Guest guest Posted December 21, 2010 Report Posted December 21, 2010 Hello all, new member here. I've heard about iodine supplementation for a couple of years and finally got around to getting some. I bought atomic iodine from purebulk.com. Now I've been researching a bit and I'm beginning to understand the differences re: Lugol's, Iodoral, SSKI etc. I did just read some conflicting info - one site says nascent iodine is different from atomic iodine, another says it's the same. It seems that most people in this group are doing Lugols or Iodoral? I realize that the therapuetic dose of nascent/atomic iodine is much lower, yet some people say it is more bioavailable... Any opinions from personal experience about this? I did a quick search of the group archives and found only a few recent references to the nascent form. Anyways, in my excitement to try it out right away, I opened the bottle and put a few drops under my tongue (not too bright, I know). It burned a bit... soon after I blew my nose and it was quite bloody (very unusual for me). I also had a very acidy stomach. Other than that I felt good - it does seem to give me more energy. In any case, I'd be interested to know people's opinions about nascent and/or atomic iodine, vs. the others... Thanks! ~ Quote
Guest guest Posted December 21, 2010 Report Posted December 21, 2010 Nascent and Atomic do not have very much iodine in them-- so to get the milligram doses we recommend, it is very costly. Lugol's was invented in the early 1800s and has been in use continuously since then. Iodoral is a tablet form of Lugol's. The claimed differences in Atomic or Nascent iodine are more a marketing scheme than a real difference-- they are banking on the old and debunked medical myths about iodine (that it is dangerous) and claiming that while other iodines (that is, Lugol's) are dangerous, theirs is safe. But the thing is, Lugol's is totally safe already. There is nothing dangerous about a few drops of those, but there is nothing dangerous about a few drops of Lugol's. Some people do get a stomach upset with Lugol's, especially at larger doses, and that is why Iodoral is a convenient form to use-- the tablets are coated and they dissolve deep in the gut to avoid any stomach issues. I don't know what to say about the noseblowing thing. -- At 10:27 AM 12/21/2010, you wrote: >Hello all, new member here. > >I've heard about iodine supplementation for a couple of years and finally >got around to getting some. I bought atomic iodine from purebulk.com. Now >I've been researching a bit and I'm beginning to understand the >differences re: Lugol's, Iodoral, SSKI etc. I did just read some >conflicting info - one site says nascent iodine is different from atomic >iodine, another says it's the same. > >It seems that most people in this group are doing Lugols or Iodoral? I >realize that the therapuetic dose of nascent/atomic iodine is much lower, >yet some people say it is more bioavailable... Any opinions from personal >experience about this? I did a quick search of the group archives and >found only a few recent references to the nascent form. > >Anyways, in my excitement to try it out right away, I opened the bottle >and put a few drops under my tongue (not too bright, I know). It burned a >bit... soon after I blew my nose and it was quite bloody (very unusual for >me). I also had a very acidy stomach. Other than that I felt good - it >does seem to give me more energy. > >In any case, I'd be interested to know people's opinions about nascent >and/or atomic iodine, vs. the others... > >Thanks! >~ ~~~ There is no way to peace; peace is the way ~~~~ --A.J. Muste Quote
Guest guest Posted December 21, 2010 Report Posted December 21, 2010 Hi ,Thanks for your response. I haven't really gotten the feeling that the difference in dosage is related to the outdated belief that iodine isn't safe. Rather it seems to be preferred because of it's (supposedly) superior absorption.I think this is one of the more complete descriptions I found of the differences - from this website:http://www.bibliotecapleyades.net/ciencia/ciencia_iodine01.htm This excerpt talks about why you don't need high doses of nascent iodine.Iodine is an easily oxidisable substance. Food that is present in the digestive tract will oxidize iodine to iodide which is not corrosive to the gastrointestinal tract. Oral iodine appears to be inactivated by combination with gastrointestinal contents. Absorption is poor due to rapid conversion of iodine to iodide [ii] and this might explain why one needs to take very high doses of Iodoral or Lugol's compared to nascent iodine, which seems to bypass the digestive track altogether meaning its absorption starts right in the mouth and continues through direct penetration of the stomach tissues. That said, this same article seems to conclude that the best results are obtained using both iodide salts and atomic/nascent iodine. I guess that's what Iodoral is? I will just have to experiment and find out which type works the best for me (that's the only way I really learn anything anyways . I was just hoping someone might have personal experience to share, as to their perception of the effectiveness of the various types.Thanks again, >> Nascent and Atomic do not have very much iodine in them-- so to get the > milligram doses we recommend, it is very costly. Lugol's was invented in > the early 1800s and has been in use continuously since then. Iodoral is a > tablet form of Lugol's. The claimed differences in Atomic or Nascent > iodine are more a marketing scheme than a real difference-- they are > banking on the old and debunked medical myths about iodine (that it is > dangerous) and claiming that while other iodines (that is, Lugol's) are > dangerous, theirs is safe. But the thing is, Lugol's is totally safe > already. There is nothing dangerous about a few drops of those, but there > is nothing dangerous about a few drops of Lugol's. Some people do get a > stomach upset with Lugol's, especially at larger doses, and that is why > Iodoral is a convenient form to use-- the tablets are coated and they > dissolve deep in the gut to avoid any stomach issues.> > I don't know what to say about the noseblowing thing.> > -- Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.