Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Discussion Groups

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Guest guest
Posted

It is a given that part of being involved with a discussion group is discussion, and that often involves disagreement. Sometimes we learn more when there are multiple opinions than we do when everyone is on the same page. Taking posts personally is a waste of energy. As for the 350,000 WBC I've seen numbers that high and higher posted more than once to more than one group. And when someone who doesn't know you except on line offers helpful suggestions based on what they do know from your posts, a simple thank you or no response is appropriate. It's impossible to know someone's CLL background or level of knowledge unless we create a page for posting such information, which would be fairly useless in my humble opinion.

PatOn Sun, Jul 11, 2010 at 2:12 PM, Ellen <rhudy@...> wrote:

" That person " that you're probably referring to with the WBCs of 350,000

is me.  But, apparently, you're clueless.  Just read Dr. Terry

Hamblin's professor's post on high WBCs.  They don't matter. 

What does matter is the HgB, platelets, lymph doubling time, etc., etc.. 

I am upset that you said I would " probably die, " how dare you!!  I

am not so stupid that I even think there's a " perfect treatment " ............there

is NONE.  Because of foot dragging.  When I feel the time is

right, I'll choose the least toxic tx..  Everyone here will die, including

the people who post who don't have cll.  So please refrain from blanket

statements about a person you know NOTHING about, it's very insulting,

and it's denigrating for you to say that if I would have tx. now I'd have

many more years of productive life...........?  How do you know that? 

A direct pipeline to God?  How do you know that the tx. wouldn't give

me an infection and kill me?  Are you saying that txs. are 100% beneficial? 

High WBCs are meaningless separated from the rest of the picture. 

I want an apology.

Ellen

Dave wrote:

 

 

From:

cllcanada <cllcanada@...>

To:

Sent:

Sun, July 11, 2010 12:32:30 PM

Subject:

Re: Treat or Die

Chris:

I think Doctor Furman is referring to people like Kurt, who waited

so long for real treatment that he couldn't make it. really knows

more about that. There are also people on this list that post numbers that

are too high. They sometimes ignore their Doctors advice. We have one who

posted that their numbers were 350,000. but did not want to start treatment.

That person wanted to wait for the perfect treatment that would produce

no side affects. At 350K, that person will probably die before the perfect

treatment comes along. But if that person got treatment now with what is

available, they would probably have many years of productive life

After I was told by a Hem/Onc in 06 that I should start treatment in

07, I stayed away from oncologists. I went to my regular Doctor who has

no clue about CLL for my regular 6 month appoinments and asked him to do

my CBCs. I still smile when I think about the night he called me and said

I should get to the emergency room as my lymphs were dangerously high. 

I think about 80K then. But he is a special guy.

But to my point, some of us get advice from our Oncologists and choose

to ignore that advice. I just chose to not deal with Oncologists for over

a year after being given bad advice. When I did choose another, She said

treatment should be started. I brought her the guidelines for when treatment

should begin and she changed her mind about me needing treatment. 

But I could have also just not went back to her and decided that I would

not see a Hem/Onc until I decided I needed treatment. Then I might initiate

contact with a pro like Dr. Furman, but it might be too late.

My current Hem/Onc is Dr. Weiss with Siteman center in St. Louis.

He was referred to me by someone on this or Acors list. He admits he is

not an expert on CLL, but is always ready to ask questions of his friend

Dr. Byrd.  I feel that I am now in good hands.

thanks for all you do for our group.

Dave

 

 

So, are you saying that Section 4.1 of the 2008 Guidelines for the

diagnosis and treatment of chronic lymphocytic leukemia (updating National

Cancer Instituteâ€展orking Group 1996 guidelines) is no longer

valid for the average CLL patient?

How would CLL patients that are being followed by an oncologist, get

themselves into the 'waiting too long situation'?

Further, until this May, many CLL patients in Canada could not get FCR

treatment under provincial insurance plans and we still can't get FR unless

it is on a clinical trial !

Not everyone's options are the same as in the USA, I would like to remind

you.

~chris

>

> I cannot emphasize this more. We have all seen patients who wait

so long to initiate therapy that once they do, they are unable to tolerate

it. Additionally, the delay in receiving treatment leads to a great many

more symptoms. FR and FCR will go a long way to getting someone back to

their normal lifestyle.

>

> Rick Furman, MD

 

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...