Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

RE: This is it -- the BIGGIE! -- Question of the Week, 2010/4

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

I don't know if I am considered a newbie or a young member or even at the beginnning of my flatback journey but I have to to say please, please don't " tone down our reports to the group so as not to scare the pre-revision members out of their wits!" Those of us who are searching for information on what is mostly a mysterious and rarely mentioned condition, need to know what is happening to others so we don't feel alone. Even the posts made by members who are in dire

straits are needed to say everybody feels low sometimes. If you "tone down" your posts as to what things happened to you, I feel you would run the risk of misleading your members. If someone unfamilair with the condition, recently diagnosed and/or just offered the chance of revision surgery came to this site and read a muted account, is there not every possiblity that they would believe "oh ok, they nothing much happened to them I'll definatly be ok! whats all the fuss

about?"Personally speaking, I don't have a choice as to whether or not to have the revision surgery (as you all know) but if I had been given the chance I may believe the phrase "put it off until you REALLY can't cope any more" or if I decided to go ahead, I would now feel I armed with knowledge about what to expect if things should go wrong - I've never had that with any other surgery. People should not be led to believe that revision surgery is a magic wand that will fix everything - after all that's what

got us all into this mess in the first place! (believing a operation would fix everything and suddenly we'd be "normal")I also believe that people should have "freedom of speech" (up to a point obviously - there is no need to offend anyone) surely part of this groups charm is the total honesty? the chance to vent your frustration at the system that has failed us and the opportunity to speak openly about your spinal problems to others who understand versus perhaps your nearest and dearest who even

if you are blessed with the most understanding and empathic circle, probably don't. If we don't speak out, 100% truthfully and honestly, how can we paint a true picture?(climbing down off soapbox now - sorry for the rant)From: <elizabethrgonzalez@...> Sent: Thu, January 21, 2010 2:36:48 AMSubject: Re: This is it -- the BIGGIE! -- Question of the Week, 2010/4

Good work, Marty! I would be happy for you to keep a file and update it

as we research more possible "candidates. "

A number of older folks do post here -- maybe some will respond to your

post. As for the younger folks, my guess would be that they do know what

lies ahead, if only from following the personal sagas posted on the

site. Most flatbackers have started to deteriorate pretty markedly by

the time they find their way to this group. (I believe our youngest

member to have revision surgery was 27 at the time.)

One concern we "older folks" have (and I have as the person who started

this group ten years ago, with a little group of newbies like myself who

were just at the beginning of their flatback -- ahem -- adventure) is

whether we need to tone down our reports to the group so as not to scare

the pre-revision members out of their wits!

What awes me most at this stage, though, is just how many of our members

have now been through massive flatback revision surgeries. Back in 2000,

not a single one of us had undergone this surgery. We were pretty much

still trying to get some basic information and locate a surgeon

somewhere who might be competent to operate on us. We've come a long way

since then..

Thanks for writing, and I hope we'll hear more from you. How are YOU

doing these days?

Best,

>

>

>

> I think we should try to raise more awareness and I will spend some

time considering what I would recommend. Is there such a thing as a

national scoliosis awareness day? Could it be linked to someone famous

(now deceased perhaps)? Found below list on Scoilosis World website and

I got as far as listing all their occupations. Maybe we could expand on

this list. I could make a "File" and we could add info to it as we

research more. I am wondering how some of the older folks on the list

are doing and also wondering if the younger ones know what might be in

store for them in the near future...

> - Later, Marty

> ------------ --------- ----

> From ScoilosisWorld. com:

>

> List of Celebrities, Famous People, Actors, Athletes, etc.

>

> Blake on Celebrity Poker Showdown

> Blair (Actress)

> Blake (Tennis)

> Usain Bolt (Sprinter)

> Blatt (Singer)

> Kurt Cobain (Musician)

> Maritza Correia (Swimmer)

> Dern (actress)

> Sophie Falkiner (actress)

> Gellar (actor)

> Madden Grey (entertainer)

> Ayesha (model)

> Jeanette Lee (billiard player)

> Giacomo Leopardi (Italian Poet)

> (golf)

> Lyons (actress)

> Yo-Yo Ma (Musician)

> andra Marinescu (Gymnast)

> Gillian Mc (cook)

> Liza Minnelli (entertainer)

> Lydon / ny Rotten (Sex Pistols)

> Oxenberg (actress)

> Shoshana Pavett (Opera Singer)

> Pesticco (Miss Wales)

> Romijn (actress)

> Isabella Rossellin (actress)

> Rene Russo (actress)

> Louise Sauvage (Australian Athlete)

> Chloe Sevigny (actress)

> Rita Simons (actress)

> Southard (Miss North Carolina)

> Spell (volleyball)

> (swimmer)

> Tutankhamon (Egyptian Pharaoh)

> Rowena Wallace (actress)

> Elettra Wiedemann (daughter of Isabella Rosselini)

> Zsa Zsa Padilla (actress, model)

>

Posted

a good spoke person would be princess eugenne of england who had rods inserted when she was 12

From: <elizabethrgonzalez@ gmail.com>Subject: This is it -- the BIGGIE! -- Question of the Week, 2010/4FeistyScolioFlatbac kers@groups .comReceived: Tuesday, January 19, 2010, 2:25 PM

Recently Barbara posted at Feisty, regarding other people's responses to her spinal problems, ". . . I have just about given up trying to educate anyone about them. Over all, people just don't care. To most people I have a 'bad back.'"Does this ring a bell with you? It sure did with me. Do you think we need to find a powerful, effective way to arouse people's interest and communicate the enormity of the flatback pandemic that has totaled a whole generation of us scoliosis grads (the vast majority of us women)? Do you think that together we may just be able to figure out how to do this, how to spread the message in such a way that it simply cannot be ignored? Call me deluded, but I do -- after all these years, I still do! I just read a review of a new documentary film called NoBody's Perfect, about the lives and feelings of 12 highly articulate adults who were born deformed by thalidomide. At least one of these

people has no limbs at all; others manage cocktails and computers with their toes. It occurred to me, reading this review, that almost everyone has heard of the thalidomide tragedy -- but almost no one has heard of flatback syndrome.Who knows what kind of public interest, funding opportunitites, etc., we might attract if anyone knew we existed? (The "thalidomides, " as they call themselves, have sought and received ongoing reparations from the drug company in Germany, although not in Britain as yet. That's gotta beat 2-3 income-free years while undergoing massive surgery and waiting for your Social Security Disability claim to be approved!) A successful public education campaign could even give some much-needed impetus to the kind of crucial scientific research we talked about yesterday, leading to a clue or two concerning the origins of that mysterious and life-shattering bombshell that clobbered so many of us in the midst of

our fun-loving years and put us squarely on the path to The Desolate Land of Flatback: Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis.Don't worry, I'm getting to the Question of the Week! -- but I've indulged in this long -winded preface because of one startling fact that leapt out at me from the movie review. Here it is: People with deformities caused by the thalidomide prescribed for their pregnant moms (in countries where the drug was allowed to go to market) total 10,000 to 12,000. (Of these, only 17 are in the US, since a vigilant female doc at the FDA studied all the premarketing data on thalidomide and said "No way.") In contrast, adults wth flatback syndrome severe enough to require revision surgery are thought to number at least 1 million. (Moreover, that SRS estimate was predicated on the approximate number of people with Harrington rods. It predated the full realization that Luque rods were also doing a number on people's spines, not

to mention the news that some spinal surgeons -- even as we speak, so to speak -- are, implausibly, continuing to destroy people's lumbar lordosis by fusing without regard to sagittal mechanics. I would tell you that last little factoid was unsubstantiated hearsay, but it came from a truly impeccable source: Dr. Ondra, my most recent revision surgeon, who was giving me an eyewitness account of what he was seeing in his practice, much to his own incredulity. )Now, maybe I'm naive, or maybe there's something I'm just not getting here -- but please tell me, if you can: Isn't there some way a million of us feisty folk can get ourselves a little bit closer to the spotlight, if not the limelight -- can get the word out to some of the multiple millions who are sure to be affected by flatback syndrome, whether as patients, family membrs, close friends, employers, or providers of medical or social services to people with

disabilities? Can you think of some "market" for our story that we haven't already tapped? (Or some sensational new way to formulate our third or fourth approach to Oprah's producers?) What's the "grabber" -- the opening line of your own proposed "sales pitch"? How would you frame the subject? How would you "explain" it in a few simple, dramatic words? Or would you skip the words and go straight to the snapshots and x-rays? How would you make sure the person you were approaching understood from the get-go that this is not, not, NOT just another saga of moaning and groaning over that nasty ruptured disk -- that it involves just a bit more than an osteoarthritic sacroiliac or "a touch of the old lumbago" on rainy days?This is such an important issue to so many of us . . . I would love to hear everyone's thoughts, fantasies, brainstorms on this one, my faithful feisty friends. I would love to get an unprecedented response from a couple

hundred members (dream on, !) I'm totally serious -- even if you have never once posted to this group, and you will never ever post again, I would love, love, love to hear from you on this issue. I feel so strongly that someone out there has an answer, a breakthrough, an absolutely original and unprecedented proposal for getting our voices heard and our tale told at last . . . . Ever-optimistically yours,

Canada Toolbar : Search from anywhere on the web and bookmark your favourite sites. Download it now!

Looking for the perfect gift? Give the gift of Flickr!

All new - Get a sneak peak at messages with a handy reading pane.

Posted

Hi ,

I am happy to help with any writing projects. But I can say that I have never met any medical professional who considered flat back syndrome a serious medical problem. Pain itself is often overlooked as something that just needs to be endured.

In my humble opinion, i believe most people are more interested in Tiger Woods' infidelities than they are about how much pain the human body can actually endure (until it happens to them). But that doesn't mean we give up. Your posts are always intelligent and it sounds like you've been through a lot without letting it defeat you.

kind regards,

brian

From: "bmansfield01@..." <bmansfield01@...> Sent: Tue, January 19, 2010 4:48:25 PMSubject: Re: This is it -- the BIGGIE! -- Question of the Week, 2010/4

hi elizabeth,

i thought i would answer. People who couldn't last a day in our bodies and yet think they have pain, too, will never be converted. I have chronic severe pain every bit as bad as it can be. I have been told this by very conservative doctors. People don't want to hear about my pain and I am well aware of it.

I have finally rec'd the ADA accommodations to take the CT bar. I plan to be visible and as productive as I can possibly be. I look like a fucked up mess because that's what a doctor did to me. Then I had to find doctors to fix it. If it wasn't for Dr. Boachie at the Hospital for Special Surgery and medication, I wouldn't be here.

Thank my lucky stars that I can get pain meds because without them I can't move or think. In fact, only one or two pain meds actually even touch my pain and it's just that bad. I hope to go back work as a disability lawyer. If I had to do physical labor of any sort it would be impossible. I wrote my story down in three very easy to read books because I owe that to anyone in this boat and I also wanted to make an honest portrait of the American medical system and what it can do to an otherwise healthy person, it's not angry , it's honest. my first surgeon was removed from a hospital and after countless botched surgeries, he killed himself.

I have considered euthanasia, if I wasn't a buddhist, I would have done it on line for the world to see what botched back surgery can lead to . But there's enough hatred out there against the disabled as slackers and freeloaders and some people would have said good. The ancient Greeks threw the disabled off of mountains. We don't need to go backwards. My plan is to keep myself from killling myself and go back to work even if only part time and I plan to keep on breathing until my natural time comes.

Three years ago I ended up detoxing myself and almost died a few times. For anyone in that situation, please try yoga. I tried nearly everything and yoga and meditation saved my life. I also found a good doctor who was willing to give me the right meds and the right dosing.

If you ever want to talk , I will be happy to do so. You're a shining star for people in our situation.

Namaste,

<elizabethrgonzalez@...> Sent: Tue, January 19, 2010 2:25:34 PMSubject: This is it -- the BIGGIE! -- Question of the Week, 2010/4

Recently Barbara posted at Feisty, regarding other people's responses to her spinal problems, ". . . I have just about given up trying to educate anyone about them. Over all, people just don't care. To most people I have a 'bad back.'"Does this ring a bell with you? It sure did with me. Do you think we need to find a powerful, effective way to arouse people's interest and communicate the enormity of the flatback pandemic that has totaled a whole generation of us scoliosis grads (the vast majority of us women)? Do you think that together we may just be able to figure out how to do this, how to spread the message in such a way that it simply cannot be ignored? Call me deluded, but I do -- after all these years, I still do! I just read a review of a new documentary film called NoBody's Perfect, about the lives and feelings of 12 highly articulate adults who were born deformed by thalidomide. At least one of these

people has no limbs at all; others manage cocktails and computers with their toes. It occurred to me, reading this review, that almost everyone has heard of the thalidomide tragedy -- but almost no one has heard of flatback syndrome.Who knows what kind of public interest, funding opportunitites, etc., we might attract if anyone knew we existed? (The "thalidomides, " as they call themselves, have sought and received ongoing reparations from the drug company in Germany, although not in Britain as yet. That's gotta beat 2-3 income-free years while undergoing massive surgery and waiting for your Social Security Disability claim to be approved!) A successful public education campaign could even give some much-needed impetus to the kind of crucial scientific research we talked about yesterday, leading to a clue or two concerning the origins of that mysterious and life-shattering bombshell that clobbered so many of us in the midst of

our fun-loving years and put us squarely on the path to The Desolate Land of Flatback: Adolescent ! Idiopath ic Scoliosis.Don't worry, I'm getting to the Question of the Week! -- but I've indulged in this long -winded preface because of one startling fact that leapt out at me from the movie review. Here it is: People with deformities caused by the thalidomide prescribed for their pregnant moms (in countries where the drug was allowed to go to market) total 10,000 to 12,000. (Of these, only 17 are in the US, since a vigilant female doc at the FDA studied all the premarketing data on thalidomide and said "No way.") In contrast, adults wth flatback syndrome severe enough to require revision surgery are thought to number at least 1 million. (Moreover, that SRS estimate was predicated on the approximate number of people with Harrington rods. It predated the full realization that Luque rods were also doing a number on people's spines,

not to mention the news that some spinal surgeons -- even as we speak, so to speak -- are, implausibly, continuing to destroy people's lumbar lordosis by fusing without regard to sagittal mechanics. I would tell you that last little factoid was unsubstantiated hearsay, but it came from a truly impeccable source: Dr. Ondra, my most recent revision surgeon, who was giving me an eyewitness account of what he was seeing in his practice, much to his own incredulity. )Now, maybe I'm naive, or maybe there's something I'm just not getting here -- but please tell me, if you can: Isn't there some way a million of us feisty folk can get ourselves a little bit closer to the spotlight, if not the limelight -- can get the word out to some of the multiple millions who are sure to be affected by flatback syndrome, whether as patients, family membrs, close friends, employers, or providers of medical or social services to people with

disabilities? Can you think of some "market" for our story that we haven't already tapped? (Or some sensational new way to formulate our third or fourth approach to Oprah's producers?) What's the "grabber" -- the! opening line of your own proposed "sales pitch"? How would you frame the subject? How would you "explain" it in a few simple, dramatic words? Or would you skip the words and go straight to the snapshots and x-rays? How would you make sure the person you were approaching understood from the get-go that this is not, not, NOT just another saga of moaning and groaning over that nasty ruptured disk -- that it involves just a bit more than an osteoarthritic sacroiliac or "a touch of the old lumbago" on rainy days?This is such an important issue to so many of us . . . I would love to hear everyone's thoughts, fantasies, brainstorms on this one, my faithful feisty friends. I would love to get an unprecedented response from a couple

hundred members (dream on, !) I'm totally serious -- even if you have never once posted to this group, and you will never ever post again, I would love, love, love to hear from you on this issue. I feel so strongly that someone out there has an answer, a breakthrough, an absolutely original and unprecedented proposal for getting our voices heard and our tale told at last . . . . Ever-optimistically yours,

Posted

Good point. However, there is nothing mild or moderate about flatback syndrome,

except for the small number of patients who are able to compensate sufficiently

to escape or postpone massive flatback revision surgery with its 30 percent rate

of complications. Nonetheless, I think you are right that we have a better

chance of getting on Dr. Oz. For whatever reason, none of us has been able to

convey the nature, prevalence, and severity of this condition to Oprah or the

producers who screen her mail.

I mention prevalence because, per Scoliosis Research Society estimates, there

are at least a million of us -- or there will be before this debacle is over and

the last patients crippled by Harrington or Luque rods (or by those surgeons --

number unknown -- who are, incredibly, still ignoring the sagittal dimension)

have all had their backs surgically broken and remade (frequently while having

to leave small children or ailing and dependent parents in the care of others),

their ability to support themselves severely compromised or destroyed, their

social lives profoundly disrupted, and (if they are lucky) their untenable

chronic pain -- which, contrary to what we and our surgeons want so much to

believe, tends to worsen with each spinal surgery --mercifully subdued by potent

medications once reserved for cancer patients.

I would agree with you re " 20/20, " which does not air or film each day and seems

to focus on even more dramatic stories than ours. In fact, our best shot at some

TV exposure might be a coincidental case of flatback syndrome popping up in the

middle of, say, " American Idol " or " Project Runway " -- or, God forbid, in

someone like Paris Hilton, " Hannah Montana, " or Trump. Come to think of

it, one of our former members had a family member who wrote for television --

maybe we missed our best shot there. If Simpson or her mom needed revision

surgery, " flatback " might soon be a household word. Or better yet, how about the

female detective on SVU? (I can't remember the actress's name at the moment, but

she is Jayne Mansfield's daughter.)

I might suggest sending a flatback patient to Dr. House, who can diagnose any

condition on earth (unlike some real-life orthopods we know!), except that he

unfortunately screwed up royally when it came to handling his own chronic pain

from a leg injury, thereby setting pain medicine back several decades. (If you

believe the show -- which had real-life pain patients inundating the studio with

complaints -- someone with pain as bad as House's who needs to take Vicodin (not

oral morphine, not Oxycontin, not even Norco-- Vicodin!) is bound to start

stealing the stuff from patients and pharmacies, lapsing into a florid

psychosis, and ultimately sending himself to Rehab. In real life, of course, he

would have sent himself into hepatotoxity and needed a liver transplant STAT.

Best,

>

> I think there is a good chance of getting on the Dr. Oz Show; however, I think

the chances of getting on Oprah (or even 20/20) is extremely slim. I have a mild

Tourette's Syndrome. The only time Oprah and 20/20 has done segments on

Tourette's is with MAJOR extremes (for example major Coprolalia ( " involuntary

swearing or the involuntary utterance of obscene words or socially inappropriate

and derogatory remarks " )). Mild or even moderate almost never.

>

>

S.

>

>

>

>

> From: Slinker <slinkers5@...>

>

> Sent: Wed, January 20, 2010 11:46:21 AM

> Subject: Re: This is it -- the BIGGIE! -- Question of the Week,

2010/4

>

>

> ,

>

> Just wanted to let you know that I sent a note to the Oprah show regarding

scoliosis and flatback. One thing that might have the greatest impact would be

to send them a video of a person or people who have gone through scoliosis and

flatback and the challenges that come with this disease. The online contact

process for the show only allows 2000 characters and no way to submit pictures,

etc.

>

> I believe the greatest impact would be to show some before and after photos as

well as some first hand experiences of some of the members here. The visuals of

x-rays and the very real impact of scoliosis would have the best impact and

therefore possible generate the most interest. Of course, mentioning

celebrities that have this condition is also a great idea.

>

> Another person that might highlight this issue is Dr. Mehmet Oz, I think he

even has his own show now but I'm not certain what cable channel it's on.

Discover Health would be another great place to go.

>

> Do you know of anyone that can help create such a video / dvd?

>

> Jeanne

>

> This is it -- the BIGGIE! -- Question of the Week,

2010/4

>

>

>

> Recently Barbara posted at Feisty, regarding other people's responses to her

spinal problems, " . . . I have just about given up trying to educate anyone

about them. Over all, people just don't care. To most people I have a 'bad

back.' "

>

> Does this ring a bell with you? It sure did with me.

>

> Do you think we need to find a powerful, effective way to arouse people's

interest and communicate the enormity of the flatback pandemic that has totaled

a whole generation of us scoliosis grads (the vast majority of us women)? Do you

think that together we may just be able to figure out how to do this, how to

spread the message in such a way that it simply cannot be ignored? Call me

deluded, but I do -- after all these years, I still do!

>

> I just read a review of a new documentary film called NoBody's Perfect, about

the lives and feelings of 12 highly articulate adults who were born deformed by

thalidomide. At least one of these people has no limbs at all; others manage

cocktails and computers with their toes.

>

> It occurred to me, reading this review, that almost everyone has heard of the

thalidomide tragedy -- but almost no one has heard of flatback syndrome.Who

knows what kind of public interest, funding opportunitites, etc., we might

attract if anyone knew we existed? (The " thalidomides, " as they call

themselves, have sought and received ongoing reparations from the drug company

in Germany, although not in Britain as yet. That's gotta beat 2-3 income-free

years while undergoing massive surgery and waiting for your Social Security

Disability claim to be approved!) A successful public education campaign could

even give some much-needed impetus to the kind of crucial scientific research we

talked about yesterday, leading to a clue or two concerning the origins of

that mysterious and life-shattering bombshell that clobbered so many of us in

the midst of our fun-loving years and put us squarely on the path to The

Desolate Land of Flatback: Adolescent ! Idiopath ic Scoliosis.

>

> Don't worry, I'm getting to the Question of the Week! -- but I've indulged in

this long -winded preface because of one startling fact that leapt out at me

from the movie review. Here it is: People with deformities caused by the

thalidomide prescribed for their pregnant moms (in countries where the drug was

allowed to go to market) total 10,000 to 12,000. (Of these, only 17 are in the

US, since a vigilant female doc at the FDA studied all the premarketing data on

thalidomide and said " No way. " )

>

> In contrast, adults wth flatback syndrome severe enough to require revision

surgery are thought to number at least 1 million. (Moreover, that SRS estimate

was predicated on the approximate number of people with Harrington rods. It

predated the full realization that Luque rods were also doing a number on

people's spines, not to mention the news that some spinal surgeons -- even as we

speak, so to speak -- are, implausibly, continuing to destroy people's lumbar

lordosis by fusing without regard to sagittal mechanics. I would tell you that

last little factoid was unsubstantiated hearsay, but it came from a truly

impeccable source: Dr. Ondra, my most recent revision surgeon, who was

giving me an eyewitness account of what he was seeing in his practice, much to

his own incredulity. )

>

> Now, maybe I'm naive, or maybe there's something I'm just not getting here --

but please tell me, if you can: Isn't there some way a million of us feisty

folk can get ourselves a little bit closer to the spotlight, if not the

limelight -- can get the word out to some of the multiple millions who are sure

to be affected by flatback syndrome, whether as patients, family membrs, close

friends, employers, or providers of medical or social services to people with

disabilities? Can you think of some " market " for our story that we haven't

already tapped? (Or some sensational new way to formulate our third or fourth

approach to Oprah's producers?) What's the " grabber " -- the! opening line of

your own proposed " sales pitch " ? How would you frame the subject? How would you

" explain " it in a few simple, dramatic words? Or would you skip the words and go

straight to the snapshots and x-rays? How would you make sure the person you

were approaching understood from the get-go that this is not, not, NOT just

another saga of moaning and groaning over that nasty ruptured disk -- that it

involves just a bit more than an osteoarthritic sacroiliac or " a touch of the

old lumbago " on rainy days?

>

> This is such an important issue to so many of us . . . I would love to hear

everyone's thoughts, fantasies, brainstorms on this one, my faithful feisty

friends. I would love to get an unprecedented response from a couple hundred

members (dream on, !) I'm totally serious -- even if you have never

once posted to this group, and you will never ever post again, I would love,

love, love to hear from you on this issue. I feel so strongly that someone out

there has an answer, a breakthrough, an absolutely original and unprecedented

proposal for getting our voices heard and our tale told at last . . . .

>

> Ever-optimistically yours,

>

>

Posted

On this one, , I must respectfully beg to differ with you.

Dr. Boachie, your surgeon, surely considers flatback syndrome a serious

issue

So do plenty of people who get to know us and eventually see the light!

It is important to keep up the dialogue. You never know when some

medical professional may " come around. "

I wrote to you about pain in my response to your previous post. You can

read it at the Feisty site if you missed it. We need to keep working on

the pain issue too, in concert with the many, many groups and activist

individuals now addressing this issue seriously today. I hope you

subscribe to some of the free materials describing varous initiatives in

this area, such as the American Pain Foundation's newsletters.

Best,

>

> Hi ,

>

> I am happy to help with any writing projects. But I can say that I

have never met any medical professional who considered flat back

syndrome a serious medical problem. Pain itself is often overlooked as

something that just needs to be endured.

>

> In my humble opinion, i believe most people are more interested in

Tiger Woods' infidelities than they are about how much pain the human

body can actually endure (until it happens to them). But that doesn't

mean we give up. Your posts are always intelligent and it sounds like

you've been through a lot without letting it defeat you.

>

>

>

> kind regards,

> brian

> From: " bmansfield01@... " bmansfield01@...

>

> Sent: Tue, January 19, 2010 4:48:25 PM

> Subject: Re: This is it -- the BIGGIE! -- Question of

the Week, 2010/4

>

>

> hi elizabeth,

>

> i thought i would answer. People who couldn't last a day in our bodies

and yet think they have pain, too, will never be converted. I have

chronic severe pain every bit as bad as it can be. I have been told this

by very conservative doctors. People don't want to hear about my pain

and I am well aware of it.

>

> I have finally rec'd the ADA accommodations to take the CT bar. I plan

to be visible and as productive as I can possibly be. I look like a

fucked up mess because that's what a doctor did to me. Then I had to

find doctors to fix it. If it wasn't for Dr. Boachie at the Hospital for

Special Surgery and medication, I wouldn't be here.

>

>

> Thank my lucky stars that I can get pain meds because without them I

can't move or think. In fact, only one or two pain meds actually even

touch my pain and it's just that bad. I hope to go back work as a

disability lawyer. If I had to do physical labor of any sort it would be

impossible. I wrote my story down in three very easy to read books

because I owe that to anyone in this boat and I also wanted to make an

honest portrait of the American medical system and what it can do to an

otherwise healthy person, it's not angry , it's honest. my first surgeon

was removed from a hospital and after countless botched surgeries, he

killed himself.

>

>

> I have considered euthanasia, if I wasn't a buddhist, I would have

done it on line for the world to see what botched back surgery can lead

to . But there's enough hatred out there against the disabled as

slackers and freeloaders and some people would have said good. The

ancient Greeks threw the disabled off of mountains. We don't need to go

backwards. My plan is to keep myself from killling myself and go back

to work even if only part time and I plan to keep on breathing until my

natural time comes.

>

> Three years ago I ended up detoxing myself and almost died a few

times. For anyone in that situation, please try yoga. I tried nearly

everything and yoga and meditation saved my life. I also found a good

doctor who was willing to give me the right meds and the right dosing.

>

> If you ever want to talk , I will be happy to do so. You're a shining

star for people in our situation.

>

> Namaste,

>

>

> elizabethrgonzalez@...

>

> Sent: Tue, January 19, 2010 2:25:34 PM

> Subject: This is it -- the BIGGIE! -- Question of the

Week, 2010/4

>

>

> Recently Barbara posted at Feisty, regarding other people's responses

to her spinal problems, " . . . I have just about given up trying to

educate anyone about them. Over all, people just don't care. To most

people I have a 'bad back.' "

>

> Does this ring a bell with you? It sure did with me.

>

> Do you think we need to find a powerful, effective way to arouse

people's interest and communicate the enormity of the flatback pandemic

that has totaled a whole generation of us scoliosis grads (the vast

majority of us women)? Do you think that together we may just be able to

figure out how to do this, how to spread the message in such a way that

it simply cannot be ignored? Call me deluded, but I do -- after all

these years, I still do!

>

> I just read a review of a new documentary film called NoBody's

Perfect, about the lives and feelings of 12 highly articulate adults who

were born deformed by thalidomide. At least one of these people has no

limbs at all; others manage cocktails and computers with their toes.

>

> It occurred to me, reading this review, that almost everyone has heard

of the thalidomide tragedy -- but almost no one has heard of flatback

syndrome.Who knows what kind of public interest, funding opportunitites,

etc., we might attract if anyone knew we existed? (The " thalidomides, "

as they call themselves, have sought and received ongoing reparations

from the drug company in Germany, although not in Britain as yet. That's

gotta beat 2-3 income-free years while undergoing massive surgery and

waiting for your Social Security Disability claim to be approved!) A

successful public education campaign could even give some much-needed

impetus to the kind of crucial scientific research we talked about

yesterday, leading to a clue or two concerning the origins of that

mysterious and life-shattering bombshell that clobbered so many of us in

the midst of our fun-loving years and put us squarely on the path to The

Desolate Land of Flatback: Adolescent !

> Idiopath ic Scoliosis.

>

> Don't worry, I'm getting to the Question of the Week! -- but I've

indulged in this long -winded preface because of one startling fact that

leapt out at me from the movie review. Here it is: People with

deformities caused by the thalidomide prescribed for their pregnant moms

(in countries where the drug was allowed to go to market) total 10,000

to 12,000. (Of these, only 17 are in the US, since a vigilant female doc

at the FDA studied all the premarketing data on thalidomide and said " No

way. " )

>

> In contrast, adults wth flatback syndrome severe enough to require

revision surgery are thought to number at least 1 million. (Moreover,

that SRS estimate was predicated on the approximate number of people

with Harrington rods. It predated the full realization that Luque rods

were also doing a number on people's spines, not to mention the news

that some spinal surgeons -- even as we speak, so to speak -- are,

implausibly, continuing to destroy people's lumbar lordosis by fusing

without regard to sagittal mechanics. I would tell you that last little

factoid was unsubstantiated hearsay, but it came from a truly impeccable

source: Dr. Ondra, my most recent revision surgeon, who was

giving me an eyewitness account of what he was seeing in his practice,

much to his own incredulity. )

>

> Now, maybe I'm naive, or maybe there's something I'm just not getting

here -- but please tell me, if you can: Isn't there some way a million

of us feisty folk can get ourselves a little bit closer to the

spotlight, if not the limelight -- can get the word out to some of the

multiple millions who are sure to be affected by flatback syndrome,

whether as patients, family membrs, close friends, employers, or

providers of medical or social services to people with disabilities? Can

you think of some " market " for our story that we haven't already tapped?

(Or some sensational new way to formulate our third or fourth approach

to Oprah's producers?) What's the " grabber " -- the! opening line of your

own proposed " sales pitch " ? How would you frame the subject? How would

you " explain " it in a few simple, dramatic words? Or would you skip the

words and go straight to the snapshots and x-rays? How would you make

sure the person you were approaching understood from

> the get-go that this is not, not, NOT just another saga of moaning

and groaning over that nasty ruptured disk -- that it involves just a

bit more than an osteoarthritic sacroiliac or " a touch of the old

lumbago " on rainy days?

>

> This is such an important issue to so many of us . . . I would love to

hear everyone's thoughts, fantasies, brainstorms on this one, my

faithful feisty friends. I would love to get an unprecedented response

from a couple hundred members (dream on, !) I'm totally serious

-- even if you have never once posted to this group, and you will never

ever post again, I would love, love, love to hear from you on this

issue. I feel so strongly that someone out there has an answer, a

breakthrough, an absolutely original and unprecedented proposal for

getting our voices heard and our tale told at last . . . .

>

> Ever-optimistically yours,

>

>

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

Hi

Sorry to take so long to reply. Life is busy with working full time and lately the many details involved in a family wedding.

I've been mulling over your request, but I'm not sure if I'm the best one to write to Ms. Rossalini on behalf of the feisties. I've been told my flatback is "mild". And after reading through the many responses, I gather that you want to zero in on the issue of flatback. My big problem is curve progression post fusion. My lumbar curve is up to 65 degrees, despite Harrington surgery in my teens. I'm now 53.

Also, as someone pointed out, Oprah's show is ending soon, so it may be too late to persue that route.

Has there been any interest from the Dr. Oz show?

>>> From: elizabethrgonzalez@ ...> Subject: This is it -- the BIGGIE! -- Question of theWeek, 2010/4> FeistyScolioFlatbac kers@groups .com> Received: Tuesday, January 19, 2010, 2:25 PM>>>>>>> Recently Barbara posted at Feisty, regarding other people's responsesto her spinal problems, ". . . I have just about given up trying toeducate anyone about them. Over all, people just don't care. To mostpeople I have a 'bad back.'">> Does this ring a bell with you? It sure did with me.>> Do you think we need to find a powerful, effective way to arousepeople's interest and communicate the enormity of the flatback pandemicthat has totaled a whole generation of us scoliosis grads (the vastmajority of us women)? Do you think that together we may just be able tofigure out

how to do this, how to spread the message in such a way thatit simply cannot be ignored? Call me deluded, but I do -- after allthese years, I still do!>> I just read a review of a new documentary film called NoBody'sPerfect, about the lives and feelings of 12 highly articulate adults whowere born deformed by thalidomide. At least one of these people has nolimbs at all; others manage cocktails and computers with their toes.>> It occurred to me, reading this review, that almost everyone has heardof the thalidomide tragedy -- but almost no one has heard of flatbacksyndrome.Who knows what kind of public interest, funding opportunitites,etc., we might attract if anyone knew we existed? (The "thalidomides, "as they call themselves, have sought and received ongoing reparationsfrom the drug company in Germany, although not in Britain as yet. That'sgotta beat 2-3 income-free years while

undergoing massive surgery andwaiting for your Social Security Disability claim to be approved!) Asuccessful public education campaign could even give some much-neededimpetus to the kind of crucial scientific research we talked aboutyesterday, leading to a clue or two concerning the origins of thatmysterious and life-shattering bombshell that clobbered so many of us inthe midst of our fun-loving years and put us squarely on the path to TheDesolate Land of Flatback: Adolescent> Idiopathic Scoliosis.>> Don't worry, I'm getting to the Question of the Week! -- but I'veindulged in this long -winded preface because of one startling fact thatleapt out at me from the movie review. Here it is: People withdeformities caused by the thalidomide prescribed for their pregnant moms(in countries where the drug was allowed to go to market) total 10,000to 12,000. (Of these, only 17 are in the US, since

a vigilant female docat the FDA studied all the premarketing data on thalidomide and said "Noway.")>> In contrast, adults wth flatback syndrome severe enough to requirerevision surgery are thought to number at least 1 million. (Moreover,that SRS estimate was predicated on the approximate number of peoplewith Harrington rods. It predated the full realization that Luque rodswere also doing a number on people's spines, not to mention the newsthat some spinal surgeons -- even as we speak, so to speak -- are,implausibly, continuing to destroy people's lumbar lordosis by fusingwithout regard to sagittal mechanics. I would tell you that last littlefactoid was unsubstantiated hearsay, but it came from a truly impeccablesource: Dr. Ondra, my most recent revision surgeon, who wasgiving me an eyewitness account of what he was seeing in his practice,much to his own incredulity.

)>> Now, maybe I'm naive, or maybe there's something I'm just not gettinghere -- but please tell me, if you can: Isn't there some way a millionof us feisty folk can get ourselves a little bit closer to thespotlight, if not the limelight -- can get the word out to some of themultiple millions who are sure to be affected by flatback syndrome,whether as patients, family membrs, close friends, employers, orproviders of medical or social services to people with disabilities? Canyou think of some "market" for our story that we haven't already tapped?(Or some sensational new way to formulate our third or fourth approachto Oprah's producers?) What's the "grabber" -- the opening line of yourown proposed "sales pitch"? How would you frame the subject? How wouldyou "explain" it in a few simple, dramatic words? Or would you skip thewords and go straight to the snapshots and x-rays? How would you

makesure the person you were approaching understood from the> get-go that this is not, not, NOT just another saga of moaning andgroaning over that nasty ruptured disk -- that it involves just a bitmore than an osteoarthritic sacroiliac or "a touch of the old lumbago"on rainy days?>> This is such an important issue to so many of us . . . I would love tohear everyone's thoughts, fantasies, brainstorms on this one, myfaithful feisty friends. I would love to get an unprecedented responsefrom a couple hundred members (dream on, !) I'm totally serious-- even if you have never once posted to this group, and you will neverever post again, I would love, love, love to hear from you on thisissue. I feel so strongly that someone out there has an answer, abreakthrough, an absolutely original and unprecedented proposal forgetting our voices heard and our tale told at last . . .

..>> Ever-optimistically yours,> >>>>>>>>>>> ____________ _________ _________ _________ _________ _________ _> Ask a question on any topic and get answers from real people. Go to Answers and share what you know at http://ca.answers. >

Canada Toolbar : Search from anywhere on the web and bookmark your favourite sites. Download it now!

Posted

Hi, --

Thanks for your reply. Yes, you're right, I do want to zero in on flatback

rather than scoliosis. I think scoliosis is much better known, while flatback is

almost unrecognized.

I guess I was just trying to be polite to all the people who wrote in to tell me

about various celebrities with scoliosis. The celebrity we need -- I fear this

sounds really crass, and I apologize in advance -- is some poor celebrity with

flatback syndrome.

I haven't written to Dr. Oz yet, but I will. This has been a demanding winter

for me in ways I don't even want to get into! But I am glad to see that Kathy

apparently got some response about antidepressants combined with pain meds -- I

am starting to think along the same lines.

I am really thrilled at the response to my question about getting some media

attention, and I really do promise to follow up.

Best,

> >

> >

> > From: elizabethrgonzalez@ ...

> > Subject: This is it -- the BIGGIE! -- Question of the

> Week, 2010/4

> > FeistyScolioFlatbac kers@groups .com

> > Received: Tuesday, January 19, 2010, 2:25 PM

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > Recently Barbara posted at Feisty, regarding other people's responses

> to her spinal problems, " . . . I have just about given up trying to

> educate anyone about them. Over all, people just don't care. To most

> people I have a 'bad back.' "

> >

> > Does this ring a bell with you? It sure did with me.

> >

> > Do you think we need to find a powerful, effective way to arouse

> people's interest and communicate the enormity of the flatback pandemic

> that has totaled a whole generation of us scoliosis grads (the vast

> majority of us women)? Do you think that together we may just be able to

> figure out how to do this, how to spread the message in such a way that

> it simply cannot be ignored? Call me deluded, but I do -- after all

> these years, I still do!

> >

> > I just read a review of a new documentary film called NoBody's

> Perfect, about the lives and feelings of 12 highly articulate adults who

> were born deformed by thalidomide. At least one of these people has no

> limbs at all; others manage cocktails and computers with their toes.

> >

> > It occurred to me, reading this review, that almost everyone has heard

> of the thalidomide tragedy -- but almost no one has heard of flatback

> syndrome.Who knows what kind of public interest, funding opportunitites,

> etc., we might attract if anyone knew we existed? (The " thalidomides, "

> as they call themselves, have sought and received ongoing reparations

> from the drug company in Germany, although not in Britain as yet. That's

> gotta beat 2-3 income-free years while undergoing massive surgery and

> waiting for your Social Security Disability claim to be approved!) A

> successful public education campaign could even give some much-needed

> impetus to the kind of crucial scientific research we talked about

> yesterday, leading to a clue or two concerning the origins of that

> mysterious and life-shattering bombshell that clobbered so many of us in

> the midst of our fun-loving years and put us squarely on the path to The

> Desolate Land of Flatback: Adolescent

> > Idiopathic Scoliosis.

> >

> > Don't worry, I'm getting to the Question of the Week! -- but I've

> indulged in this long -winded preface because of one startling fact that

> leapt out at me from the movie review. Here it is: People with

> deformities caused by the thalidomide prescribed for their pregnant moms

> (in countries where the drug was allowed to go to market) total 10,000

> to 12,000. (Of these, only 17 are in the US, since a vigilant female doc

> at the FDA studied all the premarketing data on thalidomide and said " No

> way. " )

> >

> > In contrast, adults wth flatback syndrome severe enough to require

> revision surgery are thought to number at least 1 million. (Moreover,

> that SRS estimate was predicated on the approximate number of people

> with Harrington rods. It predated the full realization that Luque rods

> were also doing a number on people's spines, not to mention the news

> that some spinal surgeons -- even as we speak, so to speak -- are,

> implausibly, continuing to destroy people's lumbar lordosis by fusing

> without regard to sagittal mechanics. I would tell you that last little

> factoid was unsubstantiated hearsay, but it came from a truly impeccable

> source: Dr. Ondra, my most recent revision surgeon, who was

> giving me an eyewitness account of what he was seeing in his practice,

> much to his own incredulity. )

> >

> > Now, maybe I'm naive, or maybe there's something I'm just not getting

> here -- but please tell me, if you can: Isn't there some way a million

> of us feisty folk can get ourselves a little bit closer to the

> spotlight, if not the limelight -- can get the word out to some of the

> multiple millions who are sure to be affected by flatback syndrome,

> whether as patients, family membrs, close friends, employers, or

> providers of medical or social services to people with disabilities? Can

> you think of some " market " for our story that we haven't already tapped?

> (Or some sensational new way to formulate our third or fourth approach

> to Oprah's producers?) What's the " grabber " -- the opening line of your

> own proposed " sales pitch " ? How would you frame the subject? How would

> you " explain " it in a few simple, dramatic words? Or would you skip the

> words and go straight to the snapshots and x-rays? How would you make

> sure the person you were approaching understood from the

> > get-go that this is not, not, NOT just another saga of moaning and

> groaning over that nasty ruptured disk -- that it involves just a bit

> more than an osteoarthritic sacroiliac or " a touch of the old lumbago "

> on rainy days?

> >

> > This is such an important issue to so many of us . . . I would love to

> hear everyone's thoughts, fantasies, brainstorms on this one, my

> faithful feisty friends. I would love to get an unprecedented response

> from a couple hundred members (dream on, !) I'm totally serious

> -- even if you have never once posted to this group, and you will never

> ever post again, I would love, love, love to hear from you on this

> issue. I feel so strongly that someone out there has an answer, a

> breakthrough, an absolutely original and unprecedented proposal for

> getting our voices heard and our tale told at last . . . .

> >

> > Ever-optimistically yours,

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> ____________ _________ _________ _________ _________ _________ _

> > Ask a question on any topic and get answers from real people. Go to

> Answers and share what you know at http://ca.answers.

> >

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

> __________________________________________________________________

> The new Internet Explorer® 8 - Faster, safer, easier. Optimized for

Get it Now for Free! at http://downloads./ca/internetexplorer/

>

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...