Guest guest Posted June 9, 2010 Report Posted June 9, 2010 This is a mistake that many, many doctors make Heidi. They believe that everybody should have a TSH above 1.0, but when you are taking ALL the thyroid hormones your body requires that are in natural desiccated thyroid, there is absolutely no requirement for any TSH, so naturally, it would be suppressed. Your pituitary gland ONLY secretes TSH when it gets a signal that the level of thyroid hormones in the blood is too low. Doctors also make the mistake of believing you are going hyperthyroid if there is no TSH and your free T3 level is high. What you should do is to stop your natural thyroid extract for at least 24 hours before you next have your blood tested. This is because T3 has a short half life, and it peaks in the blood a couple of hours or so after you have taken the tablets. Taking it the morning of your blood draw can also cause your free T4 to be flawed. Unfortunately, your TSH will remain the same, but your doctor should know that anybody who is taking all the thyroid hormones would have a suppressed TSH. Some doctors believe that thyroid function tests should not be undertaken when people are on any thyroid hormone replacement and that they are of no benefit whatsoever, and I tend to go along with that. If you are taking too much, you quickly get the effects of hyperthyroidism, i.e. palpitations, feeling spaced out, , agitated, sweaty, dizzy and generally feeling pretty awful. When that happens, you stop taking any more thyroid hormone that day and the following day, reduce the dose. If not taking sufficient, you will continue with the symptoms of hypothyroidism which is an indication to increase the dose. Unfortunately doctors are taught that blood tests are the be all and end all of everything and therefore, all they do is to treat the lab tests - and forget about treating the patients symptoms. She should know that those on natural thyroid extract get stronger bones - I know, I have had two bone scans since taking natural thyroid extract and have been told I have the " bones of an elephant " . Luv - Sheila This last year I went off the synthroid and started talking 3 grains of Armour, problem being the Armour had stopped working, and found out Armour had changed their formula. I'm now talking 3 grains of a slow release compounded Armour and starting to feel better. I went and had a blood test with new Doctor and told her about my dose of Armour. She said I was hyperthyroid because of my TSH being so low, and said I can have bone loss because my TSH is so low, and said I need to see a Endo Doc, because If she continued to see me it would be considered Malpractice. Here are my results of blood test, not sure if my dose of armoura is right yet. Any help would be very much appreciated. Heidi TSH 0.004 FT3 3.6 range 2.3-4.2 FT4 0.93 range 0.80-1.80 No virus found in this incoming message. Checked by AVG - www.avg.com Version: 8.5.437 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2924 - Release Date: 06/07/10 18:35:00 Quote
Guest guest Posted June 9, 2010 Report Posted June 9, 2010 Every since I started treatment (from my first test post-medication and whether I am on thyroxine, T3, Armour or ERFA and regardless of the dose) my TSH has always measured <0.01. I have the same conversation with every doctor I see and take my record of blood test results to show them. I don't have any problems once I explain it's not a freak result for me! Quote
Guest guest Posted June 9, 2010 Report Posted June 9, 2010 MODERATED TO REMOVE MOST OR PREVIOUS MESSAGE ALREADY READ. PLEASE DO DELETE MOST OF THE MESSAGE YOU ARE RESPONDING TO AND LEAVE JUST A SMALL PORTION BEFORE CLICKING 'SEND'. LUV - SHEILA _________________________________________ Thank you Shelia so much for your quick Response, & starting this forum. There is so much great information, and caring people here. When I had my blood test, I didn't take my armour in the morning like I normally do, so I thought it was 24hours since I took my last dose. Since it is compounded to be slow release maybe I should wait 2 days instead? I have called 25 Endo doc's in my area including the one my GP is sending me to, and none of them presribe armour. I was hoping my new GP would have been more supportive, but she got mad when I told her my TSH is high because of the cortisone she put me on for 1 week because of a bad whiplash from a car accicdent I was in a few weeks ago, and I started taking Luguls Soution 8 drops a day. I had a hair test and found out my iodine was low along with copper, so I 'm taking these to fix it. Too bad so many Doctors don't know how to read blood test. Can you please tell me what you think of my Free T4 & Free T3. Also have reading of T3 Uptake which is 34.8 Range is 25.0-40.0 Total T3 is 126.3 Range is 40.0-180.0 ng/dL. The good news is my TPO is 92 pretty good considering I started taking Luguls solution a month ago. I was scared to take it because people with hashi's I read can make it flare. Thanks agin Sheila for all your help. Luv - Heidi > > This is a mistake that many, many doctors make Heidi. They believe that > everybody should have a TSH above 1.0, but when you are taking ALL the > thyroid hormones your body requires that are in natural desiccated thyroid, > there is absolutely no requirement for any TSH, so naturally, it would be > suppressed. Your pituitary gland ONLY secretes TSH when it gets a signal > that the level of thyroid hormones in the blood is too low. > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 9, 2010 Report Posted June 9, 2010 I'm having trouble following the logic of " when you are taking ALL the thyroid hormones your body requires that are in natural desiccated thyroid, there is absolutely no requirement for any TSH, so naturally it would be suppressed. " This seems to imply that all thyroid patients treated adequately with hormones will have a suppressed TSH. And thus it also implies that TSH level in serum responds fundamentally differently to externally-dosed vs thyroid-made hormone. Does it? I don't remember that the TSH level operates like an on/off switch, suddenly going to " suppressed " when thyroid hormone level is adequate. This of course is another matter entirely than the question of TSH even being a good measure. Many of us, myself included, believe it is not a good measure for individual patients, though it has come to be used as a treatment monitor. It's like saying that one knows the fuel consumption (better yet, fuel actually correctly burned) of an engine by knowing the position of the accelerator pedal. There are many steps downstream of the accelerator pedal that influence correct fuel burning. Some cars need a deeper accelerator pedal position than others to get the same fuel consumption. Similarly, the serum is not where the action is (the action is mainly at the nucleus of the peripheral cells),and even if serum TSH can be used in a large population to make statistical judgements about hypo/hyperthyroidism incidence, when used to treat individuals, it becomes a case of " medical treatment by the laws of chance " . (My GP took offense when I used that phrase.) As in " Since most healthy people have TSH between x and y, we're counting on the law of averages to get you right. " This is logically and scientifically flawed, and as C, Lowe points out, very much lacking in compassion. It may be OK for the surgeon general, or other groups (BTA, AACE, etc) whose primary purpose is to ignore the individual and get the most number of people better with little effort. > > This is a mistake that many, many doctors make Heidi. They believe that > everybody should have a TSH above 1.0, but when you are taking ALL the > thyroid hormones your body requires that are in natural desiccated thyroid, > there is absolutely no requirement for any TSH, so naturally, it would be > suppressed. Your pituitary gland ONLY secretes TSH when it gets a signal > that the level of thyroid hormones in the blood is too low. > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 9, 2010 Report Posted June 9, 2010 Thanks Nadia,unfortunately my Doctor said she will not treat me if I stay on Armour, because of my TSH being so high. When I tried to explain to her that it was normal for me, she freaked out, and said where did I hear such a thing. I told her the internet & my Naturalist Doctor. She then said the Internet is people who do not know what they are talking about and said she would refer me to a Endo Doc. Very sad Doctors don't seem to care or listen to their patients. > > Every since I started treatment (from my first test post-medication and whether I am on thyroxine, T3, Armour or ERFA and regardless of the dose) my TSH has always measured <0.01. I have the same conversation with every doctor I see and take my record of blood test results to show them. I don't have any problems once I explain it's not a freak result for me! > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 9, 2010 Report Posted June 9, 2010 iodine supplementation often raises tsh levels, sometimes for as long as six months. trish > > Thanks Nadia,unfortunately my Doctor said she will not treat me if I stay on Armour, because of my TSH being so high. W Quote
Guest guest Posted June 9, 2010 Report Posted June 9, 2010 Thank you Trish for the info, too bad my Doctor is not as Smart as you. Heidi > > > > Thanks Nadia,unfortunately my Doctor said she will not treat me if I stay on Armour, because of my TSH being so high. W > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 9, 2010 Report Posted June 9, 2010 Thank you so much for your response, TSH is still confusing to me, when I was on Synthroid my TSH was within the acceptable range, but I felt like crap, all hypo signs back. As soon as I added the Armour I felt good again. I don't understand why the Doctors are so crazy over the TSH levels, you would think if you feel better that should mean something. I now have to go see a Endo Doc, and feeling very depressed about going, because I feel they really do not understand Natural Thyroid. Heidi > > I'm having trouble following the logic of > > " when you are taking ALL the thyroid hormones your body requires that are in natural desiccated thyroid, there is absolutely no requirement for any TSH, so naturally it would be suppressed. " > > This seems to imply that all thyroid patients treated adequately with hormones will have a suppressed TSH. And thus it also implies that TSH level in serum responds fundamentally differently to externally-dosed vs thyroid-made hormone. > > Does it? I don't remember that the TSH level operates like an on/off switch, suddenly going to " suppressed " when thyroid hormone level is adequate. > > This of course is another matter entirely than the question of TSH even being a good measure. Many of us, myself included, believe it is not a good measure for individual patients, though it has come to be used as a treatment monitor. It's like saying that one knows the fuel consumption (better yet, fuel actually correctly burned) of an engine by knowing the position of the accelerator pedal. There are many steps downstream of the accelerator pedal that influence correct fuel burning. Some cars need a deeper accelerator pedal position than others to get the same fuel consumption. Similarly, the serum is not where the action is (the action is mainly at the nucleus of the peripheral cells),and even if serum TSH can be used in a large population to make statistical judgements about hypo/hyperthyroidism incidence, when used to treat individuals, it becomes a case of " medical treatment by the laws of chance " . (My GP took offense when I used that phrase.) As in " Since most healthy people have TSH between x and y, we're counting on the law of averages to get you right. " This is logically and scientifically flawed, and as C, Lowe points out, very much lacking in compassion. It may be OK for the surgeon general, or other groups (BTA, AACE, etc) whose primary purpose is to ignore the individual and get the most number of people better with little effort. > > > > > > > > This is a mistake that many, many doctors make Heidi. They believe that > > everybody should have a TSH above 1.0, but when you are taking ALL the > > thyroid hormones your body requires that are in natural desiccated thyroid, > > there is absolutely no requirement for any TSH, so naturally, it would be > > suppressed. Your pituitary gland ONLY secretes TSH when it gets a signal > > that the level of thyroid hormones in the blood is too low. > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 9, 2010 Report Posted June 9, 2010 Doctors are so crazy over TSH because it's fast, easy, works at least passably for many (some say most) patients, and avoids having to do the much, much more laborious work of listening to and working with the patient. Wham, bam, thank you ma'am; next patient! There's very little time and work involved for the doctor himself if he uses exclusively the blood test. --- In thyroid treatment , " diamondstar9 " I don't understand why the Doctors are so crazy over the TSH levels, you would think if you feel better that should mean something. > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 9, 2010 Report Posted June 9, 2010 Doctors are so crazy over TSH because it's fast, easy, works at least passably for many (some say most) patients, and avoids having to do the much, much more laborious work of listening to and working with the patient. Wham, bam, thank you ma'am; next patient! There's very little time and work involved for the doctor himself if he uses exclusively the blood test. --- In thyroid treatment , " diamondstar9 " I don't understand why the Doctors are so crazy over the TSH levels, you would think if you feel better that should mean something. > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 10, 2010 Report Posted June 10, 2010 Hello Heidi You could be correct in that taking compounded slow release thyroid extract may need to be stopped for two days before a blood test for thyroid function. You may have to be prepared to go outside of your area if you are determined to find an endocrinologist who will recommend and prescribe Armour for you - are you able to do that. You will, by now have received my doctors list, so see if there is somebody there who might be able to help you. I do not see your TSH being high at 0.004 - that is actually very suppressed, your free T3 is fine at 3.6 but your free T4 looks OK at 0.93. Most doctors go by your free T3 result rather than total T3. Dr Peatfield spoke about iodine in his speech at our recent TPA Annual Dinner and Meeting and he said that people do worry about high levels of iodine and that the big worry is the erroneous, but firmly held belief, that iodine CAUSES autoimmune thyroiditis, He stressed strongly that it does not -it actually helps prevent it. He went on to say that there is no evidence for this assertion, but you’ll find doctors believe it all over the place and that you see it everywhere, that iodine mustn’t be used in Hashimoto’s disease. It’s not true! It actually helps! You can listen to this speech once Lee has put our latest Newsletter on to our web site. Luv - Sheila I have called 25 Endo doc's in my area including the one my GP is sending me to, and none of them presribe armour. I was hoping my new GP would have been more supportive, but she got mad when I told her my TSH is high because of the cortisone she put me on for 1 week because of a bad whiplash from a car accicdent I was in a few weeks ago, and I started taking Luguls Soution 8 drops a day. I had a hair test and found out my iodine was low along with copper, so I 'm taking these to fix it. Too bad so many Doctors don't know how to read blood test. Can you please tell me what you think of my Free T4 & Free T3. Also have reading of T3 Uptake which is 34.8 Range is 25.0-40.0 Total T3 is 126.3 Range is 40.0-180.0 ng/dL. The good news is my TPO is 92 pretty good considering I started taking Luguls solution a month ago. I was scared to take it because people with hashi's I read can make it flare. Thanks agin Sheila for all your help. Luv - Heidi > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 10, 2010 Report Posted June 10, 2010 You are not alone, many of us have trouble understanding the logic as thyroid function is a complicated subject - check out the number of NHS endocrinologists who's specialty is diabetes and NOT thyroid. However, I was talking about TSH being suppressed in those subjects taking natural desiccated thyroid extract specifically, and I was not generalising about TSH testing. If doctors tested the TSH of all subjects when they become legally 'adult' to find their individual TSH level when they were well, this would help enormously. Most folk treated adequately with thyroid hormone replacement (i.e. synthetic T4, either alone or in combination with synthetic T3, or T3 alone, will be expected to have a TSH level in the region of 1.0, and for other subjects being treated adequately with natural thyroid extract, the majority are likely to have a suppressed TSH - as many of the members of this forum taking NDT will testify. There are many, many studies showing TSH is NOT a good measure on its own, plus numerous critiques. Also, serum thyroid hormone levels may not reflect the cellular thyroid status. There are a couple of studies that show that in 36-47 % of clinically euthyroid patients receiving adequate long-term thyroid therapy for hypothyroidism, an undetectable serum TSH is found [1,2] and also a study that shows after intake of thyroid hormones, the serum TSH is transitorily depressed within 60 minutes and remains low for up to 9 hours after intake.[3]. There are also studies that show the many, many TSH test kit imperfections and these are never taken into account. However, such studies are ignored. The majority of doctors will test TSH only, even though the BTA and RCP (London) state that thyroid function should be tested using TSH with a measure of T4 ONLY. I agree with you that serum is not where the action is, and many patients are being denied adequate relief from the symptoms of hypothyroidism because less than half of the greater thyroid system is being considered by doctors. It is most definitely not being considered by the authors of BTA, RCP et al latest guidance, even though we have written to them citing references to the medical evidence that has been available for over 40 years. Neither the RCP or BTA have yet responded - and I can guarantee they will not. WHY? Because Big Pharma is paying the piper. The majority of doctors only consider serum TFT's as an aid to reaching a diagnosis or titrating treatment. That is what they have been taught. Another cause to consider is the two completely different definitions of the word 'hypothyroidism' used by the RCP and BTA. The RCP's defines ‘hypothyroidism’ as " the clinical consequences of insufficient secretion by the thyroid gland " - meaning 'hypothyroidism' is ONLY associated with the THYROID GLAND (this is the correct, and narrow definition). However, the BTA defines hypothyroidism as " the clinical consequences of insufficient levels of thyroid hormones in the body " . This ‘broad’ definition is associated with peripheral metabolism and peripheral cellular hormone reception, which produces insufficient thyroid hormones in the body. These definitions are physiologically different. If doctors diagnose 'hypothyroidism' according to the RCP (correct) definition, then they should not be giving the same diagnosis of 'hypothyroidism' to those suffering with peripheral cellular thyroid hormone deficiencies. These folk should be given a diagnosis of either ‘Clinical Euthyroidism’, ‘Type 2 Hypothyroidism’ or ‘Euthyroid Hypometabolism’ and treated accordingly with the active hormone T3. I see the whole subject of diagnosing and managing 'hypothyroidism' as logically and scientifically flawed and I do believe the BTA and RCP are the cause of much unnecessary suffering. If the purpose of the BTA, AACE, etc., primary purpose is to get the most number of people better with little effort, why are they failing so miserably? Sheila 1. lyn JA, Black EG, Betteridge J, Sheppard MC. Comparison of second and third generation methods for measurement of serum thyrotropin in patients with overt hyperthyroidism, patients receiving thyroxine therapy, and those with nonthyroidal illness. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 1994; 78(6): 1368-71 2. Gow SM, Caldwell G, Toft AD, Seth J, Hussey AJ, Sweeting VM, Beckett GJ. Relationship between pituitary and other target organ responsiveness in hypothyroid patients receiving thyroxine replacement. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 1987; 64(2): 364-70 3. Chopra U, Carlson HE, DH. Comparison of inhibitory effects of 3,5,3'-triiodothyronine (T3), thyroxine (T4), 3,3,',5'-triiodothyronine (rT3,), and 3,3'-diiodothyronine (T2) on thyrotropinreleasing hormone-induced release of thyrotropin in the rat in vitro. Endocrinology. 1978;103(2):393-402 I'm having trouble following the logic of " when you are taking ALL the thyroid hormones your body requires that are in natural desiccated thyroid, there is absolutely no requirement for any TSH, so naturally it would be suppressed. " This seems to imply that all thyroid patients treated adequately with hormones will have a suppressed TSH. And thus it also implies that TSH level in serum responds fundamentally differently to externally-dosed vs thyroid-made hormone. Does it? I don't remember that the TSH level operates like an on/off switch, suddenly going to " suppressed " when thyroid hormone level is adequate. Quote
Guest guest Posted June 10, 2010 Report Posted June 10, 2010 Hi Heidi, Sadly your story is common. docs just don't realise that when a patient is taking Armour or any T3 containing med, that TSH will be zero or close to it- mine has been there for 10+ years ,as I need losts of T3 to feel well. TSH is a very bad master- especially when FT3 and FT4 are well within range. If your doc is concerned about your bones ask her to send you for a Dexascan and I'm sure your bones will be fine- it's folk who go hyper 'naturally' who tend to suffer bone loss- the T3 there can rise to spectacular levels- yours is only mid range, and FT4 is mid range too. From those results I would think that you may need a slightly higher dose if you say you are currently symptomatic.> thyroid treatment > From: sunnysaratoga@...> Date: Tue, 8 Jun 2010 16:26:06 +0000> Subject: Malpactice if Doctor treats me!> > Hi Everyone, I'm new to the board, and have been waiting for my blood results before posting. I have had Hashimotos for the last 10 years and when I was first diagnosed they put me on synthroid, and that worked for a few years, then when I felt like it wasn't working a saw a Naturalist Doctor in L.A when I was visiting my mom. He said my hands were ice cold and he didn't need a blood test to tell I needed Armour. So I added 1 grain of Armour to the synthoid I was talking and felt great, only problem was when I had blood test from my regular Doctot my TSH was suppressed to 0.004. The Doctor said I was hyperthyroid and threated to lower my dose. I stopped taking the armour for 1 month and the blood test was fine again, unfortunately I wasn't.> This last year I went off the synthroid and started talking 3 grains of Armour, problem being the Armour had stopped working, and found out Armour had changed their formula. I'm now talking 3 grains of a slow release compounded Armour and starting to feel better. I went and had a blood test with new Doctor and told her about my dose of Armour. She said I was hyperthyroid because of my TSH being so low, and said I can have bone loss because my TSH is so low, and said I need to see a Endo Doc, because If she continued to see me it would be considered Malpractice. Here are my results of blood test, not sure if my dose of armoura is right yet. Any help would be very much appreciated. Heidi TSH 0.004 FT3 3.6 range 2.3-4.2 FT4 0.93 range 0.80-1.80> > > > > ------------------------------------> > TPA is not medically qualified. Consult with a qualified medical practitioner before changing medication.> > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 10, 2010 Report Posted June 10, 2010 Doctors are so crazy over TSH because that is what the BTA, RCP tell them they must do. Failure to follow their recommendations could mean they could be arraigned before the GMC with the risk of losing their career and livelihood. What's a poor doctor supposed to do when the BTA have it writ large on their web site http://www.british-thyroid-association.org/news/Docs/thyroid_statement.pdf that…. " …The Clinical Committee of the Society for Endocrinology and the British Thyroid Association recommend the use of sensitive and specific blood tests as the ONLY method for the precise diagnosis of thyroid dysfunction and for the monitoring of treatment with approved medications. Patients with normal thyroid function tests should not be exposed to inappropriate treatment or medications of unproven value or potentially harmful consequences. " Luv - Sheila Doctors are so crazy over TSH because it's fast, easy, works at least passably for many (some say most) patients, and avoids having to do the much, much more laborious work of listening to and working with the patient. Wham, bam, thank you ma'am; next patient! There's very little time and work involved for the doctor himself if he uses exclusively the blood test. Quote
Guest guest Posted June 10, 2010 Report Posted June 10, 2010 Hi, TSH being high indicates insufficent replacement. low TSH indicated too much replacement- this doesn't make sense. What is your TSH? 0.5 to 5.0 is the UK norm in most places> thyroid treatment > From: fielddot@...> Date: Wed, 9 Jun 2010 19:03:42 +0000> Subject: Re: Malpactice if Doctor treats me!> > iodine supplementation often raises tsh levels, sometimes for as long as six months.> > trish> > > >> > Thanks Nadia,unfortunately my Doctor said she will not treat me if I stay on Armour, because of my TSH being so high. W> > > > ------------------------------------> > TPA is not medically qualified. Consult with a qualified medical practitioner before changing medication.> > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 10, 2010 Report Posted June 10, 2010 Thank you. This is undoubtedly a large factor as well. Not sure of how big this is in the US vs the UK. Another reason is that doctors get much of their continuing " education " from Big Pharma, and thus don't know any better. Ken Holtorf MD (USA) has a webpage " Why doesn't my doctor know all this? " - http://www.hormoneandlongevitycenter.com/doctorsknowledge/ It's a good read. > > Doctors are so crazy over TSH because that is what the BTA, RCP tell them > they must do. Failure to follow their recommendations could mean they could > be arraigned before the GMC with the risk of losing their career and > livelihood. What's a poor doctor supposed to do when the BTA have it writ > large on their web site > http://www.british-thyroid-association.org/news/Docs/thyroid_statement.pdf > that.. > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 10, 2010 Report Posted June 10, 2010 The U.S is very BAD, I called Doctors from the best Stanford Hospital medical clinc, and they told me none of the Doctors in the practice never give out Armour. I was in shock, their supposed to be the best. Thanks for the great link. Heidi > > > > Doctors are so crazy over TSH because that is what the BTA, RCP tell them > > they must do. Failure to follow their recommendations could mean they could > > be arraigned before the GMC with the risk of losing their career and > > livelihood. What's a poor doctor supposed to do when the BTA have it writ > > large on their web site > > http://www.british-thyroid-association.org/news/Docs/thyroid_statement.pdf > > that.. > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 11, 2010 Report Posted June 11, 2010 My TSH is 0.005 I'm in California. The norm here is the same as UK. > > > > > > Thanks Nadia,unfortunately my Doctor said she will not treat me if I stay on Armour, because of my TSH being so high. W > > > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > > > TPA is not medically qualified. Consult with a qualified medical practitioner before changing medication. > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 11, 2010 Report Posted June 11, 2010 Thank you so much for all of the great info, you are an Angel! > > You are not alone, many of us have trouble understanding the logic as > thyroid function is a complicated subject - check out the number of NHS > endocrinologists who's specialty is diabetes and NOT thyroid. REST OF OLD POST DELETED BY MODERATOR. PLEASE DELETE OLD POSTS LEAVING JUST A PORTION OF THE NESSAGE YOU ARE REPLYING TO. OTHERWISE WE MODERATORS WILL SOMETIMES SEND YOUR MESSAGES BACK TO YOU. Quote
Guest guest Posted June 11, 2010 Report Posted June 11, 2010 Your TSH is low not high, so the doctor will consider it suppressed which is why she's threatening to stop the armour. Silly doc doesn't understand that if your bady has all the thyroid hormones it needs then it has no need to produce and thyroid stimulating hormone... > > > My TSH is 0.005 I'm in California. The norm here is the same as UK. > > > > > > > > Thanks Nadia,unfortunately my Doctor said she will not treat me if I stay on Armour, because of my TSH being so high. W > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 11, 2010 Report Posted June 11, 2010 MODERATED TO DELETE PREVIOUSLY MESSAGES ALREADY READ. PLEASE WILL YOU DO THIS BEFORE CLICKING 'SEND' AND LEAVE JUST A PORTION OF WHAT YOU ARE RESPONDING TO. MANY THANKS. SHEILA _______________________________________________________________ Hi , thank you so much for your input,and yes I,m still trying to figure out my correct dose. My temperature is now 97.6 which is better then 97.1 last month. I ordered T3 from the Mexican pharmacy on this website. I hate having to self medicate, but the Doctors here force me too. On the bright side this group is amazing,and I'm grateful for people like you who help. Thanks again. Heidi > Sadly your story is common. docs just don't realise that when a patient is taking Armour or any T3 containing med, that TSH will be zero or close to it- mine has been there for 10+ years ,as I need losts of T3 to feel well. TSH is a very bad master- especially when FT3 and FT4 are well within range. > If your doc is concerned about your bones ask her to send you for a Dexascan and I'm sure your bones will be fine- it's folk who go hyper 'naturally' who tend to suffer bone loss- the T3 there can rise to spectacular levels- yours is only mid range, and FT4 is mid range too. Quote
Guest guest Posted June 11, 2010 Report Posted June 11, 2010 Thanks , you are right I wish the Doctor was. > > Your TSH is low not high, so the doctor will consider it suppressed which is why she's threatening to stop the armour. Silly doc doesn't understand that if your bady has all the thyroid hormones it needs then it has no need to produce and thyroid stimulating hormone... > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 11, 2010 Report Posted June 11, 2010 Are you on any thyroid hormone replacement. If so, are you taking either synthetic T3 or natural thyroid extract - if the answer is yes, then it is to be expected that your TSH would be suppressed. However, it could also mean that you might be taking too much thyroid hormone replacement. Do you have any symptoms of hyPERT? Luv - Sheila My TSH is 0.005 I'm in California. The norm here is the same as UK. Quote
Guest guest Posted June 12, 2010 Report Posted June 12, 2010 Hi sunny, Then you mean your TSH is low- see your original message. Unfortunatlely docs who are not used to using Armour and the other NDT's don't realise that TSH will always be low/ non existant in Armour users as the feedback mechanism of the pituitary is more sensitive to the T3 content than the T4- you would get the same result with taking T3 alone. In this case using Ft4 and Ft3 will give more accurate results, but listening to the patient gives the best results of all. > thyroid treatment > > > My TSH is 0.005 I'm in California. The norm here is the same as UK.> > > > >> > > > Thanks Nadia,unfortunately my Doctor said she will not treat me if I stay on Armour, because of my TSH being so high. W> > > > > > > > > > > > ------------------------------------> > > > > > TPA is not medically qualified. Consult with a qualified medical practitioner before changing medication.> > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 12, 2010 Report Posted June 12, 2010 Hi , it seems it all about trail and error, how do you know how much T3 you need? You said you need lots of T3, how much and are you taking? T4 too or something else. Thanks for all your help . Heidi > > > Hi sunny, > Then you mean your TSH is low- see your original message. Unfortunatlely docs who are not used to using Armour and the other NDT's don't realise that TSH will always be low/ non existant in Armour users as the feedback mechanism of the pituitary is more sensitive to the T3 content than the T4- you would get the same result with taking T3 alone. In this case using Ft4 and Ft3 will give more accurate results, but listening to the patient gives the best results of all. > > [Ed] Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.