you've been wronged and treated badly.

Did you think about the human givens stuff or cbt stuff at all? they say they

can lift depression fast.

Reactive depression should go in time with the right support for you. There is

a book on CBT called mind over mood, which you can get off amazon. it is

designed for you to work through yourself.

Does T4 help with your depression? Thre's a US psych who has written that T3

seems to be more stimulating of dopamine and t4 more stimulating of serotonin,

which ties in with what i've experenced. sorry no link as i'm at work.

The thing is i'm not sure what would work quickly in you -if you're very

agitated then the sedating tricyclics would quickly work i think on that, but

not so sure about how long an antidepressant effect would take to work. 'they'

say that it can take several weeks for an antidepressant to work.

Do you take fish oils? Vegepa is good, you can get that discounted on the

'vegepaforme' scheme. DHA can help with depression too, tho some say EPA is

more effective than DHA at helping depression.

Have you tried EMDR, tapping? Sometimes this can help with depression and the

like.

It sounds like this has hit you really hard, are you planning how to come back

from this, making plans and moving forward, what are your resources to cope,

what are your skills? Don't lose sight of these or think in all or nothing

terms, (this is where the CBT might help and the HG stuff helps you break out of

deperssive thinking by reminding you of your strengths etc etc )

so to summarise, i found the old antidepressants more ok than the new ones, but

what works for one doesn't work for others.

chris

>

> thanks for your extensive reply. This very much a reactive depression,

due to being unfairly dismissed. I have a lawyer currently looking into whether

I have grounds to go to an employment tribunal. I started HC back in April and

T3 in June and both are helping. I've been taking SJW, but it's not enough.

> Has anyone any advice on which anti-depressants are ok and which are not?

>

Posted

Hi Angel

I don't think it's always just about T3 or adrenals though, diet can also play a

part, and it might be other hormones, not just thyroid, as well as having a

shock like this one, where someone is sacked and treaated badly, that can take

time to get over too even if hormones are 'right'

chris

>

> Hi , I would not advise taking anti-depressants as they can be addictive and

> hard to come off. depression

> is an hormone problem . maybe hormones not getting into the cells or not

enough

> T3. also the adrenals play a large part in out emotions. these hormones

produced

> by them is vital to our well being.

Posted

hi yvonne

you have my sympathy regarding being depressed and when we are treated

*unfairly* i think there is a sense of *powerlessness* that is very hard to bear

and our *fire* just dissipates.

regardless of any controversey about why you were dismissed did they follow

procedure TO THE LETTER? i know of someone who was dismissed because of an

injury sustained during the execution of his job and the back injury was chronic

so he could no longer continue to do his job, (therefore the employer was NOT

dismissing him unfairly) but because the procedure for dismissal was not

followed to the letter, the injured party successfully claimed for wrongful

dismissal and won the max allowable at the time (early 90's).

regarding anti--depressants they come very very high on my list of things not to

touch with a large barge pole ...i have had tri-cyclics in the past (before they

developed the ssri class of poison) ...there are better ways to help depression

in my view and one way is to find out what is missing (e.g. seratonin, dopamine)

and then nutritionally provide their precursors if possible ...(i am not an

expert at all though).

i don't know very much about hc i'm afraid but have you been *stress dosing*

during this difficult time? what about extra vit c, unrefined sea salt and the

b vitamins?

a daily walk in nature for 20 mins or so can be very therapeutic (but maybe when

the snow has passed!). if your mind gets locked on to things try sitting still

for a few minutes and concentrate on your breathing. if you want an easy

exercise please email and i will send it to you.

best wishes

trish

>

> thanks for your extensive reply. This very much a reactive depression,

due to being unfairly dismissed. I have a lawyer currently looking into whether

I have grounds to go to an employment tribunal. I started HC back in April and

T3 in June and both are helping. I've been taking SJW, but it's not enough.

Posted

This free book is quite helpful, it is written by a psychiatrist and talks about

helping depression with amino acids, i think it's a forerunner to holfords work

and julia ross's work

http://www.thewayup.com/upfrmdwn.htm

there are things like 5-htp you can take, or l-tyrosine - if these are the

problem, then you will notice fast results (days, not weeks)

if you are really not coping then i think you should speak to your gp about anti

depressants and take their advice. this site gives you user reviews/expriences

of various drugs

http://www.revolutionhealth.com/drugs-treatments/c/depression?src=browse

chris

>

>

> regarding anti--depressants they come very very high on my list of things not

to touch with a large barge pole ...i have had tri-cyclics in the past (before

they developed the ssri class of poison) ...there are better ways to help

depression in my view and one way is to find out what is missing (e.g.

seratonin, dopamine) and then nutritionally provide their precursors if possible

....(i am not an expert at all though).

>

Posted

Hi , I agree that although T3 and adrenals can play a major part in

depression, other things can impact too, and stress like losing your job is

bound to make things worse, and can of course in turn impact on health.When I

was at my lowest I found that 5htp helped me keep my head above water.Now

fortunately I'm in a better place but it helped for me for a while.I was on

seroxat AD for 5 years but this just made things worse for me but there might be

one that's not has bad to help you get through this patch but I'm not really up

on which ones are best.Has your gp offered you any counselling to help too? I

don't know whether that is something you would consider in combination with a

AD.I hope you feel better soon,

x

>

> Hi Angel

>

> I don't think it's always just about T3 or adrenals though, diet can also play

a part, and it might be other hormones, not just thyroid, as well as having a

shock like this one, where someone is sacked and treaated badly, that can take

time to get over too even if hormones are 'right'

Posted

Hi , before you consider going down the road of antidepressants, have you considered trying the natural way using high dose Niacin (500mgs). takes high dose Niacin and high dose CoEnzymeQ10 to lower his high BP, which worked miraculously. I was told to get him to try this by a private doctor long ago. I was reading about this again the other day and found the following article and thought this might be something you might like to try. If you do, please let us know the effect it has on your depression. http://www.spasticgoat.com/spasticity/2010/10/niacin-the-depression-cure/

Don't be tempted to go for the non-flushing Niacin as many people do because they don't like the 'flushing' effect because it won't work the same. Instead, learn to take your Niacin with, or just after a meal that fills your tummy and you will not suffer the 'flushing ' as badly, if at all. Some people never get the 'flushing'. For those who work, take your tablet with your evening meal and remember, the flushing lasts only about half an hour. For those who do 'flush', remember the word flush means you can go pretty red all over your body. However, read up about Niacin - it is quite brilliant, and natural too.

Good luck .

Luv - Sheila

> Nick, I don't feel the depression is due to a lack of T3, as I'm currently taking 2 Cynomel and 3 Goldshield T3 a day - the Goldshield seem to be about half the strength of the Cynomel, so this dosage is possibly not as high as it may look.>

Posted

Hi Sheila,How many mg. of Coq10 do you recommend for the depression?With that amount of niacin, 500 mg., I do flush. Would it be ok to just get in the bath tub or pool to cool the body down during this period?Thanks,Cheryl

Posted

Personally I have found nutritional supplements

to be very helpful with depression. I have no health insurance and hence am totally dependent on them and so very grateful that they work.

Currently I am using L-Tryptophan which I found helped within a day or so from the time that I started to use it. St. Wart

helped me a lot in the past. It is very inexpensive but it does take about 2 weeks to start working. I have also used 5htp successfully. Sometimes after long term use these supplements lose effectiveness so you may have to alternate them.Also, bare in mind that depression can be hormonally caused in women. I don't know who originally asked for help here. In this case I would advice all natural HRT.Hope this helps and best of luck with overcoming depression as I do know what it's like!Let

us know how it goes!Cheryl---

Posted

Just wanted to say thanks for all the advice and support. I've had a couple of

really black days where I haven't felt up to responding on here. I see my GP

tomorrow morning, thank goodness.

Posted

i hope you feel better soon

Please let us know how you get on, so we can support you on here

chris

Posted

I was recommending only Niacin for depression, but recommending

it with CoEnzyme q10 for lowering high cholesterol. I have no idea whether

bathing would help, but it is best to take Niacin straight after a meal and

don't have a hot drink. Having a full tummy helps you absorb Niacin better and

stops most of the flushing. After you have taken Niacin for a while, your body

gets used to it and the flushing stops. It lasts about half an hour only, so do

it at a time you know you could stand this and when you are not having to go

out and meet with people.

Luv - Sheila

Hi Sheila,

How many mg. of Coq10 do you recommend for the depression?

With that amount of niacin, 500 mg., I do flush. Would it be ok to just get

in the bath tub or pool to cool the body down during this period?

Thanks,

Cheryl

Posted

hello sue

sorry to hear you are finding life too difficult and i do hope things change for

you soon. as far as i am aware i don't think studies have shown

anti-depressants to be enduringly beneficial in the long term and there's a lot

of (anecdotal) evidence to suggest that people get better anyway over time.

having said that though sometimes a short course of a/ds can be beneficial if it

tips the brain chemistry into a different mode. as sertraline is an ssri class

of drug, have you tried upping (in your diet or supplement) the precursors to

seratonin, such as tryptophan or 5-htp?

http://www.drugs.1emallway.com/mind-works/food-serotonin.htm

http://www.painstresscenter.com/mall/5htp.html

http://home.bluemarble.net/~heartcom

/tryptophantoserotonintomelatonin.html

> But in the long run, does it make getting better more difficult? Does it, for

example interfere with absorbtion of T3 or T4, or any of the vitamins and

minerals?

============moderated to remove old messages====================

Posted

On Mon, 06 Dec 2010 10:21:25 -0000, you wrote:

>

>> But in the long run, does it make getting better more difficult? Does it,

for example interfere with absorbtion of T3 or T4, or any of the vitamins and

minerals?

There is an interaction

>

>In regard to SSRI drugs lowering thyroid hormones in the body, I read about

this possibility early on, after I was diagnosed with thyroid disease and the

fact that they can indeed do this, was included in medical research articles and

not just the opinion of non-medical people. In people who take thyroid hormone

replacement, this would likely only result in a need to raise their hormone

medication dose. In people who aren't hypothyroid however, taking an SSRI long

term, might present the need for them to have thyroid hormone level testing

every few months, to see if they are a patient whose levels are significantly

affected by the SSRI drug. Most patient's, own bodies will adjust their thyroid

hormone levels if the drug lowers them over time but might not be true in all

cases. Here again, is a need for Doctor and patient education about these drugs.

From

http://www.bellaonline.com/articles/art46441.asp

Nick

Posted

Thanks, Chris. I really appreciate your support.

I saw my GP this morning who asked if I wanted to try an anti-depressant and

which one, so I asked for Prozac as I had that once before several years ago and

it helped back then. She's signed me off for six weeks too.

I note you said in a previous post that Prozac raises cortisol. Since I'm

taking HC for adrenal insufficency (under Dr P's supervision), I imagine I don't

have much cortisol to raise.

Thanks again.

>

> i hope you feel better soon

>

> Please let us know how you get on, so we can support you on here

>

> chris

>

Posted

,

I would be more worried if I wasn't depressed about losing my job, than if I

was. If you lost your job and didn't care or if you were not apprehensive

about finding a new job and managing until you get a job, I would regard that as

a far more unusual response.

Ok, so you've lost your job and you feel rubbish, as expected. If you won the

lottery tommorow or if you had some real good luck, would you still feel

depressed? If you would still feel depressed, then chemicals in the form of

antidepressants are probably what you need to change your chemistry.

However, if winning the lottery or whatever would lift the depresssion then

taking chemicals isn't going to help much.....

Changing your situation and accepting that what has happened is rubbish will go

some way to lifting the gloom and despondency.

Please consider very carefully before you allow the doc to prescribe you meds,

they won't change your situation you'll just feel one step removed from it.

x

Posted

Hi

that sounds like progress. it will do you good to know you have time off to

recover. did your gp mention anything about counselling? sorry to nag you

again, but did you look at the mind over mood book on amazon? It will help you

look at your thoughts and worries and feelings at how bad you have been treated.

just a thought

i hope the prozac kicks in soon, if it worked before then it's good you know you

can turn to it again and get help

please keep us updated

Chris

Posted

> ============moderated to remove old messages====================

you also removed the rest of my message so here it is again!

> But in the long run, does it make getting better more difficult? Does it, for

example interfere with absorbtion of T3 or T4, or any of the vitamins and

minerals?

i can't answer your first question but i would say the stress of being depressed

is bound to have an impact on everything we take but i've no idea how much of an

impact (sorry!).

if you've got half an hour to spare, have a look at this link ....i have found

it very powerful.

http://quantumk.co.uk/

best wishes

trish

>

>

> hello sue

>

> sorry to hear you are finding life too difficult and i do hope things change

for you soon. as far as i am aware i don't think s

Posted

Hi , did you read my post about using high doses of Niacin (vitamin B3) for depression and read the links I found about this. I think taking antidepressants is most definitely the wrong road to take and you are likely to store up more problems for yourself in the future. The majority of sufferers of the symptoms of hypothyroidism suffer with depression at some time, until they get on the right dose of thyroid hormone replacement. PLEASE, BEFORE YOU MAKE SUCH A DECISION, READ THE FOLLOWING ABOUT PROZAC. http://www.fluoridealert.org/prozac.htm

"The Danger of Taking Prozac The Guardian September 4, 1999

Book: Talking Back to Prozac R. Breggin, M.D.

Prozac Backlash: Long-Term Consequences for Taking Antidepressants Are Virtually Unknown ABC News April 10, 2000

Antidepressants linked to sexual side effects CNN.com Health with WebMD February 9, 2000

Fluoextine: Drug Monograph MentalHealth.com, Long, MD, 1999

Manufacturer's Report (pdf) Eli Lilly, June 1998

Note on Prozac: One impact of prozac which is of particular concern is it's impact on the thyroid. Eli Lilly, the company that produces Prozac, reports that hypothyroidism can result from taking prozac, although the company states that such cases are infrequent (see Manufacturer's Report listed above). According to Henry Ford Health System, "The product information of Prozac reveals that infrequently Prozac may cause or worsen preexisting hypothyroidism. As hypothyroidism is known to cause depression, it is important to have your thyroid function checked." According to Shomon, author of Living Well With Hypothyroidism, "Taking thyroid hormone replacement while taking the popular antidepressant sertraline -- brand name Zoloft -- can cause a decrease in the effectiveness of the thyroid hormone replacement, and make your TSH rise. This same effect has also been seen in patients receiving other selective serotonin-reuptake inhibitors such as Paxil (paroxetine) and Prozac (fluoxetine). If you are on an antidepressant or thyroid hormone and your doctor wants to prescribe the other, be sure to discuss these issues."

Since hypothyroidism is a common cause of depression, there is concern that patients with hypothyroidism may be prescribed prozac to treat their depression, which could in turn make their hypothyroidism worse". > >> > i hope you feel better soon > > > > Please let us know how you get on, so we can support you on here> > > > chris> >>

Posted

Sheila, thank you for your concern, which is very much appreciated. But this is

not a depression as a result of being hypothyroid. This has been triggered by

the underhand way in which I have been treated by my now ex-employer. This has

been going on since the end of July, right through August/September/October and

half way through November, when my appeal against dismissal was rejected. I

have been put through an emotional wringer by them, outrageous lies have been

told about me and I been ganged up on by my ex-colleagues. All because I dared

to speak out and tell the truth about a bully who had been getting at me for a

long time. She in effect got me dismissed. I am now trying to ascertain, via a

lawyer, whether I have a claim for unfair dismissal, though I'm not sure I do.

I live alone, I have no family that I see regularly (nor are worthy of the term)

and I have few friends.

I'm not looking for sympathy, and I would appreciate that if anyone wants to

give me further advice, they bear in mind that I am now suffering a severe

depression and finding it hard to cope with doing even everyday things at the

moment. I have just spent 30 minutes on the telephone making a claim for

benefit, which reduced me to tears by the time the call ended.

I am not getting at you, or anybody else on here, so please don't think that I

am. I'm just distressed.

>

>

> Hi , did you read my post about using high doses of Niacin

> (vitamin B3) for depression and read the links I found about this. I

> think taking antidepressants is most definitely the wrong road to take

> and you are likely to store up more problems for yourself in the future.

> The majority of sufferers of the symptoms of hypothyroidism suffer with

> depression at some time, until they get on the right dose of thyroid

> hormone replacement. PLEASE, BEFORE YOU MAKE SUCH A DECISION, READ THE

> FOLLOWING ABOUT PROZAC. http://www.fluoridealert.org/prozac.htm

> <http://www.fluoridealert.org/prozac.htm>

>

Posted

>

If you won the lottery tommorow or if you had some real good luck, would you

still feel depressed? If you would still feel depressed, then chemicals in the

form of antidepressants are probably what you need to change your chemistry.

However, if winning the lottery or whatever would lift the depresssion then

taking chemicals isn't going to help much.....

>

Hi Amanada

Yes, I would still feel depressed - money is not the issue here and winning the

lottery would be more than I could cope with right now.

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...