Guest guest Posted September 3, 2010 Report Posted September 3, 2010 A friend of mine worked with an iodine doctor with active thyroid cancer and used 200 mgs Iodoral, 5,000 mgs Vit C, 400 mgs Magnesium, 400 mcg Selenium and a few other things. Her cancer was going away within 6 mos but she freaked and did the surgery. I have lost track of her now so I don't know what is going on with her currently. Another friend totally beat it w/o surgery or RAI. She did large amounts of Iodora, and many of the same supplements I have listed although I don't know her exact protocol. I did the surgery and 3 RAI and it all failed and only Iodine and other detox protocols saved my life. So yes there is a possibility of healing naturally. No I would never do RAI ever knowing what I do now. My story is on my website www.naturalthyroidchoices.com Steph Iodine and new diagnosis of cancer Asked doc to prescribe Naturethroid 5 mos ago,after reading Shamon's website. Just after a miscarriage 2 mos. ago, I was diagnosed with papillary thyroid cancer on both nodes(FNA said"suspicious cells" but I have a family history of it.Am supposed to schedule thyroidectomy and RAI. Any iodine protocol for cancer? Do I really have to have that RAI this year?I am in my forties, so the odds of getting pregnant after RAI are zero; I still hope to have ONE more, as I am still more fertile than most women my age. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 3, 2010 Report Posted September 3, 2010 Marcy-- If it were me I would try the aggressive iodine protocol first. My research shows that papillary carcinoma is the least dangerous type of thyroid cr. Further: >Papillary carcinoma grows the slowest of all types of thyroid cancer. Due >to this fact, it can be caught early enough to be treated, so is usually >not fatal. Some people can live for many years without even knowing that >they have this type of cancer. So if it were me, I would feel I had nothing to lose by letting the iodine protocol have some time, particularly since it would allow me to have another child (if that were my goal). In addition, doing the aggressive iodine protocol would prepare you for a pregnancy and the child would be extra healthy as a result. I don't know if you're aware of this, but the body requires iodine for cell apoptosis, the programmed cell death that cr cells overcome and then won't die. Some 90% or more of us are chronically short of iodine, which I think is a huge contributor to the cr epidemic. So you can't hurt yourself with the iodine protocol. And if your body responds and wipes out the cr, you will be stronger than ever, which won't be true with the course of treatment you've been prescribed. Be aware that at the higher doses of iodine you may experience strenuous detoxification symptoms. For someone with your health challenges, ramping up the dose would be more important than avoiding detox symptoms. Just be aware that if you feel " bad " it's the detox, not the iodine. wishing you most well, -- >A friend of mine worked with an iodine doctor with active thyroid cancer >and used 200 mgs Iodoral, 5,000 mgs Vit C, 400 mgs Magnesium, 400 mcg >Selenium and a few other things. Her cancer was going away within 6 mos >but she freaked and did the surgery. I have lost track of her now so I >don't know what is going on with her currently. Another friend totally >beat it w/o surgery or RAI. She did large amounts of Iodora, and many of >the same supplements I have listed although I don't know her exact >protocol. I did the surgery and 3 RAI and it all failed and only Iodine >and other detox protocols saved my life. So yes there is a possibility of >healing naturally. No I would never do RAI ever knowing what I do now. > >My story is on my website ><http://www.naturalthyroidchoices.com>www.naturalthyroidchoices.com > >Steph > > > Iodine and new diagnosis of cancer > > > > >Asked doc to prescribe Naturethroid 5 mos ago,after reading Shamon's >website. Just after a miscarriage 2 mos. ago, I was diagnosed with >papillary thyroid cancer on both nodes(FNA said " suspicious cells " but I >have a family history of it. > >Am supposed to schedule thyroidectomy and RAI. Any iodine protocol for >cancer? Do I really have to have that RAI this year? > >I am in my forties, so the odds of getting pregnant after RAI are zero; I >still hope to have ONE more, as I am still more fertile than most women my age. > > > > > >No virus found in this incoming message. >Checked by AVG - www.avg.com >Version: 9.0.851 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/3111 - Release Date: 09/03/10 >01:34:00 > ~~~ There is no way to peace; peace is the way ~~~~ --A.J. Muste Quote
Guest guest Posted September 5, 2010 Report Posted September 5, 2010 "A friend of mine worked with an iodine doctor with active thyroid cancer and used 200 mgs Iodoral, 5,000 mgs Vit C, 400 mgs Magnesium, 400 mcg Selenium and a few other things. Her cancer was going away within 6 mos but she freaked and did the surgery. I have lost track of her now so I don't know what is going on with her currently. Another friend totally beat it w/o surgery or RAI. She did large amounts of Iodora, and many of the same supplements I have listed although I don't know her exact protocol. I did the surgery and 3 RAI and it all failed and only Iodine and other detox protocols saved my life. So yes there is a possibility of healing naturally. No I would never do RAI ever knowing what I do now.My story is on my website www.naturalthyroidchoices.com Steph" Hi, Steph, I have a swelling of my thyroid, it was called nodule at tone time, then nodular goiter later. It is about 4 cm wide. When I tried Iodoral alone without Armour thyroid, I will get "pain" or tightlness around my thyroid, is this expected? Can I go throguh this without any discomfort? Mei Quote
Guest guest Posted September 6, 2010 Report Posted September 6, 2010 Could someone please direct me to some sources of information about treating thyroid cancer with iodine, vitamin C, Magnesium? I've googled around but only been able to find treatments associated with removing cancer cells by surgery and radioactive iodine. On Fri, Sep 3, 2010 at 12:40 PM, ladybugsandbees <ladybugsandbees@...> wrote: A friend of mine worked with an iodine doctor with active thyroid cancer and used 200 mgs Iodoral, 5,000 mgs Vit C, 400 mgs Magnesium, 400 mcg Selenium and a few other things. Her cancer was going away within 6 mos but she freaked and did the surgery. I have lost track of her now so I don't know what is going on with her currently. Another friend totally beat it w/o surgery or RAI. She did large amounts of Iodora, and many of the same supplements I have listed although I don't know her exact protocol. I did the surgery and 3 RAI and it all failed and only Iodine and other detox protocols saved my life. So yes there is a possibility of healing naturally. No I would never do RAI ever knowing what I do now. My story is on my website www.naturalthyroidchoices.com Steph Iodine and new diagnosis of cancer Asked doc to prescribe Naturethroid 5 mos ago,after reading Shamon's website. Just after a miscarriage 2 mos. ago, I was diagnosed with papillary thyroid cancer on both nodes(FNA said " suspicious cells " but I have a family history of it.Am supposed to schedule thyroidectomy and RAI. Any iodine protocol for cancer? Do I really have to have that RAI this year?I am in my forties, so the odds of getting pregnant after RAI are zero; I still hope to have ONE more, as I am still more fertile than most women my age. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 6, 2010 Report Posted September 6, 2010 You won't find the protocol on the net. It isn't there. I have the general supplementing on my website http://www.naturalthyroidchoices.com/IodineSuppl.html (bottom) but if fighting cancer the iodine amounts would be 100 mgs - 200 mgs and the complementary supplements would be at the upper limits. Iodine and new diagnosis of cancer Asked doc to prescribe Naturethroid 5 mos ago,after reading Shamon's website. Just after a miscarriage 2 mos. ago, I was diagnosed with papillary thyroid cancer on both nodes(FNA said"suspicious cells" but I have a family history of it.Am supposed to schedule thyroidectomy and RAI. Any iodine protocol for cancer? Do I really have to have that RAI this year?I am in my forties, so the odds of getting pregnant after RAI are zero; I still hope to have ONE more, as I am still more fertile than most women my age. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 6, 2010 Report Posted September 6, 2010 Thank you for your response. I went over your website and found this: " Iodine induces apoptosis. Apoptosis is programmed cell death which is how the body removes cells that have damaged DNA as cancer cells do. " Does this mean that Iodine might be able to cure any type of cancer? Could you please elaborate a little bit about how Iodine involves in apoptosis or, if possible, direct me to some website/document/papers/books about iodine and apoptosis? Thanks a lot.HaOn Mon, Sep 6, 2010 at 5:56 AM, ladybugsandbees <ladybugsandbees@...> wrote: You won't find the protocol on the net. It isn't there. I have the general supplementing on my website http://www.naturalthyroidchoices.com/IodineSuppl.html (bottom) but if fighting cancer the iodine amounts would be 100 mgs - 200 mgs and the complementary supplements would be at the upper limits. Iodine and new diagnosis of cancer Asked doc to prescribe Naturethroid 5 mos ago,after reading Shamon's website. Just after a miscarriage 2 mos. ago, I was diagnosed with papillary thyroid cancer on both nodes(FNA said " suspicious cells " but I have a family history of it.Am supposed to schedule thyroidectomy and RAI. Any iodine protocol for cancer? Do I really have to have that RAI this year?I am in my forties, so the odds of getting pregnant after RAI are zero; I still hope to have ONE more, as I am still more fertile than most women my age. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 6, 2010 Report Posted September 6, 2010 There may be something on www.iodine4health.com if you look in the cancer section. I don't have time to dig through all my research looking for it right now. Dr. Brownstein discusses it in his Iodine book as well as Dr. Orlee in Minerals for the genetic code. It is implicated in the P53 process. Iodine and new diagnosis of cancer Asked doc to prescribe Naturethroid 5 mos ago,after reading Shamon's website. Just after a miscarriage 2 mos. ago, I was diagnosed with papillary thyroid cancer on both nodes(FNA said"suspicious cells" but I have a family history of it.Am supposed to schedule thyroidectomy and RAI. Any iodine protocol for cancer? Do I really have to have that RAI this year?I am in my forties, so the odds of getting pregnant after RAI are zero; I still hope to have ONE more, as I am still more fertile than most women my age. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 6, 2010 Report Posted September 6, 2010 Thank you.On Mon, Sep 6, 2010 at 1:10 PM, ladybugsandbees <ladybugsandbees@...> wrote: There may be something on www.iodine4health.com if you look in the cancer section. I don't have time to dig through all my research looking for it right now. Dr. Brownstein discusses it in his Iodine book as well as Dr. Orlee in Minerals for the genetic code. It is implicated in the P53 process. Iodine and new diagnosis of cancer Asked doc to prescribe Naturethroid 5 mos ago,after reading Shamon's website. Just after a miscarriage 2 mos. ago, I was diagnosed with papillary thyroid cancer on both nodes(FNA said " suspicious cells " but I have a family history of it.Am supposed to schedule thyroidectomy and RAI. Any iodine protocol for cancer? Do I really have to have that RAI this year?I am in my forties, so the odds of getting pregnant after RAI are zero; I still hope to have ONE more, as I am still more fertile than most women my age. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 6, 2010 Report Posted September 6, 2010 Dear ,Do you have those two papers by Dr Schlumberger? Defects in iodide metabolism in thyroid cancer and implications for the follow-up and treatment of patients (2007) (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17315034) and Clinical trials for progressive differentiated thyroid cancer: patient selection, study design, and recent advances (2009) (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20001721) I would like to learn more about iodine and thyroid cancer in those two papers but can't find the full texts. If anyone has access to those papers, please share with me. Thanks, HaOn Mon, Sep 6, 2010 at 1:10 PM, ladybugsandbees <ladybugsandbees@...> wrote: There may be something on www.iodine4health.com if you look in the cancer section. I don't have time to dig through all my research looking for it right now. Dr. Brownstein discusses it in his Iodine book as well as Dr. Orlee in Minerals for the genetic code. It is implicated in the P53 process. Iodine and new diagnosis of cancer Asked doc to prescribe Naturethroid 5 mos ago,after reading Shamon's website. Just after a miscarriage 2 mos. ago, I was diagnosed with papillary thyroid cancer on both nodes(FNA said " suspicious cells " but I have a family history of it.Am supposed to schedule thyroidectomy and RAI. Any iodine protocol for cancer? Do I really have to have that RAI this year?I am in my forties, so the odds of getting pregnant after RAI are zero; I still hope to have ONE more, as I am still more fertile than most women my age. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 6, 2010 Report Posted September 6, 2010 I only have the second one (attached). The first I have requested from the medical library. Iodine and new diagnosis of cancer Asked doc to prescribe Naturethroid 5 mos ago,after reading Shamon's website. Just after a miscarriage 2 mos. ago, I was diagnosed with papillary thyroid cancer on both nodes(FNA said"suspicious cells" but I have a family history of it.Am supposed to schedule thyroidectomy and RAI. Any iodine protocol for cancer? Do I really have to have that RAI this year?I am in my forties, so the odds of getting pregnant after RAI are zero; I still hope to have ONE more, as I am still more fertile than most women my age. 1 of 1 File(s) Clinical Trials for Progressive Diff ThyCa.pdf Quote
Guest guest Posted September 6, 2010 Report Posted September 6, 2010 You are welcome. The first one interested me since none of the 3 RAI's I had took up the RAI. Steph Re: Iodine and new diagnosis of cancer Dear , Do you have those two papers by Dr Schlumberger? Defects in iodide metabolism in thyroid cancer and implications for the follow-up and treatment of patients (2007) (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17315034) and Clinical trials for progressive differentiated thyroid cancer: patient selection, study design, and recent advances (2009) (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20001721)I would like to learn more about iodine and thyroid cancer in those two papers but can't find the full texts. If anyone has access to those papers, please share with me. Thanks, Ha Quote
Guest guest Posted September 6, 2010 Report Posted September 6, 2010 Ha-- The answer is, iodine is essential to the body's capacity to throw off the cancer cells that arise, and yes, iodine can help cure any cancer. Because iodine is required for cell apoptosis, the iodine protocol is also a cancer preventative. -- At 03:32 PM 9/6/2010, you wrote: >Thank you. > >On Mon, Sep 6, 2010 at 1:10 PM, ladybugsandbees ><<mailto:ladybugsandbees@...>ladybugsandbees@...> wrote: > > >There may be something on ><http://www.iodine4health.com>www.iodine4health.com if you look in the >cancer section. > >I don't have time to dig through all my research looking for it right >now. Dr. Brownstein discusses it in his Iodine book as well as Dr. Orlee >in Minerals for the genetic code. It is implicated in the P53 process. > > > > > Re: Iodine and new diagnosis of cancer > > > >Thank you for your response. I went over your website and found this: > " Iodine induces apoptosis. Apoptosis is programmed cell death which is >how the body removes cells that have damaged DNA as cancer cells do. " > > >Does this mean that Iodine might be able to cure any type of cancer? > >Could you please elaborate a little bit about how Iodine involves in >apoptosis or, if possible, direct me to some website/document/papers/books >about iodine and apoptosis? >Thanks a lot. > >Ha ~~~ There is no way to peace; peace is the way ~~~~ --A.J. Muste Quote
Guest guest Posted September 6, 2010 Report Posted September 6, 2010 Thanks for your response. I'm now not so sure about the statement that iodine can help with all type of cancer. I came across Vitale's article (attached file) this afternoon, their experiments state that iodine excess induces apoptosis in thyroid cells (both normal and cancer cells) whereas it has no effect on cells of nonthyroid origin. I could have mis-understood the article though since I don't have any background in the field.~HaOn Mon, Sep 6, 2010 at 7:04 PM, Baker <vbaker@...> wrote: Ha-- The answer is, iodine is essential to the body's capacity to throw off the cancer cells that arise, and yes, iodine can help cure any cancer. Because iodine is required for cell apoptosis, the iodine protocol is also a cancer preventative. -- At 03:32 PM 9/6/2010, you wrote: >Thank you. > >On Mon, Sep 6, 2010 at 1:10 PM, ladybugsandbees ><<mailto:ladybugsandbees@...>ladybugsandbees@...> wrote: > > >There may be something on ><http://www.iodine4health.com>www.iodine4health.com if you look in the >cancer section. > >I don't have time to dig through all my research looking for it right >now. Dr. Brownstein discusses it in his Iodine book as well as Dr. Orlee >in Minerals for the genetic code. It is implicated in the P53 process. > > > > > Re: Iodine and new diagnosis of cancer > > > >Thank you for your response. I went over your website and found this: > " Iodine induces apoptosis. Apoptosis is programmed cell death which is >how the body removes cells that have damaged DNA as cancer cells do. " > > >Does this mean that Iodine might be able to cure any type of cancer? > >Could you please elaborate a little bit about how Iodine involves in >apoptosis or, if possible, direct me to some website/document/papers/books >about iodine and apoptosis? >Thanks a lot. > >Ha ~~~ There is no way to peace; peace is the way ~~~~ --A.J. Muste 1 of 1 File(s) Vitale_iodine apoptosis.pdf Quote
Guest guest Posted September 6, 2010 Report Posted September 6, 2010 sounds like that people who have children born with maybe two fingers, or toes are women who had low iodine? wouldn't that be an astounding discovery if the medical community would admit to it... for those that have done iodine, i hear a lot that people gain weight. about how much and does it stop at some point? is it only say right in the beginning. God knows at this point i don't need more weight on me and that is all that keeps me from using the iodine. guess i am a chicken. diane, near philly, pa On Sep 6, 2010, at 10:37 PM, West wrote:Hada,If you google "iodine apoptosis" you will find a lot on this subject, and not restricted to the thyroid. Here's the very first listing I read:Iodine ... induces apoptosis, programmed cell death. This process is essential to growth and development (fingers form in the fetus by apoptosis of the tissue between them) and for destroying cells that represent a threat to the integrity of the organism, like cancer cells and cells infected with viruses. Human lung cancer cells with genes spliced into them that enhance iodine uptake and utilization undergo apoptosis and shrink when given iodine, both when grown in vitro outside the body and implanted in mice. Its anti-cancer function may well prove to be iodine’s most important extrathyroidal benefit.On 9/6/2010 7:26 PM, hada wrote: Thanks for your response. I'm now not so sure about the statement that iodine can help with all type of cancer. I came across Vitale's article (attached file) this afternoon, their experiments state that iodine excess induces apoptosis in thyroid cells (both normal and cancer cells) whereas it has no effect on cells of nonthyroid origin.I could have mis-understood the article though since I don't have any background in the field.~HaOn Mon, Sep 6, 2010 at 7:04 PM, Baker <vbaker@...> wrote: Ha-- The answer is, iodine is essential to the body's capacity to throw off the cancer cells that arise, and yes, iodine can help cure any cancer. Because iodine is required for cell apoptosis, the iodine protocol is also a cancer preventative.--At 03:32 PM 9/6/2010, you wrote:>Thank you.>>On Mon, Sep 6, 2010 at 1:10 PM, ladybugsandbees ><<mailto:ladybugsandbees@...>ladybugsandbees@...> wrote:>>>There may be something on ><http://www.iodine4health.com>www.iodine4health.com if you look in the >cancer section.>>I don't have time to dig through all my research looking for it right >now. Dr. Brownstein discusses it in his Iodine book as well as Dr. Orlee >in Minerals for the genetic code. It is implicated in the P53 process.>>>>> Re: Iodine and new diagnosis of cancer>>>>Thank you for your response. I went over your website and found this:>"Iodine induces apoptosis. Apoptosis is programmed cell death which is >how the body removes cells that have damaged DNA as cancer cells do. ">>>Does this mean that Iodine might be able to cure any type of cancer?>>Could you please elaborate a little bit about how Iodine involves in >apoptosis or, if possible, direct me to some website/document/papers/books >about iodine and apoptosis?>Thanks a lot.>>Ha~~~ There is no way to peace; peace is the way ~~~~--A.J. Muste Quote
Guest guest Posted September 6, 2010 Report Posted September 6, 2010 Hada-- The article you linked was written prior to the year 2000. Its information is OLD. Plus it was done completely in the testtube, and we know, for better or worse, that those kinds of studies often do not reproduce what happens in the context of the whole body. Plus, they can't be saying what you are afraid they are saying because it's simply not true. Others have now quoted other sources that have the truth in them. Iodine is required throughout the body for cell apoptosis. You need to realize that there is a horrific, HUGE amount of iodine-phobic material out there in the world, available through the internet, that still claims, for example, that iodine supplementation causes hypothyroidism. We just had someone post such an article on this list. You can't just find random articles on the net and put together the truth. There are so many papers and websites out there that are lying or misled about iodine that you can't possibly find the truth by trying to read them. Here is a link that is about iodine supplementation and thyroid cancer. It is from the website called www.IodineforHealth.com, which is a super heavy-duty research-oriented information site that is the companion to this discussion group. http://www.iodine4health.com/disease/thyroidisease/thyroidcancer/thyroid_cancer.\ htm If you look along the lefthand side, you'll see a list of 26 scientific articles that are ALL about iodine and thyroid cancer. If you use one of the links in the upper lefthand side, it will take you to the rest of the site which has hundreds of articles written by iodine researchers, people who are medical professionals but who are researching and prescribing iodine because they know the conventional false teaching about iodine are causing grave illness throughout the world. Here is another link to the annotated references on the www.breastcancerchoices.org site, which shows how iodine interacts with cr: http://breastcancerchoices.org/iodineref.html The reason this discussion list must exist is because the information we have here is very rare and hard to find, in general, because of the huge landslide of false information that a person has to wade through. If you feel you can't trust the researchers on the Iodine4Health.com, optimox.com, and breastcancerchoices.org websites, then I'm afraid we can't really help you-- they are our trusted sources. It's kind of an either/or situation-- you either realize that the lies about iodine are killing us all and embrace iodine and get healthy, or you go along with conventional medicine. You're not going to find a conventional cancer research center that recommends iodine. The reason is mainly one of greed. The only treatments that get funded for study are treatments that the pharmaceutical companies can make money off of. They can't patent iodine, so they won't look into it. And they spend a great deal of money creating even more false " evidence " that iodine is bad for people, because they really are that invested in making sure that iodine does not take away their business for patented drugs. I really want to see you well. As someone else said, if you want to try nutritional therapy with iodine, you're going to have to empower yourself to do so and refuse to be swayed by the others in your life who cannot support your choices. To my mind, loving someone is the willingness to at least accept if not support their choices, but a lot of people think that controlling others' choices is the way to show love. There is so much negative information about iodine and about alternatives to Western medicine in general, and even more so about alternatives to Western cancer therapies. You won't be able to convince the naysayers in your life. You can only make a choice and tell them to keep their negativity to themselves. But if you simply cannot make this kind of choice for yourself, well... you wouldn't be the first to come here in hope and then do the surgery and the RAI anyway. I've seen it before. I think it makes all of us sad because we know the power of the iodine protocol. More than that, we know the power of the Western medical-industrial complex and the weight of that power which comes down on someone with a cr diagnosis, making it very difficult to see beyond, much less move beyond. I wish you healing and good health whatever your choice. -- >Hada, > >If you google " iodine apoptosis " you will find a lot on this subject, and >not restricted to the thyroid. Here's the very first listing I read: > >Iodine ... induces apoptosis, programmed cell death. This process is >essential to growth and development (fingers form in the fetus by >apoptosis of the tissue between them) and for destroying cells that >represent a threat to the integrity of the organism, like cancer cells and >cells infected with viruses. Human lung cancer cells with genes spliced >into them that enhance iodine uptake and utilization undergo apoptosis and >shrink when given iodine, both when grown in vitro outside the body and >implanted in mice. Its anti-cancer function may well prove to be iodine's >most important extrathyroidal benefit. > > > > >On 9/6/2010 7:26 PM, hada wrote: >> >> >>Thanks for your response. I'm now not so sure about the >>statement that iodine can help with all type of cancer. >> >>I came across Vitale's article (attached file) this afternoon, their >>experiments state that iodine excess induces apoptosis in thyroid cells >>(both normal and cancer cells) whereas it has no effect on cells of >>nonthyroid origin. >> >>I could have mis-understood the article though since I don't have any >>background in the field. >> >>~Ha >> >>On Mon, Sep 6, 2010 at 7:04 PM, Baker >><<mailto:vbaker@...>vbaker@...> wrote: >> >> >> >>Ha-- The answer is, iodine is essential to the body's capacity to throw off >>the cancer cells that arise, and yes, iodine can help cure any >>cancer. Because iodine is required for cell apoptosis, the iodine protocol >>is also a cancer preventative. >> >>-- >> >> >>At 03:32 PM 9/6/2010, you wrote: >> >> >Thank you. >> > >> >On Mon, Sep 6, 2010 at 1:10 PM, ladybugsandbees >> ><<mailto:ladybugsandbees@...>ladybugsandbees@...> >> wrote: >> > >> > >> >There may be something on >> ><<http://www.iodine4health.com>http://www.iodine4health.com>www.iodine4h >> ealth.com if you look in the >> >cancer section. >> > >> >I don't have time to dig through all my research looking for it right >> >now. Dr. Brownstein discusses it in his Iodine book as well as Dr. Orlee >> >in Minerals for the genetic code. It is implicated in the P53 process. >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > Re: Iodine and new diagnosis of cancer >> > >> > >> > >> >Thank you for your response. I went over your website and found this: >> > " Iodine induces apoptosis. Apoptosis is programmed cell death which is >> >how the body removes cells that have damaged DNA as cancer cells do. " >> > >> > >> >Does this mean that Iodine might be able to cure any type of cancer? >> > >> >Could you please elaborate a little bit about how Iodine involves in >> >apoptosis or, if possible, direct me to some website/document/papers/books >> >about iodine and apoptosis? >> >Thanks a lot. >> > >> >Ha >> >>~~~ There is no way to peace; peace is the way ~~~~ >>--A.J. Muste >> > > > > > >No virus found in this incoming message. >Checked by AVG - www.avg.com >Version: 9.0.851 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/3118 - Release Date: 09/06/10 >13:34:00 ~~~ There is no way to peace; peace is the way ~~~~ --A.J. Muste Quote
Guest guest Posted September 7, 2010 Report Posted September 7, 2010 Dear ,Thank you very much for an informative and encouraging email. I appreciate it. I never said I trusted here not there, I just don't want to blankly jump into any direction but to keep my mind open. I was really glad to learn about the relation between iodine and apoptosis and alternative clinical trials today. Yes iodine4health.com is a very informative website. Among the 26 papers under thyroid cancer directory, I like Dr Schlumberger's work the most because it relates iodine treatment with thyroid cancer more directly than others. That's why I asked about the full text of this paper. I love to know why this way is good or bad other than just hearing don't go that way because it's bad. In other words, I want to know about the scientific proof, i.e. publications, of the problem. I understand that there're a lot of questions that science hasn't been able to answer, yea because there's not much funding in that area or because the questions are too difficult. The alternative approach is from experience of people who have been through the process. I think neither of the two approaches should be underestimated. In my opinion, joining this group is useful even for people who decide to do/already done the surgery and RAI, especially when most doctors are not open to iodine nutrition treatment. Sincerely,Ha On Mon, Sep 6, 2010 at 10:28 PM, Baker <vbaker@...> wrote: Hada-- The article you linked was written prior to the year 2000. Its information is OLD. Plus it was done completely in the testtube, and we know, for better or worse, that those kinds of studies often do not reproduce what happens in the context of the whole body. Plus, they can't be saying what you are afraid they are saying because it's simply not true. Others have now quoted other sources that have the truth in them. Iodine is required throughout the body for cell apoptosis. You need to realize that there is a horrific, HUGE amount of iodine-phobic material out there in the world, available through the internet, that still claims, for example, that iodine supplementation causes hypothyroidism. We just had someone post such an article on this list. You can't just find random articles on the net and put together the truth. There are so many papers and websites out there that are lying or misled about iodine that you can't possibly find the truth by trying to read them. Here is a link that is about iodine supplementation and thyroid cancer. It is from the website called www.IodineforHealth.com, which is a super heavy-duty research-oriented information site that is the companion to this discussion group. http://www.iodine4health.com/disease/thyroidisease/thyroidcancer/thyroid_cancer.htm If you look along the lefthand side, you'll see a list of 26 scientific articles that are ALL about iodine and thyroid cancer. If you use one of the links in the upper lefthand side, it will take you to the rest of the site which has hundreds of articles written by iodine researchers, people who are medical professionals but who are researching and prescribing iodine because they know the conventional false teaching about iodine are causing grave illness throughout the world. Here is another link to the annotated references on the www.breastcancerchoices.org site, which shows how iodine interacts with cr: http://breastcancerchoices.org/iodineref.html The reason this discussion list must exist is because the information we have here is very rare and hard to find, in general, because of the huge landslide of false information that a person has to wade through. If you feel you can't trust the researchers on the Iodine4Health.com, optimox.com, and breastcancerchoices.org websites, then I'm afraid we can't really help you-- they are our trusted sources. It's kind of an either/or situation-- you either realize that the lies about iodine are killing us all and embrace iodine and get healthy, or you go along with conventional medicine. You're not going to find a conventional cancer research center that recommends iodine. The reason is mainly one of greed. The only treatments that get funded for study are treatments that the pharmaceutical companies can make money off of. They can't patent iodine, so they won't look into it. And they spend a great deal of money creating even more false " evidence " that iodine is bad for people, because they really are that invested in making sure that iodine does not take away their business for patented drugs. I really want to see you well. As someone else said, if you want to try nutritional therapy with iodine, you're going to have to empower yourself to do so and refuse to be swayed by the others in your life who cannot support your choices. To my mind, loving someone is the willingness to at least accept if not support their choices, but a lot of people think that controlling others' choices is the way to show love. There is so much negative information about iodine and about alternatives to Western medicine in general, and even more so about alternatives to Western cancer therapies. You won't be able to convince the naysayers in your life. You can only make a choice and tell them to keep their negativity to themselves. But if you simply cannot make this kind of choice for yourself, well... you wouldn't be the first to come here in hope and then do the surgery and the RAI anyway. I've seen it before. I think it makes all of us sad because we know the power of the iodine protocol. More than that, we know the power of the Western medical-industrial complex and the weight of that power which comes down on someone with a cr diagnosis, making it very difficult to see beyond, much less move beyond. I wish you healing and good health whatever your choice. -- >Hada, > >If you google " iodine apoptosis " you will find a lot on this subject, and >not restricted to the thyroid. Here's the very first listing I read: > >Iodine ... induces apoptosis, programmed cell death. This process is >essential to growth and development (fingers form in the fetus by >apoptosis of the tissue between them) and for destroying cells that >represent a threat to the integrity of the organism, like cancer cells and >cells infected with viruses. Human lung cancer cells with genes spliced >into them that enhance iodine uptake and utilization undergo apoptosis and >shrink when given iodine, both when grown in vitro outside the body and >implanted in mice. Its anti-cancer function may well prove to be iodine's >most important extrathyroidal benefit. > > > > >On 9/6/2010 7:26 PM, hada wrote: >> >> >>Thanks for your response. I'm now not so sure about the >>statement that iodine can help with all type of cancer. >> >>I came across Vitale's article (attached file) this afternoon, their >>experiments state that iodine excess induces apoptosis in thyroid cells >>(both normal and cancer cells) whereas it has no effect on cells of >>nonthyroid origin. >> >>I could have mis-understood the article though since I don't have any >>background in the field. >> >>~Ha >> >>On Mon, Sep 6, 2010 at 7:04 PM, Baker >><<mailto:vbaker@...>vbaker@...> wrote: >> >> >> >>Ha-- The answer is, iodine is essential to the body's capacity to throw off >>the cancer cells that arise, and yes, iodine can help cure any >>cancer. Because iodine is required for cell apoptosis, the iodine protocol >>is also a cancer preventative. >> >>-- >> >> >>At 03:32 PM 9/6/2010, you wrote: >> >> >Thank you. >> > >> >On Mon, Sep 6, 2010 at 1:10 PM, ladybugsandbees >> ><<mailto:ladybugsandbees@...>ladybugsandbees@...> >> wrote: >> > >> > >> >There may be something on >> ><<http://www.iodine4health.com>http://www.iodine4health.com>www.iodine4h >> ealth.com if you look in the >> >cancer section. >> > >> >I don't have time to dig through all my research looking for it right >> >now. Dr. Brownstein discusses it in his Iodine book as well as Dr. Orlee >> >in Minerals for the genetic code. It is implicated in the P53 process. >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > Re: Iodine and new diagnosis of cancer >> > >> > >> > >> >Thank you for your response. I went over your website and found this: >> > " Iodine induces apoptosis. Apoptosis is programmed cell death which is >> >how the body removes cells that have damaged DNA as cancer cells do. " >> > >> > >> >Does this mean that Iodine might be able to cure any type of cancer? >> > >> >Could you please elaborate a little bit about how Iodine involves in >> >apoptosis or, if possible, direct me to some website/document/papers/books >> >about iodine and apoptosis? >> >Thanks a lot. >> > >> >Ha >> >>~~~ There is no way to peace; peace is the way ~~~~ >>--A.J. Muste >> > > > > > >No virus found in this incoming message. >Checked by AVG - www.avg.com >Version: 9.0.851 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/3118 - Release Date: 09/06/10 >13:34:00 ~~~ There is no way to peace; peace is the way ~~~~ --A.J. Muste Quote
Guest guest Posted September 7, 2010 Report Posted September 7, 2010 Dear Ha, We're all glad to be of help and wish you well. -- At 02:59 AM 9/7/2010, you wrote: >Dear , > >Thank you very much for an informative and encouraging email. I appreciate >it. > >I never said I trusted here not there, I just don't want to blankly jump >into any direction but to keep my mind open. I was really glad to learn >about the relation between iodine and apoptosis and alternative clinical >trials today. > >Yes <http://iodine4health.com>iodine4health.com is a very informative >website. Among the 26 papers under thyroid cancer directory, I like Dr >Schlumberger's work the most because it relates iodine treatment with >thyroid cancer more directly than others. That's why I asked >about the full text of this paper. > >I love to know why this way is good or bad other than just hearing don't >go that way because it's bad. In other words, I want to know about the >scientific proof, i.e. publications, of the problem. I understand that >there're a lot of questions that science hasn't been able to answer, yea >because there's not much funding in that area or because the questions are >too difficult. The alternative approach is from experience of people who >have been through the process. I think neither of the two approaches >should be underestimated. > >In my opinion, joining this group is useful even for people who decide to >do/already done the surgery and RAI, especially when most doctors are not >open to iodine nutrition treatment. > >Sincerely, >Ha ~~~ There is no way to peace; peace is the way ~~~~ --A.J. Muste Quote
Guest guest Posted September 7, 2010 Report Posted September 7, 2010 Hi Diane, I gained weight (10-15 lbs) in the first 2-3 months of starting on Lugol's, particularly in my breasts and thighs. I'm nearly back to my previous weight, but it's taken some effort (I've recently started running again). My thyroid labs have been a little up and down, so that hasn't made it any easier. From what I understand, there's a couple things going on. First of all, breasts store iodine, so as more iodine is introduced to an iodine deficient body, the breasts swell in attempt to absorb/store more. Secondly, iodine helps to release/chelate toxins. The body reacts by creating more fatty tissue to hide the toxins in as a 'harm reduction/prevention' strategy. Reducing fat tissue will force the body to push the toxins out of the body completely. My estradiol was also up and down, (estrogen/progesterone/thyroid hormones are closely linked) so that certainly didn't help with my weight gain. So, it can be a rollercoaster ride for some people, such as myself, who was / is very toxic, but I see it as a small to price to pay for health. It's only been 6 months for me and I can already see the benefits. Ziggy i hear a lot that people gain weight. about how much > and does it stop at some point? is it only say right in the beginning. > God knows at this point i don't need more weight on me and that is all > that keeps me from using the iodine. guess i am a chicken. > diane, near philly, pa > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 7, 2010 Report Posted September 7, 2010 I never gained weight from iodine, but I have never taken less than 50mg Iodoral either. if you are on a T4 only med you might want to change to dessicated thyroid also. Gracia diane gaul wrote: > > > sounds like that people who have children born with maybe two fingers, > or toes are women who had low iodine? wouldn't that be an astounding > discovery if the medical community would admit to it... for those that > have done iodine, i hear a lot that people gain weight. about how much > and does it stop at some point? is it only say right in the beginning. > God knows at this point i don't need more weight on me and that is all > that keeps me from using the iodine. guess i am a chicken. > > diane, near philly, pa > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > On Sep 6, 2010, at 10:37 PM, West wrote: > >> Hada, >> >> If you google " iodine apoptosis " you will find a lot on this subject, >> and not restricted to the thyroid. Here's the very first listing I read: >> >> Iodine ... induces apoptosis, programmed cell death. This process is >> essential to growth and development (fingers form in the fetus by >> apoptosis of the tissue between them) and for destroying cells that >> represent a threat to the integrity of the organism, like cancer >> cells and cells infected with viruses. Human lung cancer cells with >> genes spliced into them that enhance iodine uptake and utilization >> undergo apoptosis and shrink when given iodine, both when grown in >> vitro outside the body and implanted in mice. Its anti-cancer >> function may well prove to be iodine’s most important extrathyroidal >> benefit. >> >> >> >> >> On 9/6/2010 7:26 PM, hada wrote: >> >>> >>> >>> Thanks for your response. I'm now not so sure about the >>> statement that iodine can help with all type of cancer. >>> >>> >>> I came across Vitale's article (attached file) this afternoon, their >>> experiments state that iodine excess induces apoptosis in thyroid >>> cells (both normal and cancer cells) whereas it has no effect on >>> cells of nonthyroid origin. >>> >>> I could have mis-understood the article though since I don't have >>> any background in the field. >>> >>> ~Ha >>> >>> >>> On Mon, Sep 6, 2010 at 7:04 PM, Baker <vbaker@... >>> <mailto:vbaker@...>> wrote: >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> Ha-- The answer is, iodine is essential to the body's capacity >>> to throw off >>> the cancer cells that arise, and yes, iodine can help cure any >>> cancer. Because iodine is required for cell apoptosis, the >>> iodine protocol >>> is also a cancer preventative. >>> >>> -- >>> >>> >>> >>> At 03:32 PM 9/6/2010, you wrote: >>> >>> >Thank you. >>> > >>> >On Mon, Sep 6, 2010 at 1:10 PM, ladybugsandbees >>> ><<mailto:ladybugsandbees@... >>> <mailto:ladybugsandbees%40sbcglobal.net>>ladybugsandbees@... >>> <mailto:ladybugsandbees%40sbcglobal.net>> wrote: >>> > >>> > >>> >There may be something on >>> ><http://www.iodine4health.com>www.iodine4health.com >>> <http://www.iodine4health.com> if you look in the >>> >cancer section. >>> > >>> >I don't have time to dig through all my research looking for it >>> right >>> >now. Dr. Brownstein discusses it in his Iodine book as well as >>> Dr. Orlee >>> >in Minerals for the genetic code. It is implicated in the P53 >>> process. >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > Re: Iodine and new diagnosis of cancer >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> >Thank you for your response. I went over your website and found >>> this: >>> > " Iodine induces apoptosis. Apoptosis is programmed cell death >>> which is >>> >how the body removes cells that have damaged DNA as cancer cells >>> do. " >>> > >>> > >>> >Does this mean that Iodine might be able to cure any type of cancer? >>> > >>> >Could you please elaborate a little bit about how Iodine >>> involves in >>> >apoptosis or, if possible, direct me to some >>> website/document/papers/books >>> >about iodine and apoptosis? >>> >Thanks a lot. >>> > >>> >Ha >>> >>> ~~~ There is no way to peace; peace is the way ~~~~ >>> --A.J. Muste >>> >>> >> >> > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 8, 2010 Report Posted September 8, 2010 Dear Ha, I thought of a couple of things: 1. It seems to me that the question is, what is your timeframe? If you could try the iodine protocol to see how it goes, you can always do the surgery with or without the RAI later. 2. Why not ask your doctor(s) about your timeframe? This could be approached by simply saying, " I don't feel able to do this right now. How much time can I have to make this decision? " Or whatever, but, it's a legitimate question. wishing you well, -- >Dear , > >Thank you very much for an informative and encouraging email. I appreciate >it. > >I never said I trusted here not there, I just don't want to blankly jump >into any direction but to keep my mind open. I was really glad to learn >about the relation between iodine and apoptosis and alternative clinical >trials today. > >Yes <http://iodine4health.com>iodine4health.com is a very informative >website. Among the 26 papers under thyroid cancer directory, I like Dr >Schlumberger's work the most because it relates iodine treatment with >thyroid cancer more directly than others. That's why I asked >about the full text of this paper. > >I love to know why this way is good or bad other than just hearing don't >go that way because it's bad. In other words, I want to know about the >scientific proof, i.e. publications, of the problem. I understand that >there're a lot of questions that science hasn't been able to answer, yea >because there's not much funding in that area or because the questions are >too difficult. The alternative approach is from experience of people who >have been through the process. I think neither of the two approaches >should be underestimated. > >In my opinion, joining this group is useful even for people who decide to >do/already done the surgery and RAI, especially when most doctors are not >open to iodine nutrition treatment. > >Sincerely, >Ha > > >On Mon, Sep 6, 2010 at 10:28 PM, Baker ><<mailto:vbaker@...>vbaker@...> wrote: > > >Hada-- The article you linked was written prior to the year 2000. Its >information is OLD. Plus it was done completely in the testtube, and we >know, for better or worse, that those kinds of studies often do not >reproduce what happens in the context of the whole body. Plus, they can't >be saying what you are afraid they are saying because it's simply not >true. Others have now quoted other sources that have the truth in >them. Iodine is required throughout the body for cell apoptosis. > >You need to realize that there is a horrific, HUGE amount of iodine-phobic >material out there in the world, available through the internet, that still >claims, for example, that iodine supplementation causes hypothyroidism. We >just had someone post such an article on this list. You can't just find >random articles on the net and put together the truth. There are so many >papers and websites out there that are lying or misled about iodine that >you can't possibly find the truth by trying to read them. > >Here is a link that is about iodine supplementation and thyroid cancer. It >is from the website called ><http://www.IodineforHealth.com>www.IodineforHealth.com, which is a super >heavy-duty research-oriented information site that is the companion to this >discussion group. ><http://www.iodine4health.com/disease/thyroidisease/thyroidcancer/thyroid_cance\ r.htm>http://www.iodine4health.com/disease/thyroidisease/thyroidcancer/thyroid_c\ ancer.htm >If you look along the lefthand side, you'll see a list of 26 scientific >articles that are ALL about iodine and thyroid cancer. If you use one of >the links in the upper lefthand side, it will take you to the rest of the >site which has hundreds of articles written by iodine researchers, people >who are medical professionals but who are researching and prescribing >iodine because they know the conventional false teaching about iodine are >causing grave illness throughout the world. > >Here is another link to the annotated references on the ><http://www.breastcancerchoices.org>www.breastcancerchoices.org site, >which shows how iodine interacts with cr: ><http://breastcancerchoices.org/iodineref.html>http://breastcancerchoices.org/i\ odineref.html > >The reason this discussion list must exist is because the information we >have here is very rare and hard to find, in general, because of the huge >landslide of false information that a person has to wade through. If you >feel you can't trust the researchers on the Iodine4Health.com, ><http://optimox.com>optimox.com, >and <http://breastcancerchoices.org>breastcancerchoices.org websites, then >I'm afraid we can't really help >you-- they are our trusted sources. It's kind of an either/or situation-- >you either realize that the lies about iodine are killing us all and >embrace iodine and get healthy, or you go along with conventional medicine. >You're not going to find a conventional cancer research center that >recommends iodine. The reason is mainly one of greed. The only treatments >that get funded for study are treatments that the pharmaceutical companies >can make money off of. They can't patent iodine, so they won't look into >it. And they spend a great deal of money creating even more false > " evidence " that iodine is bad for people, because they really are that >invested in making sure that iodine does not take away their business for >patented drugs. > >I really want to see you well. As someone else said, if you want to try >nutritional therapy with iodine, you're going to have to empower yourself >to do so and refuse to be swayed by the others in your life who cannot >support your choices. To my mind, loving someone is the willingness to at >least accept if not support their choices, but a lot of people think that >controlling others' choices is the way to show love. There is so much >negative information about iodine and about alternatives to Western >medicine in general, and even more so about alternatives to Western cancer >therapies. You won't be able to convince the naysayers in your life. You >can only make a choice and tell them to keep their negativity to themselves. > >But if you simply cannot make this kind of choice for yourself, well... you >wouldn't be the first to come here in hope and then do the surgery and the >RAI anyway. I've seen it before. I think it makes all of us sad because we >know the power of the iodine protocol. More than that, we know the power >of the Western medical-industrial complex and the weight of that power >which comes down on someone with a cr diagnosis, making it very difficult >to see beyond, much less move beyond. I wish you healing and good health >whatever your choice. > >-- ~~~ There is no way to peace; peace is the way ~~~~ --A.J. Muste Quote
Guest guest Posted September 8, 2010 Report Posted September 8, 2010 Dear ,Thanks for your advice, I'll ask my doctor about the timeframe. Do you know how they can specify that amount of time? It seems that thyroid cancer develops quite slowly. Also, I want to ask how to check whether I make any progress when I do the iodine protocol?My nodule is large, about 4cm. Biopsy states that it has focal microfollicles so they are not sure if it is cancer or not yet. My endocrinologist advised me to remove half of my thyroid to have it checked. Thank you,HaOn Wed, Sep 8, 2010 at 9:43 AM, Baker <vbaker@...> wrote: Dear Ha, I thought of a couple of things: 1. It seems to me that the question is, what is your timeframe? If you could try the iodine protocol to see how it goes, you can always do the surgery with or without the RAI later. 2. Why not ask your doctor(s) about your timeframe? This could be approached by simply saying, " I don't feel able to do this right now. How much time can I have to make this decision? " Or whatever, but, it's a legitimate question. wishing you well, -- >Dear , > >Thank you very much for an informative and encouraging email. I appreciate >it. > >I never said I trusted here not there, I just don't want to blankly jump >into any direction but to keep my mind open. I was really glad to learn >about the relation between iodine and apoptosis and alternative clinical >trials today. > >Yes <http://iodine4health.com>iodine4health.com is a very informative >website. Among the 26 papers under thyroid cancer directory, I like Dr >Schlumberger's work the most because it relates iodine treatment with >thyroid cancer more directly than others. That's why I asked >about the full text of this paper. > >I love to know why this way is good or bad other than just hearing don't >go that way because it's bad. In other words, I want to know about the >scientific proof, i.e. publications, of the problem. I understand that >there're a lot of questions that science hasn't been able to answer, yea >because there's not much funding in that area or because the questions are >too difficult. The alternative approach is from experience of people who >have been through the process. I think neither of the two approaches >should be underestimated. > >In my opinion, joining this group is useful even for people who decide to >do/already done the surgery and RAI, especially when most doctors are not >open to iodine nutrition treatment. > >Sincerely, >Ha > > >On Mon, Sep 6, 2010 at 10:28 PM, Baker ><<mailto:vbaker@...>vbaker@...> wrote: > > >Hada-- The article you linked was written prior to the year 2000. Its >information is OLD. Plus it was done completely in the testtube, and we >know, for better or worse, that those kinds of studies often do not >reproduce what happens in the context of the whole body. Plus, they can't >be saying what you are afraid they are saying because it's simply not >true. Others have now quoted other sources that have the truth in >them. Iodine is required throughout the body for cell apoptosis. > >You need to realize that there is a horrific, HUGE amount of iodine-phobic >material out there in the world, available through the internet, that still >claims, for example, that iodine supplementation causes hypothyroidism. We >just had someone post such an article on this list. You can't just find >random articles on the net and put together the truth. There are so many >papers and websites out there that are lying or misled about iodine that >you can't possibly find the truth by trying to read them. > >Here is a link that is about iodine supplementation and thyroid cancer. It >is from the website called ><http://www.IodineforHealth.com>www.IodineforHealth.com, which is a super >heavy-duty research-oriented information site that is the companion to this >discussion group. ><http://www.iodine4health.com/disease/thyroidisease/thyroidcancer/thyroid_cancer.htm>http://www.iodine4health.com/disease/thyroidisease/thyroidcancer/thyroid_cancer.htm >If you look along the lefthand side, you'll see a list of 26 scientific >articles that are ALL about iodine and thyroid cancer. If you use one of >the links in the upper lefthand side, it will take you to the rest of the >site which has hundreds of articles written by iodine researchers, people >who are medical professionals but who are researching and prescribing >iodine because they know the conventional false teaching about iodine are >causing grave illness throughout the world. > >Here is another link to the annotated references on the ><http://www.breastcancerchoices.org>www.breastcancerchoices.org site, >which shows how iodine interacts with cr: ><http://breastcancerchoices.org/iodineref.html>http://breastcancerchoices.org/iodineref.html > >The reason this discussion list must exist is because the information we >have here is very rare and hard to find, in general, because of the huge >landslide of false information that a person has to wade through. If you >feel you can't trust the researchers on the Iodine4Health.com, ><http://optimox.com>optimox.com, >and <http://breastcancerchoices.org>breastcancerchoices.org websites, then >I'm afraid we can't really help >you-- they are our trusted sources. It's kind of an either/or situation-- >you either realize that the lies about iodine are killing us all and >embrace iodine and get healthy, or you go along with conventional medicine. >You're not going to find a conventional cancer research center that >recommends iodine. The reason is mainly one of greed. The only treatments >that get funded for study are treatments that the pharmaceutical companies >can make money off of. They can't patent iodine, so they won't look into >it. And they spend a great deal of money creating even more false > " evidence " that iodine is bad for people, because they really are that >invested in making sure that iodine does not take away their business for >patented drugs. > >I really want to see you well. As someone else said, if you want to try >nutritional therapy with iodine, you're going to have to empower yourself >to do so and refuse to be swayed by the others in your life who cannot >support your choices. To my mind, loving someone is the willingness to at >least accept if not support their choices, but a lot of people think that >controlling others' choices is the way to show love. There is so much >negative information about iodine and about alternatives to Western >medicine in general, and even more so about alternatives to Western cancer >therapies. You won't be able to convince the naysayers in your life. You >can only make a choice and tell them to keep their negativity to themselves. > >But if you simply cannot make this kind of choice for yourself, well... you >wouldn't be the first to come here in hope and then do the surgery and the >RAI anyway. I've seen it before. I think it makes all of us sad because we >know the power of the iodine protocol. More than that, we know the power >of the Western medical-industrial complex and the weight of that power >which comes down on someone with a cr diagnosis, making it very difficult >to see beyond, much less move beyond. I wish you healing and good health >whatever your choice. > >-- ~~~ There is no way to peace; peace is the way ~~~~ --A.J. Muste Quote
Guest guest Posted September 8, 2010 Report Posted September 8, 2010 Ha, I wouldn’t let doctors remove anything when they don’t know if it is cancerous. They don’t try that with other parts of the body – Hey your eye might have cancer, let’s remove it to check it out. No! If you are making progress, your nodule would show changes and start to shrink. But it may take awhile. But you are right, IF it is cancerous, it took a long time to develop, and you can take time to work on healing. Donna in IL From: iodine [mailto:iodine ] On Behalf Of hada Sent: Wednesday, September 08, 2010 3:48 PM iodine Subject: Re: Iodine and new diagnosis of cancer Dear , Thanks for your advice, I'll ask my doctor about the timeframe. Do you know how they can specify that amount of time? It seems that thyroid cancer develops quite slowly. Also, I want to ask how to check whether I make any progress when I do the iodine protocol? My nodule is large, about 4cm. Biopsy states that it has focal microfollicles so they are not sure if it is cancer or not yet. My endocrinologist advised me to remove half of my thyroid to have it checked. Thank you, Ha On Wed, Sep 8, 2010 at 9:43 AM, Baker <vbaker@...> wrote: Dear Ha, I thought of a couple of things: 1. It seems to me that the question is, what is your timeframe? If you could try the iodine protocol to see how it goes, you can always do the surgery with or without the RAI later. 2. Why not ask your doctor(s) about your timeframe? This could be approached by simply saying, " I don't feel able to do this right now. How much time can I have to make this decision? " Or whatever, but, it's a legitimate question. wishing you well, -- >Dear , > >Thank you very much for an informative and encouraging email. I appreciate >it. > >I never said I trusted here not there, I just don't want to blankly jump >into any direction but to keep my mind open. I was really glad to learn >about the relation between iodine and apoptosis and alternative clinical >trials today. > >Yes <http://iodine4health.com>iodine4health.com is a very informative >website. Among the 26 papers under thyroid cancer directory, I like Dr >Schlumberger's work the most because it relates iodine treatment with >thyroid cancer more directly than others. That's why I asked >about the full text of this paper. > >I love to know why this way is good or bad other than just hearing don't >go that way because it's bad. In other words, I want to know about the >scientific proof, i.e. publications, of the problem. I understand that >there're a lot of questions that science hasn't been able to answer, yea >because there's not much funding in that area or because the questions are >too difficult. The alternative approach is from experience of people who >have been through the process. I think neither of the two approaches >should be underestimated. > >In my opinion, joining this group is useful even for people who decide to >do/already done the surgery and RAI, especially when most doctors are not >open to iodine nutrition treatment. > >Sincerely, >Ha > > >On Mon, Sep 6, 2010 at 10:28 PM, Baker ><<mailto:vbaker@...>vbaker@...> wrote: > > >Hada-- The article you linked was written prior to the year 2000. Its >information is OLD. Plus it was done completely in the testtube, and we >know, for better or worse, that those kinds of studies often do not >reproduce what happens in the context of the whole body. Plus, they can't >be saying what you are afraid they are saying because it's simply not >true. Others have now quoted other sources that have the truth in >them. Iodine is required throughout the body for cell apoptosis. > >You need to realize that there is a horrific, HUGE amount of iodine-phobic >material out there in the world, available through the internet, that still >claims, for example, that iodine supplementation causes hypothyroidism. We >just had someone post such an article on this list. You can't just find >random articles on the net and put together the truth. There are so many >papers and websites out there that are lying or misled about iodine that >you can't possibly find the truth by trying to read them. > >Here is a link that is about iodine supplementation and thyroid cancer. It >is from the website called ><http://www.IodineforHealth.com>www.IodineforHealth.com, which is a super >heavy-duty research-oriented information site that is the companion to this >discussion group. ><http://www.iodine4health.com/disease/thyroidisease/thyroidcancer/thyroid_cancer.htm>http://www.iodine4health.com/disease/thyroidisease/thyroidcancer/thyroid_cancer.htm >If you look along the lefthand side, you'll see a list of 26 scientific >articles that are ALL about iodine and thyroid cancer. If you use one of >the links in the upper lefthand side, it will take you to the rest of the >site which has hundreds of articles written by iodine researchers, people >who are medical professionals but who are researching and prescribing >iodine because they know the conventional false teaching about iodine are >causing grave illness throughout the world. > >Here is another link to the annotated references on the ><http://www.breastcancerchoices.org>www.breastcancerchoices.org site, >which shows how iodine interacts with cr: ><http://breastcancerchoices.org/iodineref.html>http://breastcancerchoices.org/iodineref.html > >The reason this discussion list must exist is because the information we >have here is very rare and hard to find, in general, because of the huge >landslide of false information that a person has to wade through. If you >feel you can't trust the researchers on the Iodine4Health.com, ><http://optimox.com>optimox.com, >and <http://breastcancerchoices.org>breastcancerchoices.org websites, then >I'm afraid we can't really help >you-- they are our trusted sources. It's kind of an either/or situation-- >you either realize that the lies about iodine are killing us all and >embrace iodine and get healthy, or you go along with conventional medicine. >You're not going to find a conventional cancer research center that >recommends iodine. The reason is mainly one of greed. The only treatments >that get funded for study are treatments that the pharmaceutical companies >can make money off of. They can't patent iodine, so they won't look into >it. And they spend a great deal of money creating even more false > " evidence " that iodine is bad for people, because they really are that >invested in making sure that iodine does not take away their business for >patented drugs. > >I really want to see you well. As someone else said, if you want to try >nutritional therapy with iodine, you're going to have to empower yourself >to do so and refuse to be swayed by the others in your life who cannot >support your choices. To my mind, loving someone is the willingness to at >least accept if not support their choices, but a lot of people think that >controlling others' choices is the way to show love. There is so much >negative information about iodine and about alternatives to Western >medicine in general, and even more so about alternatives to Western cancer >therapies. You won't be able to convince the naysayers in your life. You >can only make a choice and tell them to keep their negativity to themselves. > >But if you simply cannot make this kind of choice for yourself, well... you >wouldn't be the first to come here in hope and then do the surgery and the >RAI anyway. I've seen it before. I think it makes all of us sad because we >know the power of the iodine protocol. More than that, we know the power >of the Western medical-industrial complex and the weight of that power >which comes down on someone with a cr diagnosis, making it very difficult >to see beyond, much less move beyond. I wish you healing and good health >whatever your choice. > >-- ~~~ There is no way to peace; peace is the way ~~~~ --A.J. Muste Quote
Guest guest Posted September 8, 2010 Report Posted September 8, 2010 Dear Ha, >Thanks for your advice, I'll ask my doctor about the timeframe. Do you >know how they can specify that amount of time? It seems that thyroid >cancer develops quite slowly. > >Also, I want to ask how to check whether I make any progress when I do the >iodine protocol? Can anyone describe the imaging processes that are done to monitor nodules? I have not had this problem and don't know what is entailed. But Ha, people on this list often report their imaging results because their nodules are shrinking. Yes, it develops quite slowly, especially the type they are saying that it would be if you do have it, that type is the slowest. They can specify a timeframe because they know the size of your nodule and the rest of your context, how slowly these things grow, and therefore a safe interval. Some doctors may not give a fair estimate because they are insulted if a patient doesn't just hop-to. Another good step would be to consult with one of the iodine doctors about your options. They would be able to give you a good sense of what you're looking at, and because of the ease of sharing information now through the internet, many doctors will do consultations even at a distance. -- >My nodule is large, about 4cm. Biopsy states that it has focal >microfollicles so they are not sure if it is cancer or not yet. My >endocrinologist advised me to remove half of my thyroid to have it checked. > >Thank you, >Ha ~~~ There is no way to peace; peace is the way ~~~~ --A.J. Muste Quote
Guest guest Posted September 8, 2010 Report Posted September 8, 2010 there are two major ways of imaging the thyroid. 1) You are given a very low dose of RAI - I-123 on one day and then return the following day and they image the thyroid through detecting the radiation. That will give you hot and cold spots which help them to determine if it is suspicious for cancer. 2) Ultrasound is less often used but can be used for nodules. 3) VERY rare to find this form of testing but thermography can be used as well. Re: Iodine and new diagnosis of cancer Dear Ha,>Thanks for your advice, I'll ask my doctor about the timeframe. Do you >know how they can specify that amount of time? It seems that thyroid >cancer develops quite slowly.>>Also, I want to ask how to check whether I make any progress when I do the >iodine protocol?Can anyone describe the imaging processes that are done to monitor nodules? I have not had this problem and don't know what is entailed. But Ha, people on this list often report their imaging results because their nodules are shrinking.Yes, it develops quite slowly, especially the type they are saying that it would be if you do have it, that type is the slowest. They can specify a timeframe because they know the size of your nodule and the rest of your context, how slowly these things grow, and therefore a safe interval. Some doctors may not give a fair estimate because they are insulted if a patient doesn't just hop-to.Another good step would be to consult with one of the iodine doctors about your options. They would be able to give you a good sense of what you're looking at, and because of the ease of sharing information now through the internet, many doctors will do consultations even at a distance.-->My nodule is large, about 4cm. Biopsy states that it has focal >microfollicles so they are not sure if it is cancer or not yet. My >endocrinologist advised me to remove half of my thyroid to have it checked.>>Thank you,>Ha~~~ There is no way to peace; peace is the way ~~~~--A.J. Muste Quote
Guest guest Posted September 8, 2010 Report Posted September 8, 2010 I sure hope that somebody got better information from imaging than I did! My dentist found a lump on my thyroid, & told me to go to a doctor. I can't remember whether the first test was an MRI or a CAT scan (I know -- big difference, but I don't remember.) They gave me some sort of iodine-based dye, & I remember being totally freaked out about that, because I tend to have bad reactions to just about everything.Then they sent me for an ultrasound. Ultrasound techs aren't supposed to TELL you anything, of course, but she was being coy & kind of signaling without saying so that she thought it was a benign nodule, & that it was stupid for them to have even done the other test. She went on at great length about how when they got their new ultrasound & started practicing on each other, they discovered that just about everybody in the office had benign nodules, & she sure wasn't having HERS removed (wink! wink!)...But when I talked to my doctor again, she said she wanted to do a biopsy, & gave me NO indication that they had learned ANYTHING from the $2,000+ worth of testing they had already done. Essentially, all she could tell me was that I had a lump on my thyroid -- which is what I had told her when I walked in the door! At which point, I drew a line in the sand & said, "No, thank you." Which is one of the things that brought me here... If the tests didn't tell them anything, why did we do them in the first place? And why should I let a doc whittle on me, when they are so cavalier about removing "unnecessary" organs? It just didn't feel right!Which leads me to the question about asking a doctor what time frame you have to experiment. Has anybody here ever known a mainstream doctor who didn't tell people that time was of the essence & there wasn't a moment to lose? Take whatever the doc says with a grain of salt.I just don't trust docs much any more. (I guess my secret is out.) Good luck!AnneOn Sep 8, 2010, at 7:14 PM, ladybugsandbees wrote: there are two major ways of imaging the thyroid. 1) You are given a very low dose of RAI - I-123 on one day and then return the following day and they image the thyroid through detecting the radiation. That will give you hot and cold spots which help them to determine if it is suspicious for cancer. 2) Ultrasound is less often used but can be used for nodules. 3) VERY rare to find this form of testing but thermography can be used as well. Re: Iodine and new diagnosis of cancer Dear Ha,>Thanks for your advice, I'll ask my doctor about the timeframe. Do you >know how they can specify that amount of time? It seems that thyroid >cancer develops quite slowly.>>Also, I want to ask how to check whether I make any progress when I do the >iodine protocol?Can anyone describe the imaging processes that are done to monitor nodules? I have not had this problem and don't know what is entailed. But Ha, people on this list often report their imaging results because their nodules are shrinking.Yes, it develops quite slowly, especially the type they are saying that it would be if you do have it, that type is the slowest. They can specify a timeframe because they know the size of your nodule and the rest of your context, how slowly these things grow, and therefore a safe interval. Some doctors may not give a fair estimate because they are insulted if a patient doesn't just hop-to.Another good step would be to consult with one of the iodine doctors about your options. They would be able to give you a good sense of what you're looking at, and because of the ease of sharing information now through the internet, many doctors will do consultations even at a distance.-->My nodule is large, about 4cm. Biopsy states that it has focal >microfollicles so they are not sure if it is cancer or not yet. My >endocrinologist advised me to remove half of my thyroid to have it checked.>>Thank you,>Ha~~~ There is no way to peace; peace is the way ~~~~--A.J. Muste Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.