Guest guest Posted April 15, 2010 Report Posted April 15, 2010 Greetings, How many of us can recall reading the consent document regarding the use of extra biopsy tissue? . And if we did, how could we be expected to understand its implications, or our other choices? Only recently considered something to discard, the evaluation of biospecimen - particularly when annotated with clinical information (response to therapy, etc.) -- is considered the key to making progress against lymphomas, a heterogeneous condition which has variable clinical courses and underlying biologies. Presently, pathology departments, the institution, the investigators, the cooperative groups, even NCI, argue for use of it . the patient community unaware that it has become so valuable, and that " ownership " of it has become so problematic! Importantly, with the recent advent of caHUB*, we now have an alternative to a fragmented and contentious system: Instead of tissue being used to its best advantage, it remains unused because of ownership battles . or the use of it defaults to individual researchers in the center who have access to the refrigerator - a poor substitute for what's possible today. Done in isolation on relatively small numbers of sample, this use of patient tissue is unlikely to achieve anything of clinical importance. * What is caHUB? It's a " national biobank, or biorespository, of human tissue, blood, and other biological materials--collectively known as biospecimens--that can be used for medical research. It will help ensure that an adequate and continuous supply of biospecimens is available to accelerate cancer research and the development of molecularly-based diagnostic and therapeutic agents that will further enable personalized medicine. " See for more: http://bit.ly/doVai4 So I think patients need legal counsel regarding the use of biopsy tissue for research . and government regulation to standardize consent and ownership practices -- to protect the interests of patients and to save well-meaning, human, all-to-human, researchers from themselves. The carrot: Institutions that participate in caHUB, should be awarded generous grants and public acknowledgments. The stick: institutions who do not offer this option to patients, must discard the extra tissue unless they can show its use has a true potential to advance clinical science, and the institutions have provided patients with adequate consenting and knowledge of the alternative. The reason patient intervention (through legislation) is needed is to make possible an individualized approach to a heterogeneous disease . which requires cooperative studies based on biospecimen that is uniformly analyzed - what caHUB offers, and apparently what most researchers will not accept in practice, even when they agree with the concept. To illustrate, I copy comment of an unnamed investigator on the competition for use of biospecimen: " Doctors who work in the field disagree many individual sites disagree with the NCI - e.g. many good centers don't participate in cooperative group studies because they disagree, don't like, or have other priorities. Our XYZ lymphoma committee often disagrees with the NCI CTEP staff - so for us to send samples from our patients to the NCI to be used on studies we don't favor is problematic if we disagree - we will not be motivated to participate - very very challenging. . When patients have a biopsy, the operative consent form generally mentions " waste tissue " - this falls into that category. As I understand it, the patient has no clear rights to " waste tissue " , which would generally not be needed for diagnostic purposes and is therefore discarded. The generic consent form says that this may be used by the institution for research or other purposes (as it is otherwise waste) in a de-identified way. " What is step one? First, we need feedback from the NCI and research community to make sure our concerns are legitimate and the proposed remedy is feasible. ~ Karl Patients Against Lymphoma Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.