Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 Can't remember the exact place where I read it, but ferritin(iron) causes faster proliferation of cancer and tumor cells due to free radical formation or something along those lines. It's been a month or so since I read the articles. Just Google Ferritin and cancer, or iron and cancer, and a whole bunch of info pops up. That's probably why your ND doesn't want you taking iron, if you might possibly have cancerous thyroid cells. Whether taking Iodine(Lugol's or Iodoral) offsets that iron activity I have no idea. I haven't found any answers to that question. Maybe can ask Dr Brownstein about that one. I'd be interested to know the answer too. Bethann " The greatest enemy of knowledge is not ignorance...it is the illusion of knowledge " ~ Hawking wrote: > Hi , > > I am in a similar situation. I have nodules and had an FNA recently > which came back with irregular cells, adenoma. I too will not consider > surgery and even if it eventually turns into papillary cancer, I will > not consider surgery. I have hypo symptoms. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 Yes, too much iron, especially free. But one should have levels checked to make sure one has enough. Low iron affects many things including thyroid. **If one searches Lactoferrin It is quite amazing what it does! Bruce ----- Original Message ----- From: Thank you Bethann. Here is one study which I have found. Thank you for this information as I was going to start taking ferritin again. I will stop for the time being. http://www.ispub.com/journal/the_internet_journal_of_laboratory_medicine/volume_\ 3_number_2_57/article/ferritin_a_multidimensional_bio_marker.html What the report says is - iron serves as a nutrient for cell growth - helps in the formation of new blood vessel and angiogensis and is a crucial step in tumor growth - The immuno-regulatory balance induced by iron may increase growth rate of cancer cells and infectious organisms leading to cancer development. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 Iron deficiency Iron deficiency is shown to significantly reduce T4 to T3 conversion, increase reverse T3 levels, and block the thermogenic (metabolism boosting) properties of thyroid hormone (238-242). Thus, iron deficiency, as indicated by an iron saturation below 25 or a ferritin below 70, will result in diminished intracellular T3 levels. Additionally, T4 should not be considered adequate thyroid replacement if iron deficiency is present (238,239,241,242). http://nahypothyroidism.org/deiodinases/#iron%20deficiency Bruce ----- Original Message ----- From: Thank you Bethann. Here is one study which I have found. Thank you for this information as I was going to start taking ferritin again. I will stop for the time being. http://www.ispub.com/journal/the_internet_journal_of_laboratory_medicine/volume_\ 3_number_2_57/article/ferritin_a_multidimensional_bio_marker.html What the report says is - iron serves as a nutrient for cell growth - helps in the formation of new blood vessel and angiogensis and is a crucial step in tumor growth - The immuno-regulatory balance induced by iron may increase growth rate of cancer cells and infectious organisms leading to cancer development. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 I'd like to know the answer to that myself. If could ask Dr Brownstein, I'd be eternally grateful. I'm sure he's got to know something about the subject. It may be that it's okay if we're taking Iodine, and it may not be. The problem has me scratching my head. I know the iron from dessicated liver is heme iron and it acts differently than regular iron supplements. It also doesn't seem to upset the stomach and cause constipation like other iron supplements. Or at least that's what I've read from people taking it. And it's got vit A and B vits in the form the body needs. I'd still like to hear back on the safety of taking iron when their are nodules, cysts, tumors or cancerous cells involved. I know iron is important for thyroid hormones and cell integrity and all that, but still I would like some clarification if anyone has the info. Bethann " The greatest enemy of knowledge is not ignorance...it is the illusion of knowledge " ~ Hawking Deborah H wrote: > > > So, do you take iron if your ferritin level is like mine: 8? > > Because, I came to this group after a scare of breast cancer. (I also > have thyroid weakness, mercury & lead toxicity.) What I'm hearing is > that more iron increases oxidation which helps tumors grow. > > I'm confused by the results of the study (but appreciate 's cliff > notes!). > > Thanks, > deborah > > > > > > Iron deficiency > > Iron deficiency is shown to significantly reduce T4 to T3 conversion, > > increase reverse T3 levels, and block the thermogenic (metabolism > boosting) > > properties of thyroid hormone (238-242). > > > > Thus, iron deficiency, as indicated by an iron saturation below 25 or a > > ferritin below 70, will result in diminished intracellular T3 levels. > > Additionally, T4 should not be considered adequate thyroid > replacement if > > iron deficiency is present (238,239,241, 242). > > > > http://nahypothyroi dism.org/ deiodinases/ #iron%20deficien cy > <http://nahypothyroidism.org/deiodinases/#iron%20deficiency> > > > > Bruce > > > > ----- Original Message ----- > > From: > > > > > > Thank you Bethann. Here is one study which I have found. Thank you > for this > > information as I was going to start taking ferritin again. I will > stop for > > the time being. > > > > http://www.ispub. com/journal/ the_internet_ journal_of_ laboratory_ > medicine/ volume_3_ number_2_ 57/article/ ferritin_ a_multidimension > al_bio_marker. html > <http://www.ispub.com/journal/the_internet_journal_of_laboratory_medicine/volume\ _3_number_2_57/article/ferritin_a_multidimensional_bio_marker.html> > > > > What the report says is > > > > - iron serves as a nutrient for cell growth > > - helps in the formation of new blood vessel and angiogensis and is a > > crucial step in tumor growth > > - The immuno-regulatory balance induced by iron may increase growth > rate of > > cancer cells and infectious organisms leading to cancer development. > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 Your ferritin should be between 50-60 for thyroid hormones to be effective. Remember you cannot look at numbers in isolation. Yes it is great that there are research articles that isolate specific issues but our bodies are a symphony of nutrients, hormones, enzymes and more. I was fighting cancer while dealing with a low ferritin level and taking iron. I took Biotics Research Fe-Zyme as well as Floradix Iron + Herbs. Re: ND's comments about iodine So, do you take iron if your ferritin level is like mine: 8?Because, I came to this group after a scare of breast cancer. (I also have thyroid weakness, mercury & lead toxicity.) What I'm hearing is that more iron increases oxidation which helps tumors grow.I'm confused by the results of the study (but appreciate 's cliff notes!).Thanks,deborah>> Iron deficiency> Iron deficiency is shown to significantly reduce T4 to T3 conversion, > increase reverse T3 levels, and block the thermogenic (metabolism boosting) > properties of thyroid hormone (238-242).> > Thus, iron deficiency, as indicated by an iron saturation below 25 or a > ferritin below 70, will result in diminished intracellular T3 levels. > Additionally, T4 should not be considered adequate thyroid replacement if > iron deficiency is present (238,239,241,242).> > http://nahypothyroidism.org/deiodinases/#iron%20deficiency> > Bruce> > ----- Original Message ----- > From: > > > Thank you Bethann. Here is one study which I have found. Thank you for this > information as I was going to start taking ferritin again. I will stop for > the time being.> > http://www.ispub.com/journal/the_internet_journal_of_laboratory_medicine/volume_3_number_2_57/article/ferritin_a_multidimensional_bio_marker.html> > What the report says is> > - iron serves as a nutrient for cell growth> - helps in the formation of new blood vessel and angiogensis and is a > crucial step in tumor growth> - The immuno-regulatory balance induced by iron may increase growth rate of > cancer cells and infectious organisms leading to cancer development.> > > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 It is a fascinating protein yes. The below has more, and when one searches around there is some amazing things reported about it. I'm not promoting the below, just showing their research which is rather good, and an example: http://www.aor.ca/html/products.php?id=160 " Lactoferrin's multi-faceted applications make any single mechanism of action challenging for scientists to isolate, but most seem to agree that it begins with lactoferrin's ability to bind to iron. Iron is essential for the growth of pathogenic bacteria and is also a major contributor to the generation of reactive oxygen species. " I have found lactoferrin alone a bit expensive. What I do rather then taking varous amino acids for example, is take a good NON denatured whey protein. At my ND pharmacy lactoferrin is 35.00 and whey is around 50.00. The whey has lactoferring and 18 amino acids as well. Then one gets All the amino acids and lactoferrin for a lower cost..but one has to do a lot of research as few whey products are the best. I know of only a few that are good/best. (3 so far). The non denatured whey also is the best way by far to raise glutathione as well. Example from AOR: IMMUNE-ULTRA is an advanced protein formula designed to support and enhance the immune system. IMMUNE-ULTRA contains 4.82g of lactoferrin per serving. Advanced whey has 400mg lactoferrin/serving. Most good whey has around 3-400mg/serving. I'd go for the immune ultra or equivalent if I had cancer for example. But that being said, as good as this kind of whey is, it isn't the best as one needs " non denatured " . Again, 3 of hundreds on the market are truely nondenatured. There is no such thing as UN denatured as once denatured by processing or heat, it cannot be undenatured. So denatured whey cannot raise glutathione. Notice there is no mention of cysteine nor of raising glutathione on the above site. Because it is denatured by processing, still good, but definitely not ultimate. But for lactoferrin, it is quite amazing in how it sequestures iron, making it unavailable to unwanted " intruders " Bruce ----- Original Message ----- From: Bruce, I found this site on lactoferrin which is fascinating. So, if my ferritin is 26ug/l (range for females 11 - 306 ug/l) and my hematies result is 4.32 tera/l (4.50 - 6.50) I can potentially bring my ferritin levels with lactoferrin without the risk of aggravating my abnormal cells? http://www.worldwidehealth.com/health-article-Lactoferrin-Amazing-Health-Benefit\ s.html This is all fascinating stuff you are sharing with us. A few things click with me as I have suffered from anemia off and on in my life. I had hypochromic anemia when I was young or what they used to call green sickness in the olden days. I was tested for pernicious anemia and also at one point my doctor suggested TB. People usually just shrug anemia off and give you iron tablets and I have never thought (until now) how important it is to treat. I have a conversion problem and slight RT3, and nodules. Perhaps by bring my iron up I can help all of the above. I keep resisting thyroid meds in hope that iodine can help sort my issues. Thank you again Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 He put me on iron when I had active thyroid cancer. His goal was to balance my body systems. I think I asked him about it at one time because I had read an issue with it and there must not have been an issue because I continued to take it. Steph Re: Re: ND's comments about iodine > I'd like to know the answer to that myself. If > could ask Dr Brownstein, I'd be > eternally grateful. I'm sure he's got to know > something about the subject. It may be that it's > okay if we're taking Iodine, and it may not be. > The problem has me scratching my head. I know the > iron from dessicated liver is heme iron and it > acts differently than regular iron supplements. It > also doesn't seem to upset the stomach and cause > constipation like other iron supplements. Or at > least that's what I've read from people taking it. > And it's got vit A and B vits in the form the body > needs. > > I'd still like to hear back on the safety of > taking iron when their are nodules, cysts, tumors > or cancerous cells involved. > > I know iron is important for thyroid hormones and > cell integrity and all that, but still I would > like some clarification if anyone has the info. > > > > Bethann > > " The greatest enemy of knowledge is not > ignorance...it is the illusion of knowledge " > ~ Hawking > > Deborah H wrote: >> >> >> So, do you take iron if your ferritin level is like mine: 8? >> >> Because, I came to this group after a scare of breast cancer. (I also >> have thyroid weakness, mercury & lead toxicity.) What I'm hearing is >> that more iron increases oxidation which helps tumors grow. >> >> I'm confused by the results of the study (but appreciate 's cliff >> notes!). >> >> Thanks, >> deborah >> >> >> > >> > Iron deficiency >> > Iron deficiency is shown to significantly reduce T4 to T3 conversion, >> > increase reverse T3 levels, and block the thermogenic (metabolism >> boosting) >> > properties of thyroid hormone (238-242). >> > >> > Thus, iron deficiency, as indicated by an iron saturation below 25 or >> a >> > ferritin below 70, will result in diminished intracellular T3 levels. >> > Additionally, T4 should not be considered adequate thyroid >> replacement if >> > iron deficiency is present (238,239,241, 242). >> > >> > http://nahypothyroi dism.org/ deiodinases/ #iron%20deficien cy >> <http://nahypothyroidism.org/deiodinases/#iron%20deficiency> >> > >> > Bruce >> > >> > ----- Original Message ----- >> > From: >> > >> > >> > Thank you Bethann. Here is one study which I have found. Thank you >> for this >> > information as I was going to start taking ferritin again. I will >> stop for >> > the time being. >> > >> > http://www.ispub. com/journal/ the_internet_ journal_of_ laboratory_ >> medicine/ volume_3_ number_2_ 57/article/ ferritin_ a_multidimension >> al_bio_marker. html >> <http://www.ispub.com/journal/the_internet_journal_of_laboratory_medicine/volume\ _3_number_2_57/article/ferritin_a_multidimensional_bio_marker.html> >> > >> > What the report says is >> > >> > - iron serves as a nutrient for cell growth >> > - helps in the formation of new blood vessel and angiogensis and is a >> > crucial step in tumor growth >> > - The immuno-regulatory balance induced by iron may increase growth >> rate of >> > cancer cells and infectious organisms leading to cancer development. >> > >> > >> > >> >> > > > ------------------------------------ > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 Thank you For the clarification:) I'm sure he wouldn't have told you to take something bad for your condition:) It makes me feel much better to know the answer to that puzzle:) . You were taking iron while you were taking the Iodine too. So perhaps that's the key. The Iodine is what makes the difference. Bethann " The greatest enemy of knowledge is not ignorance...it is the illusion of knowledge " ~ Hawking ladybugsandbees wrote: > He put me on iron when I had active thyroid cancer. His goal was to balance > my body systems. I think I asked him about it at one time because I had > read an issue with it and there must not have been an issue because I > continued to take it. > > Steph Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 With cancer patients it depends on why one has low ferritin levels. If the tumor(s) have been removed successfully (ferritin levels usually remain low) then it is a matter of getting the body into balance. This can be accomplished with supplements as well as diet (which would be my first choice). While low ferritin levels are a precursor for anemia not everyone with low ferritin levels are anemic. For those cancer patients that are truly anemic (usually active tumor is present also more so in latter stages of cancer), then adding iron is a very bad idea since iron fuels cancer. However, I was stage 3 colon cancer and never had low ferritin levels or anemia. Patients with active cancer become anemic because the cancer is taking up all the iron. Remember that cancer patients have a completely different set of needs (nutritionally & supplements) than those who do not have cancer. It’s best to always search for the root-cause of low ferritin levels, anemia, etc. before supplementing with anything, especially iron. Good information at: http://www.stopthethyroidmadness.com/ferritin/ There are many reasons for low ferritin levels. Two reasons which are fairly common: 1) Women who still have menstrual periods have an increased need for iron on a daily basis, compared to men. These needs can be met by improving the diet so that it contains iron rich foods or by taking iron supplements. 2) If patients have a source of blood loss (intestinal issues, tumor, etc.) other than a menstrual cycle, their iron stores could become depleted. 3) Malabsoprtion issues: Many have low iron stores because they have intestinal issues and/or also low stomach acid. (celiac, chron’s, etc.) Because of the SAD so many people have very real intestinal absorption issues, but yet that is usally the last place that is addressed. This is why it is always very important to focus on healing the intestinal tract when trying to improve one’s health. Otherwise, much of what is taken to heal will not be absorbed effectively. These are not the only reasons for low ferritin levels, keep that in mind. Foods which are good sources of iron include organic free-range meats, cold-water fish, dark leafy green vegetables (greens, escarole, endive, etc.), raisins, dates and nuts. Ferritin levels can be brought up by cooking in iron skillets. Blackstrap unsulphured molasses (organic) is very effective. But again, if one has intestinal issues this must be addressed in order to obtain better iron absorption rates. Foods which help your body absorb the iron present in other foods include citrus fruits and drinks, fresh fruits and fresh lightly cooked vegetables (do not overcook). Foods which make it difficult for your body to absorb iron present in the diet include: tea, coffee, caffeinated drinks, calcium supplements that are not absorbed and antacids. I came across the following about blackstrap molasses a while back and thought the information very good: " Regarding any warnings here (about blackstrap molasses being processed and a “sugar”), I think it's important to remember that iron occurring in natural foods like molasses is balanced by all kinds of other minerals and trace minerals and so has a different effect on the body than a synthesized, inferior source of isolated iron in a pill. All of the minerals work synergistically in the body, buffering and enhancing one another. In natural foods, you find them all together for a reason. We need them all, in order for any one of them to do their best for us. In addition, trace minerals in molasses such as, specifically, chromium, are essential to our body's metabolism of sugar, so consuming molasses is going to have nowhere near the negative effects on your body as consuming sugar *without* the trace minerals that are absolutely essential for its use by the body (as is the case in white, refined sugar). Also, when one has a complaint about 'processed foods', it is because what is good for us, the nutrients, have been stripped away from the so-called 'refined' food left behind. In this case, molasses IS what has been stripped away (leaving the worthless refined white sugar behind), so molasses is of the highest nutrient-density. As a student in an M.S. program of study in Holistic Nutrition, I believe natural sources of minerals like molasses are *infinitely* superior to any synthesized supplements and should be encouraged, never discouraged. Oh, and I like to put a tablespoon or two of blackstrap molasses in heated milk (or nut milk) as a mineral-rich, medicinal alternative to hot chocolate. :-) " Be Well Dr.L Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 Bethann, You may find this interesting. Are you a meat eater? Well take a look at the nutritional stats on this link. Liver is among the highest quality meat and the cheapest you can get. http://www.nutritiondata.com/facts/lamb-veal-and-game-products/4670/2 There are also a lot of other meats there as well but you could almost drop vitamins with the amount a 100g of liver gives its quite staggering Of course not the usual meat. It would have to be organic. > > > So, do you take iron if your ferritin level is like mine: 8?> > Because, I came to this group after a scare of breast cancer. (I also > have thyroid weakness, mercury & lead toxicity.) What I'm hearing is > that more iron increases oxidation which helps tumors grow.> > I'm confused by the results of the study (but appreciate 's cliff > notes!).> > Thanks,> deborah> > > >> > Iron deficiency> > Iron deficiency is shown to significantly reduce T4 to T3 conversion,> > increase reverse T3 levels, and block the thermogenic (metabolism > boosting)> > properties of thyroid hormone (238-242).> >> > Thus, iron deficiency, as indicated by an iron saturation below 25 or a> > ferritin below 70, will result in diminished intracellular T3 levels.> > Additionally, T4 should not be considered adequate thyroid > replacement if> > iron deficiency is present (238,239,241, 242).> >> > http://nahypothyroi dism.org/ deiodinases/ #iron%20deficien cy > <http://nahypothyroidism.org/deiodinases/#iron%20deficiency>> >> > Bruce> >> > ----- Original Message -----> > From: > >> >> > Thank you Bethann. Here is one study which I have found. Thank you > for this> > information as I was going to start taking ferritin again. I will > stop for> > the time being.> >> > http://www.ispub. com/journal/ the_internet_ journal_of_ laboratory_ > medicine/ volume_3_ number_2_ 57/article/ ferritin_ a_multidimension > al_bio_marker. html > <http://www.ispub.com/journal/the_internet_journal_of_laboratory_medicine/volume_3_number_2_57/article/ferritin_a_multidimensional_bio_marker.html>> >> > What the report says is> >> > - iron serves as a nutrient for cell growth> > - helps in the formation of new blood vessel and angiogensis and is a> > crucial step in tumor growth> > - The immuno-regulatory balance induced by iron may increase growth > rate of> > cancer cells and infectious organisms leading to cancer development.> >> > > >> > ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 Bruce take a look at this link to 100g of lambs liver. The amount of vitamins and minerals probably in a bioavailable form. Its not short of amazing. I'd look for organic. It also points to inconsistences in the control of vits and minerals. Should we be eating meat with this many vits and minerals in? Certain would make a nonsense of the RDA and the Codex rubbish. They can't have it both ways. From: Bruce P <bruce@...>Subject: Re: Re: ND's comments about iodineiodine Date: Sunday, 14 February, 2010, 19:58 It is a fascinating protein yes. The below has more, and when one searches around there is some amazing things reported about it.I'm not promoting the below, just showing their research which is rather good, and an example:http://www.aor. ca/html/products .php?id=160"Lactoferrin' s multi-faceted applications make any single mechanism of action challenging for scientists to isolate, but most seem to agree that it begins with lactoferrin' s ability to bind to iron. Iron is essential for the growth of pathogenic bacteria and is also a major contributor to the generation of reactive oxygen species."I have found lactoferrin alone a bit expensive. What I do rather then taking varous amino acids for example, is take a good NON denatured whey protein.At my ND pharmacy lactoferrin is 35.00 and whey is around 50.00.. The whey has lactoferring and 18 amino acids as well.Then one gets All the amino acids and lactoferrin for a lower cost..but one has to do a lot of research as few whey products are the best.I know of only a few that are good/best. (3 so far).The non denatured whey also is the best way by far to raise glutathione as well.Example from AOR:IMMUNE-ULTRA is an advanced protein formula designed to support and enhance the immune system. IMMUNE-ULTRA contains 4.82g of lactoferrin per serving.Advanced whey has 400mg lactoferrin/ serving. Most good whey has around 3-400mg/serving.I'd go for the immune ultra or equivalent if I had cancer for example. But that being said, as good as this kind of whey is, it isn't the best as one needs "non denatured". Again, 3 of hundreds on the market are truely nondenatured. There is no such thing as UN denatured as once denatured by processing or heat, it cannot be undenatured. So denatured whey cannot raise glutathione.Notice there is no mention of cysteine nor of raising glutathione on the above site. Because it is denatured by processing, still good, but definitely not ultimate.But for lactoferrin, it is quite amazing in how it sequestures iron, making it unavailable to unwanted "intruders"Bruce----- Original Message ----- From: Bruce, I found this site on lactoferrin which is fascinating. So, if my ferritin is 26ug/l (range for females 11 - 306 ug/l) and my hematies result is 4.32 tera/l (4.50 - 6.50) I can potentially bring my ferritin levels with lactoferrin without the risk of aggravating my abnormal cells?http://www.worldwid ehealth.com/ health-article- Lactoferrin- Amazing-Health- Benefits. htmlThis is all fascinating stuff you are sharing with us. A few things click with me as I have suffered from anemia off and on in my life. I had hypochromic anemia when I was young or what they used to call green sickness in the olden days. I was tested for pernicious anemia and also at one point my doctor suggested TB.People usually just shrug anemia off and give you iron tablets and I have never thought (until now) how important it is to treat. I have a conversion problem and slight RT3, and nodules. Perhaps by bring my iron up I can help all of the above. I keep resisting thyroid meds in hope that iodine can help sort my issues.Thank you again Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 Steph, Look at the amount of heme iron in 100g ( a small amount)n of lamb's liver. and the rest of the nutrients. It would almost make me throw out my vitamins and minerals. http://www.nutritiondata.com/facts/lamb-veal-and-game-products/4670/2 From: ladybugsandbees <ladybugsandbees@...>Subject: Re: Re: ND's comments about iodineiodine Date: Sunday, 14 February, 2010, 20:05 He put me on iron when I had active thyroid cancer. His goal was to balance my body systems. I think I asked him about it at one time because I had read an issue with it and there must not have been an issue because I continued to take it.Steph Re: Re: ND's comments about iodine> I'd like to know the answer to that myself. If> could ask Dr Brownstein, I'd be> eternally grateful. I'm sure he's got to know> something about the subject. It may be that it's> okay if we're taking Iodine, and it may not be.> The problem has me scratching my head. I know the> iron from dessicated liver is heme iron and it> acts differently than regular iron supplements. It> also doesn't seem to upset the stomach and cause> constipation like other iron supplements. Or at> least that's what I've read from people taking it.> And it's got vit A and B vits in the form the body> needs.>> I'd still like to hear back on the safety of> taking iron when their are nodules, cysts, tumors> or cancerous cells involved.>> I know iron is important for thyroid hormones and> cell integrity and all that, but still I would> like some clarification if anyone has the info.>>>> Bethann>> "The greatest enemy of knowledge is not> ignorance...it is the illusion of knowledge"> ~ Hawking>> Deborah H wrote:>>>>>> So, do you take iron if your ferritin level is like mine: 8?>>>> Because, I came to this group after a scare of breast cancer. (I also>> have thyroid weakness, mercury & lead toxicity.) What I'm hearing is>> that more iron increases oxidation which helps tumors grow.>>>> I'm confused by the results of the study (but appreciate 's cliff>> notes!).>>>> Thanks,>> deborah>>>> >> >>> > Iron deficiency>> > Iron deficiency is shown to significantly reduce T4 to T3 conversion,>> > increase reverse T3 levels, and block the thermogenic (metabolism>> boosting)>> > properties of thyroid hormone (238-242).>> >>> > Thus, iron deficiency, as indicated by an iron saturation below 25 or >> a>> > ferritin below 70, will result in diminished intracellular T3 levels.>> > Additionally, T4 should not be considered adequate thyroid>> replacement if>> > iron deficiency is present (238,239,241, 242).>> >>> > http://nahypothyroi dism.org/ deiodinases/ #iron%20deficien cy>> <http://nahypothyroidism.org/deiodinases/#iron%20deficiency>>> >>> > Bruce>> >>> > ----- Original Message ----->> > From: >> >>> >>> > Thank you Bethann. Here is one study which I have found. Thank you>> for this>> > information as I was going to start taking ferritin again. I will>> stop for>> > the time being.>> >>> > http://www.ispub. com/journal/ the_internet_ journal_of_ laboratory_>> medicine/ volume_3_ number_2_ 57/article/ ferritin_ a_multidimension>> al_bio_marker. html>> <http://www.ispub.com/journal/the_internet_journal_of_laboratory_medicine/volume_3_number_2_57/article/ferritin_a_multidimensional_bio_marker.html>>> >>> > What the report says is>> >>> > - iron serves as a nutrient for cell growth>> > - helps in the formation of new blood vessel and angiogensis and is a>> > crucial step in tumor growth>> > - The immuno-regulatory balance induced by iron may increase growth>> rate of>> > cancer cells and infectious organisms leading to cancer development.>> >>> > >> >>>>>>>> ------------------------------------>>>>> Links>>>------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 That used to be what old fashioned doctors recommended for " low blood " , anemia, and other things. They recommended the patient eat liver two or three times a week:) I like liver lightly pan fried with onions. A little milk added to the pan can reduce the very strong flavor and increase tenderness. I'd never heard of that before until I got to know a Cuban American. He cooked liver for me one time, and it was very good cooked that way:) I hated liver when I was a kid. But I've read that taste buds actually change every seven years or so. Thank you for the link, Bethann " The greatest enemy of knowledge is not ignorance...it is the illusion of knowledge " ~ Hawking david kenna wrote > Bethann, > You may find this interesting. Are you a meat eater? > Well take a look at the nutritional stats on this link. > Liver is among the highest quality meat and the cheapest > you can get. > http://www.nutritio ndata.com/ facts/lamb- veal-and- game-products/ > 4670/2 > <http://www.nutritiondata.com/facts/lamb-veal-and-game-products/4670/2> > There are also a lot of other meats there as well but > you could almost drop vitamins with the amount a > 100g of liver gives its quite staggering > Of course not the usual meat. It would have to be organic. > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 I don't eat liver. Blah!! It makes me gag. I supplement with a liver pill. Steph Re: Re: ND's comments about iodine> I'd like to know the answer to that myself. If> could ask Dr Brownstein, I'd be> eternally grateful. I'm sure he's got to know> something about the subject. It may be that it's> okay if we're taking Iodine, and it may not be.> The problem has me scratching my head. I know the> iron from dessicated liver is heme iron and it> acts differently than regular iron supplements. It> also doesn't seem to upset the stomach and cause> constipation like other iron supplements. Or at> least that's what I've read from people taking it.> And it's got vit A and B vits in the form the body> needs.>> I'd still like to hear back on the safety of> taking iron when their are nodules, cysts, tumors> or cancerous cells involved.>> I know iron is important for thyroid hormones and> cell integrity and all that, but still I would> like some clarification if anyone has the info.>>>> Bethann>> "The greatest enemy of knowledge is not> ignorance...it is the illusion of knowledge"> ~ Hawking>> Deborah H wrote:>>>>>> So, do you take iron if your ferritin level is like mine: 8?>>>> Because, I came to this group after a scare of breast cancer. (I also>> have thyroid weakness, mercury & lead toxicity.) What I'm hearing is>> that more iron increases oxidation which helps tumors grow.>>>> I'm confused by the results of the study (but appreciate 's cliff>> notes!).>>>> Thanks,>> deborah>>>> >> >>> > Iron deficiency>> > Iron deficiency is shown to significantly reduce T4 to T3 conversion,>> > increase reverse T3 levels, and block the thermogenic (metabolism>> boosting)>> > properties of thyroid hormone (238-242).>> >>> > Thus, iron deficiency, as indicated by an iron saturation below 25 or >> a>> > ferritin below 70, will result in diminished intracellular T3 levels.>> > Additionally, T4 should not be considered adequate thyroid>> replacement if>> > iron deficiency is present (238,239,241, 242).>> >>> > http://nahypothyroi dism.org/ deiodinases/ #iron%20deficien cy>> <http://nahypothyroidism.org/deiodinases/#iron%20deficiency>>> >>> > Bruce>> >>> > ----- Original Message ----->> > From: >> >>> >>> > Thank you Bethann. Here is one study which I have found. Thank you>> for this>> > information as I was going to start taking ferritin again. I will>> stop for>> > the time being.>> >>> > http://www.ispub. com/journal/ the_internet_ journal_of_ laboratory_>> medicine/ volume_3_ number_2_ 57/article/ ferritin_ a_multidimension>> al_bio_marker. html>> <http://www.ispub.com/journal/the_internet_journal_of_laboratory_medicine/volume_3_number_2_57/article/ferritin_a_multidimensional_bio_marker.html>>> >>> > What the report says is>> >>> > - iron serves as a nutrient for cell growth>> > - helps in the formation of new blood vessel and angiogensis and is a>> > crucial step in tumor growth>> > - The immuno-regulatory balance induced by iron may increase growth>> rate of>> > cancer cells and infectious organisms leading to cancer development.>> >>> > >> >>>>>>>> ------------------------------------>>>>> Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 The Gerson Therapy used calf's liver as part of its therapy. (raw liver made into juice along with carrots...I drank it for a couple of years while on the therapy 20 years ago)..and calf liver is very high in iron. (they stopped using it in the nineties due to difficulty finding healthy calf livers). Re: Re: ND's comments about iodine> I'd like to know the answer to that myself. If> could ask Dr Brownstein, I'd be> eternally grateful. I'm sure he's got to know> something about the subject. It may be that it's> okay if we're taking Iodine, and it may not be.> The problem has me scratching my head. I know the> iron from dessicated liver is heme iron and it> acts differently than regular iron supplements. It> also doesn't seem to upset the stomach and cause> constipation like other iron supplements. Or at> least that's what I've read from people taking it.> And it's got vit A and B vits in the form the body> needs.>> I'd still like to hear back on the safety of> taking iron when their are nodules, cysts, tumors> or cancerous cells involved.>> I know iron is important for thyroid hormones and> cell integrity and all that, but still I would> like some clarification if anyone has the info.>>>> Bethann>> "The greatest enemy of knowledge is not> ignorance...it is the illusion of knowledge"> ~ Hawking>> Deborah H wrote:>>>>>> So, do you take iron if your ferritin level is like mine: 8?>>>> Because, I came to this group after a scare of breast cancer. (I also>> have thyroid weakness, mercury & lead toxicity.) What I'm hearing is>> that more iron increases oxidation which helps tumors grow.>>>> I'm confused by the results of the study (but appreciate 's cliff>> notes!).>>>> Thanks,>> deborah>>>> >> >>> > Iron deficiency>> > Iron deficiency is shown to significantly reduce T4 to T3 conversion,>> > increase reverse T3 levels, and block the thermogenic (metabolism>> boosting)>> > properties of thyroid hormone (238-242).>> >>> > Thus, iron deficiency, as indicated by an iron saturation below 25 or >> a>> > ferritin below 70, will result in diminished intracellular T3 levels.>> > Additionally, T4 should not be considered adequate thyroid>> replacement if>> > iron deficiency is present (238,239,241, 242).>> >>> > http://nahypothyroi dism.org/ deiodinases/ #iron%20deficien cy>> <http://nahypothyroidism.org/deiodinases/#iron%20deficiency>>> >>> > Bruce>> >>> > ----- Original Message ----->> > From: >> >>> >>> > Thank you Bethann. Here is one study which I have found. Thank you>> for this>> > information as I was going to start taking ferritin again. I will>> stop for>> > the time being.>> >>> > http://www.ispub. com/journal/ the_internet_ journal_of_ laboratory_>> medicine/ volume_3_ number_2_ 57/article/ ferritin_ a_multidimension>> al_bio_marker. html>> <http://www.ispub.com/journal/the_internet_journal_of_laboratory_medicine/volume_3_number_2_57/article/ferritin_a_multidimensional_bio_marker.html>>> >>> > What the report says is>> >>> > - iron serves as a nutrient for cell growth>> > - helps in the formation of new blood vessel and angiogensis and is a>> > crucial step in tumor growth>> > - The immuno-regulatory balance induced by iron may increase growth>> rate of>> > cancer cells and infectious organisms leading to cancer development.>> >>> > >> >>>>>>>> ------------------------------------>>>>> Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 Bethann, Did you notice on the top left you can alter the size of portion. 100g is the usual size mentioned for most food items. But what a wealth of nutrients and notice very difficult to get iron, zinc,selenium which is likely as bio available as you are likely to get. Did you notice the values way exceeded the governments Recommended Daily Allowance. Should we then stop eating meat? Similar for the codex which the people putting forward that nonsense are trying to save us from vitamins and minerals with such high values. Well what about meat the values go way off the scale. If one ate 6 ozs wow. Did you also notice Omega 3 and 6 and the ratio. and 100g contains 25 g of protein. One caveat it would need to be balanced with greens to bring down the inflammtory effect. And it would need to be organic. You are right but people who know and eat burgers and never actually cook are unlikely to know the value of liver. From: YardBirdMail <yardbirdmail@...>Subject: Re: Re: ND's comments about iodineiodine Date: Sunday, 14 February, 2010, 23:51 That used to be what old fashioned doctors recommended for "low blood", anemia, and other things. They recommended the patient eat liver two or three times a week:) I like liver lightly pan fried with onions. A little milk added to the pan can reduce the very strong flavor and increase tenderness. I'd never heard of that before until I got to know a Cuban American. He cooked liver for me one time, and it was very good cooked that way:) I hated liver when I was a kid. But I've read that taste buds actually change every seven years or so. Thank you for the link, :)Bethann"The greatest enemy of knowledge is not ignorance...it is the illusion of knowledge" ~ Hawkingdavid kenna wrote> Bethann,> You may find this interesting. Are you a meat eater?> Well take a look at the nutritional stats on this link.> Liver is among the highest quality meat and the cheapest> you can get.> http://www.nutritio ndata.com/ facts/lamb- veal-and- game-products/ > 4670/2 > <http://www.nutritiondata.com/facts/lamb-veal-and-game-products/4670/2>> There are also a lot of other meats there as well but> you could almost drop vitamins with the amount a> 100g of liver gives its quite staggering> Of course not the usual meat. It would have to be organic.> ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 yes it would need to be organic. Not stuffed with growth hormones and antibiotics, >>>>>> So, do you take iron if your ferritin level is like mine: 8?>>>> Because, I came to this group after a scare of breast cancer. (I also>> have thyroid weakness, mercury & lead toxicity.) What I'm hearing is>> that more iron increases oxidation which helps tumors grow.>>>> I'm confused by the results of the study (but appreciate 's cliff>> notes!).>>>> Thanks,>> deborah>>>> >> >>> > Iron deficiency>> > Iron deficiency is shown to significantly reduce T4 to T3 conversion,>> > increase reverse T3 levels, and block the thermogenic (metabolism>> boosting)>> > properties of thyroid hormone (238-242).>> >>> > Thus, iron deficiency, as indicated by an iron saturation below 25 or >> a>> > ferritin below 70, will result in diminished intracellular T3 levels.>> > Additionally, T4 should not be considered adequate thyroid>> replacement if>> > iron deficiency is present (238,239,241, 242).>> >>> > http://nahypothyroi dism.org/ deiodinases/ #iron%20deficien cy>> <http://nahypothyroi dism.org/ deiodinases/ #iron%20deficien cy>>> >>> > Bruce>> >>> > ----- Original Message ----->> > From: >> >>> >>> > Thank you Bethann. Here is one study which I have found. Thank you>> for this>> > information as I was going to start taking ferritin again. I will>> stop for>> > the time being.>> >>> > http://www.ispub. com/journal/ the_internet_ journal_of_ laboratory_>> medicine/ volume_3_ number_2_ 57/article/ ferritin_ a_multidimension>> al_bio_marker. html>> <http://www.ispub. com/journal/ the_internet_ journal_of_ laboratory_ medicine/ volume_3_ number_2_ 57/article/ ferritin_ a_multidimension al_bio_marker. html>>> >>> > What the report says is>> >>> > - iron serves as a nutrient for cell growth>> > - helps in the formation of new blood vessel and angiogensis and is a>> > crucial step in tumor growth>> > - The immuno-regulatory balance induced by iron may increase growth>> rate of>> > cancer cells and infectious organisms leading to cancer development.>> >>> > >> >>>>>>>> ------------ --------- --------- ------>>>>> Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 Hello Bruce, In research that I did way back int he 80's I found that iron deficiency was a direct result of high acidity int he body from environmental toxins or stress...and the buffering the body worked better to bring up iron and blood than iron supplements. Safer too. To your good health! Linsey McLean Biochemist Vita Royal Prod Inc vitaroyal.com On Feb 14, 2010, at 11:18 AM, Bruce P wrote: > Iron deficiency > Iron deficiency is shown to significantly reduce T4 to T3 conversion, > increase reverse T3 levels, and block the thermogenic (metabolism boosting) > properties of thyroid hormone (238-242). > > Thus, iron deficiency, as indicated by an iron saturation below 25 or a > ferritin below 70, will result in diminished intracellular T3 levels. > Additionally, T4 should not be considered adequate thyroid replacement if > iron deficiency is present (238,239,241,242). > > http://nahypothyroidism.org/deiodinases/#iron%20deficiency > > Bruce > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 Organic....grass fed and not grass fed makes an enormous difference. Feeding grain and soya is bad enough, feed now is much worse than just grains. I get grass fed only-no grain, isn't " certified " oraganic but when I asked how they fertilized the fields, the cattle gaze it and fertilize, and theyadd no chemical ferts. Below is a comparison- nutrition wise of grass fed/ not grass fed; http://www.eatwild.com/healthbenefits.htm Bruce ----- Original Message ----- From: david kenna yes it would need to be organic. Not stuffed with growth hormones and antibiotics, Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 Heh, I learned to use raw liver in a smoothie... YMMV Chuck Polygon: A missing parrot. On 2/14/2010 7:18:24 PM, ladybugsandbees (ladybugsandbees@...) wrote: >I don't eat liver. Blah!! It makes me gag. I supplement with a liver pill. > >Steph > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 Ferritin is a good form of iron to take. I think it is also important to take the support metals. From: Bruce P <bruce@...>Subject: Re: Re: ND's comments about iodineiodine Date: Sunday, February 14, 2010, 12:14 PM Yes, too much iron, especially free.But one should have levels checked to make sure one has enough. Low iron affects many things including thyroid.**If one searches Lactoferrin It is quite amazing what it does!Bruce----- Original Message ----- From: Thank you Bethann. Here is one study which I have found. Thank you for this information as I was going to start taking ferritin again. I will stop for the time being.http://www.ispub. com/journal/ the_internet_ journal_of_ laboratory_ medicine/ volume_3_ number_2_ 57/article/ ferritin_ a_multidimension al_bio_marker. htmlWhat the report says is- iron serves as a nutrient for cell growth- helps in the formation of new blood vessel and angiogensis and is a crucial step in tumor growth- The immuno-regulatory balance induced by iron may increase growth rate of cancer cells and infectious organisms leading to cancer development. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 Check out that article I sent. It is good and addresses the issues we have on suppleements for hyp or hyperthydroid issues. Jag From: <cindychurch@...>Subject: Re: ND's comments about iodineiodine Date: Sunday, February 14, 2010, 6:11 AM Hi ,I am in a similar situation. I have nodules and had an FNA recently which came back with irregular cells, adenoma. I too will not consider surgery and even if it eventually turns into papillary cancer, I will not consider surgery. I have hypo symptoms.You should have the blood tests to determine whether you have Hashi's. If you don't have Hashi's then what could be creating the hypo/hyper situation are your nodules. Sometimes your nodules which are cyst like, can secrete extra thyroid hormone which induces hyper symptoms.I don't understand why your ND has told you not to take ferritin. When you are low in one nutrient then it just puts pressure and overworks different areas of your body ie your adrenals for one.Do you have a goiter?I think iodine can be like jet fuel for most people. It sure has made me feel better and has reduced my goiter and given me a sense of wellbeing. It is still working on my nodules which have not grown in size now for a year. IMO you should be on the iodine protocol just for the simple reason of reversing the irregular cells and potentially getting ride of you nodules. I would start to take all the supplements and then introduce iodine slowly. For some people iodine can make you feel hyper for the first week and slightly aggressive but as you body gets used to it, you start to feel energized and normal again. Your thyroid also might swell initially as it is trying to capture the iodine in your body but eventually that settles down too. Iodine hardens your thyroid (they use it in surgery to make it easier to operate) so makes you feel less like you have something caught in your throat all the time. (can happen when you have nodules and a goiter). Some people have been able to get rid of their nodules in 4-6 months on iodine and some like myself are still trying (1 year) and believe it will eventually happen.Hope this helps>> > > > > Hi I have new labs but have no iodine testing yet. I feel both both hypo and hyper at various times and am learning about iodine.> > My ND is not sure how to proceed as I have been diagnosed through FNA as suspicious for thyroid cancer, have a lesion on my thyroid (engulfed right lobe and many small nodes in left) that is getting larger. I thought I was hypo, but now, these results make me hyper according to my ND.> > The ND says if I take iodine it will act like "jet fuel" in me and make things worse. He also didn't want me to start raising my ferritin. Any support or ideas on these results are welcome. > > I am thinking now it is Hashi's based on reading about it on STTM, but I don't really know. The ND says he is not sure what do because my free T3 is so high, however, on the Natural Thyroid list, it was suggested that people actually want to achieve these numbers. My ENT has recommended removal of the right lobe but I don't want this until there is a definitive cancer diagnosis -- not just suspicious.> > I don't take any thyroid medication yet. > > I have more results, but I think these are the main ones and I am waiting for saliva tests from ZRT for Adrenal function:> > > TSH is 0.200, range (0.200 - 4.000)> Free T4 1.10, range (0.84-1.51)> T3 total 110, range (60-181)> Free T3 575, range (230 - 420)> Reverse T3 34, range (11-32)> Ferritin 35, range (10-291)> ALT/SGPT 9L (10-35) -- what is this?> > My vit d was at 12 is a range of 32 - 100 and I'm taking 10 000 IU a day now per the ND. > > He also asked me to take BioDim and methylcobalamin but had a terrible response to it -- headaches, impatient, nasal discharge, heart racing. I also found out it is soy based and I am allergic to soy. > > Your input is welcome. Thank you so much.> > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 15, 2010 Report Posted February 15, 2010 Important point. From: Bruce P <bruce@...>Subject: Re: Re: ND's comments about iodineiodine Date: Monday, 15 February, 2010, 2:19 Organic....grass fed and not grass fed makes an enormous difference.Feeding grain and soya is bad enough, feed now is much worse than just grains.I get grass fed only-no grain, isn't "certified" oraganic but when I asked how they fertilized the fields, the cattle gaze it and fertilize,and theyadd no chemical ferts.Below is a comparison- nutrition wise of grass fed/ not grass fed;http://www.eatwild. com/healthbenefi ts.htmBruce----- Original Message ----- From: david kennayes it would need to be organic. Not stuffed with growth hormones and antibiotics, Quote
Guest guest Posted February 15, 2010 Report Posted February 15, 2010 Jag, Did you notice howmuch iron(heme) i is in lambs liver? 8.3 mg that is 46 % of the daily dose? and that is for 100g portion. From: Bruce P <brucebkdesign (DOT) ca>Subject: Re: Re: ND's comments about iodineiodinegroups (DOT) comDate: Sunday, February 14, 2010, 12:14 PM Yes, too much iron, especially free.But one should have levels checked to make sure one has enough. Low iron affects many things including thyroid.**If one searches Lactoferrin It is quite amazing what it does!Bruce----- Original Message ----- From: Thank you Bethann. Here is one study which I have found. Thank you for this information as I was going to start taking ferritin again. I will stop for the time being.http://www.ispub. com/journal/ the_internet_ journal_of_ laboratory_ medicine/ volume_3_ number_2_ 57/article/ ferritin_ a_multidimension al_bio_marker. htmlWhat the report says is- iron serves as a nutrient for cell growth- helps in the formation of new blood vessel and angiogensis and is a crucial step in tumor growth- The immuno-regulatory balance induced by iron may increase growth rate of cancer cells and infectious organisms leading to cancer development. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 15, 2010 Report Posted February 15, 2010 WOW I can eat almost anything but don't think I can drink a raw liver smoothie. I'll take my liver fried with onions. Gracia cking001@... wrote: > > Heh, > I learned to use raw liver in a smoothie... > YMMV > > Chuck > Polygon: A missing parrot. > > On 2/14/2010 7:18:24 PM, ladybugsandbees > (ladybugsandbees@... > <mailto:ladybugsandbees%40sbcglobal.net>) wrote: > >I don't eat liver. Blah!! It makes me gag. I supplement with a liver > pill. > > > >Steph > > > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.