Guest guest Posted December 25, 2010 Report Posted December 25, 2010 If it would be unethical to pay patients to participate in clinical trials as Diane argues, then what kind of trials and how reliable are the ones that claims pay healthy patients(sic) to participate? On Sat, Dec 25, 2010 at 3:05 PM, S. <scott_fs@...> wrote: > > > Says who? Participants are paid for their time and effort in clinical > trials all of the time. These are generally healthy patients, though. > > Sick people are expected to be irradiated with multiple CT scans, use > experimental therapy, and pay their own transportation and hotel and other > costs. Just so drug companies can make $5 billion a year from drugs such as > rituximab. > > Just saying. > > > > Re: Take-Home Message - use clinical trials > > Posted by: " Diane " > dimackinn@... <dimackinn%40> > > > dimackinn > > Sat Dec 18, 2010 1:05 pm (PST) > > It would be unethical to pay patients to participate in clinical trials. > That said, an obvious inducement is that often there are no costs for > procedures or drugs above what is paid for by a patient's medical insurance. > There are other problems which ones faces when entering a clinical trial. > There often are a combination of eligibility criteria (age, previous > treatment) which make significant classes of people ineligible. Patients may > not be willing to participate in a randomized study because there is no > guarantee you will get the new drug and for some of us the alternative arm > would not be recommended. But if your medical needs and the trial being > offered are a good fit then a clinical trial can be a wise choice. As > is always pointing out informed consent is the key. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 25, 2010 Report Posted December 25, 2010 I know how much I would trust most of the trials I've heard about that pay patients. You won't see my name on any of their lists.They are advertised all the time on the radio, but I've never heard of one done by a familiar name - UCLA, Cedars, USC, etc. There are several major medical institutions around here. I wouldn't consider any trial not done by one of these places, paid or not. , I hope you at least had a good response to your trial!!!! Pat Quote
Guest guest Posted December 25, 2010 Report Posted December 25, 2010 Phae 1 trials of non-cytotoxic drugs usually pay volunteers. I have heard of people receiving $5000 for their time. However, there are occasional disasters such as the Tegenero trial that I have written about on my blog. Terry Hamblin In a message dated 26/12/2010 00:17:25 GMT Standard Time, frchhu@... writes: If it would be unethical to pay patients to participate in clinical trials as Diane argues, then what kind of trials and how reliable are the ones that claims pay healthy patients(sic) to participate? On Sat, Dec 25, 2010 at 3:05 PM, S. <scott_fs@...> wrote: > > > Says who? Participants are paid for their time and effort in clinical > trials all of the time. These are generally healthy patients, though. > > Sick people are expected to be irradiated with multiple CT scans, use > experimental therapy, and pay their own transportation and hotel and other > costs. Just so drug companies can make $5 billion a year from drugs such as > rituximab. > > Just saying. > > > > Re: Take-Home Message - use clinical trials > > Posted by: " Diane " > dimackinn@... <dimackinn%40> > > > dimackinn > > Sat Dec 18, 2010 1:05 pm (PST) > > It would be unethical to pay patients to participate in clinical trials. > That said, an obvious inducement is that often there are no costs for > procedures or drugs above what is paid for by a patient's medical insurance. > There are other problems which ones faces when entering a clinical trial. > There often are a combination of eligibility criteria (age, previous > treatment) which make significant classes of people ineligible. Patients may > not be willing to participate in a randomized study because there is no > guarantee you will get the new drug and for some of us the alternative arm > would not be recommended. But if your medical needs and the trial being > offered are a good fit then a clinical trial can be a wise choice. As > is always pointing out informed consent is the key. > > > [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] ------------------------------------ Groups Links Quote
Guest guest Posted December 26, 2010 Report Posted December 26, 2010 I agree that paying for travel and other costs associated with paticipating in a study - to break even - is appropriate and needed. My impression is that it's sometimed provided by the sponsor - and that given the challenge of enrollment, and what's at stake for the company if it fails to accrue, it's a good idea to ask. Otherwise, I think the ethical concern is that paying patients who need treatment and have other treatment options, will induce patients who are fiancially challenged (the poor) to choose an investigational therapy they might otherwise decline. As in, poor man: take this potentially useful treatment for a life-threateing disease with unknown risk, or pay for an approved one. (Ironically, investigators of gleevic reported in the NEJM that participants in the study that led to the approval of the life-saving drug can't afford it and are getting sick!) In a trial involving healthy people who are sometimes paid (which I'm less familiar with) I think the risk of participation must be very low and in that case there would be no competing active intervention (potential harm from the choice. Karl > > Says who? Participants are paid for their time and effort in clinical trials all of the time. These are generally healthy patients, though. > > Sick people are expected to be irradiated with multiple CT scans, use experimental therapy, and pay their own transportation and hotel and other costs. Just so drug companies can make $5 billion a year from drugs such as rituximab. > > Just saying. > > > > Re: Take-Home Message - use clinical trials > > Posted by: " Diane " > dimackinn@... > > > dimackinn > > Sat Dec 18, 2010 1:05 pm (PST) > > > It would be unethical to pay patients to participate in clinical trials. That said, an obvious inducement is that often there are no costs for procedures or drugs above what is paid for by a patient's medical insurance. There are other problems which ones faces when entering a clinical trial. There often are a combination of eligibility criteria (age, previous treatment) which make significant classes of people ineligible. Patients may not be willing to participate in a randomized study because there is no guarantee you will get the new drug and for some of us the alternative arm would not be recommended. But if your medical needs and the trial being offered are a good fit then a clinical trial can be a wise choice. As is always pointing out informed consent is the key. > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 26, 2010 Report Posted December 26, 2010 Just think about how more thorough the study would be if we could get healthy and sick people who couldn't afford to pay travel expenses but might give you a better cross section of CLL patients. On Sun, Dec 26, 2010 at 10:53 AM, karlamonyc wrote: > I agree that paying for travel and other costs associated with participating in a study - to break even - is appropriate and needed. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.