Guest guest Posted May 22, 2010 Report Posted May 22, 2010 I listened to that programme when we were driving to Birmingham and I heard her mention that. She has abundant energy and wondered how she did what she does if she is taking levothyroxine only - perhaps she isn't. Perhaps we should find out. Perhaps she would be interested in our story. Luv - Sheila From: thyroid treatment [mailto:thyroid treatment ] On Behalf Of Jen Sent: 22 May 2010 01:03 thyroid treatment Subject: BBC Radio 4 " Running Away " .......mention of hypothyroidism Today's episode featured (Baroness) Rabbi Neuberger who touches, albeit briefly, on being diagnosed with an under-active thyroid. http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/console/b00f678s The whole programme is only 15 minutes long and is well worth listening to, but the bit about her thyroid problem is mentioned at the 9 minute mark. She always comes across as such a wonderfully dynamic and energised woman and the clip where she talks about not being even being able to get out of bed should, perhaps, be required listening by some of our GPs and specialists. Jen x No virus found in this incoming message. Checked by AVG - www.avg.com Version: 8.5.437 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2884 - Release Date: 05/20/10 18:26:00 Quote
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2010 Report Posted May 22, 2010 Hi Sheila - playing devil's advocate again - I know of quite a few people on T4 who seem perfectly happy and found it a wonderful relief from their symptoms. I'm not sure that " one size fits all " - one can always argue that they MIGHT feel even better if placed on NDT, or T4+T3.....and the recent studies sited would seem to offer some justification for this view - but only for a percentage of people. I DO understand why there is such a strong feeling about NDT on this site and such a strong feeling against T4. In some measure this is a very natural reaction given the strong bias towards T4 in the NHS (a bias which would appear to be unjustified and linked with the interests of pharmaceutical companies). Equally, I also think that TPA would do well to maintain a balanced approach and that in the long run there is more gain to be made by doing so(!) Love, Vicky > > I listened to that programme when we were driving to Birmingham and I heard > her mention that. She has abundant energy and wondered how she did what she > does if she is taking levothyroxine only - perhaps she isn't. Perhaps we > should find out. Perhaps she would be interested in our story. > > Luv - Sheila > > > > From: thyroid treatment > [mailto:thyroid treatment ] On Behalf Of Jen > Sent: 22 May 2010 01:03 > thyroid treatment > Subject: BBC Radio 4 " Running Away " ......mention > of hypothyroidism > > > > > > Today's episode featured (Baroness) Rabbi Neuberger who touches, > albeit briefly, on being diagnosed with an under-active thyroid. > > http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/console/b00f678s > > The whole programme is only 15 minutes long and is well worth listening to, > but the bit about her thyroid problem is mentioned at the 9 minute mark. > > She always comes across as such a wonderfully dynamic and energised woman > and the clip where she talks about not being even being able to get out of > bed should, perhaps, be required listening by some of our GPs and > specialists. > > Jen x > > > > No virus found in this incoming message. > Checked by AVG - www.avg.com > Version: 8.5.437 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2884 - Release Date: 05/20/10 > 18:26:00 > Quote
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2010 Report Posted May 22, 2010 Hi Vicky It's not a case of playing Devil's advocate, play that if you have some facts to the scientific evidence to show that what we are offering our members is wrong and biased. We are all aware that many people believe they are doing absolutely fine on levothyroxine only, when, in fact, if you delve much deeper, many of them are also taking other medications, i.e. pain killers, antidepressants and drugs for other symptoms. Nobody has ever denied that some people appear to do OK on levothyroxine only. Some people, however, do not do well - I am one - and 78.4% of 1500 of those treated with levothyroxine alone, in a 2005/2006 hypothyroid patient survey stated that they had not regained their normal health on levothyroxine alone. Often, this is because the T4 alone is not doing the job it should. T4 can work for years for some people, then suddenly, it stops working. One size certainly does not fit all. We require T4, T3, T2, T1 and calcitonin to make every cell in our body and brain function properly - if you are a good converter, that's good, but it doesn't work for a large minority - some would say - the majority, if the true facts were known. The recent studies give seriously flawed results - haven't you read the critiques? These patients were given tiny doses of T3 added to their T4 - a dose so small it is recommended for the very frail or for the very tiny. We are talking about 5mcgs/10mcgs that were given in these studies - where a normal starting dose of T3 is 20mcgs/25mcgs. Also, the strong feeling I (we) have about NDT has nothing whatsoever to do with there being a strong bias towards T4 within the NHS. Any bias towards T4 alone is because it is an inactive hormone, which must convert to the active T3. If a large minority of us cannot convert, why would such a bias be " unjustified " . Why would Internet and local thyroid support and help groups be full of thousands of sufferers trying to get back their normal health, who cannot do so within the NHS who are either not being given a diagnosis, or T4 only therapy? There are millions of such members world-wide. Do you think it's all in our head? In what way do you believe that TPA does not maintain a balanced approach? This is something I, and others, have strived to achieve. Please be specific and please back up your statements by citing references to the evidence that would show T4 works as well as T4/T3 combination, T3 alone or natural thyroid extract - without pointing to the well known flawed so called " scientific " studies. TPA prides itself on giving a good balanced approach, but if you feel we don't do this, perhaps you can let us know how we achieve a better result. I don't mind anybody playing Devil's Advocate, but please back up what you say with some facts and don't play Devil's Advocate just for the sake of doing this. Sheila Hi Sheila - playing devil's advocate again - I know of quite a few people on T4 who seem perfectly happy and found it a wonderful relief from their symptoms. I'm not sure that " one size fits all " - one can always argue that they MIGHT feel even better if placed on NDT, or T4+T3.....and the recent studies sited would seem to offer some justification for this view - but only for a percentage of people. I DO understand why there is such a strong feeling about NDT on this site and such a strong feeling against T4. In some measure this is a very natural reaction given the strong bias towards T4 in the NHS (a bias which would appear to be unjustified and linked with the interests of pharmaceutical companies). Equally, I also think that TPA would do well to maintain a balanced approach and that in the long run there is more gain to be made by doing so(!) Love, Vicky Quote
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2010 Report Posted May 22, 2010 In the recent comments on the telegraph article, some one posted that they had looked at the TPA web site but thought it was too opposed to the views of the BTA. Well yes, this ties in with vicky saying about people doing OK with T4. I did brilliantly with T4 for many years, as far as I was concerned it was a wonder drug and I would have definately sided with the BTA. It wasn't until it went wrong that I started to question the treatment of using T4 only. We know that a large minority - don't suit T4 only. This forum is full of people who either can't get a diagnosis or who do badly with t4 only. If they were doing well they wouldn't be looking for a forum.... so we're obviously going to be seen as being anti t4 only treatment. I do think the forum is as balanced as it can be considering that we have take up an opposing stance to the BTA who are rigid, stupid and un scientific in their one med for all approach. > > > TPA prides itself on giving a good balanced approach, but if you feel we > don't do this, perhaps you can let us know how we achieve a better result. > > > Hi Sheila - playing devil's advocate again - I know of quite a few people on > T4 who seem perfectly happy and found it a wonderful relief from their > symptoms. > Equally, I also think that TPA would do well to maintain a balanced approach and that in the long run there is more gain to be made by doing so(!) > > Love, > > Vicky > Quote
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2010 Report Posted May 22, 2010 Whoever has made comment in the Telegraph comments section about TPA website being too opposed to the views of the BTA - thank goodness we are getting our message across. If it wasn't for the BTA's statements and guidelines for those with hypothyroidism, there would be no need for groups such as TPA or any other thyroid support groups for that matter. I hold them fully responsible for stating that everybody does well on levothyroxine and boycotting all T3 containing products. I also hold them fully responsible for the tens of thousands in the UK who are being denied a diagnosis because the BTA INSIST that a diagnosis should be based on thyroid function tests only. Can somebody give me a link please to the Telegraph publication. Luv - Sheila In the recent comments on the telegraph article, some one posted that they had looked at the TPA web site but thought it was too opposed to the views of the BTA. Well yes, this ties in with vicky saying about people doing OK with T4. I did brilliantly with T4 for many years, as far as I was concerned it was a wonder drug and I would have definately sided with the BTA. It wasn't until it went wrong that I started to question the treatment of using T4 only. We know that a large minority - don't suit T4 only. This forum is full of people who either can't get a diagnosis or who do badly with t4 only. If they were doing well they wouldn't be looking for a forum.... so we're obviously going to be seen as being anti t4 only treatment. I do think the forum is as balanced as it can be considering that we have take up an opposing stance to the BTA who are rigid, stupid and un scientific in their one med for all approach. > > > TPA prides itself on giving a good balanced approach, but if you feel we > don't do this, perhaps you can let us know how we achieve a better result. > > > Hi Sheila - playing devil's advocate again - I know of quite a few people on > T4 who seem perfectly happy and found it a wonderful relief from their > symptoms. > Equally, I also think that TPA would do well to maintain a balanced approach and that in the long run there is more gain to be made by doing so(!) > > Love, > > Vicky > No virus found in this incoming message. Checked by AVG - www.avg.com Version: 8.5.437 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2884 - Release Date: 05/21/10 18:26:00 Quote
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2010 Report Posted May 22, 2010 Hi Sheila, Comments below – I guess the post that triggered my response looked very much as though you were saying that nobody did OK on Levothyroxine. Obviously I misunderstood that bit of it! I'm glad that is clearer! if you delve much deeper, many of themare also taking other medications, i.e. pain killers, antidepressants anddrugs for other symptoms. Nobody has ever denied that some people appear todo OK on levothyroxine only. Some people, however, do not do well - I am one- and 78.4% of 1500 of those treated with levothyroxine alone, in a2005/2006 hypothyroid patient survey stated that they had not regained theirnormal health on levothyroxine alone. Often, this is because the T4 aloneis not doing the job it should. T4 can work for years for some people, thensuddenly, it stops working. I am not suggesting that there are not people (and a significant minority, if not more) who quite obviously from all the wonderful data you supply do better on NDT and who do not fare well on T4. I don't think that this constitutes evidence that nobody does well on T4. I leave the research data to you as you deal with much of this so admirably. I just felt concerned that there seemed to be an automatic assumption that everyone on T4 is getting second best (that said, I suspect I personally might be better on NDT or T4+T3)One size certainly does not fit all. We require T4, T3, T2, T1 andcalcitonin to make every cell in our body and brain function properly - ifyou are a good converter, that's good, but it doesn't work for a largeminority - some would say - the majority, if the true facts were known.The recent studies give seriously flawed results - haven't you read thecritiques? These patients were given tiny doses of T3 added to their T4 - adose so small it is recommended for the very frail or for the very tiny. Weare talking about 5mcgs/10mcgs that were given in these studies - where anormal starting dose of T3 is 20mcgs/25mcgs. Yes – I have read some of the research papers presented, though nothing like as comprehensively as you have(!) I am in full sympathy with the research. I just happen to know people on T4 who are perfectly happy with their medication and doing fantastically well on it. Also, I read many stories of people who are struggling on other medications, partly because NDT is not "one" medicine – there seem to be different formulae and different people seem to respond differently. Also, the strong feeling I (we) have about NDT has nothing whatsoever to dowith there being a strong bias towards T4 within the NHS. Any bias towardsT4 alone is because it is an inactive hormone, which must convert to theactive T3. If a large minority of us cannot convert, why would such a biasbe "unjustified" . Why would Internet and local thyroid support and helpgroups be full of thousands of sufferers trying to get back their normalhealth, who cannot do so within the NHS who are either not being given adiagnosis, or T4 only therapy? There are millions of such membersworld-wide. Do you think it's all in our head? Not at all! (As many of my posts will have made quite clear, I hope).I think the TPA website is extremely well intended and doing a wonderful job. As I said in my original post, I personally think there is a very good reason to believe that NDT would be generally better tolerated and used given that it does supply the full range of hormones and is less reliant on other bits of the "jigsaw puzzle" of our bodies to do additional work. On the other side of the coin, I think the research paper cited by in a recent post demonstrated that when a sample of people who were well established on T4 therapy were given T3 in addition, the majority of them preferred dual therapy – but there was a minority group who felt they were better on T4 alone. This is the only study I have seen so far who used a group who were STABLE on therapy as the research sample. I may have misread or misunderstood some parts of the paper. My brains are still a bit addled though striving hard to get themselves back together - I am not yet up to struggling with every detail and citing research data in formalized terms as I would have done in years gone by. But it is because I have had a research training that I don't automatically adopt any one given viewpoint and always tend to question things somewhat. Sorry if this causes offence, but I really do feel quite strongly that this can be a strength. My comments are not intended to undermine you or TPA, or what you are trying to offer in any way. Sometimes, by pitting ourselves against the arguments and counter arguments we gain strength and learn to balance the arguments and gain an even stronger overview. This is my only intention in raising issues that may appear to be inflammatory. In what way do you believe that TPA does not maintain a balanced approach?This is something I, and others, have strived to achieve. Please bespecific and please back up your statements by citing references to theevidence that would show T4 works as well as T4/T3 combination, T3 alone ornatural thyroid extract - without pointing to the well known flawed socalled "scientific" studies. TPA prides itself on giving a good balanced approach, but if you feel wedon't do this, perhaps you can let us know how we achieve a better result.I don't mind anybody playing Devil's Advocate, but please back up what yousay with some facts and don't play Devil's Advocate just for the sake ofdoing this. I hope this clarifies why I sent my post. It was not intended to be critical of you, or of TPA and I think you are doing a great job. It also scares me stiff that people are self medicating to the extent that they are. It is brilliant that you are able to offer us all support and help when we are driven to these extremities. Like you, I just wish that everyone was getting sufficient help within the NHS.Vicky> Quote
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2010 Report Posted May 22, 2010 Hi Sheila, here's the link - my post was under name of hoxo I think. Helen www.telegraph.co.uk/health/healthadvice/lifecoach > Can somebody give me a link please to the Telegraph publication. > > Luv - Sheila Quote
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2010 Report Posted May 22, 2010 PERSONALLY - I don't believe that anyone does OK on levo, I think they are convinced by their doctors that their problems are not thyroid related and not having the information they believe it!! Quote
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2010 Report Posted May 22, 2010 http://www.telegraph.co.uk/health/healthadvice/lifecoach should link > > Hi Sheila, here's the link - my post was under name of hoxo I think. > > Helen > > www.telegraph.co.uk/health/healthadvice/lifecoach > > > Can somebody give me a link please to the Telegraph publication. > > > > Luv - Sheila > Quote
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2010 Report Posted May 22, 2010 Thanks Helen, I clicked on the Thyroid link and made a response. Luv - Sheila www.telegraph.co.uk/health/healthadvice/lifecoach > Hi Sheila, here's the link - my post was under name of hoxo I think. > > Helen > Quote
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2010 Report Posted May 22, 2010 I think that is the point I was trying to make here . I don't question most of other arguments, or the ethos of the site. But it is really important not to deny the fact that T4 alone is a helluva lot better than nothing for a lot of people - the fine tuning is another matter, essential, but sometimes the basics can put one in a position to at least be able to begin to recognise the problems and begin to sort things out. As such is it not to be totally denigrated. Vicky > This forum is full of people who either can't get a diagnosis or who do > badly with t4 only. If they were doing well they wouldn't be looking for a > forum.... so we're obviously going to be seen as being anti t4 only > treatment. I do think the forum is as balanced as it can be considering that > we have take up an opposing stance to the BTA who are rigid, stupid and un > scientific in their one med for all approach. > > Quote
Guest guest Posted May 22, 2010 Report Posted May 22, 2010 I don't understand! If you are prescibed levo it assumes you have a thyroid related problem! THAT CAN BE THE STARTING POINT for thinking about solutions. And looking for relevant information! The real problems arise when doctors say that your thyroid problems are normal when they are not! That is why I don't entirely denigrate Levo! Vicky > > PERSONALLY - I don't believe that anyone does OK on levo, I think they are convinced by their doctors that their problems are not thyroid related and not having the information they believe it!! > Quote
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2010 Report Posted May 23, 2010 Hi Vicky If it helps I am in total agreement with you. When you think in terms that something like 2.7% of the population are treated with levothyroxine compared with the few that treat themselves with the NDT, this has to say something. I know many people taking levothyroxine and they dont take anything else. Maybe it is just the dosing of levothyroxine for some people that is the problem. L > > > I don't understand! If you are prescibed levo it assumes you have a thyroid related problem! THAT CAN BE THE STARTING POINT for thinking about solutions. And looking for relevant information! The real problems arise when doctors say that your thyroid problems are normal when they are not! > > That is why I don't entirely denigrate Levo! > > Vicky Quote
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2010 Report Posted May 23, 2010 Hi Vicky Some of us can't get Levo prescribed on the nhs ... they will not accept we have thyroid problems because of our supposedly " normal " blood results. I hope it is a starting point but at the moment for me it just seems a continuation of the battle! Sam > > > > PERSONALLY - I don't believe that anyone does OK on levo, I think they are convinced by their doctors that their problems are not thyroid related and not having the information they believe it!! > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2010 Report Posted May 23, 2010 Is thyroxine bioidentical to T4? Most manufactured versions of natural hormones have been altered slightly so that they can be patented. It just isn't logical that some synthetic version should be better than the original. This is certainly what Dr Lee says about synthetic versus natural progesterone. Synthetic progesterone can slot into the receptors for progesterone, but doesn't work in the body in the same way. I think you should bear in mind that people who are perfectly happy on thyroxine would be unlikely to visit a site such as this. This group is fulfilling a need. Also, if you think this group is advocating a " one size fits all " approach you can't have read very much on here yet. Miriam > > I'm not sure that " one size fits all " - one can always argue that they MIGHT feel even better if placed on NDT, or T4+T3.....and the recent studies sited would seem to offer some justification for this view - but only for a percentage of people. Quote
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2010 Report Posted May 23, 2010 Hi Lynne Before the manufacture of synthetic thyroxine, EVERY single sufferer of hypothyroidism was treated with natural desiccated thyroid extract (NDT) ONLY. This was the case throughout the whole of the world, and no problems in its safety and effectiveness was reported whatsoever. It is ONLY since the manufacture of synthetic thyroxine, and the markets insistence that all such sufferers need is this mainly inactive thyroid hormone replacement, and that it works for everybody, that suddenly, the new diagnoses of fibromyalgia, chronic fatigue syndrome etc started to be given, because it is an absolute fact, that not everybody is able to convert T4 to the active thyroid hormone T3. It is T3 our body thrives on - not T4. You should be aware the thousands of cases of Fibromyalgia and CFS have been treated with great success using the active thyroid hormone triiodothyronine (T3). No matter how doctors titrate some of their patient's levothyroxine, if it can't get into the cells in the body and brain through conversion, it simply can't work. I know, I had every titration possible and only regained normal health through natural thyroid extract. Have you yourself managed to titrate your levothyroxine in such a way that now works for you which has now given you back normal health? Luv - Sheila When you think in terms that something like 2.7% of the population are treated with levothyroxine compared with the few that treat themselves with the NDT, this has to say something. I know many people taking levothyroxine and they dont take anything else. Maybe it is just the dosing of levothyroxine for some people that is the problem. L --- Quote
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2010 Report Posted May 23, 2010 As I am still trying to get my head round what this group is all about, is it you guys who want an NHS diagnosis of hypothyroidism who are taking NDT and self medicating. If this is the case, then how can people who have no NHS diagnosis claim levothyroxine does not work. It works for all the millions who have been diagnosed with hypothyroidism. L > > > Hi Vicky > Some of us can't get Levo prescribed on the nhs ... they will not accept we have thyroid problems because of our supposedly " normal " blood results. I hope it is a starting point but at the moment for me it just seems a continuation of the battle! > Sam > Quote
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2010 Report Posted May 23, 2010 Hi Vicky, There are two distinct problems that we have to deal with- those who can't get a diagnosis of hypo because TSH does not go out of range, and those who do not do well on T4 alone. Yes, we do say try T4 first- after all once you have got a diagnosis from your GP it is free and simple. BUT most of the folk who come here have already 'been there done that' so naturally most of the mail is directed to their needs- which iis usually for T3 in some form as well as other related issues. > thyroid treatment > From: hobbsvic@...> Date: Sat, 22 May 2010 10:27:22 +0000> Subject: Re: BBC Radio 4 "Running Away" ......mention of hypothyroidism> > Hi Sheila - playing devil's advocate again - I know of quite a few people on T4 who seem perfectly happy and found it a wonderful relief from their symptoms.> > I'm not sure that "one size fits all" - one can always argue that they MIGHT feel even better if placed on NDT, or T4+T3.....and the recent studies sited would seem to offer some justification for this view - but only for a percentage of people. > > I DO understand why there is such a strong feeling about NDT on this site and such a strong feeling against T4. In some measure this is a very natural reaction given the strong bias towards T4 in the NHS (a bias which would appear to be unjustified and linked with the interests of pharmaceutical companies).> > Equally, I also think that TPA would do well to maintain a balanced approach and that in the long run there is more gain to be made by doing so(!)> > Love,> > Vicky> > > >> > I listened to that programme when we were driving to Birmingham and I heard> > her mention that. She has abundant energy and wondered how she did what she> > does if she is taking levothyroxine only - perhaps she isn't. Perhaps we> > should find out. Perhaps she would be interested in our story.> > > > Luv - Sheila> > > > > > > > From: thyroid treatment > > [mailto:thyroid treatment ] On Behalf Of Jen> > Sent: 22 May 2010 01:03> > thyroid treatment > > Subject: BBC Radio 4 "Running Away" ......mention> > of hypothyroidism> > > > > > > > > > > > Today's episode featured (Baroness) Rabbi Neuberger who touches,> > albeit briefly, on being diagnosed with an under-active thyroid.> > > > http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/console/b00f678s> > > > The whole programme is only 15 minutes long and is well worth listening to,> > but the bit about her thyroid problem is mentioned at the 9 minute mark.> > > > She always comes across as such a wonderfully dynamic and energised woman> > and the clip where she talks about not being even being able to get out of> > bed should, perhaps, be required listening by some of our GPs and> > specialists.> > > > Jen x> > > > > > > > No virus found in this incoming message.> > Checked by AVG - www.avg.com> > Version: 8.5.437 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2884 - Release Date: 05/20/10> > 18:26:00> >> > > > > ------------------------------------> > TPA is not medically qualified. Consult with a qualified medical practitioner before changing medication.> > Quote
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2010 Report Posted May 23, 2010 Hi L, We have two problems- those who have all the symptoms of hypo, but have a TSH in normal range and thus do not gat a diagnosis, and those who have a diagnosis of hypo ( high TSH) and who do not have their symptoms controlled with T4 alone. both deserve consideration and yes many folk do well on levothyroxine- but many still do have residual symptoms- one size does not fit all, but all deserve help and consideration. > thyroid treatment > From: oaktrees56@...> Date: Sun, 23 May 2010 09:46:38 +0000> Subject: Re: BBC Radio 4 "Running Away" ......mention of hypothyroidism> > As I am still trying to get my head round what this group is all about, is it you guys who want an NHS diagnosis of hypothyroidism who are taking NDT and self medicating. > > If this is the case, then how can people who have no NHS diagnosis claim levothyroxine does not work. It works for all the millions who have been diagnosed with hypothyroidism.> > L> > > >> > > > Hi Vicky> > Some of us can't get Levo prescribed on the nhs ... they will not accept we have thyroid problems because of our supposedly "normal" blood results. I hope it is a starting point but at the moment for me it just seems a continuation of the battle!> > Sam> > > > > > > ------------------------------------> > TPA is not medically qualified. Consult with a qualified medical practitioner before changing medication.> > Quote
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2010 Report Posted May 23, 2010 > > As I am still trying to get my head round what this group is all about, is it you guys who want an NHS diagnosis of hypothyroidism who are taking NDT and self medicating. I'm not. I finally got a referral to Dr S after a long battle with my GP but they still don't accept the private tests I had done which showed low T3 and T4, they insist all my problems are due to fibromyalgia and refuse me a trial of Levo on the NHS for those reasons. I get my levo on private prescription at the moment. This group is very supportive and the information and research is invaluable for backing up your arguements. Without it I doubt I would have got a referral and I intend to carry on fighting. Sam Quote
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2010 Report Posted May 23, 2010 As I see it what we all want is for the reference ranges for blood tests to be re-assessed and set at the same levels as the USA and Europe, that way many people who are ill with hypo would automatically get SOME treatment. I for one would like to see ALL patients having a choice between being prescribed synthetic or natural thyroxine not just the few who are willing to battle their GP or Endo to get it, or, failing that, have to buy it themselves. (Especially after having paid into the NHS coffers all our working lives!!) As far as levo working for all the millions of people diagnosed with hypo - does it? Really? Can you back that up with evidence? I am not convinced having met many other sufferers who are still ill despite them having 'wonderful' GPs and endo's. I stand by what I have already said, that it is more likely that most patients on levo have been convinced by their doctors that the symptoms they are suffering have nothing to do with hypo and as such they are left to suffer!! This group is all about sharing our experiences and helping each other using those experiences, advice and guidance from people who have been there, not just read about it in a book!! Glynis <oaktrees56@...> wrote: > > As I am still trying to get my head round what this group is all about, is it you guys who want an NHS diagnosis of hypothyroidism who are taking NDT and self medicating. > If this is the case, then how can people who have no NHS diagnosis claim levothyroxine does not work. It works for all the millions who have been diagnosed with hypothyroidism. > > L Quote
Guest guest Posted May 23, 2010 Report Posted May 23, 2010 I absolutely agree Glynis. If all these millions were doing really well on levothyroxine alone, why am I spending hours of my day trying to help so many who are not. Why do I have hundreds of phone calls from those still suffering within the NHS. You are correct, many believe synthetic Thyroxine is fine, and they take the blame for their lingering symptoms as being down to other problems outside of their thyroid health. Luv - Sheila As I see it what we all want is for the reference ranges for blood tests to be re-assessed and set at the same levels as the USA and Europe, that way many people who are ill with hypo would automatically get SOME treatment. I for one would like to see ALL patients having a choice between being prescribed synthetic or natural thyroxine not just the few who are willing to battle their GP or Endo to get it, or, failing that, have to buy it themselves. (Especially after having paid into the NHS coffers all our working lives!!) As far as levo working for all the millions of people diagnosed with hypo - does it? Really? Can you back that up with evidence? I am not convinced having met many other sufferers who are still ill despite them having 'wonderful' GPs and endo's. I stand by what I have already said, that it is more likely that most patients on levo have been convinced by their doctors that the symptoms they are suffering have nothing to do with hypo and as such they are left to suffer!! This group is all about sharing our experiences and helping each other using those experiences, advice and guidance from people who have been there, not just read about it in a book!! Glynis <oaktrees56@...> wrote: > > As I am still trying to get my head round what this group is all about, is it you guys who want an NHS diagnosis of hypothyroidism who are taking NDT and self medicating. > If this is the case, then how can people who have no NHS diagnosis claim levothyroxine does not work. It works for all the millions who have been diagnosed with hypothyroidism. > > L No virus found in this incoming message. Checked by AVG - www.avg.com Version: 8.5.437 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2888 - Release Date: 05/22/10 18:26:00 Quote
Guest guest Posted May 24, 2010 Report Posted May 24, 2010 I would suggest reading all the files in the Files section, and reading all the messages in the archives. It will take a while, but you will certainly understand what the group is about by then! All kinds of thyroid related issues are discussed here, but obviously if someone has been diagnosed and treated successfully by the NHS they won't have much incentive to join such a group. Friends of mine who are on thyroxine mention all kinds of symptoms that they do not realise are thyroid related. So they believe all their thyroid problems are resolved, and treat these other health problems separately. This could be the case for many people. The NHS definition of a cure is simply the TSH reading. Symptoms are often not taken into account. Miriam > > As I am still trying to get my head round what this group is all about, is it you guys who want an NHS diagnosis of hypothyroidism who are taking NDT and self medicating. > > If this is the case, then how can people who have no NHS diagnosis claim levothyroxine does not work. It works for all the millions who have been diagnosed with hypothyroidism. Quote
Guest guest Posted May 24, 2010 Report Posted May 24, 2010 >playing devil's advocate again - I know of quite a few people on T4 >who seem perfectly happy and found it a wonderful relief from their >symptoms. > The only bias that TPA has is that the group is full of people who have suffered some sort of rigmarole by mainstream docotrs. i.e. trouble getting diagnosed in the first place and symptoms that are half fixed... I guess those who are perfectly happy with taking Levothyroxine wouldn't have any need to join TPA because they are fighting fit and getting on with a busy life. So naturally you only meet the " significant minority " here. The reason why I think there is so much controversy about alternatives or additional thyroid tablets is because of being a " significant minority " group. Perhaps the guidelines and mainstream medicine would view things differently if there was a 50:50 chance of symptoms being fully fixed on Levothyroxine, or perhaps if the standard medication was poor for the majority. I am sure that is what the problem is, i.e. the controversy is because it's " only " a minority of people. However statistics are meaningless if you are part of that minority and are trying to get well. I think TPA does recognise that there is a lottery that some people are fine and others are not. A bias towards a medication is one thing, as long as it works. The thing that I hate is the rigmaroles, the fighting when trying to sort out additional or alternative tablets. If you think about asthma medication, blood pressure medication, there are always alternatives and additionals if the first line of treatment doesn't fully work. I think it's all the thyroid patients want, is access to alternatives or additional tablets if their symptoms are only half fixed and cut the rigmaroles. I have had a BIG amount of controversy, both from health professionals, in the family, people I know... It never ends, all because I want better functioning. I have also found playing devils advocate has caused a lot of arguments at home with people. After all fighting for appropriate treatment is always going to be a sore point. What I have noticed is that in a letter, a family member seemed anxious and wondered what all this T3 business is about and if he needed it. I have always and still do make the assumption, until he tells me otherwise that the Levothyroxine fully alleviates things for him. Clearly it wouldn't do for a well person to pester their GP needlessly and go into the rigmaroles that we all have if they are actually well and it isn't necessary. So I have explained it to him that it's all for this signifcant minority of approx 20% who find their symptoms are fully fixed and that if symptoms are fine, it's not necessary. I also know somebody who " isn't quite right " on her Levothyroxine. So perhaps there are always going to be differences with people's symptoms. From " not quite right " but doing parenting, working part-time and housework etc, to being really really ill. Perhaps it takes a lot of people to be very ill, before they go through the rigmaroles and fighting and perhaps people wouldn't be willing to do all this if they are " not quite right " and would sooner say they are well, out of desperation to be well and carry on with their busy lives. Fiona. Quote
Guest guest Posted May 24, 2010 Report Posted May 24, 2010 > As I am still trying to get my head round what this group is all about, is it you guys who want an NHS diagnosis of hypothyroidism who are taking NDT and self medicating. > > If this is the case, then how can people who have no NHS diagnosis claim levothyroxine does not work. It works for all the millions who have been diagnosed with hypothyroidism. > I think this is why I have had a lot of controversy within the family and people I know, because the general public doesn't understand why it's possible to be so ill and yet the NHS doesn't recognise it. Basically the NHS is concerned with if you are producing the correct amount of thyroid hormone or not. It is possible for you to produce, but not utilize it at cellular level and not convert too well. Basically you are producing it fine, but doing nothing with it. This makes you very ill and gives all the symptoms. I started off with this problem and was VERY ill but the NHS doesn't recognise it and says it's unproven. I won't keep repeating myself, but I have been through hell. So there are two groups of people on this site. One with official diagnosis, but symptoms are half-fixed on Levothyroixne (group I am finally in) and the other group is the secondary problem that I mentioned above. One way or another, people have various trouble, with mainstream doctors not believing how ill they are, that's the situation for many TPA people. Those who are self medicating are doing so because the NHS wouldn't/couldn't diagnose, like I was before. Typically such patients are pushed in the direction of NDT rather than Levothyroxine, but I guess it depends on the doctor. Perhaps some of these people have tried Levothyroixne on a private basis and found it insufficient and think if they are paying for tablets, they may as well pay for something that works. As I say one way or another people on TPA who are saying it doesn't work are in the significant minority group of approx 20% of thyroid people who find that it doesn't fully alleviate the symptoms. I claim rather than it doing nothing, or making me worse, Levothyroxine gets me half-way-there, but why settle for second best? If people are well and have peace of mind about their Levothyroxine dose, good luck to them. But if people are still ill, people want further help and get their thyroid trouble fixing, rather than peddling round the same ground. Fiona Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.