Guest guest Posted December 22, 2010 Report Posted December 22, 2010 Dear Friends This issue is quite considerable and I feel hospitals must pay attention and feel responsible to avoid HAIs Such hospitals, if any, should be fined appropriately. Even though if a hospital provide free treatment, who will pay for the time lost for a patient? However, the daunting task is how to prove for a patient that the infection is acquired from the hospital? Dr. Srisailam From: Vijay <drvijaythawani@...>Subject: Why hospitals should not pay for Hospital Acquired Infections?netrum Date: Thursday, 23 December, 2010, 3:35 AM Hi all,Below is poser from Dr Santanu Tripathi.Even I feel that the patients suffering from hospital acquired infections (HAI) should not pay the medical bills for the their treatment since it is the 'gift' from hospital. Had the patients not come to hospital, they would not have contacted these infections. If the hospital has 'given' them these infections, it is the responsibility of the hospital to treat them free of cost. I will go a step further. Why the patients contacting HAI should not claim damages from the hospitals? Dont' you feel that the patients have a right to sue the hospital for having given them the new infection which their bodies did not contact before? It is inhuman that hospitals give the ailing patients HAI and then charge them for its treatment.This leads to various public health posers as well. Hospitals with poor sanitation, dirty public toilets and surroundings, spitting all around, its staff with pathetic hygiene, grown up and dirty nails, unclean linen, its employees suffering from infectious diseases which can be transmitted, poor aseptic precautions, reuse of disposables,inapt handling of sterile instruments, water scarcity resulting in low hand wash, nonavailability of soaps at wash basins, ineffective use of antiseptics & disinfectants, improper bio-waste management, can be taken to task for contributing to HAI. Any public interest litigations you are aware of which lead to some respite in the matter?I would like to hear from you on this issue, dear NetRUMians.Vijay----------------------------------------------------------Dear Dr Vijay,It just bothers me that if hospital acquired infections are hospitalacquired infections, why the patients should foot the bill for itstreatment.What is your opinion abot this? Can you put this matter to the NETRUMmembers seeking their comments on the issue?Best wishes.Santanu-- Dr. Santanu K TripathiCell: (0) 92305 66771 Quote
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2010 Report Posted December 22, 2010 Dear friends,I beg to differ. It is not the fault of the hospital if the patient acquires a new infection during hospital stay. Many of the hospitals do have a protocol in place to avoid infections. Now since the reason a patient acquires an infection is numerous, it may not be possible to pinpoint hospital as the source of infection and any such arguments man not legally hold water.Regards,Dr. S Balakrishnan, MD, DMProf & Head, Pharmacology,PIMS, Pondicherry From: Vijay <drvijaythawani@...>Subject: Why hospitals should not pay for Hospital Acquired Infections?netrum Date: Thursday, 23 December, 2010, 3:35 AM Hi all,Below is poser from Dr Santanu Tripathi.Even I feel that the patients suffering from hospital acquired infections (HAI) should not pay the medical bills for the their treatment since it is the 'gift' from hospital. Had the patients not come to hospital, they would not have contacted these infections. If the hospital has 'given' them these infections, it is the responsibility of the hospital to treat them free of cost. I will go a step further. Why the patients contacting HAI should not claim damages from the hospitals? Dont' you feel that the patients have a right to sue the hospital for having given them the new infection which their bodies did not contact before? It is inhuman that hospitals give the ailing patients HAI and then charge them for its treatment.This leads to various public health posers as well. Hospitals with poor sanitation, dirty public toilets and surroundings, spitting all around, its staff with pathetic hygiene, grown up and dirty nails, unclean linen, its employees suffering from infectious diseases which can be transmitted, poor aseptic precautions, reuse of disposables,inapt handling of sterile instruments, water scarcity resulting in low hand wash, nonavailability of soaps at wash basins, ineffective use of antiseptics & disinfectants, improper bio-waste management, can be taken to task for contributing to HAI. Any public interest litigations you are aware of which lead to some respite in the matter?I would like to hear from you on this issue, dear NetRUMians.Vijay----------------------------------------------------------Dear Dr Vijay,It just bothers me that if hospital acquired infections are hospitalacquired infections, why the patients should foot the bill for itstreatment.What is your opinion abot this? Can you put this matter to the NETRUMmembers seeking their comments on the issue?Best wishes.Santanu-- Dr. Santanu K TripathiCell: (0) 92305 66771 Quote
Guest guest Posted December 23, 2010 Report Posted December 23, 2010 Hi Srisailam, When the patient is admitted to any hospital, the diagnosis is written on case file. When the same patient is dischsrged, the diagnosis appears on discharge card. Under RTI, by spending just 10 INR the patient can demand the photocopy of his complete file. Ofcourse the patient has to pay for the photocopies. Under guidance from medical activists, it can be shown that the condition at the time of discharge, isolate reports, therapeutic treatment given and additional second opinion from outside the hospital, the patient contacted HAI. Effort has to go in to get the results. Vijay > > > From: Vijay <drvijaythawani@...> > Subject: Why hospitals should not pay for Hospital Acquired Infections? > netrum > Date: Thursday, 23 December, 2010, 3:35 AM > > > Â > > > > Hi all, > > Below is poser from Dr Santanu Tripathi. > > Even I feel that the patients suffering from hospital acquired infections (HAI) should not pay the medical bills for the their treatment since it is the 'gift' from hospital. Had the patients not come to hospital, they would not have contacted these infections. If the hospital has 'given' them these infections, it is the responsibility of the hospital to treat them free of cost. > > I will go a step further. Why the patients contacting HAI should not claim damages from the hospitals? Dont' you feel that the patients have a right to sue the hospital for having given them the new infection which their bodies did not contact before? It is inhuman that hospitals give the ailing patients HAI and then charge them for its treatment. > > This leads to various public health posers as well. Hospitals with poor sanitation, dirty public toilets and surroundings, spitting all around, its staff with pathetic hygiene, grown up and dirty nails, unclean linen, its employees suffering from infectious diseases which can be transmitted, poor aseptic precautions, reuse of disposables,inapt handling of sterile instruments, water scarcity resulting in low hand wash, nonavailability of soaps at wash basins, ineffective use of antiseptics & disinfectants, improper bio-waste management, can be taken to task for contributing to HAI. > > Any public interest litigations you are aware of which lead to some respite in the matter? > > I would like to hear from you on this issue, dear NetRUMians. > Vijay > ---------------------------------------------------------- > Dear Dr Vijay, > > It just bothers me that if hospital acquired infections are hospital > acquired infections, why the patients should foot the bill for its > treatment. > > What is your opinion abot this? Can you put this matter to the NETRUM > members seeking their comments on the issue? > > Best wishes. > > Santanu > > -- > Dr. Santanu K Tripathi > Cell: (0) 92305 66771 > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 23, 2010 Report Posted December 23, 2010 Dear Dr Balakrishnan, Why the hospital should not be held responsible for HAI sir? Yes, the hospitals do have hospital infection control committee but are they doing their work in all hospitals? If they were doing then the sanitary conditions in public hospitals will not be so pathetic. It is a common sight to see choked, overflowing gutters, broken drains leaking the waste, biomedical waste being burnt in open, the campus littered with waste, ragpickers in connivance with sanitary staff salvaging the recyclable waste, water shortage with no running water in taps in hospital, stinking toilets, dirty floors, gutka spits on walls, smoking in campus,attendants moving with masks and OT gear outside, medical doctors without aprons, underuse of gloves by sanitary staff, poor personal hygiene of the staff members, grown nails and hair, dirty clothes of staff etc; Vijay > > > From: Vijay <drvijaythawani@...> > Subject: Why hospitals should not pay for Hospital Acquired Infections? > netrum > Date: Thursday, 23 December, 2010, 3:35 AM > > > Â > > Hi all, > > Below is poser from Dr Santanu Tripathi. > > Even I feel that the patients suffering from hospital acquired infections (HAI) should not pay the medical bills for the their treatment since it is the 'gift' from hospital. Had the patients not come to hospital, they would not have contacted these infections. If the hospital has 'given' them these infections, it is the responsibility of the hospital to treat them free of cost. > > I will go a step further. Why the patients contacting HAI should not claim damages from the hospitals? Dont' you feel that the patients have a right to sue the hospital for having given them the new infection which their bodies did not contact before? It is inhuman that hospitals give the ailing patients HAI and then charge them for its treatment. > > This leads to various public health posers as well. Hospitals with poor sanitation, dirty public toilets and surroundings, spitting all around, its staff > with pathetic hygiene, grown up and dirty nails, unclean linen, its employees suffering from infectious diseases which can be transmitted, poor aseptic precautions, reuse of disposables,inapt handling of sterile instruments, water scarcity resulting in low hand wash, nonavailability of soaps at wash basins, ineffective use of antiseptics & disinfectants, improper bio-waste management, can be taken to task for contributing to HAI. > > Any public interest litigations you are aware of which lead to some respite in the matter? > > I would like to hear from you on this issue, dear NetRUMians. > Vijay > ---------------------------------------------------------- > Dear Dr Vijay, > > It just bothers me that if hospital acquired infections are hospital > acquired infections, why the patients should foot the bill for its > treatment. > > What is your opinion abot this? Can you put this matter to the NETRUM > members seeking their comments > on the issue? > > Best wishes. > > Santanu > > -- > Dr. Santanu K Tripathi > Cell: (0) 92305 66771 > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 23, 2010 Report Posted December 23, 2010 Dear all, We can make 2 classes: one is actual infection acquired from hospital and the other is what the patients and their attenders are doing in hospitals. Class 1: Patiens/attenders overuse their rights and spit on hospital walls and corridors, bathrooms. A chaos is created in hospitals when wards are overcrowded with visitors, the entry can be restricted to 2-3 visitors at a time per patient. For this patients shoud be charged. Class 2: Nosocomial and iatrogenic infections- hospitals have to treat the patients free. Anupama From: Vijay <drvijaythawani@...>Subject: Re: Why hospitals should not pay for Hospital Acquired Infections?netrum Date: Thursday, 23 December, 2010, 6:16 PM Dear Dr Balakrishnan,Why the hospital should not be held responsible for HAI sir?Yes, the hospitals do have hospital infection control committee but are they doing their work in all hospitals? If they were doing then the sanitary conditions in public hospitals will not be so pathetic.It is a common sight to see choked, overflowing gutters, broken drains leaking the waste, biomedical waste being burnt in open, the campus littered with waste, ragpickers in connivance with sanitary staff salvaging the recyclable waste, water shortage with no running water in taps in hospital, stinking toilets, dirty floors, gutka spits on walls, smoking in campus,attendants moving with masks and OT gear outside, medical doctors without aprons, underuse of gloves by sanitary staff, poor personal hygiene of the staff members, grown nails and hair, dirty clothes of staff etc;Vijay > > > From: Vijay <drvijaythawani@...>> Subject: Why hospitals should not pay for Hospital Acquired Infections?> netrum > Date: Thursday, 23 December, 2010, 3:35 AM> > > Â > > Hi all,> > Below is poser from Dr Santanu Tripathi.> > Even I feel that the patients suffering from hospital acquired infections (HAI) should not pay the medical bills for the their treatment since it is the 'gift' from hospital. Had the patients not come to hospital, they would not have contacted these infections. If the hospital has 'given' them these infections, it is the responsibility of the hospital to treat them free of cost. > > I will go a step further. Why the patients contacting HAI should not claim damages from the hospitals? Dont' you feel that the patients have a right to sue the hospital for having given them the new infection which their bodies did not contact before? It is inhuman that hospitals give the ailing patients HAI and then charge them for its treatment.> > This leads to various public health posers as well. Hospitals with poor sanitation, dirty public toilets and surroundings, spitting all around, its staff> with pathetic hygiene, grown up and dirty nails, unclean linen, its employees suffering from infectious diseases which can be transmitted, poor aseptic precautions, reuse of disposables,inapt handling of sterile instruments, water scarcity resulting in low hand wash, nonavailability of soaps at wash basins, ineffective use of antiseptics & disinfectants, improper bio-waste management, can be taken to task for contributing to HAI. > > Any public interest litigations you are aware of which lead to some respite in the matter?> > I would like to hear from you on this issue, dear NetRUMians.> Vijay> ----------------------------------------------------------> Dear Dr Vijay,> > It just bothers me that if hospital acquired infections are hospital> acquired infections, why the patients should foot the bill for its> treatment.> > What is your opinion abot this? Can you put this matter to the NETRUM> members seeking their comments> on the issue?> > Best wishes.> > Santanu> > -- > Dr. Santanu K Tripathi> Cell: (0) 92305 66771> Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.