Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: Low magnesium - supplementing and still getting muscle spasms...

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

Hi Viola,

I have had problems with leg cramps since I was about 12 and I'm past the half century mark by some years now.

What has worked for me is a delicate balance of calcium (calcium malate works best for me), magnesium (I use magnesium malate, and epsom salt. I did not like magnesium oil as it made me itch.), and Vitamin D. I take large doses of vitamin D3. It has to be D3. I take Carlson 4,000 capsules, 2 capsules, 3 X a day and if I need to, I increase to 3 capsules, 3 times a day. I have food intolerances and leaky gut issues so absorbtion is a problem.

Just an idea, you might want to try some vitamin D. Dr. Tori Hudson, in Portland, OR recommended it to me and it worked! Tressler Healthy Transitions Life Coaching 541-791-1464 Help raise funds for Legacy Land Conservancy by searching the internet or shoping online with GoodSearch (www.goodsearch.com).

Posted

do you take calcium? i was having lots of cramps and i started with the magnesium and added selenium and calcium. i can't believe how much better i feel. and the cramps are pretty much gone. yay... diane, near philly, pa On Oct 1, 2010, at 7:29 PM, Tressler wrote:Hi Viola, I have had problems with leg cramps since I was about 12 and I'm past the half century mark by some years now. What has worked for me is a delicate balance of calcium (calcium malate works best for me), magnesium (I use magnesium malate, and epsom salt. I did not like magnesium oil as it made me itch.), and Vitamin D. I take large doses of vitamin D3. It has to be D3. I take Carlson 4,000 capsules, 2 capsules, 3 X a day and if I need to, I increase to 3 capsules, 3 times a day. I have food intolerances and leaky gut issues so absorbtion is a problem. Just an idea, you might want to try some vitamin D. Dr. Tori Hudson, in Portland, OR recommended it to me and it worked! Tressler Healthy Transitions Life Coaching 541-791-1464 Help raise funds for Legacy Land Conservancy by searching the internet or shoping online with GoodSearch (www.goodsearch.com).

Posted

It looks that is too little calcium. Generally recommended to take half the

amount of magnesium of the calcium you take. For instance: 500mg calcium, then

you take 250mg magnesium.

>

Posted

I used to have leg cramps and sore joints. Now, I haven't tried the malate (I

think), but I did try different ways to raise magnesium. Most resulted in

running to the bathroom and still have aches. A health food store recommended I

try cal/mag 1-1, by starting out with one pill and adding one nightly until my

bowels started getting sloppy. I've been on 2 pills a night for about 3 years.

I still have a bit of soreness sometimes, but it's very minor unless I forget to

take my pills for a few nights ;-)

My doctor recommended glucosomine/chronium (sp) instead. To give it a chance, I

tried it. It helped some, but not near enough. I went back to the way I feel

better. I figure that everyone is different.

Debbie

> What is the best way to

> supplement?  I am taking 12.5 mg of iodoral.  I

> showed deficient in magnesium, so my doctor said I should

> get about 800 mg a day.  I've been using the magnesium

> oil/spray - about 400 mg worth a day and then taking 300 of

> the magnesium glycinate and about 200 calcium citrate. 

> But I am still having some muscle cramping - and I've been

> supplementing like this for about six weeks.  There

> have been a few days I've forgotten, and boy do I pay for

> it!

>

> Should I be supplementing even more since I am taking

> iodoral?

>

> What other forms might be good to take but not too

> expensive?

>

> Thanks!

>

> Viola

>

>

>

> ------------------------------------

>

> All off topic posts should go to the IodineOT group 

> IodineOT/

>

>

> Commonly asked questions:   http://tinyurl.com/yhnds5e

Posted

How are your potassium levels?From: Viola <viola062003@...>Subject: Low magnesium - supplementing and still getting muscle spasms...iodine Date: Friday, 1 October, 2010, 23:54

What is the best way to supplement? I am taking 12.5 mg of iodoral. I showed deficient in magnesium, so my doctor said I should get about 800 mg a day. I've been using the magnesium oil/spray - about 400 mg worth a day and then taking 300 of the magnesium glycinate and about 200 calcium citrate. But I am still having some muscle cramping - and I've been supplementing like this for about six weeks. There have been a few days I've forgotten, and boy do I pay for it!

Should I be supplementing even more since I am taking iodoral?

What other forms might be good to take but not too expensive?

Thanks!

Viola

Posted

magnesium glycinate is the easiest on the gut so ou will not have to run to the wcOn Sat, Oct 2, 2010 at 11:02 AM, david kenna <davidjohnkenna@...> wrote:

 

How are your potassium levels?

From: Viola <viola062003@...>Subject: Low magnesium - supplementing and still getting muscle spasms...

iodine Date: Friday, 1 October, 2010, 23:54

 

What is the best way to supplement? I am taking 12.5 mg of iodoral. I showed deficient in magnesium, so my doctor said I should get about 800 mg a day. I've been using the magnesium oil/spray - about 400 mg worth a day and then taking 300 of the magnesium glycinate and about 200 calcium citrate. But I am still having some muscle cramping - and I've been supplementing like this for about six weeks. There have been a few days I've forgotten, and boy do I pay for it!

Should I be supplementing even more since I am taking iodoral?

What other forms might be good to take but not too expensive?

Thanks!

Viola

Posted

I needed to add that the most important thing is BALANCE. Too much magnesium and

you can end up with bladder stones. Magnesium and calcium have to be in balance

with each other.

>

Posted

Actually it's too much calcium that causes the stones.LinnOn Oct 2, 2010, at 3:38 PM, passerina wrote:

I needed to add that the most important thing is BALANCE. Too much magnesium and you can end up with bladder stones. Magnesium and calcium have to be in balance with each other.

>

Posted

And balanced with zinc also. For years before starting the iodine regimen, both

my wife and I took calcium, magnesium, and zinc. When we took additional

magnesium as part of the iodine protocol (and kept taking the calcium, magnesium

and zinc as before), she noticed white spots appearing in her fingernails which

is a sign of zinc deficiency, and had some occasional leg cramps in the evening

also.

>

> I needed to add that the most important thing is BALANCE. Too much magnesium

and you can end up with bladder stones. Magnesium and calcium have to be in

balance with each other.

> >

>

Posted

Hi,

So what would be the correct amount for calcium and magnesium ratio?

I've been taking twice as much magnesium than calcium.

>

> > I needed to add that the most important thing is BALANCE. Too much magnesium

and you can end up with bladder stones. Magnesium and calcium have to be in

balance with each other.

> > >

> >

> >

>

Posted

,

That is the correct ratio I have been hearing.

Donna in IL

Hi,

So what would be the correct amount for calcium and magnesium ratio?

I've been taking twice as much magnesium than calcium.

>

> > I needed to add that the most important thing is BALANCE. Too much

magnesium and you can end up with bladder stones. Magnesium and calcium have to

be in balance with each other.

> > >

> >

> >

>

Posted

I would ask the same question did. What are your potassium levels? And

are you alreay supplementing with any potassium? I do not see an answer from

the original poster in this question.

I take other minerals but it is ALWAYS potassium that stops the muscle cramps

within a few minutes.

Blessings for cramplessness in your future, from a

>

> From: Viola <viola062003@...>

> Subject: Low magnesium - supplementing and still getting muscle

spasms...

> iodine

> Date: Friday, 1 October, 2010, 23:54

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>  

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

> What is the best way to supplement? I am taking 12.5 mg of iodoral. I

showed deficient in magnesium, so my doctor said I should get about 800 mg a

day. I've been using the magnesium oil/spray - about 400 mg worth a day and

then taking 300 of the magnesium glycinate and about 200 calcium citrate. But I

am still having some muscle cramping - and I've been supplementing like this for

about six weeks. There have been a few days I've forgotten, and boy do I pay

for it!

>

>

>

> Should I be supplementing even more since I am taking iodoral?

>

>

>

> What other forms might be good to take but not too expensive?

>

>

>

> Thanks!

>

>

>

> Viola

>

Posted

I take calcium citrate/malate. Tressler Healthy Transitions Life Coaching 541-791-1464 Help raise funds for Legacy Land Conservancy by searching the internet or shoping online with GoodSearch (www.goodsearch.com).

Posted

I have no idea what my potassium levels are and I do not supplement this. I am

going to look into it. I also am curious what the proper mag to calcium ratio

is. I have been hearing same amount of each, but then I see someone else says

two parts mag to one part calcium.

Viola

> >

> > From: Viola <viola062003@>

> > Subject: Low magnesium - supplementing and still getting muscle

spasms...

> > iodine

> > Date: Friday, 1 October, 2010, 23:54

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >  

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > What is the best way to supplement? I am taking 12.5 mg of iodoral.

I showed deficient in magnesium, so my doctor said I should get about 800 mg a

day. I've been using the magnesium oil/spray - about 400 mg worth a day and

then taking 300 of the magnesium glycinate and about 200 calcium citrate. But I

am still having some muscle cramping - and I've been supplementing like this for

about six weeks. There have been a few days I've forgotten, and boy do I pay

for it!

> >

> >

> >

> > Should I be supplementing even more since I am taking iodoral?

> >

> >

> >

> > What other forms might be good to take but not too expensive?

> >

> >

> >

> > Thanks!

> >

> >

> >

> > Viola

> >

>

Posted

Viola,There are numerous theories on ratio of calcium to magnesium.So individually if our diet is high in dairy then likely we get alot of calcium.But for calcium to work you need D3 and magnesium.Magnesium is very low in most people because the soilis deficient due to farming methods.Tha's why so many people need magnesium and indeedtake magnesium supplements.However knowing what you need and getting it are differentthings,Mostmagnesium tablets while they say 500mg onlygive 4% usuable elemental magnesium which is whatthe body needs.That's why many on this list use spray chloride magnesiumapplied directly to the skin which is very absorbantand delivers a high dose of magnesium.Others

prefer sulfate. see www.mgwater.com forcomments on both and a lot more studies. From: Viola <viola062003@...>Subject: Re: Low magnesium - supplementing and still getting muscle spasms...iodine Date: Sunday, 3 October, 2010, 12:46

I have no idea what my potassium levels are and I do not supplement this. I am going to look into it. I also am curious what the proper mag to calcium ratio is. I have been hearing same amount of each, but then I see someone else says two parts mag to one part calcium.

Viola

> >

> > From: Viola <viola062003@>

> > Subject: Low magnesium - supplementing and still getting muscle spasms...

> > iodine

> > Date: Friday, 1 October, 2010, 23:54

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > Â

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > What is the best way to supplement? I am taking 12.5 mg of iodoral. I showed deficient in magnesium, so my doctor said I should get about 800 mg a day. I've been using the magnesium oil/spray - about 400 mg worth a day and then taking 300 of the magnesium glycinate and about 200 calcium citrate. But I am still having some muscle cramping - and I've been supplementing like this for about six weeks. There have been a few days I've forgotten, and boy do I pay for it!

> >

> >

> >

> > Should I be supplementing even more since I am taking iodoral?

> >

> >

> >

> > What other forms might be good to take but not too expensive?

> >

> >

> >

> > Thanks!

> >

> >

> >

> > Viola

> >

>

Posted

I had the oddest muscle spasm in my eye for over a month and I too take

600-800mg calcium citrate. I was not having twitches, it was a slow pull of the

muscle above my eye and then it would release. It would do that 2-3x in a row

then it would relax for another 20-30 minutes and do it again. I finally put mag

oil on it 2 nights in a row. Funny it didn't sting like it does when I put it on

my arms or legs, but I'd do it anyway even if it did. It was worth getting those

spasms in my eye.

Karin

>

> I take calcium citrate/malate.

>

> Tressler

> Healthy Transitions Life Coaching

> 541-791-1464

>

> Help raise funds for Legacy Land Conservancy by searching the internet or

shoping online with GoodSearch (www.goodsearch.com).

>

Posted

I used to have this also, definitely a sign of magnesium deficiency.LinnOn Oct 3, 2010, at 12:33 PM, Karin wrote:

I had the oddest muscle spasm in my eye for over a month and I too take 600-800mg calcium citrate. I was not having twitches, it was a slow pull of the muscle above my eye and then it would release. It would do that 2-3x in a row then it would relax for another 20-30 minutes and do it again. I finally put mag oil on it 2 nights in a row. Funny it didn't sting like it does when I put it on my arms or legs, but I'd do it anyway even if it did. It was worth getting those spasms in my eye.

Karin

>

> I take calcium citrate/malate.

>

> Tressler

> Healthy Transitions Life Coaching

> 541-791-1464

>

> Help raise funds for Legacy Land Conservancy by searching the internet or shoping online with GoodSearch (www.goodsearch.com).

>

Posted

Yes, I stand corrected. The moment I send my post, I realized my thinking has

done a reversal on me: too much calcium CAN cause bladderstones. And much,

really, depends on your own body chemistry. I take a lot of calcium and no extra

magnesium besides what I get from a multi and a glass of milk a day. And I have

no bladderstones, or cramps and spasms. Go figure...

> > >

> >

> >

>

Posted

Karin,

re: the "slow pull" of your eye, do you happen to have any thryoid issues?

Konstantine

From: Karin <krmaya@...>iodine Sent: Sun, October 3, 2010 10:33:20 AMSubject: Re: Low magnesium - supplementing and still getting muscle spasms...

I had the oddest muscle spasm in my eye for over a month and I too take 600-800mg calcium citrate. I was not having twitches, it was a slow pull of the muscle above my eye and then it would release. It would do that 2-3x in a row then it would relax for another 20-30 minutes and do it again. I finally put mag oil on it 2 nights in a row. Funny it didn't sting like it does when I put it on my arms or legs, but I'd do it anyway even if it did. It was worth getting those spasms in my eye.Karin >> I take calcium citrate/malate.> > Tressler > Healthy Transitions Life Coaching > 541-791-1464 > > Help raise funds for Legacy Land Conservancy by searching the internet or shoping online with GoodSearch

(www.goodsearch.com).>

Posted

i was having horrible cramps every night. i had to be careful not to move my ankle during the night, would send me right into a cramp. i got cramps during the day at school, if i was driving, ( i have a clutch) my leg would cramp during driving, i had cramps in my leg between knee and groin. i was totally fed up. i take the calcium, magnesium, selenium and i take the normal over the counter amount of potassium. (gluconate). with this combination, i am finding my feet are not as stiff at night, the cramps are pretty much gone and i am definitely feeling better. if you are taking any diuretic you probably need postassium. if you are afraid to take potassium, eat some nuts. diane, near philly, pa On Oct 3, 2010, at 7:46 AM, Viola wrote:I have no idea what my potassium levels are and I do not supplement this. I am going to look into it. I also am curious what the proper mag to calcium ratio is. I have been hearing same amount of each, but then I see someone else says two parts mag to one part calcium.Viola> > > > From: Viola <viola062003@>> > Subject: Low magnesium - supplementing and still getting muscle spasms...> > iodine > > Date: Friday, 1 October, 2010, 23:54> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Â > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > What is the best way to supplement? I am taking 12.5 mg of iodoral. I showed deficient in magnesium, so my doctor said I should get about 800 mg a day. I've been using the magnesium oil/spray - about 400 mg worth a day and then taking 300 of the magnesium glycinate and about 200 calcium citrate. But I am still having some muscle cramping - and I've been supplementing like this for about six weeks. There have been a few days I've forgotten, and boy do I pay for it!> > > > > > > > Should I be supplementing even more since I am taking iodoral?> > > > > > > > What other forms might be good to take but not too expensive?> > > > > > > > Thanks!> > > > > > > > Viola> >>

Posted

,

Lol ...just large nodules on my thyroid. It's been almost a year I've been on

iodine. I take 100mgs of Iodoral with companion nutrients. Do you have some

insights?

Karin

> >

> > I take calcium citrate/malate.

> >

> > Tressler

> > Healthy Transitions Life Coaching

> > 541-791-1464

> >

> > Help raise funds for Legacy Land Conservancy by searching the internet or

> >shoping online with GoodSearch (www.goodsearch.com).

> >

>

Posted

have you had any thyroid labs done recently? TSH, FT3 or FT4 and/or TPO or TSI or TRab?

the reason I ask is because I had a pulling type sensation like you describe and I was dx with Graves' Disease 2 mos ago and the year before that, Hashimoto's with 2 nodules and 1 cyst (all benign) and had to go to the opthamologist recently for what they call "mild/moderate" Thyroid Eye Disease due to that pulling feeling. It can come and go, get worse, get better, etc. I heard that when the TSI is active there's more "eye" attack/involvment.

It's really something to keep an eye on, no pun intended.

Konstantine

From: Karin <krmaya@...>iodine Sent: Sun, October 3, 2010 3:25:10 PMSubject: Re: Low magnesium - supplementing and still getting muscle spasms...

,Lol ...just large nodules on my thyroid. It's been almost a year I've been on iodine. I take 100mgs of Iodoral with companion nutrients. Do you have some insights?Karin> >> > I take calcium citrate/malate.> > > > Tressler > > Healthy Transitions Life Coaching > >

541-791-1464 > > > > Help raise funds for Legacy Land Conservancy by searching the internet or > >shoping online with GoodSearch (www.goodsearch.com).> >>

Posted

Diane,You need quite a bit of potassium to get the RDA.Apricots, AvocadosBeets,Brussel sprouts,Cantaloupe Dates, Figs,Kiwi fruit,Lima beansMelons,MilkNectarines Orange juice Oranges Pears (fresh) Peanuts dry roasted, Potatoes, baked, Prune juice Prunes, Raisins Spinach, Tomato products, Winter squash, Yogurt plainand here by food grouphttp://www.vaughns-1-pagers.com/food/potassium-foods.htm I have no idea what my potassium levels are and I do not supplement this. I am going to look into it. I also am curious what the proper mag to calcium ratio is. I have been hearing same amount of each, but then I see someone else says two parts mag to one part calcium.Viola>

> > > From: Viola <viola062003@>> > Subject: Low magnesium - supplementing and still getting muscle spasms...> > iodine > > Date: Friday, 1 October, 2010, 23:54> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Â > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > What is the best way to supplement? I am taking 12.5 mg of iodoral. I showed deficient in magnesium, so my doctor said I should get about 800 mg a day. I've been using the magnesium oil/spray - about 400 mg worth a day and then taking 300 of the magnesium glycinate and about 200 calcium citrate. But I am still having some muscle cramping - and I've been supplementing like this

for about six weeks. There have been a few days I've forgotten, and boy do I pay for it!> > > > > > > > Should I be supplementing even more since I am taking iodoral?> > > > > > > > What other forms might be good to take but not too expensive?> > > > > > > > Thanks!> > > > > > > > Viola> >>

Posted

oh yeah i know. it is amazing doctors don't get it. i have to say i didn't really mention to my doc about the cramps, but when i finally did, after i took care of it myself he did mention the calcium but not the magnesium. i wonder what they are taught at medical school... diane, near philly, pa On Oct 3, 2010, at 7:15 PM, david kenna wrote:Diane,You need quite a bit of potassium to get the RDA.Apricots, AvocadosBeets,Brussel sprouts,Cantaloupe Dates, Figs,Kiwi fruit,Lima beansMelons,MilkNectarines Orange juice Oranges Pears (fresh) Peanuts dry roasted, Potatoes, baked, Prune juice Prunes, Raisins Spinach, Tomato products, Winter squash, Yogurt plainand here by food grouphttp://www.vaughns-1-pagers.com/food/potassium-foods.htm I have no idea what my potassium levels are and I do not supplement this. I am going to look into it. I also am curious what the proper mag to calcium ratio is. I have been hearing same amount of each, but then I see someone else says two parts mag to one part calcium.Viola> > > > From: Viola <viola062003@>> > Subject: Low magnesium - supplementing and still getting muscle spasms...> > iodine > > Date: Friday, 1 October, 2010, 23:54> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Â > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > What is the best way to supplement? I am taking 12.5 mg of iodoral. I showed deficient in magnesium, so my doctor said I should get about 800 mg a day. I've been using the magnesium oil/spray - about 400 mg worth a day and then taking 300 of the magnesium glycinate and about 200 calcium citrate. But I am still having some muscle cramping - and I've been supplementing like this for about six weeks. There have been a few days I've forgotten, and boy do I pay for it!> > > > > > > > Should I be supplementing even more since I am taking iodoral?> > > > > > > > What other forms might be good to take but not too expensive?> > > > > > > > Thanks!> > > > > > > > Viola> >>

Posted

Red Quinoa is another excellent source of potassium: 367mg / 100mg

Also, bananas: 924mg / 100mg

Ziggy

> > > 

> > > From: Viola <viola062003@>

> > > Subject: Low magnesium - supplementing and still getting muscle

spasms...

> > > To: iodine

> > > Date: Friday, 1 October, 2010, 23:54

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > >  

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > What is the best way to supplement? I am taking 12.5 mg of iodoral. I

showed deficient in magnesium, so my doctor said I should get about 800 mg a

day. I've been using the magnesium oil/spray - about 400 mg worth a day and then

taking 300 of the magnesium glycinate and about 200 calcium citrate. But I am

still having some muscle cramping - and I've been supplementing like this for

about six weeks. There have been a few days I've forgotten, and boy do I pay for

it!

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > Should I be supplementing even more since I am taking iodoral?

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > What other forms might be good to take but not too expensive?

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > Thanks!

> > > 

> > > 

> > > 

> > > Viola

> > >

> >

>

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...